Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 04
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRAA No. 35/2007
Date of pronouncement: 26.02.2026.
Date of uploading:
State of J & K and others
.....Applicant(s)/Appellant(s)
Through :- Mr. Nirmal K Kotwal, Advocate vice
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG
v/s
Amarjeet Singh S/o Maan Singh R/o Amar
Singh Ahata, Jammu
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Rahul Raina, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
SANJEEV KUMAR J
1.
This appeal by the State of J&K, now the Union Territory of J&K, arises
from a judgment of acquittal dated 26.04.2007, passed by the Court of
learned 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Jammu [“the Trial Court”], in file
No. 84/Sessions, titled “State of J&K and others Vs. Amarjeet Singh”.
2.
The impugned judgment has been assailed by the appellants on multiple
grounds. However, before we advert to the grounds of challenge urged by
learned counsel appearing for the appellants, we deem it appropriate to
take note of the prosecution story as was projected by the prosecution
before the Trial Court.
3.
The Police of Police Station, Pacca Danga, Jammu registered an FIR on
27.12.2004, on the basis of a verbal report lodged by PW-Rajan Khonja,
CRAA No. 35/2007
stating therein that on 27.12.2004 around 8:45 pm, he along with PWNarinder Singh, PW-Narotam Sharma, PW-Sanjeev Singh Jamwal and
some other boys, was standing at the gate of Ahata Amar Singh. The
respondent, who was having a long-standing enmity with Narinder Singh,
came on spot and started abusing him. He extended Narinder Singh life
threats to which Narinder Singh objected.
4.
It was further stated that the respondent left the place in annoyance after
threatening Narinder Singh. The respondent, however, came back on the
spot once again and this time carrying a Kirch in his hand. He stabbed
Narinder Singh in his chest and belly with Kirch and injured him
seriously. PW further stated that he along with others tried to intervene
and even chased the respondent, but he somehow managed to escape. The
injured was shifted in autorickshaw to the Govt. Medical College, where
he later succumbed to his injuries.
5.
Upon registration of FIR No. 296/2004, initially under Section 307 RPC
and 4/25 Arms Act, and later under Section 302 RPC and 4/25 Arms Act,
the investigation was set in motion. The Investigating Officer got the postmortem of the deceased conducted through PW-Dr. Anayat Ullah Sheikh.
The wearing apparels of the deceased were seized. The statements of the
witnesses under Section 161 Cr.P.C were recorded and on completion of
other requisite formalities, the chargesheet was laid before the Court. The
respondent was charged for Commission of offences punishable under
Section 302 RPC read with 4/25 Arms Act. The respondent pleaded not
guilty to the charge and claimed to be tried.
CRAA No. 35/2007
6.
With a view to prove its case, the prosecution examined PW-Sanjeev
Kumar, PW-Rajan Khonja, PW-Narotam Sharma, PW-Romesh Kumar,
PW-Rajesh Gupta, PW-Anoop Singh, PW-Sanjeev Singh Jamwal, PWJyoti Billoria, PW- Updesh Singh, PW-Amar Nath Badyal, PW-Mool Raj
and PW- Dr. Anayat Ullah Sheikh.
7.
On closure of the prosecution evidence, the incriminating evidence was
put to the respondent and his statement under Section 342 Cr.P.C was
recorded. He branded all the witnesses a liars and claimed innocence. He,
however, chose not to lead any evidence in defence.
8.
The Trial Court appreciated the oral as well as documentary evidence on
record and came to the conclusion that the evidence on record was
contradictory in nature and did not inspire the confidence of the Court.
The Trial Court was of the opinion that only two witnesses i.e., PWSanjeev Singh Jamwal (maternal cousin of the deceased) and PW-Jyoti
Billoria (wife of the deceased) to some extent supported the prosecution
case, but there were inherent contradictions in their statements which
made their presence on the scene of occurrence highly doubtful.
Disbelieving the prosecution evidence, the Trial Court gave benefit of
doubt to the respondent and acquitted him of the charge in terms of the
judgment impugned.
9.
The impugned judgment has been challenged by the appellants primarily
on the ground that the Trial Court has failed to appreciate in right
perspective the oral as well as documentary evidence on record, in
particular, the statements of eye witnesses, PW-Sanjeev Singh Jamwal,
and PW-Jyoti Billoria. The Trial Court has thrown out the case of the
CRAA No. 35/2007
prosecution on finding minor contradictions in the statement of the
aforesaid two witnesses.
