Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.130 of 2025
Sri Sujit Kumar Dey,
S/o: Late Ajit Kumar Deb,
Netaji Pally, Dukli, P.O.: Madhuban,
West Tripura.
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary, Home
Affairs, Government of Tripura, Secretariat, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, PIN: 799010.
2. The District General of Police, Government of Tripura, Police
Head Quarter, Agartala, PIN: 799001.
3. The Dy. Director General of Police, AP (OPS-1) Government of
Tripura, A.D. Nagar, Agartala, PIN: 799003.
4. The Commandant, 1st Bn Tripura State Rifles, V.B. Gram,
Gokulnagar, Sepahijal Tripura, PIN: 799102.
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Dr. Mihirlal Roy, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. GA
Date of hearing
Date of delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
25.02.2026
:
05.03.2026
:
YES
Whether fit for
reporting
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the
following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
any other Direction or Directions and/or Order or
Orders of like nature shall not be issued for setting
aside the impunged Order, dated 18-10-2024 of the
Disciplinary Authority of „Compulsory Retirement‟ of
the Petitioner.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
any other Direction or Directions and/or Order or
Orders of like nature shall not be issued for
consequential relief of the Petitioner on setting
aside the impunged Order, dated 18-10-2024 of the
Disciplinary Authority of „Compulsory Retirement‟ of
the Petitioner.
(iii) Call for records.
(iv) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon‟ble
High Court consider fit and proper.”
2.
Heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
Mr.
Purusuttam
Roy
Barman assisted by Learned Counsel, Dr. Mihirlal Roy appearing on
behalf of the petitioner. Also heard Learned Addl. GA, Mr. Karnajit De
appearing on behalf of the respondents-State.
3.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner drawn the attention of this Court to the fact that the
petitioner entered into service on 03.04.2000 as a Rifleman under
Tripura State Rifles, Government of Tripura (for short, TSR). In course
of his employment, while serving as Rfn (Driver) No.00010531, a
departmental proceeding was initiated against him under Rule 14 of
the Central Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules,
(for
short,
CCS(CC&A)
Rules)
read
with
Rule
40,
vide
Memorandum dated 20.05.2023 with the following articles of charge:
"ARTICLE-I
That, No. 00010531 Rfn (Driver) Sujit Kumar Dey of
Adm-Coy, 12th Bn TSR(IR-VIII), while on leave he had
fraudulently and dishonesty submitted forged guarantor
form vide dispatch No. 2385 dated 07.12.2022 by affixing
forged seal of the DDO, 12th Bn TSR (IR-VIII) and forging
the signature of DDO, 12th Bn TSR (IR-VIII). He put
forged signature of DDO, 12th Bn TSR (IR-VIII) on the
prescribed guarantor form as a guarantor in favour of the
beneficiary namely Shri Dipak Banik S/o Shri Girendra
Chandra Banik of East Badharghat, Madhuban, Amtali,
West Tripura before the Tripura Scheduled Castes Cooperative Development Corporation Limited, Agartala
towards sanction of Rs. 5,00,000/- under the small
Business Scheme which amounts to gross misconduct
and thereby punishable under section 12(1) of TSR Act,
1983."
Along with the articles of charge, statement of imputation
of misconduct, misbehaviour was framed, together with a list of
documents and a list of witnesses, which were duly supplied to the
present petitioner. An Inquiring Authority was appointed by the
Disciplinary Authority in exercise of the power conferred under Sub-
rule (2) read with Sub-rule (22) of the Rule 14 of the CCS(CC&A)
Rules, 1965 to inquire into the charges framed. The Inquiring Authority
conducted the enquiry upon the charges framed and on completion of
the enquiry, submitted its findings. On the basis of the findings of the
Inquiring Authority, the Commandant, 1st Bn, TSR, acting as the
Disciplinary Authority passed a Provisional Punishment Order on
23.09.2024 imposing a major punishment of “Removal from service
which shall not be a disqualification for future employment under the
Government” (Annexure-1 to the writ petition).
4.
Thereafter, being aggrieved, the petitioner submitted a
representation to the Commandant, 1st Bn, TSR for reconsideration
and to exonerate him from the charge (Annexure-2 to the writ
petition). Subsequently, the Disciplinary Authority, in exercise of the
powers conferred under Section 12(1)(h) of the Tripura State Rifles
Act, 1983, (for short, TSR Act) passed the final order dated
18.10.2024
imposing
punishment
of
„Compulsory
Retirement‟
(Annexure-3 to the writ petition). Accordingly, the name of the
petitioner was struck off from the strength of Tripura State Rifles w.e.f.
