Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.471 of 2021
Sri Surajit Chakraborty,
S/O Lt. Sukumar Chakraborty,
Resident of A.D. Nagar, Road no.1,
P.O. & P.S.- A.D. Nagar,
District- West Tripura
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Secretary, Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer
Affairs, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.S.- New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799010.
2. The Secretary
Director Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs, Govt. of Tripura,
New Capital Complex, P.S.- New Capital complex, Dist.- West
Tripura, Pin- 799010
3. Additional Secretary & Director
Director Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs, Govt. of Tripura,
Pandit Nehru complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, District- West Tripura
4. Sub-Divisional Magistrate
Sepahijala District, Sonamura, P.S.- Sonamura, Tripura.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Sarkar, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment & Order
:
04/08/2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D.
Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. along with Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents-State.
2.
Briefly stated, while the petitioner was serving as store in-charge
of Boxanagar Government Food Go-down , Sonamura from 19.03.2010 to
12.12.2011, the respondents through the DCM along with one Inspector of
Food, posted at Boxanagar, Sonamura inspected the said Food Go-down on
12.12.2011 to verify the stock of rice for the period from 19.03.2010 to
12.12.2011.
2.1.
It is the case of the respondents that during verification they found
shortage of 84341.640 Kgs of Gr. „A‟ raw rice i.e. shortage of 1.86%, which is
beyond the permissible limit of 0.5% during one year. The Food Inspector
through SDM has submitted the inspection report to the Director, Food, Civil
Supplies & Consumer affairs, Govt. of Tripura. On receipt of the said report, a
departmental proceeding was contemplated and show-cause notice was issued
upon the petitioner. Petitioner submitted reply. Being not satisfied with the
said reply, a disciplinary proceeding was initiated against the petitioner.
2.2.
The statement of article of charge framed against the petitioner by
the inquiring authority dated 25.04.2018 may be re-produced hereunder:“2. STATEMENT OF ARTICLE OF CHARGE FRAMED AGAINST
SRI
LITAN
DAS
(SIC.),
JR.
STORE
KEEPER
IS
REPRODUCED BELOW:
“That Sri Surajit Chakraborti while discharging the duties of
Go-down in-charge (Jr. Store-Keeper) of Boxanagar Govt. Food Godown , Sonamura Sub-Division under Sipahijala district during the
period from 19.03.2010 to 12.12.2011 exhibited gross dereliction of
duty, absolute carelessness, lack of integrity and devotion to duty
entrusted upon him by way of not maintaining the books of accounts
and other records properly thereof in the manner prescribed/instructed
by the competent Authority which is unbecoming on the part of a
government servant and amounts to gross misconduct. By resorting to
such activities with evil intention to derive personal benefit, said Sri
Chakraborty misappropriated 84341.640 kgs. Gr. „A‟ Raw Rice, money
value of which comes to Rs. 8,72,937/- (Rupees eight lacs seventy two
thousand nine hundred thirty seven) only.
These sorts of activities on the part of said Shri Surajit
Chakraborty, the then Go-down
in-charge (Jr. Store-Keeper) of
Boxanagar Govt. Good Go-down is unbecoming on the part of a Govt.
employee and violation of Rule-3 of Tripura Civil Services (Conduct)
Rules, 1988 and attract action thereof under central civil services
(Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965”.
The inquiring authority on consideration of the evidence and
materials introduced by the prosecution i.e. the department concerned came to
a finding that “the prosecution could not successfully bring home the charge
imputated against the AO, and as such, the same cannot be sustained.
Therefore the AO is found to be not guilty.”
2.3.
Thereafter, the disciplinary authority issued a memorandum dated
30.05.2018 (Annexure-IV to the writ petition) asking the petitioner “to Show
Cause as to why the value of shortage amounting to Rs. 8,72,937/- (Rupees
eight lakh seventy-two thousand nine hundred thirty-seven) only would not
be recovered from his salary including taking other actions as per law”
2.4.
The petitioner submitted reply to the said show cause notice.
However, the disciplinary authority under order dated 26.10.2018 (AnnexureV to the writ petition) imposed the following punishment:“8.
However, after considering all the facts and circumstances, I
take a considered and lenient view of the case and decide to impose a
minor penalty upon the A.O as provided in Rule 11 of the C.C.S (C.C.
