Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A.(J) No.07 of 2023
Sri Sankar Das,
Son of Sri Nibaran Das,
Of Tainani, P.O & P.S. R.K. Pur,
District: Gomati Tripura
----Convict-Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Samrat Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
Date of Hearing
:
05.02.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
12.02.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON‘BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON‘BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
[B. Palit, J]
The convict-appellant Sankar Das has preferred this
appeal challenging the judgment and order of conviction
and sentence dated 07.12.2021 passed by Learned Addl.
Sessions Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur. By the said
judgment Learned Trial Court has acquitted the accused
appellant from the charge punishable under Section 498A of
the IPC but found him guilty under Section 302 of IPC and
sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life and
with
fine
of
Rs.5,000/-
in
default
to
suffer
simple
imprisonment for three months under Section 302 of IPC.
02.
The case of the prosecution before the Learned
Trial Court was that on 27.08.2016 one Sajal De, son of
Ranjit De of village East Mohanbhog under P.S. Melaghar,
District Sepahijala laid an FIR to OC, Natun Bazaar PS,
Gomati District alleging inter alia that about three years
back his daughter Supriya was given marriage with the
accused Sankar Das as per Hindu Marriage Rites and
Customs. After six months of the marriage the accused
Sankar started causing mental and physical torture upon his
daughter at the instance of his mother-in-law and father-inlaw i.e. Nibaran Das and Rekha Das. To save his daughter
from the torture she sought assistance from the respected
person in Tainani village who attempted to resolve their
issues on so many occasions and thereafter few days were
elapsed peacefully, but again the accused Sankar Das at the
instance of his parents started causing pressure upon his
daughter to bring Rs.10,000/- (ten thousand) from him. As
his daughter expressed her inability so she was severely
beaten. He tried to file a complaint in this matter about
torture upon his daughter but the accused Sankar Das
resisted to that and as they protested the matter for the
purpose of well being of his daughter they were physically
assaulted by some villagers and in this way the accused
persons used to cause assault upon his daughter in various
ways every now and then. Around 5/6 months back the
accused Sankar took his daughter to his aunt’s house at
Jatanbari
where all the accused persons
continuously
assaulted his daughter. After that they sought redress to
one Smt. Kalpana Biswas of the Women’s Commission of
Tainani, but no fruitful decision could be arrived at. On
27.08.2016, at about 8 am there was severe altercation
between accused Sankar and his daughter and that time the
accused poured kerosene oil on her body and set her on fire
for which her body was completely burnt. The accused did
not provide any information and took her to Jatanbari
Hospital. After that she was brought to Udaipur, Tepania
Hospital when also the accused did not inform them and
finally
his
daughter
succumbed
to
her
injuries
on
27.08.2016 at about 4 pm and after arrival to the hospital
they could know the said incident. On receipt of FIR OC,
Nutanbazar PS Case No.2016 NTB 026 under Section
498A/304(B) of IPC and the IO after completion of
investigation laid chargesheet against the appellant Sankar
Das vide Chargesheet No.2/17 under Section 498A/302 of
IPC and accordingly Learned SDJM, Amarpur after receipt of
chargesheet took cognizance of offence punishable under
Section 498A/302 of IPC and transferred the case to the
court of the
Learned Judicial
Magistrate,
First
Class,
Amarpur, Gomati District and thereafter Learned Judicial
Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Amarpur committed the case
to the court of Learned Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial
District, Udaipur for trial of accused. Learned Sessions
Judge thereafter transferred this case to the court of
Learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur for disposal as per law. Before the Learned trial
court charge was framed under Section 498A/302 of IPC
and prosecution to substantiate the charge before the
Learned trial court has adduced in total 24 numbers of
witnesses and the prosecution also relied upon some
documentary evidence which were marked as exhibits in
this case:
EVIDENCE OF THE PROSECUTION
RANK
PW 1
PW 2
PW 3
PW 4
PW 5
PW 6
PW 7
PW 8
PW 9
PW 10
PW 11
PW 12
PW 13
PW 14
PW 15
PW 16
PW 17
PW 18
PW 19
PW 20
PW 21
PW 22
PW 23
PW 24
NAME
Smti. Srimati Das
Miss Shibani Saha
Miss Sipra Saha
Shri Maran Saha
Dr. Sourav Bhowmik
Smti Manibala Karmakar
Smt. Soma BarnaSharma
Shri Priyalal Chakma
Shri Sajal Dey
Smti Kalpana Biswas
Smti Rama Talukdar
Shri Babul Talukdar
Shri Mithun Debath
Dr. Chandan Kumar Tripura
Smti Sabita Shil
Smti Kalpana Acharjee
Shri Maran Madraji
Shri Goutam Dey
Shri Ranjit Dey
Shri Bishu Dey
Shri Bimalendu Saha
Shri Subhasis Bandhyopadyay
Smti Sikha Deb
Shri Souvik Dey
NATURE OF EVIDENCE
Other witness
Eye witness
Eye witness
Other witness
Medical witness
Other witness
Other witness
Police witness
Other witness
Other witness
Other witness
Other witness
Police witness
Medical witness
Police witness
Medical witness
Other witness
Other witness
Other witness
Other witness
Police witness
Other witness
Police witness
Police witness
EXHIBITS OF THE PROSECUTION
Sl.
No.
1.
Exhibit Number
Exhibit P-1 (PW2)
2.
Exhibit P-2 (PW 3)
3.
Exhibit P-3 (PW 4)
4.
5.
Exhibit P-3/1 (PW 21)
Exhibit P-3/2 (PW 21)
6.
Exhibit P-4 (PW 5)
Description
Signature of PW 2 in her
statement u/s 164
Signature of PW 3 in her
statement u/s 164
Signature of PW 4 in the
seizure list
Seizure list prepared by PW1
Signature of PW 21 in the
seizure list
Dying declaration of the
7.
8.
Exhibit P-4/1 series (PW 5)
Exhibit P-4/2 (PW 5)
9.
Exhibit P-4/3 (PW 6)
10.
Exhibit P-5 (PW 8)
11.
Exhibit P-5/1 (PW 23)
12.
Exhibit P-5/2 (PW 23)
13.
Exhibit- P6 (PW 9)
14.
15.
Exhibit P-6/1 (PW 18)
Exhibit P-6/2 (PW 18)
16.
Exhibit P-6/3 (PW 24)
Exhibit P-6/4 (PW 24)
17.
Exhibit P-7 (PW 13)
18.
Exhibit P-7/1 (PW 23)
19.
Exhibit P-7/3 (PW 24)
20.
Exhibit P-7/4 (PW 24)
21.
Exhibit P-8 (PW 14)
22.
Exhibit P-8/1 (PW 16)
23.
Exhibit P-8/2(PW 16)
24.
25.
Exhibit P-9(PW 14)
Exhibit P-9/1(PW 14)
26.
Exhibit P-9/2(PW 14)
27.
Exhibit P-9/3(PW 14)
28.
Exhibit P-10(PW 15)
29.
Exhibit P-10/1 (PW 17)
30.
Exhibit P-10/2 (PW 23)
31.
Exhibit P-10/3 (PW 23)
32.
Exhibit P-11 (PW 20)
33.
Exhibit P-11/1 (PW 23)
34.
Exhibit P-11/2(PW 23)
35.
Exhibit P-12(PW 23)
36.
Exhibit P-12/1 (PW 21)
37.
Exhibit P-13 (PW 21)
38.
Exhibit P-13/1(PW 21)
39.
Exhibit P-15(PW 21)
deceased
RTI and LTI of the deceased
Signature of PW 5 in the
dying declaration
Signature of PW 6 in the
dying declaration
Signature of PW 8 in the
seizure list
Seizure list prepared by PW
Signature of PW 23 in the
seizure list
Signature of PW 9 in the
ejahar
The written ejahar
Signature of PW 18 in the
ejahar
Endorsement of WSI Mina
Debbarma in the ejahar.