18.10.2024.
5.
Challenging the impugned final order dated 18.10.2024,
the petitioner preferred an appeal on 07.11.2024 before the Appellate
Authority, i.e. the Dy. Inspector General of Police, AP(OPS-1),
Government of Tripura under Rule 46 of the Tripura State Rifles
(Discipline, Control, Service Conditions etc) Rules, 1986 (Annexure-4
to the writ petition). However, the Appellate Authority did not consider
the appeal and by order dated 18.02.2025 affirmed the order of the
Disciplinary Authority (Annexure-5 to the writ petition).
Challenging the aforesaid order dated 18.10.2024, the
petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the reliefs as stated
above.
6.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner drawn the attention of this Court referring the report of the
Inquiring Authority and submitted that the enquiry report was not
supplied to the petitioner before the imposition of punishment, thereby
depriving him of the opportunity to submit his representation. As such,
there was total violation of the principles of natural justice.
In this regard, reliance was placed upon the judgment of
Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in
Managing Director, Ecil,
Hyderabad & Ors. vs. B. Karunakar & Ors., reported in (1993) 4
SCC 727 wherein in para Nos.29 and 30, Hon‟ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“29. Hence it has to be held that when the enquiry officer
is not the disciplinary authority, the delinquent employee
has a right to receive a copy of the enquiry officer's
report before the disciplinary authority arrives at its
conclusions with regard to the guilt or innocence of the
employee with regard to the charges levelled against
him. That right is a part of the employee's right to defend
himself against the charges levelled against him. A denial
of the enquiry officer's report before the disciplinary
authority takes its decision on the charges, is a denial of
reasonable opportunity to the employee to prove his
innocence and is a breach of the principles of natural
justice.
30. Hence the incidental questions raised above may be
answered as follows:
[i] Since the denial of the report of the enquiry officer is
a denial of reasonable opportunity and a breach of the
principles of natural justice, it follows that the statutory
rules, if any, which deny the report to the employee are
against the principles of natural justice and, therefore,
invalid. The delinquent employee will, therefore, be
entitled to a copy of the report even if the statutory rules
do not permit the furnishing of the report or are silent on
the subject.
[ii] The relevant portion
Constitution is as follows:
of
Article
311(2)
of
the
“(2) No such person as aforesaid shall be
dismissed or removed or reduced in rank except
after an inquiry in which he has been informed of
the charges against him and given a reasonable
opportunity of being heard in respect of those
charges.”
Thus the article makes it obligatory to hold an inquiry
before the employee is dismissed or removed or reduced
in rank. The article, however, cannot be construed to
mean that it prevents or prohibits the inquiry when
punishment other than that of dismissal, removal or
reduction in rank is awarded. The procedure to be
followed in awarding other punishments is laid down in
the service rules governing the employee. What is
further, Article 311(2) applies only to members of the
civil services of the Union or an all-India service or a civil
service of a State or to the holders of the civil posts
under the Union or a State. In the matter of all
punishments both Government servants and others are
governed by their service rules. Whenever, therefore, the
service rules contemplate an inquiry before a punishment
is awarded and when the enquiry officer is not the
disciplinary authority the delinquent employee will have
the right to receive the enquiry officer's report
notwithstanding the nature of the punishment.
[iii] Since it is the right of the employee to have the
report to defend himself effectively and he would not
know in advance whether the report is in his favour or
against him, it will not be proper to construe his failure
to ask for the report, as the waiver of his right. Whether,
therefore, the employee asks for the report or not, the
report has to be furnished to him.
[iv] In the view that we have taken, viz., that the right to
make representation to the disciplinary authority against
the findings recorded in the enquiry report is an integral
part of the opportunity of defence against the charges
and is a breach of principles of natural justice to deny the
said right, it is only appropriate that the law laid down in
Mohd. Ramzan case should apply to employees in all
establishments whether Government or non-Government,
public or private. This will be the case whether there are
rules governing the disciplinary proceeding or not and
whether they expressly prohibit the furnishing of the
copy of the report or are silent on the subject. Whatever
the nature of punishment, further, whenever the rules
require an inquiry to be held, for inflicting the
punishment in question, the delinquent employee should
have the benefit of the report of the enquiry officer
before the disciplinary authority records its findings on
the charges levelled against him. Hence question (iv) is
answered accordingly.