& A) Rules, 1965 and order as follows:(i) Recovery of the amount of pecuniary loss to the tune of
Rs.6,38,277/- (Rupees six lakh thirty-eight thousand two hundred
seventy-seven) only by allowing 0.5% shortage (in place of
Rs.8,72,937/-), in monthly installment @1/3rd of his basic pay from
the month of December, 2018 payable in January, 2019 from said
Sri Surajit Chakraborty, Jr. Store Keeper. The monthly recovery
amount needs to be credited/ transferred to the Cash Credit
Accouunt like Sale Proceeds every month till full recovery.
(ii) Withholding of minimum 1(one) periodical future increment of Sri
Surajit Chakraborty, Jr. Store-Keeper that would fall due after
passing of this order for 1(one) year without cumulative effect.
9.
This order shall be recorded in the concerned Service Book of
A.O. in red Ink and his pay and allowances may be regularized as per
TSCS(RP) Rules, 2017, if any pending, as per procedure.
10.
However, this order will take effect after expiry of due appeal
time.”
2.5.
Against the said order dated 26.10.2018 of the disciplinary
authority, the petitioner preferred statutory appeal to the Secretary to the
Government of Tripura (appellate authority), Food, Civil Supplies &
Consumers Affairs Department. The appellate authority on consideration of
the findings of the disciplinary authority had upheld and affirmed the order of
penalty passed by the disciplinary authority.
2.6.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said impugned orders
of penalty passed by the disciplinary authority as well as the appellate
authority, the petitioner has approached this court by means of filing the
present petition under Article 226 of Constitution of India to invoke its power
of judicial review.
3.
Mr. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
drawn my attention to the report of the inquiring authority and has submitted
that the disciplinary authority without appreciating the findings of the
inquiring authority has arbitrarily imposed the penalty as stated here-in-above
which has also been affirmed by the appellate authority. Mr. Chowdhury,
learned senior counsel has submitted that no physical verification of the stock
was conducted by the investigating team which will be evident from the
evidence of PW1, PW2 and PW3.
4.
On the other hand, Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for
the respondents-State has submitted that the disciplinary authority rightly came
to a finding that there is shortage of 1.86% of raw rice during the tenure of
service of the petitioner as store in-charge of Boxanagar Government Food
Go-down . Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A has relied upon the statements made
at para-12 and 13 of the counter-affidavit filed by the respondents. Para-12 and
13 of the counter-affidavit may be re-produced here-in-below:-
“12. That, with respect to paragraphs 14 to 15, I say that, as per
physical verification report of Boxonagar Government Food Godown for the period from 19-03-2010 to 12-12-2011, shortage of
84,341.640 kgs. Gr. A Raw Rice was detected. Detection of said
shortage was also affirmed, since 5(five) Nos Stock Adjustment
Vouchers (SAVs) had been issued by the petitioner, being the StoreKeeper (Store-in-Charge) of the go- down for adjustment of shortage
of 84,341.640 kgs. Gr. A Rice. The percentage of above said
shortage was found to be 1.86%, considering the total transacted
quantity of 4,27,081.425 kgs. Gr. A Raw Rice during the material
period, which is beyond the permissible limit of 0.5%. The standing
guideline of the Department is that "in normal case shortage not
exceeding 0.5% may only be taken into consideration if the
particular consignment remains in store for a period not less than
one year".
Moreover, a specific comment of the Verifying Officer is
found in the respective verification report that proper records in
respect of Bin Card, Bin Card Register etc. had not been maintained
by the petitioner. It is pertinent to mention that maintaining of Bin
Card for stack wise stock of Rice is mandatory on the part of the
Store Keeper (Store In-Charge), since the Bin Card indicates the
History of the Stock of rice of particular stack i.e. mainly by which,
storing period of stock of rice can be ascertained. Herein, as per
verification report of the Boxonagar Government Food Go-down
for the period from 19-03-2010 to 12-12-2011, it appears that the
petitioner did not maintain BIN Card, which indicates his ill
intension and violation of the order of the Director, FCS & CA
(Respondent No.-03). It is to be mentioned that based on Bin Card
report, period of storage of rice in the go-down can be ascertained
and accordingly, if any shortage detected, it can be justified as per
guideline, "in normal case shortage not exceeding 0.5% may only be
taken into consideration if the particular consignment remain in
store for a period not less than one year". Since, the petitioner did
not maintain BIN CARD hence, he cannot get relief from the penalty
of recovery of Rs. 6,38,277/- imposed by the Disciplinary Authority
for abnormal shortage of rice.
