Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.12 of 2024
Sri Shasanka Nath Chowdhury, aged 62 years
S/o Lt. Sanatan Nath Chowdhury
R/o: Kunjaban, West Tripura
PIN: 799006.
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
To be represented by Principal Secretary,
Department of Industries & Commerce, Govt. of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799010.
2. Tripura Handloom & Handicrafts Development Corporation
Ltd.
To be represented by the Managing Director, THHDC,
M.B.B Sarani, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin: 799007.
3. The Managing Director,
Tripura Handloom & Handicrafts Development Corporation Ltd,
M.B.B Sarani, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN: 799007.
4. The Secretary, Department of Finance,
Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN – 799010.
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv,
Mr. D. Paul, Adv,
Ms. S. Deb Barman, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. S. Bhowmik, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
02.05.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
10.05.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, Learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the petitioner assisted by Mr. D. Paul, Learned
Counsel and Ms. S. Deb Barman, Learned Counsel. Also heard
Mr. B. S. Bhowmik, Learned Counsel for the respondent nos.2
and 3 i.e. Tripura Handloom & Handicrafts Development
Corporation Ltd and the Managing Director, Tripura Handloom &
Handicrafts Development Corporation Ltd. None appeared on
behalf of the respondent nos.1 and 4.
2.
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:
i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay interest @ 9% per annum to the
Petitioner w.e.f. the date on which gratuity became
payable till date of actual payment.
ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay interest @9% per annum on
Rs.10,00,000/- w.e.f., 01.09.2022 to 11.11.2022
and
Rs.
6,69,223/w.e.f.,
01.09.2022
to
15.02.2023.
iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay to the Petitioner with interest @
9% on leave encashment benefit w.e.f. one month
after retirement till the payment is made.
iv) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay interest @ 9% per annum on
Rs.3,80,700/- w.e.f., 01.09.2022 to 29.04.2023 and
Rs. 3,80,700/- w.e.f. 01.09.2022 to 10.07.2023.
v) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay to the Petitioner with interest @
9% on group insurance w.e.f. one month after
retirement till the payment is made.
vi) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like
nature shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to pay interst @ 9% per annum on
Rs.62,469/- w.e.f. 01.09.2022 to 17.01.2023.
vii) Make the rules absolute.
viii) Call for records.
ix) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble
High Court considered fit and proper.
3.
In course of hearing, Learned Counsel for the petitioner
submitted that by memorandum dated 14.10.1985, petitioner
was appointed as Junior Salesman under the respondent nos.2
& 3. The petitioner retired from service in the same post on
attaining the age of superannuation i.e. w.e.f. 31.07.2022. The
petitioner rendered service for a period of 38 years. According
to the petitioner, after retirement from service, he became
entitled to full and final payment of gratuity within a period of
30 days from the date of retirement in terms of Section 7(3) of
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The petitioner also entitled
to encashment of Earned Leave benefit within 30 days of
retirement and entitled to Group Insurance claim within 30 days
of retirement. It was the further case of the petitioner that his
last basic pay was Rs.70,500/- at the time of retirement and he
was getting 8% D.A of the basic. Thus, his gross salary was
Rs.76,140/-.
According
to
petitioner,
vide
memo
dated
18.10.2022 issued by the Managing Director, Rs.10,00,000/was sanctioned for payment of gratuity to the petitioner. Again,
vide another sanction memo dated 30.01.2023 issued by the
Managing Director, THHDC Ltd. Rs.6,69,223/- was sanctioned in
favour of the petitioner towards payment of balance amount of
gratuity. In addition to that, vide sanction memo dated
21.03.2023 issued by Managing Director, THHDC Ltd., an
amount of Rs.7,61,400/- was sanctioned for payment to the
petitioner towards leave encashment benefit. From the sanction
memo
dated
21.03.2023,
it
was
clear
that
the
leave
encashment benefit was sanctioned on 21.03.2023 although the
petitioner retired w.e.f. 31.07.2022 and he was entitled to leave
encashment within 30days from the date of retirement but the
respondents have caused delay in causing such payment
towards the petitioner as such he is entitled to interest for such
delay caused by the respondents in causing payment to the
petitioner. The petitioner further submitted that it is settled
position of law that if gratuity and other pensionary benefits are
withheld or delay is caused in case of payment of gratuity and
other pensionary benefits in that case interest is to be paid from
the date of entitlement till the date of actual payment. So, the
petitioner submitted that on calculation he is entitled to
Rs.99,747/- for the period as mentioned in para no.22 of the
writ petition.
