Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.465 of 2023
Sri Uttam Kumar Das
S/o Sri Nitya Lal Das resident of Dhaleswar,
Ashram Chowmuhani, Swami Vivekananda Lane,
PO-Dhaleswar, PS-East Agartala, District: West Tripura.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by its Secretary, Social Welfare & Social Education
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The Secretary,
Social Welfare & Social Education Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
3. The Director,
Social Welfare & Social Education Department, Government of Tripura,
Ujan Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura-799005
4. Tripura Public Service Commission,
represented by its Secretary, having his office at Akhaura Road,
Agartala, West Tripura
5. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission
having his office at Akhaura Road, Agartala, West Tripura
6. The Chairman, DPC/Selection Committee (Chairman, Tripura
Public Service Commission) having his office at Akhaura Road,
Agartala, West Tripura
7. Sri John Calvin Debbarma,
at present posted as Joint Director at the office of Directorate of Social
Welfare & Social Education, Ujan Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura
8. Dr. Chandrani Biswas,
at present posted as Joint Director at the office of the Directorate of
Social Welfare and Social Education Department, Ujan Abhoynagar,
Agartala, West Tripura
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate
For respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & Order
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Adv. General
Mr. Tapash Datta Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. GA
Mr. Mintu Debbarma, Advocate
:
26/03/2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned
Advocate General assisted by Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned
Addl. GA appearing for the respondents no.1, 2 and 3 and Mr.
Tapash Datta Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Mintu Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
no.7 and 8.
2.
Admittedly, the petitioner, Sri Uttam Kumar Das and
Sri John Calvin Debbarma (respondent no.7) as well as Dr.
Chandrani Biswas (respondent no.8) were working along with Sri
Arun Kumar Debbarma, Sri Bijan Chakraborty and Sanjit Rupini
as Deputy Director/Programme Officer in Education (Social
Welfare & Social Education) Department [for short, „SW&SE‟],
Government of Tripura. Vide Notification dated 18.01.2023 in
exercise of Article 309 of the Constitution and in supersession of
the earlier Recruitment Rules for the post of Joint Director
(SW&SE), 3(three) posts of Joint Director were created as
promotional post from the post of Deputy Director/Programme
Officer with 5(five) years of experience in the feeder post.
3.
In 2021, a promotion policy was framed by the State
vide Notification No.F.2(24)-GA(P&T)/2021 dated 22.06.2021
(Annexure R-1) for doing promotional exercises as a stop-gap
arrangement in view of the fact that the judgment and order
dated 09.04.2015 of the High Court was challenged before the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court vide SLP(C) No.19765-19767 of 2015
and meanwhile, a large number of posts had fallen vacant to be
filled up on promotion to avoid hindrance in the day-to-day
discharge of administration of the State Government. The
relevant paragraph nos.6 and 7 of the said promotion policy of
2021 are extracted hereunder for purposeful reference:
“6. Now, the State Government hereby notifies the following
Promotion Policy, 2021 as follows:
(i) Rule 9 of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992 and the
provisos thereto shall be read in such a manner that only those
SC & ST candidates who have qualified solely on the basis of
merit and have never taken the benefit of reservation, will be
treated to be own merit candidates and entitle to occupy the
posts meant for general category and reservation shall be made
cadre-wise.
(ii) 100 point roster shall apply only where the number of posts in
the cadre is 4(four) or more.
(iii) Where the post in the cadre are 3(three) or less, the 3(three)
point replacement roster shall be followed.
(iv) Single post or small cadres cannot be combined to make the
number of posts more than 3(three).
7. Following the above policy, the DPC will identify employees eligible
for promotion to a particular post against the available vacancies.
After this exercise, DPC shall consider another exercise taking into
account the procedure as stated in the rule 9(2) of the Tripura SC &
ST Reservation Rules, 1992. Due to such exercise, if any candidate is
found not considered in the process as stated in the above process,
then such candidates shall be considered for ad-hoc promotion by
creating supernumerary post(s).”
4.
After that policy came into force, the concerned DPC
of the said SW&SE Department made a promotional exercise for
filling up the said posts of said Joint Director on 04.04.2023 and
above six persons were found to have come into the zone of
consideration for such exercise. As it appears from said DPC
minutes, two out of said three sanctioned posts of Joint Director
are to be filled up form UR category and one post is to be filled
up
from
ST
category.
After
necessary
consideration
of
candidature as well as eligibility of above said 6(six) officers, the
DPC
finally
recommended
Sri
Arun
Kumar
Debbarma
for
promotion against ST post and Sri Bijan Chakraborty and Dr.
