Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A(J) No.43 of 2022
Sri Suman Miah,
son of Md. Dulal Miah,
resident of village: Dharmapur, Pachapukur (Feni),
P.S. Feni, District: Feni, Bangladesh
---- Appellant(s)
-VERSUSThe State of Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Majumder, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing
:
21.11.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
23.11.2023
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
(Amarnath Goud,J.)
Heard Mr. P. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
and Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the State.
02.
This appeal arises out of the judgment and order of conviction and
sentence dated 21.12.2018 in Case No. Sessions Trial 15 (Type-I) of 2018
passed by Sessions Judge, Belonia, South Tripura wherein the Sessions
Judge had convicted the accused-appellant for the offence punishable under
Section 147 IPC for 6(six) months R.I., under Section 447 IPC for 2 months
RI, and 3 years and fine under Section 27(1) of Arms Act. The appellant is
sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 10(ten) years for commission
of offence punishable under Section 307 read with Section 149 of the IPC.
Villagers handed over accused Suman Miah to BSF.
03.
The case of the prosecution in brief is that on 08.03.2017 at around 8
p.m. a group of 10-12 miscreants wearing uniform of Bangladesh Police
being armed with fire arms went to Muslim Para wherein eleven Indian family
reside on the other side of Indo-Bangladesh Border fencing, but within Indian
territory. The miscreants started ransacking and looting household articles,
but the villagers showed their courage and resisted the miscreants.
Consequently,
the
miscreants
opened
fire
from
their
fire
arms
indiscriminately. Subsequntly, Kabir Ahmed, Hanif, Selim Uddin, Layla Aktar,
Abdul Mannan and Delwar Hossein sustained injuries. The miscreants fled
away but one of the miscreants was caught by the villagers. His name is
Suman Miah. Being informed, BSF Jawans and police party arrived at the
P.O. and it was detected that the dead body of another miscreants was lying.
His name is Md. Mir Nowsad Ali.
04.
On the basis of the said complaint, police took up the investigation
and on completion of investigation, police filed charge sheet against the
accused appellant of offence punishable under Section 398 & 307 IPC and
Section 27 of Arms Act and Section 3 of Passport Act, 2000.
05.
During trial, the prosecution to establish the charge had adduced as
many as 22 (twenty two) witnesses and also exhibited series of documents
including P.M. Report (marked as Exhibit-9), Inquest Report ( Exbt.1, 1/1,
1/2, 1/3, 1/4), Seizure List (Exhibit.5 and 6), Injury Report (marked as
Exhibit 11-16) and Forensic Report (Exbt.10) etc. and the accused person
was also examined under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. and after hearing the
argument the Learned Sessions Judge, South Tripura, Belonia convicted and
sentenced the appellant by the judgment dated 21.12.2018. From the date of
judgment the present appellant is in custody in the KST, Bishalgarh. Hence,
this appeal before this court.
06.
Mr. P. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the evidence as adduced by the prosecution do not constitute
any offence punishable under Section 147/447/307 of IPC and 27(1) of the
Arms Act and prima facie charge could have been framed against the
appellant and as such, the order of conviction and sentence passed by the
Learned Court below is liable to be set aside. Mr. Majumder admitted that the
appellant is no doubt a Bangladeshi National.
07.
During the course of his submission, Mr. P. Majumder, to strengthen
his points has given reliance on the PW-5, PW-8 and PW-21 and also the
injury report marked as (Exbt.11). PW-5 Selim Uddin specifically stated in his
cross-examination that he did not personally see the present appellant in the
gang of Bangladeshi National and the PW-5 only heard from the local people
that Suman Miah was apprehended by people of that area and it is further
stated that PW-8 Md. Hanif in his cross-examination specifically stated that
the present appellant was in civil dress and the present appellant did not
have any fire arm. In this context, this court feel necessary to go through the
seizure list dated 09.03.2017, the description of exhibits submitted by the
TSFSL
dated
30.05.2017(Exbt.10),
the
injury
report
dated
09.03.2017(Exbt.11), injury report dated 09.03.2017(Exbt.12), injury report
dated 09.03.2017 (Exbt.13) and the injury report dated 09.03.2017 (Exbt.14)
where it is mentioned as follows:
*
*
*
*
Description of the Seized Articles:
