Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.351/2022
Sri Somen Baidya, S/O. Sri Ratan Lal Baidya, R/O. Vill. & P.O. Kashari,
P.S.- P.R Bari, District- South Tripura, PIN-799150, age about-37 years.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by its Principal Secretary to the
Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Tripura, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
2. The Director, Directorate of Health Services, Government of Tripura,
P.O.-Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
3. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
4. The L.R. & Secretary, Law Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate,
Ms. N.C. Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
23/06/2023
Heard Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate
assisted by Mr .Soumyadeep Saha, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-State.
2.
This is the second round of litigation by the petitioner for
appointment to the post of Pharmacist (ALLO) under the Health & Family
Welfare Department, Government of Tripura conducted under the
advertisement published on 01.11.2013 and 02.11.2013. In total, 73 posts
were notified out of which 47 were recommended vide Annexure-1 page-20
by the Interview Board. Petitioner participated in the walk-in-interview and
got 9(nine) marks. Since, petitioner's name was not recommended, he
approached the Court in the previous writ petition bearing WP(C) No.99 of
2015. The case was decided on 10.02.2020 in the following manner:
"[4] Having carefully scrutinized the records as
produced before this court, this court finds that the
respondents No.1 & 2 had made attempt to invoke the
doctrine of estoppel by conduct against the petitioner as after
his participation in the selection process when he found
himself out of the fray, he has challenged the very process
itself by which he sought to achieve the selection. In this
regard, however, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned GA referred a
decision of the Calcutta High Court in State of West Bengal
& Others vs. Chandra Kanta Ganguli [judgment dated
26.04.2017 delivered in MAT 949 of 2016 & Ors.] where the
Calcutta High Court has observed that where there is no
allegation of any bias or favouritism, the recruitment process
cannot be set aside on some technical flaws, here and there. It
is an uphill task on the part of the selection committee to
interview huge number of candidates on a single day and
prepare the merit panel. The method which is to be selected
for getting the best candidates out of the basket depends on
the nature of job attached to the post. Therefore, Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. has indicated that the selection on
the maximum mark of 20 cannot be questioned by the
petitioner inasmuch as there is no specific allegation of bias,
mala-fide or manipulation against the selection committee/
board. Even the members of the selection committee are not
party in the proceeding. Therefore, against them no allegation
can be made, even if there is some allegation as not
incorporated in the writ petition. Only the mode has been
questioned as there is no such allegation that the said mode is
not equivalent for all the candidates. The impossibility of
taking interview of huge number of candidates cannot be a
ground for challenging the selection process inasmuch as in
Sadananda Halo & Ors. vs. Momtaz Ali Sheikh & Ors.,
reported in (2008) 4 SCC 619, it has been observed that the
court cannot interfere with the recruitment process
mechanically and in a mathematical manner by setting its own
benchmark. The apex court has further observed that instead
of testing the matter on the basis of the ground realities the
court shall take a decision and make the balance before
interfering with the selection process. Mr. Bhowmik, learned
counsel has submitted that still there is vacancy and the
respondents No.1 & 2 may be directed to appoint the
petitioner and if necessary to adjust the vacancy when the
vacancy might be available from the reserved category, such
as Ex-serviceman etc. It is apparent that there is no challenge
against the bona fide of the selection process and as such, this
court is not inclined to interfere with the selection process but
so far the pointed allegation of not having the registration as
the Pharmacist by the respondent No.10 is concerned, this
court is of the view that in absence of the registration as the
Pharmacist, no Pharmacist [Allo] can be appointed inasmuch
he will otherwise stand prohibited from dispensing the
medicine to the patient for which he was being observed to
find his suitability to be appointed as the Pharmacist [Allo].
Be that as it may, it has not been denied that the respondent
No.10 had the essential qualifications of getting the
registration as the Pharmacist under the State Pharmacy
Council. It is a mere formality to register someone. Without
taking a hyper technical view of the matter, this court is of the
view that since already the respondent No.10 has been granted
the registration as the Pharmacist [Allopathy], his service may
not be disturbed. That apart, the respondent No.10 has got 12
out of 20. The petitioner had got 9 out of 20. This court does
not have the jurisdiction in the background fact to verify the
process of the selection committee and as stated earlier, there
is no challenge in respect of fairness or integrity of the
selection process. Further, there is no allegation of mala fide
against the members of the selection committee. But it
appears that the petitioner is a suitable candidate. Therefore,
the respondents No.1 & 2 may consider on the appointment of
the petitioner against the vacancy, if any available, and if
required by adjustment. Result of such consideration be
communicated to the petitioner within a period of 3 months
from today. The observation as made on the basis of the
records of the interview as conducted by the respondents No.1
& 2 is fair consideration and the consequential action.
With this observation and direction, this writ petition
stands disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs."
3.
Petitioner was communicated by letter dated 07.12.2020 issued
by the Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura that there is no
scope to consider the matter of his appointment for the post of Pharmacist
(ALLO). Being aggrieved, he has approached this Court again.
