Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.860 of 2021
1. Sri Upendra Tripura,
son of Sudhir Chandra Tripura,
resident of Village & P.O. Sakbari,
P.S. Manubazar, Sabroom, South Tripura
2. Sri Senchandra Tripura,
son of late Haricharan Tripura,
resident of Village-Kalibazar, P.O. Bhuratali,
P.S. Manubazar, Sabroom, South Tripura
………… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Secretary,
Tribal Welfare Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, P.S. New Capital Complex,
PIN -799010
2. The Member Secretary,
Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Society
3. The Principal-in-Charge,
Ekalavya Model Residential School,
B.C., Santirbazar, South Tripura
………… Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of Hearing and
Judgment & Order
:
:
Ms. A. Debbarma, Adv.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
:
15.03.2022
Whether fit for reporting
:
NO
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
JUDGMENT & ORDER(Oral)
Heard Ms. A. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
respondents.
2.
The grievance of the petitioners is that even though they have
completed ten years of service from the date when they had been engaged
as Daily Rated Worker (DRW), their services have not been regularised. It
has been contended that they are covered by the policy of regularisation as
declared
by
the
memorandum
No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part)
dated
21.01.2009 [Annexure-10 to the writ petition]. By the said policy
memorandum, it has been declared that the daily rated workers, contingent
workers and casual workers shall be regularised from the next day of their
completion of their ten years of service. As that has not been done, by means
of this writ petition, the petitioners have urged this court for directing the
respondents to regularise their services on completion of ten years of service
from the day of their engagement as DRW i.e.18.03.2010. One ancillary relief
has been sought for and on behalf of the petitioner No.1 for recording his
qualification of Class-X passed in the service book.
3.
Ms. A. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
has contended that the petitioners have been discharging their duties and
responsibilities as if they were the regular Group-D employees but without
payment of the remuneration at par with the regular employees.
4.
There is no dispute that the petitioners are working under the
Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Society which has
been promoted by the Tribal Welfare Department, Government of Tripura
and the said Society is fully funded by the Government. The petitioners were
engaged by the memorandum dated 15.02.2010 [Annexure-3 to the writ
petition] as DRW at Rs.106.25 per day. By showing the memorandum dated
09.03.2010 [Annexure-4 to the writ petition], it has been contended that the
respondent, Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Society
had accepted joining of the petitioners in the Group-D post. The names of the
petitioners appear respectively at serial Nos.29 and 31. From a bare reading
of the said memorandum dated 09.03.2010, it would appear that the
petitioner No.1 had joined as Cook cum Mashalchi on 17.03.2010 and the
petitioner No.2 had joined as Watchman w.e.f.18.03.2010.
5.
It will be further apparent from the memorandum dated
16.03.2010 [Annexure-5 to the writ petition] that the petitioner No.1 had
been appointed to the post of Group-D against the post of Cook cum
Mashalchi as DRW at Rs.106.25 per day. Similarly, the petitioner No.2 was
appointed as the Group-D by the memorandum dated 16.03.2010 [Annexure6 to the writ petition] against the post of Watchman on daily rate basis.
6.
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has also referred to the proposal
of regularisation of 11 DRWs vide Note No.19 (Annexure-7 to the writ
petition). For purpose of reference, the full text of the said Note No.19 is
extracted hereunder :
Note No.19
Sub : Proposal for regularization of 11 nos. of DRW staff-reg.
11(eleven) nos. DRW staff of TTWREIS have completed 10(ten) years of
continuous service during the month of March, 2020 and are presently working in different
schools under TTWREIS w.e.f. March, 2010.
2.
They were recruited under Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational
Institutions Society (TTWREIS) against the created posts with prior concurrence from the
Finance Deptt., Govt. of Tripura vide U.O. No.1438/Fin(G)/08 dated 16.12.2008 and Memo
No.F.1-496/TW/Estt.(Vol-1)/2007/3077-80 dated 14.01.2009 (copy of Page-60).
3.
