Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.783 of 2023
Sri Shyamal Chakraborty
S/O late Sunil Chakraborty resident of- A.D Nagar,
Road No.-9, near Sanghasri Club, Surjya Para,
P.O & P.S- A.D Nagar,
District- West Tripura Pin-799003
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary, Department of Home (Jail),
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
Civil Secretariat, P.O- Kunjaban, P.S- New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura, Pin-799006
2. The Inspector General of Prisons,
Government of Tripura, Prisons Directorate, Dhaleswar,
P.O- Dhaleswar, P.S- East Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Pin-799007.
3. The Superintendent, Sonamura Sub-Jail,
(SDM, Sonamura), P.O- Sonamura,
District- Sepahijala, Pin-799131.
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Adocate
For respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.
Date of hearing &
Delivery of Judgment & Order :
06.02.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
By way of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the impugned transfer order dated 05.12.2023 issued by the
Inspector General of Prisons, Tripura whereby and whereunder he has been
transferred from Sonamura Sub-Jail to Gandachherra Sub-Jail (Annexure-19,
page-66 to the writ petition).
2.
I have heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned G.A. appearing for
the respondents-State.
3.
Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the petitioner has agitated four
grounds to challenge the said impugned order of transfer. These are:- (i)
The petitioner has been frequently transferred, (ii) The transfer is aimed to
accommodate one Sri Tapan Shil, (iii) His present health conditions, (iv)
Rules framed for regulating transfer of jail employees.
4.
In order to justify frequent transfer, the petitioner has stated in
his writ petition that by an order dated 20.06.2018, the petitioner had been
transferred from Kendriya Sansodhanagar, Bishalgarh, Tripura to Longtharai
Valley Sub-Jail, Dhalai District, Tripura wherein he served for 2 years 3
months. Thereafter, by an order dated 06.10.2020, the petitioner had been
again transferred from Longtharai Valley Sub-Jail to Udaipur District Jail.
Thereafter, under order dated 04.10.2021, the petitioner had been transferred
from Udaipur District Jail to Kendriya Sansodhanagar, Bishalgarh, Tripura.
Again, vide order dated 10.01.2023, the petitioner had been transferred from
Kendriya Sansodhanagar, Bishalgarh to Sonamura Sub-Jail. While he had
been discharging his duties as Pharmacist at Sonamura Sub-Jail, the
petitioner had been again transferred to Gandachherra Sub-Jail vide
impugned order dated 05.12.2023.
5.
According to learned counsel for the petitioner, the aforesaid
transfer orders were so frequent that itself suggests arbitrariness on the part
of the respondents-State, particularly, IG Prisons, the respondent no.2
herein.
Secondly, the IG Prisons has transferred the petitioner from
Sonamura Sub-Jail to Gandachherra Sub-Jail without any rhyme or reason
and only to accommodate one Sri Tapan Shil.
Thirdly, on the basis of the certificates relating to the treatment
of the petitioner, Mr. Datta, learned counsel has urged this court not to
transfer the petitioner from Sonamura Sub-Jail to Gandachherra Sub-Jail as
his life may be at stake.
Fourthly, Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the petitioner has relied
upon the relevant Rules governing the transfer of the jail employees of the
State of Tripura.
6.
I have considered the said Rules. Rule 690 of Tripura
Sansodhanagar Rules, 2021(for short, Rules of 2021) stipulates as follows:-
“ 1. The minimum tenure of non-gazetted and gazetted staff, at one
station, shall be five years and three years, respectively.
2. While deciding on transfers, factors like:
(a) Needs of the department and the institution,
(b) Suitability of the incumbent to the post to which he is being
transferred, and
(c) Reasonable needs of the government servant such as
availability of educational facilities for his children, domestic
difficulties of a special nature, etc shall be considered.”
7.
Opposing the submissions as advanced by learned counsel for
the petitioner and to defend the impugned transfer order, learned G.A has
urged this court that the impugned transfer order has been made only
keeping in view the public interest. Admittedly, at present there are four
Pharmacists serving under the Jail Department, Government of Tripura who
have to serve the prisoners of 13 jails throughout the State, and that
necessitate the transfer of these four pharmacists at certain intervals looking
into the interest of the prisoners in these Sub-Jails.
8.
Drawing my attention to the statements made in the writ
petition, learned G.A has contended that if we look into the matter since
2012, then it becomes crystal clear that the petitioner has been transferred on
four occasions on his own request at the place of his own choice and it is
also found that the wife of the petitioner had once made a representation on
health ground of the petitioner to the concerned Minister of the Jail
Department, who personally took interest of it at his behest the petitioner
had been transferred to a place of his choice. The statements in this regard
are found at para-10 of the writ petition.
