Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 650 OF 2024
1.SRI GOUTAM DAS
S/o Sri Gouranga Das, Vill- Radhanagar, P.O.- Agartala, P.S.- West
Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001, age-55.
2.SRI TUTAN ROY,
S/o Lt. Nikhil Ch. Roy, Vill.- No. 1 Goutamnagar, PO and PS
Bishalgarh, District- Sephahijal, Tripura, Pin- 799102, age-50.
3.SMT. SUKRITI BISWAS,
W/o Sri Gopal Nama, Vill- Montala, P.O.- Algapur, P.S.- Dharmanagar,
District- North Tripura, Pin- 799253, age-51.
4.SMT. JHUMELI DEBBARMA,
W/o- Dr. Shyama Debbarma, Vill. and P.O. and P.S.- Lefunga, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin- 799210. age- 48 years.
5.SRI UMASANKAR ACHARJEE,
S/o Lt. Sampad Kr. Acharjee, Vill- Krishnanagar, P.O.- Agartala, P.S.West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001,age-49 years.
6.SRI RAGHU PATI SINGH,
S/o Sri Bhumeswar Singh, Vill. and P.O.- Abhoy Nagar, P.S.- East
Agartala, Pin- 799005, age-45 years.
7.SMT. SUJATA DAS,
D/o Sri Bhasan Chandra Das, Vill.- 67,H.G.B. Road, P.O. Agartala, P.S.West Police Station, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799001, age-46.
8.SRI NIRMAL KANTI SAHA,
S/o Lt. Ram Kamal Saha, Vill- Indranagar Purba Kali Bari (Choudhuri
Tilla), P.O.- Indranagar, P.S.-N.C.C., District- West Tripura, Pin799006, age-47.
9.SRI RAMJATAN PASHI,
S/o Lt. Balaam Pashi, Vill and Po- Baligaon, PS- Kamalpur, DistrictDhalai, Tripura, age-48.
10.SRI RAMU ROY,
S/o Lt. Nrayan Roy, Vill- Bankumari, Jogendranagar (Nath Para), PoJogendranagar, Ps- East Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin- 799004,
age-45
11.SRI SUBHANKAR DATTA,
S/o Lt. Ajit Kumar Datta, Vill.- East Shibnagar (Piya Basanti
Apartment), P.O. Agartala College, P.S.- East Agartala, District- West
Tripura, Pin-799004,
age-45.
---Petitioners.
Versus
1.The state of Tripura
(To be represented by the Principal Secretary, Department of Tribal
Welfare, Government of Tripura), New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital Complex, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN 799010.
2.Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions
Society, (TTWREIS), to be represented by it's Member Secretary,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
3.The Director,
Tribal Welfare Department, Govt. of Tripura, Gurkhabasti,
P.N Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799006
4.Union of India,
To be represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Tribal Affairs, 416, 4th
Floor, B-Wing, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001.
5.National Education Society for Tribal Students (NESTS),
To be represented by it's Commissioner/Joint Commissioner, (An
autonomous Organization under Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Govt. of
India, Ground Floor, Gate- 3A, Jeevan Tara Building, Parliament Street,
New Delhi-110001
---Respondents.
ALONG WITH
WP(C) 652 OF 2024
1.Sri Sudhir Debbarma
S/O-Lt. Baishakh Debbarma, R/o- Old Gayangfung Para, P.O- Yeakharai
Bazar, P.S- Kalyanpur, Dist- Khowai Tripura, PIN-799203, Age-52.
2.Smt. Meenakshi Kalai,
W/o-Sri Sujit Kalai, R/o- Agartala, Ps-East Agartala, Dist- West Tripura,
Pin-799001, age-45.
3.Smt. Kalpana Daru,
W/o-Joy Kanta Noatia, R/o- Morsumpathar, P.O-Kalaban, PS-R.K. Pur,
District- Gomati Tripura, Pin-799125,age-46.