4.
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner, has
urged a number of grounds in support of the reliefs prayed for, i.e. (a)
asking the respondents to show-cause as to why he shall not be appointed on
the post of Pharmacist (ALLO) on the basis of the walk-in-interview held on
18.11.2013 and 19.11.2013; and (b) as to why the communication dated
07.12.2020 by which his claim was denied be not set aside.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn the attention of
the Court to the notings obtained under RTI under Annexure-7 whereunder
at one stage on 01.06.2020, the matter was recommended for approval of the
Council of Ministers. However, later on, the Law Department raised
objections which are contained in the notings dated 13.11.2020 at page-72/
73 of the writ petition. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
Writ Court had found the petitioner suitable and also directed the
respondents No.1 and 2 to consider his appointment against the vacancy, if
any, available and if required by adjustment. Though respondents have
taken a plea in the counter affidavit that between 9 and 12 marks, there were
91 candidates and many having more marks than the petitioner but since
other candidates either did not agitate their claim or the panel had lost its
force after one year since it was prepared in 2015, there was no occasion to
consider the case of the other candidates as has been opined by the Law
Department. As such, the direction of the learned Writ Court has been
frustrated on completely untenable grounds. Therefore, respondents should
be directed to appoint the petitioner since the vacancies on the post of
Pharmacist (ALLO) exist out of the already notified 73 vacancies and
moreover, further vacancies have accrued in between.
6.
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State, has objected to the submissions relying
upon the contents of the counter affidavit. One of the grounds regarding the
eligibility of one Protim Kr. Sinha who was appointed as a Pharmacist
(ALLO) under the same interview has also been categorically answered at
paragraph-14 of the counter affidavit by stating that the said candidate was
holding a valid registration under the Tripura State Pharmacy Council at the
time of the said walk-in-interview held in the year 2013 and his registration
number is A-2175. Therefore, the statements made by the petitioner are
baseless and imaginary and denied. However, on the main contention of the
petitioner, it has been averred that there are altogether 91 candidates who
scored marks between 9 to 12 and petitioner had scored 9 marks only. As
such, even considering the number of available vacancies which were
discussed in the notings on the file, petitioner did not stand a chance of
being appointed ahead of the better candidates. In further support of the
aforesaid contention, it is stated that other writ petitions were also filed by
12 other candidates out of whom 5(five) candidates secured more marks
than the petitioner but those writ petitions were dismissed. One of those writ
petitioners had approached the appellate Court wherein certain directions
were issued regarding apportionment of the total vacancies on the basis of
50% reservation to the reserved category. As such, none of those candidates
also succeeded. The department has taken an overall view of the matter and
since there were several candidates with more marks than the petitioner
between 9 to 12 marks, petitioner cannot stake a legal right or violation of
fundamental right to be appointed on the post of Pharmacist (ALLO) despite
the observations of the Writ Court on the previous occasion that he was a
suitable candidate.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties, the relevant facts and materials placed from the records and taken
note above which pose the only question whether the petitioner was eligible
and fit to be appointed on the post of Pharmacist (ALLO) on the basis of the
9(nine) marks secured by him in the walk-in-interview held in November,
2013. It appears that the case of the writ petitioner was decided on
10.02.2020. Though the life of a panel ordinarily remains for one year or
otherwise as per the rules prescribed but since the cause of action had been
raised in 2015 and the decision of the Writ Court came in February, 2020,
relief could not have been denied only on the ground of lapse of panel
beyond the expiry of one year. However, in order to consider the case of the
petitioner, the respondents were obliged to take into consideration the
comparative merit of the candidates in that panel and the number of
vacancies available for appointment to the suitable candidates. As it appears,
petitioner got 9 marks whereas between 9 to 12 marks there were 91
candidates. As such, petitioner's claim could not be better off than the
candidates who were above in the panel on the basis of the higher marks
obtained by them. It is not a case that any person having lower marks than
the petitioner has been appointed by the respondents making out a case of
discrimination and violation of right to equality under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. Petitioner as such cannot claim a legal right to be
appointed only on the existence of certain vacancies out of the notified
vacancies or that have accrued thereafter if no candidate having lesser marks
than him has been appointed by the respondents. The contention of the
petitioner regarding the appointment of one Protim Kr. Sinha has been
adequately answered by the respondents in their counter affidavit to justify
his appointment on the ground that he was holding a valid registration under
the Tripura State Pharmacy Council.
8.
Be that as it may, on a comprehensive and overall
consideration of the contentions raised by the writ petitioner, this Court is of
the view that petitioner has not been able to make out a case of violation of
any fundamental or legal right to be conferred the appointment of
Pharmacist (ALLO) on the basis of the marks obtained by him during the
walk-in-interview under the advertisement published on 01.11.2013 and
02.11.2013. As such, the writ petition being devoid of merit is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Date: 2023.06.27
PULAK BANIK 12:46:16 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review