Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.825 of 2021
W.P.(C) No.864 of 2021
In W.P.(C) No.825 of 2021
1.
Sri Partha Sarathi Paul,
son of late Sudhanya Kumar Paul, resident
of Ramnagar Road No.7, P.O. Ramnagar,
P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
PIN-799002
2.
Sri Asish Sur,
son of late Nani Gopal Sur, resident of
Krishna Nagar, Nazir Pukur Par, P.O.
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799001
3.
Smt. Sikha Barman,
wife of Sri Amulya Viswas, resident of
Durjoy Nagar, Agartala, AMC Ward No.4,
P.O. Durjoynagar, P.S. New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura, PIN799009
…….. Petitioners
By Advocate :
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Advocate
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O. Secretariat Complex, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District – West
Tripura, PIN-799010
2.
The Deputy Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O. Secretariat Complex, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District – West
Tripura, PIN-799010
3.
The Principal Secretary,
Public
Works
Department
(R&B),
Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O. Secretariat
Complex, P.S. New Capital Complex,
District – West Tripura, PIN-799010
4.
The Chief Engineer [WR],
Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District- West
Tripura
5.
The Engineering Officer,
Office of the Chief Engineer, Public Works
Department
(R&B),
Government
of
Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S. New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura
By Advocate :
Mr. P. Maishan, Adv.
…….. Respondents
In W.P.(C) No.864 of 2021
Sri Timir Baran Datta
son of late Hiralal Datta, resident of
Joynagar Middle Road, Datta Bari, P.O.
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799001
…….. Petitioner
By Advocate :
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Advocate
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O. Secretariat Complex, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District – West
Tripura, PIN-799010
2.
The Deputy Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O. Secretariat Complex, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District – West
Tripura, PIN-799010
3.
The Principal Secretary,
Public
Works
Department
(R&B),
Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O. Secretariat
Complex, P.S. New Capital Complex,
District – West Tripura, PIN-799010
4.
The Chief Engineer [WR],
Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District- West
Tripura
5.
The Engineering Officer,
Office of the Chief Engineer, Public Works
Department
(R&B),
Government
of
Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S. New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura
6.
The Accountant General (A&E),
Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital
Complex, District – West Tripura, PIN799005
By Advocate :
Mr. D.C. Saha, Adv.
Mr. B. Majumder, Asst. S.G.
…….. Respondents
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Date of hearing and delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
10.05.2022
Yes
No
√
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners as well as Mr. P. Maishan, Mr. D.C. Saha, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents and Mr. B. Majumder,
learned Asst. S.G. of India who has appeared for the respondent
No.6, Accountant General, Tripura in W.P.(C) No.864 of 2021.
[2]
Both these writ petitions being W.P.(C) No.825 of
2021 and W.P.(C) No.864 of 2021 are combined for disposal by a
common judgment and order inasmuch as in these writ petitions,
the petitioners have challenged the withdrawal of the clarification
[Point
No.3]
dated
14.09.2009.
It
has
unceremoniously
withdrawn and further, by the memorandum dated 30.11.2017
issued by the Public Works Department [R&B], it has been
directed to recover the benefits that was extended by the said
clarification dated 14.09.2009.
[3]
The petitioners are all working under the Public Works
Department [R & B] being initially appointed as Lower Division
Clerk [LDC]. On completion of 10 years of service as they were
not promoted they got the CAS-1 but there was no change in the
basic pay as the basic pay [before CAS-1] of the petitioners was
equal to the next higher grade. Having noticed this stalemate in
the movement of pay, the memorandum under No.F.6(1)-FIN
(PC)/2008 dated 14.09.2009 was issued with some clarifications.
In clarification No.3, it has been laid down that in
cases where the employees got the benefit of higher pay
scale/higher grade pay scale under CAS during the period from
01.01.1999 to 31.12.2005 but without any change in the basic
pay and even without any change of date of next increment [DNI]
on the ground that at the relevant time, time scale slab of lower
pay and higher pay scale was exactly equal and the date of
increment and date of CAS, according to the petitioners, fell on
the same date. Hence, that cannot be deemed as consumption of
higher pay scale while determining the eligibility for future ACP.