[v] The next question to be answered is what is the
effect on the order of punishment when the report of the
enquiry officer is not furnished to the employee and what
relief should be granted to him in such cases. The answer
to this question has to be relative to the punishment
awarded. When the employee is dismissed or removed
from service and the inquiry is set aside because the
report is not furnished to him, in some cases the nonfurnishing of the report may have prejudiced him gravely
while in other cases it may have made no difference to
the ultimate punishment awarded to him. Hence to direct
reinstatement of the employee with back-wages in all
cases is to reduce the rules of justice to a mechanical
ritual. The theory of reasonable opportunity and the
principles of natural justice have been evolved to uphold
the rule of law and to assist the individual to vindicate
his just rights. They are not incantations to be invoked
nor rites to be performed on all and sundry occasions.
Whether in fact, prejudice has been caused to the
employee or not on account of the denial to him of the
report, has to be considered on the facts and
circumstances of each case. Where, therefore, even after
the furnishing of the report, no different consequence
would have followed, it would be a perversion of justice
to permit the employee to resume duty and to get all the
consequential benefits. It amounts to rewarding the
dishonest and the guilty and thus to stretching the
concept of justice to illogical and exasperating limits. It
amounts to an “unnatural expansion of natural justice”
which in itself is antithetical to justice.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further
submitted that since the respondent authority has failed to comply
with the mandatory requirement of law, so, the punishment imposed
upon the petitioner by the Disciplinary Authority as well as the
Appellate Authority suffers from infirmity and as such, the same needs
to be interfered with and set aside. It was further submitted by
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner that in this case, the
Inquiring Authority submitted its findings based upon the report of
SFSL but unfortunately, the Scientific Officer-cum-Assistant Chemical
Examiner, who conducted the examination and submitted report was
not called for examination by the Authority. Even the petitioner was
not given the opportunity to cross-examine the said witness. As a
result, the petitioner was deprived of exercising his valuable rights.
Thus, the entire proceedings suffers from serious irregularities.
Finally, Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner urged
before this Court to interfere with the findings of the Disciplinary
Authority as well as the Appellate Authority and to remand back the
matter to the respondent authority with a direction to furnish the
report of the Inquiring Authority to the petitioner to enable him to
make his proper defence before the Disciplinary Authority before
imposition of punishment.
7.
The State-respondents have contested the case by filing
counter affidavit. In para Nos.6 to 11 of the counter affidavit, the
State-respondents have submitted as under:
“6. That, with regard to para 6 of the Writ Petition, I say
that, it is fact that a Departmental Proceeding was
drawn-up against the Petitioner when he was posted at
12th Bn TSR. As per record, Shri Prabha Ranjan
Debbarma, Asstt. Commandant, 12th Bn TSR was engaged
as Inquiring Authority. Thereafter Shri Binoy Kumar
Gour, Asstt. Commandant, 1st Bn TSR was engaged as
Inquiring Authority and Subedar (Medical) Pankaj
Majumder
was
engaged
as
Presenting
Officer.
Subsequently,
Shri
Nila
Kumar
Jamatia,
Dy.
Commandant, 1st Bn TSR was engaged as Inquiring
Authority due to posting out of Shri Binoy Kumar Gour,
Asstt. Commandant, 1st Bn TSR. Thereafter, Shri Kanulal
Das, Asstt. Commandant, 1st Bn TSR was engaged as
Inquiring Authority during the month of March, 2024 due
to deployment of Shri Nila Kumar Jamatia, Dy.
Commandant at Chhattisgarh. Shri Kanulal Das, AC, 1st Bn
TSR submitted findings of the DP after completion of
Enquiry.
7. That with regard to para 7, I say that, it is fact that,
the Article of Charges framed against the Petitioner was
"proved beyond doubt" as per findings of the Inquiring
Authority submitted on 17.09.2024. On perusal of the
findings, statement of prosecution witnesses, statement
of Presenting Officer, opinion of the State FSL, Tripura
and the final defense statement of charged official a
Provisional Punishment order "REMOVAL FROM SERVICE
WHICH SHALL NOT BE A DISQUALIFICATION FROM
FURTHER EMPLOYMENT UNDER THE GOVERNMENT" in
c/w 12th Bn TSR DP No-03/2023 dated 10.06.2023 was
issued to him vide No. F.Pers/TSR-I/Estt/SKD/2K/7456
dated 23.09.2024 which was acknowledged by him on
the same day.
