The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, the order dated 21.02.2023 passed in W.P. No. 6709/2021 is set aside. The matter is remanded back to the learned Single Judge for hearing the case on the question of maintainability as well as merits and decide the same after hearing both the parties in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 16th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT APPEAL No. 401 of 2023
BETWEEN:1.
STATE BANK OF INDIA ASSISTANT GENERAL
MANAGER PENSION BHAVISHYA NIDHI EVAM
UPADAN VIBHAG, PRADHAN KARYALAY, THRID
FLOOR,
HOSHANGABAD
ROAD,
BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER STATE OF INDIA 5,
YASHWANT NIWAS ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(SHRI ASHOK KUMAR SETHI SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI HARISH
JOSHI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANTS)
AND
VISHWAS S/O KANHAIYALAL SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 58
YEARS, OCCUPATION: NIL R-SECTOR 589, MAHALAXMI
NAGR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI ROMIL VERMA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission and interim relief.
In this writ appeal filed under Section 2(1) of M.P. Uchcha Nyayalaya
(Khand Nyay Peeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 assails the order dated
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/19/2024
5:34:21 PM
21.02.2023 passed in W.P. No. 6709/2021, whereby the writ petition filed by
the respondent was allowed with cost.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the writ petition filed by the
respondent was allowed by the writ Court wherein challenge has been made to
the letter issued by appellants/bank dated 24.09.2019 in compliance of the order
passed by the Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 5876-5877 of 2019 preferred by
the appellant as well as respondent against the order dated dated 24.04.2017
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in W.P. No. 2625/2019 filed by the
appellant/bank.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that learned Single
Judge has misinterpreted the order passed by the Apex Court wherein following
directions were issued:
"(a) The respondent - Vishwas Sharma will be paid all the
retiral benefits as admissible.
(b) The respondent would be paid pension if admissible on
the basis of the period served by him with the bank assuming he
would superannuate after such a period of service.
(c) The needful be done within eight weeks from today.
(d) The appeals stand disposed of leaving the question of
law open."
4.
In compliance of the said order passed by the Apex Court,
appellant/bank has duly examined the case of the respondent and it was
concluded that respondent should be treated as superannuated (instead of
dismissed) at the stage when he ceased to work and further concluded that at
such stage of his service, if he is entitled for pension as per bank's Rules and
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/19/2024
5:34:21 PM
Regulation, the same should be paid to him. However, respondent was not
found to be entitled for pension. Hence, bank has issued letter dated 24.09.2019
mentioning all the details. Respondent treating the said letter to be issued
ignoring the directions passed by the Apex Court has preferred the writ petition.
The said writ petition was allowed by the writ Court setting aside the order
passed by the appellant and cost of Rs. 25,000/-was also imposed on the
appellant/bank.
5. Learned counsel for the appellants/bank drawing the attention of this
Court towards the writ petition submitted that he has filed I.A. No. 8231/2022
on 17.11.2022 , which is an application for deciding the issue of maintainability
of writ petition. Thereafter, the matter was listed on 25.11.2022 when counsel
for respondent sought time to argue and on 21.02.2023, the learned Single
Judge without hearing the appellants/bank on the question of maintainability has
decided the writ petition finally at admission stage. It is further submitted that
the respondent has not made any prayer regarding payment of pension in the
prayer clause. Further, learned Single Judge had directed to pay the pension
alongwith all the retiral benefits within four weeks from the date of passing of
the impugned order and to submit report in the Court which is also not justified
.
6. Learned Single Judge has passed the impugned order going beyond
the directions given by the Apex Court while disposing off the SLPs' vide order
dated 26.07.2019 in as much as that the Apex Court has merely directed to pay
all the retiral benefits to the respondent as admissible. However, learned Single
Judge has given direction to pay the same with interest @ 9% per annum.
Learned Single Judge heard the matter only on the issue of payment of pension,
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/19/2024
5:34:21 PM
especially about payment of 'superannuation pension' provided in Regulation 28
of the State Bank of Indore(Employees) Pension Regulation, 1995. However,
during arguments, it has been brought to the knowledge of learned Single Judge
that there is no whisper about payment of pension in the relief clause itself.