4.
The claim of the petitioner has been contested by the
respondent nos.2 & 3 by filing counter affidavit. In the counter
affidavit, it was submitted that the payment of gratuity has
been made to the petitioner by two installments on 02.11.2022
and 09.02.2023 which was the full and final payment of gratuity
and on receipt of Group Insurance amount from the Life
Insurance Company Ltd., an amount of Rs.62,469/- has been
paid to the petitioner. It was further submitted that due to
financial constraint of the corporation, it was difficult on the
part of Corporation to make payment of Leave Salary to the
retired
employees
of
Tripura
Handloom
and
Handicrafts
Development Corporation Ltd. within a reasonable period.
However,
the
petitioner
was
paid
Leave
Salary
by
two
installments vide cheque bearing no.298282 dated 25.04.2023
and cheque bearing no.298351 dated 25.07.2023. It was
further submitted that Group Insurance was tied up with the
Life Insurance Company Ltd. So, Tripura Handloom and
Handicrafts Development Corporation Ltd. has no right to make
payment of Group Insurance unless the maturity amount has
been received from the Life Insurance Company Ltd and it was
submitted that the payment of Group Insurance has been made
to the petitioner as soon as the amount received from the Life
Insurance
Company.
The
contesting
respondents
further
submitted that after retirement of any employee of the
Corporation, a considerable time is required to release the
gratuity due to administrative reasons and depending on the
fund availability to the Corporation. The Corporation is running
loss of Rs.10,00,00,000 per year, for which it has become
difficult to make payment of Leave Salary to the retired
employees in time. Hence, the contesting respondents by the
counter affidavit denied the claim of the petitioner that he is
entitled to get interest for the delayed payment.
5.
In course of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy
Barman assisted by Mr. D. Paul, Learned Counsel and Ms. S.
Deb Barman, Learned Counsel referred sub-section 3, (3-A) of
Section 7 of the Payment of Gratuity Act and submitted that in
view of the aforesaid provisions, the respondents are legally
bound to pay interest to the petitioner but they did not make
any payment of interest. In respect of other pensionary benefits
like Leave Encashment and Group Insurance, he further
submitted that since the respondents have failed to make
payment of the pensionary benefits within the stipulated period
of one month from the date of superannuation. So, for Leave
Encashment and Group Insurance also, the respondents are to
make payment of interests to the petitioner and referred few
citations.
6.
Per contra, Learned Counsel, Mr. B. S. Bhowmik
appearing for the respondent nos.2 & 3 submitted that the
petitioner has given all the retirement benefits but due to some
administrative reasons and financial stringency, the payment
could not be made in time to the petitioner and furthermore,
regarding Group Insurance, the LIC has not been made party in
this case and moreso, for leave encashment, there is no scope
to award any interest to the petitioner and, as such, the claim
of the petitioner is being devoid of merit and prayed for
dismissal of this petition. Considered.
7.
I have heard rival submission of both the parties.
8.
For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein
below the relevant provision of Section 7 of the Payment of
Gratuity Act which provides as under:
Section 7
[Sub-section(3) The employer shall arrange to pay
the amount of gratuity within thirty days from the
date it becomes payable to the person to whom the
gratuity is payable.
Sub-section(3-A) If the amount of gratuity payable
under sub-section (3) is not paid by the employer
within the period specified in sub-section(3), the
employer shall pay, from the date on which the
gratuity becomes payable to the date on which it is
paid, simple interest at such rate, not exceeding the
rate notified by the Central Government from time
to time for repayment of long-term deposits, as that
Government may, by notification specify:
Provided that no such interest shall be payable if
the delay in the payment is due to the fault of the
employee
and
the
employer
has
obtained
permission in writing from the controlling authority
for the delayed payment on this ground.]
From the aforesaid provision, it appears that if the
amount of gratuity payable under sub-section 3 and (3-A) is not
paid by the employer within period specified in sub-section(3),
the employer shall pay from the date on which the gratuity
becomes payable to the date on which it is paid, simple interest
at such rate, not exceeding the rate notified by the Central
Government from time to time for repayment of long-term
deposits, as that Government may, by notification specify. Here
in this case, it is the admitted position that the contesting
respondents although admitted the fact of delayed payment of
gratuity to the petitioner so as such the respondents are liable
to pay interest to the petitioner.
9.
