Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.1067 of 2022
1. Sri Subhajit Deb,
Son of Lt. Susanta Deb, resident of Shibnagar College
Road Extension, P.O. Agartala College, P.S. East
Agartala, Sub-Division-Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Pin-799004, holding the post of Assistant Professor,
Department of Civil Engineering, National Institute of
Technology, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799046, Age-58
2. Smt. Nabanita Bhowmik,
Daughter of Lt. Nitya Gopal Bhowmik, resident of
Ramnagar Road No.6-7, T.G Road, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S.
West Agartala, Sub-Division-Agartala, District-West
Tripura, Pin-799002, holding the post of Assistant
Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, National
Institute of Technology, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin799046, Age-56
3. Sri Dhrubajyoti Bhowmik,
Son of late Dilip Kumar Bhowmik, resident of
Badharghat, Matripalli, P.O. A.D. Nagar, P.S. Amtali,
Sub-Division- Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin799003, holding the post of Assistant Professor,
Department of Computer Science & Engineering,
National Institute of Technology, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799046, Age-57
4. Smt. Dipika Debnath,
Daughter of Sri Haridhan Debnath, resident of Dhaleswar
Road No.7, P.O. Dhaleswar, P.S. East Agartala, SubDivision- Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799007,
holding the post of Assistant Professor, Department of
Civil Engineering, National Institute of Technology,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799046, Age-58
---Petitioners
Versus
1. The Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Education,
Department of Higher Education, having his office at
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi.
2. The Secretary,
Ministry of Education, Department of Higher Education,
having his office at Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi.
3. The National Institute of Technology,
Represented by its Director, having his office at Shastri
Bhawan, New Delhi.
4. The National Institute of Technology, Agartala,
Represented by its Director, having his office at Barjala,
Jirania, West Tripura, Pin-799046.
5. The Registrar, National Institute of Technology,
Agartala, having his office at Barjala, Jirania, West
Tripura, Pin-799046
6. The Dean (Faculty Welfare),
National Institute of Technology, Agartala, having his
office at Barjala, Jirania, West Tripura, Pin-799046
---Respondents.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Somik Deb,
Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Debnath, Advocate
For the Respondents
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery of Judgment & Order :
24.02.2023
23.05.2023
Whether fit for reporting
Yes
:
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
By means of filing the present writ petition, the
petitioners, who had been serving under the National Institute of
Technology, Agartala, Tripura as Assistant Professor (on contract) since
the year 2010 have challenged their reduction in status with reduced pay
structure.
2.
Factual Backgrounds:-
2.1.
All the 4(four) petitioners were engaged to the post of
Assistant Professor (on contract) on consolidated pay under the National
Institute of Technology, Agartala, Tripura after their successful
participation in the selection process at different point of times in
response to various advertisements issued time to time by National
Institute of Technology, Agartala, Tripura (for short, “NIT, Agartala”).
2.2.
The petitioner, Sri Subhajit Deb was engaged in Civil
Engineering Department on a consolidated pay of Rs.29,000/- per month
vide memorandum dated 06.08.2010 with certain terms and conditions
which are as under:“Memorandum
The Director, NIT Agartala, pleased to offer the
contractual engagement of Sri Subhajit Deb in Civil. Engg. on
the following terms and conditions to serve as Contractual
Assistant Professor and other works as and when assign to him
by the competent authority.
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
1. He will receive a consolidated amount of Rs.29,000/(Twenty nine thousand) only p.m. may be paid subject to
satisfactory appraisal report from concerned Head of Deptt.
2. His contractual engagement is valid up to 3(Three) Months
with effect from date of joining.
3. He will entitle for TA/DA whenever he will be deputed for
official duties outside of his head quarter.
4. Since this is a contractual engagement the medical reimbursement facility could not be allowed to him.
5. He will avail the normal holidays and C.L. as applicable to
NIT Agartala. Any other leave is not applicable to him
“except no pay basis”.
6. His letter of acceptance be submitted along with his joining
report, within 7 days from the date of this letter.
7. The allotment of subject/class will be decided by concerned
Head of Deptt.
8. The contract may be terminated by giving 30(thirty) days
notice from either side.
Sd/- illegible
(Dr. D. Bhattacharjee)
05.08.2010
Registrar”
2.3.
The petitioner, Smt. Nabanita Bhowmik also was engaged
against the post of Assistant Professor (on contract) in Civil
Engineering Department on a consolidated pay of Rs.29,000/- per
month vide order dated 04.12.2012 for a period of almost 7(seven)
months of similar terms and conditions as that of Sri Subhajit Deb, the
petitioner no.1. One of the added conditions is that “the future extension
can be provided depending upon the recommendation of the HOD/
Branch In-Charge/Section In-Charge and satisfactory performance.”
