Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.285 of 2024
Sri Tapas Deb
S/O. Sri Shiba Prasad Deb,
Resident of Sabroom Nagar Panchayat,
Ward No.1, Sabroom, South Tripura,
PIN: 799 145
----Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary,
General Administration (Personnel & Training)
Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:799 010
2. The Secretary,
General Administration (Personnel & Training)
Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:799 010
3. The Secretary, General Administration,
(Administrative Reforms) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:799 010
4. The Secretary,
Home Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN: 799 010
---- Respondents (s)
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Adv.
For Respondent(s): Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
Date of Hearing : 11.09.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
26.09.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman
assisted by Mr. D. Paul, Learned Counsel representing the
petitioner and also heard Mr. K. De, Learned Addl. G.A.
appearing for the State-respondents.
02.
The present writ petition is filed by the petitioner
seeking the following relief/reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why Writ in the nature of mandamus
and/or
Order/direction
shall
not
be
issued
whereby quashing and cancelling the Order,
dated 09.02.2024, issued by the Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, General Administration
(Administrative Reforms) Department.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of
mandamus
and/or
order/orders,
direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issued
whereby
impugned
issued
by
quashing
Memorandum,
the
Under
&
cancelling
dated
the
30.09.2024,
Secretary,
GA(AR)
Department, Government of Tripura.
(iii) Make the rules absolute
(iv) Call for records pertaining to the instant Writ
petition.
(v) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble
High Court considered fit and proper.
03.
Taking
part
in
the
hearing
Learned
Senior
Counsel appearing for the petitioner drawn the attention of
the Court that the petitioner is presently serving under
Tripura
Police
Service
as
Grade-II
Officer
posted
as
Assistant Commandant, 13th Battalion, TSR at Kanchanpur,
North Tripura. The petitioner had joined Tripura Police
Service on 01.10.2004 initially being appointed as Assistant
Commandant, 2nd Battalion, TSR and the petitioner was
posted as SDPO, Teliamura, Khowai in the year 2017. That
initially the Principal Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, General Administration (AR) Department issued one
memorandum dated 24.01.2022 proposing to hold an
enquiry against the petitioner under Rule-14 of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965. The substance of the imputation of
misconduct or misbehavior was set out in the statement of
Articles of Charge as mentioned herein below:
Article of Charge-I
Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, the then SDPO Teliamura Sub
Division, now Asstt. Commandant 13th Bn. TSR, during
the period from 01.04.2012 to 31.06.2018 has failed to
maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty that as
per inquiry report submitted by the SP(Vig.) vide letter
No.223/SP/VIG/Con/2021
dated
13.09.2021,
and
amount of Rs.2,32,90,546/- only was credited to the
accounts of Shri Tapas Deb and his wife, Smt. Pinaki
Lodh, Staff Nurse of Health Department which is
disproportionate to known source of income. An amount
of Rs.2,11,86,895/- out of Rs. 2,32,90, 546/- was
creditied to the account of Shri Tapas Deb and the
balance Rs.21,03,651/- was credited in the account of
Smt. Lodh.
By the above acts, Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, has
committed gross misconduct and failed maintain absolute
integrity and thus, violated Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil
Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988.
Article of Charge-II
Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, the then SDPO Teliamura SubDivision, now Asstt., Commandant 13th Bn. TSR, during
the period from 01.04.2012 to 31.06.2018 has failed to
maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty that as
per inquiry report submitted by the SP (Vig.) vide letter
No.223/SP/VIG/Con/2021 dated 13.09.2021 that, Shri
Deb has disposed of immovable property worth
Rs.3,30,000/- (Rupees Three lakhs thirty thousand)
without obtaining prior sanction from the authority which
is in violation of Rule 18(2) of the TCS (Conduct) Rules,
1988.
By the above acts, Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, has
committed gross misconduct and failed to maintain
absolute integrity and thus, violated Rule-3 & 18(2) of
the TCS (Conduct) Rules, 1988.
