Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 518 OF 2024
Sri Thakur Chan Das, S/o Late Swapan Das,
Gokulnagar, P.S. Bishalgarh, Sepahijala.
….Petitioner
Versus
Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council,
Khumulwng, West Tripura.
….Respondent
For the petitioner
: Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Amicus Curiae.
For the respondent
: Mr. Bhaskar Debbarma, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 08.10.2024
Date of delivery of
judgment & Order
: 18.03.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order
By means of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
urged for issuing a writ of mandamus upon the respondent to provide him a
Scribe in the competitive examination.
2.
Briefly stated, the facts of the case are that he being a visually
impaired with benchmark disability applied for the post of Sub-zonal
Development Officer/Dy. Principal Officer in pursuant to the Advertisement
No.03/2024, dated 03.02.2024, issued by the Tripura Tribal Areas
Autonomous District Council (for short, „TTAADC‟), Khumlwng, West
Tripura. He submitted the application on 16.02.2024 with a prayer for
providing him a scribe from respondent-TTAADC itself since he is a visually
impaired candidate. The respondent issued admit card in favour of him to
appear in the examination which was scheduled to be held on 09.06.2024, but,
that was postponed due to leakage of answer paper of that examination. It is
asserted that the petitioner had waited for three months to have the panel of
scribe to be formed by the respondent, but he did not get any reply. He
submitted another application to the respondent on 28.05.2024, but, no result
has been yielded. Subsequently, the examination was rescheduled to be held
on 21.07.2024 but since he was not provided with any Scribe, he was not able
to appear in the examination. The petitioner approached this Court with an
order of Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment dated 01.01.2019
[Annexure-J to the writ petition] referring to an order of Hon‟ble Delhi High
Court passed in the case of Shri Aditya Narayan Tiwari & Anr. Vs. Union of
India & Ors. showing that until and unless the scribe is provided to an
aspirant having visually impaired, no department can conduct any
examination, however, the Delhi High Court maintained the office
memorandum issued on 26.02.2013[Annexure-H to the writ petition] by the
Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment, Department of Disability Affairs
wherein one of the specific terms and conditions was that a candidate who has
40% or more disability can opt for a scribe of his own and no educational
qualification, age, marks scored for the scribe was fixed. But, the respondent
denied to follow the memorandum dated 26.02.2013, in spite of that they
followed the guidelines issued vide memorandum dated 29.08.2018
[Annexure-I to the writ petition] where the qualification of scribe has been
prescribed one step below the qualification of the candidate taking
examination. However, the petitioner submitted another application on
18.07.2024 for allowing him to appear in the examination as per office
memorandum dated 1st January, 2019 whereby the Delhi High Court
maintained the guidelines dated 26.02.2013. But, the respondents did not give
any response to the petitioner and hence, this writ petition.
3.
Heard Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned amicus curiae
appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B. Debbarma, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent-TTAADC.
4.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned amicus appearing for the petitioner at
the very outset has submitted that the petitioner is a candidate with 100 per
cent visual disability. He falls under Category-2(r) of the Rights of Persons
with Disability Act, 2016 [for short, Act of 2016] having benchmark disability
of more than 40%. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned amicus pointed out that as per
Clause (v) of the guidelines of Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment,
Govt. of India, dated 29.08.2018 the candidates should have the discretion of
opting for his own scribe/reader/lab assistant or request the Examination
Body for the same. The examining body may also identify the
scribe/reader/lab assistant to make panels at the District/Division/State level
as per the requirements of the examination. In such instances the candidates
should be allowed to meet the scribe a day before the examination so that the
candidates get a chance to check and verify whether the scribe is suitable or
not. Further, learned amicus has drawn the attention of this Court to the
guidelines dated 1st January, 2019, issued by the Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Govt. of India and candidly submitted that in this guideline, it
has been stipulated that –“till the panel of scribes is formed, if any
examination is conducted by any of the Department wherein the petitioners
and similarly situated persons appear in the exam, the guidelines dated
29.09.2018 shall not be applicable, however, the candidate shall appear in
terms of guidelines dated 26.02.2013….”. So, according to Mr. Bhattacharjee,
learned amicus, in view of the guidelines dated 1st January, 2019, the
respondent-TTAADC should have allowed the petitioner to sit in the
examination with his own chosen scribe, without any prohibition of
educational qualification of the scribe. Since the request of the petitioner to sit
in the examination along with his chosen scribe was rejected by the
respondent-TTAADC on 12.07.2024, according to Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
amicus, the petitioner was deprived from getting equal opportunity for
employment, as he is protected under the Act of 2016 and Articles 14 & 16 of
the Constitution of India. Thus, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned amicus urged that
this Court may consider and compensate the petitioner and impose huge cost
upon the respondent for violation of the constitutional and statutory rights of
the petitioner.
