Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.A(J)No.42 of 2024
1. Sri Tarani Kalai,
Son of Late Kartik Kalai,
Village: Jatanbari, P.S. Nutanbazar,
District: Gomati Tripura
---- Convict-Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary,
Department of Home,
Government of Tripura,
Agartala
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Anjan Kanti Pal, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Date of Hearing and
date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
12.03.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
[Amarnath Goud, J]
This appeal is directed against the judgment and order
of conviction and sentence dated 28.08.2023 and sentence
dated 30.08.2023 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge,
Gomati District, Udaipur in connection with S.T.39 of 2021.
By the said judgment and order of conviction and sentence
Learned Trial Court found the appellant to be guilty
punishable under Section 307/341 of IPC and sentenced
him to suffer RI for 10 years and fine of Rs.10,000/- in
default to suffer further RI for three months under Section
307 of IPC and under Section 351 of IPC. The convict was
sentenced to RI for fifteen days and to pay a fine of
Rs.200/- in default to suffer further RI for one day and it
was further ordered that both the sentences shall run
concurrently.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. A. K. Pal appearing
for the appellant and also heard Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta
appearing for the State. In course of hearing Learned
counsel appearing for the appellant fairly submitted that in
this case Learned Trial Court below has failed to appreciate
the evidence on record properly and furthermore there is no
independent eye witness of the alleged occurrence of
offence excepting the evidence of the victim and as such
Learned Trial Court without proper appreciation of the
record wrongly found the appellant to be guilty under
Section 307 read with Section 341 of IPC. He further
submitted that prosecution before the Learned court below
has failed to explain as to how the victim sustain injuries. As
such in absence of proving of proper injury of the victim
there was no scope on the part of the Learned court below
to found the appellant to be guilty for the alleged charge
punishable under Section 307 of IPC. It was further
submitted that charge was not properly framed by the
Learned court below and the evidence on record does not
justify warrant of conviction against the appellant under
Section 307 of IPC and alternatively Learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that if it is found the appellant has
committed the offence he may at best convicted under
Section 324 of IPC and accordingly urged for dismissal of
this appeal.
03.
Per contra, Learned P.P. taking part in the
hearing submitted that from the materials on record it
appears that the accused committed the crime on the
alleged day and from the statement of the victim and other
corroborating evidence it is crystal clear that he has
committed the crime and not only the appellant committed
the crime but he caused several infliction of dao blows upon
the person of the victim for which she sustained multiple
injuries and Learned court below has rightly found the
appellant to be guilty and convicted him accordingly and
there is no merit in this appeal and urged for dismissal of
the appeal with costs.
04.
In this case the prosecution was set into motion
on the basis of an FIR lodged by one Rajen Kalai alleging
inter alia that on 26.11.2020 at about 1.30 p.m. his elder
sister Rina Kalai (the victim) went to the pond in the lunga
situated in the eastern direction of their home to provide
water to the cow that time his maternal uncle (Mama)
namely Tarani Kalai resident of Takkum Bari chased his
elder sister to assault her and after that his sister returned
back to home and informed him. Thereafter when the victim
and the informant went towards the lunga to bring their
cows that time their maternal uncle Tarani Kalai after seeing
his ‘Didi’ started hacking her ‘Didi’ indiscriminately by a
sharp-edged dao kept in his hand with the intention of
killing his sister. Then on hearing hue and cry he went to
save ‘Didi’ when his maternal uncle chased him with a dao.
Thereafter younger maternal uncle Shambhu Kalai injured
him by fist-blows. His elder sister sustained grievous
injuries to the left ear and fell down on the ground and she
sustained grievous bleeding injury on her left hand, head
and other parts of the body and her ear fell on the ground
due to the infliction of dao blows. After that his father and
alongwith his nephew brought his sister to Nutan Bazar
hospital in an auto-rickshaw for treatment. Hence he laid
the FIR.
05.
