Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A. No.2 of 2024
Sri Subrata Nath
S/o. Late Shiv Nath,
Resident of South Hurua,
P.S- Dharmanagar,
District-North Tripura.
------ Appellant
Versus
The State of Tripura
------ Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. K. Biswas, Sr. Adv,
Mr. P. Majumder, Adv,
Mr. Rishiraj Nath, Adv,
Ms. S. Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Date of hearing
:
11.11.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
18.11.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This criminal appeal is filed under Section 374 of Cr.P.C.
challenging the judgment and order of conviction and sentence
dated 04.01.2024 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar in connection with case No.S.T.(T-1)
No.22 of 2019. By the said judgment, the appellant has been
convicted under Section 323 of IPC and sentenced to suffer RI
for 6(six) months and also to pay fine of Rs.1000/- i.d. to suffer
imprisonment for a further period of 1(one) month.
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. K. Biswas
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. P. Majumder, Learned
Counsel Mr. Rishiraj Nath and Learned Counsel Ms. S.
Debbarma for the appellant and also heard Learned P.P. Mr.
Raju Datta representing the State of Tripura.
3.
In course of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel drawn the
attention of the Court that initially the charge was framed by the
Learned Trial Court under Section 307 of IPC but on conclusion
of trial, Learned Trial Court below has found the appellant to be
guilty under Section 323 of IPC and sentenced him accordingly.
According to Learned Counsel, in this case the prosecution has
failed to explain the actual PO before the Learned Trial Court
below because in the FIR it was mentioned that the PO was on a
drain but the IO shown the PO on the bank of a pond but the
witnesses of the prosecution stated that the PO was on the
backside of the dwelling hut. There was no clear explanation
from the side of prosecution in this regard. Furthermore, as
alleged by the prosecution no blood stained earth was seized by
IO during investigation nor any wearing gamcha which according
to prosecution was stained with blood was seized by IO during
investigation and furthermore, there is no evidence on record
from the side of prosecution by what weapon actually the offence
was alleged to be committed by the accused i.e. the present
appellant. Furthermore, the witnesses of the prosecution during
their examination before the Court made improved version of
their statement. Prosecution has failed to explain those improved
version before the Court in course of hearing of argument before
the Learned Trial Court. Thus, the evidence of prosecution
suffers from various infirmities but the Learned Court below
without considering the materials on record found the appellant
to be guilty and convicted him under Section 323 of IPC for
which the interference of the Court is required and urged for
allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgment of the Learned
Court below.
4.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. representing the State
respondent submitted that the Learned Trial Court below after
considering the materials on record rightly and reasonably found
the appellant to be guilty and convicted him accordingly and
there is no merit in the appeal filed by the appellant because the
appellant by the trend of cross-examination could not discard the
evidence on record of the alleged victim and more so, at the
time of alleged occurrence save and except the victim and the
appellant no other persons were there but soon after the
occurrence he disclosed the fact to his parents and their
evidences could be shattered at any length by the appellantaccused. So, Learned P.P. finally urged for dismissal of this
appeal upholding the order of sentence and conviction delivered
by the Learned Trial Court. Considered.
5.
In the case at hand, prosecution was set into motion on
the basis of an FIR laid by one Ranadhir Nath to O/C,
Dharmanagar PS alleging inter alia that on 08.10.2017 at about
6 pm the present appellant called his son Biprajit Nath from
home and cut the wind pipe of his throat and also cut the blood
vessels of his legs and palms with a sharp knife in an attempt to
kill him. On hearing hue and cry, people of the area came and
witnessed the occurrence and rescued him from the nearby drain
in a half-dead condition. He was taken to Dharmanagar Hospital
immediately and finding his condition critical he was advised to
be taken outside the State for better treatment. Hence, the
informant laid the FIR.
6.
On receipt of FIR, O/C, Dharmanagar PS registered
Dharmanagar PS case No.75 of 2017 under Section 307 of IPC
and the IO on completion of investigation laid charge-sheet
against the appellant under Section 307 of IPC. The case was
committed to the Court of Learned Sessions Judge by the
Jurisdictional Magistrate and before the Learned Trial Court,
formal charge under Section 307 of IPC was framed against the
appellant and the same was explained to him in Bengali to which
he pleaded not guilty and claim to be tried.
7.
During the trial, to substantiate the charge, prosecution
before the Learned Trial Court has adduced in total 10nos. of
witnesses and relied upon some documents which were marked
as exhibits in this case. Finally on conclusion of trial, Learned
Trial Court below found the appellant guilty and convicted him
under Section 323 of IPC and this appeal has arisen before this
Court challenging the said judgment delivered by Learned
Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
8.
Now before coming to the conclusion, let us discuss
about the evidence on record produced before the Learned Trial
Court by the prosecution.
9.
PW-1, Pradip Kumar Singha deposed that about 2/3
years back one day police personnel came to the house of
Ranadhir Nath of their locality and he went there when he could
know that the appellant caused hurt to the son of Ranadhir Nath.
He could not say anything about the case of the prosecution and
also stated that he did not witness the occurrence of offence.
10.
PW-2, Debashish Nath deposed that about 3 years back
on a day in the evening he was at Dharmanagar Town and got
information that his brother Biprajit Nath was assaulted by
Subrata Nath and he was removed to Dharmanagar Hospital. On
receipt
of
this
information
immediately
he
rushed
to
Dharmanagar Hospital and found his brother under treatment
with a neck cut injury and came to know that the injury was
caused by Subrata Nath. Later on, he could know that on that
day at the material time, his brother was alone in the house
when the appellant-accused came to their house and called his
brother and asked him to see whether thieves came to their
house to take their cocks or not and took him to the backside of
their house. That time, his other family members were present
to their grocery shop infront of their house. Then the appellantaccused attacked his brother and cut his throat with a knife and
he also cut the arteries of the hands and legs of his brother.