2.4.
Similarly, Mr. Dhrubajyoti Bhowmik and Smt. Dipika
Debnath were engaged against the posts of Assistant Professor (on
contract) in the Department of Computer Science & Civil Engineering
respectively vide letters of engagement dated 28.03.2013 and
30.09.2014 on consolidated pay of Rs.30,000/- per month and
Rs.35,000/- per month respectively.
2.5.
On satisfactory performance, the period of contractual
engagements of the petitioners were time to time extended with
enhanced consolidated pay to the extent of Rs.51,032/- along with
additional increments.
2.6.
Lastly,
vide
memorandum
dated
26.08.2022,
the
engagements of the petitioners were extended for a further period of
6(six) months on monthly consolidated pay, but, under the following
fresh terms and conditions:“1. The engagement is not against any sanctioned post.
2. The engagement will be subject to discontinuance at any
point of time without assigning any reason if exigency of
service does not require it or the interest of the institution is
not served to the satisfaction of the engaging authority and
that engagement will not confer any right of continuation or
confirmation under any circumstances.
3. If anyone wants to leave the organization, he/she has to give
one month notice failing which he/she is required to pay one
month‟s consolidated amount to be drawn by him/her at the
time of submission of such notice.
4. You will perform all other works as and when assigned by
the Competent Authority of NIT Agartala.
5. You will be entitled for TA/ DA whenever deputed for
official duties outside the Head Quarters, as applicable to
NIT Agartala.
6. You will be entitled to avail the normal holidays and 04
days C.L. and 5 days Special Leave during the engagement
period. Any other leave is not admissible.
7. You will not be entitled to any Medical Reimbursement /LTC
from NIT Agartala.
8. If any dispute arises between an employee and the NITA, the
decision of Competent Authority, of NIT Agartala will be
final and binding.
Sd/- illegible
26.08.2022
Dean(F/W)”
2.7.
Under the aforesaid memorandum dated 26.08.2022
(Annexure-8 to the writ petition), for the first time, the 2(two) of the
petitioners have been designated as “Temporary Asstt. Prof.” and other
2(two) were designated as “Temporary Faculty” with consolidated
monthly salary of Rs.50,000/- per month.
2.8.
The grievances of the petitioners are two-folds:(a) .
Firstly, change of designation from “Asstt. Prof. (on
contract)” to “Temporary Asstt. Prof.” and “Temporary
Faculty” and,
(b) .
Secondly, reduction of consolidated monthly salary to
Rs.50,000/- from 51,032/- plus increments.
2.9.
It is Pertinent to mention herein that last consolidated
monthly salary of the petitioners no.1, 2, 3 and 4 were Rs.66,903.00,
Rs.58,687.00, 58,687.00 and Rs.53,584.00 respectively.
3.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioners:-
3.1.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioners submitted that the petitioners were first engaged
as Asstt. Prof. on contractual basis in consonance with Draft
Recruitment Rules for Faculty-NIT, dated May, 2010 (for short, “Draft
RR, 2010”) prescribing mode of recruitment in the schedule. This “Draft
RR, 2010” was followed by “NIT Faculty Recruitment Rules, 2011” (for
short, “Recruitment Rules, 2011”) for “Faculty” of NITs, which
prescribed minimum qualification and experience for faculty positions of
National Institutes of Technology (under the standard-3 tier rigid
faculty structure).
3.2.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel had tried to draw my
attention to the Schedule of “Draft RR, 2010”, where against column
no.9 „Method of Recruitment‟ was prescribed as “By direct recruitment,
failing which on deputation, failing which on contract for a maximum
tenure of 5 years”. The prescribed qualification for Asstt. Prof. on
contractual basis was mentioned as “M.Tech/ M.Phil with first class or
qualification with Master or Bachelors degree in appropriate
discipline.”
3.3.
The pointer of his submission is that all the petitioners
were recruited on the basis of “Draft RR, 2010” followed by Model
Recruitment Rules, 2011 where there is specific provision for
appointment of faculty of Asstt. Prof. and faculties on contract basis in
respect of various disciplines.
3.4.
The sudden change of their designation, and re-designating
them as Temporary Asstt. Prof. and Temporary Faculty with reduced
consolidated monthly salary and reduction of their status without
assigning any reason could not be countenanced and was contrary to
National Institute of Technology Act, 2007 (Act No.29 of 2007) as
amended from time to time including its amendment under notification
dated 21.07.2017 (for short, “Statutes 2017”).