Endorsement of the then O/C
Jaharlal Debbarma in the
ejahar
Signature of PW 13 in the
seizure list
Signature of PW 23 in the
seizure list
Seizure list prepared by PW
Signature of PW 24 in the
seizure list
Dying declaration of the
deceased
Signature of PW 14 in the
dying declaration
Signature of PW 16 in the
dying declaration
Post mortem report
Signature of PW 14 in the
post mortem report
Signature of Dr. Abhijit Dutta
in the post mortem report
Signature of PW 14 in the
post mortem report
Signature of PW 15 in the
seizure list
Signature of PW 17 in the
seizure list
Seizure list prepared by PW
Signature of PW 23 in the
seizure list
Signature of PW 20 in the
inquest report
Inquest report prepared by
PW 23
Signature of PW 23 in the
inquest report
Signature of PW 23 in the
inquest report
Signature of PW 21 in the
hand sketch map
Index of hand sketch map of
the PO
Signature of PW 21 in the
index
A portion of statement of PW
1 recorded by IO u/s 161 of
40.
Exhibit P-15 (PW 22)
41.
Exhibit P-15/1 to 15/4(PW 22)
42.
Exhibit P-16(PW 24)
43.
44.
Exhibit P-17 (PW 24)
Exhibit P-17/1 (PW 24)
03.
Cr.P.C.
Inquest report prepared by
PW 22
Signatures of PW 22 in the
inquest report
A portion of statement of PW
4 recorded by PW 24 u/s 161
of Cr.P.C.
Filled up printed form of FIR
Signature of the then O/C
Jaharlal Debbarma
Thereafter the accused was examined and on
conclusion of trial after hearing arguments of both the sides
Learned trial court found the appellant guilty of offence for
the charge framed and convicted him accordingly and
imposed punishment for which this present appeal is
preferred.
04.
Heard
Mr.
Ratan
Datta,
Learned
counsel
appearing for the appellant and also heard Mr. S. Ghosh,
Learned Addl. P.P. representing the state respondent. At the
time of hearing of arguments Learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that the prosecution has failed to prove
the charge beyond reasonable doubt against the appellant
but the Learned court below did not appreciate the evidence
on record properly and ultimately gave an erroneous
finding. Learned counsel further submitted that in the case
at hand the prosecution adduced two sets of witnesses
because PWs 2 and 3 who were present to the PO at the
time of alleged occurrence did not support the prosecution
story. But Learned court below ignoring the evidence on
record of those witnesses simply on the basis of dying
declaration of the deceased which were also not recorded in
accordance with law found the appellant guilty. Learned
counsel in course of hearing drawn the attention of the
court referring the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
and submitted that the evidence of the prosecution suffers
from various infirmities which Learned Court below failed to
appreciate at the time of delivery of judgment. Learned
counsel also failed to rely upon the inquest report prepared
by W/ASI Sikha Deb on 27.08.2016 wherein it was
specifically stated that the deceased had sustained injuries
by setting fire to her own body but the Learned Trial Court
below ignoring that part and came to a wrong conclusion
that the appellant committed the offence. Furthermore,
according to the Learned counsel the deceased according to
PM report sustained 90-95% burn injuries. So situated thus,
it was not possible on her part to gave dying declaration
and also to put any thumb impression which Learned court
below did not consider. Learned counsel also referred the
evidence of PW-5, Dr. Sourav Bhowmik who during his
cross-examination very specifically stated that at the time of
recording of the dying declaration of the deceased he did
not try to ascertain as to whether the deceased was willing
to make any statement or not or she was tutored. Further in
the dying declaration form the place of recording the same
was not mentioned and also the said witness could not say
about the name of medicines which he prescribed to the
patient on that relevant point of time. So according to the
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
the
alleged
dying
declaration was a defective one. No reliance can be placed
upon it and furthermore it was not made in presence of any
Magistrate as required by law and finally Learned counsel
for the appellant also relied upon some citations and
submitted that in view of the principles laid down in the said
citations there was no scope on the part of the Learned
court below to convict the appellant and submitted for
acquittal of the accused-appellant from the charge of the
case in view of the contradictory evidence on record of the
prosecution. Learned counsel for the appellant also drawn
the attention of the court that prosecution failed to prove
that the alleged accused-appellant caused fire by pouring
kerosene oil on the dead body of deceased and no evidence
in this regard could be proved by the prosecution before the
Learned Trial Court.
05.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Ghosh, Learned Addl.
P.P. representing the prosecution submitted that in this case
the prosecution has been able to prove the charge beyond
reasonable doubt against the appellant. According to the
Learned Addl. P.P. all the witnesses of the prosecution very
categorically stated that the present appellant caused
murder of his wife by pouring kerosene oil on her body. In
respect of evidence of PWs 2 and 3 who are the cousin
sisters of the accused appellant he submitted that although
those witnesses are the witnesses of the prosecution but no
reliance could be placed upon the evidence of said two
witnesses and furthermore since the prosecution has been
able to prove the two recorded dying declaration of the
deceased, so there is no scope to disbelieve those dying
declaration and furthermore according to Learned Addl. P.P.
her first dying declaration was recorded on 27.08.2016 at
about
9.20
a.m.
but
the
present
appellant
in
his
examination under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. took the plea that
he was not at home at the time of alleged incident rather he
went for his masonry work and returned back to home at
about 11.30 a.m., after receipt of a phone call which shows
that the present accused-appellant suppressed the real fact
and tried to build up a new story of his defence. But
according to Learned counsel for the prosecution that the
Learned court below after considering the evidence on
record and also after hearing both the sides has rightly and
reasonably delivered the judgment and convicted the
appellant and also relied upon some citations which would
be discussed later on.
06.
To
appreciate the arguments
made
by the
Learned counsel of both the sides let us revisit the evidence
on record of the prosecution adduced before the trial court.
PW-9 is the informant Shri Sajal Dey. He deposed on oath
that about 3 years 5 months back he gave marriage of his
daughter with accused Sankar Das of Tainani as per Hindu
Marriage Rites and Customs. For a period of three months
after
the
marriage
his
daughter
was
happy
at
her
matrimonial home but thereafter on different occasions the
accused used to assault her physically and mentally and
drove her out from her matrimonial home when she came to
his residence. He informed the matter to the relatives as
well as to the local villagers of Mohanbhog. Thereafter his
father-in-law Shri Babul Talukdar and his wife intervened in
the matter and mitigated the same and the accused again
took back his daughter to his home. Later on, also his
daughter was assaulted by accused and driven her out from
her matrimonial home on different occasions with a demand
of money from their side. Accordingly his father paid some
money to the accused party and during this period
whenever he visited his daughter’s matrimonial home he
was ill-treated by the family members of the accused. He
informed the matter to one Amar Das, the Pradhan of
Tainani village and a meeting was convened but his
daughter did not get any relief. Thereafter, accused took his
daughter to Nutanbazar and started residing therein. About
one and half year back Shri Nibaran Das, father of Sankar
informed him that his daughter died out of burn injuries and
was at Tepania Hospital. Accordingly, he went to the
hospital and saw the dead body of his daughter and on the
same day he lodged the ejahar against his son-in-law at
Women P.S. Udaipur which was reduced to writing by one
person and he put his signature therein. He identified his
signature on the ejahar marked Exbt.-6.
During cross-examination he deposed that after the
death of mother of Supriya he married another lady namely
Rama Dey and have been residing at Taninani and his
daughter used to visit his house at Mohanbhog where his
father resides but did not visit Tainani. He further deposed
that he did not say to police that Sankar drove out his
daughter from her matrimonial home after assaulting her.
He also did not say to police that he was ill-treated by the
family members of Sankar when he visited his daughter. He
also did not say to the IO that his father-in-law Babul
Talukdar and his wife intervened in the matter and
mitigated the same and his son-in-law took back his
daughter. He could not say the exact date when his son-inlaw assaulted his daughter on demand of money.