The petitioners were given the benefit of first ACP in the form of
2.5% increment w.e.f. 01.01.2006 and the financial benefits from
01.01.2009 by the order dated 12.09.2010 [Annexure-3 to the
writ petition]. As the petitioners completed 10 years of service,
they were allowed to move to the next higher scale without any
benefit. The pay of such employee was fixed as per clarification
No.3 of the memorandum dated 14.09.2009. The increment was
granted by the office order under Rule 10 (7) and Rule 10(8) of
the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 having
read with the aforesaid memorandum dated 14.09.2009. The
petitioners
were
enjoying
the
said
financial
benefit
vide
clarification No.3 of the memorandum dated 14.09.2009. On
16.01.2012 another clarification was issued by the respondents
No.1 & 2 by the memorandum dated No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2008
dated 16.01.2012 whereby the benefits emanating through the
clarification Point No.3 of the memorandum dated 14.09.2009 has
been withdrawn. Not only that, it has been declared that if an
employee is moved to CAS-I without change in the basic pay it is
to be treated to have availed CAS-I under Tripura State Civil
Services (Revised Pay) Rules that no further ACP-I in lieu of CASI was admissible. The said memorandum dated 16.01.2012 has in
categorical terms provided that the past cases where ACP-I had
been granted to the employees shall not be reopened. By the
note No.6 dated 20.01.2022 [Annexure-5 to the writ petitions] it
has been directed that all cases are to be reregulated in terms of
the memorandum dated 16.01.2012. In the said memorandum, it
has been also clearly provided that the past cases where ACP-I
had been granted to any employees, need not be reopened. It
has been also stated that the said clarification will uniformly
applicable in cases of movement under CAS from other prerevised lower scale to higher pre-revised scale under Tripura
State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1999. But by the
memorandum dated 30.11.2017 [Annexure-6 to the writ petition]
it has been directed that those employees who were given similar
benefit which was subsequently not agreed/denied by the further
clarification issued by the Finance Department, the Government
of Tripura having such list in hand, the concerned DDOs have
been advised to take action for recovery of the overdrawn
amount and to refix their pay accordingly. The said memorandum
has been challenged in this writ petition. On the similar issue in
Dibakar Chakraborty vs. State of Tripura [judgment dated
03.03.2021 delivered in W.P.(C) 1701 of 2017], this court had
occasion to decide the issue of the recovery of the incentive that
was released in favour of the employees alike the petitioners
herein for extensive reference. The relevant part of the said
judgment is extracted hereunder:
“[15] The Finance Department vide the Memorandum
No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2008 dated 14.09.2009, the relevant
part of which has been reproduced before, has observed
that the basic pay of the employee on the concerned date if
not changed at consequence CAS upgradation, it would not
be counted as consumption of ACP while determining the
eligibility for future ACP. The Deputy General Manager, Gas
Thermal Electrical Division, Rokhia, West Tripura based on
the said Memorandum of the Finance Department vide the
Office Order No.176 dated 28.07.2010 had fixed the pay of
the petitioner notionally w.e.f. 01.01.2006 by allowing one
increment @ 2.5% in the existing basic pay (existing pay in
the Pay Band + Grade Pay) in the scale of pay Rs.531024000/- & Grade Pay of Rs.2000/- (in Pay-Band-2) which
is the revised scale of Rs.4000-7890/- under proviso subrule 7 of Rule 10 of the ROP Rules, 2009. The said benefit
was granted under sub-rule 8 of Rule 10 of the ROP Rules,
1999. The actual financial benefit was given w.e.f.
01.01.2009 as per ROP Rules, 2009.
[16] Thereafter, those respondents have asserted that the
second ACP was released on completion of total 17 years of
service vide the said Office Order dated 28.07.2010 w.e.f.
