Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.158 of 2024
Shri Subrata Debbarma (Maj. Retd),
Son of Shri Parendra Debbarma, resident of Mainama, P.O. Mainama, P.S.
Longtharaivally, Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799275.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary, New
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2.
The State of Tripura, Secretary of General Administration Political
Department, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3.
Tripura Public Service Commission, represented by the Secretary,
Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC), Akhaura Road, Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin-799001.
4.
The Director, Directorate of Sainik Welfare, Govt. of Tripura, Nehru
Office Complex, Gorkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala-799006.
….Respondent(s)
5.
Smt. Kakali Dhar (Maj.Retd), Daughter of Pijush Kanti Dhar, resident
of Kadamtali, Krishnanagar, Agartala-799001 (Private Chamber).
….Proforma Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Anthony Debbarma, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate
Mr. P. Majumder, Advocate
Mr. D. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
21.11.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for following reliefs:
“i. Issue notice upon the Respondents.
ii. Call for the relevant records.
iii. Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
Selection process for the post of Assistant Director under the Respondents
vide advertisement dated 11/08/2023 shall not be set aside and quashed.
AND
Issue Rule Calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
appointment of the private respondent in the post of Assistant Director
under the Respondents pursuant to advertisement dated 11/08/2023 shall
not be set aside and quashed;
AND/OR
In the alternative, issue Rule Calling upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why the Petitioner shall not be considered for appointment to the post
of Assistant director, Group-B Gazetted, Directorate of Sainik Welfare
under General Administration (Political) Department, Govt. of Tripura
and thereby appoint the petitioner to the said post of Assistant Director,
Directorate of Sainik Welfare under General Administration (Political)
Department, Govt. of Tripura under the respondents.
AND
iv. And after hearing the parties be pleased to make the Rule absolute.”
2.
Facts:
Pursuant to an advertisement dated 11.08.2023(Advt. No.12/2023)
issued by Tripura Public Service Commission (for short, TPSC) to fill up one
vacant post of Assistant Director at the office of the Directorate of Sainik Board
under the Political Department, Govt. of Tripura, the petitioner being a willing
candidate had applied for the said post. He along with other candidates were
invited to appear before the Interview Board. Accordingly, all appeared before
the Selection Committee constituted by the TPSC. After completion of the
selection process, result was declared where the petitioner found that the
respondent no.5, Smt. Kakali Dhar (Maj.Retd) was selected for the said post of
Assistant Director. The petitioner not being happy with the selection of the
respondent no.5 challenged the marks awarded in favour of the respondent no.5
in the viva-voce test.
3.
Heard Mr. Anthony Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the
respondents-State, Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-TPSC and Mr. P. Majumder and Mr. D. Saha, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent no.5.
4.
Contentions of the petitioner:
Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner has submitted that in the API score, the petitioner was awarded 100
marks and the respondent no.5 obtained 90 marks. The petitioner has no
grievance as regards the awarding of marks in regard to the API score. However,
the grievance of the petitioner is that the respondent no.5 was awarded 14 marks
out of 15 marks, which is excessively high and the Selection Board has
arbitrarily awarded only 5 marks in favour of the petitioner. As such, the entire
selection panel had acted arbitrarily against the petitioner.
5.
Contentions of the respondents-TPSC:
Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC has submitted
that the selection panel had selected the best candidate out of all the candidates
appeared before the Interview Board. There was no arbitrariness. The respondent
no.5 performed well and for that reason she was awarded 14 marks out of 15 and
in total she secured more marks than that of the petitioner. The selection process
was conducted on the basis of merit. Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the
respondents-TPSC has further submitted that this is not a case where the writ
Court can exercise its power of judicial review. In support of his submission, Mr.
Datta, learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC has placed reliance upon the
case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi and Ors. vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir and Ors.,
reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 344 (paras 66, 67 and 89).
6.
Contentions of the respondents-State:
Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. GA for the respondents-State has adopted
the submission of Mr. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondentsTPSC.
7.
Contentions on behalf of respondent no.5:
Mr. Majumder, learned counsel for the respondent no.5 has drawn
the attention of this Court to a chart in tabular form reflected in the counter
affidavit as regards the modes of computing the API score and made
submissions in similar tune to that of Mr. Datta, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents-TPSC.
8.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing for
the parties.
9.
Discussion and conclusion:
9.1.
Keeping in mind the facts and submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties, it will be profitable to reproduce the table showing the
awarding of marks in computing total API score of the petitioner and respondent
no.5. The API score calculation of the petitioner and the respondent no.5 is
reproduced hereunder in tabular form:
NAME
Kakali
Dhar
Subrata
Debbarma
Age as
on
25.09.2
49 years
month 1
day
39 years
4 month
19 days
Academic qualification
Type of previous
defense service
Length of Defense service
and age
Total
API
Marks
Matricul
ation
passed
Higher
Seconda
ry Pass
Gradua
tion
Pass
Marks
SSC
O/R
SCO
JCO/
Equiv
alent
Marks
More than
10 years
and below
45 years
Less
than
years
and
abov
e 45
years
age
Marks
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
It is noticed that in course of interview, assessment of the
candidates were made on consideration of his/her intellectual ability, social
traits, interest in current affairs, critical power of judgment, variety and depth of
interest, ability for leadership moral integrity etc. and marks were awarded on
the basis of consensus of the members of the Board.