4.Sri Litan Deb,
S/O- Sanjoy Deb, R/o- Bardowali, P.O.- A.D. Nagar, PS- A.D. Nagar,
District- West Tripura, Pin- 799003, age-47.
5.Sri Kumar Debbarma,
S/O- Late-Sambhucharan Debbarma, R/o-Amtali, P.O.-Brajapur, P.S.Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala, Pin-799102, age-48.
6.Smt. Sankari Roy Das,
D/o- Arun Chandra Roy, R/o-A.D. Nagar, Road No 6, P.O. A.D. Nagar,
P.S.-A.D. Nagar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799003, age-46.
7.Smt. Panna Rani Debbarma,
W/o- Kritu Debbarma, R/o-- Baramaidan bazar, P.S-Kalyanpur, Dist.Khowai Tripura, Pin- 799203, age-44.
8.Smt. Tinku Senchoudhuri,
W/O- Ratan Gon Choudhury, R/o- Kalikapur, Hrishyamukh, P.O.
Hrishyamukh, P.S.- BELONIA, Dist- South Tripura, PIN 799156, age48.
9.Sri Amitabha Pal,
S/O Late Phanindra chandra Pal, R/o- Badharghat, MatriPalli, Agartala,
Pin-799003, age-47.
10.Smt. Kanika Das,
D/O- Jagadish Das, R/o- -Subhasnagar, P.O-Birendranagar, P. S- Jirania,
Dist- West Tripura, Pin-799045, age-45.
11.Smt. Jharna Banik,
W/o- Satyajit Bandyopadhyay, R/o- Subhashpalli, North Badharghat,
P.O.- A.D Nagar, P.S.- A.D. Nagar, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799003,
age-49.
12.Sri Dhiman Chakraborty,
S/o Lt. Anil Chandra Chakraborty, R/o- Kulai Thakur Pally, P. O Kulai
Bazar, P.S Ambassa, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, PIN-799204. age-48.
---Petitioners.
Versus
1.The State of Tripura (to be represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Tribal Welfare, Government of Tripura), New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799010.
2.Tripura Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions
Society, (TTWREIS),
To be represented by it's Member Secretary, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin- 799006.
3.The Director,
Tribal Welfare Department, Govt. of Tripura, Gurkhabasti, P.N
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
4.Union of India,
To be represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Tribal Affairs, 416, 4th
Floor, B-Wing, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001.
5.National Education Society for Tribal Students (NESTS),
To be represented by it's Commissioner/Joint Commissioner,
(An autonomous Organization under Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Govt. of
India, Ground Floor, Gate- 3A, Jeevan Tara Building, Parliament Street,
New Delhi-110001.
---Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Counsel.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. G.A.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy.SGI.
Mr. P. Maishan, Advocate.
Date of hearing and date of
delivery of Judgment & Order : 28.11.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. Pradyumna Gautam,
learned senior G.A. appearing for respondents-State, Mr. Bidyut
Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing for respondents-Union of
India and Mr. Pradyot Maishan, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.2.
2.
The gravamen of the grievances of the petitioners, as
gathered from the pleadings, is that the petitioners in WP(C) No.650 of
2024 were appointed against different non-teaching posts under Tripura
Tribal Welfare Residential Educational Institutions Society (for short,
TTWREIS) during the period from 2003 to 2010, and in WP(C) No.652
of 2024, all the petitioners, who are teaching staff, were appointed under
TTWREIS from 2003 to 2011 as Graduate Teachers and Trained
Graduate Teachers (TGT). The TTWREIS is a society under the control
of Tribal Welfare Department, Government of Tripura.
3.
On 23.03.2020, a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU)
was executed between TTWREIS and the National Education Society
for Tribal Students (for short, NESTS), a society under control of
Ministry of Tribal Welfare, Govt. of India,for providing good quality
modern education including a strong component of inculcation of values,
awareness of the environment, adventure activities and physical
education to the tribal children. The relevant clauses of said MoU
regarding roles and responsibilities of the First Party i.e. NESTS, are
extracted hereunder:
“3. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE
FIRST PARTY
3.1. Operationalisation of the scheme in all its
contours.