Article of Charge-III
Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, the then SDPO Teliamura Sub
Division, now Asstt. Commandant 13th Bn. TSR, during
the period from 01.04.2012 to 31.06.2018 has failed to
maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty that as
per inquiry report submitted by the SP(Vig.) vide letter
No.223/SP/VIG/Con/2021 dated 13.09.2021 that, Shri
Deb has taken Rs.60,00,000/- (Rupees Sixty Lakhs) only
as Home Loan from ICICI Bank Ltd, as a co-applicant and
also agreeing to repay the monthly EMI of Rs.44,784/-,
without prior approval from the competent authority as
required under Rule-16(4)(i)(a) of the Tripura Civil
Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988.
By the above acts, Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, has
willfully committed gross misconduct and failed to
maintain absolute integrity and thus he has violated Rule3 & 16(4)(i)(a) of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct)
Rules, 1988.
Article of Charge-IV
Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, the then SDPO Teliamura Sub
Division, now Asstt. Commandant 13th Bn. TSR, during
the period from 01.04.2012 to 31.06.2018 has failed to
maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty that as
per inquiry report submitted by the SP(Vig.) vide letter
No.223/SP/VIG/Con/2021 dated 13.09.2021, Shri Deb
had purchased Crypto currency for Rs.15,00,000 (Rupees
Fifteen lakhs) and had invested in shares without prior
permission of the competent authority and violated Rule
16(1) of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988.
By the above acts, Shri Tapas Deb, TPS Gr-II, has willfully
committed gross misconduct and failed to maintain
absolute integrity and thus he has violated Rule-3 &
16(1) of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988.
The petitioner relied upon the said memorandum
dated 24.11.2022 marked as Annexure-1.
04.
According to Learned Senior Counsel thereafter
the Principal Secretary, Government of Tripura GA(AR)
Department being the disciplinary authority by order dated
31.05.2022
appointed
Commissioner
of
Departmental
Inquiries as the inquiring authority to inquire into the
charges framed against the petitioner and one Shri Ajoy
Kumar Das, TPS Gr-II was appointed as the Presenting
Officer to present the case on behalf of the Government
before the inquiring authority. The copy of the order dated
31.05.2022 is annexed with this writ petition marked as
Annexure-2.
05.
On 30.11.2022 the inquiring authority after
completion of his inquiry proceeding submitted report to the
disciplinary authority. Copy of this order dated 30.11.2022
is annexed with the petition marked as Annexure-3. Further
according
to
Learned
Senior
Counsel
the
disciplinary
authority without recording any disagreement with the
inquiry
report
opportunity
to
and
without
giving
any
the
petitioner
issued
an
reasonable
order
dated
15.05.2023 further appointed Shri Ajoy Kumar Das as the
Presenting Officer (Anneuxre-4) and without affording any
copy of the finding dated 29.11.2022 to the petitioner the
Disciplinary Authority vide order dated 15.05.2023 again
arbitrarily appointed Dr. Sandeep R. Rathod, IAS, Secretary
RD Department to re-inquire into the charges framed
against the petitioner towards further inquiry. A copy of the
order is annexed with this petition marked as Annexure-5.
06.
After that the petitioner due to arbitrary action of
the respondents had no other alternative but to approach
this High Court by filing one Writ Petition bearing No.WP(C)
of
seeking
quashing
of
the
order
dated
15.05.2023 as well as the inquiry initiated by memorandum
dated 24.01.2022 along with further direction upon the
respondents to provide the petitioner with a copy of the
inquiry report submitted by letter dated 30.11.2022. After
that, this High Court by order dated 03.07.2023 in WP(C)
No.396 of 2023 suspended the operation of the impugned
order for further inquiry dated 15.05.2023. Copy of the
order of the High Court dated 03.07.2023 is annexed with
this petition marked as Annexure-6.
07.
It was further submitted that after that the
Special Secretary to the Government of Tripura GA(AR)
Department again issued order on 19.11.2023 cancelling
the order of appointment of the inquiring authority by order
dated 15.05.2023. Copy of the order dated 19.10.2023 is
annexed with this petition marked as Annexure-7. But
surprisingly
while
the
writ
petition
was
pending
the
Secretary, GA(AR) Department, Government of Tripura
(Disciplinary
Authority)
again
issued
order
dated
22.11.2023 appointed Shri Saurav Sen, TPS Gr-II, Dy.
SP(PHQ) as Presenting Officer to present the case on behalf
of the Government before the inquiring authority. Copy of
the order dated 22.11.2023 is annexed with this petition
marked as Annexure-8.
