Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)(PIL) No.18/2022
Sri Subhankar Bhowmik, Son of Sri Swapan Bhowmik, permanent resident
of Srinagar, P.O.-Srinagar, P.S.-Manu Bazar, District:-South Tripura, State:
Tripura, PIN-799143, Presently residing at Lake Chowmuhani, Supari
Bagan, Krishna Nagar, PIN-799001.
----- Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Union of India, represented by its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, North
Block, New Delhi-110001.
2. The Asstt. Commissioner of Customs, Agartala Customs Division,
Bordowali, Milan Sangha, Near Mouchak Club, P.O.-A.D. Nagar, Agartala.
3. The Union of India, Its Secretary, Ministry of Commerce, Udyog Bhavan,
New Delhi-110049.
4. The Additional Director General of Foreign Trade, 4, Esplanade East,
Kolkata-700069 (WB).
-----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Angshuman Khound, Advocate,
Ms. Sudipa Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Date of hearing
: 3rd November, 2022.
Date of judgment
: 7th November, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Indrajit Mahanty, C.J.)
The PIL petitioner is seeking issuance of the following
directions by claiming public interest“(a)
This Hon’ble Court be pleased to issue in public interest such
appropriate orders or direction as may deem just and expedient,
directing the Respondents 1 and 3 to initiate appropriate action
against their erring Officers who have failed to deny exemption from
Basic Customs Duty to goods imported by the Transferees under
Transferrable Duty Free Import Authorisation (DFIA) despite nonfulfilment of condition contained in first proviso to condition (iii) of
the Custom Notification No.19 of 2015 and/or issued Transferrable
DFIAs contrary to the provisions and spirit of Foreign Trade Policy;
(b)
This Hon’ble Court be pleased to issue in public interest such
appropriate orders or direction as may deem just and expedient,
directing the officers of the Respondent nos.1 and 3 to forthwith take
steps(i)
To deny exemption from payment of Basic Customs
Duty under Custom Notification No.19 of 2015 in respect of the
goods imported by a Transferee under a Transferrable Duty Free
Import Authorisation (DFIA), for non-fulfilment of condition
contained in first proviso to condition (iii) of the said Notification
read with Paragraphs 4.12 (i), 4.12 (ii), 4.29 (iv) and 4.29 (v) of
Foreign Trade Policy, if the imported goods are not of same quality,
technical characteristics and specifications as the materials used in
the shipping bills;
(ii)
To issue any Transferrable DFIA or to strictly restrict
duty free import entitlement under any Transferrable DFIA already
issued as per any specific material actually used with quality,
technical characteristics and specifications declared by the
exporter/original license holder under Appendix 4H notwithstanding
Paragraph 4.27(i) of FTP and the Standard Input Output Norms;”
2.
The petitioner seeks directions to initiate appropriate action
against their erring Officers who have failed to deny exemption from Basic
Customs Duty to goods imported by the Transferees under Transferrable
Duty Free Import Authorisation (DFIA) despite non-fulfilment of condition
contained in first proviso to condition (iii) of the Custom Notification No.19
of 2015 and/or issued Transferrable DFIAs contrary to the provisions and
spirit of Foreign Trade Policy. He contends that the officers of the
respondent-Union of India have failed in their constitutional and statutory
obligation to confer exemption from duty under Custom Notification No.19
of 2015 to only those Transferees of DFIAs, who fully satisfy all the
provisions of Foreign Trade Policy in its true spirit and also satisfy the
conditions particularly condition (iii) of the said Notification. The petitioner
contends that first proviso to condition (iii) is erroneously being construed to
only require establishing broad nexus of the material to be imported and the
material actually used in the export product, only for their specific name,
description or quantity. He contends that in the first proviso to condition (iii)
close nexus ought to be established even for the quality, technical
characteristics and specifications of the material to be imported and the
material actually used in the export product. He contends that the officers of
the respondent-Union of India have failed to apply these provisions and
conditions with such restrictive meaning in the actual spirit of the Foreign
Trade Policy, and that such failure is resulting in huge revenue leakage. The
inputs referred in paragraphs 4.12 (i) and 4.12 (ii) of FTP can be either
procured domestically or can be imported goods. In either event he contends
that not only the specific name/description and quantity, but also quality,
