Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl.Rev.P.No.42 of 2022
Sri Suman Bhowmik
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
……….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Majumder, Adv.
Ms. S. Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
:
18.01.2023
Date of hearing
of Judgment & Order
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Judgment & Order(Oral)
Ms. S. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing on instruction of Mr.
P. Majumder, learned counsel for the petitioner as well as Mr. S. Ghosh,
learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the State.
2.
This is a petition under Section 397 read with Section 401 of
Cr.P.C. for setting aside the judgment dated 06.07.2022 passed in Criminal
Appeal No.22 of 2019 along with Criminal Appeal No.25 of 2019 passed by the
Additional Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, Tripura affirming
the order of conviction and sentence dated 29.06.2019 passed by the Assistant
Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, Tripura in Case No.ST 12
(GT/U) of 2017 (Type-II) sentenced the petitioner to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for five years for commission of offence punishable under Section
366 of the IPC and also sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- only in default
to suffer further rigorous imprisonment for six months.
3.
The genesis of the case is that on 15.11.2017 at about 21/11 hrs.
one Uttam Kumar Das, son of Sri Jagadish Chandra Das of Mirza, Takhirai Para,
P.S. Kakraban has appeared at Kakraban P.S. and lodged a written complaint
to the fact that on 14.11.2016(morning) at about 9:00 hrs. the daughter of the
complainant aged about 14 years left her friend’s house at Mirza Bazar to
collect examination note but till 14:00 hrs., she did not return and accordingly,
on 14.11.2016 (night) at about 21:30 hrs. the complainant received information
from Cell phone No.3259013168 that his daughter is well and subsequently the
said mobile number was switched off and based on the said facts, the
complainant suspected that his daughter was forcibly kidnapped by unknown
person. Thereafter, a case was registered at Kakraban P.S. vide Kakraban P.S.
Case No.2016 KKB 088 dated 15.11.2016 under Section 363 of the IPC against
the accused persons.
4.
During the course of investigation and after collecting the
statement of the witnesses during investigation and considering the other
circumstantial evidence, the I.O. found prima facie charge against the accused
persons namely, Suman Bhowmik, Mithun Das, Paltu Debnath, Binoy Debnath
and Biplab Debnath under Section 366A read with Section 34 of the IPC and
submitted the charge sheet against the accused persons vide Charge Sheet
No.08 of 2017 dated 28.02.2017. Thereafter, after hearing the prosecution as
well as the defence and also on perusal of the papers submitted by the
Investigating Officer, the Trial Court framed the charge against the accused
petitioner for the offence punishable under Section 366 of the IPC to which the
accused petitioner pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
5.
Thereafter,
the
prosecution
has
examined
as
many
as
14(fourteen) witnesses and they were cross-examined and exhibited some of
the documents and thereafter, the accused petitioner was examined under
Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. and he declined to adduce any defence evidence in
support on his behalf.
6.
The Trial Court after hearing the argument of both the sides, the
Assistant Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, Tripura in Case
No.ST 12(GT/U) of 2017 (Type-II) sentenced the petitioner to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for five years for commission of offence punishable under Section
366 of the IPC and also sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- only in default
to suffer further rigorous imprisonment for six months on 29.06.2019.
7.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order of sentence dated
29.06.2019 passed by the Assistant Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur, Tripura in Case No.ST 12 (GT/U) of 2017 (Type-II) as mentioned
above, the petitioner preferred a Criminal Appeal vide No.Criminal Appeal
No.25 of 2019 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur, Tripura on the following grounds :
i) the Learned Trial Court has failed to appreciate the
evidences in accordance with law.
ii) the findings of the Learned Trial Court are passed on mere
surmise and conjecture.
iii) the finding of the Learned Trial Court are perverse and
against the evidence on record or based on no evidence.
iv) the Learned Trial Court has erred both in law and evidence
in appreciating the evidence on record.
v) the order passed by the Learned Trial Court is highly illegal,
perverse and liable to be set aside.
8.
After hearing the arguments of both sides, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Gomati, Udaipur, Tripura by his
judgment dated 06.07.2022 dismissed the Criminal Appeal No.25 of 2019 and
affirmed the order of sentence dated 29.06.2019 passed by the learned
Assistant Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, Tripura.