During treatment his brother was referred to AGMC & GBP
Hospital.
During cross-examination, he stated that his brother
stated to him that the accused cut his throat with a knife.
Attention of the witness was drawn to the aforesaid statement
recorded by IO but the said statement was not found in the
statement recorded by IO under Secion 161 of Cr.P.C. and this
witness is also not the eye-witness of this case.
11.
PW-3, Ranadhir Nath is the father of the victim. He
deposed that he lodged this case on 08.07.2017. On that day,
his son Biprajit Nath was with him in his shop. That time, he was
aged about 15 years. Subsequently, his son went back to house
to say his wife to bring a cup of tea for him. Subrata Nath i.e.
the appellant also came to their house and remained there for
quite some time and his wife took a cup of tea for him. After
some time, his son rushed to his shop with some bleeding
injuries on his neck, palm and leg and he wrapped his neck with
a ‘gamcha’ and he saw he was pulled with blood. Somehow he
could say that Subrata Nath in absence of his mother took him to
the back side of his house and on the pretext that he caught a
thief while stealing cocks from their house. He compelled his son
to remove his shirt and thereafter caused sharp-cutting injuries
on his neck. His son tried to save himself from indiscriminate
assault with knife by Subrata Nath and his son sustained severe
cut injuries on his palm and thereafter Subrata Nath also caused
bleeding injury on his leg. Thereafter, Subrata Nath left his son
in the back side of his house and fled away. Seeing his son, he
raised alarm and somehow managed a e-rickshaw and removed
him to Dharmanagar Hospital for treatment. During treatment,
his son was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala and his
son had to undergo treatment for about a month and on the date
of incident, he laid the complaint to O/C, Dharmanagar PS and
his ejahar was prepared by one police personnel at Dharmanagar
PS as per his version. The witness identified his signature on the
ejahar marked as Exbt.-1. He further stated that he sold a piece
of land to Subrata Nath and he had a dispute with him over the
price of the said land and thus Subrata took revenge.
During
cross-examination,
he
stated
that
during
investigation, police visited the spot and he has shown the blood
stain on the ground and also shown the blood stained wearing
apparels and ‘gamcha’ to the police. He made statement to the
police. He was confronted with the statement that Subrata Nath
forcibly removed the shirt of his son and also stated that his son
rushed to his shop with bleeding injuries and at the material time
his neck was wrapped with a ‘gamcha’ but such portion of
statement was not found in his statement recorded by IO under
Section 161 of Cr.P.C. He did not say to police that while his son
tried to save himself form indiscriminate assault by the accused
with a knife, his son received severe bleeding injuries on his both
hand palm. He also confronted with the statement that he stated
to IO that Subrata Nath left his son to the backside of his house
and fled away. Attention of the witness was also drawn but the
said part of statement was also not found in the statement of
witness recorded by IO under Section 161 of Cr.P.C.
12.
PW-4, Rina Rani Nath is the wife of the informant. She
deposed that on 08.10.2017 her husband was at their shop
infront of their house and her son was with him in the shop. At
the material time, Subrata Nath came to their house and
enquired about his husband and she stated that her husband is
in their shop and in the mean time, her son returned back to
home and stated that her husband asked for a cup of tea.
Thereafter, she took a cup of tea for her husband and Subrata
Nath left their house and her son remained in their dwelling hut.
As her son was remaining alone so her husband asked her to go
back to home as jackles moves around in the night in their
locality. In the mean time, her son rushed to the shop of her
husband when he was pulled with blood and his neck was
wrapped with a ‘gamcha’ and he received severe sharp cutting
injuries on his neck, both hand and leg. He was immediately
removed to Dharmanagar Hospital and on the way her son
stated that he was assaulted by Subrata Nath with a knife.
During treatment her son was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital
and he remained there under treatment for a month. She further
stated that Subrata Nath is a resident of their locality and he had
a dispute with her husband with regard to the price of piece of
land which was sold to him by her husband.
During
cross-examination,
she
stated
that
during
investigation when police visited the PO, they have shown the
blood stain on the ground and also shown the blood stainned
wearing apparel and ‘gamcha’ to the police. Nothing more came
out relevant.
13.
PW-5 is the victim. He deposed that on 08.10.2017, he
was in their dwelling hut and was listening music in the
headphone. Door was closed. He was with his father in his tong
shop situated nearby their house and her father asked him to
say his mother to bring a cup of tea, as such, he returned back
to home and asked her mother to take a cup of tea for her
father. At the material time, Subrata Nath was in their house and
he was talking with his mother but while her mother prepared
tea and taken it to his father in his shop that time Subrata Nath
departed from their house. While her mother left, Subrata Nath
also left the house and he was alone. After a little while, Subrata
Nath again came and knocked the door when he was listening
music and asked him to open the door and said that someone
came to steal cocks. He asked him to accompany, as such, he
opened the dood and took him to the backside of their house. As
he was on a white shirt, he asked him to remove his shirt as it
would be visible even in the darkness. At his instance on good
faith, he removed his shirt and thereafter he suddenly caught
hold of him from his back and cut his throat with a knife and he
received severe cut injury on his neck in the front side and while
he tried to resist and rescue himself again the accused caused
severe cut injury on the palm of his left hand. During clutches he
also caused other cut injuries on his right hand and right leg just
above the ankle. He fell down on the ground that time Subrata
thought that he might have died and he fled away. Immediately
thereafter, he went to the shop of his father and narrated the
incident. He further stated that at the material time few persons
were there in the shop of his father and they also saw and heard
himself and after that he was brought to Dharmanagar Hospital
and immediately he was shifted to Hospital at Agartala.