25.08.2007 not w.e.f. 25.08.2000 as stated in the writ
petition, by allowing one increment @ 2.5% in the existing
scale of pay Rs.5310-24000/- along with the next available
Grade Pay i.e. Rs.2100/- under the proviso to sub-Rule 7 of
Rule 10 of the TSCS(RP) Rules, 2009 and actual financial
benefit was given w.e.f. 01.01.2009 as per ROP Rules,
2009.
[17] The said financial benefits was granted to the
petitioner in terms of the clarification at point no. 3 in the
Memorandum dated 14.09.2009 which was, subsequently,
withdrawn
by
the
Finance
Department
by
their
memorandum dated 16.01.2012, as referred before. As the
said
clarification
contradicted
the
provisions
of
FR.22(2)(a)(2), so it had to be withdrawn. It has been
further clarified that from the pre-revised pay scale of
Rs.3300-7100 the concerned employee would move [CAS1] to the next higher pre-revised pay scale of Rs.40007890/- having the higher rate of increment that of the prerevised pay scale of Rs.3300/-7100/- with fixation of pay
at Rs.4000/- vide FR(22)(I)(a)(2) after completion of the
required qualifying service in the pre-revised pay scale of
Rs.3300-7100/- during the period from 01.01.1999 to
31.12.2005. The petitioner has been treated to have availed
CAS-1 under ROP Rules, 1999. So further ACP or other
benefit has been made under ROP Rules, 2009.
[18] What appears from the said paragraph as indicated by
Mr. Sharma, learned Addl. GA is that the benefit under sub
rule 7 of Rule 10 of the ROP Rules, 2009 had already been
provided to the petitioner. As the benefit under the point
No.3 was withdrawn by the Finance Department, the
respondents have seriously objected to the statement of
the petitioner that the excess payment that has been made
by mistake cannot be recovered from the petitioner.
[19] Mr. Sharma, learned Addl. GA has in this regard
submitted that the entitlement that was given wrongly to
the petitioner was notified within a short time, immediately
after discovery of the wrong. But unfortunately, no such
office order is available in the records. On the contrary, the
memorandum dated 16.01.2012 (Annexure 4 to the writ
petition) provides as follows:
However, the past cases where ACP-1 had been
granted to any employee in such cases need not be
re-opened. This clarification is also uniformly
applicable in cases of movement under CAS from
other pre-revised lower scales to higher prerevised pay scales under the TSCS (RP) Rules,
1999.
[20] According to this court, this does not reflect that the
respondents have been preparing to recover the excess
amount that has been paid to the petitioner as is evident
that they had expressly waived the element of recovery.
[21] Having appreciated the submission of the learned
counsel appearing for the parties, it appears that the
petitioner is not entitled to any further movement or
amount as the petitioner has been granted the benefits
under Rule 10(7) of the ROP Rules, 2009. Now, the solitary
question that remains to be considered by this court is
whether the respondents will be permitted to recover the
excess amount from the petitioner that has been paid for
withdrawal of the said clarification [point No.3] by the
memorandum dated 14.09.2009? The petitioner is still
working as the Lower-Division Clerk. However, he has been
disbursed certain financial benefits which have been
withdrawn latter. His status is squarely covered by the
status as categorized in Rafiq Masih (supra) and as such
since there was no attempt to make recovery of the amount
in five years and hence, such recovery be deemed to have
waived conscientiously. Hence, the respondents are
directed not to recover any amount from the petitioner as
the amount that has been paid in excess while
implementing the clarification [point No.3] as stated
before. However, the respondents are entitled to fix the pay
and other allowances in terms of the Rule 10(7) of the ROP
Rules, 2009 and subsequent revisions.”
[4]
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners has drawn attention of this court to another judgment
dated 03.03.2021 delivered in W.P.(C) No.47 of 2018 [Kinkar
Roy vs. State of Tripura & Ors.]. The said judgment is a
common judgment in a series of writ petitions including W.P.(C)
No.47 of 2018. In the said judgment, having discussed the
context having highlighted the observation in the memorandum
dated 16.01.2012, it has been clearly laid that past cases where
ACP-I has been granted to any employee need not be reopened.