3.5.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel emphasized that “Statutes
2017”, prescribed the requirement of Ph.D. for the first time as an
essential qualification to fill up the post of Assistant Professor (on
contract). According to learned senior counsel for the petitioners, the
post of Assistant Professor (on contract) is a statutory post as embodied
in “Draft RR, 2010” and “Model Recruitment Rules,2011”. Mr. Deb,
learned senior counsel contended that „Statutes 2017‟ cannot operate
retrospectively.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents:
4.1
On the other hand, Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy.SGI of
India contended that the advertisements issued by the NIT authority for
engaging contractual faculty only to meet the requirements of the
Institute arose from time to time. These advertisements were for purely
contractual engagement and not for filling up vacant post of Assistant
Professor. Learned Dy.SGI further contended that the engagement of the
petitioners were subject to discontinuation at any point of time without
assigning any reason if exigency of service did not require it or the
interest of the Institute was not served to the satisfaction of the engaging
authority and that engagement would not confer any right of
continuation or confirmation under any circumstance. However, learned
Dy.SGI admitted that extension of the engagement of the petitioners was
based on the performance as assessed by the HOD of the concerned
department.
4.2
Learned Dy.SGI most emphatically submitted that the
Draft RR of MHRD circulated in May, 2010 is only a draft document as
it had not been notified and hence, the petitioners could not take recourse
to it. He further emphasized that as per “Statutes 2017”, Ph.D.
qualification has been made mandatory for the post of Assistant
Professor (on contract). For that reason, the contention raised by the
petitioners that they were engaged under valid Recruitment Rules had no
legal basis and as such liable to be rejected. Learned Dy.SGI had
defended the re-designation of the petitioners and the reduction of pay
structure for the reason that those recommendations were approved by
the NIT, Agartala. He further submitted that since the petitioners had no
requisite qualification, their pay had been reduced.
5.
Analysis:
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties. The principal question to be decided in the
present writ petition filed by the petitioners is whether re-designation of
the petitioners with reduction of pay structure suffers from the vice of
arbitrariness and the relevant notifications issued for this purpose is
liable to be quashed.
5.1
The National Institute of Technology Act, 2007 [here-in-
after referred to as “the NIT Act, 2007”] came into force w.e.f. 6th June,
2007. Section 3(h) defines “notification”, which means a notification
published in the Official Gazette. Section 3(i) defines “prescribed”
which means prescribed by rules made under this Act. Under Section
3(k) “Schedule” means the schedule annexed to the Act.
5.2
Section 26 of the NIT Act, 2007 postulates that:
(1) The first statute of each Institute shall be framed
by the Central Govt. with the prior approval of
the Visitor and a copy of the same shall be laid
as soon as may be before each House of
Parliament.
(2) The board may, from time to time, make new or
additional Statutes or may amend or repeal the
Statutes in the manner provided in this Section.
(3) Every new Statute or addition to the Statutes or
any amendment or repeal of the Statutes shall
require the previous approval of the Visitor who
may grant assent or withhold assent or remit it to
the board for consideration.
(4) A new Statute or a Statute amending or repealing
an existing Statute shall have no validity unless it
has been assented to by the Visitor.
5.3
Section 32(2)(b) empowers or authorises the Council to lay
down policy regarding cadres, method of recruitment and conditions of
service of employees.
5.4
Ministry of Human Resource Development (Department of
Higher Education) [for short, MHRD] vide notification dated 23rd April,
2009 created the “First Statutes for all the National Institutes of
Technology,2009” [here-in-after referred to as the “First Statutes,2009].
This First Statutes was created in exercise of powers conferred by subsection (1) of section 26 of the “NIT Act, 2007” by the Central Govt.,
with prior approval of the Visitor. Under this “First Statutes,2009” the
“Act” is defined under Section 2(1)(a), which means the NIT Act,2007.
Under Section 2(i) “rules” means the rules made under Chapter-III of
the Act and “Schedule” means schedule annexed to these Statutes
[section 2 (j)].
5.5.
Section 23 of “the NIT Act” prescribes that posts other
than the post on contract basis shall be filled up by the Selection
Committees by issuance of publication of advertisements or by
promotion from amongst the members of staff of the Institute. Section
23(8) stipulates that- “where a post is to be filled up on contract basis or
by invitation, the board may constitute such ad hoc Selection Committee,
as circumstance of each case may require”.
5.6.