5.
Further, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned amicus pointed out that the
scribe facility for the petitioner should be given from independent body or
from the Court because the integrity of the scribe should not be in question
due to adverse mindset of the respondent towards the petitioner. If the Court
finds appropriate reason and suitable solution for conducting special
examination for the petitioner, then the petitioner should be given at least 3
months preparation time for examination and the examination should be
conducted in Agartala under video surveillance.
6.
This Court vide order dated 24.09.2024 requested the learned
counsel for the petitioner to give some suggestions for regulating the
recruitment process in respect of differently abled persons in the light of the
principles and objects of Act of 2016. Accordingly, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
amicus in terms of the order of this Court, on 08.10.2024 submitted following
written suggestions, which reads thus:
“IN GENERAL FOR FUTURE RECRUITMENT EXAM, THE BELOW
MENTIONED CRITERRIA NEEDED TO BE FOLLOWED:1. As per Clause- 8 Sub Clause 3 of Person with Disability
Rules 2017, a Liaison Officer should be appointed by every establishment
who deals with the recruitment process to monitor the recruitment of
Person with Disabilities to fulfil the objective in recruitment as per Rights
of Person with Disability Act 2016.
In Tripura, the Respondent as well other establishments of
State Government not yet notified about recruitment of any Liaison
Officer.
2. As per Clause 11 Sub Clause-3 of Rights of Person with
Disabilities Rules 2017, every establishment should publish the
reservation quota for person with disabilities and in the recruitment
notification/advertisements category wise reservation under RPWD Act
2016 to be followed/ mentioned in terms of Section 34 of the said Act. The
State Authorities are not following the same.
3. Every recruitment body should follow mandatorily the
guidelines of conducting written examination for person with disabilities
dated 29th August 2018 of Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment.
4. Every recruitment body should notify the panel of Scribe
and in the advertisement, it is to be mentioned specifically, that, persons
with disability category candidates can have the option to choose a scribe
from the panel & sit in the exam with his chosen scribe from the said
panel, notified by the competent authority.
5. Every recruitment body should simplify the process of
taking the scribe facility according to the guidelines of conducting written
examination for person with disabilities, dated 29th August 2018 and take
all the records of requirements of PWD candidates like scribe, mode of
examination, assistive devices etc at the time of filling of form.
6. When any PWD candidate request for scribe from the
examiner, the examiner should make a panel of scribe as per the
requirement of PWD candidate in accordance with guidelines of
conducting written examination for person with disabilities dated 29th
August 2018.
7. When the examiner body makes panel of scribe after
receiving requirements from PWD candidates, the number of members
should be 3 times the number of requirements. For example, if in any
exam total 5 candidates request for scribe from the examiner, the number
of members in panel of scribe should be 15. The candidates should be
called at least two days before the exam and choose a suitable scribe for
him from the panel for exam and choose another one for reserve if 1st
selected scribe could not be able to reach for any unavoidable
circumstances then the 2nd scribe will be allowed to sit in the exam, for
PWD candidate.
8. If any examiner fails or unable to make panel of scribe, the
candidates should be informed at least 3 weeks before the exam and the
candidates should be given chance of taking scribe of his own choice of
any qualification, in terms of Clause-v of the 2013 Guideline. The
candidates should inform the examiner 7 days prior to the exam with the
details of his own scribe. If the candidate does not able to find his own
scribe of any qualification, then also the candidates should inform the
recruiting body at least 7 days before the exam. On that situation, the
examination should be postponed till the date the examiner able to make
panel of scribe.
9. When a candidate chooses to bring his own scribe, the
examiner should take all the information about his own scribe at time of
filing of form. The examining body may conduct an enquiry about scribes'
information before the examination, to rule out any malpractices.