9.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order dated 06.07.2022
dismissed the Criminal Appeal No.25 of 2019 preferred by the petitioner and
affirmed the order of sentence dated 29.06.2019 passed by the learned
Assistant Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, Tripura. Hence, this
Criminal Revision Petition.
10.
Ms. S. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
has submitted that the learned Additional Sessions Judge should have set aside
the order of sentence passed by the learned Trial Court as the learned Trial
Court has failed to apply its judicious mind in appreciation of evidence on
record and accordingly, arrived at a wrong conclusion and as such, the
judgment dated 06.07.2022 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, Tripura in respect of the present petitioner is
liable to be set aside. She has further stated that the appellate court has very
carefully illustrate the objection and ingredients of offence under Section 366 of
the IPC in the judgment dated 06.07.2022 and accordingly, the same is
mentioned in para-24(1), 24(2), 24(11) which reads as under :
24. Section 366 of the IPC :
“366. Kidnapping, abducting or inducing woman to compel her
marriage, etc. whoever kidnaps or abducts any woman with
intent that she may be compelled, or knowing it to be likely
that she will be compelled, to marry any person against her
will, or in order that she may be forced or seduced to illicit
intercourse, or knowing it to be likely that she will be forced
or seduced to illicit intercourse, shall be punished with
imprisonment of either description for a term which may
extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine; and
whoever by means of criminal intimidation as defined in this
Code or of abuse of authority or any other method of
compulsion, induces any woman to go from any place with
intent that she may be or knowing that it is likely that she will
be, forced or seduced to illicit intercourse with another person
shall be punishable as aforesaid.”
24(1)
Section
clearly
stated
that
whoever
kidnaps/abducts any woman with the intent that she may be
compelled or knowing that she will be compelled, to either get
her married or forced/seduced to have illicit intercourse, they
shall be punished with imprisonment of up to ten year and
fine. The aforesaid Sections requires the prosecution not only
to lead evidence to prove kidnapping simpliciter, but also
required them to lead evidence to portray the above
mentioned specific intention of the kidnapper. Therefore, in
order to constitute an offence under Section 366, besides
proving the factum of the abduction, the prosecution has to
prove that the said abduction was for one of the purposes
mentioned in the section.
24(2) The Hon’ble Supreme Court in a case in Kavita
Chandrakant Lakhani versus State of Maharashtra reported in
2018 6 SCC 664 held in para-10 that “……….in order to
constitute the offence of abduction a person must be carried
off illegality by force or deception, that it, to compel a person
by force or deceitful means to induce to go from one place to
another. The intention of the accused is the basis and the
gravamen of an offence under this Section. The volition, the
intention land the conduct of the accused to determine the
offence, they can only bear upon the intent with which the
accused kidnapped or abducted the woman and the intent of
the accused is the vital question for determination in each
case. Once the necessary intent of the accused is established,
the offence is complete, whether or not the accused
succeeded in effecting his purpose, and whether or not the
woman consented the marriage or the illicit intercourse.
24(11) Apart from this, to constitute an offence under Section
366 IPC, it is necessary for the prosecution to prove that the
accused induced the complainant woman or compelled by
force to go from any place, that such inducement was by
deceitful means, that such abduction took place with the
intent that the complainant may be seduced to illicit
intercourse and that the accused knew it to be likely that the
complainant may be seduced to illicit intercourse as a result of
her abduction. Mere abduction does not bring an accused
under the ambit of this penal section. So far as charge under
Section 366 IPC is concerned, mere finding that a woman was
abducted is not enough, it must further be proved that the
accused abducted the woman with the intent that she may be
compelled or knowing it to be likely that she will be compelled
to marry any person or in order that she may be forced or
seduced to illicit intercourse or knowing it to be likely that she
will be forced or seduced to illicit intercourse. Unless the
prosecution proves that the abduction is for the purpose
mentioned in Section 366 of the IPC, the court cannot hold the
accused guilty and punish him under Section 366 IPC.”
11.