Chandrani Biswas (respondent no.8) against 2(two) UR vacant
posts. Simultaneously, the DPC also proposed for promotion of
one ST candidate, namely, Sri John Calvin Debbarma against
creation of supernumerary post and on such recommendation of
the DPC, the State issued a Notification dated 22.05.2023
(Annexure-6) by promoting the above said 4(four) persons on
ad-hoc basis with a request to the officers to join their places of
posting by 24.05.2023 positively. The said notification is under
challenge in this writ petition by the petitioner.
5.
The grievance canvassed in this writ petition by the
petitioner is that as per said DPC minutes, there were 3(three)
sanctioned posts [2(two) UR category and 1(one) ST category],
but the respondent
no.7 i.e. John Calvin Debbarma
was
recommended against supernumerary post without considering
the fact that as per 100 point roster, 4th post should be filled up
from SC category, and the petitioner here among the six
persons, only belongs to SC category. However, later on from the
counter affidavit, it came to light that there are only 3(three)
promotional posts of Joint Director wherein 100 point roster will
not be applicable, rather replacement roster will be applicable as
per
the
Tripura
Scheduled
Castes
and
Scheduled
Tribes
Reservation Act, 1991 and according to the State, as per said
replacement roster, there was no vacancy for SC category of
candidate.
6.
During the course of hearing, Mr. Lodh, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that as per said replacement
roster, one ST candidate was only supposed to be promoted to
the post of Joint Director and accordingly the same was done by
the Department by promoting one Sri Arun Kumar Debbarma,
but as per the promotional policy of 2021 as framed by the
State, more particularly, in paragraph 7 of the same, it is
envisaged that after this exercise of promotion, the DPC shall
consider another exercise taking into account the procedure as
stated in Rule 9(2) of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules,
1992 and due to such exercise, if any candidate is found not
considered in the process as stated in the above process, then
such candidates shall be considered for ad-hoc promotion by
creating supernumerary post(s).
[emphasis supplied]
6.1
According to learned counsel for the petitioner, as per
said Paragraph 7, the responsibility of the department was to
give promotion to Sanjit Rupini and also to Uttam Kumar Das
(present petitioner) by creating supernumerary posts along with
said John Calvin Debbarma (respondent no.7) as all the three
were senior to said Smt. Chandrani Biswas (respondent no.8)
who was given promotion under the UR quota. But, here,
according to learned counsel, Mr. Lodh, the State has committed
discrimination by only promoting John Calvin Debbarma by
creating such supernumerary post to the utter deprivation of the
said present petitioner and Sanjit Rupini. Mr. Lodh, learned
counsel also tries to impress that the words mentioned in
paragraph 7 of the said policy i.e. “due to such exercise, if any
candidate is found not considered in the process” though denote
singularity in number but the subsequent wordings of said
paragraph i.e. “such candidates shall be considered for ad-hoc
promotion by creating supernumerary post(s)” denotes plurality
and therefore, what is mentioned in the former part of the clause
in singular form will also to be automatically interpreted to cover
the plurality of “any person” and therefore, it was the duty of the
concerned Department to promote the petitioner by creating a
supernumerary post and thus there has been violation of Article
14 of the Constitution by causing discrimination to the petitioner.
7.
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned Advocate General,
argues that the promotion policy of 2021 was not challenged by
the petitioner and even he also did not challenge the decision of
the DPC and therefore he is estopped from challenging the same
in the hearing now. Learned Advocate General also contends that
the entire writ petition was projected by misconception of facts
that 100 point roster was applicable in case of the petitioner and
not the replacement roster. Learned Advocate General further
argues that promotion is not a matter of right and therefore the
claim of the petitioner is required to be turned down. Learned
Advocate General with all emphasis submits that the words “any
person” as mentioned in paragraph no. 7 of the said promotion
policy will denote only “a single person” and cannot be
interpreted to cover plurality and the words “such candidates” as
mentioned in said Rules are merely a typographical mistake,
rather it should be considered as “such candidate” and not “such
candidates”.
8.
Learned senior counsel, Mr. T. D. Majumder on the
other hand, submits that Dr. Chandrani Biswas was promoted as
she was UR candidate and Sri John Calvin Debbarma was senior
to the present petitioner in the seniority list and therefore, he
was also rightly promoted by creating supernumerary post as per
the policy of the State Government framed in 2021 and in no
way the petitioner can supersede him.
9.