07.
PW-1, Srimati Das (Saha) is the relative of the
accused. However, she deposed that about 3 to 4 years
back Sankar Das was married to Supriya das and resided at
Garji, Tainani. In the last part of Chaitra Sankar visited her
house along with Supriya and their son. They stayed therein
for three days and during that period Sankar requested her
to allot a piece of land to him so that he could reside therein
with his wife and son. Then she advised Sankar to take up
the matter with his father. After few days his father came
and requested to allot some land to his son. Accordingly,
she allotted a piece of land and Sankar started residing
therein after constructing a hut. Both Sankar and his wife
led a peaceful life for some days but thereafter there was a
quarrel between husband and wife and she heard that
Sankar
abusing
his
wife.
In
the
month
of
following
Sharavana one day at about 2.30 to 3.00 p.m. Supriya
came to her and complained that Sankar had ousted her
and Supriya also informed the matter to a member of Nari
Samiti namely Soma Barna Sharma but the matter was not
resolved. Thereafter on 27th
day
of English calendar
corresponding to the month of Bhadra she was working in
her field when her daughter Shipra aged about 12 years
came to her and informed that there was a fire in her house
and she rushed to the home and found Supriya lying on the
ground with severe burn injuries on her body. Immediately
she sent Sankar to the Fire Service and after some time Fire
Service personnel came and shifted Supriya to the Nutan
Bazar Hospital from where she was referred to Tepania
District Hospital, Udaipur. She along with her husband and
Sankar accompanied Supriya to Tepania District Hospital
where her statement was recorded by one Doctor in her
presence as well as Sankar. In the statement Supriya stated
that Sankar had set her on fire after pouring kerosene oil
and
on
the
same
day
at
about
2.00
p.m.
Supriya
succumbed to the injuries.
During cross-examination she stated that did not say
specifically to the police that Sankar abused his wife. She
did not witness any physical torture by Sankar on his wife
and after the incident Supriya did not tell her anything with
regard to setting fire on her by Sankar. Nothing more
relevant came out from her cross-examination.
08.
PW-2 Sibani Das deposed that accused Sankar is
her cousin. Few months back before the date of death of
Supriya, Sankar came to their house and started residing
with Supriya and his son by constructing a hut. She further
stated that frequently there used to be quarrel between
husband and wife. On the alleged day of incident she along
with her two sisters was cooking food in the kitchen when
she heard some noise of quarrel. That time Sankar gave a
push to his wife Supriya and she fell down on the ground.
Immediately she got up and rushed to their kitchen and
picked up a burning fire wood from the oven and tried to
self immolate her, but failed. Thereafter she picked up
another file of burning wood and set fire upon her and
seeing all these they become frightened and could not do
anything. In the meanwhile her mother reached and shortly
thereafter Fire Service came and shifted Supriya to Hospital.
Same day Supriya succumbed to her injury at Tepania
District
Hospital,
Udaipur.
After
2/3
days
the
police
produced her before the SDJM Court at Amarpur where her
statement
was
recorded.
The
witness
identified
her
signature on the statement marked Exbt.1.
During cross-examination she stated that she did not
say to the Magistrate that there used to be quarrel between
Sankar and his wife Supriya since they started residing at
their residence.
09.
PW-3, Sipra Saha deposed in the same manner
like PW-2 and also deposed that relation between Sankar
and Supriya was not good and there used to be quarrel
between them. On the day of incident in the morning at
about 8.00 a.m. she along with her two sisters was cooking
in the kitchen when she heard noise of quarrel and noticed
that Sankar gave a push to Supriya and she fell down on
the ground. Immediately thereafter she got up and rushed
to their kitchen and picked up a file of burning fire wood
from the oven and self immolated her. Seeing that she
rushed to her mother and informed the matter and after
some time Fire Service came and shifted Supriya to the
hospital where she succumbed to her injuries at Tepania
District Hospital on the same date. She produced before the
Magistrate for recording her statement and identified her
signature marked as Exbt.2.
During cross-examination by the defence she stated
that she did not say to Magistrate that relation between
Sankar and his wife was not good as they used to quarrel
with them and she also did not say that on the alleged day
she heard the noise of quarrel and noticed Sankar giving a
push to Supriya due to which she fell down on the ground.
10.
PW-4 Maran Saha deposed that accused Sankar
Das is the son of his wife’s brother. Further he deposed that
about 5/6 months back prior to the death of Supriya,
Sankar started residing at his house constructing a hut. On
the day of incident he was not present at his home as he
had gone for his work. There one Panchayet member
Shyamal Sarkar asked him to reach his home immediately.
Accordingly, he came where his daughter informed that his
wife
had
gone
to
Nutanbazar
Hospital
accompanying
Supriya who had sustained burn injuries. He was about
reach to the hospital that time police came and restrained
him and searched his house and seized one drum containing
kerosene oil, burnt pieces of cloths and a file of burnt fire
wood by preparing a seizure list marked Exbt.3 and
identified the seized alamats marked Exbt.-MO.1 series. He
went to Nutanbazar Hospital and found Supriya with burn
injuries
and
she
was
continuously
asking
for
water.
Immediately thereafter she was referred to the District
Hospital, Tepania and he along with his wife Sankar
accompanied to the District Hospital where she succumbed
to her injuries on the same day at about 1.30 to 2.00 p.m
and when the dead body was shifted to morgue, he
returned back to his home. He was declared hostile by the
prosecution.
During cross-examination by the prosecution he stated
that he did not say to police that Sankar used to quarrel
with his wife on frequent basis and he had tried to settle the
matter and his portion of statement was marked in red ink,
subject to approve by IO. In cross-examination nothing
came out relevant.
11.
PW-5, Dr. Sourav Bhowmik deposed that on
27.08.2016 he was posted as MO at Nutanbazar Rural
Hospital. On that day he recorded the dying declaration of
one female patient. In the said dying declaration she stated
that her husband had set her on fire after pouring kerosene
oil. That time the patient was well oriented and conscious
with regard to the time and place but he did not give any
clear finding with regard to this observation. After recording
the dying declaration he obtained the RTI and LTI of the
patient. That time one staff nurse Krishna Mani Chakma and
Manibala Karmakar, GDA were present and in their presence
the statement was recorded. The witness identified the
dying declaration recorded by him marked as Exbt.4 and he
identified RTI and LTI of deceased obtained by him marked
as Exbt.4/1 series and the signature of the witness on the
bottom of the declaration marked as Exbt.4/2.
During cross-examination he stated that he did not
record the dying declaration in question and answer form
and also he did not say to the IO that at the time of
recording dying declaration the patient was well oriented
and conscious with time and place and in the dying
declaration he did not mention that he obtain the thumb
impression of the deceased and also in the dying declaration
the place of recording was not reflected. He further stated
that at the time of recording dying declaration except the
patient and two witnesses and himself none were present.
Nothing
more
came
out
relevant
from
his
cross-
examination.
12.
PW-6, Manibala Karmakar, deposed that
on
27.08.2016 he was posted as GDA at Nutanbazar Rural
Hospital. That day Dr. Sourav Bhowmik recorded the dying
declaration of a female patient when she stated that her
husband had set her on fire after pouring kerosene oil. He
further stated that at the time recording dying declaration
she herself, patient, Dr. Sourav Bhowmik and one Krishna
Mani Chakma were present. She put her signature on dying
declaration and identified the same marked as Exbt.4/2.
During cross-examination nothing came out relevant.
13.
PW-7,
Soma
Barna
Sharma
deposed
that
accused Sankar Das along with his wife and his son started
residing in the house of Shrimati Das by constructing a hut.