9.
Learned G.A has strongly denied and refuted the submissions
of Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner has been
transferred to Sonamura Sub-Jail to Gandachherra Sub-Jail to accommodate
one Sri Tapan Shil. Learned G.A has submitted that Sri Tapan Shil has
applied for VRS, which the Government had denied due to acute shortage of
pharmacists in the Jail Department, Government of Tripura.
10.
I have considered the rival submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties.
11.
It is settled proposition of law that transfer is incidental to
service. An employee has no Fundamental Right or for that matter, a vested
right to claim a transfer or posting at a place of his/her choice. It is
absolutely within the domain and prerogative of the transferring authorities
and the court will not sit in appeal over their decisions.
12.
I have considered the judgment referred to by Mr. Datta,
learned counsel for the petitioner relating to the case of B. Varadha Rao Vs.
State of Karnataka and Ors. reported in (1986) 4 SCC 131, para-6 of which
is reproduced here-in-below:- [SSC p.135 para 6]
“6.
One
cannot
but
deprecate
that
frequent,
unscheduled and unreasonable transfers can uproot a family,
cause irreparable harm to a government servant and drive him
to desperation. It disrupts the education of his children and
leads to numerous other complications and problems and
results in hardship and demoralization. It therefore follows that
the policy of transfer should be reasonable and fair and should
apply to everybody equally. But, at the same time, it cannot be
forgotten that so far as superior or more responsible posts are
concerned, continued posting at one station or in one
department of the government is not conducive to good
administration. It creates vested interest and therefore we find
that even from the British times the general policy has been to
restrict the period of posting for a definite period. We wish to
add that the position of class III and class IV employees stand
on a different footing. We trust that the government will keep
these considerations in view while making an order of
transfer.”
13.
In the instant case, the petitioner stated that he has college
going children who have been pursuing higher education in Agartala and the
petitioner has been suffering from blood sugar and frozen shoulder pain and
once he has been suggested by the Doctor to undergo surgery.
14.
I have taken note of the observations rendered at para 6 of the
case of B. Varadha Rao (supra) where it was also observed that transfer in a
transferable job is inevitable and Government, as a benevolent employer
should look into the problems and hardships of its employees. There is no
quarrel in this regard. In the instant case, it transpires that the respondentState had transferred the petitioner on three occasions at his own requests
and for once at the request of his wife. So, it cannot be said that the
Government has not considered the hardship and problems faced by the
petitioner. In the instant case, it is apparent that the Jail Department is run by
only four Pharmacists at present. All the Sub-Jails under the respondents
need Pharmacists and the Government has to manage all the prisoners in
those Sub-Jails with the active aid and assistance of the said four
Pharmacists including the petitioner. In this situation, in the opinion of this
Court, the transfer of the petitioner is bona fide.
15.
True it is, individual interest be considered, but keeping in view
the administrative exigencies, the employees under the Government also
need to respond to the situation, vis-à-vis the compelling circumstances the
employer faces. When the transfer order is made bona fide, personal
inconvenience should not come in the way of smooth administrative
functions and greater public interest. From the records, it is evident that
Sonamura Sub-Jail is situated at a distance of only 4-5 kms. from the SubDivisional Hospital, Sonamura. So, a prisoner can easily be taken to hospital
if the circumstances so require. It is also evident that the petitioner was
posted at Sonamura Sub-Jail and went on leave for more than seven months
which has been submitted by learned G.A on instructions and during this
period the prisoners of Sonamura Sub-Jail did not complain of any
inconvenience due to his absence. It is also understood that in an emergent
situation it will not be inconvenient for a doctor to visit and attend a prisoner
in the Sonamura Sub-Jail.
16.
In addition, Rule 690(2)(a) of the Rules of 2021 clearly
provides that in case of departmental and institutional needs, jail employees
can be transferred.
17.
For the reasons stated and observed here-in-above, I am of the
considered view that the impugned transfer order does not suffer from any
arbitrariness, and transfer of the petitioner has been made in the interest of
public as would be apparent from the impugned order itself. The petitioner
has failed to make out a case of malice towards him. As such, the said
impugned order does not call for any interference. Hence, the writ petition is
dismissed.
18.
However, the respondents may dispose of the representation of
the petitioner which was submitted on 07.12.2023, if it is not disposed of till
today.
Interim order granted by this court stands vacated.
JUDGE
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.02.09
GHOSH 17:17:47 +05'30'
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review