During cross-examination, he stated that his father and
uncle accompanied him to Agartala. He was confronted with the
statement that he stated to IO that as he was on a white shirt so
the appellant asked him to remove his shirt as it would be visible
even in the darkness. Attention of the witness was drawn to his
statement recorded by IO under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. but the
said portion of statement was not found in the statement of
victim recorded by IO under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. He also could
not say the name of the persons who were present to the shop
of his father as he was not in a position to recognise them. He
was further confronted with the statement that he was with his
father in his tong shop situated nearby their house and when his
father asked him to say his mother to bring cup of tea and as
such he returned home and asked his mother to take a cup of
tea for his father. Attention of the witness was further drawn but
the said part of statement was also not found in the statement of
witness recorded by IO under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. He was
further confronted with the statement that he stated to IO while
his mother left, Subrata Nath also left his house and he was
alone and after sometime, Subrata again came and knocked the
door when he was listening music and asked him to open the
door stating that someone came to steal cocks. Attention was
further drawn and on drawing attention, witness admitted that
no such aforesaid portion of statement was found to his
statement recorded by IO under Section 161 of Cr.P.C.
14.
PW-6, Ashish Paul deposed that about 3 years back one
day at about 6.30 pm he was watching TV in his dwelling hut
when he could hear some chaos outside of his house and he
came out and found Biprajit Nath with bleeding injury on his
neck and he was lying on the ground infront of the shop of his
father. Huge persons were present and after that, the victim was
taken to Hospital. He was declared hostile by the prosecution
and his portion of statement was marked as Exbt.-2 subject to
confirm by IO.
During
cross-examination,
he
stated
that
he
had
moderate relation with Ranadhir Nath.
15.
PW-7, Haradhan Bose deposed that on transfer of
previous IO, he took up investigation of the case and during the
part of his investigation, he perused the previous investigation
report and recorded the statement of witness Ashish Paul and
some other witnesses under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. and he
confirmed Exbt.-2 but as he was transferred so he handed over
the case docket to O/C of the PS.
During cross-examination, he stated that during the part
of his investigation, he did not see any other statement of the
witness Ranadhir Nath and Biprajit Nath and he recorded the
statement of the informant Ranadhir Nath on 04.06.2018 and
during investigation, Ranadhir Nath did not produce the blood
stained wearing apparels with blood stained ‘gamcha’.
16.
PW-8, Laxmikanta Singha was also declared hostile by
the prosecution and his portion of statement was marked as
Exbt.-3 subject to confirm by IO.
During cross-examination, nothing came out relevant.
17.
PW-9, Swapan Singha deposed that on 15.10.2018 he
was posted at Dharmanagar PS as Sub-Inspector of Police and
on that day this case was endorsed to him for investigation due
to transfer of previous IO. He visited PO and examined some
witnesses but he recorded the statement of informant Ranadhir
Nath. He collected injury report of the victim Biprajit Nath from
AGMC & GBP Hospital and he submitted charge-sheet against the
appellant Subrata Nath under Section 307 of IPC.
During cross-examination, he stated that in the FIR as
well as in the first statement of the informant recorded under
Section 161 of Cr.P.C, Ranadhir Nath did not disclose anything
regarding motive of the charge-sheeted accused behind the
commission of alleged crime. He did not collect any document
from the complainant to show that the victim Biprajit Nath had
collected any extra money from the accused Subrata Nath
toward sale of his land to accused Subrata Nath denying the
terms and conditions of their earlier agreement. He further
stated that the place of occurrence of this case was near a pond
and the shop of the complainant was situated at a distance of
100 meters from the house of the complainant towards NorthWest side. He also could not say the exact location of the pond.
18.
PW-10, Dr. Sankar Sarkar deposed that on 09.10.2017
he was posted as Registrar, Department of Otorhinolary, Head
and Neck Surgery, AGMC, Agartala. On that day, one patient
Biprajit Nath came in connection with Dharmanagar PS case
No.75 of 2017 was admitted with alleged homicidal lacerated
wound on the neck, both hands and right leg. He examined the
patient and found the wound on the end part of the neck and
injury was slight and caused by blunt object and it was simple in
nature and he identified the report marked as Exbt.-4(as a
whole).
During cross-examination, he stated that he did not
mention the father’s name of the patient in the report and as per
report, the patient was discharged on 19.10.2017. He further
stated that he mentioned as per record in the column case and
symptoms and record means the admission form which was filled
up by the concerned Medical Officer in the Emergency. He could
not say the name of the Medical Officer who was posted at
Emergency on that relevant point of time. The patient was
referred to GBP Hospital from Dharmanagar Hospital but that
was not mentioned in the report and during examination he
found that the wounds were stitched and it was done in
Dharmanagar Hospital.
These are the sum and substances of the evidence on
record of the prosecution in respect of determination of the
charge, produced by the prosecution before the Learned Court
below.
19.
I have heard argument of both the sides and also gone
through the record of the Learned Court below. Admittedly in
this case prosecution could not produce or prove the alleged
weapon of offence for marking exhibit. Nor there was any effort
from the side of IO to seize the same. Prosecution also could not
give any proper explanation regarding the actual place of
occurrence of offence because in the FIR it was mentioned that
the alleged PO was on a drain. But when the witnesses turned up
to the witness box before the Learned Court below, they stated
that the alleged incident took place on the backside of dwelling
hut and the IO when turned to the witness box he stated that
the place of occurrence was near a pond. In this regard, the
prosecution could not explain anything in course of hearing of
argument.
20.