technical characteristics and specifications shall be declared for such
material actually used in the export of the resultant product. In effect he
contends that requirements applicable in second proviso to condition (iii)
though appear to be construed as restricted to sensitive input items specified
in Paragraph 4.30 of the Foreign Trade Policy, shall equally apply to all
inputs under first proviso to condition (iii) which are referred in paragraphs
4.12 (i) and 4.12 (ii) of FTP even if they are other than sensitive items, and
that the words “the quality, technical characteristics and specifications”
shall be read even into the first proviso to condition (iii) and in Paragraphs
4.12 of the Foreign Trade Policy. He also submits that although the
substantive condition (iii) of Notification No.19 of 2015 refers to the words
“of materials imported”, the words “the material used” in the first proviso
would also include not only the material imported but also even the material
which is domestically procured. The petitioner further submits that
irrespective of the fact that the words “same quality, technical
characteristics and specifications” are used only in second proviso to
condition (iii), the same shall also be necessarily read even in the first
proviso to condition (ii). The petitioner further contends that to restrict duty
exemption in public interest, the officers shall be directed to issue any
Transferrable DFIA or to strictly restrict duty free import entitlement under
any Transferrable DFIA already issued, only as per any specific material
actually used with quality, technical characteristics and specifications
declared by the exporter/original license holder under Appendix 4H,
notwithstanding Paragraph 4.27(i) of FTP and the Standard Input Output
Norms.
3.
The petitioner also submits that Exporters, Traders and
Importers are importing goods by availing exemption without showing the
actual use in the export goods by contending that they are post export
replenishments and, therefore, are not required to satisfy the actual user
conditions under DFIA Scheme. In many of the input goods, though the
input items in SION appears to be of ‘specific entries’, but they are actually
‘generic entries’. However, they are being imported as ‘specific entries’
under DFIAs without establishing close nexus as stated above and cleared
without payment of duty. He had also given examples that in the
Automotive industry, ‘Automotive Spare Parts’ are considered as generic
entries and permitted goods specified under the SION are considered as
specific entries. Similarly, in the Food category, it is claimed that ‘Food
Ingredients’ are generic entries and items specified in the SION are specific.
He has also placed on record certain judgments of different High Courts and
Tribunal which have construed the DFIA Scheme contrary to what the
petitioner is contending and he submits that such judgments are erroneous
and the issue requires consideration. These judgments are(i)
Judgment of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) in the
case of Shah Nanji Nagsi Exports Pvt. Ltd., Vs. UOI and Order of Hon’ble
Supreme Court dismissing SLP thereagainst;
(ii)
Order of the Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) in the case of M/s.
Unicolloide Impex Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Customs, Nhavasheva),
and
(iii)
Judgment of Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Sachin
Pandey v. UOI Through Secy. Ministry of Commerce & Industries & Ors.
4.
The contentions of the petitioner are without any merits.
5.
The subject condition (iii) for exemption from Basic Customs
Duty under Custom Notification No.19 of 2015 reads as under:“(iii) that the description and other specifications wherever
applicable, value and quantity of materials imported are mentioned
in the said authorisation and the value and quantity thereof are
within the limits specified in the said authorisation;
Provided that in respect of inputs referred in paragraphs 4.12
(i) and 4.12 (ii) of the Foreign Trade Policy, the material permitted
to be imported in the said authorisation shall be of the specific
name/description or quantity, respectively, as the material used in
the export of resultant product. The exporter shall declare these
particulars of materials used in the shipping bill or bill of export.
Provided further that in respect of resultant products
requiring inputs specified in paragraph 4.30 of the Foreign Trade
Policy, the materials permitted in the said authorisation shall be of
the same quality, technical characteristics and specifications as the
materials used in the said resultant product. The exporter shall
declare these particulars of materials used in the shipping bill or bill
of export;”
6.