3.2. Plan, construct, establish, endow and administer
the Schools and to do all acts and things necessary for
or conductive to tribal education.
3.3. Provide good quality modern education- including
a strong component of inculcation of values,
awareness of the environment, adventure activities
and physical education to the tribal children.
3.4. Provide facilities, at a suitable stage for
instruction through a common medium all over the
county as per the language norms of CBSE.
3.5. Offer a common core-curriculum of NCERT to
ensure uniformity in standards.
3.6. Facilitate CBSE affiliation of schools.
3.7. Facilitate conduct of training / capacity building
programmes for teaching and non-teaching staff in
coordination with the Second Party.
3.8. Transfer the admissible Recurring Costs based on
the actual requirement as to be projected by the
Second Party in the beginning of the financial year
for onward transmission to the schools through
PFMS.
3.9. Shall provide detailed standards and norms for
recruitment of Teaching and Non-Teaching Staff as
formulated by the Ministry of Tribal Affairs,
Government of India.
3.10. Shall provide detailed standards and norms for
continuation of existing staff as formulated by the
Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India.
3.11. Shall review the existing MoUs signed by the
Second Party or the State Government with NonGovernmental Organizations (NGOs) regarding
running of the existing schools and may allow the
Second Party to enter into a fresh MoU only if the
academic results are found good and any other
benchmarks as decided by the Ministry of Tribal
Affairs, Government of India is met.
3.12. If need be, could entrust the recruitment of
teachers for States to an independent agency duly
ensuring reservation quota prescribed therein.
3.13. Aid, establish and conduct other institutions as
may be required for the furtherance of the Society’s
objectives in any part of India.
3.14. Do all such things as may be considered
necessary, incidental or conducive to the attainment of
all or any of the objectives of the Society.
3.15. Carry out any other activities required for
implementation of the Scheme, as directed by Ministry
of Tribal Affairs, Government of India from time to
time.”
4.
The NESTS also issued guidelines, in terms of said MoU on
05.06.2024 [Annexure-39 of WP(C) No. 650 of 2024] regarding the
absorption of regular employees from Eklavya Model Residential School
(EMRS) into NESTS.
5.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel submits that
3(three) types of institutions are run by the TTWREIS, namely, Ashram
Schools, Residential Schools and Eklavya Model Residential Schools.
The entire guidelines of absorption of employees are extracted
hereunder:
“NESTS/Admin/GBM/31/2020-21-Part(1) Dated:05th
June, 2024
The Principal Secretary,
Tribal Development/Welfare Department,
(Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh,
Tripura, Himachal Pradesh)
Sub: Guidelines for absorption of regular employees
at NESTS
This
is
with
reference
to
the
absorption/continuation of regular staff of EMRSs as
employees of NESTS. In this regard, a meeting of
Committee of NESTS and concerned states,
constituted for framing guidelines for absorption of
regular employees was held in the Office of NESTS.
New Delhi on 18.05.2024. After considering all
aspects the committee recommendations were
submitted for approval after taking legal opinion.
Following guidelines have bene approved, as
recommended by committee, for absorption of regular
teaching and non-teaching staff, recruited by State
Societies in EMRS:i.
Regular teaching and non-teaching staff who
meet the eligibility requirement of RRs of
NESTS as per sanctioned post of NESTS will
be considered for absorption at the initial
stage.
ii.
The regular TST teaching staff who do not
meet the eligibility requirement of RRs of
NESTS will be given the option as under:
a.
b.
c.
Existing teachers who do not possess the
CTET/STET qualification will be allowed to
attain the qualification within two years. If
they clear the CTET/STET within this time
frame, they will be considered for absorption.
However, their date of joining for the purpose
of seniority will be the actual date of joining in
regular plus time taken to clear CTET/STET
exam.
