Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 5/2023
1. Sri Satya Ranjan Dey,
S/O late Narendra Chandra Dey, resident of Natunnagar, Barjala,
Durjoynagar, West Tripura, 799009
2. Smt. Tara Pashi,
W/O Kunja Lal Pasi, resident of Barjala, near Khejur Bagan, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, 799006
….. Petitioners
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Secretary, Department of Finance, Government
of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.
New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010
2.
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Ltd.,
to be represented by the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Tripura State
Electricity Corporation Limited, Bidyut Bhavan, Banamalipur, P.S. East
Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN-799001
3.
The Chairman cum Managing Director
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited, Bidyut Bhavan, Banamalipur,
P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN-799001
4.
The Deputy General Manager
Capital Complex, Electrical Division, 79 Tilla, Agartala, Tripura
5.
The Senior Manager
Durjoynagar Electrical Sub-Division, Durjoynagar, Agartala, Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Dates of hearing
:
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate
Mr. N. Majumder, Advocate
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
03.07.2023 / 04.09.2023
Date of delivery of Judgment
and Order
:
06.09.2023
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order
The petitioners filed the instant writ petition for regularization of their
services in the post of Group „D‟ under the respondents. In a nutshell, it is
the case of the petitioners that they were engaged as Contingent workers
under the respondents in the year 2004. The petitioner no. 1 joined as
Contingent worker on August, 2004 and petitioner no. 2 joined on
19.01.2004. It is the further case of the petitioners that their claim for
regularization was matured in the year 2014 on completion of ten years of
service i.e. on 01.09.2014 and 19.02.2014 respectively under the policy
decision taken by the Government of Tripura vide memorandum dated
21.01.2009, but since first round of litigation (W.P(C) No.66 of 2022), till
filing of the present writ petition, their claim for regularization have not been
considered. While disposing of the earlier writ petition [WP(C) No.66 of
2022], vide judgment and order dated 27.06.2022, this court had passed the
following order:
“*5+ It is further submitted by the petitioners that the memorandum no. 10(2)FIN(G)/2008 (Part), dated 01.09.2008, issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Finance Department, was in respect to the regularization of service of
DRW/Casual/Contingent workers on completion of 10 years as on 31.03.2008. By the
aforesaid Memo it was made known, that Govt. has taken a policy decision to regularise
the service of full time DRW/Contingent/Casual workers, who have completed 10 years
service as on 31.03.2008. As per the said Memo, the regularization will take effect from
01.07.2008. The petitioners are squarely covered by the Memo dated 01.09.2008
according to the petitioners.
[6] Having perused the entire records, so placed before this court, this court is of the
opinion that the respondents shall consider the letters dated 29.11.2021 of the
petitioners within two months from the date of the receipt of the copy of this order.”
2.
In compliance of the aforesaid directions, the respondents vide
communication dated 14.12.2022 (Annexure 19 to the writ petition)
informed the petitioner that under the policy decision dated 21.01.2009,
there was complete ban on engagement of DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc.
workers after 31.03.2003 without concurrence from the Finance Department.
The contents of the entire communication (supra) may be reproduced herein-below:
“TRIPURA STATE ELECTRICITY CORPORATION LIMITED
(A Government of Tripura Enterprise)
No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court Case/2022/ 49647-83
Dated the 14th December, 2022
To
Sri Satya Ranjan Dey,
Contingent worker (Technical) [Petitioner-01]
O/o Sr. Manager, ESD- Durjoynagar, Agartala
Sub: Compliance to the Judgment & Order of Hon'ble High Court of Tripura bearing case
no. WP(C) 66 of 2022 dated 27/06/2022 and Cont.Cas(C) No.140 of 2022-reg.
Ref.- Representation of Petitioner-01 dated 29/11/2021 & 20/09/2022.
Sir,
In compliance to the direction of Hon'ble High Court of Tripura bearing case no. WP(C)
66 of 2022 dated 27/06/2022, an Enquiry Committee consisting of higher level officials of
TSECL was formed to enquire about the Service status of the Petitioners vide No.F.3(50)TSECL/HRM/Court Case/2022/47735-45 dated 3" December, 2022. In line to the Enquiry
Committee Report it has been mentioned that you have been engaged under TSECL in
August, 2004 as Contingent worker (Technical) and working on full time basis from the
date of engagement record.
It is also found that you have not completed requisite period of 10 (Ten) years' of
service as on 31/03/2008 from the date of joining in Service as per Memorandum vide
No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part), Govt. of Tripura Department of Finance dated Agartala, the
1st September, 2008. Moreover, by Memorandum dated 21st January 2009 issued by the
Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura in paragraph-3 it was the Policy Decision that there
shall be a complete ban on engagement of DRW/Casual/Contingent etc. workers after
31/03/2003 without concurrence from the Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura. As per
Enquiry Report', no financial concurrence was obtained and hence the regularization of
service of the petitioner-01 cannot be considered.
Therefore, the representation of the petitioner is hereby regretted as you are not
eligible for regularization as per the Memorandum dated 1" September, 2008.
This is for your information and ready reference.
Sd/- Illegible
(Debashis Sarkar)
Managing Director, TSECL”
3.
From the aforesaid communication dated 14.12.2022, it is further
revealed that the petitioners had not completed the requisite period of ten
years of service as on 31.03.2008 from the date of joining in service as per
memorandum vide no. F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part), dated 01.09.2008, issued
by the Government of Tripura, Department of Finance.
4.
Heard Ms. A. Debbarma, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the respondentsTSECL, and Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Additional GA appearing for the
respondent-State.
5.
I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel for
the parties.
6.
At the outset, I have perused the Memorandum dated 01.09.2008
(Annexure 9 to the writ petition), Memorandum dated 21.01.2009
(Annexure 10 to the writ petition), Memorandum dated 03.01.2014
(Annexure 11 to the writ petition) and Memorandum dated 31.07.2018
(Annexure 13 to the writ petition), which would be relevant to decide the
questions involved in the instant petition.
7.
From the Memorandum dated 01.09.2008 issued by the Government
of Tripura, it comes to fore that the Government of Tripura had taken a
policy decision to regularize the services of the “full time DRWs/Casual/
contingent workers”, who had completed ten years of service as on
31.10.2008 subject to fulfillment of some parameters, as laid down under the
said Memorandum.
8.
Under the Memorandum dated 21.01.2009, some further decisions
were taken for the purpose of regularization. One of the most important
decisions, which was taken by the Government of Tripura under the said
memo dated 21.01.2009 (Annexure 10 to the writ petition) is enumerated at
paragraphs 3 and 4, which may be reproduced here-under, for convenience,
in extenso:
“3. There shall be a complete ban on engagement of DRW/Casual/ Contingent etc.
workers after 31.3.2003 without concurrence from Finance Department.
Responsibility shall be fixed on the official found responsible for any irregular
engagement henceforth. Such irregular engagement shall have to be instantly
terminated. The wages, if paid any, shall be recovered from the official concerned.
4. The undersigned is directed to request all concerned to ensure strict
implementation of the above decisions.”
9.
