The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
41. Therefore, while exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226, the Court is entitled to enquire into whether the action of the State or its instrumentalities is arbitrary or unfair and in consequence, in violation of Article 14. The jurisdiction under Article 226 is a valuable constitutional safeguard against an arbitrary exercise of state power or a misuse of authority. In determining as to whether the jurisdiction should be exercised in a contractual dispute, the Court must, undoubtedly eschew, disputed questions of fact which would depend upon an evidentiary determination requiring a trial. But equally, it is well-settled that the jurisdiction under Article 226 cannot be ousted only on the basis that the dispute pertains to the contractual arena. This is for the simple reason that the State and its instrumentalities are not exempt from the duty to act fairly merely because in their business dealings they have entered into the realm of contract. Similarly, the presence of an arbitration clause does oust the jurisdiction under Article 226 in all cases though, it still needs to be decided from case to case as to whether recourse to a public law remedy can justifiably be invoked. The jurisdiction under Article 226 was rightly invoked by the Single Judge and the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh in this case, when the foundational representation of the contract has failed. TS…
44. 2 If the Intended Completion Date is extended after liquidated damages have been paid, the Engineer shall correct any overpayment of liquidated damages by the Contractor by adjusting the next payment certificate.” It is apparent that the Contractor is under obligation to pay the liquidated damage to ‘the employer’ at the rate per week or part thereof as stated in the Contract data for the period from the stipulated completion date to the actual completion date. Liquidated damages at the same rate shall be withheld if the Contractor fails to achieve the milestones prescribed in the Contract data. [12] When Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. is queried by this court whether any such damage has been reflected in their reply he has candidly submitted that no such plea has been raised by the respondents. According to Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. after the completion certificate is issued, the final payment and the release of security deposit and performance deposit will be considered. As that has not been done as yet, the petitioner does not have any right to claim for releasing the said amount. [13] Having appreciated the submission of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and the respondents also scrutinized the records produced with the writ petition and the rejoinder, this court is of the view that by filing the reply the respondents have admitted two pertinent facts na…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.759 of 2021
Sri Utpal Datta,
son of late Upendra Chandra Datta,
resident of Lake Road,
Haradhan Sangha, Krishnanagar,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura
---- Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary,
Public Works Department,
New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura
2. The Chief Engineer,
Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana,
TRRDA, Secretariat Complex,
Agartala
3. The Chief Engineer,
Public Works Department (Road & Building),
Secretariat Complex, Agartala
4. The Executive Engineer,
Public Works Department (Road & Building),
Dharmanagar Division,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
5. The Superintending Engineer,
Second Circle,
Public Works Department,
Agartala, West Tripura
6. Assistant Engineer,
Public Works Department (Road & Building),
Sub-Division: Panisagar,
Government of Tripura,
P.O. & P.S. Panisagar,
District: North Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. R. Datta, Adv.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. P. Saha, Adv.
Date of Hearing &
Judgment and Order
:
23.03.2022
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. assisted by Mr.
P. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[02]
There is no dispute that the petitioner is a category-1
Contractor
as
registered
under
the
Public
Works
Department,
Government of Tripura, NBCC, NPCC, ONGC, HSCL and several other
Government and Public Sector Enterprises. The petitioner has claimed
his robust experience in the business. In response to the NIT
No.63/CE/PWD (R & B)/SQC/PD-III/2007-08 for up-gradation of road
from Ramnagar to Jalabazar under 40% renewal under Bharat Nirman
Programme, the petitioner participated in the tendering and got
selected.
The
work
order
No.31-718/EE/(DD)/6065-6082
dated
06.11.2018 was issued in favour of the petitioner. According to the
petitioner, he had the liability to provide maintenance services for a
period of five years but that period came to end on 04.05.2017. He
had been pressing for payment of the final bill and release of the
performance security. But that was not so done, notwithstanding the
fact that the petitioner has satisfactorily completed the whole work.
[03]
The petitioner submitted the final bill amounting to
Rs.3,23,697/- to the respondents after completion of the work. The
said final bill, the security deposit and the performance security
deposit amounting to Rs.16,95,358/- had not been paid till the day of
filing of the writ petition, despite serious persuasion from the end of
the petitioner. On 02.12.2019, the petitioner asked the respondents
for payment of the said amount but without any yield. Thereafter, on
21.10.2020, the petitioner issued a notice of demand for releasing the
security deposit, performance security deposit, payment against the
final bill amounting to Rs.19,49,055/- (in aggregate) along with
interest within a period of fortnight. But again, there was no response.