This
Court
has
given
due
consideration
to
the
submissions made by all the parties and also have meticulously
perused the records. The core issue here for decision is
interpretation of the provisions of paragraph 7 of the promotion
policy dated 22.06.2021. As per said provision after due
promotional exercise if any candidate is found not considered in
the process as stated in the said paragraph then such candidates
shall
be
considered
for
ad-hoc
promotion
by
creating
supernumerary posts. Though the learned Advocate General
submits that in the first part of said sentence of paragraph no.7,
consciously it was mentioned as “if any candidate is found not
considered” by the policy maker, therefore, in the later part of
that sentence “such candidates shall be considered” should be
understood as said candidate by ignoring the letter „s‟ in word
„candidates‟, however, such interpretation is not accepted by this
court for the reason that all the words were used consciously by
the policy maker in the said policy and the words “such
candidates” are followed by other two words “supernumerary
post(s)” and such use of word post(s) itself indicates that the
basic intention of the policy maker was to mean plurality. In this
regard, assistance may also be taken from Section 13 of the
General Clauses Act, 1897 where it is envisaged that the words
in the singular form shall include the plural, and vice-versa.
10.
This Court has also gone through the decision of the
DPC. From their minutes dated 04.04.2023, it reveals that the
promotion was to be given on the basis of merit-cum-seniority
and after consideration of ACR grading of the eligible candidates,
but detailed discussion as to how such assessment was made,
was not reflected in the minutes. However, there being no
specific challenge on that point, this Court is not embarking upon
that issue. However, what is revealed from the final decision of
the DPC is that the above said 3(three) persons, namely Sri Arun
Kumar Debbarma, Sri Bijan Chakraborty and Smt. Chandrani
Biswas, were proposed for promotion against three sanctioned
posts along with promotion of Sri John Calvin Debbarma by
creation of such supernumerary post. The DPC did not give any
further reason as to why it considered only the case of Sri John
Calvin
Debbarma
to
be
promoted
by
creation
of
such
supernumerary post leaving the other two candidates namely, Sri
Uttam Kr. Das and Sanjit Rupini apart. In that perspective, this
Court
vide
order
dated
26.07.2024
directed
the
State-
respondents to clarify by affidavit as to why after fulfillment of
the three vacancies as per Replacement Roster Policy, only one
supernumerary post was created to accommodate said John
Calvin Debbarma whereas the other two persons including the
petitioner were also senior to respondent no.8, Smt. Chandrani
Biswas. Thereafter, one additional affidavit was submitted, but
this court was not satisfied with the reply given by the State in
this regard. Then, liberty was given to learned Addl. GA, Mr.
Mangal
Debbarma
vide
order
dated
02.08.2024
to
seek
instructions about the cadre strength of the post of Joint
Director, (SW & SE) and also to seek instruction from the GA
(P&T) Department and also from the parent department of the
petitioner i.e. the Social Welfare & Social Education Department
as to why only one supernumerary post was created, but
ultimately, the State-respondents failed to answer the query of
this court made in this regard.
11.
The
grievance
of
the
petitioner
that
when
the
petitioner himself was senior to respondent no.8, like respondent
no.7 and was deprived of getting promotion after promotional
exercise was done by the concerned department as per the
promotional policy of 2021, it was incumbent upon the concerned
department to explain as to why they felt it necessary to give
promotion to respondent no.7 only by creating a supernumerary
post and by depriving two others who were senior to said
respondent no.7 and stood on the same footing like respondent
no.7, especially when the Promotion Policy of 2021 does not
restrict the creation of supernumerary post more than one. This
Court finds force in the submission of Ld. Counsel Mr. Lodh. Lack
of
any
reasoning
respondent
no.7
or
justification
in
giving
promotion
alone
depriving
the
petitioner,
to
manifests
discriminatory treatment towards the petitioner.
12.
In view of the above, the State-respondents are
directed to examine and consider the case of the present
petitioner for the purpose of promotion to the post of Joint
Director by creation of a supernumerary post like Sri John Calvin
Debbarma, if he is otherwise found eligible to get promotion. As
Sri Sanjit Rupini is not before this Court, no observation is being
made in respect of said Sri Sanjit Rupini. In case, the petitioner
is considered for promotion, his pay and allowances shall be fixed
notionally with all financial benefits with effect from the date of
promotion of other four persons till the date of his joining to the
post of Joint Director. The entire exercise shall be completed
within 8(eight) weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this
order.
Needless to say, if any further grievance persists to
the petitioner against the decision of the Respondents, he may
approach appropriate authority in accordance with law.
13.
With the above observations and directions, the
instant writ petition stands disposed of.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Rohit
Digitally signed
SATABDI
SATABD by
DUTTA
2025.03.28
I DUTTA Date:
12:18:14 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review