Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31087
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 341 OF 2017
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 28.06.2016 IN OS NO.234
OF 2007 OF I ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, KOZHIKODE
----APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY NORTH CIRCLE, P.W.D. COMPLEX,
KOZHIKODE.
BY ADV SRI.SUNIL KUMAR KURIAKOSE, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
RESPONDENT/DEFENDANT:
M.ALAVIKUTTY ALIAS BABU,
P.W.D. CONTRACTOR, RESIDING AT CHALAYAM PURATH,
KONDOTTY AMSOM, KOLATHER DESOM, THURAKKAL, KONDOTTY,
MALAPPURAM.
BY ADVS.
SMT.AMRIN FATHIMA
SRI.BABU KARUKAPADATH
SRI.K.M.FAISAL KALAMASSERY
SRI.MITHUN BABY JOHN
SRI.RAHUL ROY
SMT.M.A.VAHEEDA BABU
SRI.P.U.VINOD KUMAR
THIS
REGULAR
FIRST
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
ON
10.04.2025, ALONG WITH RFA.201/2017 & CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:31087
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 201 OF 2017
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 28.06.2016 IN OS NO.234
OF 2007 OF I ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, KOZHIKODE
----NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE APPELLANT/DEFENDANT:
M.ALAVIKUTTY @ BABU,
AGED 31 YEARS,
S/O LATE AHAMMED KUTTY,PWD CONTRACTOR,
RESIDING AT CHELAMPURATH HOUSE,THURAKKAL PO,
KONDOTTY AMSOM,KOLATHUR DESOM, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SMT.M.A.VAHEEDA BABU
SMT.AMRIN FATHIMA
SRI.K.M.FAISAL KALAMASSERY
SRI.MITHUN BABY JOHN
SRI.J.RAMKUMAR
SRI.P.U.VINOD KUMAR
NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY, NORTH CIRCLE,PWD COMPLEX,
KOZHIKODE-673001.
BY ADV SRI.SUNIL KUMAR KURIAKOSE, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS
REGULAR
FIRST
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
ON
10.04.2025, ALONG WITH RFA.341/2017 & CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:31087
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO.(INDIGENT) No.145 OF 2022
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 28/06/2016 IN OS NO.62
OF 2008 OF 1st ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, KOZHIKODE
----NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE APPELLANT/PLAINTIFF:
ALAVIKUTTY ALIAS BABU,
AGED 31 YEARS,
S/O LATE AHAMED KUTTY, PWD CONTRACTOR,
RESIDING AT CHELAMBURATH HOUSE, THURAKKAL PO.,
KONDOTTY AMSOM, KOLATHUR DESOM,
ERNAD TALUK IN MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
BABU KARUKAPADATH
M.A.VAHEEDA BABU
K.M.FAISAL (KALAMASSERY)
P.U.VINOD KUMAR
MITHUN BABY JOHN
J.RAMKUMAR
AMRIN FATHIMA
RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, KERALA PUBLIC WORKS
DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM DISTRICT-695001.
THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY, KERALA PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT,
VAZHUTHACAUD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695001.
2025:KER:31087
RFA NO.(INDIGENT) No.145 OF 2022
-2-
THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
KERALA PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, NATIONAL HIGHWAY(NORTH
CIRCLE), PWD COMPLEX IN NAGARAM AMSOM DESOM,
KOZHIKODE TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT 673001.
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
10.04.2025, ALONG WITH RFA.341/2017, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:31087
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
R.F.A. Nos.341, 201 of 2017 & 145 of 2022
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 10th day of April, 2025
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
RFA No.341 of 2017 and RFA No.201/2017 are by the
plaintiff
and
the
defendant
234/2007.
The
suit
was
declaration
that
the
by
respectively,
the
Department,
defendant-Contractor
in
OS
for
a
committed
breach of contract, and for damages. It was decreed in
part by the trial court. RFA 145/2022 is filed by the
Contractor, challenging the dismissal of his suit for a
declaration that the termination of the contract by the
Department is void, and for realisation of money. The
suit was dismissed by the trial court. As noticed, the
suits are by the Department and the Contractor, against
each other.