Now if we go through the evidence of victim, it appears
that at the time of alleged occurrence save and except the victim
and the appellant no other persons were there. The victim soon
after the occurrence appeared to the tong shop of his father and
narrated the incident. But save and except the parents of the
victim the other witnesses did not submit anything regarding the
allegation of the prosecution.
21.
Now if we go through the evidence of the parents of the
victim as well as the victim, it appears that those three witnesses
during their examination before the Court deviated from their
earlier statements made to IO. Prosecution also could not explain
anything in this regard in course of hearing of argument.
22.
More interestingly in this case, the prosecution to
substantiate the charge failed to produce any blood stained sand
or the alleged ‘gamcha’ by which the victim according to the
prosecution wrapped his neck. Prosecution also could not explain
anything why those alamats were not seized by IO during
investigation. Prosecution also in course of trial before the
Learned Trial Court also failed to produce the said alamats before
the Court to substantiate the charge.
23.
As already stated, there was no effort from the side of
the prosecution to recover the alleged weapon of offence. Now, if
we go through the evidence of the medical officer who in course
of his examination very specifically stated that the nature of
injury was slight inflicted by blunt weapon but the prosecution
story was that the injury was caused by a knife. Knife cannot be
termed as blunt weapon. The concerned medical officer, PW-10
in course of examination did not submit anything regarding
sustaining of other injuries on other parts of the body by the
victim. There is also no explanation from the side of prosecution
in this regard.
24.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Senior
Counsel Mr. P. K. Biswas relied upon the following citations:
In Syed Ibrahim v. State of Andhra Pradesh bearing
case No.SLP(Cri) No.2787 of 2005 dated 27.07.2006 reported
in AIR 2006 SC 2908 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in para
No.11 observed as under:
“11. In the background of principles set out above it
is to be seen how far the evidence of PW1 is cogent
and credible. Merely because he was the solitary
witness who claimed to have seen the occurrence,
that cannot be a ground to discard his evidence, in
the background of what has been stated in Section
134 of the Evidence Act, 1872 (in short „the Evidence
Act‟). No particular number of witnesses are required
for the proof of any fact, material evidence and not
number of witnesses has to be taken note of by the
courts to ascertain the truth of the allegations made.
Therefore, if the evidence of PW 1 is accepted as
cogent and credible, then the prosecution is to
succeed. It is to be noted that PW1-father of the
appellant, claimed to have set law into motion. The
testimony of PW1 was to the effect that after
witnessing a part of the occurrence he had to run to
the police station and had come back within about
five minutes. The evidence on record dis-proves
veracity of this part of his evidence. The occurrence
is alleged to have taken place and at about 10 P.M.
the FIR was lodged at the police station at about
11.30 P.M. PW1 and the investigating officer
accepted that it will take nearly one hour for
somebody on foot to reach the police station
considering the distance of the alleged place of
occurrence and the police station. There is another
interesting factor PW1 accepted in the cross
examination that the report (Ex.B1) was written in
the police station in the presence of sub inspector
and a constable. But in his examination-in-chief. he
had stated that he had got written the report by
somebody at a hotel and the person normally writes
petitions. No particulars of this person who allegedly
scribed the report, not even his name, was stated by
PW-1. His evidence is further to the effect that he
alone had come to the police station where the report
was lodged and that is how he admitted that the
report was written at the police station. This may not
appear to be that important a factor considering the
illiteracy of PW1. But there is another significant
factor which completely destroys the prosecution
version and the credibility of PW1 as a witness. He
has indicated four different places to be the place of
occurrence. In his examination in chief he stated that
the occurrence took place in his house. In the crossexamination he stated that the incident took place at
the house of his wife-the deceased‟s mother. This is a
very important factor considering the undisputed
position and in fact the admission of PW1 that he and
his wife were separated nearly two decades ago, and
that he was not in visiting terms with his wife. Then
the question would automatically arise as to how in
spite of strained relationship he could have seen the
occurrence as alleged in the house of his wife. That is
not the end of the matter. In his cross examination
he further stated that the incident happened in the
small lane in front of the house of his wife. This is at
clear variance with the statement that the occurrence
took place inside the house where allegedly he, the
deceased, his son-PW2 and daughters PWs. 3 and 6
were present. That is not the final say of the witness.
He accepted that in the FIR (Ex. B1) he had stated
the place of occurrence to be house of the deceased.
Though the FIR is not a substantive evidence yet, the
same can be used to test the veracity of the witness.
PW1 accepted that what was stated in FIR was
correct. When the place of occurrence itself has not
been established it would be not proper to accept the
prosecution version.”
In Mani Ram and Others v. State of U.P. bearing case
No.Crl. A. No.238 of 1993 dated 13.05.1994 reported in 1994
Supp(2) SCC 289 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in para Nos.7
and 9 observed as under:
“7. Learned counsel appearing for the appellants
strenuously urged that Prabhoo Nath, PW 2 is none
else but the real brother of the deceased and,
therefore, he is a highly interested witness and as
such his sole testimony should not be accepted in
convicting the appellants without any corroboration
from independent source. He also submitted that the
evidence of the solitary eyewitness Prabhoo Nath is
not consistent with the medical evidence which fact
by itself is sufficient to hold that he is not an
eyewitness to the incident but a got-up witness
which fact has been ignored by both the courts below
and, therefore, the findings of the two courts below
suffer from serious infirmity and the conviction of the
appellants could not be sustained. On a close scrutiny
of the evidence of Prabhoo Nath, PW 2 and the
evidence of Dr Tekariwal, PW 1, we find that there is
great force in the aforesaid submissions.