On the basis of the FIR Nutanbazar PS Case
No.37 of 2020 under Section 341/323/326/307/34 of IPC
was registered and the I.O. took up the investigation of the
case and after completion of investigation the I.O. laid
chargesheet against this appellant and his brother Sambhu
Kalai for their prosecution before the court. Learned
Sessions Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur framed charge
against the present appellant under Section 341/326/307 of
IPC and against another accused Sambhu Kalai charge was
framed under Section 341/323 of IPC. To substantiate the
charge before the Learned court prosecution in total has
adduced 12 numbers of witnesses and the prosecution has
also tendered and relied upon some documents which were
marked as exhibits in this case and on conclusion of trial
Learned Trial court below found the appellant to be guilty
and
convicted
him
accordingly
but
acquitted
another
accused Sambhu Kalai from the charge of this case as
prosecution could not place any materials to warrant his
conviction in the case. Challenging that judgment this
present appeal is filed before this Court. Now let us see the
evidence on record.
06.
PW-1 Rajen Kalai is the informant of this case.
He deposed that
the alleged incident took place on
26.11.2020 when his sister Rina Kalai went to their land to
bring back the cattle grazing thereon. She was chased by
their maternal uncle Tarani Kalai with a dao. She came back
home and requested him to accompany her to the field and
when they proceeded towards the cattle field and that time
the accused started assaulting her sister with the dao. She
fell down on the ground. He could not help her as he was
also pinned to the ground by Shambhu Kalai who is also
their maternal uncle. Tarani Kalai wanted to assault him by
dao but he fled away and informed his father who came to
the spot. By this time the accused person left the spot. His
sister was lying in a pool of blood. They had cut off her ears,
hands and had given multiple blows on her head. Then with
the help of their nephew Karan Uchoi they took their sister
to the Nutan Bazar hospital in an auto and he laid the FIR
which was scribed by some other person. He identified the
signature on the FIR marked Ext.P.1. It was further
submitted that police had seized some blood from as well as
some samples of hair of his sister from the spot and one
wooden lathi (stick) stained with blood which was with his
sister and a piece of wood which belongs to his sister by a
seizure list and this witness signed on the seizure list. The
witness identified his signature on the seizure list dated
26.11.2020 marked Exbt.P.2 and the seized lathi was
marked as Ext.MO.1.
During cross-examination he stated that he did
not say to I.O. that he could not help his sister as he was
pinned to the ground by Shambhu Kalai. Nothing more
came out relevant.
07.
PW-2, Rina Kalai is the victim. She deposed that
on the alleged day she went to their land to give water to
the cattle grazing thereon. That time her maternal uncle
Tarani Kalai chased her with a dao. She came back home
and requested her brother Rajen Kalai to accompany her to
the field and when they proceeded towards the cattle field
that Tarani Kalai and Shambhu Kalai who were hidden
inside the jungle started assaulting her with a dao.
Shambhu hold her body when Tarani assaulted her. The
accused caused injury to her hands, one of her ear and also
assaulted her head, neck and her chest. She became
unconscious due to the blows given by dao and regained her
sense on the way to hospital.
During cross-examination she stated that she did
not say to I.O. that Shambhu Kalai hold her while Tarani
Kalai assaulted her. Nothing more came out relevant from
the cross-examination.
08.
PW-3, Nazir Islam deposed that on the alleged
day on 26.11.2020 as per dictation of Rajen Kalai he wrote
the FIR and identified the FIR marked as Exbt.P1/1.
During cross-examination nothing more came out
relevant.
09.
PW-4, Dr. Tapan Kumar Das deposed that a per
requisition of the police being permitted by MS, GBP
Hospital he collected the blood sample and bunch of hair of
Rina Kalai who was admitted in the hospital. The witness
identified his signature on his collection report marked
Exbt.P3 as a whole.
He was declined to cross-examination by the
accused.
10.
PW-5, Ashim Tripura deposed that he did not see
the incident. Later on police came and from the spot seized
one ear and some blood stained soil in his presence. He
signed as a witness. The witness identified his signature in
the seizure list dated 26.11.2020 marked as Exbt.P2/1.
During
cross-examination
nothing
came
out
relevant.
11.
PW-6, Prasanta Das on 17.02.2021 at 1130 hrs
SI Jiban Das seized one DVD cassette in his presence. The
witness identified his signature in the seizure list marked
Exbt.P4. He further stated that the I.O. of this case also
seized blood sample of the accused Tarani Kalai from Nutan
Bazar hospital. The witness identified his signature on the
seizure list dated 05.12.2020 marked Exbt.P5.