The first and second proviso refer to Paragraphs 4.12(i), 4.12(ii)
and 4.30 of Foreign Trade Policy, which read as under:“4.12 Accounting of Input
(i)
Wherever SION permits use of either (a) a generic input or
(b) alternative input, unless the name of the specific input
together with quantity which has been used in manufacturing
the export product gets indicated/endorsed in the relevant
shipping bill and these inputs, so endorsed, within quantity
specified and match the description in the relevant bill of
entry, the concerned Authorisation will not be redeemed. In
other words, the name/description of the input used (or to be
used) in the Authorisation must match exactly with the
name/description endorsed in the shipping bill.
(ii)
In addition, if in any SION, a single quantity has been
indicated against a number of inputs (more than one input)
then quantities of such inputs to be permitted for import shall
be in proportion to the quantity of these inputs actually
used/consumed in production, within overall quantity against
such group of inputs. Proportion of these inputs actually
used/consumed in production of export product shall be
clearly indicated in shipping bills.”
“4.30 Sensitive Items under Duty Free Import Authorisation
(a)
In respect of following inputs, exporter shall be required to
provide declaration with regard to technical characteristics,
quality and specification in Shipping Bill: “Alloy steel
including Stainless Steel, Copper Alloy, Synthetic Rubber,
Bearings,
Solvent,
Perfumes/Essential
Oil/Aromatic
Chemicals, Surfactants, Relevant Fabrics, Marble, Articles
made of Polypropylene, Articles made of Paper and Paper
Board, Insecticides, Lead Ingots, Zinc Ingots, Citric Acid,
Relevant
Glass
fibre
reinforcement
(Glass
fibre,
Chopped/Stranded Mat, Roving Woven Surfacing Mat),
Relevant Synthetic Resin (unsaturated Polyester Resin, Epoxy
Resin, Vinyl Ester Resin, Hydroxy Ethyl Cellulose), Lining
Material”.
(b)
While issuing Duty Free Import Authorisation, Regional
Authority shall mention technical characteristics, quality and
specification in respect of above inputs in the Authorisation.”
7.
The petitioner cannot seek any action against the officers of the
respondents who have reasonably construed the provisions of the FTP or the
conditions of the Notification as per the plain language thereof. What
petitioner seeks is to read into the provisions of FTP namely in Paragraphs
4.12(i) and 4.12(ii) and also in the first proviso to Condition (iii) of the
Customs exemption notification, further words namely “the same quality,
technical characteristics and specification”, which are specifically omitted.
Such beneficial DFIA scheme which is intended for export promotion,
cannot be construed in such manner as suggested by the petitioner. Such
recourse would be ex facie erroneous and illegal.
8.
It is amply clear that whereas these further words i.e. “same
quality, technical characteristics and specification” are categorically used in
Paragraph 4.30 of FTP and also in the second proviso to the condition (iii) of
the Customs Notification No.19 of 2015, however they are absent in
Paragraph 4.12 of FTP and also in first proviso to condition (iii) of the said
Customs Notification. These further words i.e. “same quality, technical
characteristics and specification” cannot be read in Paragraph 4.12and also
in first proviso to condition (iii). These further words would apply only
while making declaration in shipping bills in respect of sensitive inputs
specified in Paragraph 4.30 of FTP, while issuing DFIA in respect of such
specified sensitive inputs, or while duty free import of such specified
sensitive items under such DFIA to establish close nexus with the specified
sensitive inputs used.
9.
Paragraph 4.27 (i) of the FTP stipulates the eligibility criteria
for issuance of DFIA as follows:“4.27 Eligibility:
(i)
Duty Free Import Authorisation shall be issued on post export
basis for products for which Standard Input Output Norms
have been notified.”
10.
It is clear that Paragraph 4.30 is an exception to the above
Paragraph 4.27(i) of FTP regarding eligibility for issuance of DFIA.