It is pertinent to mention that to avoid damage of rice for long
time storage in the go-down, a Departmental guideline vide
Memorandum No.F.5-2(2)-DF/2005 dated. April 23,2005 is in force,
wherein, it says that FIFO (First in First out) system should be
followed in the go-down so that no old stock remains lying in the godowns for a long time. In the instant case, if the petitioner had
followed the above said FIFO system, there would not have been
abnormal shortage of rice in the go-down during his tenure.
Moreover, the Verifying Officer recorded his comments in the
said SAVS that it is 'Abnormal shortage, hence not justifiable' during
the verification. Hence, Order dated 26.10.2018 as passed by the
Disciplinary Authority against the petitioner is not illegal and
arbitrarily, rather, it is based on certain grounds of facts and
documents. The shortage of PDS rice worth of Rs.8,72,937/- is
attributed to the misconduct of the petitioner, which cannot be
denied under any normal circumstances. Despite that, the
Disciplinary Authority in considering and allowing 0.5% shortage,
reduced the recovery amount of pecuniary loss and ordered recovery
of Rs.6,38,277/- (Rupees six lakh thirty-eight thousand two hundred
seventy-seven) only in place of Rs.8,72,937/-.
13. That, with respect to paragraph 16, I say that, the statement of
the petitioner made in this para 16 that the periodical verification of
the Boxonagar Government Food Go-down had not been made for
several long years is not true. As per practice, the physical
verification of go-down is being conducted sequence wise. In the
instant case, physical verification of Boxonagar Government Food
Go-down was conducted for the period from 19-03-2010 to 12-122011 that is 24 to say that earlier verification of the said go-down
was completed up to the day immediately preceding the period
considered by the instant verification. Further, during the physical
verification, basically, quantity of shortage of commodities is being
calculated in following manner;
Taking into
Taking
account the
into
Opening
account
balance of the total
commoditie quantity
s as it stand
of
as per
commodit
respective
ies
Stock
received
register on
as per
the date the respectiv
verification
e stock
is being
register/
undertaken.
Tally
Book
during
the
period of
verificati
on.
Taking into
account the
total
quantity of
stock of
commoditie
s as it stand
as per
respective
stock
register
Column
(1+2)
Taking into
Balance
account the
quantity as
total quantity it stand as
despatched/d
per
elivered
respective
during the
stock
period of
register
verification (Column (3as per
4)
respective
stock
register/Tall
y Book
In the above manner, after ascertaining the balance, quantity
of respective commodities as per stock register, physical stock of
respective commodities is being cent percent weighted under the
supervision of respective verifying officer. Thereafter, both the
balance quantity of commodities (StockBook balance and physical
balance) are being compared and accordingly, shortage or excess
quantity, as the case may be, is being ascertained.
Herein, as per verification report, abnormal shortage was
detected to the tune of 84,341.640 kgs. Rice worth Rs.8,72,937/-.
But, as per Departmental guideline, after considering and allowing
0.5% admissible shortage on the total transacted quantity during the
material period, penalty amount was reduced to Rs.6,38,277/- from
Rs.8,72,937/- upon Sri Surajit Chakrabartty, Jr. Storekeeper (Store
In-Charge), which was a reasonable and justified decision of the
Disciplinary Authority (Director, Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer
Affairs, Respondent No.-3).
Apart from the above, Food Go-downs are generally roofed
with GCI sheet and it cannot be the reason for abnormal shortage as
detected during the physical verification. As per standing practice,
on receiving report from the storekeeper of go-down in any go-down
related matter, the same is being 16/20 attended by the respective
authority and necessary measures are also taken accordingly.