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 2 :-
2. Ext.A1 agreement dated 11.03.2004 was entered
into between the parties with regard to the work of
“Improvement of Riding Quality Works” in Km. 42/000 to
55/000 of NH-212. The work was to be completed within
three months. According to the Department, the site was
handed over to the contractor on 19.03.2004. In spite of
repeated instructions, both oral and in writing, the
contractor failed to execute the work. After issuing
Ext.A7 show cause notice dated 27.05.2005, the contract
was terminated as per Ext.A11 order dated 29.07.2005.
The contractor was put on notice that, as per the terms
of
the
contract
he
was
liable
to
compensate
the
Department for the loss sustained on the breach.
3.
seeking
The
a
Department
declaration
filed
that
the
the
suit
OS
234/2007
contractor
committed
breach of the contract and for realisation of an amount
of ₹ 1,63,35,794/-, which is allegedly the loss suffered
consequent on the breach of contract by the contractor.
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 3 :-
4. The contractor denied that he had committed
breach
of
the
contract.
It
was
contended
that
the
Department did not hand over the site on 19.03.2004 as
claimed. There were several obstructions at the site for
carrying out the works. The level measurements were not
taken by the authorities in spite of repeated requests.
There was heavy rainfall, preventing carrying out of the
work. It was contended that he was always ready and
willing to carry out the work but it could not be
carried out for the aforesaid reasons. It was contended
that part of the work was done and that he was willing
to complete the same. The termination of the contract
was alleged to be illegal. By way of OS 62/2008 the
contractor sought a declaration that the termination of
the contract is void, and claimed ₹ 79,14,000/- from the
Department
under
various
heads
including,
return
of
security deposit and performance guarantee, value of
work done etc.
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 4 :-
5.
The
trial
court
found
that
the
contractor
committed breach of contract; the reasons urged by the
defendant for the non-performance were not accepted.
With regard to the claim for damages, the trial court
held that the Department failed to establish the same.
Accordingly,
but
for
declaring
that
the
breach
of
contract was committed by the contractor, all other
reliefs claimed by the parties against each other were
declined.
6. We have heard Sri.Sunil Kumar Kuriakose, the
learned Government Pleader on behalf of the Department,
and Sri.Babu Karukappadath, the learned counsel for the
contractor.
7. The points that arise for determination are :(i) Is the finding of the trial court that the contractor committed
breach of contract, founded on evidence?
(ii) Was the trial court right in having declined the Department
the relief of damages?
(iii) Do the decree and judgment of the trial court warrant any
interference?
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 5 :-
8. The contract was entered into on 11.03.2004 and
the
period
for
performance
was
three
months.
The
termination of the contract was under Ext.A11, dated
29.07.2005. The conduct of both parties reveal that they
did not intend time to be the essence of the contract,
or at any rate, both the parties were willing to accept
extended
performance.
The
reasons
projected
by
the
contractor for the delay and non-performance are (a) the
delay in handing over the site, (b) failure of the
Department to abate the hindrances/obstructions to carry
out the work, (c) delay on the part of the Department to
take initial level measurements, and (4) heavy rains
preventing carrying out the work.
9. Though the contractor would contend that there
was delay in handing over of the site, there is not even
a
single
communication
by
the
contractor
to
the
Department whereby he had voiced such a grievance and
required them to hand over the site for starting the
work. On the other hand, it is the definite case of the
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 6 :-
Department that the site was handed over on 19.03.2004
i.e
days
after
the
agreement.
Ext.A2
is
the
communication dated 26.08.2004 by the Department to the
contractor wherein it is mentioned that the site was
handed over. Such statement with regard to the handing
over of the site is reiterated by the Department in
Ext.A4 communication dated 21.12.2004. The contractor
never controverted it. Therefore, the said contention of
the contractor is bound to fail.
10. With regard to the alleged failure on the part
of the Department to remove the hindrance/obstructions
at the site to enable carrying out of the work, the
learned counsel for the contractor would, by referring
to Ext.B1, a document maintained by the Department,
which gives details of the works arranged for the period
ranging from 11.03.2004 to 29.07.2005, contend that, as
is
evident
therefrom
various
works
including
construction of retaining walls, drains, filling up of
potholes etc. were being carried out at the very same
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 7 :-
site, simultaneously, by different contractors. Going by
the nature of work involved, unless unhindered site is
provided, the contract could not have been executed, it
is argued. Here it is relevant to note that, there is no
material to find that the contractor had at any point of
time raised such a grievance before the Department. If
the grievance of the contractor was that he was unable
to carry out the work consequent on such hindrances, he
should have immediately brought it to the notice of the
Department. In the absence of any evidence in such
regard, such contention can only fail.