Therefore, wherever sensitive inputs specified in Paragraph 4.30 are used,
the DFIA would be issued to permit import of only those material which
shall not only be of the specific name/description or quantity, but also
having close nexus having “the same quality, technical characteristics and
specification”, as the material used in the export of resultant product. The
exporter would also require to declare all these particulars of materials used
in the shipping bill.
11.
However, in other cases, i.e. wherever sensitive inputs specified
in Paragraph 4.30 are not used, as per Paragraph 4.27(i) of FTP, DFIA
would be issued for products for which SION have been notified and broad
nexus to be established would be limited to specific name/description or
quantity, without requirement of establishing close nexus of having “the
same quality, technical characteristics and specification” as the material
used in the export of resultant product. The exporter would also require to
declare only these limited particulars as per SION, without any requirement
of declaring the quality, technical characteristics and specification of
materials used in the shipping bill.
12.
There is also no merit in the contention of the petitioner that
although the substantive condition (iii) of Notification No.19 of 2015
concerns mentioning in Transferrable DFIA the details “of materials
imported”, in the first proviso the words “as the material used” for the
purpose of ascertaining the “material permitted to be imported” would
include not only the “material imported” but also even such material used
which is “domestically procured”.
13.
Further, the Appendix 4H is “Register for accounting the
consumption and stocks of duty free imported or domestically procured raw
materials, components, etc., allowed under Advance Authorisation/DFIA”.
The said Appendix 4H is prescribed in terms of Paragraph 4.57 of Handbook
of Procedure to ascertain from the exporter/original licence holder
accounting of consumption and stock of duty free goods allowed under
DFIA, whether imported or domestically procured. The said Appendix 4H is
in consonance with Paragraph 4.27(i) of FTP and not in derogation thereof.
It nowhere stipulates requirement of declaration of quality, technical
characteristics and specifications either of the inputs used for the exported
product or of the duty-free goods imported or domestically procured.
14.
Neither the officers nor any Transferee of a transferrable DFIA
issued by the office of DGFT can be subjected to any of the impediments as
suggested by the petitioner in the garb of public interest.
15.
Vide a Judgment dated 18.10.2019, the Hon’ble Allahabad
High Court was pleased to dismiss a similar PIL Civil No.28695 of 2019 in
Sachin Pandey vs. UOI thru Secy. Ministry of Commerce & Industries &
Ors., while inter alia relying upon judgment of Hon’ble Bombay High Court
in Shah Nanji Nagsi Exports Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India reported in 2019
(367) E.L.T. 335 (Bom), with the following observations:“4.
A new Foreign Trade Policy 2015-20 was announced
on 01.04.2015 incorporating various changes under DFIA Scheme.
The FTP for the year 2015-20 provides a frame work and
mechanism for increasing export of Indian goods. In order to
increase the foreign trade, certain concessions have been accorded
to Indian traders.
5.
FTP
2015-20
floated
a
Duty
Free
Import
Authorization Scheme (DFIA) to regulate export viz-a-viz import of
the goods. It is a post export scheme which gave exemption from
basic custom duty while importing specified inputs. The design of the
scheme is like, the merchant/export trader, has to file on-line
application to the concerned regional authority before exporting the
goods under DFIA scheme. It is stipulated that export shall be
completed within the span of twelve months from the date of
generation of particular file number. On completion of export and
realization of proceeds, one has to apply for issuance of DFIA with
the concerned authority. On each transaction, separate DFIA is
issued as per the Standard Input Output Norms (SION). On issuance
of authorization the trader will get exemption from paying basic
custom duty on the goods allowed to be imported under scheme.
6.
In order to give effect to the DFIA Scheme contained
in Foreign Trade Policy 2015-20, the Government of India, Ministry
of Finance, issued Notification dated 1st April, 2015 in exercise of
powers conferred upon it under Sub-section (1) of Section 25 of
Customs Act, 1962. The said notification exempts material imported
into India against a valid DFIA Scheme in terms of paragraph 4.25
and 4.27 of the Foreign Trade Policy, 2015-20, subject to the
conditions contained therein…..”