08.
Thereafter
this
High
Court
by
order
dated
23.11.2023 dismissed WP(C)396/2023 as the impugned
order under challenge had been cancelled and as such
nothing survived for adjudication and gave an opportunity
to the petitioner that if any fresh proceeding is issued the
petitioner would be at liberty to challenge the same. Copy of
the order dated 23.11.2023 is annexed with this petition
marked as Annexure-9. On 09.02.2024 the Secretary to the
Government of Tripura GA(AR) Department being the
Disciplinary
Authority
again
issued
an
order
dated
09.02.2024 that the findings of the IA was carefully
examined in the GA(AR) Department and the Disciplinary
Authority had disagreed with the findings of the Inquiring
Authority and decided that an Inquiring Authority should be
appointed to further enquire into the case on the ground
that on examination of the enquiry report submitted by the
Inquiring Authority, it appeared that the inquiry was not
conducted by the IA as a summary trial wherein the IA in
search of concrete evidence against the AO had concluded
the enquiry considering the accused officer not guilty of
charges framed against him and as per CCS(CCA) Rules,
1965 Disciplinary Proceeding has to be conducted and
concluded considering the preponderance of probability and
IA had concluded the case giving the benefit of doubt to
A.O. and remitted the case back to the Commissioner of
Departmental Inquiries to further enquire in to the charges
framed against the petitioner. Copy of the impugned order
dated 09.02.2024 is annexed with the writ petition as
Annexure-10.
09.
According to Learned Senior Counsel the order
dated 09.02.2024 was passed by the Disciplinary Authority
in complete disregard and disobedience of the specific
mandate of Rule 15(1) & Rule 15(2) of CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965. Although the inquiring authority gave a clean chit
after full-fledged inquiry but the Disciplinary Authority did
not give any cogent reasons in writing as to why the
Disciplinary Authority was not agreeable to the inquiry
report in terms of Rule 15(2). Even the Disciplinary
Authority did not forward a copy of the inquiry report
together with its own tentative reasons for disagreement
with the findings of inquiring authority on any article of
charge to the petitioner, so as to enable him to submit his
written representation as required under Rule 15(2). It was
further submitted that on 30.09.2024, the Under Secretary,
GA(AR) Department, Government of Tripura who was not
authorized to issue any memorandum issued an impugned
memorandum whereby arbitrarily and illegally remitted the
matter back to the CDI for further inquiry from the stage of
examination of prosecution witness which was issued in
violation of Rule-15(2) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further
submitted
that
the
impugned memorandum dated 30.09.2024 was issued as an
unilateral
order
for
re-inquiry
without
taking
into
consideration the submission of the petitioner or without
even waiting for representation of the petitioner. Thus
infringed the constitutional rights of the petitioner available
under Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India hence
Learned senior Counsel urged for allowing this writ petition
by cancelling the memo dated 09.02.2024 and subsequent
memo dated 30.09.2024 issued by Under Secretary, GA(AR)
Department, Government of Tripura.
10.
In course of hearing Learned Senior Counsel also
relied upon one citation of this High Court in Dhiman
Singha vs. State of Tripura and Ors. reported in (2015)
2 TLR 900 wherein in para No.7, 10, 11 and 12 this High
Court observed as under:
“7. Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 15 envisages a situation where
the disciplinary authority is itself not the inquiring
authority. On going through the report of the inquiry
officer, if the disciplinary authority finds that further
inquiry proceedings should be held then it must record its
reasons for coming to such a finding and thereafter it
must remit the case to the inquiring authority for further
inquiry and report the matter to the disciplinary
authority. Therefore, what is contemplated under this
sub-rule is a further inquiry which obviously means a
continuation of the old inquiry but not a fresh or de novo
inquiry. The language used is very specific that the
disciplinary authority after recording its reasons in
writing can remit the case to the inquiry officer.
Remission of a case means that it must be sent back to
the same authority to proceed further in accordance with
law. Officers may change but the authority must remain
the same. The words, „remit‟ and „further inquiry‟ leave
no manner of doubt that what is contemplated under Rule
15(1) is the continuation of the old inquiry by the same
authority which conducted the inquiry earlier.