Further the learned Single Judge has imposed exorbitant cost of Rs. 25,000/without considering the facts on record in as much as that there is no delay or
wilful avoidance on the part of the appellant bank in examining and deciding the
case of respondent in terms of the order passed by the Apex Court.
7.
He further submitted that since relief sought for by the learned
counsel for respondent is not in consonance with the directions given by the
Apex Court in the common order 26.07.2019 and keeping in view the fact that
the preliminary objection as regards maintainability has not been decided,
therefore, this matter deserves to be remanded back for fresh adjudication .
8 . On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent opposed the
prayer and submitted that learned Single Judge has not committed any error in
allowing the petition filed by the respondent. Hence, the writ appeal deserves to
be dismissed.
9. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10.
On perusal of the order passed by the learned Singe Judge, it is
apparent that the writ petition was decided finally without adverting to the
preliminary objection as regards maintainability of the petition and without
hearing the appellant/bank.
11.
Moreso, in the relief clause, as rightly pointed out by the learned
counsel for the appellant/bank that there is no mention of grant of pension in the
relief clause in the writ petition filed by the respondent. For the sake
convenience and ready reference, the same is reproduced below:
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/19/2024
5:34:21 PM
''सहायता
सहायता1. माननीय न्यायालय
य ायालय से िनवे द न है िक याि◌िचकाकता
याि◌िचकाकता को माह अ ैल 1999
से आज िदनॉंक तक का वे त न सभी लाभ,
लाभ भत्ते
ते , अवकाश नगदीकदण,
नगदीकदण पी. एफ. ,
ेच ुइ टी,
टी बक एवं कमचारी का अं श दान एवं बक का अं श दान दोन
त्याथीगण
य ाथीगण से िदलवाये जाने व िदनॉंक 24.09.19 का प
का भुग तान
िनरस्त कर यािचका
स्वीकार
व ीकार कर िकये जाने का कृ पा कर◌ा
2. यािचकाकता को ियािचका का संपूण व्यय त्याथ गण से िदलाये जाने क कृपा
कर◌ा
3. अन्य कोई सहायता जेा माननीय न्यायालय न्यायिहत म उिचत समझे यह भी
िदलवाई जावे ◌ा
4. यािचकाकता क यािचका सव्यय स्वीकार क जावे ◌ा ''
12. From a careful reading of relief no.1, it is apparent that respondent
prayed that he be paid salary from April 1999 till the date of filing of petition
and other benefits, leave encashment, PF, Gratuity including employee and
employer's contribution. However, there is no mention of grant of pension in
the relief clause whereas the learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition
had directed the appellant/bank to pay the pension w.e.f. the date of leaving the
service alongwith interest@ 9% p.a., which is beyond the reliefs sought by the
respondent. Even otherwise, learned Single Judge ought to have decided the
preliminary objection raised by the appellant/bank about maintainability of the
petition first and then has to dwell upon deciding other issues, which has not
been done in the case in hand.
13. With regard to deciding preliminary objections first, this Court is
supported in its view by the judgment rendered by the Apex Court in the case
o f Union of India and Others Vs. Ranbir Singh Rathaur and Others
reported in (2006) 11 SCC 696 has held thus:
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/19/2024
5:34:21 PM
42. In any event we feel that the High Court's approach is
clearly erroneous. The present appellants in the counter affidavit filed
had raised a preliminary objection as regards the maintainability of
the writ petitions and had requested the High Court to grant further
opportunity if the necessity so arises to file a detailed counter
affidavit after the preliminary objections were decided. The High
Court in fact in one of the orders clearly indicated that the
preliminary objections were to be decided first.
14. Taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the case
and in the light of judgment rendered by the Apex Court in the case of Union of
India and Others(supra), that preliminary objection raised by the
appellant/bank as regards maintainability of petition has not been dealt with by
the learned Single Judge, it would be appropriate to remand the matter back for
fresh adjudication in accordance with law.
15.
Accordingly, the order dated 21.02.2023 passed in W.P. No.
6709/2021 is set aside. The matter is remanded back to the learned Single
Judge for hearing the case on the question of maintainability as well as merits
and decide the same after hearing both the parties in accordance with law as
expeditiously as possible.
16. The writ appeal stands finally disposed off.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
sh
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/19/2024
5:34:21 PM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review