……….
“11. Sri S.B. Pandey, learned ASG for the respondent no.1
(Union of India) and respondent no.2 (DGFT) and Sri Dipak Seth,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent no.3 (Commissioner of
Customs, Lucknow), opposed the admission of the PIL and submitted
that the PIL is misconceived and the claims made therein are
erroneous.”
………
“13. We are unable to agree with the petitioner. Directions
are being sought by the petitioner against the respondents without
any justifiable grounds. The DFIA Scheme as also the earlier
Transferable DEEC Schemes are based on the Standard Input
Output Norms. In any event, there is no need to go into the issue of
applicability or otherwise of the various judgments referred by the
petitioner.
………
15.
In Shah Nanji Nagsi Exports Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of
India reported in 2019 (367) E.L.T. 335 (Bom), a Division Bench of
the Bombay High Court has also considered the DFIA Scheme and
has observed as under:
25.
It is not denied that popcorn maize has also similar
starch contents as other varieties of maize, indicating that popcorn
maize can be used to manufacture maize starch powder. The scheme
never conveys that there is actual user condition attached to the
import against the export obligation. It amounts to adding some
conditions in the FTP when they never exist. Moreover, when the
authorisation is made transferable under the scheme there is no
question of actual user condition.
27.
As per SION export item at serial No.E-75 is maize
starch powder against which exporter is permitted to import
“maize” without putting any condition or restriction as regards to
variety, quality or characteristic in the said entry. Moreover, there is
no such corresponding condition in licence. In its absence, any
addition of words cannot be imported to change the equation.
Precisely, import of popcorn maize is not excluded from the scope of
term “maize”.
16.
We see no reason to take a different view to take away
the benefits otherwise available under the DFIA Scheme under the
Foreign Trade Policy, whether of 2009-14 or 2015-20, merely to
satisfy the petitioner. According to us the aforesaid judgments of the
Punjab and Haryana High Court and Bombay High Court still hold
the field, so far as permitting duty-free imports under DFIA are
concerned. The contention of the petitioner that duty free import of
any goods under DFIA cannot be permitted unless each of the
abovementioned “three essential conditions” are satisfied, clearly
runs counter to the above judgments which are binding on the
authorities. Neither the officers of the respondents can be proceeded
against for following such binding precedents nor can the exporters
or importers be subjected to any onerous conditions, declaration,
bond or undertaking contrary to these binding precedents, which if
taken would be non-est.
17.
In that view of the matter there is no merit in any of
the prayers of the petitioner. Neither any prima facie case is made
out for grant of writ of prohibition as sought nor for any direction to
initiate departmental or other proceedings against the officers of the
respondents. Similarly, no prima facie case is made out to issue any
direction to prosecute the exporters/importers or to take any action
of recovery against them.
18.
Accordingly, the PIL is dismissed. No order as to
costs.”
16.
These observations of Hon’ble Allahabad High Court are apt
and in accordance with law. None of the decisions of Courts and Tribunal
referred by the petitioner as erroneous actually suffer from any infirmity for
taking a contrary view. The officers of the respondents are rightly complying
with these binding precedents. Neither the officers of the respondents can be
proceeded against for complying with the provisions and notification while
following such binding precedents, nor can a Original Licence Holder or a
Transferee can be denied issuance of any DFIA or exemption under a
Transferrable DFIA by subjecting them to any such unintended onerous
condition or declaration, direction for which are sought in the petition.
17.
In view of the above, no action is warranted against the officers
of the respondent-Union of India even on prima facie basis. On the contrary
the contentions of the petitioner and interpretation put forth by him to seek
action against the officers and to seek further directions in alleged public
interest are ex facie erroneous.
18.
Accordingly, the contentions and prayers of the petitioner are
misconceived and without any merit. The PIL is liable to be dismissed.
(S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Pulak
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review