1. 01 (one) 7.62x39 MM ASSAULT RIFLE, M56-BDF-06-A46827, Butt No.862
2. BDF live ammunition 7.62x39 MM- 04 Nos.
3. Empty cartridge 12 Bore CHEDDITE – 06 (six) Nos.
4. Sling – 01 (one) nos.
5. Mobile phone (Watson) – 01(one) nos. (Broken condition)
6. 01 (one) Nos Sim Card (Rubi)
*
*
*
*
Parcel No.
No. of seals & Impression
11(eleven)
“SDPO BELONIA”
*
*
Description of exhibits
01(One)
7.62x39mm
assault rifle bearing body
number
“M56-BOF-06A46827”
marked
as
exhibit “A” 05 (five)
7.62x39
mm
live
cartridges
marked
as
exhibit “B’’ by IO which
are re-marked as B-1 to
B-5 in Laboratory, 06(six)
fired 12 bore cartridge
cases marked as exhibit
“C” by IO which are remarked as “C-1” to “C-6”
in laboratory.
*
*
Cause of Injury or of Poisoning as stated by the Patient
Result of Examination by the Medical Officer
Case and Symptoms— H/O alleged rubber bullet injury on 08/03/2017
Approx 8.00 pm
Chest
No h/O LoC
CVS
No h/o vomiting
CNS
O/E, pt-conscious, a fertile
P/A
PR= 84 bpm
BP120/80 mmHg
Rx,
Treated conservatively & discharged after giving first aid.
*
*
*
*
Cause of Injury or of Poisoning as stated by the Patient
Result of Examination by the Medical Officer
Case and Symptoms— H/O alleged rubber bullet injury on 08/03/2017
Approx 8.00 pm
Chest
No h/O LoC
CVS
No h/o vomiting
CNS
O/E, pt-conscious, a fertile
P/A
PR= 88 bpm
Rx,
Treated conservatively & discharged after giving first aid.
*
*
*
*
Cause of Injury or of Poisoning as stated by the Patient
Result of Examination by the Medical Officer
Case and Symptoms— H/O alleged rubber bullet injury on 08/03/2017
Approx 8.00 pm
Chest
No h/O LoC
CVS
No h/o vomiting
CNS
O/E, pt-conscious, a fertile
P/A
PR= 72 bpm
BP130/80 mmHg
Rx,
Treated conservatively & discharged after giving first aid.
*
*
*
*
Cause of Injury or of Poisoning as stated by the Patient
Result of Examination by the Medical Officer
Case and Symptoms— H/O alleged rubber bullet injury on 08/03/2017
Approx 8.00 pm
Chest
No h/O LoC
CVS
No h/o vomiting
CNS
O/E, pt-conscious, a fertile
P/A
PR= 84 bpm
BP124/84 mmHg
Rx,
Treated conservatively & discharged after giving first aid.
*
*
*
*
Cause of Injury or of Poisoning as stated by the Patient
Result of Examination by the Medical Officer
Case and Symptoms— H/O alleged rubber bullet injury on 08/03/2017
Approx 8.00 pm
Chest
No h/O LoC
CVS
No h/o vomiting
CNS
O/E, pt-conscious, a fertile
P/A
PR= 80 bpm
BP110/70 mmHg
Rx,
Treated conservatively & discharged after giving first aid.
*
*
*
*
He has further stated that PW-21, Ajitesh Pal, attached to the
office of the Scientific Officer-cum-Assistant Chemical Examiner, Narsingarh,
Agartala, specifically stated in his deposition as follows:
“After examination, I opined that Exbt.A was not possible to be opined
whether recently any bullet was fired or not because of absence of
nitrate/nitrite. The reason of non availability of nitrate/nitrite in Exbt.A was
either delay in examining the rifle and in the meantime not handling the rifle
properly, consequently the nitrate would be washed out from the barrel.”