10. The examination of the candidates using scribe should be
conducted within the video surveillance to reduce the cheating and
malpractices.
The Respondent and any establishment of the State have yet
not been formulated any guidelines to fulfil the objectives of Rights of
Person with Disabilities Act 2016. The guidelines which are needed to be
formulated by the Respondent are mentioned below,
1. Reservation guidelines should be formulated to provide
reservation for PWD person (in each category under Act, 2016) in direct
recruitment as well as in promotion in accordance with the RPWD Act
2016 and RPWD Rules 2017 to ensure equal opportunity for them.
2. In terms of Section-21 of the Act, 2016, every
establishment shall notify equal opportunity policy detailing measures
proposed to be taken by it in pursuance with Chapter 4 of the RPWD Act
2016.
3. Every establishment should make appropriate schemes and
guidelines for inclusive growth of person with disabilities in the field of
education, health, skill development, sports, culture etc. in accordance
with the RPWD Act 2016 and RPWD Rules 2017.
4. Every establishment should follow the rules and
regulations of accessibility in public infrastructure in accordance with
RPWD Act 2016.
5. A special officer should be appointed by the Competent
Authority and the Respondent through State Commissioner only for
persons with disabilities to resolve the complaints received from disabled
person.”
7.
At the time of argument, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned amicus has
relied upon two Judgments, wherein some broader criteria have been laid
down by the Hon'ble Apex Court for Persons with Disabilities candidates. The
reference of the said judgments is as follows:
(i)
Arnab
Roy
Vs.
Consortium
of
National
Law
Universities & Ors., 2023 Live Law(SC) 3439 &
(ii)
Vikash Kumar Vs. Union Public Service Commission &
Ors., (2021) 5 SCC 370.
8.
On the other side, Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent-TTAADC, on a divergent view has simply contended that as
per guidelines issued by the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment,
Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities (Divyangjan), dated
29.08.2018, the petitioner was informed vide communication dated
12.07.2024 that he was allowed to use his own scribe on condition that the
qualification of his Scribe should be 1(one) step below his qualification.
Except this submission, Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel for the respondentTTAADC could not make any other convincing submissions before this
Court.
9.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and on
meticulous examination of the records, I find that the petitioner is a blind
handicapped with 100% disability as per the Disability Certificate [AnnexureA to the writ petition], issued by the District Disability Medical Board, West
Tripura District. He was diagnosed „Retinal Aplasia B/E’.
10.
Now, coming to the fact of the case, indubitably the petitioner has
all the essential qualifications for the post of Sub-Zonal Development
Officer/Deputy Principal Officer as advertised by the respondents-TTAADC
and accordingly admit card was issued in favour of him to sit in the
examination scheduled to be held on 09.06.2024 for the said Post by the
respondent, but, due to leakage of answer sheet, the examination was
postponed. Subsequently, when the examination was rescheduled on
21.07.2024, the petitioner submitted an application to the respondent to
provide him a scribe since he is visually impaired. The respondent in reply on
12.07.2024 intimated the petitioner that he is allowed to use his own scribe on
condition that the qualification of his scribe should be one step below his
qualification. But, when he went to the examination centre with his scribe, the
respondent had denied to allow him to appear in the examination since the
scribe had one-step higher qualification than that of the petitioner. Having
denied to sit in examination, the petitioner approached this Court for
appropriate remedy.
11.
On the background of the aforesaid facts, Mr. Bhattacharjee,
learned amicus for the petitioner heavily stressed upon the Office
Memorandum dated 1st January, 2019 issued by the Ministry of Social Justice
& Empowerment, Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities
(Divyangjan).
At the outset, for the sake of convenience, the Office
Memorandum dated 1st January, 2019 may be quoted as under:
“F.No.34-02/2015-DD-III(Pt)
Government of India
Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment
Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities (Divyangjan)
Pt. Antyodaya Bhawan, 5th Floor,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi
Dated 1st January, 2019
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Sub: Compliance of order of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the matter of
Shri Aditya Narayan Tiwari & Anr. Vs Union of India & Anr reg.
In continuation of this Department's O.M. of even number
dated 28/11/2018( copy enclosed), the undersigned is directed to say that
Hon'ble High Court of Delhi has further clarified in the matter as under
vide order dated 04/12/2018 (copy enclosed):
"Till the panel of scribes is formed, if any examination is
conducted by any of the Department wherein the petitioners and
similarly situated persons appear in the exam, the guidelines dated
29.8.2018 shall not be applicable, however, the candidate shall
appear in terms of guidelines dated 26.02.2013....... "
2.
