Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 641 of 2023
1. Sri Tapan Kr. Sarkar, age 55 years S/O Lt. Sunatan Sarkar Resident of
Arunachal Sangha, Rajarbag, P.O-Rajarbag, P.S.-Udaipur. District-Gomati
Tripura.
2. Pradip Debbarma age 53 Years S/O Lt. Kartik Debbarma, Resident of North
Banamalipur, Near Volcan Club. P.O.-Sadar. P.S.-East Agartala, District-West
Tripura.
3. Ajoy Jamatia age 47 Years S/O Lt. Nirmal Ch. Jamatia, Resident of Silghati,
P.O Silghati, P.S.-Udaipur District-Gomati, Tripura.
....... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura Represented by the secretary, to department of GA
(P &T), New capital complex, Kunjaban, Agartala
2. Secretary of Rural Development Department Kunjaban, Agartala
3. Chief Engineer, Rural Development Department P.N Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala
………Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s):
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate,
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate.
For Respondent(s):
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
01/10/2024
Petitioners seek quashing of the Recruitment Rules, 2015 for the
post of Superintending Engineer published vide notification dated 25 th June,
2015 and also communication dated 31st January, 2013. They have also prayed
for consideration of their cases for promotion to the post of Superintending
Engineer from the post of Executive Engineer in accordance with the seniority
list without making any discipline wise embargo as like Civil Engineer.
2.
As per the averments in the writ petition, the petitioners are
Bachelor of Engineering (Mechanical). They were initially appointed as Junior
Engineer on 1st August, 1986, 7th August, 1986 and 2nd June, 2003 respectively
under the respondent department. The petitioners have in due course of time
been promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer and then to the post of
Executive Engineer on ad hoc basis as per the ad hoe promotion policy dated
22nd June, 2021. However, for the purpose of promotion to the post of
Superintending Engineer the petitioners have been discriminated in view of the
Recruitment Rules, 2015 which are a replica of the Recruitment Rules dated
27th December, 2010. Under Clause 11 of the said two Rules, recruitment to the
post of Superintending Engineer shall be by promotion/deputation/transfer from
the post of Executive Engineer having seven years continuous and regular
service in the grade and having degree in Civil Engineering from a recognized
University or its equivalent educational qualification. As such, petitioners who
are degree holders in Mechanical Engineering have been ousted from the zone
of consideration which is arbitrary and unreasonable. Under the Recruitment
Rules, juniors to the petitioners will be promoted to the post of Superintending
Engineers.
3.
It is also contended that the petitioners had made representations
for airing their grievances, which were replied in a clumsy manner by
communication dated 01.01.2023 (Annexure 8 & 9 to the writ petition).
According to the petitioners, the existing rule, which segregates eligible
Executive Engineers like the petitioners only on the ground of their discipline
i.e. Mechanical or Electrical Engineering, is discriminatory as there has been no
such distinction ever before in the basic entry level post or for promotion to the
post of Executive Engineer. During pendency of the writ petition, promotions
were carried out to the post of Superintending Engineer from the post of
Executive Engineer in pursuance to clause 11(i) of the Recruitment Rules, 2015
only from the discipline of Civil Engineers which is ex facie illegal. The
petitioners are being illegally and arbitrarily denied chances of promotion to the
higher grade. Petitioners, however, do not raise any grievance against the
persons who have availed the promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer
and hence, have not arrayed them as party respondents. On these grounds,
challenge has been made.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has referred to the judgment
rendered earlier in the case of Shri Manas Nath Vs. State of Tripura & Ors.,
[WP(C) No. 530/2011] dated 31.07.2014 wherein the petitioner who was a
degree holder in Civil Engineering had raised a grievance that there are no
separate posts earmarked for engineers who had done their engineering in
Mechanical or Electrical field. He had prayed that separate seniority list should
be made for Junior Engineer (Civil), Junior Engineer (Mechanical) and Junior
Engineer (Electrical) and promotions should be made in the respective streams.
5.
However, learned Division Bench of this Court after consideration
of the rival submission of the parties rejected the petition as being without
merit. It was held that it would be unfair to introduce such a criteria now to
deny promotion to Mechanical and Electrical engineers to the higher level by
amending the rules at the behest of the petitioner. Therefore, the respondents
are not justified in introducing Clause 11 in the 2015 Recruitment Rules to
deny the legitimate expectation of the petitioners for promotion to the higher
post of Superintending Engineer.