10. Rule 15(2) deals with a different situation. This
contemplates a situation where on the evidence on record
and without any further evidence being recorded the
disciplinary authority is of the view that the finding
recorded by the inquiring officer exonerating the
delinquent official is against the evidence of law. In such
a case, the disciplinary authority is directed to indicate
and give its prima facie or tentative reasons for
disagreeing with the report of the inquiring authority and
then communicate the reasons to the delinquent official
giving him a chance to put forth his case and answer the
queries of the disciplinary authority.
11. Thereafter, the disciplinary authority is required not
only to consider the inquiry report but also it‟s own
tentative reasoning as well as the reply given by the
delinquent official. After considering all three the
disciplinary authority has a right to form his own opinion
on the basis of the evidence. This does not envisage the
holding of any fresh inquiry but only on the basis of the
evidence already recorded by the inquiring officer the
action is to be taken.
12. There is no rule which permits the disciplinary
authority to start a fresh inquiry. In the present case, the
disciplinary authority did not follow any of the above two
options. In case the disciplinary authority was of the view
that the statements of some material witnesses had not
been recorded or that some material evidence had not
been taken into consideration then the disciplinary
authority should have recorded these reasons and then
could have remitted the matter to the inquiring officer to
carry out the further enquiry in terms of Rule 15(1). This
has not been done. What has been done is to order a
fresh inquiry officer and start de novo inquiry which is
not permissible under the law. The procedure followed is
totally illegal. We, therefore, have no option but to set
aside the entire inquiry proceedings and quash the order
dismissing the petitioner from service.”
Relying upon the said citation Learned Senior
Counsel submitted that this present case is squarely
covered by the judgment of the Division Bench of this High
Court and urged for allowing this writ petition.
11.
The
State-respondents
contested
the
writ
petition by filing counter-affidavit and additional counteraffidavit denying the assertion of the petitioner and in para
Nos.16, 17 and 18 the State-respondents took the plea as
under:
“16. That, with regard to para 15 of the Petition, I say
that, it is correct that the Hon‟ble Court vide order dated
23.11.2023 dismissed the WP(C) No.396 of 2023 as the
impugned order under challenge had been cancelled and
as such nothing survived for adjudication. The Hon‟ble
Court also made it clear that in the event if any fresh
proceeding is issued the petitioner would be at liberty to
challenge the same.
17. That, with regard to para 16 of the Petition, I say
that, it is fact that on disposal of the WP(C) 396 of 2023
filed by the Petitioner, the order dated 09.02.2024
appointing the Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries
(CDI) was issued with valid reasons for further inquiry
into the case as per Rule 15(1) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
18. That, with regard to para 17 of the Petition, I say
that, it is correct that the Disciplinary Authority passed
the order dated 09.02.2024 with reasons and remit the
case for further inquiry as per rules 15(1) of the
CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
Besides, in compliance of Rule 15 of CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965 a copy of the findings was served to the
Petitioner/Charged Officer vide Memo dated 18.07.2024
seeking his representation. It is also pertinent to mention
here that through a distinct and separate order dated
30.09.2024, the reason of disagreement with the former
inquiry report and the necessity of further inquiry was
also
communicated
to
the
concerned
charged
officer/Petitioner.”
The State-respondents also relied upon some
documents which were marked as Annexure R/1 and
Annexure R/2. However the State-respondents admitted the
facts of earlier proceeding and the filing of case which was
filed by the petitioner by providing documentary evidence.
12.
Thereafter
the
State-respondents
also
filed
additional counter-affidavit and in the additional affidavit in
para No.5 the State-respondents took the following pleas:
“5. That, with regard to para 20(A) of the amended writ
petition, I say that, through a distinct and separate order
dated 30.09.2024, the reason of disagreement with the
former inquiry report and the necessity of further inquiry
was also communicated to the petitioner. The said Memo
dated 30.09.2024 so assailed by the Petitioner was
issued by order of the Governor and not an order of the
under secretary in his capacity as such. Accordingly, the
petitioner had submitted one representation dated
09.10.2024. Thus the contentions of the petitioner that
no opportunity was given to the petitioner to file
representation against the memo dated 30.09.2024 is
false.
Copy of the representation dated 09.10.2024 of the
petitioner is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure
R/1.”