Again, by way of issuance of another Memorandum dated 03.01.2014,
the Government of Tripura instructed all the Heads of the Departments to
furnish the list of workers who were serving as DRWs/Casual/contingent
etc. workers with concurrence of the Finance Department on or after
31.03.2003 in a prescribed format appended to the said Memorandum itself.
10.
However, having continued the above policies of regularization for
more than 10(ten) years, the Government of Tripura as a policy matter had
repealed all the above policies under Memorandum dated 31.07.2018.
11.
After careful consideration of the aforesaid Memorandums conjointly,
it becomes clear that under the Memorandum dated 01.09.2008, the
Government of Tripura decided that the workers who had completed ten
years of service as on 31.03.2008 as full time DRWs/ Casual/Contingent etc.
workers, would only be considered for regularization of their services.
Under memorandum dated 21.01.2009, the Government of Tripura had
declared total ban on the engagement of DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc.
workers after 31.03.2003 without concurrence from the Finance Department.
In addition, the responsibilities had been fixed upon the erring officials and
the concerned authorities were instructed to strict implementation of the
directives of the Government of Tripura under memorandum dated
01.09.2008. Under memorandum dated 03.01.2014, the Government of
Tripura had informed all the concerned authorities to furnish the list of
DRWs/Casual/Contingent etc. workers working under their jurisdiction who
were engaged on or after 31.03.2003 with the concurrence of the Finance
Department.
12.
Now, the issue falls for consideration before this court, in the instant
case, is to examine as to whether the claim for regularization of the
petitioners comes within the ambit of the policy decisions of the
Government of Tripura, as reproduced and discussed here-in-above.
13.
It is evident that both the petitioners were appointed after the cut-off
date 31.03.2003. Moreso, there is absolutely no evidence that the petitioners
were engaged after 31.03.2003 with the concurrence of the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura. Naturally, the petitioners had not
completed requisite period of 10 (ten) years‟ of service as on 31.03.2008
from the date of their joining into service under the respondents, as provided
under the Memorandum dated 01.09.2008. On the above two scores, in the
opinion of this court, the present writ petition merits no consideration.
14.
Furthermore, the rights of the petitioners, if any, to claim
regularization arose in the year 2014 during the life of the afore-discussed
Schemes and within the realm of those schemes, but they had approached
this court for the first time in the year 2022 to enforce their claims, that too,
under the repealed schemes. Such claim, according to this court, by now has
become stale, and thus, is absolutely barred by the doctrine of delay and
laches. On this count also, the present writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
It is re-iterated that the Schemes made for the purpose of regularization of
irregular appointees, as noted here-in-above, were existed for more than 10
(ten) years.
15.
Needless to mention, regularization or absorption is not a matter of
right. It is a right to be considered by the employer and subject to availability
of sanctioned vacant posts, etc. There is no material before this Court that
the petitioners have been working against the regular sanctioned posts. Any
appointments/engagements made not against duly sanctioned posts must not
be treated as “irregular appointments but it would be treated as illegal
appointments”.
16.
It is also established proposition of law that the court cannot direct the
Government to create posts. According to me, creation of post is a matter of
policy, which is absolutely within the domain of the Government itself.
17.
In the context of the case, I may gainfully refer the Constitution
Bench judgment in Secretary, State of Karnataka and others vs. Uma Devi
(3) and others, reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1, where-under it was held that
orders for absorption, regularization or permanent continuance of such
employees are passed apparently in exercise of the wide powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution. The wide powers under Article 226 are not
intended to be used for a purpose certain to defeat the concept of social
justice and equal opportunity for all, subject to affirmative action in the
matter of public employment as recognized by our Constitution. It is time
that the courts desist from issuing orders preventing regular selection or
recruitment at the instance of such persons and from issuing directions for
continuance of those who have not secured regular appointments as per
procedure established. The passing of orders for continuance tends to defeat
the very constitutional scheme of public employment. It has to be
emphasized that this is not the role envisaged for the High Courts in the
scheme of things and their wide powers under Article 226 are not intended
to be used for the purpose of perpetuating illegalities, irregularities or
improprieties or for scuttling the whole scheme of public employment. Its
role as the sentinel and as the guardian of equal rights protection should not
be forgotten. [SCC.p. 18, para 4]
It was further been held that this bypassing of the constitutional
scheme cannot be perpetuated by the passing of orders without dealing with
and deciding the constitutional validity of the interim and final orders of the
Supreme Court and High Courts which have issued directions for
regularization, permanent continuation or absorption without referring to
the legal position obtaining thereby, and which have been relied on by the
respondent employees to claim the same relief. While approaching the
questions falling for decision before this Constitution Bench, it is necessary
to bear this in mind and to bring about certainty in the matter of public
employment. The claim to a parity of treatment based on such orders also
highlights the need for the Supreme Court to formally lay down the law on
the question and ensure certainty in dealings relating to public employment.
The very divergence in approach in the Supreme Court, the so-called
equitable approach made in some, as against those decisions which have
insisted on the rules being followed, also justifies a firm decision by the
Supreme Court one way or the other. It is necessary to put an end to
uncertainty and clarify the legal position emerging from the constitutional
scheme, leaving the High Courts to follow necessarily, the law thus laid
down. This Constitution Bench has to lay down the law. It has to approach
the question as a constitutional court should. [SCC.pp. 20, 23-24, paras 10
& 14]
In para 53 of Uma Devi (3)(supra), it has been held that“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases where irregular appointments
(not illegal appointments) as explained in State of Mysore vs. S.V. Narayanappa, reported in
(1967) 1 SCR 128, R.N. Nanjundappa vs. T. Thimmiah, reported in (1972) 1 SCC 409, B.N.
Nagarajan vs. State of Karnataka, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 507, and referred to in
paragraph 15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly sanctioned vacant posts might have
been made and the employees have continued to work for ten years or more but without
the intervention of orders of courts or of tribunals. The question of regularization of the
services of such employees may have to be considered on merits in the light of the principles
settled by this Court in the cases above referred to and in the light of this judgment. In that
context, the Union of India, the State Governments and their instrumentalities should take
steps to regularize as a one time measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who
have worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of orders of
courts or of tribunals and should further ensure that regular recruitments are undertaken to
fill those vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in cases where temporary
employees or daily wagers are being now employed. The process must be set in motion
within six months from this date. We also clarify that regularization, if any already made,
but not subjudice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but there should be no
further by-passing of the constitutional requirement and regularizing or making permanent,
those not duly appointed as per the constitutional scheme.”
18.
In the instant case, there is no averment that the petitioners have been
working in duly sanctioned vacant posts under the respondents. One of the
pre-conditions as laid down by the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)
(supra), is that the employees concerned apart from due qualification,
should have worked for 10 (ten) years or more in a “duly sanctioned vacant
post” without the benefit or protection of any interim order from any court
or tribunal.
19.
Further, the direction of the Constitution Bench was that the Union of
India, State Governments and their instrumentalities to take steps to
regularize the services of irregularly appointed temporary employees or
daily wagers as “one time measure”. In the line of the directions, the State
of Tripura had formulated schemes as stated supra to regularize the services
of the Daily Rated Workers (DRWs), Casual, and Contingent Workers.