Existing teachers who do not possess the
subject combinations in degree/PG in respect
of TGT/PGT will be allowed to attain the
qualification within three years. If they clear
the degree/PG, as the case may be, within this
time frame, they will be considered for
absorption. However, their date of joining for
the purpose of seniority will be the actual date
of joining in regular service plus time taken to
acquire degree/PG.
In respect of non-teaching staff, absorption
will be considered only if they possess the
required qualification as per RRs of NESTS.
In respect of employees who do not possess the
required qualification, a maximum period of
three years may be considered to acquire the
qualification as per RRs.
iii.
With regard to single seniority list of NESTS
the following has been decided:
a.
Seniority of absorbed employees will be
considered from their date of joining as regular
staff in the respective State Societies in case of
(i) above.
In case two staff having the same date of
joining, the staff who is senior in age will be
considered as senior.
In case there are two staff who have the same
date of joining as well as age, the staff having
the higher marks in the minimum degree
required as per NESTS RRs will be considered
as senior.
For staff (teaching and non-teaching) who are
being absorbed, the promotion will be subject
to these staff fulfilling the eligibility for the
promotional post. NESTS will issue separate
guidelines in this regard.
b.
c.
d.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
For staff being considered for absorption, one
time document verification will be carried out
by NESTS before issuing absorption orders. If
at the time of document verification, the
qualification as per NESTS RR is not available
with the staff, the offer of absorption may not
be issued.
If the regular employee of a state society is
working in a post which is not sanctioned by
the DoE for NESTS, the employee will not be
considered for absorption.
In case of Staff Nurse, the mandatory
experience as mentioned in RRs of NESTS
would be relaxed by considering the service
being rendered in EMRSs.
The employees whose age is beyond 60 years,
as on the date of effect of this decision, would
not be considered for absorption.
To address the issue of absorption of staff
having same nature of work as well as similar
designations, a concordance table is attached
as annexure. The absorption would be
considered according to this table.
The absorption would be subject to the consent
given by the staff.
The instructions contained in this letter are effective
from the date of the committee meeting i.e.
18.05.2024.
This issues with the approval of the competent
authority.
(Anupam Sonalkar)
Joint Commissioner”
6.
For effecting such absorption, the NESTS authority also
issued a letter to the Principal Secretary, Tribal Welfare Department,
Government of Tripura, on 23.09.2024 [Annexure-40 of WP(C) No.650
of 2024] for necessary document verification. In said letter dated
23.09.2024, against the State Tripura, numbers of non-teaching staffs
were mentioned to be total 58+58= 116 Nos. who were proposed to be
absorbed, and similarly, in case of PGT & TGT, total 22+48= 70 Nos. of
teaching staffs were proposed for such absorption along with two
principals. Thereby total 188 numbers of employees/officials from
Tripura were proposed to be absorbed.
7.
Vide letter dated 12.03.2024 (Annexure-II of said writ
petition) the Secretary, Tribal Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, sent required informations with respect to absorption of said 188
nos. of employees into NESTS form both teaching and non-teaching
staffs, excluding the present petitioners of both the present writ petitions.
8.
Mr. Barman, learned senior counsel, submits that as per the
said MoU and subsequent correspondences made by both the authorities,
the present petitioners are also required to be absorbed but they were
illegally and arbitrarily excluded from such absorption, despite the fact
that similarly situated persons were already absorbed under NESTS.
9.
Learned senior counsel also submits that all the petitioners
in both the writ petitions were appointed against the sanctioned posts
created for Eklavya Model Residential School and, therefore, as per the
said MoU, all of them were also required to be absorbed. It is further
submitted by him that the selection process for appointment of both
teaching and non-teaching staff was a combined selection process
conducted by TTWREIS for all the above said 3(three) categories of
schools, and therefore, all the 3(three) categories of employees are
required to be absorbed under NESTS.
10.
