The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. As such, this Court finds that petitioners do not have a case for interference for quashing of the notification of promotion dated 12.08.2022. Writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pulak 2024.02.19 PULAK BANIK Date: 15:42:46 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.427/2023
Sri Sukhen Debbarma & others
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
The Principal Secretary, Animal Resource Development Department & others
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Anthony Debbarma, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Rajib Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment : 08th February, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Anthony Debbarma, learned counsel for the petitioners,
and Mr. Rajib Saha, learned counsel for the State.
2.
The writ petitioners who have been working on the post of Animal
Resources Development Assistant (ARD Assistant, for short) have approached
this Court alleging denial of promotion to the post of Senior ARD Assistant
under the notification dated 12.08.2022 (Annexure-5). The promotional
exercise has been held for 125 vacant posts in the cadre of Senior ARD
Assistant with the following break up:
68 for UR; 35 for ST and 22 for SC as per the 100 point roster
calculated in terms of the ad-hoc promotion policy dated 22.06.2021 issued by
the G.A.(P&T) Department (Annexure-4), paragraph-6 & 7 in particular.
3.
The DPC, however, recommended 158 candidates who have been
promoted. Incidentally, on account of such recommendation, 34 supernumerary
posts had to be created. The persons who have been accommodated on
supernumerary posts are those who as per their seniority in the UR cadre could
not be accommodated against the 68 UR posts because candidates belonging to
SC and ST category, about 34 in number, had been accommodated against the
68 UR posts as they had qualified solely on the basis of merit and have never
taken the benefit of reservation and were treated to be own merit candidates
entitled to occupy the posts meant for general category though reservation was
to be made cadrewise. The fact that the last ST candidate who was promoted
from the combined seniority list of ST category at Sl. No.99 Haradhan
Debbarma stands above all the petitioners including the petitioner No.1 who is
at Sl. No.102 and petitioner No.11 who is at Sl. No.145 in the ST category is
not a matter of dispute, meaning thereby that in the ST quota no ST candidate
who is junior to the petitioner has been promoted.
4.
Petitioners do not have any quarrel with those SC quota
candidates who have been promoted against their SC quota. Their grievance is
against accommodation of SC or ST or UR candidates by creating
supernumerary posts. These supernumerary posts have been created in terms of
paragraph-7 of the ad-hoc promotion policy which provides that DPC would
follow the policy enumerated at paragraph-6 of the notification dated
22.06.2021 to identify employees eligible for promotion to a particular post
against the available vacancies. After this exercise DPC shall consider another
exercise taking into account the procedure as stated in Rule 9(2) of the Tripura
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Rules, 1992. Due to such
exercise, if any candidate is found not considered in the process as stated in the
above process then such candidate shall be considered for ad-hoc promotion by
creating supernumerary posts.
5.
Paragraphs-6, 7 & 8
of the notification dated 22.06.2021
containing policy for ad-hoc promotion are extracted hereunder:
"6.
Now, the State Government hereby notifies the following Promotion
Policy, 2021 as follows:(i) Rule 9 of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992 and the
provisos thereto shall be read in such a manner that only those SC & ST
candidates who have qualified solely on the basis of merit and have never taken
the benefit of reservation, will be treated to be own merit candidates and entitle
to occupy the posts meant for general category and reservation shall be made
cadre-wise.
(ii) 100 point roster shall apply only where the number of posts in the
cadre is 4(four) or more.
(iii) Where the post in the cadre are 3(three) or less, the 3(three) point
replacement roster shall be followed.
(iv) Single post or small cadres cannot be combined to make the
number of posts more than 3(three).
7.
Following the above policy, the DPC will identify employees eligible
for promotion to a particular post against the available vacancies. After this
exercise, DPC shall consider another exercise taking into account the procedure
as stated in the rule 9(2) of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules, 1992. Due
to such exercise, if any candidate is found not considered in the process as stated
in the above process, then such candidates shall be considered for ad-hoc
promotion by creating supernumerary post(s).