Those schemes were continued for long 10(ten) years. During the said
period, the employees/workers who had completed 10(ten) years of service
on 31.03.2008 were regularized either by the Government or by the order of
this Court within the realms of the policy. As stated above, the Government
also decided to regularize those classes of irregularly appointed employees
who were engaged on or after the cut-off date (31.03.2003) with concurrence
of the Finance Department. The schemes were existed for more than 10(ten)
years till those were repealed vide Memorandum dated 31.07.2018.
20.
In Uma Devi (3) (supra), Hon‟ble Supreme Court has extended the
benefit of regularization as “one time measure” to the employees who were
appointed irregularly, but, not illegally against duly sanctioned posts. In
State of Karnataka vs. M.L. Kesari, reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247, the
distinction between the illegal appointment and irregular appointment was
made in the manner as under:
“7. It is evident from the above that there is an exception to the general principle against
regularization enunciated in Uma Devi (3) 1, if the following conditions are fulfilled:
(i) The employee concerned should have worked for 10 years or more in a duly
sanctioned post without the benefit or protection of the interim order of any court or
tribunal. In other words, the State Government or its instrumentality should have
employed the employee and continued him in service voluntarily and continuously for
more than ten years.
(ii) The appointment should not be illegal, even if irregular. Where the appointments
are not made or continued against sanctioned posts or where the person appointed do
not possess the prescribed minimum qualifications, the appointments will be
considered illegal. But where the person possessed the prescribed qualifications and
was working against sanctioned posts, but had been selected without undergoing the
process of open competitive selection, such appointments are considered to be
irregular.
8. Umadevi (3) 1 casts a duty upon the Government or instrumentality concerned to take
steps to regularize the services of those irregularly appointed employees who had served
for more than ten years without the benefit or protection of interim orders of courts or
tribunals, as a one time-measures, Umadevi (3)1 directed that such one time-measure
must be set in motion within six months from the date of its decision.
9. The term ‘one time-measure’ has to be understood in its proper perspective. This
would normally mean that after the decision in Umadevi (3) 1, each department or
instrumentality should undertake a one-time exercise and prepare a list of all casual, daily
wage or ad-hoc employees who have been working for more than ten years without the
intervention of courts and tribunals and subject them to a process verification as to
whether they are working against vacant posts and possess the requisite qualification for
the post and if so, regularize their service.”
21.
As I have said earlier, in the instant case, there is no material before
this court that the petitioners were appointed against duly sanctioned regular
posts and the said posts were vacant at the time of their appointment or are
still lying vacant. That apart, since the appointments of the petitioners were
not made in duly sanctioned posts, their appointments cannot be said to be
irregular appointments, but, as per Uma Devi (3)(supra) and M.L. Kesari
(supra), their appointments were illegal appointments. In addition, the
petitioners have merely stated that they have requisite qualifications for
appointments against Group-D posts, but, did not furnish any documents in
support of this statement.
22.
Another interesting feature surfaced in the present case, is that the
petitioners have not been able to produce any document that they were
appointed as Contingent Workers under any order of the competent authority
of the respondent-TSECL. Only they have annexed Certificates dated
05.06.2007 and 10.10.2011 issued by the Senior Manager (Elect.) of the
Electrical Sub-Division under the Respondent no. 2 (TSECL), namely,
Durjoynagar Electrical Sub-Division (Annexures 1 and 2 to the writ
petition). Needless to say, that a Senior Manager of an Electrical SubDivision is not the appointing authority. So, on this score also, the
appointments of the petitioners under the Respondents no. 2 and 3 were per
se illegal.
23.
In the instant case, it is revealed by this court that in compliance with
the directions passed by this court while disposing of the writ petition being
WP(C) 66 of 2022, the respondents had constituted an Enquiry Committee.
The Enquiry Committee after examining all the records had found the
petitioners not eligible for regularization, as stated and discussed here-inabove. In this situation, this Court in exercise of power of judicial review
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India will not sit in appeal to
re-evaluate the eligibility of the petitioners and review the correctness of the
decision of the Enquiry Committee.
24.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan and ors. vs. Daya
Lal & ors., reported in (2011) 2 SCC 429, while dealing a case in respect of
regularization or absorption of some of the temporarily appointed employees
under the State of Rajasthan, had recast the well-settled principles relating to
regularization, which is as under: [SCC pp. 435, 436, para 12]
“12. We may at the outset refer to the following well settled principles relating to
regularization and parity in pay, relevant in the context of these appeals:
(i) The High Courts, in exercising power under Article 226 of the Constitution will not issue
directions for regularization, absorption or permanent continuance, unless the employees
claiming regularization had been appointed in pursuance of a regular recruitment in
accordance with relevant rules in an open competitive process, against sanctioned vacant
posts. The equality clause contained in Articles 14 and 16 should be scrupulously followed
and courts should not issue a direction for regularization of services of an employee
which would be violative of constitutional scheme. While something that is irregular for
want of compliance with one of the elements in the process of selection which does not
go to the root of the process, can be regularized, back door entries, appointments
contrary to the constitutional scheme and/or appointment of ineligible candidates cannot
be regularized.
(ii) Mere continuation of service by an temporary or ad hoc or daily-wage employee,
under cover of some interim orders of the court, would not confer upon him any right to
be absorbed into service, as such service would be `litigious employment'. Even
temporary, ad hoc or daily- wage service for a long number of years, let alone service for
one or two years, will not entitle such employee to claim regularization, if he is not
working against a sanctioned post. Sympathy and sentiment cannot be grounds for
passing any order of regularization in the absence of a legal right.
(iii) Even where a scheme is formulated for regularization with a cut-off date (that is a
scheme providing that persons who had put in a specified number of years of service and
continuing in employment as on the cut-off date), it is not possible to others who were
appointed subsequent to the cut-off date, to claim or contend that the scheme should be
applied to them by extending the cut-off date or seek a direction for framing of fresh
schemes providing for successive cut off dates.
(iv) Part-time employees are not entitled to seek regularization as they are not working
against any sanctioned posts. There cannot be a direction for absorption, regularization
or permanent continuance of part time temporary employees.
(v) Part time temporary employees in government run institutions cannot claim parity in
salary with regular employees of the government on the principle of equal pay for equal
work. Nor can employees in private employment, even if serving full time, seek parity in
salary with government employees. The right to claim a particular salary against the State
must arise under a contract or under a statute.
(See : Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi - 2006 (4) SCC 1, M. Raja vs. CEERI
Educational Society, Pilani - 2006 (12) SCC 636, S.C. Chandra vs. State of Jharkhand - 2007
(8) SCC 279, Kurukshetra Central Co-operative Bank Ltd vs. Mehar Chand - 2007 (15) SCC
680, and Official Liquidator vs. Dayanand - 2008 (10 SCC 1)”
25.
What emerges in Daya lal (supra) is that the appointments even if
irregular must be against sanctioned posts. Sympathy and Sentiment cannot
be a ground for passing any order of regularization in the absence of a legal
right. Further, whereas the scheme is formulated for regularization with
cut-off date (i.e. a scheme providing that persons who have put in a
specified number of years and continuing in employment as on cut-off
date), it is not possible to others who were appointed subsequent to the cutoff date, to claim or contend that the scheme should be applied to them by
extending the cut-off date.
