Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1RFA No.100414 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
®
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100414 OF 2018
BETWEEN:
SRI. SRIDHAR
S/O LATE G. KRISHNAMURTHY
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: AGRIL.,
R/O: ANNUR GOURAMMA CAMP,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL-582114.
…APPELLANT
Digitally signed
by
MOHANKUMAR
B SHELAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
(BY SRI. RAJASHEKAR GUNJALLI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
LALITHA
D/O LATE G. KRISHNAMURTHY
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: AGRIL.,
R/O: ANNUR GOURAMMA CAMP,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL-582114.
NOW AT:C/O RADHA KRISHNAN
II 41 8TH “A” CROSS,
BHADRAPPA LAYOUT, MARUTI NAGAR,
NAGASHETTY BANGALORE NORTH-560094.
2.
SMT. SRILAKSHMI
W/O LATE G. KRISHNAMURTHY
AGE: 58 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: HIREJANTHAKAL ROAD,
ANNUR GOURAMMA CAMP,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL-582114.
-2RFA No.100414 of 2018
3.
SMT. VALARAMATI
W/O RADHAKRISHNA
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: NO.38, 1ST MAIN ROAD,
5TH CROSS, MARUTHINAGAR,
NAGASHETTYHALLI, BENGALURU-94.
4.
SMT. RENUKA
W/O VEERESH GONAL
AGE: 28 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: HEROOR VILLAGE,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL-582114.
…RESPONDENTS
(R4-HELD SUFFICIENT;
R1 TO R3-APPEAL DISMISSED (VIDE ORDER DATED 19.02.2025)
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
96 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE PASSED BY THE LEARNED SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE AT GANGAVATHI IN OS NO.58/2014 DATED
09.07.2018
IN
RESPECT
OF
GRANTING
SHARE
IN
SUIT
ITEM NO 5 IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS RFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT
ON
PRONOUNCEMENT
20.01.2026
THIS
DAY,
AND
COMING
JUDGMENT
WAS
ON
DELIVERED
THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
FOR
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
-3RFA No.100414 of 2018
CAV JUDGMENT
The present appeal is filed by defendant No.4 to set
aside the judgment and decree dated 09.07.2018 passed in
O.S.No.58/2014 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge at
Gangavathi (hereinafter referred to as 'the trial Court' for
short) in respect of granting share in suit item No.5.
2.
The
appellant
herein
is
defendant
No.4,
respondent No.1 herein is the plaintiff and the respondents
No.2 to 4 herein are the defendants No.1 to 3 before the
trial Court.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties herein
are referred to as per their ranking before the trial Court.
4.
Brief facts of the case are as follows:
The suit is filed for partition and separate possession
wherein the plaintiff seeks her 1/5th share by metes and
bounds in the suit schedule properties, contending that the
same are ancestral joint family properties of herself and
defendants. It is the specific case of the plaintiff that
defendant No.1 is her mother, defendant Nos.2 and 3 are
-4RFA No.100414 of 2018
her sisters, and defendant No.4 is her brother and that the
suit
schedule
properties
stand
in
the
names
of
the
defendants and late G. Krishnaswamy, the father of the
plaintiff. According to the plaintiff, there is no prior partition
in the family, and all of them are in joint possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule properties. It is further
pleaded that upon demand for partition and allotment of her
legitimate share, the same was denied by the defendants,
therefore, cause of action arose for the plaintiff to file a suit
for partition and separate possession.
5.
After service of summons, defendants No.1 to 4
entered appearance through their counsel. Defendant No.1
filed her written statement, defendants No.2 and 3 did not
file any written statement; and defendant No.4 adopted the
written statement filed by defendant No.1.
6.
Defendant No.1, while admitting the relationship
between the parties, denied all other plaint averments and
contended that the suit schedule properties are neither
ancestral nor joint family properties. It is specifically
-5RFA No.100414 of 2018
pleaded that suit schedule item No.2 was purchased by
defendant No.1 from Narasappa under a registered sale
deed dated 18.05.1987 and her name was mutated in the
revenue records.