13.
However, at the time of hearing Learned Addl.
G.A. appearing for the State-respondents took the plea that
the memorandum was issued in accordance with the law by
the Under Secretary, Government of Tripura as per rules of
executive business. He also submitted that there was no
infirmity
in
the
memorandum
issued
by
the
Under
Secretary, Government of Tripura and furthermore as
alleged by the petitioner that no scope was given to furnish
him the representation but it is on record that after receipt
of copy of memorandum the present petitioner submitted
representation to the Government. So finally Learned Addl.
G.A. submitted that there is no merit in the petition filed by
the petitioner and furthermore it was the prerogative of the
Disciplinary Authority to issue order for further inquiry and
there was no infirmity to that and finally urged for dismissal
of the writ petition. It was further submitted by Learned
Addl. G.A. that although in course of hearing Learned Senior
Counsel took the plea that the petitioner was acquitted from
the criminal charge which cannot be a ground for dismissal
of the departmental proceeding and in this regard so many
decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court are there and again
submitted that there is no merit in this petition and the
same is liable to be dismissed with costs.
14.
I have heard detailed submission of both the
sides and perused the documents submitted by both the
sides along with the writ petition as well as the counteraffidavit. It is to be noted here that After receipt of the reply
filed
by
the
State-respondents
the
writ
petitioner
approached this Court for amendment of the writ petition
and accordingly after hearing both the sides the prayer of
the petitioner for amendment of writ petition was allowed
and accordingly the writ petitioner filed amended writ
petition before this Court.
15.
Now after hearing both the sides at this stage
this court is to decide whether the initial memorandum
dated 09.02.2024 and subsequent memorandum dated
30.09.2024 issued by the respondents authority were
lawfully issued in accordance with the relevant provision of
Rule-15(1) and 15(2) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 or not.
Since
the
aforesaid
memorandums
are
relevant
for
consideration in this writ petition. So without going into the
details of other issues which are not disputed by the Staterespondents let us examine as to whether the aforesaid
documents are required to be interfered with by exercising
writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India by this Court or not. Now for the sake of convenience
let me mention below the relevant provision of Rule 15 of
CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 which provides as under:
“Action on the inquiry report
(1) The Disciplinary Authority, if it is not itself the
Inquiring Authority may, for reasons to be recorded by it
in writing, remit the case to the Inquiring Authority for
further inquiry and report and the Inquiring Authority
shall thereupon proceed to hold the further inquiry
according to the provisions of Rule 14, as far as may be.
[(2) The Disciplinary Authority shall forward or cause to
be forwarded a copy of the report of the inquiry, if any,
held by the Disciplinary Authority or where the
Disciplinary Authority is not the Inquiring Authority, a
copy of the report of the Inquiring Authority together
with its own tentative reasons for disagreement, if any,
with the findings of Inquiring Authority on any article of
charge to the Government servant who shall be required
to submit, if he so desires, his written representation or
submission to the Disciplinary Authority within fifteen
days, irrespective of whether the report is favourable or
not to the Government servant.
(2-A) The Disciplinary Authority shall consider the
representation, if any, submitted by the Government
servant and record its findings before proceeding further
in the matter as specified in sub-rules (3) and (4).]
(3)If the Disciplinary Authority having regard to its
findings on all or any of the articles of charge is of the
opinion that any of the penalties specified in Clauses (i)
to (iv) of Rule 11 should be imposed on the Government
servant, it shall, notwithstanding anything contained in
Rule 16, make an order imposing such penalty:
Provided that in every case where it is necessary to
consult the Commission, the record of the inquiry shall be
forwarded by the Disciplinary Authority to the
Commission for its advice and such advice shall be taken
into consideration before making any order imposing any
penalty on the Government servant.
(4) If the Disciplinary Authority having regard to its
findings on all or any of the articles of charge and on the
basis of the evidence adduced during the inquiry is of the
opinion that any of the penalties specified in Clauses (v)
to (ix) of Rule 11 should be imposed on the Government
servant, it shall make an order imposing such penalty
and it shall not be necessary to give the Government
servant any opportunity of making representation on the
penalty proposed to be imposed:
Provided that in every case where it is necessary to
consult the Commission, the record of the inquiry shall be
forwarded by the Disciplinary Authority to the
Commission for its advice and such advice shall be taken
into consideration before making an order imposing any
such penalty on the Government servant.”