During cross nothing came out relevant.
12.
PW-7, Prantodh Rudra Paul is the seizure list
witness in respect of seizure of blood sample vide seizure
list dated 05.12.2020 marked Exbt.P5/1. He further stated
that in presence of Magistrate the accused gave a statement
that the dao he had used to assault the victim Rina Kalai
nearby Baidya Bari English Medium School. He was present
that time and he identified the signature on the disclosure
statement marked Exbt.P6. He further stated that the I.O.
has seized some blood sample of the victim and her hair.
The witness identified his signature on the seizure list dated
07.12.2020 marked Exbt.P7.
During
cross-examination
nothing
came
out
relevant.
13.
PW-8, Saddak Hoshen another witness of the
seizure and he identified his signature on the seizure list
dated 07.12.2020 in respect of seizure of blood sample of
the victim and her hair marked as Exbt.P7/1.
During cross nothing came out relevant.
14.
PW-9, Rupanjan Das deposed that on 06.12.2020
as per requisition of police as being Deputy Collector and
Magistrate of Karbook he went to Nutan Bazzar PS when
Tarani Kalai gave a statement before him that he had used
dao to assault the victim. He also told that he had thrown
away the dao in a bush near Baidya Bari School which can
be recovered. The statement was recorded by the I.O. and
he signed on the endorsement and the same was recorded
in his presence. The witness identified his signature on the
endorsement marked Exbt.P6/1. Thereafter the accused
according to this witness led them to Baidya Bari English
Medium
School
from
where
weapon
of
offence
was
recovered which was concealed in a bush on the road side.
Police seized the same in his presence by preparing a
seizure list and the witness identified his signature on the
seizure list marked Exbt. P8.
During cross-examination he stated that after
lapse of two years it was not possible on his part to identify
the accused. Nothing more came out relevant.
15.
PW-10, Dr. Subhankar Nath deposed that on
28.01.2021 he was posted as Deputy Director, DNA Typing
Division, SFSL, Tripura and on that day he received 11
exhibits marked as A, A1, B, B1, C, D, E, F, G, H and I from
the Biology/Serology Division. The exhibits were forwarded
by SDPO, Amarpur in connection with Nutan Bazar PS Case
No.37/2020. He conducted DNA test on these three exhibits
as per standard protocol given in page 3, 4, 5 & 6 of his
report. He gave the result of examination and observation
which are as follows:
Result of Examination:- A portion of blood stain cotton
of Ext.A (sime amount of blood stain collected from
PO), Ext.A1 (swab prepared from blood stain grassed
and soil, Exbt. B blood stain collected from PO, Ext. B1
swab prepared from some amount from blood stain
grasses and soil collected from PO, Ext C swab
prepared from one wooden lathi sezed from P.O. Ext.E
(chopped ear of victim Rina Kalai, Ext.F blood sample
of accused Tarani Kalai, Ext.G swab prepared from one
chopper (dao) and Ext.H blood sample of victim Rina
Kalai were subjected to DNA isolation by organic
extraction method.
DNA recovered from the above-mentioned exhibit
were subjected to multiplex PCR reaction for coamplification of the 15 STR loci & Amelogenin using
AmpF/STR Identifier Plus TM PCR amplification kit. The
amplified products along with controls were run on the
Automated
DNA
sequencer.
The
sizing
of
the
fragments was carried out using Gene Mapper ID
software V3.2 with respect to Gene Scan 500 LIZ size
standard. The resultant allelic distribution for the
studied loci in the different exhibits is shown in the
table of Annexure-A.
Observation:-
(1)
Female
genetic
profile
was
generated from Ext.A (2) No alleles has been amplified
from Ext. A1 (3) Female genetic profile was generated
from Ext.B (4) No alleles has been amplified from
Ext.B1 (5) Female genetic profile was generated from
Ext.C (6) Female genetic profile was generated from
Ext.E (7) Male genetic profile was generated from
Ext.F. (8) No alleles has been amplified from Ext.G.
(9) Female genetic profile was generated from Ext.H
(10) No alleles has been amplified from Ext.A, Ext.B,
Ext.C, Ext.E, Ext. H are matches with each other.