On 27.08.2016 wife of Sankar died of burn injury. That day
at around 8.00 to 9.00 a.m. on hearing hue and cry he
rushed to the spot and found Supriya lying on the ground
with burn injuries. Immediately she informed the matter to
Jatanbari police outpost through mobile. Meanwhile the Fire
Service came and shifted Supriya to Nutan Bazar Rural
Hospital from where Supriya was referred to District
Hospital, Tepania. About two weeks back before the incident
one day Supriya came and stated that Sankar had assaulted
her. Hearing this, she along with few neighbourers went to
the house of Sankar and tried to persuade him not to
commit such type of acts and to lead a peaceful conjugal
life.
During cross-examination she stated that she did not
say to IO that exactly two weeks before the incident Supriya
came to her and stated that Sankar had assaulted her. She
also stated that when she reached to the PO that time twin
daughters of Shrimati were present.
14.
PW-8,
Priya
Lal
Chakma
deposed
that
on
07.09.2016 he was posted at Nutanbazar PS as a Constable
of Police. On that day SDPO, Amarpur seized one silver
colour 5 liters plastic drum containing approximately 1 lts K.
oil, some burnt pieces of wooden file and some burnt pieces
of cloths being produced by SI Bimalendu Saha at PS in his
presence and he put his signature on the seizure list as
witness
marked
Exbt.5
and
identified
seized
alamats
marked as Exbt. MO.1 series.
During cross-examination he stated that he was
unable to say as to how the seized alamats were brought to
police station.
15.
PW-10, Kalpana Biswas deposed that Sankar
married to Supriya in the year 2015 and their marital life
was satisfactory but after few months some differences
cropped up between husband and wife on account of triffle
family matters and this witness declared hostile by the
prosecution
and
during
cross-examination
by
the
prosecution she stated that she said to police that from the
side of Nari Samiti and Panchayet an effort was made to
resolve the dispute between Sankar and his wife and that
time Supriya told that Sankar used to inflict physical torture
upon her. Later on, she could know that Supriya died.
During cross-examination by the defence she stated
that she had no knowledge with regard to their dispute
during their stay at Jatanbari and again stated that at the
time of negotiation Supriya stated with regard to the
infliction of physical torture upon her by Sankar.
16.
PW-11, Rama Talukdar deposed that Supriya was
her step daughter. About three years back Supriya was
married to Sankar of Taninani and about three to four
months after the marriage Sankar started torturing her on
the allegation that she was not following his commands.
Subsequently Sankar along with Supriya shifted to his
house at Jatanbari and started residing therein and about
one and half year back she received information that
Supriya died due to burn injuries.
During cross by the defence she stated that she did
not say to IO that Supriya told her that Sankar was
torturing her on the allegation that she was not following his
command.
17.
PW-12, Babul Talukdar deposed that for a period
of 5/6 months after the marriage her grand-daughter led a
happy marital life. Thereafter some differences cropped up
between husband and wife on account of some family
matters and it led to physical violence upon Supriya with
regard to that matter. The matter was taken up by the
family members and a meeting was organized wherein both
were advised to lead a peaceful conjugal life with mutual
respect
to
each
other.
But
things
did
not
improve.
Thereafter Supriya took shelter in the residence of one
person belonging to Reang community. Again the matter
was taken up and Supriya persuaded to live with her
husband. Even thereafter a dispute arose between Supriya
and her husband and then they shifted to Nutanbazar and
started residing there and about one year back one day he
received information that Supriya had died of burn injuries
as she was set on fire by her husband.
During cross-examination he stated that he could not
remember whether he stated to the IO that Sankar had set
Supriya on fire or not and again stated that he did not say
to IO that Sankar assaulted Supriya on the matter relating
to not preparing food in time and not following his command
as she used to remain busy in taking care of her baby.
18.
PW-13, Mithun Debnath, Constable of Police
posted in the office of the SDPO, Amarpur deposed that on
11.09.2016 he accompanied Souvik Dey, the then SDPO,
Amarpur and came to RK Pur Women P.S., Udaipur where
he seized the viscera samples of stomach, liver, kidney and
samples of skin and hair of deceased Supriya Das by
preparing a seizure list and he put his signature on the
seizure list as a witness marked as Exbt.7.
19.
PW-14,
Dr.
Chandan
Kumar
Tripura
who
recorded the second dying declaration of the deceased. He
deposed that on 27.08.2016 he was posted as Medical
Officer in Gomati District Hospital, Tepania. That day he
recorded the dying declaration of one Supriya Das when she
stated that on 27.08.2016 in the morning at about 8.00 to
8.30 a.m. an altercation took place between her and her
husband and during the period of altercation her husband
shut the door of the room from inside and brutally assaulted
her and then poured kerosene oil on her body and lighted
the match sticks. Resultantly she sustained burn injuries. He
further deposed that at the time of recording the statement
two staff nurse
namely Maneka Begam and Kalpana
Acharjee were present. He further deposed that as per his
observation on that relevant point of time the patient was in
fit
mental
condition
for
the
purpose
of
making
the
statement. He identified the statement recorded by him in
his own handwriting which was marked Exbt.8 and the
signature of witness on the statement marked Exbt-8/1. He
also obtained the RTI of patient on the bottom of the
recorded statement. Subsequently the patient succumbed to
her injuries. On 28.08.2016 he along with other two doctors
of the hospital namely Dr. Abhijit Datta and Dr. Rituparna
Dey conducted postmortem examination on her dead body.
The examination revealed that the body was totally burnt
except palm (both sides), sole (both sides) and top of the
head and it constituted about 90 to 95% of the total body
surface area (TBSA). The base of the burn was reddish and
blackish in colour. Burn involves the epidermis and dermis
layer of skin. Stomach, liver, kidneys were congested.
Heart, lungs also found congested. Soot particles were
found inside the larynx and trachea. He further deposed
that the opinion as to cause of death was ante-mortem burn
due to shock following 90 to 95% burn of TBSA and the
probable age of the death was 6 to 12 hours prior to holding
of
postmortem
examination.
He
identified
the
PM
examination report as Exbt.9 and his signature marked
Exbt.9/1 series and he further identified the signatures of
another two Doctors namely Dr. Abhijit Datta and Dr.
Rituparna Dey marked as Exbt-9/2 and Exbt.9/3.
During cross-examination he deposed that against the
column No.3 of the dying declaration form reflecting the
mental status only the word ‘Conscious’ was mentioned.
Further deposed that in the Postmortem examination report
it was not reflected and as to what basis the said report was
prepared
on
08.09.2016.
Although
said
postmortem
examination was conducted on 28.08.2016. Nothing more
came out relevant.
20.
PW-15, Sabita Shil deposed that on 28.08.2016
she was posted as Women Constable of Police at RK Pur
Women PS. That day she accompanied WSI Smt. Sikha Deb
to the morgue at District Hospital, Tepania where she seized
the viscera samples of kidneys, liver, stomach and samples
of skin and hair belonging to deceased Supriya Das by
preparing a seizure list and put her signature as a witness
and identified the signature marked as Exbt.10.
21.
PW-16, Smt. Kalpana Acharjee deposed that on
27.08.2016 she was posted as Staff Nurse at Gomati
District Hospital, Tepania. That day one Supriya Das was
admitted into the hospital with history of burn injuries and
as per the practice the statement of a patient with burn
injuries are recorded and same was done by Dr. Chandan
Tripura who recorded the statement of the victim patient
Supriya Das in her presence. That time another staff nurse
namely Maneka Begam was also present. She further stated
that the patient stated that on the same day in the morning
her husband assaulted her in the room and thereafter
closed the doors from inside, poured kerosene oil and set
fire on hire. She put her signature on the recorded
statement and identified her signature marked Exbt-8/2.
During cross-examination she deposed that she was
not examined by police in connection with the case and for
the first time she was deposing that accused Sankar Das
had set fire upon Supriya after assaulting her.
22.