The MHRD had framed “Draft RR, 2010”. Rule 3
prescribes „Method of Recruitment and other matters‟. Rule 7 deals with
“Other conditions of service” and stipulates that “the other conditions of
service of the Faculty for which no specific provisions have been
provided in these rules shall be regulated in accordance with such rules
as are, from time to time, applicable as per the First Statutes of NITs.
For matters not covered by the Statutes, the Central Govt. Rules shall be
applicable.”
This “Draft
RR,2010” consists of
„SCHEDULE‟,
comtemplating Recruitment Rules [RRs] for the post of Assistant
Professor/Associate Professor and Professor in NIT. Rule 11 prescribes
“Minimum Qualification and Experience”, and for regular appointment
of Assistant Professor, requisite qualification of Ph.D. Degree (with first
class degree at Bachelors or Master‟s level) in appropriate discipline
has been prescribed. Noticeably, for contractual appointments, it is
prescribed that one must have M.Tech/M.Phil with first class or
equivalent grade at Masters or Bachelors degree in appropriate
discipline. Therefore, under the said “Draft RR,2010”, Ph.D. degree is
not a required qualification for engagement/appointment in the post of
Assistant Professor (on contract).
5.7.
In pursuance of the said “Draft RR,2010”, the MHRD had
framed “Model Recruitment Rules,2011” for Faculty of NITs and these
rules were called the “NIT Faculty Recruitment Rules, 2011” [here-inafter referred to as “NIT Faculty RR,2011”]. Rule 2 of “NIT Faculty
RR, 2011” defines „Act‟ which means „NIT Act,2007‟. “Statutes” means
the First Statutes of the NITs and the Statutes subsequently framed by
the respective NIT or framed by the MHRD and “Faculty” means the
Professor, Associate Professor and Assistant Professor of the NITs
[Rule 2(d)]. Rule 4 of “NIT Faculty RR, 2011” prescribes that Faculty
without Ph.D degree shall be regarded on contract basis for a fixed
period not exceeding 5 years.
5.8.
Rule 9 of “NIT Faculty RR 2011” stipulates that the Rules
mentioned in the “NIT Faculty RR 2011” may be amended by the Board
of Governors of the respective NIT for reasons to be recorded in writing.
The amended rules shall not be applied retrospectively and shall take
effect only after they are approved by the MHRD. This “NIT Faculty RR
2011” consists of a „SCHEDULE‟ relating to „Recruitment Rules (RRs)
for the Post of Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and Professor of
NITs. Rule 11(a) of the schedule of the “NIT Faculty RR,2011”
prescribes that „candidates of M.Tech degrees may be appointed as
Assistant Professors, on contract basis only‟.
5.9.
Under the caption “Prescribed Minimum Qualification and
Experience for Faculty Positions of National Institutes of Technology”,
there is specific post designated as “Assistant Professor (on contract)
with Grade Pay of Rs.6000/- PB3 + 2 increments”. The prescribed
essential qualification is M.Tech for the post.
5.10.
Annexure VI to the „Schedule‟ of the “NIT Faculty
RR,2011” postulates specific procedure and circumstances for
appointment of “Faculty on Contract” which lays down that --“when
regular Faculty positions cannot be filled, to Board at its discretion, may
fille up sanctioned Faculty positions “on contract”, where the terms of
separation will be far easier than those who are regular Faculty. Other
facilities and mode of selection, to the extent possible, will be same as
those for regular Faculty. Examples of contractual Faculty will include
Assistant Professors without Ph.D degree under the 3 tier system....”.
5.11.
It further defines “Temporary Faculty” which stipulates
that --“the Director may record temporary faculty” against sanctioned
posts to tide over serious shortage of faculty to handle UG and PG
teaching load. This will be possible only in department where the
number of faculty in position, not counting teachers on allowing leave, is
below 0.75 X normal strength....”
5.12.
The “NIT Act, 2007” has been amended in the year 2012
by Act No. 28 of 2012 as notified on 8th June, 2012 and the said Act
called as “The National Institutes of Technology (Amendment Act)
2012” [here-in-after referred to as “the NIT Amendment Act,2012”].
Under this “NIT Amendment Act, 2012”, the “NIT Act,2007” will be
referred to as the “Principal Act”. Further, amendment has been carried
out changing the nomenclature of the „Act‟ and under Section 3 of the
“NIT Amendment Act, 2012”, it is notified that „in Section 1 of the
Principal Act, in sub-section(I) for the words “National Institutes of
Technology”, the words, “National Institutes of Technology, Science
Education and Research shall be substituted”, that means, in view of the
“NIT Amendment Act,2012”, the nomenclature of the „NITs‟ is changed
and it is re-named as “National Institutes of Technology, Science
Education and Research”.
