Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.477 of 2021
Sri Sumendra Debbarma,
S/o-Late Subindra Debbarma,
R/o-Suparibagan, Krishnanagar, Near Dasarath Bhavan,
P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799001, Aged about-42 years.
[[
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The District and Sessions Judge,
Dhalai Judicial District, P.O. & P.S.-Ambassa, District-Dhalai Tripura,
Pin-799289.
2. The Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Dhalai Judicial District, P.O. & P.S.-Kamalpur, District-Dhalai Tripura,
Pin-799285.
3. The Sub Judicial Magistrate,
Kamalpur, Dhalai Judicial District, P.O.& P.S.- Kamalpur, DistrictDhalai, Tripura, Pin-799285.
4. Sri Hrishikesh Chakraborty,
at present posted as Judge, Family Court, P.O. & P.S.-Khowai, DistrictKhowai Tripura, Pin-799202.
5. Sri Subhasish Sharma Roy,
at present posted as District and Sessions Judge, Ambassa, P.O. & P.O.Ambassa, District-Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799289.
6. Smt. Arpita Chakma,
presently serving as Office Superintendent (Group-B, Non Gazetted),
notice to be served through District & Sessions Judge, Khowai Judicial
District, P.O. + P.S.-Khowai, District- Khowai, Pin-799202.
7. Sri Arup Chakma,
presently serving as Office Superintendent (Group-B, Non Gazetted),
notice to be served through District & Sessions Judge, Unakoti Judicial
District, Kailashahar, P.O. + P.S.- Kailashahar, District-Unakoti Tripura,
Pin-799277.
8. Sri Joy Datta Chakma,
presently serving as Office Superintendent (Group-B, Non Gazetted),
notice to be served through District & Sessions Judge, Sepahijala
Judicial District, Sonamura, P.O.+ P.S.-Sonamura, District- Sepahijala
Tripura, Pin-799181.
9. Sri Sandipan Chakma,
presently serving as Office Superintendent (Group-B, Non Gazetted),
notice to be served through District & Sessions Judge, North Tripura
Judicial District, Dharmanagar, P.O.+ P.S.- Dharmanagar, District-North
Tripura, Pin-799250.
10. Sri Pradip Debbarma,
presently serving as Office Superintendent (Group-B, Non Gazetted),
notice to be served through District & Sessions Judge, West Tripura
Judicial District, Agartala, P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin-799003.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, GA
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
:
25.09.2023
of judgment & order
[[
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned GA assisted by Mr. S.
Saha, learned counsel appearing for respondent nos.1 to 5.
2.
By way of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the grading recorded in his Performance Appraisal Report(for
short, P.A.R.) as „Good‟ affecting his next promotion in the year 2020 and
prayed for setting aside the communication dated 31.03.2021 and the
communication dated 19.02.2021.
3.
The case of the petitioner, in a nutshell, is that while he was
discharging his duties under the District Judiciary, he was graded „Very
Good‟ for the reporting year 2018 and 2019. However, for the assessment
year 2020, he was graded „Outstanding‟. It is the further case of the
petitioner that the District & Sessions Judge, Dhalai Judicial District,
Ambassa vide communication dated 19.02.2021 intimidated the petitioner
that he was graded as „Outstanding‟ in the P.A.R. by the Accepting
Authority for the reporting year 2020(Annexure 4 to the writ petition).
However, vide another communication dated 31.03.2021, the same District
& Sessions Judge, Dhalai Judicial District had communicated the petitioner
that he was inadvertently communicated mentioning his grading as
„Outstanding‟ and that mistake had occurred due to the clerical error which
was written as „Outstanding‟ instead of „Good‟. The relevant extract of the
communication may be reproduced hereunder:
“Therefore, the grading “Outstanding” of your P.A.R./A.C.R.
for the reporting year, 2020 as communicated to you vide
No.118, dated 19-02-2021 will not effect and your original
grading awarded by the Accepting Authority for the reporting
year, 2020 is “Good”.”
4.
