Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.331/2023
Sri Shuvam Majumder, S/O. Sri Babul Chandra Majumder, C/O. Sri Jatindra
Chandra Sarkar, (aged about 27 years), Resident of Ramnagar Road No.10,
P.O.-Ramnagar, P.S.-West Agartala, Sub-Division-Agartala, District-West
Tripura, Pin-799002.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited, an Indian Central Public Sector
Undertaking under the Ownership of Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas,
Government of India, having its Headquarters at Green Hills, Tel Bhavan,
Dehradun, Pin-248003 represented by its Chairman and CEO.
2. The General Manager (HR)-Incharge, Corporate Recruitment, ONGC, Green
Hills, Tel Bhavan, Dehradun, Pin-248003.
3. The Manager (HR), ONGC, Tripura Asset, Badharghat Complex, Agartala,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799014.
4. Sri Bidyut Sarkar, S/O. Manik Sarkar, Chittaranjan palli, Melaghar, Dist.Sepahijala, Pin-799115.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. D.K. Biswas, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Pradip Chakraborty, Advocate,
Mr. S.S. Debnath, Advocate,
Mr. Debarun Singh Kunwar, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 19th October, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. Pradip Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No.1 to
3/ONGC and Mr. D.K. Biswas, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.S.
Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the private respondent No.4.
2.
The case of the petitioner is encapsulated in the order dated
12.09.2023 which is reproduced hereunder:
"It is the case of the petitioner that under advertisement
No.2/2022 (R&P) [Annexure-3 to the writ petition] issued for
recruitment of Non-Executives in ONGC, petitioner was eligible for the
post of Junior Engineering Assistant (Electrical) under the category of
posts at Column-C which required 3(three) years Diploma in Electrical
Engineering with a valid certificate of competency as Electrical
Supervisor. Annexure-1 is the Certificate of Diploma in Engineering
issued in the year 2015 by the Tripura University and Annexure-2 is the
Certificate of Proficiency issued by the National Apprenticeship
Training Scheme, Ministry of Education, dated 09.09.2021 after the
petitioner completed the Apprenticeship Training between the period
from 01.09.2020 to 31.08.2021. The Selection Criteria at paragraph-O
of the advertisement provides for preparation of final merit list based on
the weightages assigned to various parameters, i.e. (i) Computer Based
Test-85 marks; (ii) Academic Performance-10 marks; and (iii)
Apprenticeship Certificate-05 marks, Total-100 marks.
Clause-(b) under paragraph-O provides as under:
"Candidates possessing a National Apprenticeship certificate
issued by the NCVT in addition to a Trade Certificate or possessing a
Certificate of Proficiency issued by the Ministry of HRD/Education in
addition to a Diploma in Engineering shall be given additional 5
marks (wherever applicable). Candidates must note that they should
possess the certificate in relevant trade issued by the respective
Authority as on the last date of the online application to be eligible for
award of marks for Apprenticeship Certificate."
Though petitioner was awarded 05 marks initially but later the
same has been deleted upon review on a grievance raised by one of the
candidates vide Annexure-J, communication dated 11.07.2023. After
deletion of the 05 marks for Certificate of Proficiency obtained after
graduation, petitioner has been held not entitled thereto in terms of
paragraph-O(b) of advertisement No.02/2022 as per corrigendum at
Annexure-K at page-87 of the counter affidavit which is the result for
2nd vacancy for the post of Junior Engineering Assistant (Electrical)-F1
Level (Conditional). In place of the petitioner against the 2nd vacancy,
one Bidyut Sarkar from the General category having 70.35 marks has
been offered appointment. Petitioner had got 71.10 marks as per the
results published by the respondents-ONGC, HRD Section, Tripura
Asset at Annexure-8. Petitioner belongs to the Scheduled Caste
category.
Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
the additional qualification of Degree in Engineering of the petitioner
has not been prescribed as a disentitlement for counting of the 05 marks
for having obtained Certificate of Proficiency under the advertisement
in any of the criteria. Petitioner fulfills the minimum eligibility criteria
of Diploma in Engineering and also having the Certificate of
Proficiency in his favour but on a misconstrued understanding of the
provisions of the Selection Criteria under paragraph-O(b), the deletion
of 05 marks has resulted in ousting the petitioner from the 2nd vacancy
which is being filled up through another candidate having 70.35 marks
from the General category.