In this connection, it is to mention here that, after completion of 10(ten) years
of continuous service as on March, 2020 in the post of DRW, the following staff are eligible for
regularization of their services Finance Department Memos vide No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/2008(Part)
dated 21st January, 2009 (copy vide at Page-63) & No.F.10(12)-FIN(G)/2007(Part-1) dated
7th November, 2012 (copy vide at Page-64).
Sl No.
1.
Name of the DRW
staff/employee
Sri Tripurna Joy Tripura
2.
3.
4.
Smt. Kumari Reang
Sri Dhananjoy Reang
Sri Ananta Reang
5.
Sri Ajit Debbarma
6.
7.
8.
9.
Sri Abadhan Tripura
Smt. Danabi Chakma
Sri Draw Kr. Reang
Sri Upendra Tripura
10.
11.
Sri Senchandra Tripura
Smt. Sebika Tripura
Presently Post
held
Cook-CumMasalchi
Cleaner
Watchman
Cook-CumMasalchi
Cook-CumMasalchi
Watchman
Cleaner
Watchman
Cook-CumMasalchi
Watchman
Cleaner
DRW w.e.f.
18/03/2010(F/N)
Presently
working at
BMRS, KGT
18/03/2010(F/N)
17/03/2010(F/N)
18/03/2010(F/N)
RMMAS, KCP
BMRS, BCN
RMMAS, KCP
18/03/2010(F/N)
RMMAS, ABS
17/03/2010(F/N)
18/03/2010(F/N)
18/03/2010(F/N)
17/03/2010(F/N)
RS, Bhuratali
AS, Karbook
AS, Karbook
BNRS, BCN
18/03/2010(F/N)
17/03/2010(F/N)
RS, Bhuratali
RS, Bhuratali
4.
In this regard, it is stated here that, a joint representation (vide at Page-59)
has been received from these 11(eleven) nos. of DRW staff for regularization of their services
on sympathetically and humanitarian ground.
5.
Presently, these 11(eleven) no. DRW staffs of TTWREIS have completed their
10(ten) years of continuous service are being paid at par with the revised rate of wages @
Rs.230 per day w.e.f.1st October, 2018 as amended by the State Finance Deptt. issued vide
Memo No.7(2)-FIN(PC)/2018 dated 6th November, 2018 (copy at flag-„A‟).
6.
The requirement of Cook-cum-Mashalchi, Watchman & Cleaner for Residential
School(s) are utmost essential for smooth functioning of the schools as they play vital role to
maintain proper hygiene and nutrition in and around hostels and schools.
7.
In view of the above, the matter is no placed before the authority for
regularization of 11(eleven) nos. DRW staff as they completed their 10(ten) years of
continuous service as on March, 2020, if approved.
8.
The initial Scale of Pay of Group-D staff for t eh posts of Cook-cum-Masalchi,
Watchman & Cleaner as per Tripura State Pay Matrix 2018 is Rs.4,840/-13000- GP-1,400/-,
PB-1, Cell-1, Level-1, Entry Pay-Rs.16,000/- (copy at flag-„B‟) and the requirement of fund for
the said purpose will be borne from the Grant to EMR School and Recurring Grant to Society as
per the details herein below :
(In rupees)
Present wages
Monthly
Yearly
6,900/82800/-
For 01 (one) no. DRW staff
Fixed Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
12,000/1,44,000/-
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
18,080/2,16,960/-
@ Rs.230/- per day
Present wages
Monthly
Yearly
75,900/9,10,800/-
(75% of
initial pay)
For 11(eleven) nos. DRW staff
Fixed Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
1,32,000/15,84,000/-
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
2,16,960/26,03,520/-
But what the decision was taken on the said note is not available in the
writ petition.
7.
But from the memorandum dated 24.09.2011 , it transpires, that
the Group-D employees working under Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential
Educational Institutions Society were appointed against the post concurred by
the Finance Department and they were allowed regular pay scale of
Rs.4,530-13,000/- (PB-1) with the grade pay of Rs.1,200/- w.e.f 01.10.2011.
But the petitioners name are not there, but six persons were appointed as
Cook cum Mashalchi and the other eight were appointed as watchmen on
regular scale of pay. The petitioners have been agitating for their
regularisation under the Group-D post or in the post where they are presently
working.