PW-17,
Maran
Madrajee
deposed
that
on
28.08.2016 he was posted as a Dom in Tepania District
Hospital. On that day Dr. Chandan Kr. Tripura conducted PM
examination over the dead body of Supriya Das. Thereafter
he collected viscera of stomach, liver, kidney, skin, hair in
separate jars and the aforesaid jars were handed over to
the police by him which were seized by police in his
presence by preparing seizure list and he put his signature
on the seizure list as witness marked Exbt.10/1.
23.
PW-18, Gautam Dey deposed that on 27.08.2016
as a para legal volunteer of DSLA Gomati, Tripura he wrote
an ejahar as per instruction of Sajal Dey, son of late Ranjit
Dey and thereafter the contents of the same was read over
to him and after accepting the same as correct he put his
signature
over
the
ejahar
marked
Exbt.6/1
and
his
signature marked as Exbt.6/2. During cross-examination
nothing came out relevant.
24.
PW-19,
Ranjit
Dey
deposed
that
deceased
Supriya was his grand-daughter who was given marriage
with Sankar and after the marriage Sankar used to inflict
torture upon his grand-daughter Supriya and also used to
tie her neck by Gamcha. Thereafter Supriya was taken back
to their house from the house of the accused at Tainani.
Subsequently accused Sankar came to their house and told
them some money for the purpose of construction of
residential
house
at
Jatanbari.
Accordingly
he
paid
Rs.1800/- (eighteen hundred) and thereafter accused took
Supriya with him. About two years back when he reached
the house of his son at Tainani he could learnt that his
grand-daughter Supriya Dey died of burn injury and in the
hospital from the nurse he could know that her husband
Sankar Das set her on fire. He also deposed that as the
dead body of Supriya was not taken by the accused or his
family so they performed her funeral.
During cross-examination he stated that he did not
say to the IO that he paid Rs.1800/- to the accused for the
purpose of construction of residential hut at Jatanbari and
also he did not say to the IO that one nurse of the Hospital
informed him that the deceased set fire by her husband
Sankar Das.
25.
PW-20, Bishu Dey deposed that since after three
years of marriage of Sankar and Supriya, he heard from his
son that Supriya died and thereafter he rushed to Hospital
where he found the dead body of Supriya. His son Bapan
told him that Sankar caused the death of Supriya by setting
fire after pouring kerosene oil and in the Hospital police
conducted in quest over the dead body of Supriya where he
signed as witness and identified his signature marked
Exbt.11.
During cross by the defence he stated that his son told
that Sankar caused the death of Supriya by setting fire after
pouring kerosene oil.
26.
PW-21,
Bimalendu
Saha
deposed
that
on
27.08.2016 he was posted as SI of Police in the Nutanbazar
Police Station. On that day in the morning at about 9.40
a.m. one requisition was sent to the Nutanbazar police
station from the rural hospital, Nutanbazar with information
that one patient with burn injuries had been admitted in the
hospital. Accordingly he entered the same in the GDE vide
No.13 dated 27.08.2016 and visited hospital. He went to
hospital and found the victim Supriya Das was admitted
with burn injuries. On consultation, the Doctor informed
that the condition of the patient was very serious and
accordingly he was informed that the dying declaration of
the patient was already been recorded by Dr. Sourav
Bhowmik before his arrival in the hospital. Thereafter the
patient was referred to the Tepania District Hospital and on
the same date on the basis of said GDE he visited PO and
seized one 5 liter silver colour plastic K. oil drum containing
about 1 liter of K. oil, one half burnt piece of wood, partially
burnt a piece of cloth by preparing seizure list and identified
the seizure list marked Exbt.3/1 and his signature marked
Exbt.3/2. On the same day Sajal Dey, father of the victim
lodged an ejahar to the OC, RK Pur Women PS alleging the
death of his daughter involving the accused person Sankar
Das, Nibaran Das and Rekha Das addressed to OC,
Nutanbazar PS and on the same day the said ejahar was
sent to the Nutanbazar P.S. and OC Nutanbazar PS
accordingly registered Nutanbazar PS Case No.026/2016
under Sections 498A/304B of IPC. On receipt of case docket
he was satisfied that the information of GDE correlated with
the ejahar and accordingly after registration of the case by
OC Nutanbazar a requisition was sent to the SP, Gomati for
allowing the IO to conduct preliminary investigation. On
28.08.2016 he again visited the PO where he examined and
recorded the statement of Srimati Das(Saha), Shibani Saha
and Shipra Saha and thereafter he prepared hand sketch
map of PO with index. He identified the hand sketch map
marked
Exbt.12
and
identified
his
signature
marked
Exbt.12/1, also identified the index of hand sketch map
marked Exbt.13 and his signature marked Exbt.13/1. He
also recorded the statement of Maran Saha and Swapan
Barna Sharma. On the same day he arrested the accused
Sankar Das from his house and produced before the Court.
On 29.08.2016 he arranged recording the statement of
Shibani Saha and Shipra Saha under Section 164(5) of
Cr.P.C. before the Magistrate and after that on 31.08.2016
SP, Gomati directed him to hand over the case docket to the
SDPO Amarpur and accordingly he handed over the case
docket on 01.09.2016 to the SDPO Souvik Dey. During
cross-examination nothing came out relevant.
27.
PW-22 Subhasis Bandopadhya deposed that on
28.08.2016 he was posted as SDM, Udaipur Sub-Division.
On that day he received one requisition from OC RK Pur for
conducting inquest over the dead body of Supriya Das.
Accordingly he conducted inquest over the dead body of
Supriya Das at the morgue of District Hospital, Udaipur on
28.08.2016 being identified by one Smt. Sikha Deb, WSI RK
Pur PS and after conducting the inquest he prepared a
report in four sheets and identified the report marked
Exbt.15 and the signature of witness in four numbers
marked as Exbt.15/1 to 15/4.
28.
PW-23
Smt.
Sikha
Deb
deposed
that
on
27.08.2016 she was posted at RK Pur Women PS as an ASI
of Police. As per requisition of OC, RK Pur Women PS she
went to Tepania District hospital and she conducted inquest
over the dead body of Supriya Das being identified by one
Sabita Shil and Abhima Mog, both are Constables and
prepared the inquest report and identified the same marked
as Exbt.11/1 and 11/2. On 28.08.2016 Maran Madrasi
produced a white plastic bag containing three jars full of
viscera of the deceased Supriya in Tepania District Hospital
morgue and the same was also seized by her by preparing
seizure list in connection with RK Pur PS GD Entry No.21/16
dated 27.08.2016. She identified the seizure list marked
Exbt.10/2
and
her
signature
marked
Exbt.10/3.
On
11.09.2016, SDPO, Amarpur on her production seized three
jars containing the viscera by preparing seizure list wherein
he put her signature and identified her signature marked
Exbt.7/1.
During
cross-examination
nothing
came
out
relevant.
29.
PW-24, Souvik De is the IO who laid chargesheet
against the accused appellant. He deposed that as an IO he
took up the investigation of the case and during the part of
his investigation he found that his predecessor already
visited PO and prepared hand sketch map with index and
during the part of investigation he examined and recorded
the statements of Shibani Saha, Shipra Saha, Arati Saha,
Soma Rani Banik, Mani Bala Karmakar and Dr. Sourav
Bhowmik
who
recorded
the
dying
declaration
of
the
deceased. He also examined and recorded the statements of
Shyamal
Debnath,
Priyalal
Chakma,
Srimati
Das,
Krishnamani Chakma, Sajal Dey, Rama Talukdar, Kalpana
Biswas, Amar Das, Babul Talukdar, Ramesh Chakraborty,
WSI Sikha Dey, Mithun Debnath, Biswajit Banik, Sabita Shil,
Abhima Mog, Dr. Chandan Kumar Tripura, Menaka Begam,
Kalpana
Acharjee,
Ranjit
Dey,
Bishu
Dey,
Subhash
Banerjee, Subasish Bandapadhyay, Dr. Abhijit Datta, Dr.