The State-respondents have relied on a letter dated
23.02.2025 (Annexure-I of their additional counter affidavit) whereby
the TTWREIS requested the absorption of left out 32 regular staff
members (16 teaching and 16 non-teaching staffs) for including them in
the zone of consideration for absorption into NESTS. According to the
petitioners, all the present petitioners of both the writ petitions are from
the group of said 32 Nos. of staff members. The entire letter dated
23.02.2025 is also extracted hereunder for convenience of reference and
understanding:
“OFFICE OF
TRIPURA TRIBAL WELFARE RESIDENTAIL
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS SOCIETY
(TTWREIS)
GURKHABASTI, AGARTALA
To
The Commissioner,
National Education Society for Tribal Students
(NESTS), (A Central Society under Ministry of Tribal
Affairs) Jeevan Tara Building, Patel Chowk, Gate
No.3, Government of India, New Delhi.
Subject:
Request for Document Verification and
Absorption of Remaining 32 Regular
Staff of TTWREIS at NESTS.
Ref. letter(s): F.No.NESTS/Admin/GBM/31/2020-21part(1), dated 29/02/2024
(E-Office No.22551)
F.No.NESTS/Admin/G9BM/31/202021-part(1), dated 05/03/2024
(E-Office No.22551)
Sir,
The undersigned is directed to invite your kind
attention to the letter from NESTS dated 29/02/2024,
requesting the submission of point-wise relevant
documents for the verification of employees to be
absorbed into NESTS. In compliance with this
directive, the State Society (TTWREIS) submitted the
required documents for 220 regular teaching and nonteaching staff in the prescribed Excel format to the
NESTS Committee at its headquarters in New Delhi
on 07/03/2024,vide letter F.No.25-24/ TW/ REIS/ GoI
/Estt./ 2023/15102-108,dated 05/03/2024.
2.
Subsequently, NESTS, through its letter no.
F.NESTS/Admin/GBM/31/2020-21-part(1),
dated
23/09/2024, invited only 188 teaching and nonteaching staff for the Document Verification (DV)
process in New Delhi, leaving out the remaining 220180 = 32 regular staff members (Teaching & NonTeaching).
3.
It is pertinent to highlight that the 32 left-out
staff members, although they got to be posted at
Ashram Schools, Residentials Schools or the State
Society Headquarters, were recruited through the
same common recruitment process as the 188 who
have been called for DV. There is no distinction in
terms of recruitment procedures, roster maintenance,
eligibility qualifications, recruitment rules, offer letter,
appointment letter, etc., between the two groups, with
the solitary distinction being in their place of posting.
However, it is worth noting here that it was the State
Society (TTWREIS) which had the prerogative of
deciding their place of posting – not the candidates
who accepted the offers of appointment without
having any foreknowledge about where they would
eventually be posted.
4.
All of the aforesaid 220 staff members were
recruited by the TTWREIS against sanctioned posts
for EMRS, Ashram Schools, and other Residential
Schools, with a common merit and seniority list being
maintained. Their postings-whether at EMRSs,
Ashram Schools, Residential Schools, or the State
Society Headquarters-were determined solely by
TTWREIS based on institutional needs. Moreover, all
such postings were amenable to transferability from
one institution to another. Consequently, some staff
initially posted outside EMRSs were later transferred
to EMRSs, with vice versa of that happening too.
5.
At the time of issuing appointment letters, it
was not anticipated that only those posted at EMRS
institutions would be considered for absorption into
NESTS. However, in the circumstances explained
above, excluding the remaining 32 regular staff
members from consideration based solely on their
place of posting warrants reconsideration.
6.
It is, therefore, requested that the remaining
32 regular staff members (16 Teaching & 16 NonTeaching), as listed in Annexure-I (teaching staff) and
Annexure-II (non-teaching staff), may kindly be
included in the zone of consideration for absorption
into NESTS and called for DV as immediately as
possible.