8. It has also been decided by the Government to allow such appointment on adhoc promotion as one time measure, following the below mentioned conditions:(i) Appointment on Promotions may be allowed purely on ad-hoc basis subject to
final outcome of the SLP pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
(ii) Ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be considered keeping in view of the
latest available seniority list of the feeder post/grade subject to condition that
he/she is otherwise suitable & eligible for promotion.
(iii) No inter-se seniority list shall be determined/published in respect of these
ad-hoc promotions.
(iv) Benefit of the ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be available to
accommodate a candidate to the immediate next higher promotion post/grade
only and such benefit shall not be considered to accommodate the said candidate
to multiple higher posts/grade with prospective effect.
(v) To create supernumerary posts, administrative Department shall assess the
number of posts to be created to materialize the promotion as per above
procedure and inform the total number of posts so determined to Finance
Department. No, further concurrence of Finance Department is required.
(vi) This ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall not be treated as regular
appointment on promotion.
(vii) The ad-hoc appointment on promotion as per guidelines illustrated above
shall be started in the highest grade of a cadre/service first. Due to such
promotion, the resultant vacancies shall be added with the vacancies in the lower
grade, and to be filled up subsequently.
(viii) Regular DPC may be held based on the existing seniority list. However,
while issuing the orders it should be stipulated that these promotions are
provisional and subject to the final outcome of the S.L.P. pending before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. Subsequently, when the directions become
available, a review DPC may be held and the necessary adjustments be made in
the promotions of officers based upon the revised seniority list. In case any of the
officers/candidate appointment on ad-hoc promotion do not figure in the list
approved by the review DPC they may be reverted to the posts held by them
earlier.”
6.
Rule 9 of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
Reservation Rules, 1992 is also extracted hereunder:
“9. Recruitment by Promotion:
(1) The appointing authority while making a request to the Selection
Committee/Selection Board/ Departmental Promotion Committee for
recommending candidates for promotion shall communicate to the Selection
Committee/Selection Board/Departmental Promotion Committee the details
about reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and shall also
furnish details about the number of candidates required against reserved vacant
posts and unreserved vacant posts in accordance with the provisions of the
concerned service rules. Where there is no rules for the post or service to which
promotion is to be made the appointing authority will furnish the details about
the candidates within the zone of consideration according to normal procedure.
The particulars about reserved vacant posts available shall be based on an
inspection report of 100-point roster in respect of the concerned post or service
to be furnished jointly by the Director for Welfare of Scheduled Castes and
Other Backward Classes and by the Director for Welfare of Scheduled Tribes as
mentioned in Rule 8(1).
(2) The Selection Committee/Selection Board/ Departmental Promotion
Committee will consider the suitability of the candidates, the details of whom are
furnished by the appointing authority and recommend a combined list of all
categories of candidates found suitable for promotion in order of their merit
which shall be the determining factor about the inter se seniority of the
candidates after promotion.
Provided that a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate who
occupies on merit or seniority or seniority-cum-fitness etc. an unreserved point
of the 100 –point roster in the combined list, shall not be shown against any
reserved point.
Provided further that at the time of recommending candidates for
promotion to any post, the names against unreserved vacant posts shall first be
recommended in order of their merit or seniority or seniority-cum-fitness etc., as
the case may be, and then the names against reserved vacant posts shall be
recommended.
(3) In addition to the combined list mentioned in Sub-Rule (2) the
Selection Committee/Selection Board/ Departmental Promotion Committee shall
furnish separate lists of candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes and a list of candidates of unreserved category in order of their merit for
promotion against the vacant posts shown as reserved or unreserved as the case
may be.
(4) The inspection report of the 100 Point Roster as furnished by the
Director for Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Other Backward Classes and the
Director for Welfare of Scheduled Tribes shall form a part of the record of the
minutes/proceedings of the Selection Committee/Selection Board/Departmental
Promotion Committee etc.