All the Ministries/Departments are requested to issue
appropriate advisory to all examining bodies under their administrative
control to make a panel of scribe/reader/lab assistant at the
District/Divisional/State Level in terms of clause V of the guidelines dated
29/08/2018. Till the panel of scribes is not formed, any of the Department
who are conducting the exam, shall not conduct the exam in terms of
guidelines dated 29/08/2018.
Sd/(D.K. Panda)
Under Secretary to the Govt. of India & CPIΟ
Tel. No. 24369059”
12.
It is, therefore, crystal clear that in view of the judgment of
Hon‟ble Delhi High Court in Aditya Narayan Tiwari (supra), the
memorandum dated 26.02.2013 is in existence. Further, from the judgment of
Vikash Kumar Vs. UPSC, reported in (2021) 5 SCC 370, as referred to by
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, it appears that in view of the
decision of the Apex Court in Vikash Kumar (supra), the Ministry of Social
Justice and Empowerment, Govt. of India by an Office Memorandum dated
10th August, 2022, formulated certain guidelines.
13.
Let me have a look upon the first and foremost concept of the
case of Vikash Kumar (supra). In the said case, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
under the heading-Benchmark disability not precondition to obtaining a
scribe, in paras 34, 35,36,37,38,39 & 40 of the judgment has observed thus:
“34. It is in this backdrop that the Court must resolve the
issue, bearing as it does on the rights of similarly situated candidates.
The 2016 RPwD Act embodies two distinct concepts when it speaks of; (i)
“persons with benchmark disabilities”, and (ii) persons with disability. In
defining a person with benchmark disability, Section 2(r) encompasses
two categories; (i) a person with not less than 40 per cent of a specified
disability, where the specified disability has not been defined in
measurable terms, and (ii) a person with disability where the specified
disability has been defined in measurable terms, as certified by the
certifying authority. In other words, Section 2(r) encompasses both a
situation where a specified disability has not been defined in measurable
terms, in which event it means a person not less than 40 per cent of the
specified disability but also where a specified disability has been defined
in measurable terms. A certification by the certifying authority is
contemplated in regard to whether the person concerned does in fact meet
the specified norm as quantified.
35. The second concept which is embodied in Section 2(s) is
that of a person with disability. Section 2(s) unlike Section 2(r) is not
tagged either with the notion of a specified disability or a benchmark
disability as defined in Section 2(r). Section 2(s) has been phrased by
Parliament in broad terms so as to mean a person with a long term
physical, mental, intellectual or sensory impairment which in interaction
with various barriers hinders full and effective participation in society
equally with others.
36. Section 2(s) is significant because it recognises firstly, the
nature of the impairment, secondly, the interconnection of the impairment
with various barriers and thirdly, the impact of the impairment in
hindering full and effective participation on a footing of equality. On the
first aspect, namely, the nature of the impairment, Section 2(s) requires
that the impairment should be long term—physical, mental, intellectual or
sensory. The statutory definition has evidently recognised that it is the
nature of the impairment in its interaction with barriers that results in the
full and effective participation of the person in society equally with others
being hampered. Section 2(s) is, in other words, a far-reaching
recognition by the legislature of disability as not only a function of a
physical or mental impairment but of its interaction with barriers
resulting in a social milieu which prevents the realisation of full, effective
and equal participation in society.
37. Both as a matter of textual construction and bearing in
mind the purpose and object underlying the term, it is necessary to
emphasise that the definition in Section 2(s) cannot be constricted by the
measurable quantifications tagged with the definition under Section 2(r).
38. The concept of a benchmark disability under Section 2(r)
cannot be conflated with the notion of disability under Section 2(s). The
definition in Section 2(r) applies in the case of a specified disability. The
expression “specified disability” is defined in Section 2(zc) to mean the
disabilities as specified in the Schedule. The Schedule to the Act
incorporates five specified disabilities:
1. Physical disabilities comprised of
(a) Locomotor disability including
(i) leprosy cured persons
(ii) cerebral palsy
(iii) dwarfism
(iv) muscular dystrophy
(v) acid attack victims;
(b) Visual impairment encompassing
(i) blindness
(ii) low vision
(c) Hearing impairment
(d) Speech and language disability
2. Intellectual disability including
(a) specific learning disabilities
(b) autism spectrum disorder
3. Mental behaviour
4. Disability caused due to
(a) Chronic neurological conditions, such as
(i) multiple sclerosis
(ii) Parkinson's disease
(b) Blood disorder
5. Multiple disabilities (more than one of the above specified
disabilities).