In State of Kerala and Ors. v. M. Padmanabhan
Nair dated 17.12.1984 reported in (1985) 1 SCC 429,
wherein Hon’ble the Supreme Court observed para nos.3, 4 & 5
as under:
“3. The instant case is a glaring instance of such
culpable delay in the settlement of pension and
gratuity claims due to the respondent who retired
on May 19, 1973. His pension and gratuity were
ultimately paid to him on August 14, 1975, i.e.,
more than two years and 3 months after his
retirement and hence after serving lawyer’s notice
he filed a suit mainly to recover interest by way of
liquidated damages for delayed payment. The
appellants put the blame on the respondent for
delayed payment on the ground that he had not
produced the requisite L.P.C. (last pay certificate)
from the Treasury Office under Rule 186 of the
Treasury Code. But on a plain reading of Rule 186,
the High Court held – and in our view rightly – that
a duty was cast on the Treasury Officer to grant to
every retiring Government servant the last pay
certificate which in this case had been delayed by
the concerned officer for which neither any
justification nor explanation had been given. The
claim for interest was, therefore, rightly, decreed in
respondent’s favour.
4. Unfortunately such claim for interest that was
allowed in respondent’s favour by the District Court
and confirmed by the High Court was at the rate of 6
per cent per annum though interest at 12 per cent
had been claimed by the respondent in his suit.
However, since the respondent acquiesced in his
claim being decreed at 6 per cent by not preferring
any cross-objections in the High Court it would not
be proper for us to enhance the rate to 12 per cent
per annum which we were otherwise inclined to
grant.
5. We are also of the view that the State
Government is being rightly saddled with a liability
for the culpable neglect in the discharge of his duty
by the District Treasury Officer who delayed the
issuance of the L.P.C. but since the concerned
officer had not been impleaded as a party defendant
to the suit the Court is unable to hold him liable for
the decretal amount. It will, however, be for the
State Government to consider whether the erring
official should or should not be directed to
compensate the Government the loss sustained by it
by his culpable lapses. Such action if taken would
help generate in the officials of the State
Government a sense of duty towards the
Government under whom they serve as also a sense
of accountability to members of the public.”
Further in Dr. A. Selvaraj v. C.B.M. College and Ors.
dated 04.03.2022 reported in (2022) 4 SCC 627, Hon’ble the
Supreme Court in para nos.10, 11, 12, 13 & 14 observed as
under:
“10. Having heard the learned counsel for the
respective parties, we are of the opinion that as
there was a delay in making the payment of
retirement benefits and settling the dues for which
the appellant employee is not at all responsible, he
is entitled to the interest on the delayed payment.
Even the Division Bench of the High Court has also
observed in the impugned judgment and order that
the appellant is entitled to the interest on the
delayed payment. However, there is an inter se
dispute between the Secretary, Management and
the Government as to who is responsible for the
delay in making the payment to the appellant and
therefore, he has been denied the interest on
delayed payment though entitled to.
11. It is to be noted that as such pursuant to the
interim order dated 9-8-2021, the Government did
conduct an enquiry and fastened the liability on the
College and observed that the former Secretary,
Shri C. M. Ramaraj was responsible for the delay in
disbursal of the terminal benefits to the original writ
petitioner.
12. In that view of the matter, subject to the further
final order that may be passed by the Government,
the College/Management is first liable to pay the
interest on the delayed payment of retirement dues
subject to the final decision, which may be taken by
the Government, after hearing the Management and
the former Secretary. However, because of the inter
se dispute between the Management, Secretary and
the Government on who is responsible for the delay
in making the payment and/or settling the dues, the
retired employee should not be made to suffer for
no fault of his.
13. In view of the above discussion and for the
reasons stated above, the present appeal succeeds.
The impugned judgment and order :2021 SCC
OnLine Mad 10636 passed by the Division Bench of
the High Court and that of the learned Single Judge
:2020 SCC OnLine Mas 8446 denying the interest on
delayed payment of retirement benefits to the
appellant is hereby quashed and set aside. The
Management/Trustees/College are hereby directed
to pay the interest on the delayed payment of
retirement benefits to the appellant, from the date
of retirement till the actual payment was made,
subject to the final decision that may be taken by
the Government on the objections to the enquiry
report that may be filed by the former Secretary
and/or the College and it will be open for the
College/ Management/Trustees to recover the same
from the person, who, ultimately is held to be
responsible for the delay.
14. The payment of interest on delayed payment of
retirement benefits to be paid strictly within a
period of six weeks from today. In the meantime,
the Government to pass a final order on the enquiry
report
after
giving
an
opportunity
to
the
College/Management/former Secretary. It goes
without saying that it would be open to the
aggrieved party to challenge the said decision
before the appropriate forum.
