Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.55 of 2025
Sri Suman Nandi (27),
Son of Sri Amal Nandi,
Resident of Vill- Uttar Haripur,
P.O.-Matai, P.S.- Belonia,
District-South Tripura,
PIN-799155.
…. Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. Union of India,
Represented by its Secretary,
Having his/her office at Ministry of Home Affairs,
North Block, Central Secretariat,
New Delhi-110001.
2. Staff Selection Commission (SSC),
Represented by his/her Chairman,
Having his office at Staff Selection Commission,
Block No.-12, 4th Floor, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
3. Director General of Border Security Force (B.S.F.),
Having his/her office at, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
4. Director General of Central Industrial Security
(CISF),
Having his/her office at, Block No.13, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
Force
5. Director General of Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF),
Having his/her office at, Block No.-1, C.G.O. Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003, India.
6. Director General of Sashastra Seems Bal (SSB),
Having his/her office at, East Block-V,
RK Puram, New Delhi, PIN-110066.
7. Director General of Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP),
Having his/her office at, Block 02,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
8. Director General of Assam Rifles,
Having his/her office at, Shillong-793011,
East Khast Hills, Meghalaya, India.
…….Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. Rumela Guha, Adv.
Mr. Mrinmoy Debnath, Adv.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
Date of Hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order
Whether fit for Reporting
:
18.02.2026
:
:
26.02.2026
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the
following relief/reliefs:(i)
To admit the instant writ petition;
(ii)
Issue Rule NISI.
(iii) ISSUE RULE, calling upon the Respondents No.1
to 9 and each one of them to show cause as to why a
Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall
not be issued, directing and/or mandating them to
admit the Petitioner as a Constable (GD) in any of the
force of Respondents No.3 to 9.
(iv) ISSUE RULE, calling upon the Respondents No.1
to 9 and each one of them, to show cause as to why a
Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall
not be issued, to set aside and/or quash the “FORM
NO.01 FOR DETAILED MEDICAL EXAMINATION OF
CT/GD EXAM-2024 MEMORANDUM UNFIT”, dated
04.10.2024, (Annexure 6).
(v)
ISSUE RULE, calling upon the Respondents No.1
to 9 and each one of them, to show cause as to why a
Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall
not be issued, to set aside and/or quash the “FORM
NO OF CONSTABLE (GD) EXAM-2024 REVIEW MEDICAL
EXAMINATION REPORT”, conducted on 14.10.2024
(Annexure 7).
(vi)
ISSUE RULE, calling upon the Respondents No.1
to 9 and each one of them, to show cause as to why a
Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall
not be issued, mandating all the Respondents to admit
and/or accept medical report of the Petitioner, dated
17.10.2024, issued by AGMC & GBP Hospital
(Annexure-9),
as
the
final
finding
of
his
Ophthalmological Test.
(vii) To constitute a medical board under the
direction and scrutiny of this Hon’ble Court to verify
and/or conduct examination of the medical fitness of
the Petitioner for the post of Constable (GD) as
advertised in (Annexure-1) by the Respondents no.1
to 9.
(viii) ISSUE RULE, calling upon the Respondents No.1
to 9 and each one of them, to show cause as to why a
Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall
not be issued, directing them to call for all the
relevant records and/or documents in connection to
instant matter.
(ix)
Cost of and incidental to this proceeding may be
directed to borne by Respondents No.1 to 9.
(x)
Any other Order(s), Direction(s), may be given
as the Hon’ble High Court deem fit and proper for the
benefit of conscionable justice.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Ms. Rumela Guha, and
Learned Counsel, Mr. Mrinmoy Debnath, appearing on behalf of
the petitioner and also heard Learned Dy.S.G.I, Mr. Bidyut
Majumder appearing on behalf of the respondents Union of
India.
03.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel, Ms. R.
Guha appearing for the petitioner drawn the attention of the
Court that the petitioner being an Indian citizen against an
advertisement dated 24.11.2023 issued by respondent No.2
applied for the post of Constables (GD) in Central Armed Police
Forces (CAPFs), SSF, and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles
Examination, 2024 under respondent Nos.3 to 8 [Annexure1].
04.
As the petitioner had all the requisite qualification
credential and as such he applied for the said post under the
respondents
and
submitted
all
the
relevant
documents
[Annexure-2 and Annexure-3]. Thereafter, the petitioner
appeared in the written examination which was conducted on
21.02.2024 having the Roll No.5601001172. The written
examination according to Learned Counsel was conducted
through computer in Multiple Choice questions and the same
was called as Computer Based Examination (CBE) and in the
written examination the petitioner obtained Final Score 81.63.
05.
