Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 78
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: - CRAA No. 76/2011
Reserved on:- 05.02.2026
Pronounced on:-12.02.2026
Uploaded on:- 13.02.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced:-Full
…. Appellant(s)
State of Jammu & Kashmir
Through: - Mr. Dewakar Sharma, Dy. AG
V/s
1. Gulzar Hussain Shah @ Gazi
S/o Rafeeq Hussain Shah,
SPO No. 498.
....Respondent(s)
2. Waras Hussain Shah
S/o Nazak SPO No. 167/SPO Hussain Shah,
both residents of Village Sangla Surankote-Poonch.
Through: - Ms. Mandeep Reen, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICESANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Per: Sanjay Parihar-J
1.
The present appeal has been preferred by the appellant–State now
UT of J&K, against the judgment dated 27.05.2011 of Principal
Sessions Judge, Poonch (hereinafter referred to as “the Trial
Court”) in a case arising out of FIR No. 184/2003 registered at
Police Station Surankote for offences under Sections 302/34 RPC,
whereby the respondents have been acquitted of the charges framed
against them. By way of this appeal, the State seeks reversal of the
acquittal and conviction of the respondents for the offence of murder
with the aid of common intention.
CRAA No. 76/2011
2.
The prosecution case, as projected in the complaint lodged by PW-3
Ahad Joo on 25.10.2003, is that on 24.10.2003 at about 6:00 PM, the
respondents along with another person, allegedly dressed in uniform
and armed with rifles, came to the complainant’s house and forcibly
took away his son Abdul Qayoom after bolting the complainant
inside the house from outside. It was alleged that the deceased was
taken to a distance of about 150–200 yards and shot, as a result of
which he sustained bullet injuries and later succumbed to the same
while being shifted to hospital. On the basis of the said complaint,
FIR No. 184/2003 came to be registered.
3.
During investigation, however, it surfaced that the respondents were
working as Special Police Officers (SPOs) with Special Operation
Group of J&K Police Poonch, and were part of a search operation
conducted under orders of superior officers in an area then affected
by militancy. It was found that the deceased was accompanying the
police party, allegedly as a guide. According to the investigation,
firing took place during the operation with the militantsin which
deceased received bullet injuries from the fire that emanated from the
respondents. Initially, a charge-sheet under Section 304-A RPC was
filed before the learned Sub-Judge (Judicial Magistrate 1st Class),
Surankote, and vide order dated 20.02.2004 charges under Section
304-A RPC were framed. However, upon recording certain
statements alleging intentional killing, the learned Magistrate
committed the case to the Court of Sessions under Section 347 CrPC,
holding that the matter was exclusively triable by the Sessions Court.
The learned Sessions Judge, Poonch framed charges under Sections
CRAA No. 76/2011
302/34 RPC on 29.03.2005, to which the respondents pleaded not
guilty.
4.
The prosecution examined as many as 27 witnesses including the
complainant, relatives of the deceased, police personnel forming part
of the search party, the ballistic expert, the medical officer who
conducted the post-mortem, and the Investigating Officer. The
respondents examined three defence witnesses and, in their
statements under Section 342 CrPC, denied the allegations and
claimed false implication, asserting that the occurrence was a result
of cross-firing during a search operation that was conducted to track
down militants.
5.
Upon appreciation of the entire evidence, the Trial Court recorded a
finding that there was no reliable eye-witness to the occurrence. The
complainant himself admitted that after his son was taken away, he
was bolted inside the house and only heard gunshots from a distance.
He did not witness the actual firing. The uncles and relatives of the
deceased either admitted that they had not seen the occurrence or
their testimony was based on what they were allegedly told by
others. One witness, who attempted to project himself as an eyewitness, was not cited as such in the charge-sheet and his presence at
the scene was found doubtful.
6.
The SPOs who were part of the police party, namely PW-Abdul
Qayoom and PW-Mohd. Yousaf, did not support the prosecution
version and were declared hostile. They denied that the respondents
had forcibly taken the deceased from his house or intentionally fired
upon him. Their testimony indicated that firing had occurred during
the search operation. The Investigating Officer categorically stated
CRAA No. 76/2011
that during investigation it was found to be a case of accidental firing
and that no evidence of forcible abduction or intentional murder had
surfaced.
7.
The scientific evidence also did not conclusively connect the
respondents with the fatal injuries. The ballistic expert admitted that
the rifles were not properly sealed when examined and that no
opinion could be formed regarding the range of fire as the clothes of
the deceased and relevant materials were not provided. The bullet
that passed through the body of the deceased was not examined. The
medical officer opined that the injuries were consistent with gunshot
wounds and that the minimum distance of firing could not be less
than 100 feet, and that such injuries could possibly be caused by
more than one person. However, no conclusive nexus was
established between the fatal injury and the weapon carried by either
respondent.