Conclusion:- On the basis of the above observations it
is concluded that:- (1) Ext.E (chopped ear of victim
Rina Kalai, belongs to Ext.H (blood sample of victim
Rina Kalai), (2) Ext.A and Ext.B (some amount of
blood stain collected from PO, Ext.C (swab prepared
from one wooden lathi seized form PO), (3) Ext.A
(swab prepared from blood stained grasses and soil),
Ext. B1 (swab prepared from some amount of blood
stained grasses and soil collected from PO and Exbt.G
(swab prepared from one chopper (dao). It is not
possible to draw any opinion but all the blood belongs
to human female origin.
The report prepared by him containing nine
paged bearing his signature marked Exbt.9.
He was declined to cross-examination by the
accused.
16.
PW-11 Dr. Milan Bhakta Jamatia deposed that on
26.11.2020 he was posted at NTB rural Hospital and on that
day he examined one Rina Kalai aged 26 years admitted
with the history of assault with sharp weapon in connection
with NTB PS Case No.37 of 2020. On examination he found
the below noted wounds:
1. Incised wound measuring 15 cmx1.5 cm x scalp
deep, clean cut present over the left parietal region
and 3 cm left lateral to mid line.
2. Reddish abrasion measuring 4.5 cm x 1 cm, with
swelling incised would scalp tissue deep present over
left side of the face in front.
3. Incised would (debrled) measuring 2 cm x 1 cm x
soft tissue deep with clean cut margin present 3 cm
above tip of left mastoid.
4. Chop would with amputation of part of left ear
measuring 7 cm x1 cm cartilage deep margins are
regular and clean cut present over left ear pina.
5. Incised wound with following inferiorly measuring 5
cm x 1 cm x soft tissue and clean deep, margins are
regular present over the left side of the neck 1 cm
below tip of mastoid.
6. Incised would with falling inferiorly 3 cm x 1 cm x
soft tissue and clean deep, margins are regular
present over the left side of the neck 1 cm below tip of
mastoid.
7. Incised wound 3 cm x 1 cm with soft tissue deep
with regular margins and clean cut border present
over left side of chin 2 cm below left angle of mouth
present vertically.
8. Incised would measuring 8 cm x 3 cm x muscle
deep with regular margins and clean cut present over
back and lower one third of right forearm.
9. Chop wound 15 cm x 7 cm x bone deep with regular
margins with cutting of underlying muscle, tendon and
bone present over left forearm frontal aspect and bak
at middle one third of left forearm.
10. Chop wound 10 cm x 5 cm x bone deep with
regular margins with cutting of underlying muscle and
tendon present over back of left forearm 4 cm below
injury No.9.
All the injuries are caused by heavy sharp cutting
weapon with sharp edge. The injuries mentioned above can
be caused by the dao (MO-2) i.e., shown to him. The
injuries mentioned at Sl. Nos. 4, 9 and 10 are grievous in
nature caused by sharp weapon. The witness identified his
signature on the report marked as Exbt.P10.
During cross-examination he stated that he had
personally examined the patient and the injury report does
not mention the state of consciousness, blood pressure etc.
Nothing came out relevant.
17.
PW-12 SI Jiban Ch. Das is the I.O. who laid the
chargesheet against the accused. He deposed that on
26.11.2020 he was posted at NTB PS and on that day SI
Dhrubajyoti Debbarma received an FIR and registered NTB
PS Case No.37 of 2021. The FIR was received by OC, Bapi
Debbarma at the spot. The printed FIR form filled up by SI
Dhrubajyoti Debbarma. He identified the endorsement by
OC in the FIR marked Exbt.P1/2 while that of SI Dhrubajyoti
Debbarma marked as Exbt.P1/3 and the printed FIR form
containing two sheets of paper marked Exbt.P11. He visited
the PO and prepared hand sketch map of the same with
index which are marked as Exbt.P12. He also made some
seizures from the spot viz. blood stains collected from the
lunga, blood stained grass and soil collected from the PO.
One wooden lathi stained with blood, some black colour hair
of the victim and one piece of human hair also belonging
from the victim by preparing a seizure list. The witness
identified
the
seizure
list
dated
Exbt.P2/2.