11. That apart, it is to be noticed that the other
works undertaken by the other contractors as mentioned
in Ext.B1, to which the attention of this court was
drawn by the learned counsel for the contractor, were
all
completed
well
within
the
stipulated
time
of
completion in the year 2004 itself. With regard to the
contract in question, it is evident that the Department
was willing to accept the performance of the contract
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 8 :-
even beyond the year 2004. They did not seek any damages
for
not
carrying
out
the
work
within
the
original
stipulated period of 3 months or even in the year 2004.
Since the Department was willing to accept the work even
if it was done at least in the year 2005, the hindrance
if at all any at the site due to the other works at the
site could not extend beyond the year 2004. Therefore,
for the said reason also, the non-carrying out of the
work
alleging
hindrance/obstruction,
cannot
be
justified.
12. The next contention of the contractor is with
regard to the failure on the part of the Department to
take initial level measurements. The work involved being
with regard to the soling of the road, it is necessary
that the initial level of measurements ought to be
taken, without which the quantity of work done could not
be correctly assessed. The level measurements were taken
only in February, 2005. Therefore, the contractor could
not be faulted for not having carrying out the work, it
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 9 :-
is contended.
13. It is the case of the Department that, as per
the nature of the work involved, taking of initial level
measurement is irrelevant and the payment is to be on
area basis. This is evident from Ext.A3 communication by
the Department to the contractor wherein it is stated
“As a registered contractor you should be well aware, that there is no need to take level
measurements for BUSG Work since the same is measured and paid on area basis
only”. In the written statement by the Department in OS
62/08 it is admitted that the initial level measurements
were taken on 01.02.2005, 03.02.2005 and 04.02.2005 and
it was reported on 15.02.2005. However, it is reiterated
therein that such exercise was done at the instance of
the contractor who insisted that without initial level
measurement he cannot do the work. Therein they still
maintain that taking of initial level measurement was
not
necessary.
Ext.B2
is
a
reply
obtained
by
the
contractor from the Department in his query under the
Right to Information Act. Therein also it has been
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 10 :-
stated that the level measurements were reported to the
CTE
on
15.02.2005.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
contractor would rely on Page No.145 of Ext.A1 agreement
which provides that joint measurements with precision
instruments are to be taken prior to commencement of
work.
It
suggests
that
taking
of
initial
level
measurement would be necessary.
14. Even considering that taking of initial level
measurement was necessary for carrying out the work and
it
was
completed
only
by
15.02.2005,
still
the
Department was prepared to accept the performance of the
contract after that. It would have been sufficient if
the
contractor
had
completed
the
work
within
three
months from 15.02.2005. However, he failed to do so. In
Ext.A10 communication letter by the contractor to the
Department it is stated that the levels were reported on
15.01.2005 (though by the records it is 15.02.2005) and
that
he
started
works
on
the
26 th.
In
Ext.A5
communication by the Department to the contractor, dated
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 11 :-
28.03.2005,
it
has
been
stated
that,
though
the
contractor started the work on 11.03.2005, it was not
done as per the specifications and the work was stopped.
The contractor was asked to rectify the defects pointed
by
the
officers.
No
reply
was
sent
to
Ext.A5
communication by the contractor. It is thereafter on
27.05.2005 that the Department issued Ext.A7 show cause
notice to the contractor pointing out that he had done
work
only
on
one
day
and
that
too
not
as
per
specifications, and that the contract is liable to be
terminated at his risk and costs. Noticeably, the said
notice (Ext.A7) was issued only on 27.05.2005 ie. after
a period of three months from the reporting of the
initial level measurement. It shows that, even after the
taking of the initial level measurement the contractor
had the contract period of three months for performance
of the contract. Still the contractor failed to carry
out
the
work.
Therefore,
the
contention
of
the
contractor that the failure to carry out the work was
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 12 :-
due to the delay on the part of the Department in taking
initial level measurements does not hold good.
15.