Rituparna Dey and Miss Shibani Acharjee. He further
deposed that on 07.09.2016 he collected the first dying
declaration of deceased from Dr. Sourav Bhowmik, MOIC of
Nutanbazar Hospital. He received SCD on 11.09.2016 and
also obtained the second dying declaration of deceased from
WSI Sikha Dey. On 07.09.2016 he seized one 5 ltrs. Silver
colour plastic container with mark Veta with red colour cap
containing 1 ltrs of liquid substance appeared to be
kerosene,
one
half
burnt
file
of
wood
of
length
approximately 15 inch and some burnt pieces of cloths
which were already seized by the previous IO and reseized
by him by preparing seizure list from SI Bimalendu Saha.
He identified the seizure list marked Exbt.5/1 and his
signature
of
the
seizure
list
marked
Exbt.5/2.
On
11.09.2016 he seized three plastic jars marked A, B and C
containing viscera of the deceased and identified the seizure
list marked as Exbt.7/3 and the signature marked as
Exbt.7/4. He further deposed that he arranged for sending
the viscera, i.e. skin and hair of deceased for forensic
examination and on 10.10.2016 he received the SFSL
report. He also arranged for recording of judicial statement
of witnesses Shibani Saha and Shipra Saha and he caused
the arrest of accused on 28.08.2016 and forwarded him
before the court on 29.08.2016 and on completion of
investigation he laid chargesheet against accused Sankar
Das for having commission of offence punishable under
Section
498A/302
of
IPC.
He
identified
Exbt.16,
the
statement of witness Maran Saha (PW-4). He identified the
drum containing K. oil, burnt pieces of cloths and a file of
burnt fire wood marked as Exbt.MO.1 series. He identified
the endorsement of WSI Mina Debbarma on the ejahar
marked Exbt.6/3 and identified the endorsement regarding
receipt and registration of FIR by the then OC Jaharlal
Debbarma marked Exbt.6/4. He identified the printed FIR
form marked as Exbt.17 and the signature of the then OC
Jaharlal Debbarma marked as Exbt.17/1.
During
cross-examination
he
deposed
that
the
occurrence took place on 27.08.2016 at about 8.00 a.m.
The first dying declaration was recorded on 27.08.2016 but
the same was collected on 07.09.2016 as the concerned
Doctor made delay in delivering the same. The second dying
declaration was received by him on 11.09.2016. He further
deposed that although the second dying declaration was
recorded on 27.08.2016 but the same was procured on
10.09.2016 but he could not say the reason for delay. He
further deposed that he did not find any certificate of Doctor
showing
that
the
deceased
was
fit
for
giving
dying
declaration. At the time of seizure, kerosene drum was
closed. He identified the portion of statement of witness
Srimati Saha marked Exbt.A. He also deposed that during
investigation he did not seize the bed head ticket of
deceased and also during investigation it was not revealed
to him that there was any demand of dowry on the part of
the accused before the occurrence.
30.
We have heard detailed argument of both the
sides and also gone through the evidence on record of the
prosecution adduced before the Learned Trial Court, during
trial of the present appellant and also the citations as
referred by Learned counsel of both the sides. In the case at
hand there is no dispute on record in respect of the fact that
the deceased of this case was the wife of the present
accused appellant. It is on record that after the marriage,
both the parties resumed conjugal life for a certain period
peacefully. After that their family discord started. Although
in the case Learned Trial court framed charge against the
appellant under Section 498A read with Section 302 of IPC.
But after conclusion of trial Learned court below acquitted
the appellant from the charge levelled against him under
Section 498A of IPC but found him guilty for the charge of
punishable under Section 302 of IPC. In course of hearing
Learned
Addl.
PP
representing
the
state
respondent/
prosecution also could not satisfy the court regarding
acquittal of the appellant from the charge framed under
Section 498A of IPC. So after going through the evidence on
record we also concur with the finding of Learned Trial Court
that the prosecution has failed to bring whom the charge
against the accused appellant under Section 498A of IPC.
Now in respect of charge framed under Section 302 of IPC it
appears to us that there were two sets of evidence adduced
before the Learned Trial Court by the prosecution and at the
time of delivery of judgment Learned Trial Court did not
consider the evidence of PW-2, Miss Sibani Saha aged about
14 years and PW-3, Miss Sipra Saha aged 14 years and
ultimately relied upon the dying declaration of the deceased
victim. We have also gone through the evidence of PWs 2
and 3. PW-2, Sibani Saha in course of her examination
before the court stated that on that relevant point of time a
quarrel was going on and at that time the present appellant
gave a push to his wife i.e. the deceased and she fell down
on the earth and thereafter she got up and rushed to the
kitchen and took up a file of burning fire wood and set fire
upon her. Similarly PW-3 Sipra Saha also deposed in the
same manner that on that relevant point of time she heard
noise of quarrel amongst the accused and the deceased.
When the appellant gave a push to Supriya, she fell down
on the ground and thereafter she got up and rushed to their
kitchen and picked up a file of burning fire wood from the
oven and self immolated her. These part of evidence cannot
appears to be trustworthy and it appears to us that Learned
Trial Court below rightly discarded their evidences made
before the court. In a criminal prosecution it is not possible
that every witnesses of the prosecution in toto would
support the version of each other and from the evidence of
those two witnesses it appears to us that just only for
pushing by the appellant the deceased victim could not have
taken such step to vanish/destroy her life and there was
also no evidence on record that the deceased victim was
suffering from any mental disorder earlier to commit such
offence by self immolating her. So after gone through the
evidence on record we stand agree with the findings of the
Learned Trial court below that the evidence of PWs 2 and 3
were not sufficient to justify conviction against the present
appellant of this case.
31.
Now to substantiate the charge we have also
gone through the other evidence on record including the
evidence of Medical Officers who recorded the dying
declaration of the deceased as already stated. The dying
declaration of the deceased was recorded twice, one at
Nutanbazar Hospital just after the initial admission of
deceased of the alleged incident and thereafter at Udaipur
District Hospital, Tepania when she was referred from
Nutanbazar Rural Hospital to Udaipur for better treatment
on the ground of her severe condition. Excepting the
Medical Officers other witnesses were also supported the
version of the prosecution that the death of the deceased
was caused due to pouring of Kerosene oil by the accused
appellant on the alleged date. The appellant accused by the
trend of cross-examination could not shaken the evidence of
prosecution witnesses in this regard. Now if we go through
the evidence of PW-5 Dr. Sourav Bhowmik who in course of
his examination specifically stated that on 27.08.2016 as an
MO of Nutanbazar Rural Hospital he recorded the dying
declaration of the deceased when she stated that her
husband i.e. the present appellant has set fire on her after
pouring K. oil. This witness further stated that the deceased
victim was well oriented and conscious with regard to the
time and place, although he did not give any specific
certificate with regard to the observation. He also identified
his report which was duly marked and from his evidence it
appears that at the time of recording dying declaration one
staff nurse Krishnamani Chakma and one GDA Manibala
Karmakar were present and the witness also obtained the
RTI and LTI of the deceased victim on the body of same
dying declaration which was marked as Exbt.4 and he
identified the thumb impression of the deceased marked
Exbt.4/1 series and his signature on the body of dying
declaration marked Exbt.4/2. The accused by the trend of
cross-examination could not raise any doubt to disbelieve
his evidence. Furthermore, from his evidence it also appears
to us at the time of recording dying declaration apart from
himself, the patient and two witnesses Krishna Mani
Chakma and Manibala Karmakar were present and in their
presence the statement was recorded. Now if we go through
the
evidence
of
PW-6
Manibala
Karmakar
she
also
supported the version of PW-5, Dr. Sourav Bhowmik and
from her evidence it also appears that at the time of
recording dying declaration the victim stated that her
husband had set fire on her after pouring kerosene oil and
she also identified her signature on the body of dying
declaration marked Exbt.4/3. The accused appellant could
not
discredit
the
evidence
of
said
witness
Manibala
Karmakar and the other witness Krishna Mani Chakma was
not tendered for examination by the prosecution.