9. Apart from the above facts it may be pointed out
that Prabhoo Nath, PW 2 admitted in crossexamination that soon after the appellants emerged
from the sugarcane field and when the appellant
Santram challenged Basdeo, he started running and
at that point of time the appellant Mani Ram was
standing at a distance of 60-70 yards towards eastwest and the appellant Agya Ram who was standing
at distance of about 4-5 feet from Mani Ram chased
Basdeo and both of them fired at him from their
kattas while the deceased was running. This
statement clearly goes to show that the deceased
was fired at from behind when he was running and
the appellants Mani Ram and Agya Ram were chasing
him. That being so the bullet or pellet injuries should
have been caused on his back or at least somewhere
behind his shoulder but as stated earlier according to
the medical evidence and the post-mortem report
injury 7 was caused by a firearm. A perusal of injury
7 will distinctly go to show that there were multiple
gunshot wounds on an area 17 x 13 cms on right
shoulder and front of upper arm and outer part but
there was no injury either on the back or anywhere
behind the shoulder. There is no other gunshot injury
except injury 7. Neither the doctor who first
examined the injured Basdeo nor the doctor who
performed the post-mortem found any injury on the
back or back portion of the shoulder to lend support
to the evidence of the sole eyewitness Prabhoo Nath.
It is well settled by long series of decisions of this
Court that where the direct evidence is not supported
by the expert evidence then the evidence is wanting
in the most material part of the prosecution case and,
therefore, it would be difficult to convict the accused
on the basis of such evidence. If the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses is totally inconsistent with the
medical evidence this is a most fundamental defect in
the prosecution case and unless this inconsistency is
reasonably explained it is sufficient not only to
discredit the evidence but the entire case. In the
present case as noticed above the evidence of the
solitary witness Prabhoo Nath is wholly inconsistent
with the medical evidence and, therefore, it is
difficult to accept him as an eyewitness to the
occurrence and therefore it would not be safe to base
the conviction on the solitary evidence of such a
witness. There is no other evidence to support the
prosecution case. Consequently the conviction of the
appellants deserves to be set aside.”
In State of Haryana v. Inderaj and another bearing
case
No.Crl. A. Nos.532-33 of 1984 dated
30.03.1993
reported in AIR 1994 SC 115 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in
para No.7 observed as under:
“7. These appeals are against the acquittal and since
the High Court has reversed the findings of the trial
Court, to satisfy ourselves, we have gone through the
evidence of the two eye-witnesses carefully. Their
evidence shows that they are interested witnesses.
Therefore, their evidence requires to be the
scrutinised carefully. So far as PW 4 is concerned he
admitted in the cross-examination that he went to
the school at 9 a.m. and he made further admissions
to the effect that being a Republic Day there was a
function in the school and there were certain items
like Flag Hoisting Ceremony, speeches, sports and
prize distribution. The witness being a student aged
18 years is expected to know the time taken in
respect of the each event that took place. If we add
up the timings then as pointed out by the defence
counsel the whole function must be over after 1.15
p.m. in which case the presence of this witness at the
place of the occurrence becomes highly doubtful. The
witness also admitted that he had to cover a distance
of three miles from the school to reach the place of
occurrence. In the cross-examination, he admitted
that he is an interested witness. Then coming to the
evidence of PW 3, no doubt, he gave the F.I.R. at
about 1.40 p.m. but again the doubt would be
whether the occurrence took place at 12 noon or
earlier. In any event his conduct appears to be
unnatural. He deposed that the deceased who is no
other than his nephew, was going in the Gali and he
followed him 10-15 paces behind him but the way he
has described his presence at the scene of the
occurrence there is some doubt regarding his
presence. In this context, it becomes important to
note that the place of occurrence is within a short
distance and there are number of houses in the
vicinity but none of the residents has been examined
at least to show that this witness was present
immediately after the occurrence and the prosecution
has not adduced any evidence to that effect. The
evidence of local Sarpanch DW 1 (Ram Rikh) is that
his house was very close to the place of occurrence
and there is nothing in cross-examination which
warrants rejection of his evidence. DW 1 has stated
that at about 10.30 am he came out and saw the
dead body. Being the resident of the house which is
very close to the place of occurrence, his version
cannot be rejected. If his version is to be accepted
then the presence of PW 3 just at the time of
occurrence becomes doubtful. The prosecution has
not examined any other person from the locality. PW
3 being highly interested witness, has also made
certain improvements regarding the nature of the
weapon used and since the whole case rests on his
sole testimony without any corroboration, we think it
is highly unsafe to convict the respondents in the
appeals against acquittal. For these reasons these
appeals are dismissed.”
In Amar Singh and others v. State of Punjab bearing
case No.Crl. A. No.161 of 1978 dated 17.02.1987 reported in
1987 CRI. L. J. 706 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in para
Nos.10 and 11 observed as under:
“10. In this connection, we may refer to the evidence
of the second eye-witness P.W. 6 Anokh Singh. In his
examination-in-chief this witness sought to support
the prosecution case, but in cross-examination he
stated in clear and unequivocal term that he did not
see Piara Singh deceased receiving any injury at the
hands of the accused. No reliance, therefore, can be
placed on the evidence of P.W. 6. So far as P.W. 4
Murta Singh is concerned, he is not a witness of the
actual incident, as he had started running towards
village Dhariwal on being chased by Amar Singh and
Rattan Singh, sons of Isher Das, and hid himself in
the bushes. He then waited for a short while in the
bushes out of fear and then went to his house. His
mother P.W. 5 told him that his brother Piara Singh
had been murdered in the house of Bachan Singh,
and that he should run away from home. Thus, out of
the three witnesses, the only witness who gave
evidence about the beating of the Piara Singh
deceased by the appellants and the other accused is
P.W. 5 Smt. Veero. Her evidence, as already noticed,
is contrary to the medical evidence.