Further, in Dr Uma Agrawal v. State of U.P and
another dated 22.03.1999 reported in (1999) 3 SCC 438, the
Apex Court in para nos.5, 6 & 7 also observed as under:
“5. We have referred in sufficient detail to the Rules
and instructions which prescribe the time-schedule
for the various steps to be taken in regard to the
payment of pension and other retiral benefits. This
we have done to remind the various governmental
departments of their duties in initiating various
steps at least two years in advance of the date of
retirement. If the Rules/instructions are followed
strictly, much of the litigation can be avoided and
retired government servants will not feel harassed
because after all, grant of pension is not a bounty
but a right of the government servant. The
Government is obliged to follow the Rules
mentioned in the earlier part of this order in letter
and in spirit. Delay in settlement of retiral benefits
is frustrating and must be avoided at all costs. Such
delays are occurring even in regard to family
pensions for which too there is a prescribed
procedure. This is indeed unfortunate. In cases
where a retired government servant claims interest
for delayed payment, the court can certainly keep in
mind
the
time-schedule
prescribed
in
the
Rules/instructions apart from other relevant factors
applicable to each case.
6. The case before us is a clear example of
departmental delay which is not excusable. The
petitioner retired on 30-4-1993 and it was only after
12-2-1996 when an interim order was passed in this
writ petition that the respondents woke up and
started work by sending a special messenger to
various places where the petitioner had worked.
Such an exercise should have started at least in
1991, two years before retirement. The amounts
due to the petitioner were computed and the
payments were made only during 1997-98. The
petitioner was a cancer patient and was indeed put
to great hardship. Even assuming that some letters
were sent to the petitioner after her retirement on
30-3-1993 seeking information from her, an
allegation which is denied by the petitioner, that
cannot be an excuse for the lethargy of the
Department inasmuch as the Rules and instructions
require these actions to be taken long before
retirement. The exercise which was to be completed
long before retirement was in fact started long after
the petitioner’s retirement.
7. Therefore, this is a fit case for awarding interest
to the petitioner. We do not think that for the
purpose of the computation of interest, the matter
should go back. Instead, on the facts of the case, we
quantify the interest payable at Rs 1 lakh and direct
that the same shall be paid to the petitioner within
two months from today.”
In Md. Sayeedul Islam Mir v. State of West Bengal
& Ors. dated 13.12.2012 reported in 2012 SCC OnLine Cal
12570, wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“The learned advocate for the petitioner relying
upon a judgment of a Co-ordinate Bench of this
court in the case of Niranjan Kumar Mondal v. The
State of West Bengal, reported in (2012) 1 WBLR
(Cal) 903, submits that non-payment of interest on
delayed payment of pensionary benefit is a
continuing wrong.
Upon noticing the said judgment, it appears that
one of the points, which was taken, was whether
the interest could be awarded for delayed payment
of the retiral benefit after a lapse of considerable
period of time. In such perspective, it was held
that:“Claim for interest cannot be held to be a stale claim
as right to claim interest on delayed payment of
retiral dues accrues due to continuing wrong
committed by the State respondents for withholding
the payment of the petitioner’s retiral dues causing
continuous injury to the petitioner until such
payment is made.”
Let me explain as to how non-payment of interest
amounts to a continuing wrong. It has now been
settled universally that payment of retiral dues is
not a bounty. The scheme for payment of such
retiral
dues
was
introduced
by
the
State
Government by the Office Memorandum dated 26th
May, 1998. Under the said scheme the State
Government is required to pay the retiral dues such
as death-cum-retiring gratuity, commuted value of
pension etc., on the day following the date of his
retirement. If such payment is not made on the said
date, then the State Government acquires a liability
to pay interest on delayed payment of such retiral
dues, simultaneously corresponding right to claim
interest on delayed payment of retiral dues is
accrued in favour of the retired person as such right
is recognised in the Part III of the favour of the
retired person as such right is recognized in the Part
III of the Constitution. Thus, whenever such retiral
dues is paid to a retired person beyond the due
date, the State Government is required to pay
interest till the date of payment of such retiral dues,
so that the interest which he could have earned by
way of depositing his retiral dues in any
Nationalized Bank or any financial institutions from
the date since when it became due and payable to
him upto the date of payment thereof, can be
recovered by him from the employer. This liability to
pay interest by the State, in my view, continues till
the date of actual payment of the retiral dues but in
case interest is not paid along with the retiral dues,
liability to pay interest continues till the date of
payment of interest as the interest which was
accumulated on the retiral dues upto the date of
payment of such retiral dues, also carries interest
day to day until such interest is paid. Thus, this
court is of the view that nonpayment of interest on
delayed payment of retiral dues is a continuing
wrong causing continuous injury to the petitioner.