8. That, with regard to para 8, I say that, provisional
order issued after careful consideration of findings as
submitted by Inquiring Authority after conducting day to
day proceeding of Enquiry.
9. That, with regard to para 9, I say that, the petitioner
was given sufficient scope and he was also provided with
all relevant documents to defend his case.
It is pertinent to mention here that, the Inquiring
Authority by a letter vide No. 1390/F/DP No03/2023/TSR-XII/SKD/2023 dated 12.06.2023 was
given the scope to inspect the documents by which the
article of Charges were proposed in the chamber of
Inquiring Authority on 19/06/2023 at 1030 hours and
was also given liberty to the petitioner that he can take
extracts of relevant portions there from, if necessary. It
was also mentioned under above letter that the
Petitioner may intimate the name and particulars of the
defence assistant to the E.O.
Copies of the documents provided to him are enclosed
hereto and marked as Annexure R/1.
Copy of the letter No. 1390/F/DP No-03/2023/TSRXII/SKD/2023 dated 12.06.2023 is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure R/2.
10. That, with regard to para 10 and 17, I say that, the
contentions raised in this paragraph is not factually
correct. The representation was received on 10.10.2024
not on 19.10.2024. The representation of charged
official/petitioner was considered on the basis of the
economic condition of the family of charged official for
carrying out study of his son and livelihood, as the
delinquent official is the only earning member of his
family. Thereafter, finally he was awarded major penalty
of "Compulsory retirement" from Government service in
place of "removal from service which shall not be a
disqualification for future employment under the
Government".
11. That, with regard to para 11, I say that, the
representation was received on 10.10.2024 not on
19.10.2024. The representation of charged official was
considered on the basis of the economic condition of his
family in carrying out the study of his son and their
livelihood, as the delinquent official is the only earning
member of his family. Thereafter, finally he was awarded
major penalty of "Compulsory retirement" from Govt
service in place of "removal from service which shall not
be a disqualification for future employment under the
Government". It is not correct that pension benefits
under Compulsory retirement scheme will forfeiture his
retirement benefit.”
8.
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Addl. GA, Mr. De
appearing on behalf of the State-respondents submitted that in this
case all opportunities were given to the petitioner to conduct his
defence properly and the charges were duly proved against him. As
such, there was no scope for causing prejudice to the petitioner.
Furthermore, referring para No.2(IV) of the order dated 18.02.2025
(Annexure-5 to the writ petition), Learned Addl. GA drawn the
attention of this Court that in the said order it was specifically
mentioned that in course of the enquiry, ample opportunities was
given to the petitioner at every stage to defend himself but inspite of
the opportunities, the petitioner failed to produce any witness or
documentary evidence in support of his defence. Learned Addl. GA
further submitted that the charges were framed as per the TSR Act,
1983 based upon the documentary evidence on record and the
departmental proceeding was drawn up accordingly. So, no prejudice
was caused to the petitioner and as such, Learned Addl. GA in
conclusion of his argument urged for dismissal of this writ petition.
9.
Further, at the time of hearing, being asked by this Court,
Learned Addl. GA fairly submitted that the enquiry report was not
furnished to the petitioner before imposition of punishment enabling
him to submit his representation to the Disciplinary Authority as
observed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the aforenoted case.
In this regard, Hon‟ble the Supreme Court in State of
Uttar Pradesh through Principal Secretary, Department of
Panchayati Raj, Lucknow vs. Ram Prakash Singh, reported in
2025 SCC OnLine SC 891, in para Nos.33, 38, 39, 52, 55 observed
as under:
33. Resting on the aforesaid reasoning, the answer to the
basic question (majority view) in B. Karunakar (supra) is
found in paragraph 29 reading as follows:
“29. Hence it has to be held that when the
enquiry officer is not the disciplinary authority,
the delinquent employee has a right to receive a
copy of the enquiry officer's report before the
disciplinary authority arrives at its conclusions
with regard to the guilt or innocence of the
employee with regard to the charges levelled
against him. That right is a part of the employee's
right to defend himself against the charges
levelled against him. A denial of the enquiry
officer's report before the disciplinary authority
takes its decision on the charges, is a denial of
reasonable opportunity to the employee to prove
his innocence and is a breach of the principles of
natural justice.”