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Pradip Chakraborty, learned counsel for the respondents-ONGC, has
referred to the criteria under the advertisement and submitted that the
deletion of 05 marks have been made for the reason that petitioner has
obtained the Certificate of Proficiency after graduation or obtaining
Degree in Engineering whereas the eligibility criteria required a
Diploma in Engineering with Certificate of Proficiency only.
Learned counsel for the petitioner seeks to implead the candidate
namely Bidyut Sarkar who has been offered appointment as per
Annexure-K in the writ petition. He is permitted to do so by making
necessary addition in the array of parties by tomorrow.
Let notice be issued upon the newly added respondent No.4
under ordinary process and speed post, for which requisites be filed by
Friday (15.09.2023).
The matter be listed on 13.10.2023."
3.
The moot question involved in the present writ petition is whether
by virtue of Clause-(b) under paragraph-O of the advertisement a candidate like
the petitioner possessing a Graduate Certificate of Proficiency obtained after
completing the Degree in Engineering ought to be given additional 5 marks in
terms of the weightages assigned to various parameters, i.e. (i) Computer
Based Test-85 marks; (ii) Academic Performance-10 marks; and (iii)
Apprenticeship Certificate-05 marks, Total-100 marks under the advertisement
No.2/2022 issued for recruitment of Non-Executives in ONGC across India.
4.
The official respondents in their counter affidavit have besides
traversing other statements made by the writ petitioner categorically answered
this contention at paragraphs-8.2 to 8.6 of the counter affidavit. According to
them, though inadvertently 5 marks were allotted to the petitioner on having
submitted a certificate of proficiency obtained after completing the graduation
course, i.e. (Graduate Apprentice) but on examination of the issue in the light
of the clarification from the Corporate Recruitment Section, Dehradun, the
doubt has been cleared by the Corporate Recruitment Section on 10.04.2023
that the essential qualification for F1 level engineering discipline is 3 years
Diploma in Engineering. Therefore, the additional 5 marks for certificate of
proficiency should be awarded only if it was obtained after Diploma. Petitioner
and the private respondent are both claimants to the second vacancy under the
advertisement for the post of Junior Engineering Assistant (Electrical).
5.
It is the case of the respondent No.4 as also borne from its counter
affidavit that the terms of the advertisement specifically Clause-O(b)
categorically prescribe 5 marks for a certificate of proficiency obtained after
diploma and not after Degree in Engineering. Respondent No.4 though had
obtained the certificate of proficiency as a Graduate after the Degree of
Engineering but being conscious of the prescription under Clause-O(b) of the
advertisement did not submit the Graduate certificate of proficiency for the
purposes of computation of weightage in order to compete. As such, the
respondent No.4 obtained 70.35 marks only and was at the third position. On
this point, the respondent-ONGC obtained the opinion of the Corporate
Recruitment Section, Dehradun and thereafter rectified the error of awarding 5
marks for the Graduate certificate of proficiency to the petitioner. As a result,
petitioner's total marks came down to 66.10. That is why, respondent No.4 has
been offered appointment letter by the employer.
6.
Upon consideration of the pleadings on record, it appears that the
petitioner has set up his case relying upon the same Clause-O(b) of the
advertisement which is extracted hereunder once again:
"Candidates possessing a National Apprenticeship certificate
issued by the NCVT in addition to a Trade Certificate or possessing a
Certificate of Proficiency issued by the Ministry of HRD/Education in
addition to a Diploma in Engineering shall be given additional 5 marks
(wherever applicable). Candidates must note that they should possess
the certificate in relevant trade issued by the respective Authority as on
the last date of the online application to be eligible for award of marks
for Apprenticeship Certificate."
7.
For the purposes of the instant case, the relevant clause would
read in the manner that candidates possessing a certificate of proficiency issued
by the Ministry of HRD/Education in addition to a Diploma in Engineering
shall be given additional 5 marks. The expression is couched in an affirmative
manner indicating the intention of the employer to award additional 5 marks if
the certificate of proficiency is in addition to Diploma in Engineering and not
Degree in Engineering. The rationale behind such a condition appears to be that
the recruitment is to be done for the post of Junior Engineering Assistant
(Electrical), F1 level for which the minimum qualification is Diploma in
Engineering.