8.
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has submitted that the
petitioners are on the verge of crossing the maximum age limit. That apart,
the engagement of the petitioners was made following a transparent mode.
9.
The respondents No.1, 2 and 3 filed a combined reply and
stated that the petitioners have been working as the Daily Rated Worker
(DRW) w.e.f. 17.03.2010, so far as the petitioner No.1 is concerned and the
petitioner No.2 and 18.03.2010 so far the petitioner No.2 is concerned. The
respondents No.1, 2 and 3 have stated in para-9 of their reply that a proposal
was sent to the Finance Department, Government of Tripura vide Annexure-6
to this writ petition for regularisation of their services. Finance Department in
response of the Note No.24 dated 09.07.2021 has opined that the
department is requested to follow the extant Rule of the State Government in
the proposed matter.”
Thus, Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has repeatedly stated that the
respondents be directed to regularise the services of the petitioner against
the Group-D post. The respondents have further submitted that the
petitioners were engaged on casual basis.
10.
In para-13 of the reply, the respondents have stated that the
petitioners had approached before the respondent department vide
representation dated 02.03.2017, though it is evident from the Memorandum
dated 15.02.2010 [Annexure-3 to this writ petition] and subsequent joining to
their services as DRW on 17.03.2010 and 18.03.2010 respectively that they
have not completed their 10 (ten) years of requisite services as on the date
of representation dated 02.03.2017 and in the light of the Memorandum
dated 01.09.2008 and 21.01.2009 issued by the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura for letting them to come under the zone of
consideration for regularisation of their services under the respondent
establishment.
11.
In para 17 of the said reply, it has been stated that the
respondents were asked by the Finance Department to follow the extant rules
of the State government in the matter of regularisation of the petitioners.
12.
The respondents No.1 to 3 have acceded that the petitioners
have completed their ten years of service on 17.03.2020 so far the petitioner
No.1 was concerned and on 18.03.2020 so far the petitioner No.2 is
concerned.
13.
Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents
has quite categorically stated that when the matter was pending for decision.
Finance
Department
published
the
memorandum
dated
31.07.2018
[Annexure-R/4 to the reply filed by the respondents No.1 to 3]. By means of
the memorandum, the Government of Tripura has cancelled all the
notifications
including
the
memorandum
dated
01.09.2008
and
the
memorandum 21.09.2009 with immediate effect.
14.
In
para-3
of
the
said
memorandum
dated
31.07.2018
[Annexure-R/4 to the reply filed by the respondents No.1 to 3], it has been
provided that with a view to ensure transparent public employment policy for
engagement of staff for such services, all the memorandums as mentioned in
the said memorandum dated 31.07.2018 are repealed. As consequence of the
said memorandum dated 31.07.2018, the plea of the writ petitioners that
they are entitled to be regularised on completion of ten years of service in
view of the policy declared by the memorandum dated 21.01.2009 falls flat.
15.
The solitary question that remains to be answered is that
whether the petitioners are entitled to be considered for regularisation for
their long service as admittedly the petitioners have completed ten years of
service as DRW. In this regard, Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has relied a
decision of this court in Basudeb Debnath and Others versus Union of
India and Others etc. [judgment and order dated 09.03.2021 delivered in
WP(C)1162/2018]. In that judgment, this court has referred to para-53 of
Secretary, State of Karnataka and Others versus Umadevi(3) and
Others reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1 . The said passage is reproduced
hereunder :
“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases
where irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as
explained in S.V. NARAYANAPPA (supra), R.N. NANJUNDAPPA
(supra), and B.N. NAGARAJAN (supra), and referred to in
paragraph 15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly
sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the
employees have continued to work for ten years or more but
without the intervention of orders of courts or of tribunals. The
question of regularization of the services of such employees
may have to be considered on merits in the light of the
principles settled by this Court in the cases above referred to
and in the light of this judgment. In that context, the Union of
India, the State Governments and their instrumentalities should
take steps to regularize as a onetime measure, the services of
such irregularly appointed, who have worked for ten years or
more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of orders of
courts or of tribunals and should further ensure that regular
recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned
posts that require to be filled up, in cases where temporary
employees or daily wagers are being now employed. The
process must be set in motion within six months from this date.