From the income generated from item
No.2, she purchased item No.9 from K. Nageshwararao
under a registered sale deed dated 16.06.1989 and item
No.10 from Smt. Kokilamma under a registered sale deed
dated 13.04.2000 and her name was mutated in the
revenue records. It is further contended that suit schedule
item No.1 originally belonged to her father Sanniyappa S/o
Alagiri, who relinquished the same in her favour and from
its income, she purchased item No.7 under a registered sale
deed dated 30.06.2012. Defendant No.1 thus asserts
absolute ownership over item Nos.1, 2, 7, 9 and 10. It is
further contended that defendant No.2 purchased item No.4
under a registered sale deed dated 15.10.2001 and she is
the absolute owner.
7.
Defendant No.4, having independent income as a
contractor purchased item No.5 out of his self-earnings
-6RFA No.100414 of 2018
under registered sale deed No.454/2004-05. According to
defendant No.1, item Nos.1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 9 and 10 were not
left by deceased G. Krishnaswamy, and that only item
Nos.3, 6 and 8 were belonged to him. It is further pleaded
that late G. Krishnaswamy suffering from kidney ailments in
his last days, for which defendant Nos.1 and 4 incurred
heavy medical expenses.
To clear such dues, defendant
No.4 availed a loan of Rs.14,00,000/- by mortgaging item
Nos.6 and 8, apart from an additional loan of Rs.7,00,000/obtained by defendants No.1 and 4 from Pragathi Krishna
Gramin Bank, Sangapur and VSSNS, Mallapur.
8.
The trial Court based on the pleadings of the
parties, framed the following issues for its consideration:
i. Whether plaintiff proves that the suit schedule
properties are joint family ancestral properties of
herself and defendants?
ii. Whether plaintiff proves that she has 1/5th
share in suit properties?
iii. Whether defendant No.1 proves that item
No.1, 2, 7, 9 & 10 of suit schedule properties are
absolute properties of defendant No.1 as pleaded
-7RFA No.100414 of 2018
in para No.9 of written statement of defendant
No.1?
iv. Whether defendant No.4 proves that he is
absolute owner of item No.4 and 5 of suit
properties?
v. What order or decree?
9.
In
order
to
substantiate
her
case,
plaintiff
examined herself as PW-1 and got marked documents
marked as Exs.P1 to P57. On the other hand, defendant
No.4 examined himself as DW-1 and got marked documents
marked as Exs.D1 to D22.
10. The trial Court based on the pleadings, oral and
documentary evidence, decreed the suit in part with costs.
It is held that the plaintiffs and defendants are entitled to a
1/5th share in the suit schedule item Nos.3, 5, 6 and 8
properties.
11. Learned counsel for the appellant-defendant No.4
submitted that the finding of the trial Court granting a share
in item No.5 of the suit schedule property is perverse,
against both oral and documentary evidence. The trial Court
-8RFA No.100414 of 2018
failed to appreciate that the father of the appellant was
suffering from a prolonged kidney ailment, for which
substantial amounts were spent by raising loans from third
parties. After the death of the father of the appellant,
agricultural lands were mortgaged to banks and loans were
availed and repaid. In view of these undisputed facts, there
was no surplus income from joint family properties, and the
conclusion that item No. 5 is joint family property is
erroneous.
12. He further submitted that the appellant has been
working independently as a contractor with S.P. Ramu and
S.P. Nagaraju, the maternal uncles of the appellant and he
has independent earnings. From such self-acquired income,
the appellant purchased item No.5 of the suit schedule
property.
Respondent
No.1-plaintiff,
in
her
cross-
examination, has admitted that the appellant has been
working as a PWD contractor from the past 15 years and
had independent income as early as the year 2004.
Respondent No.1 is a well-educated B.E. graduate, residing
-9RFA No.100414 of 2018
at Bengaluru, and was fully aware of the family affairs,
including
appellant’s
the
loans
father
raised
and
the
for
the
treatment
subsequent
bank
of
the
loans
approximately to the tune of Rs.14,00,000/- secured by
mortgaging suit item Nos.3 and 6 after his death.
13. Heard learned counsel for the appellant and
perused the materials placed on record.