[Emphasis supplied]
26.
I have already discussed that in the instant case, the petitioners had,
firstly, failed to assert or in other words, could not substantiate that they
were appointed against “sanctioned vacant posts” and, secondly, both the
petitioners were appointed after cut-off date 31.03.2003.
27.
However, I am not unoblivious of the decisions and directions of the
two-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Narendra Kumar Tiwari
and ors. vs. State of Jharkhand and ors., reported in (2018) 8 SCC 238,
[though not referred by learned Counsel for the petitioner] where the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court directed the State of Jharkhand to take necessary
steps for regularization of the irregularly appointed employees in the spirit of
the decisions of the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra). In the case
of Narendra Kumar Tiwari (supra), the Hon‟ble supreme Court had
referred and discussed the cases of Uma Devi (3)(supra) and M.L. Keshari
(supra). To evaluate the distinguishing features of the case in hand, than that
of the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari (supra), it is necessary to reproduce
the relevant paragraphs from the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari (supra) :[SCC.pp.240, 241,242, paras 5,6,7,8,9,10,11 & 12]
“5. The decision in Umadevi (3) was intended to put a full stop to the somewhat
pernicious practice of irregularly or illegally appointing daily wage workers and continuing
with them indefinitely. In fact, in paragraph 49 of the Report, it was pointed out that the
rule of law requires appointments to be made in a constitutional manner and the State
cannot be permitted to perpetuate an irregularity in the matter of public employment
which would adversely affect those who could be employed in terms of the constitutional
scheme. It is for this reason that the concept of a one-time measure and a cut-off date
was introduced in the hope and expectation that the State would cease and desist from
making irregular or illegal appointments and instead make appointments on a regular
basis.
6. The concept of a one-time measure was further explained in Kesari in paragraphs 9, 10
and 11 of the Report which read as follows: (SCC pp.250-51, paras 9-11)
“9. The term “one-time measure” has to be understood in its proper perspective.
This would normally mean that after the decision in Umadevi (3), each department
or each instrumentality should undertake a one-time exercise and prepare a list of
all casual, daily-wage or ad hoc employees who have been working for more than
ten years without the intervention of courts and tribunals and subject them to a
process verification as to whether they are working against vacant posts and
possess the requisite qualification for the post and if so, regularise their services.
10. At the end of six months from the date of decision in Umadevi (3), cases of
several daily-wage/ad hoc/casual employees were still pending before courts.
Consequently, several departments and instrumentalities did not commence the
one-time regularisation process. On the other hand, some government
departments or instrumentalities undertook the one- time exercise excluding
several employees from consideration either on the ground that their cases were
pending in courts or due to sheer oversight. In such circumstances, the employees
who were entitled to be considered in terms of para 53 of the decision in Umadevi
(3), will not lose their right to be considered for regularisation, merely because the
one-time exercise was completed without considering their cases, or because the
six- month period mentioned in para 53 of Umadevi (3) has expired. The one-time
exercise should consider all daily-wage/ad hoc/casual employees who had put in 10
years of continuous service as on 10-4-2006 without availing the protection of any
interim orders of courts or tribunals. If any employer had held the one-time
exercise in terms of para 53 of Umadevi (3), but did not consider the cases of some
employees who were entitled to the benefit of para 53 of Umadevi (3), the
employer concerned should consider their cases also, as a continuation of the onetime exercise. The one-time exercise will be concluded only when all the employees
who are entitled to be considered in terms of para 53 of Umadevi (3), are so
considered.
11. The object behind the said direction in para 53 of Umadevi (3) is twofold. First is
to ensure that those who have put in more than ten years of continuous service
without the protection of any interim orders of courts or tribunals, before the date
of decision in Umadevi (3) was rendered, are considered for regularisation in view
of their long service. Second is to ensure that the departments/instrumentalities do
not perpetuate the practice of employing persons on daily-wage/ad hoc/casual
basis for long periods and then periodically regularise them on the ground that they
have served for more than ten years, thereby defeating the constitutional or
statutory provisions relating to recruitment and appointment. The true effect of
the direction is that all persons who have worked for more than ten years as on 104-2006 [the date of decision in Umadevi (3)] without the protection of any interim
order of any court or tribunal, in vacant posts, possessing the requisite
qualification, are entitled to be considered for regularisation. The fact that the
employer has not undertaken such exercise of regularisation within six months of
the decision in Umadevi (3) or that such exercise was undertaken only in regard to
a limited few, will not disentitle such employees, the right to be considered for
regularisation in terms of the above directions in Umadevi (3) as a one-time
measure.”
7. The purpose and intent of the decision in Umadevi (3) was therefore two-fold, namely,
to prevent irregular or illegal appointments in the future and secondly, to confer a benefit
on those who had been irregularly appointed in the past. The fact that the State of
Jharkhand continued with the irregular appointments for almost a decade after the
decision in Umadevi (3) is a clear indication that it believes that it was all right to continue
with irregular appointments, and whenever required, terminate the services of the
irregularly appointed employees on the ground that they were irregularly appointed. This
is nothing but a form of exploitation of the employees by not giving them the benefits of
regularisation and by placing the sword of Damocles over their head. This is precisely
what Umadevi (3) and Kesari sought to avoid.
8. If a strict and literal interpretation, forgetting the spirit of the decision of the
Constitution Bench in Umadevi (3), is to be taken into consideration then no irregularly
appointed employee of the State of Jharkhand could ever be regularised since that State
came into existence only on 15th November, 2000 and the cut-off date was fixed as 10 th
April, 2006. In other words, in this manner the pernicious practice of indefinitely
continuing irregularly appointed employees would be perpetuated contrary to the intent
of the Constitution Bench.
9. The High Court as well as the State of Jharkhand ought to have considered the entire
issue in a contextual perspective and not only from the point of view of the interest of the
State, financial or otherwise – the interest of the employees is also required to be kept in
mind. What has eventually been achieved by the State of Jharkhand is to short circuit the
process of regular appointments and instead make appointments on an irregular basis.
This is hardly good governance.
10. Under the circumstances, we are of the view that the Regularisation Rules must be
given a pragmatic interpretation and the appellants, if they have completed 10 years of
service on the date of promulgation of the Regularisation Rules, ought to be given the
benefit of the service rendered by them. If they have completed 10 years of service they
should be regularised unless there is some valid objection to their regularisation like
misconduct etc.
11. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is set aside in view of our
conclusions. The State should take a decision within four months from today on
regularisation of the status of the appellants. 13. The appeals are accordingly disposed of.
12. We may add that that it would be worthwhile for the State of Jharkhand to
henceforth consider making regular appointments only and dropping the idea of making
irregular appointments so as to short circuit the process of regular appointments.”
28.