Yours faithfully,
Enclo: As stated
Signed by
Subhasis Das
Date:23-02-2025 23:11:52
Subhasis Das, TCS SSG)
Addl. Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura
Tribal Welfare Department”
[Underscored emphasized]
11.
Mr. Barman, learned senior counsel also relies on a reply
given under the RTI Act on 26.11.2024 [Annexure-46 of the said writ
petition], whereby information was furnished that total 172 posts were
created vide memorandum dated 07.09.2001 [Annexure-41 of the said
writ petition] for 3(three) Nos. of Residential Schools, namely,
Khumulwng, B.C. Nagar and Kumarghat, all of the above said 3(three)
schools are under Eklavya Model Residential School [EMRS]. It is also
submitted on behalf of the petitioners that all of them were appointed
against the posts created vide notification dated 07.09.2001.
12.
In view of above submission, the Court, vide order dated
16.07.2025 directed the State-respondents/TTWREIS to inform by
affidavit as to whether all the petitioners were appointed against the posts
created vide said memorandum dated 07.09.2001 and, if not, against
which category of school under TTWREIS they were so appointed. Now,
in reply, the State-respondents submitted one additional affidavit and the
relevant portion of the reply, as furnished, is reproduced below:
“2. That, I humbly submit that in compliance with the Order
dated 16.07.2025 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura, in
connection with case No.W.P.(C) 650 of 2024 and W.P.(C) 652 of
2024,the State Respondents has carried out exercise to collect
information as to whether all the petitioners were appointed against
the post created by memorandum dated 07.09.2001 (and not
07.09.2021), if not, then against the sanction post(s) of which category
of school(s) of TTWREIS, each of them were appointed. On scrutiny of
the records, it appears that in respect of Case No.W.P.(C) 652 of 2024
all the 12(twelve) petitioners (teaching staff) were appointed against
the post created vide Memorandum dated 07.09.2001 (and not
07.09.2021 as observed by the Hon’ble Court).
And, in respect of case No.W.P.(C) 650 of 2024 (Sri Goutam
Das & Ors. Vrs. the State of Tripura) pertaining to the Non-Teaching
Staff, out of 11(eleven) petitioners, the following 7(seven) nos.
petitioners
were
appointed
against
the
posts
created
vide
Memorandum dated 07.09.2001:
(i)
Petitioner No.1- Shri Goutam Das (Lower Division
Clerk),
(ii)
Petitioner No.2- Shri Tutan Roy (Store-Keeper),
(iii)
Petitioner No.3- Smt. Sukriti Biswas (Lower Division
Clerk),
(iv)
Petitioner No.4-Smt. Jhumeli Debbarma (Hostel
Superintendent),
(v)
Petitioner No.5-Shri Umasankar Acharjee (Cashier),
(vi)
Petitioner No.9-Shri Ramjatan Pashi (Cook-cumMasalchi),
(vii) Petitioner No.10-Shri Ramu Roy (Cook-cumMasalchi).
However, in respect of the petitioner No.6, 7 and 8 who have
been joined in the year 2011 vide advertisement No.01/2009, it is
ambiguous to interpret their post creation individually/petitioner-wise,
as the said advertisement was placed for the posts endorsed by
forwarding and merging up of vacant posts created vide Memorandum
dated 07/09/2001, 14/01/2009 for EMRS/Ashram/Residential Schools
under TTWREIS. This is the reason for constitution of common
Interview Board followed by same proceeding of interview and a
Common Merit List was prepared for recruitment of 19 Nos. posts of
LDC/ Store-keeper/Cashier including the petitioners 6, 7 & 8.”
13.
From the said reply, it appears that out of the total 11
numbers of petitioners of WP(C) 650 of 2024, 7 (petitioner Nos. 1, 2, 3,
4, 5, 9 and 10) were recruited against posts created for EMRS. Regarding
the other 3 petitioners, i.e. the petitioner Nos. 6, 7 & 8 the TTWREIS or
the State could not give a specific reply. According to them, these above
said 3 petitioners joined in the year 2011 pursuant to the advertisement
No.01/2009, as the said recruitment process was held for 3 categories of
schools, namely, EMRS, Ashram Schools and Residential Schools in a
combined way. They could not furnish any reply in respect of petitioner
no.11.