8.
The Trial Court also noticed the absence of any motive or prior
enmity between the parties. It was admitted that the respondents
were engaged in anti-militancy operations during a period when
militancy was prevalent in the area. On overall appreciation of the
evidence, the Trial Court concluded that the prosecution had failed to
establish the guilt of the respondents beyond reasonable doubt and
accordingly acquitted them.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant-State has argued that the Trial
Court mis appreciated the evidence and failed to properly evaluate
the testimonies of prosecution witnesses. It is contended that the
respondents having taken the deceased from his house stands proved
and that the chain of circumstances clearly indicates their culpability.
CRAA No. 76/2011
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents has supported
the impugned judgment and submitted that the prosecution case is
riddled with contradictions, that the witnesses are either interested or
hearsay witnesses, that the independent police witnesses did not
support the prosecution, and that the view taken by the Trial Court is
a plausible and reasonable view.
10. We have heard both counsels besides examined the evidence lead in
trial.It is well settled that in an appeal against acquittal, the
presumption of innocence stands reinforced by the order of acquittal.
Though the appellate court has the power to reappreciate the
evidence, interference is warranted only when the judgment under
challenge is perverse, manifestly illegal, or based on misreading of
evidence.
11. In the present case, the prosecution has failed to establish, beyond
reasonable doubt, that the respondents had the intention or common
intention to commit the murder of the deceased. The star witness,
namely the father of the deceased (PW-Ahad Joo), is admittedly not
an eye-witness to the actual occurrence. His testimony, at best,
establishes that the deceased was taken away by the respondents and
that he later heard gunshots. The actual firing was not witnessed by
him. The other witnesses, who are closely related to the deceased,
have either deposed on the basis of hearsay or attempted to improve
their version during trial. Their testimonies, as rightly appreciated by
the Trial Court, do not inspire confidence.
12. The two SPOs, namely PW-Abdul Qayoom and PW-Mohd. Yousaf,
who were part of the police party on the night of occurrence, have
not supported the prosecution case. Though declared hostile, nothing
CRAA No. 76/2011
substantial could be elicited from them in cross-examination to
implicate the respondents. On the contrary, their version supports the
defence plea that firing had taken place during the course of search
operation.
13. The medical and ballistic evidence also does not conclusively
connect the respondents with the fatal injuries. The ballistic expert
has admitted serious lapses in the manner in which the weapons were
produced and examined. The clothes of the deceased were not sent
for forensic examination, the bullet was not examined, and even the
post-mortem report was not provided to the expert for proper
evaluation. In such circumstances, the prosecution has failed to
establish the necessary nexus between the injuries sustained by the
deceased and the weapons allegedly used by the respondents.
14. The Investigating Officer himself has deposed that during
investigation; no material was found to substantiate the allegation of
forcible abduction or intentional killing. Rather, his conclusion was
that the deceased had been accompanying the police party and might
have been hit during firing. This materially weakens the prosecution
case and creates a reasonable doubt as to the manner in which the
incident occurred.
15. It is a settled proposition that suspicion, however grave, cannot
substitute proof. Where two views are reasonably possible on the
evidence on record, the one favourable to the accused must be
adopted. In the present case, the view taken by the Trial Court is a
plausible and reasonable view based on appreciation of the evidence.
Merely because another view may be possible is not a ground to
reverse an order of acquittal.
CRAA No. 76/2011
16. The prosecution, in the memo of appeal, has sought conviction of the
respondents for culpable homicide amounting to murder. However,
such a stand is wholly inconsistent with the narration of the
Investigating Officer, who has categorically stated that there is no
evidence of any intentional firing by the two respondents and that the
incident, at best, reflects death caused by negligence. Even with
regard to the offence under Section 304-A IPC, the evidence on
record is conspicuously deficient. The two police officials, who were
cited as accomplice witnesses to the respondents, did not support the
prosecution case and the later failed to elicit any material from their
cross-examination which could be construed as substantive evidence
against the respondents.
17. In these circumstances, the view taken by the learned Trial Court
cannot be said to be perverse, unreasonable, or contrary to the
evidence on record. The appellant has not been able to demonstrate
any material illegality, perversity, or misappreciation of evidence
warranting interference by this Court in an appeal against acquittal
Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed by affirming the judgement of
trial court.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
12.02.2026
Diksha
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
CRAA No. 76/2011
Yes
No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review