According to Learned Counsel as the petitioner
passed his written examination so he was issued admit card for
his Physical Standard Test (PST)/Physical Efficiency Test (PET)
and DV/DME which was conducted on 30.09.2024 at AR West
Tripura, 18 Assam Rifle, Agartala, West Tripura. The petitioner
qualified and passed in his PET & PST examination and after
verification of his all the documents the petitioner was
forwarded for his Medical Test, wherein the petitioner was
diagnosed having eye defect namely „Squint and not able to
open right eye alone‟. Thereafter, the petitioner was declared
as “unfit” in his first Medical Examination. The result of the first
Medical Examination was declared on 04.10.2024. After that on
14.10.2024, a review Medical Examination was conducted upon
the petitioner wherein he was again declared as “unfit” and
during the Review Medical Examination „no squint‟ was found in
the eye of the petitioner but he was again declared “unfit” due
to “Clinically examined by ophthalmologist and opined that No
Squint observed. But candidate is not able to open the right
eye. PTOSIS (Rt.) eye present incomplete ptosis & it can cause
problem in fire arm handling”. According to Learned Counsel,
the review medical examination was conducted by Border
Security Force Office of The Inspector General Frontier Head
Quarter BSF, Salbagan, Agartala, Dist.-West (Tripura), PIN799012. The petitioner got his consolidated mark details of
SSC, which was 81.63 [Annexure-4].
The petitioner also
relied upon the Admit Card [Annexure-5] and the copy of the
Medical Examination report dated 04.10.2024 [Annexure-6]
and the Review Medical Examination report dated 14.10.2024
[Annexure-7].
06.
It was the further case of the petitioner that he was
called for Review Medical Examination which was conducted
on 14.10.2024 and during such Review Medical Examination,
the petitioner was called upon at 2.30 pm to see a doctor, who
checked his eyes and declared him
“fit” and therefore
underlined the said final opinion listed at clause 6(c) of his
Review Medical Examination Report. Thereafter the petitioner
was asked to wait for collection of his fitness certificate and at
about 7.30 – 8 pm on that day the petitioner was again called
upon when he was declared “unfit” which was beyond the
knowledge of the petitioner.
07.
It was further submitted that the reasons for
declaring him as unfit in his Review Medical Examination
Report dated 14.10.2024 was contrary to the Rule 6 of the
Guidelines for Recruitment Medical Examination in Central
Armed Police Forces and Assam Rifles, Revised Guidelines as
on May, 2015. For the sake of convenience the Grounds for
Rejection as mentioned in the aforesaid Rule in enumerated
herein below:General Grounds For Rejection”:1. Indication of any chronic disease like tuberculosis,
syphilis, or other venereal disease, rheumatoid/any
type of arthritis, hypertension etc.
2. Bronchial or laryngeal disease like Asthma, chronic
Tonsillitis & Adenoids etc.
3. Indication of Valvular or other disease of heart.
4. Generally impaired constitution, so as to impede
efficient discharge of training/duties.
5. Low standard vision.
6. Any degree of squint.
7. Otitis media.
8. Deafness, any degree of impaired hearing
9. Stammering, as specified later
10.Loss off decay of teeth resulting in reduction of
dental points below 14.
11.Wearing of half or complete artificial denture.
12.Contraction or deformity of chest and deformity of
joints.
13.Abnormal curvature of spine (exact nature, e.g.,
kyphosis, scoliosis, lordosis etc. to be specified).
14.Abnormal Gait.
15.Endocrinal disorders.
16.Mental or nervous instability-evidence of nervous
instability
17.Defective intelligence
18.Any type of hernia.
19.Chronic skin disease like vitiligo, Leprosy, SLE,
Eczema, Chronic extensive Fungal dermatitis.
20.Any congenital abnormality, so as to impede
efficient discharge of training/duties.
21.Anal fistula, haemorrhoids and other anorectal
diseases as specified later.
22.Deformity of feet like Flat foot, Club foot, Plantar
warts etc.
23.Epilepsy (history or evidence; history as per
Annexure-II).
24.Nystagmus/Progressive Pterygium.
25.Large hydrocele, even if curable by operation.
Small hydrocele (if operated upon & no bad scar is
left after operation, may be accepted).
26.Cubitus varus/Valgus.
27.Polydactyl of hands/feet.
28.Undescended testis, atrophic testis, marked
varicocele, testicular swellings.
29.Varicose veins. The diagnosis of varicose vein
should be made on the basis of dilatation and
tortuosity of veins and after confirmation of
incompetecy
of
Sapheno-femoral
junction/Sapheno-popliteal junction or perfarators
by relevant clinical tests. Only prominence of veins
should not be criteria for rejection. Cases of
Varicose veins, even if operated, are not to be
accepted
because
basic
defect
remains
unchanged.”