Being aggrieved of such grading as “Good”, the petitioner has
approached this Court urging this Court to set aside or quash the grading as
“Good” in exercise of its discretionary and extraordinary jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
5.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that the assessment and grading of the petitioner as “Good”
amounts to downgrading of the P.A.R./A.C.R. of the petitioner from
“Outstanding”. Next submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner is
that the petitioner was not given reasonable opportunity to submit
representation against such communication. Learned counsel for the
petitioner has emphatically submitted that it is the requirement of law that
the authority concerned should state in the communication that the
employee concerned, the petitioner herein should submit representation.
According to Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner, due to such
grading, the petitioner‟s promotion to the next higher post had been
affected and his juniors, the private respondents herein had been promoted.
During promotion it was considered that “Outstanding” would be given 10
marks, “Very Good” would be given 8 marks and “Good” would be given 6
marks. The petitioner at the time of consideration of promotion, secured 6
marks since he was graded as “Good” for the reporting year 2020.
6.
Opposing the submissions of learned counsel for the petitioner,
learned GA appearing for respondent nos.1 to 5 has drawn my attention to
the statements made in the counter affidavit and contended that the
petitioner has suppressed the actual facts. During the reporting year 2020,
the conduct of the petitioner forced the Reporting Officer, Reviewing
Officer and the Accepting Officer to assess his performance as “Good”. In
support of his submission, learned GA has referred para 14 of the counter
affidavit, which is reproduced here-in-below:
“14. That, with respect to paragraph-12, I say, that, the
averments made in para 12 of the Writ Petition are all false,
fabricated and frivolous. The petitioner has most illegally
referred name of some staff members in the Writ Petition who
were graded “Outstanding” in the P.A.R. for the reporting year
2020 claiming that those staff members had enjoyed more leave
than the petitioner in the year 2020. But the fact remains that
those staff members have been serving at Kamalpur station for
long time and also with the satisfaction of their higher
authorities.
The petitioner most illegally made the statement on oath
before the Hon’ble High Court that the petitioner availed only
5(five) Casual Leaves out of 12(twelve) casual leaves in the
reporting year and he also availed only 5(five) earned leaves in
the said reporting year.
But it is revealed from the office records that petitioner Sri
Sumendra Debbarma joined in the establishment of the District &
Sessions Judge, Dhalai Judicial District at Ambassa on
14.01.2020
being
Subsequently,
transferred
petitioner
Sri
from
Longtharai
Sumendra
Valley.
Debbarma
was
transferred to Kamalpur on 17.03.2020 from Ambassa and the
petitioner joined at Kamalpur on 18.03.2020 i.e. the petitioner
could perform his official duty in the establishment of District &
Sessions Judge, Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa only for 63
days and during such period, the petitioner enjoyed full days
Casual Leave on 20.01.2020, 29.02.2020 and 13.03.2020 and he
also enjoyed half days’ Casual leave on 12.02.2020, 28.02.2020
and 10.03.2020.
Record also shows that on 31.01.2020 petitioner, Sri
Sumendra Debbarma was absent from his official duty but he did
not file any prayer seeking any kind of leave for that day till the
end of the year 2020.
On the other hand, it is revealed from the office records
available with the respondent No.2 that during the reporting
year, petitioner availed 8(eight) Casual Leaves at Kamalpur
station on 19.05.2020, 20.05.2020, 21.05.2020, 03.06.2020,
06.07.2020, 01.07.2020, 21.12.2020 and 22.12.2020.
From the office record available with the Sub-Divisional
Judicial Magistrate, Longtharai-Valley, Dhalai Judicial District,
it is revealed that petitioner also enjoyed casual leave on
08.01.2020 during his posting at Longtharai-Valley.
So, from the official records it is revealed that the petitioner
most illegally enjoyed total 13(thirteen) and half days Casual
Leaves in the year 2020 though he was entitled to enjoy only
12(twelve) days Casual Leave in a year.
Apart from this, petitioner also enjoyed 3(three) days Earned
Leaves on 04.07.2020, 07.12.2020 and 17.12.2020 and filed an
application to his authority on 07.01.2021 for granting such
earned leaves whereas, as per rule a Government employee
cannot enjoy earned leave without prior approval of the
sanctioning authority.
Petitioner enjoyed 04(four) days Casual Leaves on 19.05.2020
to 21.05.2020 and 03.06.2020 but filed application to the
sanctioning authority on 25.06.2020.
Petitioner enjoyed casual leave on 01.12.2020 but filed
application on 03.12.2020.