11. We may further examine the evidence of P.W. 5
as to the place where Piara Singh was alleged to have
been killed. In her examination-in-chief she stated
that all the accused took Piara Singh deceased to the
courtyard of the house of Bachan Singh where he was
beaten by Amar Singh, the appellant No. 1, with
Thappi. Thereafter Piara Singh was dragged inside
the room of the house of Bachan Singh by the
accused persons. In her cross-examination she said
that after killing Piara Singh on the spot, the accused
took him inside the room of the house. The evidence,
however, is that blood was recovered from the room
and no blood was found on the courtyard. Her
evidence is, therefore, inconsistent as to the place
where Piara Singh was killed by the accused. In this
connection, it may be pointed out that although
according to the evidence of P.W. 4 Murta Singh, that
when he came home he found his mother weeping
and she told him that the accused had killed Piara
Singh. In the First Information Report lodged by P.W.
4, there is no mention of the statement of his mother
that Piara Singh was killed by the accused.”
In Ashim Das and etc. etc. v. State of Assam bearing
case No.Crl. A. Nos.109 with 113 and 119 of 1978 dated
02.05.1986 reported in 1987 CRI. L. J. 1533 wherein Hon’ble
the Apex Court in para Nos.7 and 11 observed as under:
“7. Dr. Hawque P. W. 7 who conducted the autopsy,
found five injuries namely; one abrasion, two
lacerated wounds and two ecchymosis. According to
him the death was due to shock and intra-cranial
haemorrhage as a result of injuries sustained. In
cross-examination he has stated that this intracranial
haemorrhage was due to injury No. 4 i.e. ecchymosis
over the left side of the forehead, 3" × 2".
11. In Ram Narain, AIR 1975 SC 1727: (1975 Cri LJ
1500) it was held that if the evidence of the
witnesses for the prosecution is totally inconsistent
with medical evidence, this is a most fundamental
defect in the prosecution case and unless reasonably
explained it is sufficient to discredit the entire case.
In Purshottam, AIR 1980 SC 1873: (1980 Cri LJ
1298) it was held that if there is a contradiction
between medical testimony and alleged eye-witness
regarding fatal injury, medical testimony is to be
preferred. In Maula Bux (1983) 1 SCC 379 it was held
that if there is a discrepancy between the post
mortem report and the inquest report and if the post
mortem and the testimony of the Doctor who
conducted the post mortem if otherwise reliable the
benefit of discrepancy must be given to the accused
by accepting the post mortem report, if it is more
favourable to the accused.”
In Gurmej Singh and others v. State of Punjab
bearing case No.Crl. A. No.778 of 1979 dated 16.07.1991
reported in 1992 CRI. L. J. 293 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court
in para No.8 observed as under:
“8. Counsel for the appellants next submitted that
according to the prosecution appellant Gian Singh
was armed with a Gandasi and he is alleged to have
given a blow therewith on the chest of the deceased.
Ordinarily a Gandasi blow would cause an incised
wound whereas the deceased had an abrasion 5" x 1"
on the chest caused by a hard and blunt substance.
According to counsel normally when a witness
deposes to the use of a particular weapon there is no
warrant for supposing that the blunt side of the
weapon was used by the assailant. In support of this
contention counsel invited our attention to two
decisions, namely, Hallu v. State of M.P. (1974) 4 SCC
300: (1974 Cri LJ 1385) and Nachhattar Singh v.
State of Punjab (1976) 1 SCC 750: (1976 Cri LJ 691).
In his submission, therefore, the injury found on the
chest could not be attributed to Gian Singh who is
stated to have used the Gandasi. We see no merit in
this contention for the simple reason that the
prosecution witnesses have categorically stated that
Gian Singh used the blunt side of the Gandasi. If the
prosecution witnesses were silent in this behalf the
submission of counsel would have carried weight. But
where the prosecution witnesses categorically state
that the blunt side of the weapon was used there is
no room for believing that the sharp side of the
weapon which would be normally used had in fact
been used. The observations in the aforesaid two
judgments do not lay down to the contrary. In fact in
the first mentioned case it is clearly stated that if the
prosecution witnesses have clarified the position,
their evidence would prevail and not the normal
inference. Counsel, however, made a grievance that
the prosecution had not tried to elicit the opinion of
P.W. 1 Dr. Malhotra on the question whether such an
abrasion was possible by a Gandasi blow. According
to him, as held by this Court in Kartarey v. State of U.
P. (1976) 1 SCC 172: (1976 Cri LJ 13) and Ishwar
Singh v. State of U. P. (1976) 4 SCC 355: (1976 Cri LJ
1883), it was the duty of the prosecution to elicit the
opinion of the medical man in this behalf. P.W. 1
clearly stated in the course of his examination-inchief that injuries Nos. 2, 3 and 4 were caused by a
blunt weapon. It is true that he was not specifically
asked if the chest injury could have been caused by
the blunt side of the Gandasi. It cannot be gainsaid
that the prosecution must endeavour to elicit the
opinion of the medical man whether a particular
injury is possible by the weapon with which it is
alleged to have been caused by showing the weapon
to the witness. In fact the Presiding Officer should
himself have elicited the opinion. However, in this
case it should not make much difference because the
evidence of P.Ws. 2 and 3 is acceptable and is
corroborated by the first information report as well
as P.W. 4. If the medical witness had also so opined
it would have lent further corroboration. But the
omission to elicit his opinion cannot render the direct
testimony of P.Ws. 2 and 3 doubtful or weak. We,
therefore, do not see any merit in this submission. In
fact if we turn to the cross-examination of P.W. 1 we
find that the defence case was that these three
injuries were caused by the rubbing of the body
against a hard surface, a version which has to be
stated to be rejected.”
