The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
03. 12.2020 [Annexure-P/4 to the writ petition]. Those are set aside on the ground of denying the petitioner the opportunity of placing his representation on the inquiry report by exercising his right as provided under Rule 15(2) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
18. Having observed thus, the matter is remanded to the disciplinary authority with a direction to provide the petitioner opportunity to file the representation against the report of enquiry in terms of Rule 15(2) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The petitioner is directed that at the time of filing the representation, he should lay his submission on the provisional order dated
20. 08.2020 [Annexure-P/2 to the writ petition]. Only thereafter, the disciplinary authority shall having considered the representation substantively pass the final order. If the petitioner is aggrieved by the final order that would be passed by the disciplinary authority i.e. the Superintendent of Police (traffic), then his right to file a fresh appeal would accrue and the petitioner may file a fresh appeal, if he is so inclined. Since the petitioner was not allowed to attend the duties, this court would not pass any order as regards the restitution but the respondents are directed to complete the exercise as indicated above within a period of two months from the date when the petitioner shall furnish a copy of this order. It is further mentioned that the observation on the proportionality of penalty will have no effect as this court has reversed the final order and the order of the appellate authority. as corollary, the disciplinary authority shall not be influenced by the above observation on the proportionality of penalty while passing the fresh order. Having observed thus, this writ petition stands allowed to the extent as indicated above. A copy of this order be supplied to Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents for onward transmission. The records as produced by Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. is returned. Sabyasachi B
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.715 of 2021
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Adv.
: Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
23/05/2022
Heard Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
respondents.
2.
By means of this writ petition, the petitioner who was serving as
the Constable of Police under the Traffic Unit, Agartala has challenged the
memorandum dated 30.10.2019, the inquiry report dated 21.07.2020, the
provisional order of punishment dated 20.08.2020 and the final order dated
09.09.2020. The petitioner has also challenged the appellate order dated
03.12.2020 whereby the penalty of compulsory retirement has been affirmed by
the appellate authority i.e. the Deputy Inspector General of Police [South range],
Tripura, Agartala. The petitioner has further urged that the respondents be
directed to reinstate in the service w.e.f. 09.09.2020, as according to him, he
was restrained from joining the service.
3.
Briefly stated the case of the petitioner is that while the petitioner
was posted in the Traffic Unit at Agartala, against him by the memorandum
No.5711/F/16/SP(T)RSV /18 dated 30.10.2019, a disciplinary proceeding under
Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules,
1965 was proposed on the charge of misconduct by absence from duty. The
petitioner was released from the Office of the Superintendent of Police (Security)
on 15.06.2019 and was directed to joined in his new place of posting under the
control of the Superintendent of Police (Traffic), Tripura. But the petitioner had
reported to the Office of the Superintendant of Police (Traffic) on 06.08.2019
after fifty one days of his release from the earlier place of posting and submitted
an application stating that he was under KABIRAJI treatment. The petitioner had
urged for accepting his joining. The petitioner had remained away from the duty
without any intimation to the competent authority and at the time of initiation of
the disciplinary proceeding, he was allegedly on unauthorized absence. Thus, it
has been contended by the said memorandum that the petitioner’s above
absence from duty constituted the act of misconduct.
4.
By the said memorandum dated 30.10.2019 [Annexure-1 to the
writ petition], the petitioner was asked to file his written statement of defence.
The period of absence was 15.06.2019 to 06.08.2019, total fifty one days. The
petitioner was on several other occasions absent from duty unauthorisedly. In
total, the petitioner was absent from the duty unauthorisedly for 364 days from
14.08.2019. The petitioner denied the charges by filing his written statement of
defence. As consequence thereof, the disciplinary authority referred the matter
to the inquiry officer. The inquiry officer on completion his inquiry submitted his
report on 21.07.2020 with the finding that the charge framed against the
delinquent constable, the petitioner herein, has been substantiated. Thereafter,
the respondent No.2 had issued the provisional order of punishment dated
20.08.2020 proposing the compulsory retirement and by regularizing the period
of absence from 14.08.2019 till the date of the final order as dies non without
break in service in terms of Rule 11 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965. The provisional
order proposing the penalty was passed on 20.08.2020 [Annexure-2 to the writ
petition].
5.
In the interregnum, on 26.08.2020, the petitioner filed one
representation to the respondent No.2, the disciplinary authority alleging
infirmities in the inquiry proceeding conducted by the inquiry officer. It has been
further stated that the inquiry officer did not conduct the inquiry in a fair and
impartial manner. On 09.09.2020, the final order imposing the compulsory
retirement of the petitioner including the period from 14.08.2019 till 09.09.2020
[Annexure-3 to the writ petition] was passed directing to treat the period of
absence as dies non without break in service. The petitioner had filed an appeal
under Rule 23 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965. It has been stated in the writ
petition that the petitioner having gathered knowledge from the reliable source
in respect of the final order dated 09.09.2020 had preferred an appeal before
the respondent No.4 on 16.11.2020. His objections had been elaborated therein.