It has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
case of Union of India v. Tarsem Singh, reported in
(2008) 8 SCC 648, that where a service related
claim is based on a continuing wrong, relief can be
granted even if there is long delay in seeking
remedy, as continuing wrong creates a continuous
source of injury and the claim never gets fridged
until payment is made.
The law enunciated in the said report squarely
applies in the facts of the present case. The claim of
the writ petitioner, therefore, cannot be refused as
non-payment of interest on delayed payment of
pensionary
benefit,
is
a
continuing
wrong.
Furthermore, in the said report, the Co-ordinate
Bench recorded the stand of the State Government
in implementing the Court’s order for payment of
interest on delayed payment of gratuity in the
following words:
“22. Thus, when the State Government, on its own,
took a decision to implement the Court’s order for
payment of interest on delayed payment of Gratuity
and further when the State Government granted
interest on delayed payment of Gratuity in
numerous cases following the orders of this Court
which were passed by taking note of such
concession given by the State Government, this
Court does not find any justification to reject the
petitioner’s claim for interest merely on the ground
of delay when this Court finds that the State itself
committed default in discharging its duty to pay
such legitimate dues of the petitioner at the right
time and because of nonpayment of interest, the
petitioner has made to suffer a continuous injury till
date.”
Thus, in view of the above, the petitioner is entitled
to an interest on the delayed payment of gratuity
and the respondent no.4 herein, the Treasury
Officer, Uluberia, Howrah, is directed to pay the
interest @ 6% per annum on delayed payment of
such gratuity from the date of attainment of
superannuation till the date of actual payment and
such amount shall be paid within eight weeks from
the date of communication of this order. In default
of payment of an amount indicated above within the
stipulated period, the concerned authority shall pay
an additional interest @ 2% per annum over and
above the interest already awarded till the actual
payment is made.
The writ petition is, thus, disposed of without any
order as to costs.
Xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for, will
be made available to the applicant within a week
from the date of putting in the requisites.”
In Major-Gen.(Old. Capt.) Virender Kumar v. Chief
of the Army Staff and three proforma respondents dated
11.03.1994 reported in 1994 Supp (2) SCC 303 wherein
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in para no.14 observed as under:
“14. We hope that this order will finally bring down
the curtain on the litigation which has been going
on for nearly 30 years. But we are constrained to
observe that the petitioner was not paid the sums
which were due to him under the Group Insurance
Scheme, Defence Service Officers’ Provident Fund,
Children Education Fund and Terminal Gratuity
benefits. The total amount, excluding the amount of
Children Education Fund, comes to approximately
Rs.21,000 and odd. That this amount has not been
paid to the petitioner for all these years brings out
fully the observation made by this Court that the
department was viewing the matter as one of false
prestige. In the circumstances, there is no option
but to award an interest of 14 per cent on this
amount from March 1986 to February 1994. The
petitioner shall further be entitled to interest at
14% on Children Education Fund. The department
shall pay interest on same rate at the total pension
from March 1986 to February 1994.”
In Jagdish Prasad Saini and other v. State of
Rajasthan and others dated 26.09.2022 reported in 2022
SCC OnLine SC 1298, the Apex Court in para no.21 and 24
observed as under:
“21. This court had categorically ruled, in Senior
Higher Secondary School (supra) that leave
encashment is part of salary. In the scheme of the
1993 Rules, the assessment of, and determination
of the extent of, aid to be granted to any institution,
is provided by Rule 13. What forms part of the
approved expenditure that would be the content of
aid, is provided by Rule 14. In the present case, the
management establishment was recipient of 70%
aid, in the form of grant. In these circumstances,
the State cannot shrug its responsibility to shoulder
its part of the responsibility to pay the appellants
the share of leave encashment benefits, and hide
behind either Rule 5(viii) or the undertaking
executed by them. The appellant are held entitled to
privilege leave entitlement benefits. Such benefit
shall be calculated from the date they entered the
service of the establishment till the date of their
absorption, by the State, in 2016. The State shall
pay the benefits due to the extent of 70%, and the
balance 30% shall be payable by the management
establishment.