On meticulous reading of the above paragraphs, it is clear that the
two-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Narendra Kumar Tiwari
(supra) has approved the interpretation of the term “one-time measure” as
explained in M.L. Keshari (supra) that the State or its instrumentalities had
to undertake one-time exercise for regularization of all casual, daily wages
or adhoc employees who had been working for more than ten years without
the intervention of the courts or tribunals and subject to a process of
verification as to whether such employees were working against sanctioned
vacant posts, and possess requisite qualification for the post they were
holding. In the process of such regularization, if any employer had held the
„one-time exercise‟ in terms of para 53 of Uma Devi (3) (supra), but did not
consider the cases of some employees who were entitled to the benefit of
para 53 of Uma Devi (3) (supra), the employer concern who considered
their cases also as a continuation of „one-time exercise‟. Furthermore, the
said „one-time exercise‟ would be concluded only when all the employees
who were entitled to be considered in terms of para 53 of Uma Devi (3)
(supra) were considered.
29.
In my opinion, the object behind the directions passed by the
Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra) was to save all daily-wage, ad
hoc, casual employees from exploitations by the State and their
instrumentalities and to bind the States and their instrumentalities to stop
irregular appointments ignoring the established norms of employment as
enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. There are
conditionalities. Firstly, the employees must have completed atleast 10 (ten)
years of continuous service as on 10.04.2006 [the date of decision in Uma
Devi (3) (supra)] without the protection of any interim orders of courts or
tribunals; Secondly, those appointments, though irregular, but not illegal;
Thirdly, the appointments must be against sanctioned vacant posts; and,
Fourthly, they must possess requisite qualification commensurate the posts
they held.
30.
In the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court had observed that the State of Jharkhand continued with the irregular
appointments for almost a decade after the decision of Uma Devi (3)(supra).
It was further observed that the State of Jharkhand had taken it granted that
it is all right to continue with irregular appointments, and whenever required,
could terminate the services of the irregularly appointed employees on the
ground that they were irregularly appointed, and in that context, it was held
that the said process was nothing but a form of exploitation of the employees
by not giving them the benefits of regularization and by placing the sword of
Damocles over their head, contrary to the object, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
wanted to achieve in the case of Uma Devi (3)(supra) and M.L. Keshari
(supra).
31.
I am constrained to say that this is not the state of affairs in the case in
hand. The Government of Tripura had come up with a policy decision in
terms of the decision of the Constitution bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra) in
respect to the regularization of the services of the DRWs/casual/contingent
workers who had completed 10(ten) years of continuous services on
31.03.2008 subject to other eligible criterias enumerated in the said policy
dated 1st September, 2008 (Annexure 9 to the writ petition). The process was
carried out in terms of the said policy and the services of many employees
were regularized in their respective posts. Many eligible employees who
were excluded from the benefit of regularization of their services were
regularized in terms of the direction of this court being approached this court
by such employees. The policy decision of the Government of Tripura under
Memorandum
dated
01.09.2008
convenience, in verbatim:
is
reproduced
here-in-below,
for
“No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part)
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated, Agartala, the 1st September, 2008
MEMORANDUM
Subject:
Regularization of services of DRWS/ Casual/ Contingent Workers on
completion of 10 years of service as on 31-03-2008
The undersigned is directed to inform that the Government has taken a policy decision
to regularize services of full-time DRWS/Casual/Contingent Workers who have
completed 10 (ten) years of service as on 31-03-2008 and fulfill the following criterion
as per Department-wise names and particulars attached herewith:
i)
DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who were engaged on a full time basis in
different Departments with or without concurrence of Finance Department and have
completed 10 years of service as on 31-3-2008 other than Permanent Labourers, Parttime workers, Anganwadi Workers and Helpers, Home Guards, Teachers and Workers
engaged under SSA and other Schemes/programmes, may be considered for
regularization as per names attached.
ii)
Requirement of age as per Recruitment Rules will be deemed to be relaxedfor
the purpose of this regularization.
iii)
Requirement of educational qualification as per Recruitment Rules will be
deemed as relaxed for regularization under Group D only. In case of DRW/ and
Contingent Workers who were appointed under Group-C category, educational
qualification as required under concerned R.R. must be ensured while entertaining
their cases for regularization.
iv)
Except age and educational qualification mentioned in point (iii) all other
criterion as per relevant Recruitment Rules including reservation roster will have to be
followed strictly for this process of regularization.
v) Subject to fulfillment of above conditions, the eligible workers will be provided pay
scale in the relevant grade for their regularization which will take effect from 1st July
2008.
2. To facilitate quick action for implementation of the above decision, appropriate
authorities of the concerned Administrative Departments of the State Government are
authorized to take following actions:
i) The Departments will scrutinize the records and particulars of the workers whose
names and particulars are included in the annexure attached herewith to ascertain
their eligibility for regularization. Only those workers out of the attached annexure
who fulfills all the above criterion are to be regularized.
ii) While ascertaining eligibility, other than relaxation made in respect of educational
qualification and age, other requirements like nationality, reservation quota are to be
followed strictly.
iii) After ascertaining the number of eligible cases, the department will take steps for
creation of required number of posts in the appropriate category including creation for
post for SC and ST as per 100 point roster for accommodating them in the concerned
pay scale for regularization. The computation is to be done to ensure 31% reservation
for ST & 17% reservation for SC against the member of UR candidates as per list
enclosed without bringing any previous backlog. Formal appointment orders are to be
issued by concerned appropriate authority accordingly. After taking this step
department will send proposal to the Finance Department for ex-post-facto
concurrence for creation of posts.
iv) Following regularization of the eligible cases out of list attached herewith, the
Departments are required to take action to ensure recruitment of shortfall of
candidates under ST & SC category to fulfill the roster. In respect of such shortfall
under Group D category, the Tribal Welfare Department would act as the Nodal
Department for selection of required number of candidates and sponsoring them to
the respective Department. The Departments are requested to send a report within
one month to the Finance Department indicating action taken as per the instant
Memorandum and details of posts filled up/lying vacant on completion of the process.
3. The undersigned is directed to request all concerned to ensure strict implementation
of the above decisions.
Sd/- illegible
(N. Das)
Joint Secretary to the Government of Tripura”
Thereafter, the State of Tripura had issued another Memorandum
dated 21.01.2009 (Annexure 10 to the writ petition), which for convenience,
may be reproduced here-under, in extenso:
“No. F.10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(Part)
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated, Agartala, the 21st January, 2009
MEMORANDUM
Subject: Regularization of services of DRW/Casual/Contingent Workers on the next
date of completion of 10 years of service.
The undersigned is directed to inform that the Government has taken a policy decision
to regularize services of full-time DRWS/Casual/Contingen Workers from the next date
of completion of 10 years of service and fulfill the following criterion as per
Department-wise names and particulars attached herewith:
(1) DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who were engaged on a full time basis in
different Departments with or without concurrence of Finance Department other than
Permanent Labourers, Part-time workers. Anganwadi Workers and Helpers, Home
Guards, Teachers and Workers engaged under SSA and other Schemes/ programmes,
may be considered for regularization as per names attached.
(ii) Requirement of age as per Recruitment Rules will be deemed to be relaxed for the
purpose of this regularization.