We also clarify that regularization, if any already made, but not
subjudice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but
there should be no further by-passing of the constitutional
requirement and regularizing or making permanent, those not
duly appointed as per the constitutional scheme.”
16.
It has been provided in Umadevi(supra) that qualified persons
who have continued to work for ten years or more without intervention of the
courts or tribunal, they should be regularised against the sanctioned vacant
posts.
17.
In State of Karnataka and Others versus M.L. Kesari and
Others reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247, the apex court has expanded the
scope of Umadevi(supra) by observing that always there is an exception to
the
general
principles
against
regularisation
as
enunciated
in
Umadevi(supra). The said exception as referred above can be formed if the
following conditions are fulfilled :
“(i) The employee concerned should have worked for 10 years
or more in duly sanctioned post without the benefit or
protection of the interim order of any court or tribunal. In other
words, the State Government or its instrumentality should have
employed the employee and continued him in service
voluntarily and continuously for more than ten years.
(ii) The appointment of such employee should not be illegal,
even if irregular. Where the appointments are not made or
continued against sanctioned posts or where the persons
appointed do not possess the prescribed minimum
qualifications, the appointments will be considered to be illegal.
But where the person employed possessed the prescribed
qualifications and was working against sanctioned posts, but
had been selected without undergoing the process of open
competitive selection, such appointments are considered to be
irregular.”
18.
In Basudeb Debnath (supra), it has been observed that
Umadevi(supra) cannot be seen as providing a rigid cut-off date for applying
the principle of ten years of engagement without the court intervention. Any
such argument would give a complete license to the state and its authorities
to continue engage persons on casual basis and to refuse to recognize any of
their rights even after decades of such engagement by citing the cut off date
referred to in Umadevi(supra).
19.
In Amarkant Rai versus State of Bihar and Others
reported in (2015) 8 SCC 265, the apex court having referred to
Umadevi(supra) and M.L. Kesari(supra) directed regularisation of the
daily wagers in the post of clerk for their completing more than ten years by
liberalising the rigidity of the cut-off date.
20.
Again, in Narendra Kumar Tiwari and Others versus State
of Jharkhand and Others reported in (2018) 8 SCC 238 it has been
observed by the apex court that the decision of Umadevi(supra) intended to
put a full stop to pernicious practice of irregulary or illegally appointing daily
wagers and continuing them indefinitely. For that purpose the concept of one
time measure and cut off date were introduced with hope that the state
would cease and desist from making irregular or illegal appointments. It has
been observed in Narendra Kumar Tiwari (supra) as follows :
“7.The purpose and intent of the decision in Umadevi (3) was
therefore two-fold, namely, to prevent irregular or illegal
appointments in the future and secondly, to confer a benefit on
those who had been irregularly appointed in the past. The fact
that the State of Jharkhand continued with the irregular
appointments for almost a decade after the decision in Umadevi
(3) is a clear indication that it believes that it was all right to
continue with irregular appointments, and whenever required,
terminate the services of the irregularly appointed employees
on the ground that they were irregularly appointed. This is
nothing but a form of exploitation of the employees by not
giving them the benefits of regularisation and by placing the
sword of Damocles over their head. This is precisely what
Umadevi (3) and Kesari sought to avoid.”
21.
The petitioners herein have also questioned the wage that has
been paid to them as the Daily Rated Worker. The work that the petitioners
are doing is that of Mashalchi and Watchman. Those posts are borne in the
scale of pay of Rs.4,530/-Rs.13,000/- Pay Band-I with grade pay of
Rs.1,200/-. But the petitioners are getting much less than the minimum of
the said pay scale which is, according to Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel is
contrary to the law laid down by the apex court in State of Punjab and
Others versus Jagjit Singh and Others reported in (2017) 1 SCC 148.