The
next
contention
of
the
contractor
is
pointing out climatic conditions. According to him there
were
heavy
rains
during
the
entire
period
which
prevented him from carrying out the work. Relying on the
“Specifications For Road and Bridge Works” issued by the
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways published by the
Indian
Roads
Congress,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
contractor would argue that the work, which included
‘prime coat over granular base, build up spray grout,
bituminous pavement layers’ etc. cannot be carried out
unless the surface is dry. Therefore, the continuous
rains in the year prevented him from carrying out the
work, it is argued. To substantiate that there were
rains
during
this
period,
he
relied
on
Ext.B16
communication from the Indian Meteorological Department,
Government of India, providing a data with regard to the
daily
rain
fall
in
the
area
concerned
during
the
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 13 :-
relevant period. A perusal of the same would show that
it would not support the claim of the contractor. The
report evidences that there were not much rains after
the
taking
of
the
initial
level
measurements
on
15.02.2005. Hence the said document would not come to
the aid of the contractor. The fact that there were
rains
in
the
year
2004,
consequent
to
which
the
contractor was unable to do work, has been acknowledged
by the Assistant Engineer in Ext.B5 communication sent
to the Assistant Executive Engineer. But we have already
excluded the entire period up to 15.02.2005 to the
benefit of the contractor. We are confining ourselves to
the question as to whether there was failure on the part
of the contractor to do work treating the period of
commencement as 15.02.2002. There is no communication
there after, whereby he voiced any grievance regarding
any of the above heads as disabling him from carrying
out the work. None of the grievances projected by him
subsisted after 15.02.2005. The contractor could have
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 14 :-
very well completed the work within three months from
15.02.2005. It is on the failure to do so that Ext.A7
show cause notice for termination of the contract was
issued by the Department on 27.05.2005. It was followed
by
Ext.A11
termination
notice
dated
29.07.2005.
Therefore, it can only be held that the breach of the
contract was committed by the contractor and that the
termination was justified. The trial court was right in
having held so.
16. With regard to the claim of the Department for
damages, it is their case that consequent to the breach
of the contract by the contractor the Department had to
make alternate arrangements. The court found that there
is paucity of evidence with regard to the rearrangement
of work and also the damages. The court found that there
is no evidence to show the details of the work executed
under
the
subsequent
agreement
as
claimed
by
the
Department. The learned Government Pleader would contend
that
Exts.A13
and
A14
have
been
produced
by
the
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 15 :-
Department
to
prove
the
damages.
Ext.A13
is
a
communication by the Department to one M/s C.Vijayan and
Co., in connection with acceptance of his bid dated
18.11.2005 for execution of “IRQP 2003-04-Improvements
of Riding Quality Works from km 42/00 to 55/00 of NH212”. Ext.A14 is the intimation by the Department to the
contractor pointing out the damages and claiming the
same. These two documents amply justify the claim for
damages,
is
the
argument
of
the
learned
Government
Pleader.
17. The assessment of damages by the Department was
challenged by the contractor before this Court in W.P.
(C)
Nos.27585/2005
and
10998/2006.
As
per
Ext.B15
judgment this Court held that the Department cannot be
an arbiter in its own cause and that the damages are to
be assessed through the forum of civil court. Therefore,
it was obligatory on the part of the Department to
produce
the
relevant
materials
relating
to
the
subsequent tender, prove the identity of the works etc.
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 16 :-
No document is produced by the Department to prove the
mode in which the alternate arrangement was made. But
for the reference in Ext.A13 that the allotment was
preceded by a bid, no documents in the said regard are
produced. The nature and quantity of the work in respect
of such bid if any was invited is not available on
record. Without proving that the nature of the work
covered under the subsequent arrangement was the very
same as that in Ext.A1 agreement, the damages could not
be assessed by the court. Mere production of Ext.A13
communication is not sufficient to prove the damages
suffered. It was in the absence of any material in the
said regard that the court held that there is dearth of
material to find the damages suffered by the Department.
In the absence of specific details, the trial court
without awarding further damages merely permitted the
security amount to be forfeited. On the particular facts
of the case we find that the trial court was justified
in holding so.
R.F.A. Nos.341 & 201 of 2017 &
145 of 2022
2025:KER:31087
-: 17 :-
18. On the discussions as above, we concur with the
findings of the trial court. The decree and judgment of
the trial court warrants no interference.
Resultantly, the appeals fail and are dismissed. No
costs.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review