(iii) Requirement of educational qualification as per Recruitment Rules will be deemed as
relaxed for regularization under Group-D only. In case of DRW/ and Contingent Workers
who were appointed under Group-C category, educational qualification as required
under concerned R.R. must be ensured while entertaining their cases for regularization.
(iv) Except age and educational qualification mentioned in point (ii) & ( all other criterion
as per relevant Recruitment Rules including reservation roster will have to be followed
strictly for this process of regularization.
(v) Subject to fulfillment of above conditions, the eligible workers will be provided pay
scale in the relevant post on the following day of completion of 10 years of
service(without any break) from the date of joining. In the event of revision of pay scales
the revised structure will be followed as per Govt.'s decision
2.
To facilitate quick action for implementation of the above decisions, appropriate
authorities of the concerned Administrative Departments of the State Government are
authorized to take following actions:
i) The Departments will scrutinize the records and particulars of the workers whose
names and particulars are included in the annexure attached herewith to ascertain their
eligibility for regularization. Only those workers out of the attached annexure who fulfills
all the above criteria are to be regularized.
ii) While ascertaining eligibility, other than relaxation made in respect of educational
qualification and age, other requirements like nationality, reservation quota are to be
followed strictly. All original documents shall be checked by the Departments to ensure
genuineness of records/documents.
iii) After ascertaining the number of eligible cases, the department will take steps for
creation of required number of posts in the appropriate category including creation of
post for SC and ST as per 100 point roster for accommodating them in the concerned pay
scale for regularization. The computation is to be done to ensure 31% réservation for ST
& 17% reservation for SC against the number of UR candidates as per list enclosed
without bringing any previous backlog. Formal appointment orders are to be issued by
concerned appropriate authority accordingly. After taking this step department will send
proposal to the Finance Department for ex-post-facto concurrence for creation of posts.
iv) Following regularization of the eligible cases out of list attached herewith, the
Departments are required to take action to ensure recruitment of shortfall of candidates
under ST & SC category to fulfill the roster. In respect of such shortfall under Group D
category, the Tribal Welfare Department would act as the Nodal Department for
selection of required number of candidates and sponsoring them to the respective
Department. The Departments are requested to send report to the Finance Department
within one month immediately after action taken as per the instant Memorandum
alongwith list of workers regularized.
3.
There shall be a complete ban on engagement of DRW/Casual Contingent etc.
workers after 31.3.2003 without concurrence from Finance Department. Responsibility
shall be fixed on the official found responsible for any irregular engagement
henceforth. Such irregular engagement shall have to be instantly terminated. The
wages, if paid any, shall be recovered from the official concerned.
4. The undersigned is directed to request all concerned to ensure strict implementation
of the above decisions.
Sd/- illegible
(N. Das)
Joint Secretary to the Government of Tripura”
32.
Noticeably, under the policy dated 21.01.2009, the Government of
Tripura as a policy maker had declared a complete ban on engagement of
DRWs/casual/contingent workers after 31.03.2003 without concurrence
from the Finance Department. Even it was declared that the responsibilities
would be fixed on the officials found responsible for any irregular
employments henceforth, and such irregular engagement would have to be
instantly terminated. It was further decided that the wages, if paid, would be
recovered from the official concerned (Clause 3 of the Memorandum dated
21.01.2009) (Annexure 10 to the writ petition).
33.
It is pertinent to mention here that both the petitioners of the present
writ petition were appointed after 31.03.2003 and there is no material or
evidence that they were appointed with concurrence from the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura. Thereafter, the Government of Tripura
had undertaken further exercise to regularize services of the DRWs/casual/
contingent etc. workers having noticed that in some departments such
workers were engaged with prior approval of the Finance Department on
Full Time basis after 31.03.2003, and some of them by that time had
completed 10 (ten) years of continuous service, and in this regard, a policy
decision was taken on 3rd January, 2014 (Annexure 11 to the writ petition).
In view of the aforesaid policy decision dated 03.01.2014, the Government
of Tripura directed the Heads of all the Departments to send the names of
DRWs/casual/contingent workers to Finance Department who were engaged
after 31.03.2003 with prior approval of the Finance Department, in
prescribed format within 10th January, 2014.
34.
On conjoint reading of the policy decision under Memorandums dated
21.01.2009 and 03.01.2014, I find two factors for the purpose of
regularization of DRWs/casual/contingent workers. Firstly, the Government
of Tripura had declared complete ban on engagement of such workers after
31.03.2003 without concurrence from the Finance Department and
responsibility was also fixed on the erring officials. Secondly, the then
existing policy being reviewed, the Government of Tripura found that in
some departments the DRWs/casual/contingent workers were engaged with
prior approval of the Finance Department with Full Time basis after
31.03.2003 and some of them by that time had completed 10(ten) years of
continuous services.
35.
As a matter of further exercise, the Government had decided to
regularize the services of such workers and the Heads of the Department
were directed to submit the list of the workers who fulfilled the above
criteria within a stipulated date, i.e., within 10 th January, 2014 in a
prescribed format. On perusal of the writ petition and having heard learned
counsel appearing for the parties, I find no evidence that the names of the
petitioners had ever been considered by the Heads of the Department to the
Government of Tripura for consideration of their regularization, though the
process continued for a considerable periods. There is no evidence that the
petitioners, though were appointed after 31.03.2003, but, were engaged with
prior concurrence of the Finance Department. Thereafter, the Government of
Tripura had come up with a Memorandum dated 31.07.2018 (Annexure 13
to the writ petition) whereunder all the policy decisions formulated for
regularization of DRWs/casual/contingent workers had been repealed. It
would be apposite to reproduce the Memorandum dated 31.07.2018 issued
by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura, for convenience, in
extenso:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
Dated:- The 31st July, 2018
MEMORANDUM
Subject: Policy decision of regularization of service of DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc.
Workers in Government Establishment and State PSUs and Autonomous bodies including
AMC/NPS
Finance Department has issued instructions from time to time as given for regularization
of service of DRWs/Casual/Contingent/PTW etc. workers on the date completion of 17
years/15 years/10 years of services. The memorandums are as follows:
Sl.No.
Memo No.
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/05,
Dated 04.03.2006
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/05,
Dated 22.02.2007
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/08(part),
Dated 01.09.2008
No.F.10(2)-Fin(G)/ 08(part),
Dated 21.01.2009
No.F.34(3)-Fin(G)/2012,
Dated 04.09.2012
No.F.10(12)-Fin(G)/7(part-1),
Dated 07.11.2012
Issues
Regularization of DRWs/Contingent etc. workers on
completion of 17 years of service as on 31.03.2005
allowing effect from 01.02.2006
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent
etc.
workers on completion of 15 years of service as on
31.03.2006 allowing effect from 01.01.2007
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent
etc.
workers on completion of 10 years of service as on
31.03.2008 allowing effect from 01.07.2008
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent
etc.
workers from the next date of completion of 10
years of service
Regularization of DRWs/Casual/Contingent
etc.
workers working in State PSUs and Autonomous
bodies including AMC/NPs on completion of 10 years
of service
Engagement of PTWs etc. as DRWs (Group-D)
working in different Departments of the Government
for 2/3/4 hours who were engaged on or prior to
31.03.2003 and have completed 10 years of service
w.e.f. 01.12.2012
2. Recently, the matter has been further reviewed it has been observed that there are
some shortcoming in these instructions for regularization of the service of
DRWs/Casual/contingent staff affecting institutional efficiency and individual
productivity due to different reasons.