Petitioner also enjoyed 02(two) days casual leaves on
21.12.2020 and 22.12.2020 but filed application to the
sanctioning authority on 07.01.2021.
So, from the conduct of the petitioner, it is very much evident
that he was always trying to enjoy more leaves unauthorised for
which the petitioner intentionally filed application on 7th January,
2021 for granting casual leaves for two days of the previous year
i.e. on 21.12.2020 and 22.12.2020.”
7.
This Court in exercise of its discretionary power of judicial
review will not revisit the assessments made by the Reporting Authority,
Reviewing Authority and the Accepting Authority. The Court will be
confined only to examine whether the grading, whatever it may be, has
been communicated to the employee concerned.
8.
In the instant case, it is found that the first communication
mentioning the P.A.R./A.C.R. of the petitioner as “Outstanding” was made
inadvertently which was rectified later on by issuance of a communication
dated 31.03.2021 from the Office of the District & Sessions Judge, Dhalai
Judicial District, Ambassa. On receipt of this communication, the petitioner
did not submit any representation and directly has approached this Court
challenging the assessment and grading as well.
9.
The grievance of the petitioner is that he was not given
opportunity to submit representation. It is difficult to digest this argument
of learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that the communication must
state that the employee concerned should submit representation. The settled
legal position is that every entry in the P.A.R./A.C.R. must be
communicated to the employee concerned within a reasonable period,
irrespective of the fact that he was graded as “Outstanding, Very Good,
Good or Poor”. After receipt of such communication, it is the right of the
petitioner to submit representation.
10.
In the opinion of this Court, there is no requirement of law that
such communication must state that the employee concerned should submit
representation. It is the wisdom of the employee concerned whether he
would submit representation or not. To re-iterate, the legal position is very
clear in respect of the fact that the assessment and grading thereof,
whatever it may be, must be communicated to the public servant.
11.
In this regard, I may profitably refer to the case of Dev Dutt vs.
Union of India and Ors. reported in (2008)8 SCC 725 where the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court held thus:[SCC p.733, paras 17 and 18]
“17. In our opinion, every entry in the ACR of a public servant
must be communicated to him within a reasonable period,
whether it is a poor, fair, average, good or very good entry. This
is because non-communication of such an entry may adversely
affect the employee in two ways : (1) had the entry been
communicated to him he would know about the assessment of his
work and conduct by his superiors, which would enable him to
improve his work in future; (2) he would have an opportunity of
making a representation against the entry if he feels it is
unjustified, and pray for its upgradation. Hence, noncommunication of an entry is arbitrary, and it has been held by
the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Maneka Gandhi
v. Union of India [(1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597] that
arbitrariness violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
18. Thus, it is not only when there is a benchmark but in all cases
that an entry (whether it is poor, fair, average, good or very
good) must be communicated to a public servant, otherwise there
is violation of the principle of fairness, which is the soul of
natural
justice.
Even
an
outstanding
entry
should
be
communicated since that would boost the morale of the employee
and make him work harder.”
12.
Added to it, I do not find any ground to form an opinion that
the assessment made by the Reporting Officer, Reviewing Officer and the
Accepting Officer suffers from any perversity since the petitioner was
found to be absent on so many days on this particular assessment year.
13.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has placed
reliance upon a decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Union of India and
Anr. Vs. Major Bahadur Singh, (2006) 1 SCC 368 to substantiate his
submission that before making final assessment, the respondents had to
follow 3 stages, that is, there should be counselling, necessary advice and
instruction.
14.
I have perused the cited decision which is related to an army
officer where there are Standing Instructions of the Government of India
which prescribe procedures of making assessment and ultimate grading
thereof. The present case before this Court is not the case under any Army
Act or Rules where certain instructions are found laying down as such kind
of procedures.
15.
In the context of the case, the service of the petitioner being
regulated by CCS(CC & A) Rules, he is only entitled to be communicated
with the assessment and the grading thereof, which was duly communicated
to him.
16.
For the reasons stated above, I do not find any element of
violation of the principles of natural justice qua any infirmity in the grading
of the petitioner since it is already held that the law as regards the
communication of the P.A.R./A.C.R. does not postulate that it must contain
the statement that the concerned public servant should submit
representation.
In the result, the present writ petition is devoid of merit and
accordingly stands dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review