Thereafter, the final merit list was prepared on the basis of marks
awarded in the interview/personality test and the 85% of API marks. The marks
of API and interview/personality test are as follows:
Sl
No.
Name of
candidate
Total API
Score
85% of
API Score
Kakali Dhar
Subrata
Debbarma
76.50
85.00
9.2.
Marks obtained in
the interview (Out
of 15)
Total marks obtained
(out of 100)
90.50
90.00
In my opinion, this is not a fit case where this Court can exercise its
extraordinary and discretionary jurisdiction as vested upon it under Article 226
of the Constitution of India. The Court’s power to overstep the decision of the
Selection Committee is very limited. It is settled proposition of law that when a
Selection Committee recommends the selection of a person, the same cannot be
presumed to have been done in an errorneous or mistaken manner in the
absence of any allegation of bias or favouritism. In the absence of allegation of
malafides against the members, selection by a Selection Committee should not
be interfered with. Further, this Court cannot act as an appellate authority over
the selection of the candidates in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India. In the case of Madan Lal vs. State of J&K, (1995) 3
SCC 486, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that it was in the exclusive domain of
the expert committee to evaluate the merits of the candidates appearing before it
and the marks to be awarded against each of the candidates after assessing their
merits. In the process, some candidates may secure more marks than the
unsuccessful candidates. In such a case, the Court cannot sit as a Court of
Appeal over the assessment made by such expert committee.
[emphasis supplied]
9.3.
Here, I may gainfully refer the case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi (supra)
where the Hon’ble Supreme Court has delineated the principle of Court’s power
while dealing with similar questions of facts. The relevant paras are reproduced
hereunder:
“66. Thus, the inexorable conclusion that can be drawn is that it is not
within the domain of the Courts, exercising the power of judicial review, to
enter into the merits of a selection process, a task which is the prerogative
of and is within the expert domain of a Selection Committee, subject of
course to a caveat that if there are proven allegations of malfeasance or
violations of statutory rules, only in such cases of inherent arbitrariness,
can the Courts intervene.
67. Thus, Courts while exercising the power of judicial review cannot step
into the shoes of the Selection Committee or assume an appellate role to
examine whether the marks awarded by the Selection Committee in the
viva-voce are excessive and not corresponding to their performance in
such test. The assessment and evaluation of the performance of candidates
appearing before the Selection Committee/Interview Board should be best
left to the members of the committee. In light of the position that a Court
cannot sit in appeal against the decision taken pursuant to a reasonably
sound selection process, the following grounds raised by the writ
petitioners, which are based on an attack of subjective criteria employed
by the selection board/interview panel in assessing the suitability of
candidates, namely, (i) that the candidates who had done their postgraduation had been awarded 10 marks and in the viva-voce, such PG
candidates had been granted either 18 marks or 20 marks out of 20. (ii)
that although the writ petitioners had performed exceptionally well in the
interview, the authorities had acted in an arbitrary manner while carrying
out the selection process, would not hold any water.
89. Only 20 out of 100 marks were allocated for interview/viva-voce. The
same is only 20% of the total marks which cannot be said to be an
excessive proportion out of the total marks. Further Courts cannot sit in
judgment over the award of marks by an interview panel. That is best left
to the judgment and wisdom of the interview panel. In the above premise,
we do not think there is any merit in the contention of the writ petitioners
regarding the award of marks to the candidates who appeared for vivavoce before the panel. Moreover, the award of 80% of the total marks is on
objective criteria depending upon the educational qualification of the
individual candidates.”
10.
In the instant petition, the petitioner has not pleaded or alleged any
bias or malafides or favouritism, neither against the Selection Board nor against
any of its members. Only allegation which has been averred in the present writ
petition is that the petitioner had performed very well in the interview, but, he
was not awarded the marks he deserved. This statement cannot be accepted by
the Court in absence of any substance or materials that evaluation or
assessment of merits of candidates was made erroneously. The assessment and
evaluation of the performance in such interview or viva-voce test should be left
to the members of the selection panel itself. The Court in exercise of its power of
judicial review cannot sit in appeal to arrive at an alternative view other than
the view taken by the experts. The members of the Interview Board have
sufficient expertise and the evaluation of the candidates appearing before such
Board is entirely within the domain of those experts in the panel.
[emphasis supplied]
11.
Mr. Debbarma, learned counsel for the petitioner has urged this
Court that there must be a CCTV camera at the place where the interview was
conducted. According to me, this submission has no relevance to reach to a
decision as regards the question raised in this petition. The petitioner may agitate
this aspect in the appropriate forum. In furtherance thereof, Mr. Datta, learned
counsel for the respondents-TPSC has candidly submitted that there is no system
of installation of CCTV camera inside the room where the interview is
conducted. This Court will not enter into this question while dealing with the
merits of the instant writ petition.
12.
In the instant writ petition, the Court will only decide whether the
petitioner has been able to establish his case for issuance of mandamus upon the
respondents and to quash the selection and appointment of the respondent no.5.
13.
In the light of the above discussion on facts and law and for the
reasons recorded here-in-above, I find no merit in the present writ petition
calling for interference with the selection of the respondent no.5 and her
recommendation for appointment to the post of Assistant Director by the TPSC.
14.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed. However,
there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.11.22
GHOSH 16:49:40 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review