The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
28. 06.2020 to 06.07.2020. The petitioner was examined and treated at ILS Hospital, Agartala. During stay he was diagnosed with “Upper Gastrointestinal bleed, Etiology-Peptic ulcer disease, Comorbidities–DM2, HTN, Hypothyroidism”. The situation was so grave that there was no scope to go through the usual process of being referred by the standing medical board for treatment to any referral Hospital. [5] Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner is entitled to medical reimbursement for his treatment and the petitioner is covered by the Central Civil Services (Medical Attendance) Rules, 1944, which is applicable to the employees of the State Government. He has further contended that vide memo dated 09.08.2005 issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the Finance Department, it has been clarified, inter alia, that, when a Group-C/Group-D Government employee, himself/herself suffering from disease other than cancer is referred to Medical Institution/Hospital, the cost of treatment in that institution/hospital excluding the cost of journey is admissible for reimbursement. [6] Mr. Nath, learned counsel has further argued that vide memo dated 01.08.2007 issued by the Under Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura, in the Finance Department, it has been clarified that whenever a Group-C or D employee duly referred by the standin…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No. 728 of 2021
Sri Tapan Chakraborty
.....Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
The State of Tripura and 3 others
.....Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
20/06/2022
Heard Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The petitioner has prayed for medical reimbursement of a sum of
Rs.2,77,467/- spent by him on his own treatment which the Government has
refused to grant on the ground that the petitioner did not obtain prior referral
order from the Medical Board before taking treatment in the ILS Hospital,
Agartala.
[3]
The petitioner served in the post of Sub-Inspector of Police under
the respondents. On attaining the age of superannuation, the petitioner retired
from service on 28.02.2021. Before retirement, the petitioner was posted at
MTF Headquarter, AD Nagar, Agartala. In the morning of 28.06.2020,
suddenly the petitioner suffered severe chest pain, abdominal pain, difficulty in
breathing, etc and became unconscious. The petitioner had to be taken to
Tripura Medical College & Dr. BR Ambedkar Memorial Teaching Hospital. In
the evening, the petitioner’s condition became very serious. The petitioner
started blood vomiting. Immediate admission of the petitioner in ICU became
necessary. On that day ICU facility at TMC Hospital could not be made
available for the petitioner. For life saving treatment, the petitioner had to be
shifted to ILS Hospital, Agartala.
[4]
The petitioner availed treatment in ILS Hospital, Agartala from
28.06.2020 to 06.07.2020. The petitioner was examined and treated at ILS
Hospital, Agartala. During stay he was diagnosed with “Upper Gastrointestinal
bleed,
Etiology-Peptic
ulcer
disease,
Comorbidities–DM2,
HTN,
Hypothyroidism”. The situation was so grave that there was no scope to go
through the usual process of being referred by the standing medical board for
treatment to any referral Hospital.
[5]
Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that the petitioner is entitled to medical reimbursement for his
treatment and the petitioner is covered by the Central Civil Services (Medical
Attendance) Rules, 1944, which is applicable to the employees of the State
Government. He has further contended that vide memo dated 09.08.2005 issued
by the Joint Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the Finance Department,
it has been clarified, inter alia, that, when a Group-C/Group-D Government
employee, himself/herself suffering from disease other than cancer is referred
to Medical Institution/Hospital, the cost of treatment in that institution/hospital
excluding the cost of journey is admissible for reimbursement.
[6]
Mr. Nath, learned counsel has further argued that vide memo
dated 01.08.2007 issued by the Under Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura, in the
Finance Department, it has been clarified that whenever a Group-C or D
employee duly referred by the standing medical board to a particular institution
for medical treatment undertakes the medical treatment at some other
institution of his own volition, he/she shall be entitled to get medical
reimbursement which shall be limited to the treatment cost at the rates of the
referred medical institutions/hospitals including journey expenses.
[7]
Thereafter, the AIG of Police HQ. vide letter dated 09.10.2020
communicated to the Superintended of Police, MTF, Agartala in respect to the
medical reimbursement bill of Rs.2,77,467/- submitted by the petitioner in
connection with his treatment at ILS Hospital without referral certificate of the
State Medical Board. By that letter AIG of Police (HQR) returned the bill on
the ground that the petitioner availed treatment from ILS Hospital without any
prior referral of Standing Medical Board, Tripura.
[8]
Mr. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
strenuously argued that most arbitrarily and illegally the Asst. IG of Police
(HQR), by the impugned letter dated 09.10.2020 returned the medical
reimbursement bill of the petitioner on the ground of absence of referral from
the Standing Medical Board. But the Asst. IG of Police (HQR) did not
consider, that the condition of the petitioner was so serious, that there was no
scope to take referral from the Standing Medical Board. Return of the medical
bill of the petitioner was against numerous decisions of the Apex Court passed
in many writ petitions to the effect that everybody has the inherent right to self
preservation and for being referred; one cannot be expected to stand in queue,
when he or she is in need of immediate life saving treatment on emergency
basis. As there was no diagnostic procedure to check with Upper G.I. bleeding
of the petitioner at TMC Hospital and the petitioner was in need of proper
diagnosis on urgent basis, the referral of the petitioner by the State Referral
Board was a foregone conclusion and the situation was so compelling, that the
petitioner was not in a position to obtain such referral certificate. Keeping this
view, the medical reimbursement bill of the petitioner ought not to have been
rejected.