In Miran Bux v. Liloo alias Shagir Ahmad and
others bearing case No.Crl. A. Nos.410 with 411 of 1992
dated 23.07.1993 reported in AIR 1994 SC 1612 wherein
Hon’ble the Apex Court in para No.3 observed as under:
“3. The prosecution case is that one Manzoor Ahmed
gave a report to the police on 8th November, 1983
stating that while he and his cousin were working in
his meat shop and when the deceased Nazruddin was
sitting there at about 8 P.M. the accused armed with
Iron rods and hockey-stick came there all of a sudden
and questioned the deceased and attacked him with
their respective weapons. On the basis of this report
the police registered a crime under Sections 147,
148, 307 and 323 I.P.C. The investigation was
commenced. Later in the night the deceased
Nazaruddin died and an altered FIR was issued. The
inquest was held over the dead body and the Doctor,
who conducted the post-mortem, found 18 external
injuries and one of them was in the head resulting in
a fracture. The Doctor opined that the deceased died
as a result of intra-cranial haemorrhage. The
prosecution relied on the evidence of the eyewitnesses P.Ws 1, 6 and 20. P.W. 1 is the main
witness. He deposed that there was dispute
regarding some money between Lallu, A-1 and the
deceased and there was a fight between them and on
the day of occurrence all the accused came in a body
and attacked the deceased. This witness was crossexamined at length. The High Court has examined the
evidence of this witness in great detail and pointed
out several contradictions and discrepancies. If the
evidence of P. W. 1 had to be believed there must
have been blood on the stones nearby but no blood
was found either in the shop or near the shop or on
the stones covering the nallah. The High Court
pointed out that no explanation has been put
forward. All the other eye-witnesses stated to the
same effect namely that the deceased was attacked
inside the shop but strangely no blood was found.
Likewise is the evidence of other eye-witnesses P.W.
2 Noor Mohmmad. P.Ws. 6, 8, 20 and 21 and the
same has been considered in detail by the High Court.
As rightly observed by the High Court all of them
gave the same version in a parrot-like manner. The
High Court having discussed their evidence in detail
held that they came forward with a version which
cannot be relied upon and they have suppressed the
genesis of the incident. The High Court has also
commented that the investigation was not conducted
in a fair manner.”
In Harchand Singh and another v. State of Haryana
bearing case No.Crl. A. No.32 of 1970 dated 31.08.1973
reported in AIR 1974 SC 344 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in
para No.10 observed as under:
“10. The other eye witness, upon whose testimony
reliance has been placed by the prosecution, is Ram
Asra (PW 14). So far as this witness is concerned, we
find that his presence at the scene of occurrence was
not mentioned by Ajaib Singh deceased in the dying
declaration which was recorded by ASI Harbhajan
Singh at Khanna hospital. According to Ram Asra, he
was working with the deceased at the well when the
three accused came there and assaulted the
deceased. If Ram Asra was, in fact, present and
working with Ajaib Singh deceased at the time of the
occurrence, it is not clear as to why the deceased
should fail to mention that fact in the dying
declaration. The evidence of Amarjit Singh, Mal Singh
and Teja Singh upon which also the prosecution
placed reliance goes to show that Ram Asra had not
witnessed the occurrence. The name of Ram Asra was
in the very nature of things not mentioned in the first
information report, because the said report was
based upon the dying declaration of Ajaib Singh. It
would thus appear that the eye-witness upon whose
testimony the prosecution wants to sustain the
conviction of the appellants is shown to be an
unreliable witness by the other evidence produced by
the prosecution. The present is a case wherein one
set of prosecution evidence condemns the other set
of evidence produced by the prosecution. In the
above state of affairs, we find it difficult to secure a
firm ground upon which to base the conviction of the
accused appellants.”
Referring the said citations, Learned Senior Counsel
drawn the attention of the Court that the principles of the
aforesaid citations can be applied in this case.
25.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. representing the State-
respondent relied upon one citation of Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in connection with case No. Crl. A. No.1587 of 2008
(Birbal Nath v. State of Rajasthan & Ors.) dated 30.10.2023
reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1396 wherein para Nos.20,
21, 22, 23 and 28, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“20. No doubt statement given before police during
investigation under Section 161 are “previous
statements” under Section 145 of the Evidence Act
and therefore can be used to cross-examine a
witness. But this is only for a limited purpose, to
“contradict” such a witness. Even if the defence is
successful in contradicting a witness, it would not
always mean that the contradiction in her two
statements would result in totally discrediting this
witness. It is here that we feel that the learned
judges of the High Court have gone wrong.
21. The contractions in the two statements may or
may not be sufficient to discredit a witness. Section
145 read with Section 155 of the Evidence Act, have
to be carefully applied in a given case. One cannot
lose sight of the fact that PW-2 Rami is an injured
eye witness, and being the wife of the deceased her
presence in their agricultural field on the fateful day
is natural. Her statement in her examination in chief
gives detail of the incident and the precise role
assigned to each of the assailants. This witness was
put to a lengthy cross examination by the defence.
Some discrepancies invariably occur in such cases
when we take into account the fact that this witness
is a woman who resides in a village and is the wife of
a farmer who tills his land and raises crops by his
own hands. In other word, they are not big farmers.
The rural setting, the degree of articulation of such a
witness in a Court of Law are relevant considerations
while evaluating the credibility of such a witness.
Moreover, the lengthy cross examination of a witness
may invariably result in contradictions. But these
contradictions are not always sufficient to discredit a
witness. In Rammi v. State of M.P. (1999) 8 SCC 649,
this Court had held as under:
“24. When an eyewitness is examined at length
it is quite possible for him to make some
discrepancies. No true witness can possibly
escape from making some discrepant details.