But finally, the appeal was dismissed by the order dated 03.12.2020 [Annexure-4
to the writ petition] having observed that there is no infirmity in the impugned
order.
6.
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has strenuously argued that if this court lifted the skin, it would be
apparent that the disciplinary authority has nurtured bad faith against the
petitioner and that had been manifested in the dis-proportionality of the
punishment. The order of penalty is extremely harsh and that cannot be
sustained. The final order of compulsory retirement, according to the petitioner,
is wholly unwarranted. According to the petitioner, he ought to have been
exonerated from the charges, as the charges are vague and both the inquiring
authority and the disciplinary authority have not appreciated how the petitioner
was prevented by illness from attending his duties. The order of compulsory
retirement is therefore liable to be interfered with and set aside. Similarly, the
report of the inquiry, being unfair and unreasonable, is liable to be set aside.
7.
In para 15 of the writ petition, the petitioner has categorically
stated that he was not provided any copy of the report and other documents
relating to the disciplinary proceeding. Further, it has been asserted that on
completion of the departmental proceeding, the respondent authorities did not
inform him of the order of compulsory retirement from the service. On the
disclosure made under RTI Act, for the first time the petitioner came across the
inquiry report dated 21.07.2020, a copy of which has been filed along with the
writ petition. It will be apparent that the respondents had caused serious breach
of the laid down procedure. As such, since the petitioner has been denied the
reasonable opportunity to have his say as regards what has been alleged against
him the impugned orders be set aside. The respondents filed a joint reply
whereby they have refuted all the allegations brought by the petitioner. They
have categorically stated that the petitioner was given enough opportunity to
defend his case by observing due procedure. If the petitioner was at all serious
in attending his duties, and if he had any reason for absenting from the duty
from 14.08.2019 to 09.09.2020 he would have intimated the higher authority.
According to Mr. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
regularization of absence by applying dies non itself has taken the effect of
absence from the records. Thus, there is no impediment to extend the reliefs as
prayed by the petitioner.
8.
In response thereof, the respondents have categorically stated that
the petitioner was supplied a copy of the inquiry report with the provisional order
of penalty. Before that, at the fag end of the inquiry proceeding, the petitioner
himself had declared by a letter dated 24.06.2020 [Annexure-R/1 to the reply
filed by the respondents] that he would be allowed to be relieved from his job.
That letter has not been challenged by the petitioner.
9.
Mr.
M.
Debbarma,
learned
Addl.
G.A.
appearing
for
the
respondents has highlighted that the said statement as made voluntarily and
independently by the petitioner was considered while passing the provisional
order. In the provisional order, it has been observed that the petitioner is no
more willing to continue in the job of traffic constable and he would not resume
his duties. That apart, in the provisional order, it has been observed that a
lenient view has been taken while imposing the punishment and as such,
objection built upon the proportionality is destined to fail.
10.
Having appreciated the submissions of the learned counsel
appearing for the parties as well as the averments, two pertinent questions do
emerge for consideration of this court :
1) Whether the report of the inquiry was supplied to the
delinquent as per the prescription of Rule 15(2) of the
CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 has been followed ? and
2) whether the penalty as imposed on the petitioner for fifty
one days’ absence from the service on the demonstrated ground
of ailments suffers from the dis-proportionality?
11.
So far the supply of the report of inquiry is concerned, it is
available from the provisional order that a copy of the report of the inquiry
officer dated 21.07.2020 had been furnished. The petitioner was showcaused
why the provisional order should not be made final, meaning why the petitioner
shall not be sent for compulsory retirement. But in the said provisional order,
there is no note whether the copy was at all supplied to the petitioner or not. For
purpose of reference, Rule 15(2) of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 may be
reproduced :
(2) The disciplinary authority shall forward or cause to be
forwarded a copy of the report of the inquiry, if any, held by the
disciplinary authority or where the disciplinary authority is not
the inquiring authority, a copy of the report of the inquiring
authority together with its own tentative reasons for
disagreement, if any, with the findings of inquiring authority on
any article of charge to the Government servant who shall be
required to submit, if he so desires, his written representation
or submission to the disciplinary authority within fifteen days,
irrespective of whether the report is favourable or not to the
Government servant.
12.
In reply to the specific averment made by the petitioner in para 15
of the writ petition, the respondents in their reply have not made any specific
denial or positive statement that the report of enquiry was furnished to the
petitioner with the provisional order.
Today, Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
respondents has produced the records of the departmental proceeding being DP
No.02 of 2019. On scrutiny of the records, this court does not find any record of
receipt that the petitioner had acknowledged the receipt of the departmental
enquiry. However, it appears from the records that the petitioner had received
the provisional order and the final order on putting his signature on those
orders. But no such signature in acknowledging the receipt of the report of the
enquiry, which is available from pages 71-63 of the said files, is available.