24. In view of the above discussion, it is held that
with respect to leave encashment, the State and the
respondent nos. 3 to 7 are liable to pay the
appellants, in the ratio of 70 : 30 respectively. The
respondent State shall, within four weeks from
today, determine the extent of entitlement of each
appellant, and communicate the extent of amount
payable
by
the
management
establishment
(respondent nos.3 to 7), to the appellants. These
amounts shall be paid by all the respondents, within
six weeks from today. The respondent nos.3 to 7
shall also calculate and pay the amount of gratuity,
to the appellants (on the basis of their initial date of
entry in the school, till the date of order of
absorption, by the respondent State), within six
weeks from today. Since both sets of respondents
contested their liability and denied them to the
appellants, the amounts payable to the appellants
shall also carry interest, at the rate of 10% from the
date(s) of their entitlement, till the date of
payment.”
This High Court in Bhupati Debnath v. The State of
Tripura and Ors. bearing case no. WP(C) No.1054/2019 dated
13.02.2020 in para 13 observed as under:
“13. Under the circumstances, petition is disposed
of with following directions:
(i) As provided earlier, the petitioner shall
apply to the respondent No.2 stating his
calculation
of
payable
gratuity.
The
respondent
No.2
shall
examine
the
petitioner’s calculation and convey to him if
any gratuity remains still payable;
(ii) While calculating such gratuity, revised
limit of `20,00,000 (rupees twenty lakhs)
shall be applicable;
(iii) If there is any shortfall in payment of
gratuity, the same shall be paid within a
period of 4(four) months from today with
simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one
month after the date of superannuation till
actual payments;
(iv)
The
remaining
amount
of
leave
encashment shall be released within a period
of 4(four) months from today. The entire
leave encashment payment shall carry simple
interest @ 7.5% per annum from one month
after the date of retirement till actual
payments;
(v) The gratuity already paid shall also carry
simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one
month after the date of retirement till actual
payments”
In Lal Zakim Rokhum v. Tripura Road Transport
Corporation and Ors. bearing case no. WP(C) No.1209/2019
dated 20.02.2020, this Court in para no.7 observed as under:
“7. In view of the above discussion, respondents are
directed to release the remaining amount of gratuity
payable to the petitioner which shall carry simple
interest @ 7.5 % after completion of one month
from the date of retirement till actual payment.
Payment shall be made within three months from
today.”
From the aforesaid principles of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and this High Court in different cases,
it appears that the petitioner of the present case is entitled to
interest due to delayed payment of retirement benefits.
10.
Here, Learned Counsel for the contesting respondents
in course of hearing, save and except administrative reason and
financial incapacity could not raise any other legal points to
discard the claim submitted by the petitioner and thus it
appears that the respondent no.2 & 3 by their act have
admitted their fault to make payment of the retirement benefits
in belated stage i.e. after the period of retirement. Furthermore,
the
Corporation
also
cannot
take
the
plea
of
financial
constraints indefinitely for paying post retirement benefits to his
employees. The petitioner was in service for more than 38
years. His service is also not covered by the pension scheme.
So after his retirement, he would only have the savings in the
form of gratuity, provident fund accumulated in his account,
leave encashment, group insurance, etc during his old days and
such amount should be paid to him as soon as possible which
the respondents have failed to disburse in time.
In
course
of
hearing,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-department also took the plea that the LIC has not
been made party in this case. But in this regard, it is submitted
that since the department itself made agreement with the LICI,
so it is the liability of the respondent-department to ensure the
claim of the petitioner i.e. the post-retirement benefit within
time.
11.
In view of the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble
the Apex Court and after hearing both the sides, this Court
deems it prudent to allow the writ petition with the following
observations:
i)
The
petitioner
shall
apply
to
the
respondent-
department within a period of 15 days from the date of receipt
of the copy of this judgment in the form of representation with
due calculation as mentioned by him in para 22 of the writ
petition.
ii) The respondent nos.2 & 3 shall examine the
petitioner’s calculation and shall try to make all endeavour to
release the interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the
date of his entitlement till date of payment so as to enable him
to lead a peaceful hassle-free life during the retirement stage
within a period of 3(three) months from today.
12.
A copy of this order, if applied for, be furnished to the
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner immediately and also
a copy of this order be supplied to Learned Counsel for the
contesting respondents for taking up the matter with the
contesting respondent-department for early settlement of the
claim of the petitioner as ordered above.
13.
With this observation, the instant writ petition stands
allowed and disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE Date: 2024.05.14 17:37:56
-07'00'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review