14.
In case of 12 petitioners of WP(C) 652 of 2024, the State-
respondents through their said affidavit submitted that all these
petitioners were appointed against the posts created vide Memorandum
dated 07.09.2001 [Annexure-43 of the said writ petition]. By the said
Memorandum dated 07.09.2001, total 172 Nos. of teaching and nonteaching posts were actually created under the TTWREIS for 3 Nos. of
residential schools. As per the information furnished by TTWREIS under
RTI Act [Annexure-41 of the said writ petition], said three residential
schools are Eklavya Model Residential School [EMRS] of Khumlwng,
Birchandra Nagar, Kumarghat.
15.
Mr. Barman, learned senior counsel, also submits that the
other 3 persons, namely, Susmita Paul, Papri Marak Das and Smt.
Anamika Saha (Deb) [appointed as Metron] appearing in (Annexure-II)
i.e. the letter dated 12.03.2024, sent from the TTWREIS to the NESTS,
recommending their names for absorption, were also recruited through
the same recruitment process like above said petitioner Nos. 6, 7 & 8.
According to him, the above said 3 petitioners were also appointed
against the creation of above said 172 Nos. of posts. Learned senior
counsel further contends that the denial of absorption was mainly on the
ground that presently they were not posted at EMRS, despite the fact that
they were originally appointed against the sanctioned posts meant for
EMRS. Learned senior counsel further argues that total 77 Nos. of
employees as mentioned in the recommended list were not presently
posted at EMRS, but despite the same, their names were recommended
for absorption.
16.
Mr. Pradyumna Gautam, learned senior G.A., relies on the
counter affidavit and the additional affidavits submitted by the Staterespondents. Learned senior G.A. also submits that the obligation of
absorption, if any, totally lies with NESTS, and the State/TTWREIS has
no responsibility in this regard.
17.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy SGI, submits that the
agreement between the NESTS and TTWREIS was confined only to the
teaching and non-teaching staff who were appointed against the
sanctioned posts of Eklavya Model Residential Schools, and therefore,
there is no contractual obligation on the part NESTS to absorb any other
employees who were not appointed against the sanctioned post of
EMRS. Learned Deputy SGI further submits that the writ petition itself is
not maintainable, inasmuch as no contractual or any statutory right has
been accrued in favour of the petitioners to claim for such absorption.
Learned Deputy SGI also refers to a decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court
in the case of Ram Pravesh Singh & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors.,
(2006) 8 SCC 381, and relevant paragraphs No.11, 12 and 13 are
extracted hereunder:
“Contractual obligation
11. The licence granted to the Society under
Section 3 of the Electricity Act, 1910 was revoked by
the State Government on 25-4-1995. It is no doubt true
that on such revocation, the Board took over the entire
activities of the Society relating to distribution of
power to the licensed areas. The Board also gave its
concurrence to purchase the undertaking of the
Society. But the Board neither entered into any
contract with the Society, nor gave any assurance to
the Society or its employees to absorb the employees of
the Society into its service. Therefore, obviously, there
is no contractual obligation on the part of the Board to
absorb the services of the appellants.
Statutory obligation
12. Section 3 of the Act dealt with grant of licence
by the State Government to any person to supply
energy in any specified area. Section 4 dealt with
revocation of such licences. The provisions that would
have effect when a licence was revoked, were listed in
Section 5. Section 6 gave the option to the Electricity
Board and the State Government to purchase the
undertaking of a licensee, in the circumstances
mentioned therein. Section 7 provided for vesting of
the undertaking of the licensee sold to a purchaser
under Section 5 or 6. Section 7-A provided for
determination of the purchase price. None of these
provisions of the Act required the purchaser of the
undertaking to take over the services of the employees
of the Society. The appellants have not been able to
show any other statutory provision which entitles them
to seek absorption by the Board. Hence, there is no
statutory obligation to absorb them into the Board’s
service.