5.13.
The “National Institutes of Technology, Science Education
and Research Act, 2007” [here-in-after-referred to as the “Principal
Act”] has been further amended by the Act No. 9 of 2014 w.e.f. 4th
March, 2014 and is called as “National Institutes of Technology, Science
Education and Research Amendment Act,2014”.
5.14.
Again, in exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (3)
and sub-section(4) of Section 26 of the Principal Act [29 of 2007], the
Central Govt. with prior approval of the Visitor has amended the “First
Statutes,2009” which is called as “Statutes,2017”. Under Section 12 of
the „Statutes, 2017‟ it is prescribed that „for the purposes of appointment
in the Institute, „Statutes 23‟ of the Principal Statutes has been amended
and it is notified that the rules as approved by the Council or Central
Govt. shall apply.‟ Under Section 12(b) „Statutes 23(4)‟ of the Principal
Statutes has been substituted in the manner as under:
“(4) The Selection Committee, for filling
posts under the Institute (other than the posts on
contract basis) by advertisements or by promotion
from amongst the members of the staff of the Institute,
shall be constituted in such a manner as laid down by
the Central Govt. or Board from time to time by
ordinances”.
5.15.
Under „Schedule E‟ of the “Statutes,2017” qualification for
Assistant Professor (on contract) has been amended, and Ph.D. degree is
prescribed. Under Clause (2) of Note No.1 of the said „Schedule E‟
stipulates that “all new entrants shall have Ph.D. degree in the relevant
or equivalent discipline and shall have first class in the preceding
degrees.”
5.16.
At the foot of „Schedule E‟ by way of inserting a „NOTE‟
it is clarified that “the Principal Statutes were published in the Gazette of
India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section I, sub-section (i) vide Notification
No.G.S..R 280(E), dated the 23rd April, 2009 and subsequent
amendment was published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II,
Section 1, sub-section(i) vide Notification No.G.S.R. 837 (E), dated 5th
November,2015.
5.17.
Now, coming into the merits of the present case, and
keeping in view the aforesaid provisions of law governing the
appointment of Assistant Professor (on contract) with a specific pay
band, it becomes apparent that the appointment of the petitioners as
Assistant Professor (on contract), on different dates of the year 2010 and
further extension of the petitioners cannot in any way be said to be
illegal, as submitted by the Director of NIT, Agartala who was present in
the court in person on the date of hearing at the request of this court. His
submission in respect of the fact that the petitioners were not appointed
by the Selection Committees as stipulated in the “NIT Act, 2007”, in my
opinion, has no force on the ground that Section 23(8) of the “First
Statutes,2009”, the post of Assistant Professor (on contract) can be filled
up by constituting an ad hoc Selection Committee. Again, from the
„Schedule‟ attached to “Draft RR 2010”, it comes to fore that under this
Recruitment Rules, the requisite qualification for appointment to the post
of Assistant Professor on contractual basis is M.Tech/M.Phil with first
class or equivalent grade on Masters and Bachelors degree in appropriate
discipline. It is specifically mentioned in the „Schedule‟ that for regular
appointment to the post of Assistant Professor Ph.D. degree was
necessary. Furthermore, the post Assistant Professor (on contract) as it is
encapsulated in the “Draft RR,2010”, “Recruitment Rules,2011”, “NIT
Faculty RR,2011” and the “Statutes 2009 & 2017” undoubtedly, in my
considered view, be said to be or recognized as a statutory post and also
finds place in the “First Statutes,2009” [Statutes 23(8)]. In addition,
Statute 28 of the “First Statute, 2009” categorically deals with the
method of “Appointments on Contract”. It reads as under:
“28. APPOINTMENT ON CONTRACT
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in these Statutes, the
Board with the prior approval of the Visitor may in special
circumstances appoint an eminent person on contract for a
period not exceeding 5 years.
(2) Subject to the provisions of the Act, the Board may appoint
any person on contract in the prescribed scales of pay and on
terms and conditions applicable to the relevant post for a
period not exceeding 3 years.
(3) For making such appointments, the Chairperson, Board of
Governors shall constitute such ad hoc Selection Committee,
as the circumstances of each case may require.
Provided that such constitution of committee shall be
reported to the Board for confirmation.
5.18.