6.
The respondent-Department has filed counter affidavit. Learned
counsel for the respondents has taken this court to the averments made therein.
It is asserted that the Rural Development Department is involved in the
implementation and execution of allied rural infrastructure development
activities in the State for which the engineers from branches of Civil,
Mechanical and Electrical were recruited as per provisions of the recruitment
rules. The engineering works of the Rural Development Department
irrespective of their nature are being implemented through all these categories
of engineers till date. Therefore, there is a common seniority list is of Junior
Engineers, Assistant Engineers and Executive Engineers.
7.
The Recruitment Rules of the Assistant Engineers dated 25th June,
2015 is not only for promotion of degree and diploma holders but direct entry
provision is also there in the recruitment rules. Whereas 20% of the post of
Assistant Engineers is to be filled up through direct recruitment and 80% of the
posts are to be filled up (a) 50% from degree holder of Civil, Mechanical &
from Electrical Engineering; and (b) 50% from candidates with diploma in
Civil, Electrical and Mechanical Engineering. The department has, in pursuance
of the government notification dated 22nd June, 2021 granted ad hoc promotion
to the eligible candidates as per provisions in the existing recruitment rules and
common seniority list prevailing in the department.
8.
However, promoted candidates have not gained any new seniority
and there is no provision to give next promotion to such candidates counting
the ad hoc period of service. Notification dated 22nd June, 2021 also stipulates
only one time promotion. They have further stated that for promotion to the
higher post, the requirement of having seven years of regular service on the
post of Executive Engineer with a degree in Civil Engineering has been
stipulated.
9.
In relation to the contention advanced by the petitioners relying
upon judgment and order dated 31st July, 2014 in WP(C)530/2011 it is stated
that the department has not taken any steps to make separate seniority list for
the Junior Engineers, Assistant Engineers and Executive Engineers. Initially,
the Recruitment Rules for the post of Superintending Engineer, notified on 28th
November, 2003 provided for promotion to the post of Superintending
Engineer from the post of Executive Engineers of Rural Development
Department having degree in engineering with seven years regular service in
the grade. However, in the year 2010 vide notification dated 24th December,
2010 the Rural Development Department framed recruitment rules for the post
of Superintending Engineer under proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India in supersession of the earlier Recruitment Rules of 2003. The 2010 rules
prescribe the criteria of 7 years regular service in the grade of Executive
Engineer in the Department with at least a degree in Civil Engineering from a
recognized university (Annexure-R/2).
10.
Thereafter, in the year 2015 department made recruitment rules of
Superintending Engineer under proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India in supersession of the earlier Recruitment Rules of 2010 in consultation
with the TPSC. In the said Recruitment Rules of 2015 the probation period of 2
(two) years was changed to 1 (one) year in respect of promoted candidates and
new provisions for departmental examinations were introduced. The
educational qualification criteria has not been changed and it was as stipulated
in the Recruitment Rules of 2010, i.e. degree in civil engineering or its
equivalent. The respondents contend that the present challenge has been made
to the aforesaid criteria after about 13 and 8 years by the writ petitioners though
the said qualification was prescribed even in the Recruitment Rules of 2010 and
later in 2015.
11.
All those writ petitioners have availed two promotions to the post
of Assistant Engineer and Executive Engineer as per prevailing rules. They
have been granted three numbers of financial upgradation in their service career
CAS/ACP/MACP scheme as per relevant ROP Rules. The respondent-State has
in the counter affidavit to the amended writ petition contended that by the
memorandum dated 5th February, 2024 promotion has been granted to the post
of Superintending Engineer on full duty charge to three engineers holding the
post of Executive Engineer (ad hoc), two from unreserved category and one
from the reserved category who are all senior to the petitioners. The vacancy
against the SC category has not been filled up as Er. Tapan Sarkar who belongs
to reserve SC category is a Mechanical engineer. The prevalent recruitment
rules prescribed degree in civil engineering or its equivalent.
12.