He
further
stated
that
26.11.2020
on
marked
26.11.2020
he
recorded the statement of Rajen Kalai and Ashim Tripura.
On 27.11.2020 he examined one Lalita Kalai and Sukanta
Debbarma and on 29.11.2020 he examined one Ananta
Tripura. On 05.12.2020 he arrested accused Tarani Kalai
and arranged for his medical examination. He also seized
the blood sample of the accused collected by the doctor. He
identified the seizure list dated 05.12.2020 marked as
Exbt.P5/2. He further stated that he recorded the statement
of Tarani Kalai in presence of DCM. The witness identified
the statement marked Exbt.P6/2. He also seized the dao in
presence of the DCM and other witnesses. The witness
identified
the
seizure
list
dated
06.12.2020
marked
Exbt.P8/1. On 07.12.2020 he examined the victim at GBP
Hospital. He also collected her blood sample and controlled
hair sample for analysis by the FSL. He identified the
seizure
list
dated
07.12.2020
marked
Exbt.P7/2.
On
09.12.2020 he sent the seized articles to the SFSL for
forensic analysis. He collected identity card of the accused
Tarani Kalai on 10.12.2020 and also seized the DVD
cassette which records the recovery of dao and statement of
accused. The witness identified the seizure list dated
17.12.2020 marked Exbt.P4/2. On 17.12.2020 he examined
five witnesses and on 20.12.2020 he examined one witness.
On 27.12.2020 he examined the DCM and on 20.02.2021 he
examined the scribe. He collected the injury report and FSL
report on 20.02.2021. Being prima facie satisfied from the
evidence collected by him he filed charge sheet vide NTB PS
Case
No.3
of
dated
28.02.2021
under
Section
341/323/326/307 of IPC against the accused persons
namely Tarani
Kalai
and Sambhu Kalai. The witness
identified the chargesheet in form 16 containing 2 pages
marked as Exbt.P13.
During cross-examination he stated that he did
not mention the name of the owner of the house marked J
in his map and witness volunteered that the CD indicates
the house belongs to Smt Lalita Kalai. Witness Ashim
Tripura is not related to any of the parties. In his disclosure
statement Tarani Kalai stated that he was admitted in
hospital after the incident. He had not collected any record
to that effect from the hospital. Nothing more came out
relevant from the cross-examination.
These are the sum and substance of the evidence on
record.
18.
We have heard both the sides and gone through
the evidence on record of the prosecution. From the
evidence it appears to us that on the alleged day the
present appellant committed the offence and inflicted
multiple injuries to the victim using dao. The appellant
during cross-examination could not raise any circumstance
to disbelieve the evidence on record of the prosecution.
Situated thus, on the face of the evidence on record it
appears to us that the prosecution before the Learned court
below has been able to prove the charge levelled against
the accused appellant. So considering the evidence on
record of the prosecution and also the injury report of the
victim submitted by PW-11 we are of the considered opinion
that Learned court below rightly found the appellant to be
guilty and convicted him and as such this present appeal is
liable to be dismissed. However, at the time of hearing of
argument Learned Counsel appearing for the appellant
submitted that the appellant for the first time committed
the offence and it is not clear as to why he committed the
crime on the alleged day. Since he is a first time offender so
Learned counsel for the appellant urged for reducing the
punishment imposed upon the appellant. Section-307 of IPC
provides punishment upto 10 years which may extend to
ten years and shall also be liable to fine and if hurt is
caused to any person by such act, the offender shall be
liable either to imprisonment for life or to such punishment
as is hereinbefore mentioned. So considering nature and
gravity of the offence and also the fact that the present
appellant has committed the offence for the first time as
there is no adverse evidence on record in this regard the
sentence of imprisonment imposed by Learned Trial Court is
reduced to 7 (seven) years from 10 (ten) years and the
other mode of punishment will remain as it is.
With this observation this appeal stands partly
allowed and disposed of.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
judgment and also a copy of this judgment be forwarded to
the
convict-appellant
through
Superintendent
of
Kendriya Sansodhanagar, Bishalgarh.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.03.21 05:46:48
+05'30'
Jail,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review