08.
Learned Counsel at the time of hearing further
submitted that there was no „special investigation / test /
examination‟ conducted upon the petitioner by any Specialist
Doctor during his Review Medical Examination conducted on
14.10.2024. According to Learned Counsel appearing for the
petitioner, only a doctor blinked one torch light upon both of
his eyes for a moment and declared him fit and thereafter the
petitioner was asked to wait outside to obtain his fitness
certificate.
9.
According to the petitioner, the Review Medical
Examination did not comply Rule 7 Note (c) of the Guidelines
for Recruitment Medical Examination in Central Armed Police
Forces and Assam Rifles, Revised Guidelines published on May
2015 issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Home
Affairs (Police Division-II).
For the sake of convenience the
said guideline is also mentioned herein below:“Rule 7 Note (c):- In doubtful cases candidates
may be referred to a specialist for examination and
opinion which may include X-Ray examination or
any other special investigation/test/examination.”
10.
It was further submitted that the guidelines were
not followed by the authority and the petitioner was not
presented before any board and neither the Review Medical
Report shows formation of any board on record. It was also
submitted that in [Annexure-7] the portion of name and seal
of „Member-II (RME Board)‟ and name and signature of „Coopted Member (RME Board)‟ was left blank in the Review
Medical
Examination
Report
and
the
Review
Medical
Examination was conducted by 02 members violating the rules
and signed by another additional member whose name or
stamp has not been properly indicated. The 4th Member i.e. coopted member (RME Board) did not sign the Review Medical
Examination Report and his column was left out.
11.
It was further submitted by Learned Counsel for the
petitioner that before the first Medical Examination of CT/GD
Examination conducted on 04.10.2024, the petitioner visited
the Belonia Sub-Divisional Hospital Road 1 nos Tilla Belonia for
his eye checkup on 19.09.2024 and during his eye checkup on
19.09.2024, Dr. Amit Sen, MS Eye, declared that the petitioner
is having "color vision normal” after examining eyes of the
petitioner. Thereafter, on 04.10.2024, his Medical Examination
by the SSC was conducted wherein he was declared “unfit” and
thereafter again on 14.10.2024, a Review Medical Examination
was conducted upon the petitioner wherein he was again
declared
“unfit”
petitioner
went
illegally.
After
that
for
eye
checkup
his
on
17.10.2024,
to
the
the
Agartala
Government Medical College & GBP Hospital, Government of
Tripura,
wherein
Department
of
it
was
opined
Ophthalmology
by
as
the
well
Medical
Officer,
as
Deepak
Dr.
Debbarma, Asstt. Professor, Department of Ophthalmology
that the petitioner had “No Squint” “No Ptosis” and “PE is
Medically Fit Regarding His eyes” and relied upon the Medical
Report dated 19.09.2024 issued by Belonia Sub-Divisional
Hospital Road 1 nos Tilla Belonia [Annexure-8] and the report
of
AGMC
&
GBP
Hospital,
Agartala
dated
17.10.2024
[Annexure-9]. Thereafter, he submitted the said report to the
authority of the BSF but no response was given.
12.
It
was
further
submitted
by
Learned
Counsel
appearing for the petitioner that the petitioner was all along
medically fit but due to some unknown reasons he has been
declared “unfit” by the respondent-authority for which he has
been deprived of his legitimate right and finally under
compelling circumstances filed this writ petition before this
Court. The respondent-authority on receipt of notice have
appeared through Learned Dy.SGI and filed counter-affidavit
denying the allegation of the petitioner in his writ petition but
admitted that the petitioner appeared in the exam but
submitted
that
as
the
petitioner
could
not
qualify
the
Medical/Review Medical Test so he was rightly disqualified by
the Review Medical Board and as such he is not entitled to
employment in absence of medical report as “fit”. The
respondents also relied upon some documents in support of
their contention and submitted the same along with their
counter-affidavit before the Court and submitted the Review
Medical
Examination
report
[Annexure-R/6]
and
finally
Learned Dy.SGI submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to
get any relief in this case.
13.
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner relied upon one citation of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court of India in His Holiness Kesavananda
Bharati Sripadagalvaru Vs. State of Kerala and Another
reported in (1973) 4 SCC 225 wherein in Para No.897,
Hon‟ble the Apex Court observed as under:“897. The contention that essential features are
not amendable under Article 368 as it stood before
the Constitution 24th Amendment Act is not only
reading negative restrictions on the express power
of amendment but is also putting the clock back.