In the case in hand, for filling up the vacant post of
Assistant Professor, in various disciplines, in the NIT, Agartala, the
Registrar, issued various advertisements from time to time. Pursuant to
such advertisements, the petitioners participated in their respective
selection process and were selected for appointment in their respective
posts. Subsequently, the Registrar, NIT, Agartala issued offers of
appointments to the post of Assistant Professor (on contract), in various
departments, in favour of the petitioners. After a certain period of time
and based on the approval accorded by the competent authority the
contractual services of the petitioners were extended and they were
holding such posts continuously till their status was altered to
“Temporary Faculty” with simultaneous reduction of their pay
structures. The petitioners submitted representations for reconsideration
of restoration of their earlier salary along with the granted increments,
but, those representations were not addressed to by the respondents.
Annexure-VI of the “First Statutes 2009” deals with both “Faculty on
Contract” and “Temporary Faculty” [Annexure-7 to the writ petition,
pages 140 -141 respectively].
For convenience, it is reproduced here-in-below again:
“Faculty on Contract”
When regular faculty positions cannot be filled, to
Board at its discretion, may fill up sanctioned faculty
positions “on contract”, where the terms of separation
will be far easier than those of regular faculty. Other
facilities and mode of selection, to the extent possible, will
be same as those for regular faculty. Examples of
contractual faculty will include Assistant Professors
without Ph.D. degree under the 3 tier system…….”
“Temporary Faculty”
The director may recruit “Temporary faculty”
against sanctioned posts to tide over serious shortage of
faculty to handle UG & PG teaching load. This will be
possible only in departments where the number of faculty
in position, not counting teachings on long leave, is below
0.75 X normal strength….”
5.19.
On conjoint reading of the above, in the opinion of this
court, the nature and purpose of appointment of Assistant Professor on
contract) and the recruitment of “Temporary Faculty” is quite different
having distinguished features. The post of Assistant Professor (on
contract) is filled up against sanctioned faculty positions when the post
of “Family” cannot be filled up regular basis. The purpose of
recruitment of “Temporary Faculty” is to meet/overcome serious
shortage of faculty to handle UG and PG teaching load, that is,
contingent to certain situations.
5.20.
On careful scrutiny of the “Statutes, 2017”, it is evident
that the prescribed qualifications (Ph.D.) as required for appointment of
Assistant Professor (on contract) cannot be enforced against the
Assistant Professor who have already been holding the post of Assistant
Professor (on contract). From „Note 1‟ of the “Statutes,2017”, it is
apparent that this prescribed qualification (Ph.D.) is applicable in respect
of “new entrants” in the NIT and this expressed clarification clearly
suggests that the “Statutes,2017” has not been given retrospective effect
and thus, it protects the service of the contractual Assistant Professors
appointed under the Principal Statutes and Rules thereunder. As such,
the impugned notifications dated 14.07.2020 & 26.08.2022 altering the
status of the petitioners with reduction of pay structures is wholly illegal,
arbitrary and inconsistent to that of the “Statutes, 2017”.
5.21.
It is further well-settled that unless an Act or Rule
expressly or by necessary implication is made to have been given
retrospective effect or shows the intention of the legislature to affect
existing rights, such amended Act or Rules must be held to be
prospective and cannot curtail the existing rights of the persons
appointed under the Original Act or Rules [Ref. P. Mahendran & Ors.
Vrs. State of Karnataka & Ors. along with another connected writ
petition, (1990) 1 SCC 411].
[Emphasis supplied]
5.22.
In addendum, the above analysis of this court is further
fortified in view of the clarification made by MHRD vide
communication dated 31.01.2018 (though not submitted by learned
counsel appearing for the parties) as regards controversy arising out of
the requirement of Ph.D. under “Statutes,2017” for appointment in
relevant or equivalent discipline. The said communication dated 31 st
January,2018
[Ref.
F.No.33-9/2011-TS.III]
may
be
reproduced
hereunder, for convenience, in verbatim:
“F.No.33-9/2011—TS.III
Government of India
Ministry of Human Resource Development
Department of Higher Education
To
The Director,
National Institute of Technology,Rourkela,
Rourkela—769008(Odisha).
Subject:- Clarification on Recruitment Rules for Faculty of
NITs and IIEST-regarding.
Sir,
I am directed to refer to National Institute of
Technology, Rourkela‟s letter No.NITR/RG/2018/L/0170 dated
23rd January,2018 on the subject mentioned above and to state
that the condition of first class in preceding degrees was
published in the Gazette of India on 24th July,2017 as per
decision of the Council. As per the new RRs notified in the
Gazette, the new entrants are required to have Ph.D. in
relevant or equivalent discipline and shall have first class in
the preceding degrees.
2.