The Central Government has been empowered to notify any other
category as a specified disability.
39. The concept of benchmark disabilities under the 2016 RPwD Act
has specifically been adopted in relation with the provisions of Chapter
VI and Chapter VII. Chapter VI contains special provisions for persons
with benchmark disabilities. Among those provisions is Section 31 (free
education for children with benchmark disability), Section 32 (reservation
in higher educational institutions), Section 33 (identification of posts for
reservation), Section 34 (reservation), Section 36 (Special Employment
Exchange) and Section 37 (Special Schemes and Development
Programmes). Chapter VII contains special provisions for persons with
benchmark disabilities in need of high support. Thus, the concept of
benchmark disabilities has been adopted by the legislation bearing in
mind specific provisions which are contained in the law for persons
meeting this description.
40. Conflating the rights and entitlements which inhere in persons
with disabilities with the notion of benchmark disabilities does disservice
to the salutary purpose underlying the enactment of the 2016 RPwD Act.
Worse still, to deny the rights and entitlements recognised for persons
with disabilities on the ground that they do not fulfil a benchmark
disability would be plainly ultra vires the 2016 RPwD Act.”
14.
Further, in the heading „D.The legal framework’ of the judgment
of Vikash Kumar (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in para 14 of the
judgment observed thus:
“14. On 7-2-2018, a Notification was issued by the Ministry
prescribing the Rules for the Conduct of the CSE to be held by UPSC in
2018. The notification covers diverse aspects governing the conduct of the
examination. Among them is Section 1 of Appendix I which incorporates
the “plan of examination” and Section 2 which provides for the “scheme,
subjects for the preliminary and main examination”. This is followed by
“general instructions” for the conduct of the preliminary and main
examination for the civil services. Insofar as is material, the general
instructions contain the following stipulations:
“General Instructions (Preliminary as well as Main Examination):
(i) Candidates must write the papers in their own hand. In no
circumstances will they be allowed the help of a scribe to write the
answers for them. However, blind candidates and candidates with
locomotor disability and cerebral palsy where dominant (writing)
extremity is affected to the extent of slowing the performance of function
(minimum of 40% impairment) will be allowed to write the examination
with the help of a scribe in both the Civil Services (Preliminary) as well
as in the Civil Services (Main) Examination.
(ii) Compensatory time of twenty minutes per hour shall be permitted
for the blind candidates and the candidates with locomotor disability and
cerebral palsy where dominant (writing) extremity is affected to the extent
of slowing the performance of f1, motion (minimum of 40% impairment)
in both the Civil Services (Preliminary) as well as in the Civil Services
(Main) Examination.”
These rules have since been amended in 2019.”
15.
In Vikash Kumar (supra), Hon‟ble Supreme Court issued a
broader direction to the Union Government in the Ministry of Social Justice
and Empowerment to ensure the framing of proper guidelines which would
regulate and facilitate the grant of a facility of a scribe to persons with
disability within the meaning of Section 2(s) where the nature of the disability
operates to impose a barrier to the candidate writing an examination. These
guidelines should also prescribe appropriate norms to ensure that condition of
the candidate is duly certified by such competent medical authority as may be
prescribed so as to ensure that only genuine candidates in need of the facility
are able to avail it. Consequently, the Government of India, Ministry of Social
Justice and Empowerment (for short, „MSJE‟), Department of Empowerment
of Persons with Disabilities (Divyangjan) issued an office memorandum
dated, 10th August, 2022 in compliance with the direction issued in Vikash
Kumar (supra). The operative portion of the said office memorandum reads
thus:
“…..2. Keeping in view the above order of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, an Expert Committee was constituted to consider the issue and
suggest guidelines accordingly. The Committee noted that there are
various types of clinical problems that can affect the writing capacity.