From the aforesaid rules it appears that as per
rule 15(1) if the Disciplinary Authority is not the inquiring
authority may for reasons to be recorded in writing remit
the case to the inquiring authority for further inquiry and
report and the inquiring authority shall thereupon proceed
to hold the further inquiry in accordance with the provisions
of Rule 14, as far as may be. Thus it appears that there is
scope for further inquiry if the disciplinary authority is not
satisfied with the report of the inquiring authority and in
that case the disciplinary authority may for reasons to be
recorded in writing remit the case to the inquiring authority
for further inquiry and report. There is no dispute to that.
Here in the case at hand it appears that disciplinary
authority was not satisfied with the report of the inquiring
authority and as such remitted back the matter to the
inquiring authority for further inquiry and report.
Now on perusal of the Rule 15(2) it appears that Rule
15(2) is different from Rule-15(1) which provides that the
Disciplinary Authority shall forward or cause to be forwarded
a copy of the report of the inquiry, if any, held by the
Disciplinary Authority or where the Disciplinary Authority is
not the Inquiring Authority, a copy of the report of the
Inquiring Authority together with its own tentative reasons
for disagreement, if any, with the findings of Inquiring
Authority on any article of charges to the Government
servant who shall be required to submit, if he so desires, his
written representation or submission to the Disciplinary
Authority. Here in the given case at hand at the time of
hearing Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner
drawn the attention of the Court that since in this case the
disciplinary authority was not the inquiring authority and the
disciplinary authority remitted back the matter to the
inquiring authority for further inquiry. But surprisingly at the
time of referring the matter the copy of the report of the
inquiring authority together with the own tentative reasons
for disagreement if any, with the findings of the inquiring
authority on any article of charge of the government
servant were not communicated to the present petitioner.
Thus he was deprived of his legal right. In this regard
Learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the State-respondents
drawn the attention of the Court that this opportunity was
given
and
the
present
petitioner
submitted
his
representation to the disciplinary authority within fifteen
days so at this stage there is no scope on the part of the
present petitioner to take this plea.
16.
I have gone through the relevant documents
submitted by both the parties. I have also gone through the
citation of the Division Bench of this High Court referred by
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner. In
para-10 of the said citation this Hon’ble High Court
observed that where on the evidence on record and without
any
further
evidence
being
recorded
the
disciplinary
authority is of the view that the finding recorded by the
Inquiring Officer exonerating the delinquent
official is
against the evidence of law. In such a case, the disciplinary
authority is directed to indicate and give its prima facie or
tentative reasons for disagreeing with the report of the
inquiring authority and then communicate the reasons to
the delinquent official giving him a chance to put forth his
case and answer the queries of the disciplinary authority
and thereafter as per para-11, the disciplinary authority is
required not only to consider the inquiry report but also it’s
own tentative reasoning as well as the reply given by the
delinquent official and after considering all three the
disciplinary authority has a right to form his own opinion on
the basis of the evidence. This does not envisage the
holding of any fresh inquiry but only on the basis of the
evidence already recorded by the Inquiring Officer the
action is to be taken. But here in the case at hand on
perusal of the memo dated 09.02.2024 i.e. Annexure-10 of
the writ petition and memo dated 30.09.2024 [AnnexureR/2] relied upon by the State-respondents it appears to this
Court that the directions of the Division Bench in the
aforesaid case was not followed in the present case at hand
by the disciplinary authority rather the disciplinary authority
mechanically issued the memorandum without following the
mandate of law which caused grave injustice to the present
petitioner. Further there is no rule which permits disciplinary
authority to start a fresh inquiry. In the present case the
disciplinary authority did not follow any of the above two
options rather the disciplinary authority came to the
observation that the inquiry was not conducted by IA as
summary trial where in the IA in search of the concrete
evidence
against
the
I.O.
has
concluded
the
inquiry
considering the accused officer not guilty of the charges find
against him and as per CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 disciplinary
proceeding
conducted
and
concluded
considering
the
preponderance of probability and thus I.O. concluded the
case giving benefit of doubt to the I.O. (memo dated
09.02.2024
Annexure-10).