In above context, the new entrant means a candidate
who is not existing faculty of concerned NIT. Therefore,
existing faculty will not be considered as new entrant. Apart
from this, there will not be any distinction between the external
and internal candidates with regard to the requirement of
qualification and experience. It is requested to kindly adhere to
the RRs notified in the Gazette on 24th July,2017 by the
Ministry.
3.
This issues with the approval of the competent
authority in the Ministry.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/[K. Rajan]
Under Secretary to the Government of India”
5.23.
In the above clarification, it is clearly stated that required
qualification of Ph.D. in relevant or equivalent discipline under
“Statute,2017” for filling up the post of Assistant Professor (on contract)
at respective disciplines will be applicable to new entrants and “new
entrant” means a candidate who is not an existing faculty of concerned
NIT. Therefore, such existing faculty will not be considered as “new
entrant”. So, I may unhesitatingly hold that the petitioners being the
existing Assistant Professor (on contract) cannot be treated as new
entrants.
5.24.
More importantly, “Statutes,2017” is not in supersession or
in derogation of the provisions of the “First Statutes,2009”. “Statutes,
2017” is an amendment to the “First Statutes, 2009”. At the cost of
repletion, it is significant to notice that at the foot of the “Statutes, 2017”
by way of incorporating a “NOTE”, the framers of the Statutes have
clarified that the Principal Statutes were published in the gazette of India
vide notification number G.S.R. 280(E), dated 23rd April,2009 and
subsequent amendment was published vide notification number G.S.R.
837 (E) dated, 5th November,2015, meaning thereby, one is not
overlapping to another as tried to be projected by the respondents in the
present controversy.
5.25.
issued
In the light of above propositions, the impugned orders
by
the
competent
authorities
of
the
respondents
in
alteration/reduction of the status of the petitioners designated them as
“Temporary Faculty” or “Temporary Assistant Professor” with reduction
of pay structure and placing their services against non-sanctioned post
from their original engagement against sanctioned posts are wholly
illegal, arbitrary and inconsistent with the „Statutes, 2017‟ and cannot be
sustained in law. In furtherance thereof, it is settled principle of law that
one set of contractual employees cannot be replaced/substituted by
another fresh set of contractual employees.
5.26.
Applying the aforesaid principle, in the instant case, the
petitioners having held the post of Assistant Professors appointed on
contract basis cannot be replaced/substituted by another set of
contractual employees on the ground that new qualification (Ph.D.)
appended to by the amended Statutes [“Statutes,2017”] does not erase or
wipe out the qualification prescribed under “NIT Faculty Statutes,2009”
i.e. the Principal Statute and Rules thereunder, where, for filling up the
post of Assistant Professor (on contract), Ph.D. was not the requisite
qualification. As such, the posts of Assistant Professor (on contract) held
by the petitioners cannot be replaced/substituted by another set of
Assistant Professor (on contract) merely because new recruitment policy
prescribes higher qualification for the same post. However, this right of
contractual Assistant Professor will be limited uptill the posts are filled
up on regular basis.
[Emphasis supplied]
Needless to say, by now, the petitioners having served the
respondents satisfactorily as Assistant Professor for the last 13 (thirteen)
years have already gained substantial experience to provide quality
teaching to the students. So, the appointment made under First Statute,
2009 cannot be disturbed/dislodged in any manner whatsoever. Of
course, the respondents have every right to fill up the unfilled vacant
posts of Assistant Professor (on contract) by the candidates having Ph.D.
degree as prescribed under “Statutes,2017”.
5.27.
The above propositions made by this court, in the context
of the present case, gets support from sub-section (3) of Section 34 of
the Principal Act, which mandates that Parliament may make
modification or annul in a provision of the Act or Rules made
thereunder, but, any such modification or annulment shall be without
prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under that Rule. In
light of this, the placement of the petitioners against non-sanctioned
posts from sanctioned posts of Assistant Professor (on contract) is,
according to this court not only contrary to Section 34(3) of the Principal
Act [“Statutes,2009”], but also inconsistent to the intention of the
framers of the Statutes.
5.28.
In the light of the above provisions, the appointments of
the petitioners made under “Draft RR, 2010” and “NIT Faculty RR,
2011” cannot be disturbed or dislodged in view of the “Statute,2017”.
This proposition is further fortified from Rule 9 of “NIT Faculty RR,
2011”, where it is specifically stated that the Recruitment Rules may be
amended but the amended rules shall not be applied retrospectively.
[Emphasis supplied]
5.29.