Moreover, Vide Memorandum No.F.5- 2(2)-DF/2005 dated. April
23,2005, it says that FIFO (First in First out) system should be
followed in the go-down so that no old stock remains lying in the godowns for a long time. In the instant case, if the petitioner had
followed the above said FIFO system, there would not have been
such quantity of abnormal shortage of rice in the go-down during
his tenure. Therefore, pleas as stated by the petitioner in this Para
are only lame excuse of the petitioner to hide his guilt. In the instant
case, shortage is found to be 1.86%, which was beyond permissible
limit of 0.5% and could not be justified. It is a clear case of
misappropriation of the government stock by the petitioner.”
5.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions and
statements made by the respondents in the counter-affidavit as quoted here-inabove.
6.
At the outset, I should say, it is settled proposition of law that the
scope of exercising the power of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is very limited. This court can only interfere with the
findings of the disciplinary authority as well as the appellate authority, if the
penalty imposed upon the delinquent is based on no evidence or there is
procedural violation causing substantial prejudice to the delinquent-employee,
or there is violation of principles of natural justice.
7.
On careful consideration of the findings of the inquiring authority
and the grounds for disagreement as surfaced in the memorandum dated
30.05.2018, issued by the disciplinary authority, in my opinion, the penalty
imposed by the respondents to the petitioner is based on no evidence and the
findings of the disciplinary authority as well as the appellate authority suffer
from serious infirmities and perversity.
8.
It transpires that PW1, Krishnadhan Sarkar categorically stated
that during the tenure of service of the petitioner in the said Go-down , i.e.,
w.e.f. 19.03.2010 to 12.12.2011, he had inspected the said Go-down
on
various occasions and during his inspection he could not detect any shortage of
rice.
PW2, Pankaj Chakraborty, SDM Sonamura is only a forwarding
authority and he had only forwarded the report, which was submitted by PW1.
PW3, Tapash Kumar Sinha in his cross-examination during the
course of proceeding had admitted that physical verification was meant to
verify the stock of the said Go-down and not of documents. He also could not
state if the verification was a periodical one or it was any special verification.
PW3 also could not recollect if during the verification the labourers had raised
any bill as their wages for weighing and handling. There is no evidence that
PW3 had interacted with the petitioner. PW3 has further categorically stated
that he could not recollect on the basis of which documents he had tallied the
physical stock of rice.
9.
The inquiring authority came to a finding that from Exbt.
S/1(series) whereby the verification officer (PW3) in his 22 points inspection
report had submitted that the receipt and dispatch tally book, gunny bag
register were properly maintained. It was also found that abnormal shortage
was detected from the SAVs. According to Exbt. S/2(series), it is relevant to
mention here that in absence of bin card/ bin card register, it is hardly possible
to ascertain the actual percentage of shortage occur in a particular Go-down
during the particular period. The inquiring authority further found that even the
stock book register was not furnished during the proceeding.
10.
I do not find any reason as to why the prosecution did not produce
the stock book. Further, neither bin card nor bin card register was produced
before the inquiring authority during the course of proceeding. This amounts to
suppression of material facts, which, it produced, would have been a probable
cause to hold the charged officer, i.e., the petitioner herein guilty of
committing the alleged misconduct. I find no error in the findings of the
inquiring authority that from the statement of PW3, it appears that inspection
was of the stock and not of the documents which is sufficient to dislodge the
charge framed against the petitioner. More importantly, I find that PW1 has
categorically stated in his statement that no shortage was detected during his
inspection for the relevant period.
11.
Thus, I am in agreement with the findings of the inquiring
authority that the prosecution had not taken any endeavour to produce the bin
card/ bin card register to substantiate the allegations imputed against the AO.
On consideration of the findings of the disciplinary authority as surfaced in the
memorandum dated 30.05.2018, I find that the disciplinary authority only went
upon the report of the inspection committee without considering the materials
as discussed in the preceding paragraphs. Both the disciplinary authority and
the appellate authority arbitrarily came to a finding that the petitioner was
responsible for shortage of 1.86% of raw rice from the Go-down.
12.
In the light of above, I have no other alternative but to arrive at a
finding that the present case is a case based on no evidence and the findings of
the disciplinary authority as well as appellate authority suffer from serious
infirmities and perversity and accordingly, the writ petition stands allowed.
In the result, the penalty imposed by the disciplinary authority
and upheld by the appellate authority is hereby set aside and quashed.
JUDGE
SAIKA
T KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.08.08
16:30:40 +05'30'
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review