8.
Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel for the petitioner, has accorded
an interpretation of Clause-O(b) in a manner that the employer does not specify
the category of National Apprenticeship Certificate issued by the NCVT in the
three categories, i.e. Graduate Apprentice, Technician Apprentice and
Technician (Vocational) Apprentice. As such, if a National Apprenticeship
Certificate or a certificate of proficiency per se is submitted by a candidate like
the petitioner, his certificate of proficiency cannot be excluded only for the
reason that it is a Graduate Certificate of Proficiency obtained after Degree in
Engineering for the purposes of giving additional 5 marks.
9.
I have given considerable thought to the rival submission of the
parties and the interpretation of the relevant Clause-O(b) which is the main
bone of contention in the instant case. On a plain reading of Clause-O(b) as
observed hereinabove, it appears that the employer has insisted upon a
certificate of proficiency or a National Apprenticeship Certificate which is in
addition to a Diploma in Engineering for providing additional 5 marks keeping
into mind that the recruitment is to be held for the post of Junior Engineering
Assistant (Electrical) of F1 level and not a superior level of post like an
Assistant Engineer (Electrical) or an Executive Engineer (Electrical) where the
qualification would be Degree in Engineering. The instant recruitment is for a
much junior post and though higher qualifications are not excluded like Degree
in Engineering and a Graduate certificate of proficiency obtained after Degree
in Engineering but the employer in its wisdom has restricted the allocation of
additional 5 marks to a candidate who fulfills the minimum eligibility criteria
for such post, i.e. Diploma in Engineering and a certificate of proficiency
obtained after Diploma in Engineering which is nomenclatured as Technician
Certificate of Proficiency. It is also evident from Annexure-2 which is the
Certificate of Proficiency submitted by the petitioner that he was a Graduate
Apprentice having undergone Apprenticeship Training under the Apprentices
Act, 1961 and not a Technician Apprentice who has undergone Apprenticeship
Training after a Diploma in Engineering. If looked at from this angle, the
distinction is quite obvious.
10.
It is beyond cavil that laying down of terms and conditions for
recruitment to a post lies in the domain of the employer. Unless the terms and
conditions are palpably irrational and arbitrary, Courts are loathe in interfering
in the terms of the advertisement. In the present case, the relevant Clause-O(b)
of the advertisement is not in question. It is also apparent from the counter
affidavit of the respondents-ONGC that merely on the representation of the
private respondent, the 5 marks earlier allotted to the petitioner on this criteria
have not been deducted. The concerned wing of the ONGC has obtained the
opinion of the Corporate Recruitment Section at Dehradun and since the
recruitment exercise was PAN India covering about 900 posts, the recruiting
cell has advised a uniform yardstick for award of additional 5 marks to
candidates who possess a Technician certificate of proficiency obtained after
Diploma in Engineering and not any other qualifications such as, Graduate
certificate of proficiency which is obtained after Degree in Engineering. If a
contrary view is taken on the interpretation of Clause-O(b), it is likely that the
entire recruitment exercise conducted on a uniform yardstick of allocation of
additional 5 marks for having a certificate of proficiency obtained after
Diploma in Engineering would be upset. It is not a case where any candidate
who has submitted the Graduate certificate of proficiency has been allotted
additional 5 marks under Clause-O(b) whereas the petitioner has been
discriminated.
11.
Having considered the entire gamut of facts, the relevant
provisions of the advertisement in question and the submissions of the parties,
this Court is of the firm view that the relevant condition O(b) of the
advertisement postulated allotment of additional 5 marks only if a candidate
possesses a certificate of proficiency obtained in addition to Diploma in
Engineering or nomenclatured as Technician certificate of proficiency. A
candidate not having this additional qualification is not ousted from the zone of
consideration but allocation of additional marks has been conditioned only
upon possession of this additional qualification of certificate of proficiency
after Diploma in Engineering.
12.
Having held so, this Court does not find any merit in the writ
petition. Accordingly, it is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
MUNNA SAHA SAHA
Date: 2023.10.20 12:57:25
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review