32.
Now if we go through the evidence of Dr.
Chandan Kumar Tripura, PW-14 who recorded the second
dying declaration of the deceased victim. It appears that on
27.08.2016 he was posted as Medical Officer of Gomati
District Hospital, Tepania and on that day he recorded the
dying declaration of one Supriya Das (deceased) when she
stated that on 27.08.2016 in the morning at about 8.00 to
8.30 a.m. a hot altercation took place in between the
deceased and her husband and during the said hot
altercation her husband shut the door from inside and
brutally assaulted her and then poured kerosene oil on her
body
and
lighted
the
match
sticks.
Resultantly,
she
sustained the burn injuries and at the time of recording the
statement two staff of their hospital namely Maneka Begam
and Kalpana Acharjee were present. He further stated that
as per his observation on that relevant point of time the
deceased victim was in fit mental condition for the purpose
of making the statement and identified the dying declaration
recorded by him marked Exbt-8 and also identified his
signature on the body of dying declaration marked Exbt.8/1.
He further stated that on the bottom of the recorded
statement he also obtained the RTI and subsequently same
day the victim succumbed to her injuries and on 28.08.2016
he along with two other Doctors namely Abhijit Datta and
Rituparna Dey conducted Postmortem over the dead body of
the deceased and according to him the cause of death was
ante-mortem burn due to shock following 90 to 95% burn of
TBSA and the probable age of the death was 6 to 12 hours
prior to holding of postmortem examination. He identified
the postmortem report marked Exbt.9 and his signature
marked Exbt-9/1 and the signatures of two other Doctors
marked as Exbt.9/2 and Exbt.9/3. During cross-examination
nothing came out relevant.
33.
Now if we go through the evidence of PW-16,
Kalpana Acharjee it appears to us that on 27.08.2016 she
was posted as Staff Nurse of Gomati District Hospital,
Tepania and on that day one Supriya Das was admitted in
the
hospital
with
burn
injuries
and
accordingly
the
statement of the deceased victim was recorded by Dr.
Chandra Kumar Tripura in her presence. That time another
staff namely Maneka Begam was also present. She further
stated that on that relevant point of time the victim stated
that on that day in the morning her husband assaulted her
in the room and thereafter closed the door from inside,
poured kerosene oil and set fire on her. She put her
signature on the recorded statement and identified the
same marked as Exbt.8/2. Thus it appears that this witness
PW-16 also supported the version of PW-14, Dr. Chandan
Kumar Tripura. During cross-examination nothing came out
relevant.
34.
At the time of argument Learned counsel for the
appellant relied upon few citations and submitted that since
the victim according to postmortem examination report
sustained 90-95% burn injuries, so according to law she
was not in a position to make any statement and she was
also not in a position to put her thumb impression on the
body of dying declaration. But the Learned court below did
not consider those aspects and ultimately found the
appellant guilty of the offence charged. It was further
submitted that the dying declaration was not recorded in
presence of any
Magistrate
as
required by
law
and
furthermore that was not taken in the shape of question
answer forms. So according to Learned counsel there was
no scope to place any reliance on the alleged dying
declarations recorded by the concerned Medical Officers PWs
5 and 14. In Nirmala Devi alias Ghunghera Devi vs.
State of Uttaranchal reported in 2005 CRI.L.J. 625,
Hon’ble Uttaranchal High Court in para Nos.30 and 32
observed as under:
―30. It also need repetition that the so called dying
declaration (Ext. Ka.7) clearly appear to be a detailed,
perfectly prepared and full of facts statement which could
not be at any rate expected to have been given by Smt.
Urmila Devi considering her precarious condition due to
almost 100% burns and as also referred above.
32. The learned counsel for the appellant also drew
attention to the fact that there is nothing on record to
show that the Medical Officer attending to the deceased
in the hospital sent any memo to the police station to
send some officer to record the dying declaration of the
deceased. Had it been so Dr. Rajesh Singh (P. W. 4)
would have given evidence to this effect also. There is
also nothing to show that from the police station a
reference was sent to the Sub Divisional Magistrate to
record the dying declaration. No G. D. report to this effect
was brought on record. Nothing has also been said about
this by the Investigating officers S. I. Digambar Singh
Rawat (P.W.8) and Dy. S. P. Jagat Ram Joshi (P.W.9). As
regards the statement of Tehsildar Pratap Singh Sah (P.
W. 7) is concerned he merely gave out that he was
deputed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate to record the
dying declaration of the deceased but no written order to
this effect was brought on record. In these circumstances
the suggestion given to this witness that no statement
was given by the deceased and that the so called dying
declaration was got prepared by him fictitiously at the
instance of the informant of the case cannot said to be
without any substance despite the suggestion having
been denied by this witness.‖
Referring the same Learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that in this case from the inquest report
[Exbt.11] it is clear that the deceased had sustained injuries
by setting fire to her own body, but that part of statement
of the recording officer was not considered by Learned Trial
Court
and
further
submitted
that
the
alleged
dying
declaration was not recorded by Magistrate so no reliance
could be placed upon those dying declarations.
35.
In Sampat Babso Kale and Another vs. State
of Maharashtra reported in AIR 2019 SC 1852, Hon’ble
the Supreme Court in paras 14, 15 and 19 has further
observed as under:
―14. No doubt, a dying declaration is an extremely
important piece of evidence and where the Court is
satisfied that the dying declaration is truthful, voluntary
and not a result of any extraneous influence, the Court
can convict the accused only on the basis of a dying
declaration. We need not refer to the entire law but it
would be apposite to refer to the judgment of this Court
in the case of Sham Shankar Kankaria v. State of
Maharashtra:(2006) 13 SCC 165 held as follows:
11. Though a dying declaration is entitled to great
weight, it is worthwhile to note that the accused
has no power of cross-examination. Such a power
is essential for eliciting the truth as an obligation
of oath could be. This is the reason the court also
insists that the dying declaration should be of such
a nature as to inspire full confidence of the court in
its correctness. The court has to be on guard that
the statement of deceased was not as a result of
either tutoring or prompting or a product of
imagination. The court must be further satisfied
that the deceased was in a fit state of mind after a
clear opportunity to observe and identify the
assailant. Once the court is satisfied that the
declaration was true and voluntary, undoubtedly, it
can base its conviction without any further
corroboration. It cannot be laid down as an
absolute rule of law that the dying declaration
cannot form the sole basis of conviction unless it is
corroborated. The rule requiring corroboration is
merely a rule of prudence………….
15. In the present case, as we have already held above,
there was some doubt as to whether the victim was in a
fit state of mind to make the statement. No doubt, the
doctor had stated that she was in a fit state of mind but
he himself had, in his evidence, admitted that in the case
of a victim with 98% burns, the shock may lead to
delusion. Furthermore, in our view, the combined effect
of the trauma with the administration of painkillers could
lead to a case of possible delusion, and therefore, there
is a need to look for corroborative evidence in the present
case.
19. Another factor which needs to be taken into
consideration is that none of the witnesses from the
neighbourhood have been examined. Even as per the
prosecution case it was the neighbours who first raised
an alarm. There is no explanation why none of them have
been examined. It is also the prosecution case that the
accused husband along with another neighbour went to
the hospital to arrange for an ambulance. This person has
not been examined. The non-examination of these
important witnesses leads to nocorroboration of the
dying declaration. The best witnesses would have been
the neighbours who reached the spot immediately after
the occurrence. They would have been the best persons
to state as to whether the victim told them anything
about the occurrence or not.‖
Referring the same Learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that since the victim sustained burn
injuries and from the evidence on record it transpires that
administration of pain killers could lead to a case of possible
delusion, so no reliance could be placed upon the alleged
dying declaration as relied upon by the prosecution in
proving the charge against the accused appellant, but the
Learned court below did not consider the same and from the
evidence of PWs 2 and 3 and their mother it was crystal
clear that there was no fault on the part of the accused
appellant but the victim herself by a piece of burnt fire wood
immolated her and set fire on her body. But those part of
evidence were overlooked by the Learned court below and
urged for setting aside the judgment of the Learned Trial
court.