(5) The appointing authority shall consider the recommended list in
accordance with the provisions of the respective service rules and shall, after
consultation with the Commission where such consultation is necessary finally
approve the list.
(6) The appointing authority shall thereafter make promotion in
accordance with the 100 Point Roster as shown in the Schedule to the Act in
order of merit /preference as indicated in the list. A Scheduled Caste or
Scheduled Tribe candidate who occupies an unreserved point of the 100 – Point
Roster in the combined list of candidates shall not be fitted against any reserved
point.
(7) In case of non-availability of required number of Scheduled Caste or
Scheduled Tribe candidates against the reserved vacancies, the vacancies shall be
carried forward. In such case the appointing authority may take action under rule
8(8) and 8(9) if considered necessary.”
7.
The seniority list is part of the memorandum dated 25.04.2022
(Annexure-3). The notification of promotion dated 12.08.2022 is Annexure-5
to the writ petition. If the methodology of working out the principle enshrined
in the ad-hoc promotion policy dated 22.06.2021 read with Rule 9 of the
Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Rules, 1992 is
understood in this manner, petitioners who have entered into the feeder cadre
of ARD Assistant on the basis of their reservation quota of ST category cannot
have a genuine grievance against the promotional exercise since the last ST
candidate whose seniority stands at Sl. No.99 and have been promoted as
Senior ARD Assistant are ranked above the petitioners in the combined
seniority list. Petitioners have compared themselves with those reserved
category or UR candidates who have been promoted against supernumerary
posts which were created to meet the exigency of accommodating candidates as
per the seniority list of UR category who were left out on account of promotion
of candidates belonging to SC/ST category (who had qualified on their merit)
and who had been promoted against 34 of the 68 UR category vacancies.
8.
Petitioners belong to a class of ST category candidates who have
entered into service on the basis of the reservation to ST category and no one in
that category has been promoted junior to them. Petitioners in such manner
cannot compare themselves with those who have been promoted against the
UR vacancy without availing the benefit of reserved quota and having qualified
on merit though belonging to SC/ST category and those of UR category for
whom 34 supernumerary posts were created to accommodate them as per
paragraph-7 of the ad-hoc promotion policy dated 22.06.2021. Paragraph-8(iii)
of the ad-hoc promotion policy itself indicates that no inter-se seniority shall be
determined/published in respect of these ad-hoc promotions. These
appointments on promotion shall not be treated as regular appointment on
promotion and the appointment on promotion would be purely on ad-hoc basis
subject to final outcome of the SLP pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court
of India. Considered thus, the grievances of the petitioners are misconceived.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has laboured to impress that
juniors belonging to SC, ST and UR category have been promoted by creating
supernumerary posts. However, petitioners have failed to realize that these
supernumerary posts have been created to accommodate 34 candidates
belonging to the UR category out of the total 68 vacancies in UR category
because SC/ST candidates who had qualified on their merit at the time of entry
in service have got promotion against that 34 vacancies. They do not form a
same class with the petitioners as they have qualified on their own merit and as
such, they are entitled to occupy posts meant for general category as per
paragraph-6(i) of the promotion policy contained in notification dated
22.06.2021.
10.
Learned counsel for the State has taken pains to explain as to how
the methodology of granting promotion under the ad-hoc promotion policy of
22.06.2021 is being carried out by the department so that it does not result any
discrimination or injustice to any category or persons keeping into mind that
promotions to all these category of employees were withheld in all departments
of the State due to the pendency of the Special Leave Petition Nos.1976519767 of 2015. The promotion policy of 22.06.2021 framed by the G.A.(P&T)
Department, Government of Tripura is only pursuant to the interim order dated
27.07.2015 passed by the Apex Court.
11.
As such, this Court finds that petitioners do not have a case for
interference for quashing of the notification of promotion dated 12.08.2022.
Writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
2024.02.19
PULAK BANIK Date:
15:42:46 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review