One of the salutary principles of construction of a
statute is to be found in R. v. Burah. : 3 AC 889. It
was a case to determine whether the prescribed
limitations of a colonial legislature had been
exceeded. The Judicial Committee said that a duty
must be performed by looking to the terms of the
instrument by which affirmatively legislative
powers are created, and by which, negatively, they
are restricted. "If what has been done is legislation
within the general scope of the affirmative words
which give power, and if it violates no express
condition or restriction by which that power is
limited, it is not for any court of justice to enquire
further
or
to
enlarge
constructively
those
conditions and restrictions". The maxim Expressum
facit cessare tacitum was similarly applied in Webb
v. Outrim: 1907 AC 89. The theory of implied and
inherent limitations can be best described as a
subtle attempt to annihilate the affirmative power
of amendment. Lord Halsbury in Fielding v. Thoms :
1896 AC 600, said that if the legislature had full
power to make laws it was difficult to see how the
power was taken away. The power is always
sufficient for the purpose. Lord Dunedin in
Whiteman v. Sadler : 1910 AC 514, said "express
enactment shuts at shuts the door to further
implication".
Reliance was further placed upon another citation of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Competition Commission of
India Vs. Steel Authority of India Limited reported in
(2010) 10 SCC 744 wherein in Para No.60, the Hon‟ble Apex
Court observed as under:“60. Expressum facit cessare tacitum - express
mention of one thing implies the exclusion of other.
(Expression precludes implication). This doctrine
has been applied by this Court in various cases to
enunciate the principle that expression precludes
implication.
(Union
of
India
v.
Tulsiram
Patel:(1985) 3 SCC 398.) It is always safer to apply
plain and primary rule of construction. The first and
primary rule of construction is that intention of the
legislature is to be found in the words used by the
legislature itself. The true or legal meaning of an
enactment is derived by construing the meaning of
the word in the light of the discernible purpose or
object which comprehends the mischief and its
remedy to which an enactment is directed. (State
of H.P. v. Kailash Chand Mahajan :1992 Supp (2)
SCC 351 and Padma Sundara Rao v. State of
T.N.:(2002) 3 SCC 533).”
Again reliance was placed upon another citation of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Satyavir Singh and Others Vs.
Union of India and Others reported in (1985) 4 SCC 252
wherein in Para No.22, the Hon‟ble Apex Court observed as
Under:“(22) The governing words of the second proviso to
clause (2) of Article 311, namely, “this clause shall
not apply”, are mandatory and not directory and
are in the nature of a constitutional prohibitory
injunction restraining the disciplinary authority
from holding an inquiry under Article 311(2) or
from giving any kind of opportunity to the
concerned civil servant in a case where one of the
three clauses of the second proviso becomes
applicable. There is thus no scope for introducing
into the second proviso some kind of inquiry or
opportunity to show cause by a process of
inference or implication. The maxim expressum
facit cessare tacitum (“when there is express
mention of certain things, then anything not
mentioned is excluded”) applies to the case. This
well-known maxim is a principle of logic and
common sense and not merely a technical rule of
construction as pointed out in B. Shankara Rao
Badami v. State of Mysore: (1969) 3 SCR 1.”
Referring the aforesaid citations, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner submitted that the maxim expressum facit
cessare tacitum that is when there is express mention of
certain things then anything not mentioned is excluded.
Meaning
guidelines
for
the
thereby
since
there
was
no
specific
respondent-authority
to
exclude
the
candidature of the petitioner on the grounds stated in the
report and as such in view of the observation of the Review
Medical Board which is explicitly excluded from the rules there
was no scope to disqualify the petitioner by the respondentauthority for the post he applied for which he was already been
qualified and furthermore the report of Medical Officer, Belonia
Sub-Divisional Hospital [Annexure-8] and the report of the
AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala [Annexure-9] are totally
contrary to the report of Review Medical Board and as such
there was no scope/reason to disqualify the petitioner from the
post which he applied for and urged for allowing the writ
petition.
The petitioner also further relied upon another
citation of the Hon‟ble High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan
Bench at Jaipur in Ramkala Varma Vs. Union of India and
Others
numbered
as
Civil
Writ
Petition
No.17749/2024
wherein in Para Nos.18 and 19, Hon‟ble the Rajasthan High
Court observed as under:“18. Ergo, in précis it can be noted that the
petitioner’s case appears to be resilient; that the
medical rejection and rejection by the respondents
is based on speculative presumptions and does not
meet the threshold of legal justification; that the
independent medical opinion, which supports the
petitioner’s medical fitness, is not rebutted, and
the prior declaration of medical fitness in an earlier
BSF recruitment process further reinforces the
petitioner’s entitlement to consideration; that the
petitioner has also demonstrated that she is not
disqualified by the relevant medical guidelines or
by any other factor that would preclude her from
being considered for this post, especially given her
current noncombat role in the CAPFs.