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Additional Government Advocate, has
referred to the corrigendum dated 20.09.2006 issued by the Rural Development
Department, Government of India to the notification dated 07.05.2005
whereunder Recruitment Rules regulating the method of recruitment to the post
of Junior Engineer, Grade-I & Grade-II under Rural Development Department
(Rural Engineering Wing) were framed with the nomenclature Junior Engineer
Grade-I & Grade-II of the RD Department (First Amendment) Recruitment
Rules, 2005 brought into effect from the date of publication in the official
gazette i.e. 18.05.2005. By the corrigendum dated 20.09.2006, Clause 7(A) and
(B) of the Recruitment Rules of 2005 which prescribe the educational and other
qualification required for direct recruitment inter alia;
“7. Educational and other qualification required for direct recruitment:
A) Degree in Engineering from a recognized university/institute or equivalent for Junior
Engineer, Grade-I
B) Diploma in Engineering from a recognized Institute or equivalent for Junior
Engineer, Grade-II”
were substituted in the following manner:
“7. Educational and other qualification required for direct recruitment:
A) Degree in Civil Engineering from a recognized University/Institute or equivalent
for Junior Engineer, Grade-I
B) Diploma in Civil Engineering from a recognized Institute or equivalent for Junior
Engineer, Grade-II.”
13.
By reference to the Recruitment Rules of Junior Engineer Grade-I
& Grade-II in the Rural Development Department as above, it is submitted that
the competent authority has made a conscious decision to lay down the
educational and other qualifications required for direct recruitment to the post
of Junior Engineer making it mandatory for the candidate to have a degree in
Civil Engineering for Junior Engineer Grade-I and Diploma in Civil
Engineering for Junior Engineer Grade-II. As such, recruitment from the entry
post of Junior Engineer in the Rural Development Department is now
permissible only to Degree holder and Diploma holder in Civil Engineering to
Grade-I or Grade-II, as the case may be.
14.
Petitioners have been granted two promotions from the grade of
Junior Engineer to Assistant Engineer and then to Executive Engineer though
they have a degree in Mechanical Engineering. However, the rule making
authority has in the aforesaid background consciously laid down additional
criteria of Degree in Civil Engineering with experience of 7 years of regular
service in the post of Executive Engineer for promotion to the higher post of
Superintending Engineer, which cannot be questioned on grounds of
arbitrariness or discrimination. It is submitted that no vested right was created
in favour of the petitioners since the 2010 Recruitment Rules also provide for
same educational criteria for degree in Civil Engineering which the petitioner
never thought it necessary to challenge. Therefore, no vested right for
promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer has accrued which are being
taken away by the impugned Recruitment Rules of 2015. The writ petition may,
therefore, be dismissed.
15.
We have considered the submission of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the materials placed on record in support and in
traverse of the Recruitment Rules of 2015 which prescribe the criteria of 7
years experience as an Executive Engineer and a degree in Civil Engineering
for promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer.
16.
The requirement of a Degree in Civil Engineering with 7 years of
experience as Executive Engineer on regular basis for promotion to the higher
post of Superintending Engineer has a rational nexus with the object sought to
be achieved. In PU Joshi & Ors Vs. Accountant General, Ahmedabad & Ors.,
reported in (2003) 2 SCC 632, the Apex Court has laid down that it is open and
within the competency of the State to change the rules of a service and alter or
amend and vary by addition/subtraction of the qualifications and eligibility
criteria and other conditions of the service including avenues of promotion
from time to time as an administrative exigency may need or necessitate. It has
been also held that there is no right in any employee of the State to claim that
rules governing conditions of his service should be forever the same as the one
when he entered service for all purposes and except for ensuring or
safeguarding rights or benefits already earned, acquired or accrued at a
particular point of time, a government servant has no right to challenge the
authority of the State to amend, alter and bring into force new rules relating to
even an existing service. The relevant paragraph 10 of the said decision is
extracted hereinbelow:
“10. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of both
parties. Questions relating to the constitution, pattern, nomenclature of posts,
cadres, categories, their creation/abolition, prescription of qualifications and
other conditions of service including avenues of promotions and criteria to be
fulfilled for such promotions pertain to the field of policy is within the
exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of the State, subject, of course, to the
limitations or restrictions envisaged in the Constitution of India and it is not
for the statutory tribunals, at any rate, to direct the Government to have a
particular method of recruitment or eligibility criteria or avenues of
promotion or impose itself by substituting its views for that of the State.