Further
in
memo
dated
30.09.2024 it was the observation of the under Secretary,
GA(AR)
Department
that
as
per
Rule
15(1)
if
the
Disciplinary Authority is not satisfied with the inquiry report
it may remit the case to the Inquiring Authority for further
inquiry and therefore based on the deposition made by the
hostile witness the matter is remitted back to CDI for
further inquiry from the stage of examination of prosecution
witnesses. Thus it appears that the disciplinary authority in
passing the orders did not actually follow the rule as
contained in 15(1) and 15(2) of the CCS(CCA) Rules and
also the observation passed by this Hon’ble High Court in
para No.10 and 11 and ordered for a fresh inquiry i.e. De
Novo inquiry from the stage of examination of prosecution
witnesses which was not permissible under the law and the
procedure followed according to this Court was totally
illegal. As such, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the subsequent order for fresh inquiry by the aforesaid
memo dated 09.02.2024 and memo dated 30.09.2024 are
illegal, inoperative and not binding upon the petitioner and
the same were not issued in accordance with the relevant
rules of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 and also in violation of
the judgment delivered by this High Court in the aforenoted
case. As such in the considered view of this Court the
petitioner has got a prima facie case and there is no scope
to proceed for fresh inquiry as ordered by the Staterespondents against the petitioner. It is also necessary to be
mentioned here that in course of hearing Learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the petitioner drawn the attention of
this Court that the criminal case filed against the petitioner
was ended in final report and by order dated 18.01.2025 in
NCC P.S. Case No.47 of 2021 passed by the Learned Special
Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala accepted the final
report submitted by I.O. and challenging that order dated
18.02.2025, no appeal has been preferred by the Staterespondents against the petitioner of this case.
17.
In this regard Hon’ble the Supreme Court in a
judgment in Ram Lal vs State of Rajasthan and Others
reported in (2024) 1 SCC 175 in para Nos. 11 and 12
observed as under:
“11. We are also conscious of the fact that mere acquittal
by a criminal court will not confer on the employee a
right to claim any benefit, including reinstatement.
(See Deputy Inspector General of Police and Another v. S.
Samuthiram, (2013) 1 SCC 598).
12. However, if the charges in the departmental enquiry
and the criminal court are identical or similar, and if the
evidence, witnesses and circumstances are one and the
same, then the matter acquires a different dimension. If
the court in judicial review concludes that the acquittal in
the criminal proceeding was after full consideration of
the prosecution evidence and that the prosecution
miserably failed to prove the charge, the Court in judicial
review can grant redress in certain circumstances. The
court will be entitled to exercise its discretion and grant
relief, if it concludes that allowing the findings in the
disciplinary proceedings to stand will be unjust, unfair
and oppressive. Each case will turn on its own facts.
[See G.M. Tank vs. State of Gujarat & Others, (2006) 5
SCC 446, State Bank of Hyderabad vs. P. Kata Rao,
(2008) 15 SCC 657 and S. Samuthiram (2013) 1 SCC
598].”
Here in the case at hand although in the criminal
prosecution
final
report
was
submitted
and
in
the
departmental proceeding some article of charges were
framed and in both the matters the allegations are almost
identical and similar in nature. In the criminal proceeding
final report was accepted by order dated 18.01.2025 by
Learned Special Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala
against NCC PS Case No.47 of 2021 and in the departmental
proceeding the inquiring authority found the petitioner not
guilty to any of the article of charge as framed against him
So the observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
aforenoted case can be applied in this case and relied upon
the same principle. It appears to this court that in the given
facts and circumstances of the case the memo dated
09.02.2023 (Annexure-10) of the writ petition and the
subsequent memo dated 30.09.2024 issued by the Under
Secretary, Government of Tripura (Annexure R/2) have got
no legal basis to stand against the present petitioner of this
case.
In the result, the petition filed by the petitioner
stands allowed and disposed of.
The memo dated 09.02.2024 (Annexure-10 to
the
writ
petition)
and
the
subsequent
memo
dated
30.09.2024 issued by Under Secretary on behalf of the
Governor stands set aside and accordingly the same are
quashed.
Pending application if any, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMIT
A DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.10.03
01:47:48 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review