[9]
In the instant petition, the claim of the petitioner is of the medical
expenses which was incurred by him during his treatment at ILS Hospital,
Agartala to be more specific from 28.06.2020 to 06.07.2020 and the claim for
reimbursement of medical bills incurred in ILS Hospital, Agartala was turned
down by the respondents under communication dated 09.10.2020 assigning the
reason that the petitioner availed treatment from ILS Hospital without any prior
referral of Standing Medical Board, Tripura.
[10]
It is settled that in case of entitlement to medical reimbursement,
if the treatment is availed at elsewhere instead of referral hospital, medical
reimbursement bill will be required to be paid at the rate of the referral hospital.
It is also well settled position of law governing the entitlement of medical
reimbursement, that when life is at danger and time is very crucial factor for
preserving the life, one cannot be compelled to stand in the queue and wait for
his turn to avail the life saving treatment. After the petitioner became suddenly
ill, the health condition became so much critical and vulnerable; the petitioner
was required to be rushed to ILS Hospital, Agartala. The petitioner is entitled to
take such urgent steps in exercise of his right to life granted under Article-21 of
the Constitution of India.
[11]
In a decision of our own High Court reported in WP(C) No. 1479
of 2017, has held that so far medical reimbursement is concerned, reference
from the Standing Medical Board is not mandatory and without referral from
such board, if the treatment is genuinely taken from any referral centre, then,
MR Bill is to be sanctioned.
[12]
The prime consideration was to save his life which is
concomitant of the right to life as enshrined in Article-21 of the Constitution of
India. At that time services of whichever hospital was suited could be utilized
because emergency knows no law and procedure. When human life is put at
stake, in such situation the ultimate responsibility of the State could not be
washed off. When life of a person is in danger we cannot wait to follow the
official formalities and in case of emergency which in the instant case certainly
cannot be ruled out. What expected was to get immediate the best treatment
without going into details because in such emergent situation it cannot be
expected to think calmly for getting treatment at a particular hospital.
[13]
In the given facts and circumstances it was expected from the
government to volunteer and relax the rules if any and extend the best medical
facilities possible to the patient and there appears no reason for the respondents
to withhold the medical bills which were furnished b y the petitioner for his
treatment. In Harendra Ch. Das v. State of Tripura [WP(C) No. 208 of 2008,
the Gauhati High Court held “having regard to the above decision of the
Supreme Court in Surjit Singh, I find that the refusal by the State Authorities to
reimburse the costs of medical expenses on the ground of not being referred to
by the Medical Board cannot be sustained and accordingly, I am of the view
that the petitioner is entitled to obtain reimbursement of costs of medical
treatment, incurred by him for his medical treatment at Kolkata.”
[14]
The Apex Court in case of Surjit Singh v. State of Punjab and
others reported in (1996) 2 SCC 336 had in somewhat similar circumstances
made following observations:
It is otherwise important to bear in mind that self preservation of one's
life is the necessary concomitant of the right to life enshrined in Article
21 of the constitution of India, fundamental in nature, sacred, precious
and inviolable. The importance and validity of the duty and right to selfpreservation has a species in the right of self defence in criminal law.
Centuries ago thinkers of this Great Land conceived of such right and
recognized it. Attention can usefully be drawn to versus 17 18, 20, and
22 in Chapter 16 of the Garuda Purana (A Dialogue suggested between
the Divine and Garuda, the bird) in the words of the Divine:
Vinaa dehena kasyaapi canpurushaartho na vidyate Tasmaaddeham
dhanam rakshetpunyakar manni Saadhayet:
Without the body how can one obtain the objects of human life?
Therefore protecting the body which is the wealth, one should perform
the deeds of merit.
Rakshayetsarvadaatmaanamaatmaa sarvasya bhaajanam rakshane
yatnamaatishthejje vanbhaadraani pashyati:
One should protect his body which is responsible for everything. He,
who protects himself by all efforts, will see many auspicious occasions in
life.
Sharirarakshanopaayaah kriyante sarvadaa budhaih necchanti cha
punastyaagamapi kushthaadiroginah:
The wise always undertake the protective measures for the body. Even
the persons suffering from leprosy and other diseases do not wish to get
rid of the body.
Aatmaiva
yadi
naatmaanama
hitebhyo
nivaarayet
konsyo
hitakarastasmaa daatmaanam taarayishyati:
If one does not prevent what is un-pleasant to himself, who else will do?
it? Therefore one should do what is good to himself.
[15]
In the result, the petition stands succeeds and is hereby allowed.
The impugned letter dated 09.10.2020 issued by the Asst. Inspector General of
Police, HQr to Superintendent of Police (MTF), Agartala, Tripura is set aside.
The respondents are directed to pay the petitioner’s medical bills in question as
permissible within a period of one from the date of receipt of the copy of this
order. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review