There is yet another aspect to be noticed, in the context of
the present controversy. It is an admitted fact that the petitioners were
appointed
in
pursuance
of
advertisements
where
educational
qualification was prescribed. Those advertisements were notified in
terms of the Recruitment Rules that were prevailing in the year 2009 i.e.
rules framed under the “First Statutes, 2009”, the “Draft RR, 2010”, and
the “NIT Faculty RR, 2011” there-under. The petitioners were found to
be eligible and were otherwise qualified in accordance with the relevant
rules, and the terms contained in the advertisements.
5.30.
As I said earlier, in the instant case also the
“Statutes,2017” does not postulate any such provision where it has been
given retrospective effect affecting the existing rights of the persons
appointed under the “First Statutes, 2009” that is the “Principal Statutes”
and the Recruitment Rules made thereunder, rather, sub-section (3) of
Section 34 of the “Principal Act,2007” clearly mandates that any
modification or amendment will not affect or prejudice in any way to the
validity of anything previously done under that rule, which existed at the
relevant point of time.
[Emphasis supplied]
5.31.
Another important aspect relevant to mention herein that
the respondents while issuing the impugned Memorandum dated
26.08.2022 converting the services of the petitioners from the sanctioned
posts of Assistant Professor (on contract) to the non-sanctioned posts of
“Temporary Faculty” and “Temporary Assistant Professor” wholly
ignored the relevant provisions embodied in “NIT Act,2007” read with
the relevant Recruitment Rules and Statutes thereof as extracted and
discussed in the preceding paragraphs in detail, which, in the opinion of
this court, is per se irrational, unwarranted, arbitrary and capricious and
is, therefore, liable to set aside and quashed.
5.32
Lastly, I have also considered the submission of learned
Dy.SGI that the instant writ petition filed by the petitioners is barred by
the principle of constructive res judicata in view of the judgment and
order passed in WP(C) 342 of 2018 [Dr. Sagnik Pal & Ors. Vrs. The NIT
& Ors.] where one of the petitioners of the present writ petition was also
a party to the earlier round of litigation. On perusal of the facts stated in
that writ petition, it appears that by way of filing the aforenoted writ
petition the petitioners had urged for issuance of writ of certiorari for
setting aside an advertisement dated 22.09.2017 and sought for
regularizing to the post of Assistant Professor. But, in the instant writ
petition, the petitioners have challenged the alteration of their status of
Assistant professor (on contract) from their original post of Assistant
Professor (on contract) and cause of action of the present writ petition
arose when the Memorandum dated 26.08.2022 had been issued by the
competent authority of the respondents whereby and whereunder the
respondents have reduced their status with reduction of pay structure,
that is, their fresh engagement vide communications dated 14.07.2020
[Annexure-4 to the writ petition] on consolidated pay of Rs.50,000/- per
month. In view of this, according to this court, the present writ petition is
not barred by the principles of constructive res judicata and accordingly,
this submission of learned Dy.SGI is repelled.
6.
Conclusion:
For the reasons stated and discussed above on the relevant
Acts and Rules vis-à-vis the Principal Statues [“Statutes,2009”] qua the
amended Statutes [“Statutes,2017”], this writ petition stands disposed
with the following directions:(i)
The respondents are directed to restore the initial
engagement or original status of the petitioners as
Assistant Professor (on contract) within 7(seven)
days from the date of receipt of the copy of this
judgment, revoking or rescinding the Memorandum
dated 26.08.2022 [Annexure-8 to the writ petition];
(ii)
the reduction of pay structures of the petitioners is
declared as illegal and arbitrary;
(iii)
fresh
engagements
of
the
petitioners
vide
communications dated 14.07.2020 [Annexure-4 to
the writ petition] determining their salary on
consolidated pay of Rs.50,000/- is hereby declared
as void ab initio and non est and the respondents are
directed to restore their last pay structures;
(iv)
the salaries of the petitioners including arrears, if
any, shall be disbursed within 30 days from the date
the petitioners place a copy of this judgment to the
Director, NIT, Agartala;
(v)
the Memorandum dated 26.08.2022 [Annexure-8 to
the writ petition] putting their services against non-
sanctioned post changing their designation from
Assistant Professor (on contract) to “Temporary
Faculty” or “Temporary Assistant Professor” stands
set aside and quashed; and
(vi)
the respondents are at liberty to make fresh
engagements/appointments
in
terms
of
“Statutes,2017” against the vacant posts without
disturbing
engagements/appointments
of
the
petitioners as Assistant Professor (on contract) till
regular appointments are made against the posts of
Assistant Professor.
AND
(vii) However, the prayer of the petitioners to pass a
direction upon the respondents for regularization of
their services as Assistant Professor with regular pay
scales is hereby rejected.
JUDGE
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review