Similarly, it is well open and within the competency of the State to change
the rules relating to a service and alter or amend and vary by
addition/substraction the qualifications, eligibility criteria and other
conditions of service including avenues of promotion, from time to time, as
the administrative exigencies may need or necessitate. Likewise, the State by
appropriate rules is entitled to amalgamate departments or bifurcate
departments into more and constitute different categories of posts or cadres
by undertaking further classification, bifurcation or amalgamation as well as
reconstitute and restructure the pattern and cadres/categories of service, as
may be required from time to time by abolishing the existing cadres/posts and
creating new cadres/posts. There is no right in any employee of the State to
claim that rules governing conditions of his service should be forever the
same as the one when he entered service for all purposes and except for
ensuring or safeguarding rights or benefits already earned, acquired or
accrued at a particular point of time, a government servant has no right to
challenge the authority of the State to amend, alter and bring into force new
rules relating to even an existing service.”
17.
The wisdom of the rule making authority cannot be questioned. It
is also well settled that the service conditions can be altered during the career of
an employee unless some vested rights for promotion to the post of
Superintending Engineer has been taken away.
18.
In this context, it is necessary to refer to the ratio laid down by the
Apex Court in the case of PU Joshi & Ors Vs. Accountant General,
Ahmedabad & Ors., reported in (2003) 2 SCC 632. The petitioners are not in a
position to contend that by virtue of the Recruitment Rules of 2010 and 2015
subsequently, any vested right has been taken away. The department has
provided for promotional avenues to the post of Assistant Engineer and
Executive Engineer to the incumbents from all the three disciplines, i.e. Civil,
Mechanical and Electrical Engineering. However, for promotion to the higher
post of Superintending Engineer since the department is primarily engaged in
execution of infrastructure work, the rule making authority has, in its wisdom,
chosen to lay down the requisite eligibility criteria as 7 years experience in the
grade of Executive Engineer with an educational qualification of Bachelor of
Civil Engineering. Laying down educational qualification or prescribing an
additional educational qualification for promotion to higher post would be
permissible keeping in mind the object sought to be achieved which is to man
the higher post in the Rural Development Department with incumbents who are
qualified with degree in Civil Engineering with seven years experience, since
the nature of the works carried under the Rural Development Department
related to execution of infrastructure projects.
19.
The Apex Court has in a number of decisions held that though
equality is the very bulwark of the provisions of the Constitution, in service
jurisprudence, classifications are a matter of necessity. Judicial pronouncements
have sought to balance the equality principle with the principle of classification,
dependent upon the nexus for making the classification. Higher educational
qualifications have been repeatedly emphasized as an aspect which can give
exclusive promotion, earlier promotion or for that matter, an accelerated
promotion. A higher degree of qualification intrinsically would bring in certain
skills, though undoubtedly, that should be useful and have a nexus with the job
being performed. Similarly, the question whether the difference in educational
qualification is sufficient to give preferential treatment to one class of
candidates against another, is ordinarily left to the executive authorities to
decide as they have expertise in administrative matters. As to who should
examine this nexus, it has been left to the wisdom of the administrative
authorities, who are best equipped to do so.
20.
Therefore, if a classification has been made on the basis of the
educational qualification, i.e. degree in Civil Engineering for promotion from
the post of Executive Engineer to Superintending Engineer taking into
consideration that the department is primarily engaged in execution of
infrastructure works and since 2005 even recruitment to the entry level post of
Junior Engineer Grade-I and Grade-II have been confined to incumbents
holding a degree or diploma in Civil Engineering, the decision of the Executive
to prescribe a classification on the basis of the qualification of the incumbents
to the post of Executive Engineer for promotion to the higher post of
Superintending Engineer in the department cannot be said to be unreasonable or
having no nexus with the object sought to be achieved or being discriminatory.
21.
Moreover, on facts also none of the petitioners have requisite 7
years of experience counted from the date of grant of ad hoc promotion to the
post of Executive Engineer pursuant to the ad hoc promotion policy dated 22nd
June, 2021. Therefore, they also do not qualify in the first criteria of 7 years
experience as an Executive Engineer.
22.
Therefore, this court is of the considered view that the petitioners
have failed to make out a case for interference in the impugned Recruitment
Rules on the ground that they are arbitrary or discriminatory in nature.
23.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
lodh
DIPESH DEB
Date: 2024.10.07 15:24:15
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review