But in the present case, according to Ms. Debbarma, learned
counsel as per deposition of the PW-12 before the learned Trial Court that she
was boarded a flight from Agartala to Kolkata along and from Kolkata Airport
she was taken to Nabadwip in the friend’s house of the petitioner and on the
subsequent date, she was taken to another friends of the petitioner and was
taken to a fare of Rashmela and the petitioner has taken to her to a nearby
temple and forcibly put bungles on her hand. Petitionre has used force against
her wish to put verbally on her forehead and bangles on her hands. She
admitted that at that relevant point of time she could not resist to such act of
the petitioner and thereafter, the petitioner took her to his friends house and
subsequently, his maternal uncle house at Nabadwip.
12.
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has submitted that in the cross
examination, PW-12 has specifically stated in her deposition that :
“I entered into the Airport to prove my identity. I have shown
the Aadhar Card in the gate of the Airport, I was also in the
Airport when the Airport staff was conducting the security
check. On that point of time I also never disclosed any fact
about my kidnapped.”
It has been further stated by PW-12 in her cross-examination
that:
“After the exit from Kolkata Airport I have disclosed the fact
to any police personnel. I have also never called to my parents
when I was in the Airport. I have my grandmother’s house in
West Bengal. I have never visited my grandmother’s house in
West Bengal.”
13.
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has stoutly submitted that PW-12
in her cross-examination has clearly admitted that she do not have any kind of
love affairs with the present petitioner for last one year and she has also
admitted that she has seen some SMS to the present petitioner from her
mother’s mobile phone. In the cross-examination she has stated as under :
“I have not informed the name of the persons namely Paltu,
Binoy, Biplab and Mithun who forcibly took me to Agartala
Airport from Mirja School Chowmuhani and boarded me a
flight at Agartala from Agartala Airport for Kolkata wither to
the police or before any Court. I have stated to the Court and
also before the IO that Suman Bhowmik forcibly put
vermillion and bangles upon my forehead and my hand and I
could not resist to such act of Suman and identified me as his
wife to everybody.”
14.
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel has submitted that as per
deposition of PW-1 indicated that PW-12 used to talk over mobile phone
frequently with the appellant No.2, Mithun Das and it is also evident from PW12 that she was received by appellant No.2, Mithun Das at Kolkata Airport and
taken to Nabadwip in the friends house of appellant No.2. From the conduct
and relation of PW-12 with the present petitioner it is very much clear that
relationship between PW-12 and the present petitioner is deep love and there
is no such inducement of force from the part of the present petitioner in
respect of abduction took place with the intent that PW-12 may be seduced as
a result of her abduction and also from the evidence of PW-12 it is very much
evident that there is no forceful and forcibly done anything by the present
petitioner at any time during the course of stay at West Bengal and there is no
evidence to show that neither any force was applied in the alleged kidnapping
of PW-12 nor she was at any point of time induced by the present petitioner to
go with him. It is very much evident that PW-12 had gone to Kolkata by flight
alone and as such, allegation of abduction, kidnapping or inducement is wrong,
illegal and perverse and not tenable in the eye of law.
15.
The court below as well as the appellate court ought to have held
that the present petitioner was never liable to commit any offence under
Section 366 of the IPC and there is no proof that the present petitioner induced
the PW-12 to go for any place. It is further stated that PW-12 voluntarily fled
away to her grandmother’s house at Kolkata with all relevant documents
including Aadhar Card and it is further stated that when the relatives of PW-12
brought her at Tripura, they did not inform the matter either to any PS of West
Bengal or to Airport PS at Agartala including the name of the persons namely
Paltu, Binoy, Biplab and Mithun who forcibly took her at Airport from Mirja
School Chowmuhani and boarded her a flight at Agartala Airport for Kolkata
and as such, the order of conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court as
well as affirmed by the appellate Court in respect of the present petitioner is
liable to be set aside.
16.
On the contrary, Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl. P.P. has vehemently
opposed the submission of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and
prays for dismissal of the petition.
17.
Having heard the learned counsel and on scrutinized the records
this court finds sufficient force in the submission of Ms. S. Debbarma, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner and accordingly, the present Criminal
Revision stands allowed to the extent as indicated above.
CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review