In Jagjit Singh(supra) it has been clearly observed that the daily wages
may not equate with the regular government servant for the purpose of pay
and allowances, nevertheless, on the principle of equal pay for equal work
they must get wages on daily basis in the minimum of the scale prescribed
for the post in question minus other allowances.
22.
Mr. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. has submitted that the
regularisation is not a right, but at the same time he has admitted that after
completion of ten years of continuous service as DRW, the proposal for
regularisation of service of the petitioners along with other nine DRWs were
initiated and sent to the Finance Department, Government of Tripura for
approval but the Finance Department has regretted the proposal and asked
the society to follow the extant rules of the government.
23.
Having appreciated the submissions of the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and having taken note of the proposal sent by the
Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Society vide Note
No.19 [as reproduced], this court is of the view that the respondents shall
consider the regularisation of the petitioners in the post of Cook cum
Mashalchi/Watchman in the scale of pay of Rs.4,840-13,000/- GP-1,400/under Tripura State Pay Matrix, PB-1 Cell-1, Level-1, Entry pay-Rs.16,000/-,
not in terms of the policy of the government which have been repealed but
for their completing of their ten years of service as the Daily Rated Worker.
From the Note No.19, it is evident that the competent authority in the Society
has taken the responsibility of finance, as may be required for such
regularisation, having clearly declared as under :
“The requirement of fund for the said purpose will be borne from the Grant to EMR School and
Recurring Grant to Society as per the details herein below :
Present wages
Monthly
Yearly
6,900/82800/@ Rs.230/- per day
Present wages
Monthly
Yearly
75,900/9,10,800/-
For 01 (one) no. DRW staff
Fixed Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
12,000/1,44,000/(75% of
initial pay)
For 11(eleven) nos. DRW staff
Fixed Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
1,32,000/15,84,000/-
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
18,080/2,16,960/-
Regular Pay Basis
Monthly
Yearly
2,16,960/26,03,520/-
Therefore, the posts for such regularisation be created by the
respondents.
24.
In this juncture, this court may refer to a decision of the apex
court in Nihal Singh and Others Versus State of Punjab and Others
reported in (2013) 14 SCC 65 where it has been held :
“32. Coming to the other aspect of the matter pointed out by
the High Court - that in the absence of sanctioned posts the
State cannot be compelled to absorb the persons like the
appellants into the services of the State, we can only say that
posts are to be created by the State depending upon the need
to employ people having regard to various functions the State
undertakes to discharge.
“Every sovereign Government has within its
own jurisdiction right and power to create
whatever public offices it may regard as
necessary to its proper functioning and its
own internal administration.”42 American
Jurisprudence 902, para 31
33. It is no doubt that the assessment of the need to employ a
certain number of people for discharging a particular
responsibility of the State under the Constitution is always with
the executive Government of the day subject to the overall
control of the Legislature. That does not mean that an
examination by a Constitutional Court regarding the accuracy
of the assessment of the need is barred.
35. Therefore, it is clear that the existence of the need for
creation of the posts is a relevant factor reference to which the
executive government is required to take rational decision
based on relevant consideration. In our opinion, when the facts
such as the ones obtaining in the instant case demonstrate that
there is need for the creation of posts, the failure of the
executive government to apply its mind and take a decision to
create posts or stop extracting work from persons such as the
appellants herein for decades together itself would be arbitrary
action (inaction) on the part of the State.”
[Emphasis added]
Therefore, the direction as regards creation and sanction of posts has
been made on the assessment made by the competent authority for
regularisation of the petitioners and others.
25.
As regards the other two reliefs, it is directed that if the
petitioners are getting less wage than as directed in Jagjit Singh(supra),
than they shall be paid equivalent wage, minimum to the scale of the Group-
D employee of Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions
Society.
26.
So far the recording of the education qualification is concerned,
the respondent No.2, after verification of the qualification certificate if it is
found that the same has been issued from any institute, approved by the
Government of India or by the Government of Tripura that, may be reflected
in the service records of the petitioner No.1. The directions as regards
regularisation and payment of wage shall be carried within a period of 3
(three) months from the date when a copy of this order will be furnished by
the petitioners.
In terms of the above, the writ petition stands allowed and
disposed of.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review