After careful consideration of the matter, the Committee recommended
that sole criteria for grant of scribe and compensatory time should be
based on assessment of the capability of a person to write.
3. The Committee accordingly recommended the following guidelines
for conducting written examination for persons with specified disabilities
covered under the definition of Section 2(s) of the RPwD Act,2016 but
not covered under the definition of Section 2(r) of the said Act, i.e.
persons having less than 40% disability and having difficulty in writing: (a) These guidelines may be called as Guidelines for conducting
written examination for persons with specified disabilities covered under
the definition of Section 2(s) of the RPwD Act, 2016 but not covered
under the definition of Section 2(r) of the said Act, i.e. persons having
less than 40% disability and having difficulty in writing.
(b) The facility of scribe and/or compensatory time shall be granted
solely to those having difficulty in writing subject to production of a
certificate to the effect that person concerned has limitation to write and
that scribe is essential to write examination on his/her behalf from the
competent medical authority of a Government healthcare institution as
per proforma at Appendix-I.
(c) The medical authority for the purpose of certification as
mentioned in point (b) above should be a multi-member authority
comprising the following:i. Chief Medical officer/Civil Surgeon/Chief District Medical
Officer.....Chairperson
ii. Orthopaedic/PMR specialist
iii. Neurologist, if available*
iv.
Clinical
Psychologist/Rehabilitation
Psychologist/
Psychiatrist/Special Educator
v. Occupational therapist, if available*
vi. Any other expert based on the condition of the candidate as may be
nominated by the Chairperson.
(* the Chief Medical Officer/Civil Surgeon/Chief District Medical
Officer may make full efforts for inclusion of neurologists, occupational
therapist from the nearest District or the Medical College/Institute, if the
same is not available in the District)"
(d) The candidate should have the discretion of opting for his own
scribe or request the Examination Body for the same. The examination
body
may
also
identify
the
scribe
to
make
panels
at
the
District/Division/State level as per the requirements of the examination.
In later instances the candidates should be allowed to meet the scribe two
days before the examination so that the candidates get a chance to check
and verify whether the scribe is suitable or not.
(e) In case the examination body provides the scribe, it shall be
ensured that qualification of the scribe should not be more than the
minimum qualification criteria of the examination. However, the
qualification of the scribe should always be matriculate or above.
In case the candidate is allowed to bring his own scribe, the
qualification of the scribe should be one step below the qualification of
the candidate taking examination. The person opting for own scribe
should submit details of the own scribe as per proforma at Appendix-II.
(f) There should also be flexibility in accommodating any change in
scribe in case of emergency. The candidates should also be allowed to
take different scribe for writing different papers especially for languages.
However, there can be only one scribe per subject.
(g) The candidate should be allowed to use aids and assistive devices
such as prosthetics & orthotics, hearing aid as mentioned in para 2 of the
certificate issued by medical authority as per Appendix I.
(h) Compensatory time not less than 20 minutes per hour of the
examination should be allowed for persons who are eligible for getting
scribe. In case the duration of the 3 examination is less than an hour, then
the duration of the compensatory time should be allowed on pro-rata
basis. Compensatory time should not be less than 5 minutes and should
be in the multiple of 5.
(i) The examination bodies shall modify their application forms to
incorporate specific needs of this category of persons. In case, any
incident has been reported after filling up the form, the examination
bodies shall inform the candidates to obtain medical certificate as per
these guidelines for facilitating grant of scribe and/or compensatory time.
(j) As far as possible the examination for such persons may be held at
ground floor. The examination centres should be accessible for persons
with disabilities.
(k) These guidelines are applicable to written examinations conducted
by central recruitment agencies as well as academic institutions. The
States/UTs may adopt these guidelines or issue similar guidelines to
maintain uniformity.
(l) These guidelines are independent of the Guidelines for conducting
written examination for persons with benchmark disabilities issued by the
Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities on 29.08.2018.
(m) The examining bodies shall ensure strict vigilance to check
misuse of facility of scribe.
4. All the recruitment agencies, Academics/Examination Bodies etc.
under the administrative control of each Ministry/Department may be
advised appropriately to ensure compliance of implementing these
guidelines.
5. The above guidelines are issued with the approval of Hon’ble
Minister (Social Justice & Empowerment).”
16.