08.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. P.P. has supported
the findings of the learned trial court while convicting the accused. He has
also submitted that if the evidences of prosecution witnesses are read
conjointly, it could safely be presumed that the convict appellant had
committed the alleged offence.
09.
From the evidence on record of the prosecution produced before the
Learned Court below, it appears that a group of 10/12 Bangladeshi
miscreants wearing uniform of Bangladesh Police attacked Muslim Para
situated on the other side of the Indo-Bangladesh border fencing, i.e within
the Indian Territory to loot household articles and kidnap some villagers and
they also entered into the hut of PW-8, Md. Hanif, PW-11 Md. Saddam
Hossein and started looting household articles. Those miscreants caught the
husband of Nachima Begum, PW-15. At that time PW-15 and other villagers
started resisting the miscreants and managed to apprehend accused Suman
Miah, one of the members of the group of miscreants and other members of
the group of miscreants fled away. Later on, the dead body of one of the
miscreants was found lying. There was no evidence on record how that
miscreant died.
The accused being a Bangladeshi National being a member of
unlawful assembly consisting of 10/12 persons committed criminal trespass
by entering into the house of some of the witnesses of the prosecution
particularly into the house of PWs-8, 11 and 15 with an intention to commit
dacoity and kidnapping of Indian villagers. Not only that the unlawful
assembly being resisted by the villagers opened fire arms and for that PWs-2
& 5 sustained bullet injury and their injury reports have been marked as
Exhibit-11 and Exhibit-13. In addition to that, some other villagers namely
Layla Aktar, Md. Hanif and Abdul Mannan also sustained bullet injuries and
their injury reports have been marked as Exhibit-12, Exhibit-14 and Exhibit15 before the Learned Trial Court below. The intention of the miscreants was
to cause death of the villagers but fortunately the injured persons survived.
From the evidence on record further it appears that the accused Suman Miah
being a member of unlawful assembly of 10/12 persons shared common
object and had the intention of causing death of the villagers. Thus, it
appears that the prosecution has been able to prove the charges levelled
against the appellant/convict in this case.
10.
However, the court below being convinced by the arguments of the
learned Public Prosecutor convicted Suman Miah and is sentenced to suffer
rigorous imprisonment for six months for commission of offence punishable
under Section-147 of IPC. He is also sentenced to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for two months for commission of offence punishable under
Section 447 of IPC. The convict is sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment
for three years and to pay fine of Rs.2000/- (Rupees two thousand) only, in
default, to suffer rigorous imprisonment for three months for commission of
offence punishable under Section 27(1) of Arms Act. The convict is further
sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for ten years for commission of
offence punishable under Section 307 read with Section 149 of IPC.
11.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and scrutinized the
records and evidences as well as the findings passed by the court below, this
court is of the considered opinion that the accused person a Bangladeshi has
not explained in 313 examination before the concerned court in his defence
as to why he was present at the crime scene and also did not explained
specifically to say that he is innocent.
12.
Hence, this court has no hesitation to draw adverse inference against
the appellant to say that he had an intention along with other persons and
with a common intention to commit a crime. They have committed the crime
as proved by the prosecution.
13.
It is the settled principle of law that, if an offence is committed by
any member of an unlawful assembly in prosecution of the common object of
that assembly, or such as the members of that assembly knew to be likely to
be committed in prosecution of that object, every person who, at the time of
committing of that offence, is a member of the same assembly, is guilty of
that offence.
14.
Thus, this court finds that there is ground to prove the case of the
appellant and as such the judgment passed by the court below is affirmed
and it requires no interference.
Accordingly, this appeal stands dismissed.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
Date: 2023.11.27 21:00:47 -08'00'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review