10.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on
record, we are of the considered opinion that the judgment of acquittal
passed by the Trial Court is perfectly legal and does not suffer from any
infirmity. The Trial Court has appreciated evidence in correct perspective
and has rightly concluded that the testimonies of the two eye witnesses
i.e., PW-Sanjeev Singh Jamwal, and PW-Jyoti Billoria, the only eye
witnesses who have supported the case of prosecution are fraught with
serious contradictions making their presence on the scene of occurrence
highly doubtful.
11.
We have gone through the judgment as also evidence on record. It needs
to be stated that PW- Rajan Khonja, who claimed to have witnessed the
commission of crime and lodged FIR with the Police Station on the date
of occurrence itself, has turned hostile. He has even denied having lodged
any FIR with regard to the incident. He was also a witness to the
disclosure statement made by the respondent and the recovery of Kirch
allegedly recovered at his instance, but did not support the prosecution
case when he entered the witness box before the Trial Court. He has
denied having seen the respondent making any disclosure statement or any
recovery of weapon of offence made at his instance. The other witnesses
like PW-Sanjeev Kumar, PW-Narotam Sharma, PW-Romesh Kumar,
PW-Rajesh Gupta, and PW-Anoop Singh have either turned hostile or
have indicated their presence on the spot after the occurrence had
happened.
CRAA No. 35/2007
12.
PW-Anoop Singh is brother of the deceased and was cited as an eye
witness by the prosecution. In his deposition before the Trial Court, he has
denied having seen occurrence and has stated that at the time of
occurrence, he had gone to the house of his father’s sister and was
informed about the occurrence by his sister. This way he too did not
support the prosecution case.
13.
The Trial Court was, thus, left with testimony of PW-Sanjeev Singh
Jamwal, and PW-Jyoti Billoria. Although PW-Sanjeev Singh Jamwal has
to some extent supported the prosecution case and stood by his statement
that he had seen the respondent inflicting Kirch injury on the deceased, but
his presence on the spot has been seriously doubted by the Trial Court for
the reason that he was a chance witness and it was highly improbable that
he was present on the spot on three occasions under similar set of
circumstances and in the presence of similar set of witnesses and people.
14.
The Trial Court has also found his statement in serious contradiction with
the statement of PW-Jyoti Billoria. Similarly the statement of PW-Jyoti
Billoria, too has not been believed by the Trial Court. On appreciation of
the evidence, the Trial Court was of the opinion that had the PW-Jyoti
Billoria been present on spot, the other eye witnesses in particular PWSanjeev Singh Jamwal, would have spoken about her presence in his
statement made before the Police under Section 161 Cr. P.C or in their
testimony made before the Trial Court.
15.
The Trial Court has, thus, rightly came to the conclusion that PW-Sanjeev
Singh Jamwal, a close relative of the deceased (a cousin), was introduced
CRAA No. 35/2007
as the eye witness by the Police to strengthen its case. Similar is the view
of the Trial Court with regard to PW-Jyoti Billoria.
16.
We have gone through the testimonies of PW-Sanjeev Singh Jamwal, and
PW-Jyoti Billoria, and we see no good reason to differ with the view
taken by the Trial Court upon appreciation of their testimonies. Apart
from the aforesaid witnesses, there is no other material evidence on record
which would connect the respondent with the commission of murder of
the deceased Narinder Singh.
17.
Needless to reiterate that the scope of interference by the appellate Court
with the judgment of acquittal rendered by the Trial Court is limited and
well-circumscribed. Even if the appellate Court, on appreciation of
evidence, is of the opinion that a view other than the one taken by the Trial
Court is possible yet it would tend to take the view taken by the Trial
Court and the view that goes in favour of the accused. Undoubtedly, there
is a presumption of innocence in favour of the accused, and such
presumption gets fortified when he earns acquittal from the Trial Court.
18.
For all these reasons we are not inclined to interfere with well-reasoned
judgment of acquittal passed by the Trial Court. The appeal is found
devoid of any merit and is, accordingly, dismissed.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
26.02.2026
Shafqat
Whether this order is reportable: Yes/No
Whether this order is speaking: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review