3. With a view to ensure transparent public employment policy for engagement of staff
for such services, all the memorandums as mentioned above is repealed.
4. All the concerned are required to ensure the implementation of above decision with
immediate effect.
Under Secretary to
Government of Tripura
Finance Department”
36.
Now, reverting to the facts of the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari
(supra), it comes to fore that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had noticed that
the exercise undertaken by the State of Jharkhand for regularization of
irregularly appointed employees suffers from doctrine of impossibility. The
State of Jharkhand came into existence only on 15.11.2000, but the cut-off
date for the purpose of regularization of the irregularly appointed employees
under the State of Jharkhand was fixed as 10.04.2006. It was noticed that the
State of Jharkhand was preferring to continue with irregular appointments.
In that context, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had held that when the State of
Jharkhand came into existence only on 15.11.2000 it was impossible for any
of the employees to complete 10 (ten) years of continuous service as on
10.04.2006, further holding that, such pernicious practice of indefinitely
continuing of irregularly appointed employees would be perpetuated
contrary to the spirit and intent of the decision of the Constitution Bench in
Uma Devi (3)(supra) and directed the State of Jharkhand to take a decision
within four months from the date of the judgment (decided on August, 1,
2018) for regularization of the services of the irregularly appointed
employees who have completed 10 (ten) years of service.
37.
In my opinion, any direction for regularization dehors the directions
passed by the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi (3)(supra), will tentamount
to show disrespect to the Constitution as well as the Constitution Bench of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court where it directed the Union of India, the State
and their instrumentalities to desist from appointing any person inconsistent
to the constitutional schemes as enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. According to this court, the Constitution Bench
judgment in Uma Devi (3)(supra) is obiter dicta upon all the courts.
38.
I have taken note of the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Nihal Singh & Ors. vs. State of Punjab & Ors., reported in (2013)14 SCC
65, where the State of Punjab was directed to regularize the services of the
Special Police Officers by creating necessary posts within a certain period.
After perusal of the said judgment, in my opinion, in the said case, the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court did not decide any ratio, but, directed the
Government of Punjab to regularize the services of the SPOs on
consideration of the fact that requisition for engagement of SPOs was given
by the bank authorities to guard and protect the banks operating in the State
and expenditures including their salaries would be borne by those banks
only, and not by the State Government.
Added to it, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Nihal Singh(supra)
categorically held that “ the creation of posts necessarily means additional
financial burden on the exchequer of the State. Depending upon the
priorities of the State, the allocation of the finances is no doubt exclusively
within the domain of the legislature. However in the instant case creation
of new posts would not create any additional financial burden to the State
as the various banks at whose disposal the services of each of the
appellants is made available have agreed to bear the burden.”[SCC p.80,
para 36].
39.
More importantly, in Divisional Manager, Aravali Golf Club & Anr.
Vs. Chander Hass & Anr., reported in (2008) 1 SCC 683, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has settled the proposition that the courts cannot direct the
creation of posts. Creation and sanction of posts is a prerogative act of the
legislatures and executives. The Apex Court held thus:
“5. The court cannot direct the creation of posts. Creation and sanction of posts is a
prerogative of the executive or legislative authorities and the court cannot arrogate to
itself this purely executive or legislative function, and direct creation of posts in any
organisation. This Court has time and again pointed out that the creation of a post is an
executive or legislative function and it involves economic factors. Hence the courts
cannot take upon themselves the power of creation of a post. Therefore, the directions
given by the High Court and the first appellate court to create the posts of tractor driver
and regularize the services of the respondents against the said posts cannot be sustained
and are hereby set aside.”
40.
In a later case, in Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation &
Anr. vs. Casteribe Rajya Parivahan Karmchari Sanghatana reported in
(2009)8 SCC 556, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held thus:
“41. Thus, there is no doubt that creation of posts is not within the domain of judicial
functions which obviously pertains to the executive. It is also true that the status of
permanency cannot be granted by the Court where no such posts exist and that executive
functions and powers with regard to the creation of posts cannot be arrogated by the
courts.”
41.
I have also kept in mind the case of Amarkant Rai vs. State of Bihar
& Ors., reported in (2015) 8 SCC 265, where the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
directed the Government of Bihar to regularize the services of the petitioner,
Amarkant Rai. In the said decision the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had found
that the petitioner/appellant Amarkant fell in exception carved out in
Umadevi(3)(supra). A two-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Amarkant (supra) had considered the fact that the engagement of Amarkant
was irregular but not illegal. He served for 29 years. There were two
sanctioned vacant posts of Class IV employees in the concerned college and
Amarkant was appointed against the same. It was found that the Human
Resources Development, Department of Bihar Government, vide its Letter
dated 11.7.1989 intimated to the Registrar of all the Colleges that as per the
settlement dated 26.4.1989 held between Bihar State University and College
Employees' Federation and the Government, it was agreed that the services
of the employees working in the educational institutions on the basis of
prescribed staffing pattern are to be regularized. Besides, in terms of
Resolution No. 989 dated 10.5.1991 issued by the Human Resources
Development Department, employees working upto 10.5.1986 had to be
adjusted against the vacancies arising in future. It was noticed that the
petitioner was appointed in 1983 temporarily. In the context of the said case,
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that though the initial engagement of the
appellant was not against a sanctioned post, but, he was entitled to
regularization pursuant to said resolution in one of the sanctioned posts
subsequently fell vacant.[SCC p. 269, para 9].
42.
In State of M.P. and others vs Yogesh Chandra Dubey and others,
reported in (2006) 8 SCC 67, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while dealing
with a claim of regularization and minimum of pay scale has held that the
State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India, while
offering public employment, must comply with the constitutional as also
statutory requirements. Appointments to the posts must be made in terms of
the existing Rules. A person who had been appointed by State upon
following the Recruitment Rules, enjoys a status. A post must be created
and/or sanctioned before filling it up. As the respondents did not hold any
post, they are not entitled to any scale of pay. It has further been held that
regularization is not a mode of appointment. If any recruitment is made by
way of regularization, the same would mean a back door appointment, which
does not have any legal sanction [Ref. paras 9, 11 and 14].
43.
In M.P. State Coop. Bank Ltd. Bhopal vs Nanuram Yadav and
others, reported in (2007) 8 SCC 264, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that:
[SCC pp. 274, 275, Para 24]
“24) It is clear that in the matter of public appointments, the following principles are to be
followed:
1) The appointments made without following the appropriate procedure under the
Rules/Government Circulars and without advertisement or inviting applications from the
open market would amount to breach of Arts. 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.
2) Regularisation cannot be a mode of appointment.
3) An appointment made in violation of the mandatory provisions of the statute and in
particular, ignoring the minimum educational qualification and other essential
qualification would be wholly illegal. Such illegality cannot be cured by taking recourse to
regularization.
4) Those who come by back door should go through that door.
5) No regularization is permissible in exercise of the statutory power conferred under Art.