The petitioner has stated that the performance security can be
retained
for
five
years
for
purpose
of
ensuring
the
routine
maintenance in terms of the agreement. For withholding of the said
amount, the petitioner has been put to serious financial stress and
hence he has approached this court for directing the respondents to
release security deposit, performance security deposit amounting to
Rs.95,358/- and the final bill amounting to Rs.3,23,697/- along with
interest etc.
[04]
The respondents have stated in the reply that the writ
petition itself is not maintainable in asmuch as the dispute has arisen
from the contract. That apart, it has been stated that the petitioner
has neither executed any maintenance work nor has corrected any
defect during the five years by way of maintenance in terms of clause32 of the agreement. Clause-32 of the agreement provides that the
defect be corrected by the Contractor, but the petitioner did not
correct the defects. It has been projected in their reply that the final
deviation bill has not been approved. As the petitioner did not execute
the maintenance work in terms of the agreement, he cannot ask for
release of the security deposit and the performance deposit. The
petitioner does not have any indefeasible right as claimed by him.
[05]
In response thereof, the petitioner has filed the rejoinder
stating that there had been no notice to the Contractor (the
petitioner) in terms of the Clause-32.1.1 from the Engineer by
detecting the defects which are to be corrected by the petitioner. This
is an imaginative plea that has been taken by the respondents in order
to defeat the justice. It has been also stated by the petitioner in the
rejoinder that the amount of money has been settled in the contract
for maintenance against each year during the period of five years. The
petitioner never asked for any amount nor had he been asked to
correct any defect. That apart, the petitioner has stated that the final
deviation has been approved by the communication dated 28.01.2022
[Annexure-8 to the writ petition].
[06]
Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel has submitted that the plea
of non-maintainability is without any substance. The act of the
respondents by withholding the due money is a serious breach of the
contractual obligation. There is no dispute regarding completion of the
work. There is no demand for corrective measure in the form of
maintenance. Despite that, arbitrarily for the last four years, the
amount due to the petitioner is being withheld by the respondents. In
respect of the maintainability, Mr. Datta, learned counsel has relied on
a decision in Unitech Limited and Others vs. Telangana State
Industrial
Infrastructure
Corporation
(TSIIC)
and
Others
reported in 2021 SCC Online SC 99. In that report, the apex court
having relied on
ABL International Ltd. vs. Export Credit
Guarantee Corporation of India reported in (2004) 3 SCC 553
has observed as follows:
“39. A two judge Bench of this Court in ABL International
Ltd. v. Export
Credit
Guarantee
Corporation
of
India(2004)3 SCC 553 [ABL International] analyzed a
long line of precedent of this Court8 to conclude that writs
under Article 226 are maintainable for asserting
contractual
rights
against
the
state,
or
its
instrumentalities, as defined under Article 12 of the
Indian Constitution. Speaking through Justice N Santosh
Hegde, the Court held:
“27. …the following legal principles emerge as to the
maintainability of a writ petition:
(a) In an appropriate case, a writ petition as against a
State or an instrumentality of a State arising out of a
contractual obligation is maintainable.
(b) Merely because some disputed questions of fact
arise for consideration, same cannot be a ground to refuse
to entertain a writ petition in all cases as a matter of rule.
(c) A writ petition involving a consequential relief of
monetary claim is also maintainable.”
40. This exposition has been followed by this Court, and
has been adopted by three-judge Bench decisions of this
Court in State of UP v. Sudhir Kumar 9 and Popatrao
Vynkatrao Patil v. State of Maharashtra: Civil Appeal 1600
of 2000 (Supreme Court of India). The decision in ABL
International, cautions that the plenary power under
Article 226 must be used with circumspection when other
remedies have been provided by the contract. But as a
statement of principle, the jurisdiction under Article 226 is
not excluded in contractual matters. Article 23.1 of the
Development Agreement in the present case mandates the
parties to resolve their disputes through an arbitration.
However, the presence of an arbitration clause within a
contract between a state instrumentality and a private
party has not acted as an absolute bar to availing
remedies under Article 226. If the state instrumentality
violates its constitutional mandate under Article 14 to act
fairly and reasonably, relief under the plenary powers of
the Article 226 of the Constitution would lie. This principle
was recognized in ABL International:
“28. However, while entertaining an objection as to the
maintainability of a writ petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, the court should bear in mind
the fact that the power to issue prerogative writs under
Article 226 of the Constitution is plenary in nature and
is not limited by any other provisions of the
Constitution. The High Court having regard to the facts
of the case, has a discretion to entertain or not to
entertain a writ petition. The Court has imposed upon
itself certain restrictions in the exercise of this power.