Thus, this court has been persuaded to infer that even though in the
provisional order the reference of the report of inquiry has been made by
claiming that the copy had been served, but it is difficult to believe.
13.
So far the question of proportionality is concerned, the petitioner
being a member of a disciplined force has shown serious dereliction of the duty
by not informing even the competent authority of his absence. Considering that
aspect of the matter, this court would observe that the ground of proportionality
is not tenable in the present context.
14.
The ancillary objection as raised by Mr. Biswanath Majumder
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that as by imposing dies non the
period of absence has been regularized, no penalty can be imposed for absence.
This submission on the first blush appears very attractive but on reading the
entire final order that has been challenged it will appear that after holding the
petitioner guilty of misconduct and proposing his punishment of compulsory
retirement, the period of absence has been regularized by way of dies non
without break in service, meaning, the petitioner will not get any salary for that
period. The respondents have further stated that they have taken a lenient
approach so that the petitioner does not suffer disproportionately.
15.
This court does not find any substance in the submission of Mr.
Majumder, learned counsel as regards regularization of absence by way of dies
non inasmuch dies non with or without break up of service is itself a mechanism
for taking action against the person who absents from the duties without
application of leave.
16.
Having appreciated the entire records, submissions of the learned
counsel for the parties and the letter of the petitioner dated 24.06.2020, this
court is of the view that the letter cannot be treated adversely against the
petitioner inasmuch as the said letter has been issued to the inquiry officer who
has no right to decide on that issue and this is not a statement of admitting to
the misconduct. It is a sporadic statement showing someone’s state of mind.
This ought not to have been taken into consideration by the respondents to
come to a finding against the petitioner. The appellate authority passed the
order dated 03.12.2020 merely extracting the reason provided in the final order
passed in the D.P.No.02 of 2019. Nowhere the appellate authority has given any
reason either for affirmation or for rejection, except only what the appellate
authority has invested is “considered and rejected.” Thus, the appellate order
has failed to conform to the directions given in Rule 27 of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965
which mandates as follows :
“(2) In the case of an appeal against an order imposing any of the penalties specified
in rule 11 or enhancing any penalty imposed under the said rules, the appellate
authority shall consider(a) whether the procedure laid down in these rules have been complied with and if
not, whether such non-compliance has resulted in the violation of any provisions of
the Constitution of India or in the failure of justice;
(b) whether the findings of the disciplinary authority are warranted by the evidence
on the record; and
(c) whether the penalty or the enhanced penalty imposed is adequate, inadequate or
severe;”
As such, the appellate order is ex facie bad and cannot be sustained.
17.
So far the report of inquiry is concerned, this court will not make
any observation as the petitioner is entitled to make a substantive representation
against the finding of the report of inquiry. Denial of the opportunity for filing
such representation as provided by Rule 15(2) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 is
unsustainable. As this particular rule has come into being from the law declared
by
the
apex
court
in
Ramzan
Ali Khan
vs
Musammat
Asghari
Begam and Anr., reported in AIR 1991 SC 471. As such, this court is inclined
on the limited grounds to interfere with the provisional order dated 20.08.2020
[Annexure-P/2 to the writ petition], the final order dated 09.09.2020 [AnnexureP/3 to the writ petition] and the order of the appellate authority dated
03.12.2020 [Annexure-P/4 to the writ petition]. Those are set aside on the
ground of denying the petitioner the opportunity of placing his representation on
the inquiry report by exercising his right as provided under Rule 15(2) of
CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
18.
Having observed thus, the matter is remanded to the disciplinary
authority with a direction to provide the petitioner opportunity to file the
representation against the report of enquiry in terms of Rule 15(2) of CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965. The petitioner is directed that at the time of filing the
representation, he should lay his submission on the provisional order dated
20.08.2020 [Annexure-P/2 to the writ petition]. Only thereafter, the disciplinary
authority shall having considered the representation substantively pass the final
order. If the petitioner is aggrieved by the final order that would be passed by
the disciplinary authority i.e. the Superintendent of Police (traffic), then his right
to file a fresh appeal would accrue and the petitioner may file a fresh appeal, if
he is so inclined. Since the petitioner was not allowed to attend the duties, this
court would not pass any order as regards the restitution but the respondents
are directed to complete the exercise as indicated above within a period of two
months from the date when the petitioner shall furnish a copy of this order. It is
further mentioned that the observation on the proportionality of penalty will
have no effect as this court has reversed the final order and the order of the
appellate authority. as corollary, the disciplinary authority shall not be influenced
by the above observation on the proportionality of penalty while passing the
fresh order.
Having observed thus, this writ petition stands allowed to the
extent as indicated above.
A copy of this order be supplied to Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl.
G.A. appearing for the respondents for onward transmission.
The records as produced by Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. is
returned.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review