Equitable considerations
13. Realising that the appellants had no
contractual or statutory right, learned counsel for the
appellants sought to derive support for the claim on
equitable considerations, by placing reliance on an
amalgam of the principles relating to legitimate
expectation, fairness in action and natural justice,
reiterating the contentions urged before the High
Court.”
18.
Mr. Pradyot Maisan, learned counsel also submits in the
same line like Mr. Gautam, learned senior G.A.
19.
Now, on consideration of submission of both sides and also
of the pleadings and materials as placed by both sides, it appears that it is
the admitted position that 7 Nos. of petitioners i.e. the petitioner Nos. 1,
2, 3, 4, 5, 9 and 10 of WP(C) No. 650 of 2024 and all the 12 petitioners
of WP(C) No.652 of 2024 were appointed against the sanctioned post
meant for EMRS.
20.
Now, regarding other 03 other petitioner of left out 4
petitioners of WP(C) 650 of 2024, it is stated in the additional affidavit
submitted by the respondents-State, as indicated earlier, that they could
not ascertain asto whether they were appointed against the posts, created
for EMRS for the reason that by a common selection process and by
preparation of a common seniority list and merging of vacant posts of all
the three categories of school under TTWREIS, they were appointed.
However, it is not specifically also not denied by the respondents-State
or TTWREIS that said 4 persons were not appointed against the vacant
posts meant for EMRS.
21.
As said 7 petitioners of WP(C) 650 of 2024 and 12
petitioners of WP(C) 652/2024 were appointed against the posts
sanctioned for EMRS, they are automatically entitled to be absorbed
under NESTS as per the agreement entered by them with TTWREIS.
22.
Now, regarding other left out 4 persons, there is no specific
material that they were also appointed against the posts sanctioned for
EMRS. But, in their case also it is admitted position that during a
combined recruitment process, taken up for all the three categories of
schools under TTWREIS, they were selected and appointed. According
to the respondents-State, there were no distinction in terms of their
recruitment procedure, roster maintenance, eligibility qualifications,
recruitment rules etc. and they fall within the similar category of persons
like said other petitioners. Therefore, any sort of difference in the
treatment between them and the other petitioners will lead to an illegal
discrimination. Even if, the contract (MoU) as entered between NESTS
and TTWREIS created the contractual obligation upon the NESTS to
absorb the employees who were employed in EMRS only, such
contractual limitation or obligation leading to any discrimination to said
04 petitioners, cannot override their fundamental rights as protected
under Article 14 of the Constitution.
23.
In WP(C) 652 of 2024, the petitioners have also placed 3
Memorandums [Annexures-47,48 & 49] each dated 14.10.2011, whereby
3(three) persons namely Anamika Saha, Papri Marak and Susmita Pal
were initially appointed as Matron temporarily on fixed pay basis in
Ashram School situated at Sadhutilla, Karbook
and Kanchanpur
respectively. However, from the list of such employees as sent by
TTWREIS to NESTS proposing for their absorption, vide letter dated
12.03.2024 [Annexure-II to the said writ petition], names of these 3
persons are also found available there against Sl. Nos. 6, 15 and 25 at
pages 168 and 169 of the paper book. Therefore, rejection of claim of the
petitioners for such absorption will also lead to their discrimination with
said three persons too.
24.
In view of the above, both the writ petitions are allowed.
The respondents are directed to take necessary steps for absorption of
above said petitioners of both the writ petitions in NESTS, following the
due procedure within four weeks of receipt of copy of this judgment, and
thereafter to complete the entire process of such absorption within a
reasonable time, not later than 4 (four) months from the said date of
receipt of copy of the judgment.
25.
Both the writ petitions are, accordingly, disposed of.
Interim application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Sanjay/ Dinashree
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review