(See Whirlpool
Corpn. v. Registrar
of
Trade
Marks [(1998) 8 SCC 1].) And this plenary right of the
High Court to issue a prerogative writ will not normally
be exercised by the Court to the exclusion of other
available remedies unless such action of the State or its
instrumentality is arbitrary and unreasonable so as to
violate the constitutional mandate of Article 14 or for
other valid and legitimate reasons, for which the Court
thinks it necessary to exercise the said jurisdiction.”
(emphasis supplied)
41. Therefore, while exercising its jurisdiction under
Article 226, the Court is entitled to enquire into whether
the action of the State or its instrumentalities is arbitrary
or unfair and in consequence, in violation of Article 14.
The jurisdiction under Article 226 is a valuable
constitutional safeguard against an arbitrary exercise of
state power or a misuse of authority. In determining as to
whether the jurisdiction should be exercised in a
contractual dispute, the Court must, undoubtedly eschew,
disputed questions of fact which would depend upon an
evidentiary determination requiring a trial. But equally, it
is well-settled that the jurisdiction under Article 226
cannot be ousted only on the basis that the dispute
pertains to the contractual arena. This is for the simple
reason that the State and its instrumentalities are not
exempt from the duty to act fairly merely because in their
business dealings they have entered into the realm of
contract. Similarly, the presence of an arbitration clause
does oust the jurisdiction under Article 226 in all cases
though, it still needs to be decided from case to case as to
whether recourse to a public law remedy can justifiably be
invoked. The jurisdiction under Article 226 was rightly
invoked by the Single Judge and the Division Bench of the
Andhra Pradesh in this case, when the foundational
representation of the contract has failed. TSIIC, a state
instrumentality, has not just reneged on its contractual
obligation, but hoarded the refund of the principal and
interest on the consideration that was paid by Unitech
over a decade ago. It does not dispute the entitlement of
Unitech to the refund of its principal.”
[Emphasis added]
[07]
The crux of the said decision is that the jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution cannot be ousted only on the basis that
the dispute pertains to the contractual arena. This is for the simple
reason that the State and its instrumentalities are not exempt from
the duty to act fairly merely because in their business dealings they
have entered into the realm of contract. Even it has been observed
that existence of an arbitration clause does not oust the jurisdiction
under Article 226 in all cases. But this is an area which depends on
the fact adverted in each case. The said decision has also reminded
that going beyond the boundaries of the contract may not be
suggestible under the jurisdiction as conferred by Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
[08]
Mr. Datta, learned counsel has thereafter referred to
paragraph-9 of the reply filed by the respondents where it has been
clearly averred that the work was completed on 05.05.2012, but work
was not completed within the date as stipulated in the work order. The
stipulated date for completion of work was 19.11.2009. Time
extension
was
granted
by
the
competent
authority
by
the
communication No.F.36(269)/SE(I)/KGT/2222-23 dated 08.02.2020
with levy of compensation for an amount of Rs.80,282/-. It has been
also stated that the petitioner has not executed any maintenance work
during the five years, the routine maintenance period as per clause-32
of the agreement, ‘in spite of several persuasion’ as long as the defect
remains to be corrected, the petitioner cannot claim the final
payment. Even the petitioner has not been issued the completion
certificate. A reference has also been made in para-13 of the reply
filed by the respondents. It has been stated that the petitioner’s final
bill has been calculated at Rs.3,23,697.00/-. But the amount could not
be released because the final deviation statement has not been
approved. In response, Mr. Datta, learned counsel has taken this court
to clause-32.1.2 of the agreement, which reads as under:
“Every time notice of Defect/Defects is given, the
Contractor shall correct the notified Defect/Defects within
the length of time specified by the Engineer’s notice.”
Mr. Datta, learned counsel has succinctly submitted
having reference to that clause that at no point of time any notice was
issued to the Contractor (the petitioner) for correcting any defect by
the Engineer. Therefore, there is no question of correcting defect as
asserted by the respondents.
[09].
In this regard Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel has further
taken us to the Bill of Quantities for percentage rate bids [page-78 to
the writ petition] where for each year, the amount has been provided
for purpose of maintenance after completion of the construction. If
maintenance is required, the approved amount is Rs.1,53,14,243.00.