162 of the Constitution of India if the appointments have been made in contravention of
the statutory Rules.
6) The Court should not exercise its jurisdiction on misplaced sympathy.
7) If the mischief played so widespread and all pervasive, affecting the result, so as to
make it difficult to pick out the persons who have been unlawfully benefited or
wrongfully deprived of their selection, it will neither be possible nor necessary to issue
individual show-cause notice to each selectee. The only way out would be to cancel the
whole selection.
8) When the entire selection is stinking, conceived in fraud and delivered in deceit,
individual innocence has no place and the entire selection has to be set aside.”
44.
Again, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Vibhuti Shankar Pandey vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., reported in (2023)3 SCC 639 had set
aside the order of learned Single Judge of Madhya Pradesh High Court
directing the State to regularize the service of the petitioner who was
appointed on daily rated basis under a project and not against any sanctioned
post as it was noticed that the initial appointment of the petitioner/appellant
was not made by the competent authority and the appointment was not made
against a sanctioned post. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Vibhuti
Shankar(supra) has reiterated the principle laid down in Umadevi (supra).
[SCC p 640 para 4]. As I said earlier, in the case in hand, the initial
appointment of the petitioners was not made by the competent authority of
the Corporation and there is no evidence that they were appointed against
sanctioned vacant post.
45.
In a recent decision, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Government of
Tamil Nadu & Anr. vs. Tamil Nadu Makkal Nala Paniyalargal & Ors.,
2023 SCC Online SC 393, relying upon the judgments of the Supreme Court
in Chander Hass(supra) and Maharashtra State Road Transport
Corporation(supra) reiterated the principles that the creation of posts is not
within the domain of judicial functions and it pertains to the executive or
legislature. In the case of Government of Tamil Nadu(supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has categorically held that in absence of sanctioned posts,
the State cannot be compelled to create the post and absorb the persons who
are continuing in service of the State.
I have also gone through the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme court in
46.
Raman Kumar & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. [decided on July 03, 2023
in SLP(C) No.7898/2020], where the Supreme Court has directed the
regularization of 35 Group-D employees considering the fact that the Chief
Commissioner of Income Tax had found that 65 persons were entitled to be
regularized, but, the act of regularizing the services of only 35 employees
and not regularizing the services of other employees including the
petitioners was blatently discriminatory or violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India on the ground that some of the Group-D posts had been
abolished.
47.
The present case of the petitioners is clearly distinguishable from the
cases of Nihal Singh(supra), Amarkant Rai(supra), Narendra Kumar
Tiwari(supra) and Raman Kumar(supra) as regards the factual aspects are
concerned.
48.
On analysis of the above narrations of facts and the law enunciated in
the decisions cited above, the following ratios have emerged out in matters
related to regularization.
(i)
The engagement/appointment must be made by a competent
authority;
(ii)
The appointment must be against duly sanctioned vacant post;
(iii)
Regularization, if any, has to be made within the realm of the
Government Rules/Circulars;
(iv)
The appointment should be irregular, but not illegal, to justify
his/her claim that he/she falls within the exception curved out in para 53
of Uma Devi (3) (supra);
(v)
The court cannot direct the State or its instrumentalities in
regard to creation of post/s;
(vi)
Such irregularly appointed employees must have requisite
qualification for the posts they hold;
(vii)
The Courts should not be swayed with emotion and sympathy;
(viii)
Budgetary provision and sanction thereto against the post/s
must be taken into consideration before passing any direction for
regularization;
(ix)
If there is any cut-off date, such date cannot be elongated or
extended;
49.
At the cost of repetition, in the instant case, the petitioners were
neither appointed by the competent authority nor they have been able to
justify that they were engaged against a duly sanctioned vacant post, nor
they have been able to justify that they have requisite qualification to hold
any post under the respondents.
50.
Before concluding, I must deal with the argument advanced by
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners that since they were
engaged in the year 2004 (though, after cut-off date 31.03.2003 and without
financial concurrence), and completed their 10(ten) years of service in the
year 2014, their rights to claim regularization were ripened in the year 2014
itself when the scheme for regularization was existed before its repeal in the
year 2018. I have considered the submission of learned senior counsel. As I
said earlier, the petitioners herein have filed the writ petition on 03.01.2023.
The schemes for regularization have been repealed on 31.07.2018. In the
opinion of this court, the argument advanced by learned counsel for the
petitioners would have some force if the petitioners would have approached
the court during the existence of the scheme because regularization must be
made within the realm of the scheme. Moreso, the petitioners were engaged
after the cut-off date i.e. after 31.03.2003 and that too without financial
concurrence. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Daya Lal (supra) has
categorically held that where a scheme is formulated by the government for
regularization with a cut-off date, the employees who are appointed
subsequent to the cut-off date have no right to claim or contend that the
scheme should be applied to them by extending the cut-off date.
51.
Again, in my opinion, the person who enters through back-door at the
whims of certain officers, and the government made provision to regularize
the services of such irregularly appointed employees under certain Schemes,
then, they undoubtedly acquire right for consideration of regularization of
their services. However, in case of non-consideration or discrimination, they
must agitate their right and claim the benefit of regularization before such
scheme is repealed. The delayed approach and lackadaisical attitude should
not be given a liberal view. As is well-known- “vigilantibus non
dormientibus jura subveniunt”- equity helps the vigilant and not the indolent
i.e. equity comes to the rescue of those who approach the court for their
rights within time and not to the rescue of those who slumber over their
rights. In the instant case, according to the petitioners, their right ought to
have been considered in the year 2014 i.e. on completion of 10(ten) years of
their services as per the regularization schemes. But they have not agitated
their rights till the schemes are repealed in the year 2018. Repealing the
schemes was a policy decision of the Government and it is absolutely within
their domain because they know the ground realities as regards the
requirements and continuation of the scheme, which the courts do not have.
Even they approached the court, as I said earlier, in the year 2023 to get the
benefit of the repealed scheme, which according to this court cannot be
entertained at all.
52.
The persons appointed irregularly or illegally at the behest of some
officers depriving large number of eligible and competent job aspirants are
none but the offenders to societal as well as constitutional wrongs, which,
according to me, should not be allowed to be perpetuated for an indefinite
period, and after long ten years‟ of continuation thousands of job aspirants
must expect to see it‟s end in line with the constitutional ethos as enshrined
under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Here it is noticed that
the Government of Tripura had declared total ban on engagement of DRWs/
Casual/Contingent, etc. workers under the Policy dated 21.01.2009 supra in
the line of the Constitutional scheme for employment, and the schemes for
regularization of irregularly appointees have been repealed under
Notification dated 31st July, 2018.
53.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, the services of the
petitioners deserve no consideration for regularization, and I do not find any
error in the findings of the Inquiry Committee, as reflected in the
communication dated 14.12.2022, quoted supra, whereby and whereunder,
the Managing Director of TSECL, by a reasoned order, informed the
petitioners that their claims for regularization being taken into consideration
could not be acceded to.
54.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of
merit, and thus, disposed of.
JUDGE
SAIKAT
KAR
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.09.06
16:48:54 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review