Perhaps an untrue witness who is well tutored
can successfully make his testimony totally
non-discrepant. But courts should bear in mind
that it is only when discrepancies in the
evidence of a witness are so incompatible with
the credibility of his version that the court is
justified in jettisoning his evidence. But too
serious a view to be adopted on mere
variations falling in the narration of an incident
(either as between the evidence of two
witnesses or as between two statements of the
same witness) is an unrealistic approach for
judicial scrutiny.”
22. In the same case, how far a contradiction in the
two statements can be used to discredit a witness
has also been discussed.
“25. It is a common practice in trial courts to
make out contradictions form the previous
statement of a witness for confronting him
during cross-examination. Merely because
there is inconsistency in evidence it is not
sufficient to impair the credit of the witness. No
doubt Section 155 of the Evidence Act provides
scope for impeaching the credit of a witness by
proof of an inconsistent former statement. But
a reading of the section would indicate that all
inconsistent statements are not sufficient to
impeach the credit of the witness. The material
portion of the section is extracted below:
“155. Impeaching credit of witness.- The
credit of a witness may be impeached in the
following ways by the adverse party, or, with
the consent of the court, by the party who
calls him –
(1)-(2)***
(3)
by
proof
of
former
statements
inconsistent with any part of his evidence
which is liable to be contradicted;””
“26. A former statement though seemingly
inconsistent with the evidence need not
necessarily be
sufficient to amount to
contradiction. Only such of the inconsistent
statement which is liable to be “contradicted”
would affect the credit of the witness. Section
145 of the Evidence Act also enables the crossexaminer to use any former statement of the
witness, but it cautions that if it is intended to
“contradict” the witness the cross-examiner is
enjoined to comply with the formality
prescribed therein. Section 162 of the Code
also permits the cross-examiner to use the
previous statement of the witness (recorded
under Section 161 of the Code) for the only
limited purpose i.e. to “contradict” the
witness.”
23. In Tahsildar Singh v. State of U.P., AIR 1959 SC
1012, it was held that to contradict a witness would
mean to “discredit” a witness. Therefore, unless and
until the former statement of this witness is capable
of “discrediting” a witness, it would have little
relevance. A mere variation in the two statements
would not be enough to discredit a witness. This has
been followed consistently by this Court in its later
judgment, including Rammi(supra). Moreover, in this
case the High Court lost sight of other more relevant
factors such as the witness being an injured eye
witness.
28. The High Court has gone wrong in its appreciation
of the case, both on facts as well as on law. The
statement of an injured eye-witness is an important
piece of evidence which cannot be easily discarded by
a Court. Minor discrepancies do not matter. In State
of M.P. vs. Mansingh and Others (2003) 10 SCC 414
where conviction of the accused by the trial court,
inter alia, under Section 302, was set aside by the
High Court on the so called discrepancies of an
injured witness this court while allowing the State‟s
appeal against the acquittal said this:
“9. The evidence of injured witness has greater
evidentiary value and unless compelling
reasons exist, their statements are not to be
discarded lightly. Merely because there was no
mention of a knife in the first information
report, that does not wash away the effect of
the evidence tendered by the injured witnesses
PWs 4 and 7. Minor discrepancies do not
corrode the credibility of an otherwise
acceptable
evidence.
The
circumstances
highlighted by the High Court to attach
vulnerability to the evidence of the injured
witnesses are clearly inconsequential.””
Relying upon the said citation, Learned P.P. drawn the
attention of the Court that for the minor contradictions, there is
no scope to disbelieve the entire prosecution story and Learned
Trial Court below considering the materials on record rightly and
reasonably found the appellant to be guilty.
26.
In this case, the charge-sheet was submitted under
Section 307 of IPC against the appellant and the Learned Trial
Court below also framed charge against the appellant under
Section 307 of IPC
but before
the Learned
Trial
Court,
prosecution could not place any materials to sustain the charge
against the appellant under Section 307 of IPC but the Learned
Court below considering the materials on record found the
appellant to be guilty under Section 323 of IPC and convicted
him accordingly.
27.
But here in the given case, from the evidence on record
it appears that in the given case, the evidence of prosecution
suffers
from
various
infirmities
as
discussed
above
and
furthermore from the evidences of victim and his parents, it
appears
that
their
evidences
are
suffering
from
full
of
improvements which they made for the first time in Court
because
the
victim
and
his
parents
although
in
their
examination-in-chief tried to support the version of each other
but during cross-examination, it appears that they have deviated
from their statements recorded by IO during investigation.
Prosecution in course of hearing of argument has failed to
explain those lacunas to sustain the judgment against the
appellant and for such contradiction, it appears to this Court that
the Learned Trial Court below at the time of delivery of judgment
misinterpreted
or
misappreciated
the
evidence
on
record
properly for which in the considered view of this Court the
present appellant deserves to be acquitted on benefit of doubt
for want of corroborating evidence on record as such the
appellant
is
liable
to
be
Furthermore,
the
citations
acquitted
as
on
referred
benefit
by
of
doubt.
Learned
P.P.
representing the prosecution is although very much relevant but
the principle of said citation cannot be applied in this case for
want of convincing evidence on record.
28.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby
allowed. The Judgment and order of conviction and sentence
dated 04.01.2024 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar in connection with case No.S.T.(T-1)
No.22 of 2019 is hereby set aside. The appellant namely Subrata
Nath is hereby acquitted on benefit of doubt and he is set at
liberty. His sureties, if any also stands discharged from the
liability of bond. The case is thus disposed of on contest.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.11.19
DATTA
18:26:48 +05'30'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review