Mr. Datta, learned counsel has categorically stated for the petitioner
that there was no claim on behalf of the petitioner on that amount as
there is no requisition for maintenance during the five years after
completion of the work.
[10]
Mr. Datta, learned counsel has finally submitted that
withholding of the said amount is entirely arbitrary and violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India and the petition deserves to be
allowed by this court.
[11]
Per contra, Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. has stated
that the certificate of completion has not been issued as yet in favour
of the petitioner. The petitioner has not paid the levied amount for
extension of time and at the time of filing the reply, the final deviation
statement was not approved by the competent authority. That apart,
the compensation recoverable from the contractors has not been
determined in terms of the Clause-44.1 and 44.2. For purpose of
reference, those clauses are reproduced hereunder:
“44.1 The Contractor shall pay liquidated damages to the
Employer at the rate per week or part thereof stated in
the Contract Data for the period that the Completion Date
is later than the Intended Completion Date. Liquidated
damages at the same rate shall be withheld if the
Contractor fails to achieve the milestones prescribed in
the Contract Data. However, in case the Contractor
achieves the next milestone the amount of the liquidated
damages already withheld shall be restored to the
Contractor by adjustment in the next payment certificate.
The total amount of liquidated damages shall not exceed
the amount defined in the Contract Data. The Employer
may deduct liquidated damages from payments due to the
Contractor. Payment of liquidated damages shall not
affect the Contractor’s other liabilities.
44.2 If the Intended Completion Date is extended after
liquidated damages have been paid, the Engineer shall
correct any overpayment of liquidated damages by the
Contractor by adjusting the next payment certificate.”
It is apparent that the Contractor is under obligation to
pay the liquidated damage to ‘the employer’ at the rate per week or
part thereof as stated in the Contract data for the period from the
stipulated completion date to the actual completion date. Liquidated
damages at the same rate shall be withheld if the Contractor fails to
achieve the milestones prescribed in the Contract data.
[12]
When Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. is queried by this
court whether any such damage has been reflected in their reply he
has candidly submitted that no such plea has been raised by the
respondents. According to Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. after the
completion certificate is issued, the final payment and the release of
security deposit and performance deposit will be considered. As that
has not been done as yet, the petitioner does not have any right to
claim for releasing the said amount.
[13]
Having appreciated the submission of the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner and the respondents also scrutinized the
records produced with the writ petition and the rejoinder, this court is
of the view that by filing the reply the respondents have admitted two
pertinent facts namely completion of work and lapse of five years of
time for routine maintenance.
[14]
True it is that, no final certificate of completion has been
issued but in para-6 of the reply filed by the respondents they have
admitted that outstanding bill amount is Rs.3,63,697/- and total
security deposit including performance security is Rs.16,95,358/-. In
para-13, again they have stated that since the final deviation
statement is not approved the final bill amounting to Rs.3,63,697/could not be released for payment. But the petitioner has stated that
the final deviation cannot be kept pending for approval by the Chief
Engineer PWD (PMGSY) for an indefinite period. However, there is no
impediment as of now to release the security and the performance
security deposit in favour of the petitioner and also to make payment
of the final bill. The objection that has been raised by Mr.
Bhattacharya, learned G.A. that the certificate of completion of the
work has not been issued, if read with their statements in paragraphs
6 & 13 together, it will be apparent that non-issuance of the said
completion certificate is absolutely arbitrary and violative of the
constitutional spirit as enshrined under Article 14 of the Constitution of
India. For such arbitrary action this writ petition is maintainable in
view of the law laid down by the apex court in Unitech Limited
(supra). As such, the requirement of the issuance of certificate of
completion is liable to be waived and accordingly it is ordered.
[15]
In this resume of facts as noted by this court the
respondents are directed to make payment of the amount of
Rs.3,63,697/- as the final bill for the aforesaid work and to release the
security and performance deposit to the extent of Rs.16,95,358/within a period of one month from the date when the petitioner shall
furnish a copy of this order. It is also clearly mentioned that if the
amount levied for delay in completing the work to the extent of
Rs.80,282/- has not been paid by the petitioner, the said amount shall
be deducted at the time of making payment. This court however is not
inclined to grant any interest from the date when this amount was due
but if this amount is not paid within one month from the delivery of
the copy of the judgment and order that shall carry interest @7% till
the money is realized by the petitioner.
In terms of the above, this writ petition stands allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review