(emphasis ours)
38. Thus, the right to receive the enquiry report as a
fundamental safeguard in disciplinary proceedings,
where such report holds the charges against the
delinquent employee to be established, was firmly
entrenched
by
the
Constitution
Bench
in
the
jurisprudence relating to proceedings initiated for
disciplinary action for misconduct. This valuable right
applies uniformly, regardless of who the employer is
(Government, public or private) and regardless of what
the rules governing the service ordain. Even if the rules
are silent or do not require furnishing of the enquiry
report, the same has to be furnished. Additionally, the
report must be furnished to the employee even without a
request, as it forms an integral part of ensuring a fair and
reasonable opportunity to defend against the charges. By
not furnishing the report, an employer cannot scuttle the
rights of the delinquent employee.
39. Reading the passage from S.K. Sharma (supra)
highlighted above bearing in mind the guidance received
from the dicta in B. Karunakar (supra), one can safely
conclude that furnishing of a report of enquiry though is
a procedural step, it is of a mandatory character.
However, such a requirement can be waived by the
delinquent employee, expressly or by conduct, but if on
facts he is found not to have waived his right to receive
the report, the theory of substantial compliance or the
test of „prejudice‟ would not be applicable.
52. We now sum up our understanding of the law
declared in B. Karunakar (supra) and answer the four
questions
delineated
in
paragraph
(supra)
compositely. Reading the declaration of law by the
Constitution Bench regarding the imperative need to
furnish the report of enquiry to the delinquent employee
even when : (i) the relevant statutory rules are silent or
against it, (ii) the punishment to be imposed is other
than the punishment referred to in clause (2) of Article
311 of the Constitution, (iii) the employee does not ask
for it, and (iv) the burden is cast on a private employer
too, and the law requiring furnishing of the report being
made to operate prospectively from the date the decision
in Mohd. Ramzan Khan (supra) was rendered, thereby
reinforcing the legal position that prevailed after the GoI
Act was enacted but became unsettled later, there can be
no two opinions that on and from 20th November, 1990
[i.e., when Mohd. Ramzan Khan (supra) was decided] it
is the mandatory requirement of law that the report of
enquiry has to be furnished to the delinquent employee.
Taking a cue from S.K. Sharma (supra), we are inclined
to the view that the requirement of furnishing the report
of enquiry, though procedural, is of a mandatory
character and the bogey argument of the employer to
apply the test of „prejudice‟ when the report of enquiry is
not furnished cannot be of any avail to thwart the
challenge of the delinquent employee. Such test could
call for application, if from the facts and circumstances, it
can be established that the delinquent employee waived
his right to have the report furnished. Should satisfactory
explanation be not proffered by the employer for its
failure/omission/neglect to furnish the enquiry report,
that ought to be sufficient for invalidating the
proceedings and directing resumption from the stage of
furnishing the report. No proof of prejudice for breach of
a statutory rule or the principles of natural justice and
fair play need be proved, unless there is a waiver, either
express or by conduct, to of the right to receive the
report. And, it is only in specific and not in all
circumstances that proof of „prejudice‟ ought to be
insisted upon.
55. Relying on the law declared in S.K. Sharma (supra)
which, in turn, relied on B. Karunakar (supra), we hold
that prejudice is self-evident and no proof of prejudice as
such is called for in this case.”
From the aforesaid observation of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court of India, it appears that Hon‟ble the Supreme Court also came to
the observation that even if the rules are silent or do not require
furnishing of the enquiry report, the same has to be furnished. The
report must be furnished to the employee even without a request, as it
forms an integral part of ensuring a fair and reasonable opportunity to
defend against the charges and by not furnishing the report, an
employer cannot scuttle the rights of the delinquent employee.
10.
Here, in the case at hand, after hearing both the sides and
after going through the records, it appears that the respondent
authority has failed to discharge that burden, which was legally casted
upon them. As such, in the considered opinion of this Court, there has
been a violation of the principles of natural justice before imposition of
punishment.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner stands
allowed. The orders of the Appellate Authority as well as the
Disciplinary Authority passed against the petitioner stands quashed
and set aside. The matter is remanded back to the respondent
authority with a direction to supply a copy of the enquiry report to the
petitioner so as to enable him to submit his defence before imposition
of punishment by the Disciplinary Authority.
The Disciplinary Authority, accordingly, may ensure supply
copy of the enquiry report to the petitioner and ask him to submit his
defence against the report for further proceeding and thereafter, after
considering the representation of the petitioner, the Disciplinary
Authority shall pass appropriate order in accordance with law within a
period of 3(three) months from the date of passing of this judgment
and order.
With this observation, the present writ petition stands
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed
SNIGDH Digitally
by SNIGDHA DAS
2026.03.05
A DAS Date:
16:43:12 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review