19. In light of the above considerations and
upon a careful review of the facts, legal principles,
and judicial precedents, it is hereby directed that
the petitioner is entitled to be considered for the
post of Constable (GD) in the Central Armed Police
Forces (CAPFs) under the recruitment process
initiated in the year 2024. The petitioner’s medical
disqualification,
based
on
an
unfounded
assumption regarding her birthmark, is found to be
arbitrary, lacking in sufficient medical or logical
reasoning.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
the case of the present petitioner squarely covers by the said
judgment.
14.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused
the writ petition along with the documents submitted
by
the
respondent-authority. However, at the time of hearing and also
on perusal of the documents relied upon by the parties
specifically the medical examination report of the Review
Medical Board [Annexure-7] as relied upon by the petitioner
and also the report submitted by the respondent-authority of
the same petitioner by the Review Medical Board [AnnexureR/6] appears to be does not match with each other.
15.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner relying upon
Annexure-7 submitted that this report was furnished to the
petitioner by the authority on the same day i.e. on 14.10.2024
wherein it appears only 03 Medical Officers have given their
signatures but on perusal of Annexure-R/6 submitted by the
respondent-authority it appears that, that was signed by 04
Medical Officers thus there is a clear discrepancy apparent on
the face of those documents and also on bare perusal of the
said documents it was also not clear to the Court whether the
Medical Officers who have given their signatures on the body of
the said documents are any Medical Specialists or not. Learned
Dy.SGI in this regard also failed to satisfy the Court by
showing any convincing reply in regard to discrepancies.
Further, at the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner submitted that since on 17.10.2024, the petitioner
consulted the Specialist Doctor at AGMC & GBP Hospital,
Agartala so it would be better if the matter is referred to the
Standing Medical Board of Tripura for Medical Examination of
eyes of the petitioner by Specialist Doctors of Eye Department
so as to address the grievance of the petitioner.
16.
To that Learned Dy.SGI fairly submitted that he
shall have no objection if the matter is referred to Standing
Medical Board of AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala for opinion
and it was further submitted by Learned Dy.S.G.I. that if the
Standing Medical Board of AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala
opines that the petitioner is “fit” to discharge the duties for the
post for which he has applied for in that case the respondent authority shall have no objection to abide by the said report of
the Standing Medical Board of AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala.
17.
In view of the above, this present writ petition is
disposed of interfering with the report of Review Medical Board
(Annexure-7 and Annexure-R/6) with a direction to the
Medical Superintendent, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala to
constitute a Medical Board for examination of eyes of the
petitioner of this writ petition by a group of 04 Doctors out of
which 03 Doctors should be Eye Specialists of the respective
Eye Department of the said Medical College and thereafter on
examination shall furnish the copy of the report to the
authority-representative of the respondent-Union of India and
also to the petitioner with a further copy to the Registrar
(Judicial), High Court of Tripura for keeping the same with the
record.
It is further made clear that at the time of Medical
Examination, the representative of the Union of India and the
petitioner himself shall remain present before the Standing
Medical Board and also shall produce the relevant documents
i.e. the relevant medical reports relied upon by both the
parties. If the Standing Medical Board opines that, the
petitioner is physically “fit” of his eyes to discharge his duties
for the post he has applied for then in that case, the
respondent-authority thereafter, after receipt of the report
shall issue offer of appointment within a period of next 02(two)
months in favour of the petitioner provided the petitioner
fulfills the other criterias.
In case of disobedience liberty is given to the
petitioner to approach to the Court in due course of time.
The Medical Superintendent, AGMC & GBP Hospital,
Agartala shall complete the process within a period of 15
(fifteen) days from the date of receipt of the copy of this order
from the Registry of the High Court of Tripura and on
completion of the process shall supply the reports as indicated
above to the parties.
Registry be asked to forward a copy of this order to
the Medical Superintendent, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala for
information and compliance.
Supply a copy of this order to Learned Counsel for
the petitioner for information and compliance. Also supply a
copy of this order to Learned Dy.SGI, Mr. B. Majumder for
information and compliance.
Both the parties shall accordingly approach to the
Medical Superintendent, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala for
further proceeding.
With
these
observations,
this
writ
petition
is
disposed of.
Pending application/s, if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA
DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2026.02.27
12:35:05 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review