This clarification is also to be uniformly applied in cases of the
movement under CAS from other pre-revised lower scale to
higher pre-revised scale under the TSCS (RP) Rules, 1999. It has
been observed in the said judgment as follows:
“Now, the solitary question that remains to be considered
by this court is whether the respondents will be permitted
to recover the excess amount from the petitioners that has
been paid for withdrawal of the said clarification [point
No.3]
by
the
memorandum
dated
14.09.2009?
The petitioner is still working as the Lower-Division Clerk.
However, he has been disbursed certain financial benefits
which have been withdrawn later. His status is squarely
covered by the status as categorized in Rafiq Masih (supra)
and as such since there was no attempt to make recovery
of the amount in five years and hence, such recovery be
deemed to have waived conscientiously. Hence, the
respondents are directed not to recover any amount from
the
petitioner
as
the
amount
that
has
been
paid in excess while implementing the clarification [point
No.3] as stated before. However, the respondents are
entitled to fix the pay and other allowances in terms of the
Rule 10(7) of the ROP Rules, 2009 and subsequent
revisions.”
[5]
Mr. D.C. Saha, learned counsel has appeared for the
respondents in W.P.(C) No.825 of 2021 and Mr. P. Maishan,
learned counsel has appeared for the respondents No.1 to 5 in
W.P.(C) No.864 of 2021. Mr. B. Majudmer, learned Asst. S.G of
India has, as noted before, appeared for the respondents No.6 in
W.P.(C) No.864 of 2021.
[6]
The respondent No.6 in their reply has categorically
observed as follows:
“It may be
mentioned here that as per Finance
Department’s Memorandum No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2008 dated
14.09.2009 [Annexure-2 of the writ petition) at Point No.3
some employees had already got the one additional
increment on 01.01.2006 after re-fixation of revised pay
regulation under ROP, 2009 which was subsequently
withdrawn vide Finance Department’s clarification bearing
Memorandum No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/2008 dated 16.01.2012
[Annexure-4 of the writ petition] wherein it has also been
mentioned in the said clarification that the past cases
wherever ACP-1 had been granted to any employee need
not be re-opened. This clarification is also uniformly
applicable in cases of movement under CAS from other prerevised lower scale to higher pre-revised pay scale under
the TSCS(RP) Rule, 1999. In this way, the writ petitioner
has already got the benefit of 1st ACP.”
The respondent No.6 however has not faltered to
state that the respondent No.6 has no authority to make
comment on the said policy of the Government, but such policy is
on record.
[7]
The respondents, represented by Mr. Saha, learned
counsel and Mr. Maishan, learned counsel having responded to
the averments of the writ petitions have contended that the
benefits of CAS-1 with one increment was allowed by the
department as per the clarification given at Point No.3 of the
memorandum
dated
14.09.2009
issued
by
the
Finance
Department. But by the order dated 16.01.2012, the Finance
Department asked for recovery of overdrawn amount and
accordingly, the employees who were given the benefit in terms
of Point No.3 of the clarification dated 14.09.2009 were asked to
refund. DDOs are also advised to take action to recover the
overdrawn amount and refix the pay of the petitioners.
[8]
Having appreciated the case of the petitioners in the
backdrop of Dibakar Chakraborty (supra) and Kinkar Roy
(supra), the respondents are directed to not recover any amount
which the petitioners received in terms of Point No.3 of the
clarification dated 14.09.2009 [Annexure-2 to the writ petitions].
However, the respondents are entitled to fix the pay and other
allowances in terms of Rule 10(7) of the ROP Rules, 2009 and to
apply
the
subsequent revisions of
pay.
Consequently, the
respondents are prohibited from recovering any amount which
the petitioners were given in terms of the Point No.3 of the
clarification dated 14.09.2009.
[9]
Having observed thus, both the writ petitions are
allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review