A person with benchmark disability is defined under Section 2(r)
of the Act of 2016 which reads as under:
“2(r) “Person with benchmark disability” means a person
with not less than forty per cent of a specified disability where specified
disability has not been defined in measurable terms and includes a person
with disability where specified disability has been defined in measurable
terms, as certified by the certifying authority.”
17.
Keeping in view the above provision, it is crystal clear that the
definition in Section 2(r) applies in the case of a specified disability. The
expression “specified disability” is defined in Section 2(zc) to mean the
disabilities as specified in the Schedule of the Act of 2016. For the sake of
brevity, „Schedule B‟ of the Specified Disability may be reproduced here-inbelow:
“B. Visual impairment(a) “blindness” means a condition where a person has any of the
following conditions, after best correction—
(i)
total absence of sight; or
(ii)
visual acuity less than 3/60 or less than 10/200
(Snellen) in the better eye with best possible
correction; or
(iii) limitation of the field of vision subtending an angle of
less than10 degree.
(b) “low-vision” means a condition where a person has any of the
following conditions, namely—
(i)
visual acuity not exceeding 6/18 or less than 20/60
upto 3/60 or upto 10/200 (Snellen) in the better eye
with best possible corrections; or
(ii)
limitation of the field of vision subtending an angle of
less than 40 degree up to 10 degree.”
18.
It is apparent from the office memorandum dated 10 th August,
2022, that the department of MSJE, Govt. of India issued the guidelines to
protect the disabled person who is covered under Section 2(s) of the Act of
2016, but not covered who falls under the definition of Section 2(r) of the said
Act.
Having gone through the above quoted observations of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court and the guidelines dated 10th August, 2022, this Court
may safely come to a conclusion that the extent of disability of the petitioner
as it appears from the Disability Certificate, issued by the District Disability
Medical Board is above benchmark. He was diagnosed „Retinal Aplasia B/E’
which means a birth defect where an organ or tissue is wholly or largely
absent. Thus, he is suffering from total absence of his sight and has become
100 per cent visually impaired who comes under the purview of definition
embodied in Section 2(r) of the Act of 2016 i.e. “person with benchmark
disability”. Therefore, Section 2(r) of the Act of 2016 envisages the provision
to arrange or offer a scribe to the petitioner to sit in the written examination in
terms of the guidelines dated 26.02.2013, but, the respondent-TTAADC had
not allowed the petitioner to sit in the examination with the help of a scribe,
which action of the respondent, in my considered opinion, is unwarranted. In
my opinion, the respondent-TTAADC is liable to pay a sum of Rs. 25,000/(Rupees twenty five thousand) only as compensation to the petitioner for
harassment he suffered and a cost of Rs.10,000/-(Rupees ten thousand) due to
their arbitrary conduct not to allow him to sit with his own scribe in the
examination.
19.
In the light of aforesaid enunciation of law and for the reasons
recorded here-in-above, following directions are issued:
I.
The
respondent-TTAADC
shall
make
a
panel
of
Scribe/Reader/Lab-Assistant, etc. and till the panel of Scribe
is formed, if any examination is conducted by any of the
department wherein the petitioner and similarly situated
persons appear in the exam, the respondent-TTAADC shall
permit the specially abled candidates in terms of the
guidelines dated 26.02.2013.
II.
The
respondent-TTAADC
shall
formulate
necessary
schemes/guidelines in line with the spirit and directions
passed in the Vikash Kumar (supra) and to make a specially
abled candidates to participate in any selection process to be
undertaken by the respondent-TTAADC.
III.
The respondent-TTAADC shall pay a sum of Rs.25,000/(Rupees twenty five thousand) only, as compensation and
Rs.10,000/-(Rupees ten thousand ) only as cost to the
petitioner.
AND
IV.
The entire process shall be completed within a period of
6(six) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment and order.
20.
Before I part, I would like to place on record my appreciation for
valuable assistance provided by Shri Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned amicus,
who with consent of the petitioner and on my request has argued the case on
his behalf. Learned amicus is entitled to Rs.10,000/- as his fees. However,
Shri Bhattacharjee, learned amicus has fairly submitted that he has argued the
case as pro bono keeping in mind the petitioner is specially abled.
21.
The instant writ petition stands disposed in terms of above
directions. Connected application, if any, shall also stand disposed.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.03.19 14:44:10 +05'30'
Sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review