14. Having considered the contentions advanced and
upon re-appreciation of the pleadings and material placed
on record, this Court finds no infirmity in the judgment and
decree passed by the trial Court. The plaintiff failed to prove
that all suit schedule properties are ancestral joint family
properties. The plaint is conspicuously silent as to the
existence of any ancestor prior to late G. Krishnaswamy,
and no material is placed to show devolution of property
through three male generations. In the absence of such
pleadings and evidence, the trial Court rightly held that the
suit properties cannot be treated as ancestral properties.
- 10 RFA No.100414 of 2018
The claim could extend only to properties standing in the
name of late G. Krishnaswamy during his lifetime.
15. It is not in dispute that suit schedule items No.3,
6 and 8 stood in the name of late G. Krishnaswamy. The
RTC extracts placed on record disclose that these properties
continued in his name and thereafter devolved upon his
legal heirs. There is neither pleading nor evidence of
severance of joint family status. The trial Court has
correctly applied the settled principle that a Hindu family is
presumed to be joint unless the contrary is established, and
has rightly held that these properties constitute joint family
properties which are liable for partition among the plaintiff
and defendants.
16. The trial Court has also rightly held that the
existence of joint family nucleus stood proved in respect of
the aforesaid properties. The admissions of the defendants
coupled with the revenue records establish that the family
had income-yielding joint family properties. Therefore, the
burden
shifted
on
the
defendants
to
establish
that
- 11 RFA No.100414 of 2018
subsequent acquisitions standing in their names were made
from independent sources and not from joint family income.
17. Insofar as suit schedule item No.5 is concerned,
defendant No.4 claimed that it is his self-acquired property.
However, no documentary evidence was produced to prove
his independent income or contracting business. On the
contrary, the evidence shows that defendant No.4 had
access to income from joint family properties, particularly
suit schedule item No.6, which stood transferred to his
name after the death of G. Krishnaswamy. In the absence
of evidence of sufficient independent income, the trial Court
rightly presumed that item No.5 was acquired from joint
family nucleus.
18. In respect of the suit schedule item Nos. 1, 2, 7,
9 and 10 standing in the name of defendant No.1 and item
No.4 standing in the name of defendant No.2 is concerned,
the trial Court has correctly held that these are the absolute
properties of defendants No.1 and 2 respectively. The sale
deeds and mutation entries clearly establish individual
- 12 RFA No.100414 of 2018
acquisitions and there is no document to show use of joint
family funds. Even assuming that the said property is gifted
to defendant No.2 by G. Krishnaswamy during his lifetime,
such
properties
would
vest
absolutely
in
the
female
defendants under Section 14(1) of the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956, and are not amenable to partition. Therefore, the
decree granting the 1/5th share to the plaintiff only in suit
schedule items No.3, 5, 6 and 8 therefore warrants no
interference.
19. Section 14 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
reads as under:“14. Property of a female Hindu
to be her absolute property.(1)Any property possessed by a female
Hindu, whether acquired before or after the
commencement of this Act, shall be held by
her as full owner thereof and not as a limited
owner.
Explanation.—In
this
sub-section,
“property”
includes
both
movable
and
immovable property acquired by a female
Hindu by inheritance or devise, or at a
partition, or in lieu of maintenance or arrears
of maintenance, or by gift from any person,
whether a relative or not, before, at or after
her marriage, or by her own skill or exertion,
or by purchase or by prescription, or in any
other manner whatsoever, and also any such
- 13 RFA No.100414 of 2018
property held by her as stridhana immediately
before the commencement of this Act.
(2)
Nothing
contained
in
subsection (1) shall apply to any property
acquired by way of gift or under a will or any
other instrument or under a decree or order of
a civil court or under an award where the
terms of the gift, will or other instrument or
the decree, order or award prescribe a
restricted estate in such property”.
20. For the foregoing discussions, this Court finds
that the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court is
based
on
proper
appreciation
of
pleadings,
oral and
documentary evidence. In view of the above, this Court
proceeds to pass the following:ORDER
(i)
The appeal is devoid of merit stands
dismissed.
(ii)
The
judgment
and
decree
dated
09.07.2018, passed in O.S.No.58/2014 on
the file of the Senior Civil Judge at
Gangavathi is hereby confirmed.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(DR.K.MANMADHA RAO)
JUDGE
MBS
CT:VP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review