36.
Learned counsel for the appellant further referred
another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jayamma
and Another vs. State of Karnataka reported in (2021)
6 SCC 213. In para Nos. 17, 21, 23 and 24 Hon’ble the
Supreme Court observed as under:
17. Consistent with the cited principles, this Court
refused to uphold the conviction in the case of Sampat
Babso Kale and Another v.State of Maharashtra: (2019) 4
SCC 739. The dying declaration in that case was made by
a victim who had suffered 98 percent burn injuries, and
the statement was recorded after the victim was injected
with painkillers. This Court adopted a cautious approach,
and opined that there were serious doubts as to whether
the victim was in a fit state of mind to make the
statement. Given the extent of burn injuries, it was
observed that the victim must have been in great agony,
and once a sedative had been injected, the possibility of
her being in a state of delusion could not be completely
ruled out. Further, it was specifically noted that
14.the endorsement made by the doctor that the
victim was in a fit state of mind to make the
statement has been made not before the statement
but after the statement was recorded. Normally it
should be the other way around.
21. The litmus test, therefore, is whether the victim made
the statement (Ex.P5)and if so, whether such statement
can be the solitary foundation for conviction of the
appellants?
23. The other important reason to depart from the High
Court‘s view re conviction of the appellants is that the
power of scrutiny exercisable by the High Court under
Section 378, CrPC should not be routinely invoked where
the view formed by the trial court was a ‗possible view‘.
The judgment of the trial court cannot be set aside
merely because the High Court finds its own view more
probable, save where the judgment of the trial court
suffers from perversity or the conclusions drawn by it
were impossible if there was a correct reading and
analysis of the evidence on record. To say it differently,
unless the High Court finds that there is complete
misreading of the material evidence which has led to
miscarriage of justice, the view taken by the trial court
which can also possibly be a correct view, need not be
interfered with. This self-restraint doctrine, of course,
does not denude the High Court of its powers to reappreciate the evidence, including in an appeal against
acquittal and arrive at a different firm finding of fact.
24. If the case in hand is evaluated on these parameters,
it may be seen from paragraphs 4 and 6 of its order that
the High Court dealt with the appeal against acquittal
summarily and did not even discuss the ocular evidence,
especially of the son and daughter-in-law of the
deceased, who have, to some extent, belied the version of
the doctor(PW-16) or the investigating officer (PW-11).
We say so for the reason time when she was rushed to
the hospital in a bullock cart arranged by Kumaranaika
(PW-3). Without discarding or disbelieving such
statement(s), it is difficult to accept that injured —
Jayamma was in a fit state of mind at 1:15 a.m. when the
alleged dying declaration was recorded. Her state of mind
can be well imagined due to the combined effect of the
trauma and the administration of painkillers. that
according to Ravi Kumar (PW-2), son of the deceased, the
victim Jayamma had lost consciousness and was unable
to speak at the The High Court, on the other hand, relied
upon the dying declaration(Ex.P-5) as the same was
purportedly corroborated by the statements of doctor
(PW-16), and the police official (PW-11) who authored
the document (Ex.P-5). Such a conclusion, in our
considered opinion, is totally erroneous and based upon
misreading of the evidence on record. It has already been
noticed that according to the doctor (PW-16), the victim
had suffered 80% injuries including on her hands. As
against it, the Police Officer (PW-11) claims that there
were no burn injuries on the hand of the victim, hence
she could put her left thumb impression on the dying
declaration (Ex.P-5). These glaring contradictions should
not have gone unnoticed by the High Court.‖
Referring the same Learned counsel for the appellant
submitted that since the victim had suffered 90-95% burn
injuries and the statement of the victim was recorded after
the victim was injected with painkillers and from the
evidence of the Medical Officers it was not clearly explained
by the prosecution that the victim was a fit state of mind to
make the statement. So according to Learned counsel the
possibility of the victim being in a state of delusion could not
be completely rule out. But the Learned court below did not
consider these aspects and came to the conclusion of
finding guilty of the appellant in this case and furthermore,
Learned counsel drawn the attention of the court that the
prosecution before the Learned Court failed to prove that
the present appellant caused death of the victim by pouring
K. oil and no such expert evidence was led by the
prosecution to prove the charge against the appellant.
Furthermore, no Magistrate who recorded the statement of
the witnesses under Section 164(5) of Cr.P.C. was adduced
by the prosecution to substantiate the charge leveled
against the appellant and furthermore there was delay in
delivering the dying declaration recorded by the concerned
Medical Officers. There was also no explanation in this
regard from the side of the prosecution.
37.
Finally
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant referring the PM examination report submitted
that in the PM report nowhere it is found that at the time of
examination of the deceased victim they found the smell of
kerosene on the body of the deceased victim. There was
also no explanation from the side of prosecution in this
regard and finally urged for acquittal of the appellant from
the charge of the case by setting aside the judgment.
38.
On the other hand Learned Addl. P.P. Mr. S.
Ghosh at the very outset referring the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses and specifically referring the dying
declarations of the victim recorded by PW-5, Dr. Sourav
Bhowmik and PW-14, Dr. Chandan Kumar Tripura and the
connected evidence submitted that the Learned court below
after proper appreciation of the evidence on record rightly
and
reasonably
delivered
the
judgment
holding
the
appellant to be guilty of offence and submitted that there is
no scope to interfere with the judgment passed by the
Learned Trial court and he also submitted that the Learned
court below rightly and reasonably discarded the evidence
of PWs 2 and 3 and further submitted that the evidence of
PWs 5 and 14 are so trustworthy and convincing that there
was no room to disbelieve their evidence and in support of
the prosecution case Learned Addl. P.P. relied upon one
citation.
In
Ashabai
and
Another
vs.
State
of
Maharashtra reported in (2013) 2 SCC 224 in para No.15
Hon’ble the Apex court observed as under:
―15) About the evidentiary value of dying declaration of
the deceased, it is relevant to refer Section 32(1) of the
Evidence Act, 1872, which reads as under:32. Cases in which statement of relevant fact by
person who is dead or cannot be found, etc. is
relevant.- Statements, written or verbal, of
relevant facts made by a person who is dead, or
who cannot be found, or who has become
incapable of giving evidence, or whose attendance
cannot be procured without an amount of delay or
expense which, under the circumstances of the
case, appears to the Court unreasonable, are
themselves relevant facts in the following cases:(1) when it relates to cause of death.- When the
statement is made by a person as to the cause of
his death, or as to any of the circumstances of the
transaction which resulted in his death, in cases in
which the cause of that person‘s death comes into
question.
Such statements are relevant whether the person
who made them was or was not, at the time when
they were made, under expectation of death, and
whatever may be the nature of the proceeding in
which the cause of his death comes into question.
(2)-(8)
*
*
*
It is clear from the above provision that the
statement made by the deceased by way of a
declaration is admissible in evidence under Section
32(1) of the Evidence Act. It is not in dispute that
her statement relates to the cause of her death. In
that event, it qualifies the criteria mentioned
in Section 32(1) of the Evidence Act. There is no
particular form or procedure prescribed for
recording a dying declaration nor it is required to
be recorded only by a Magistrate. As a general rule,
it is advisable to get the evidence of the declarant
certified from a doctor. In appropriate cases, the
satisfaction of the person recording the statement
regarding the state of mind of the deceased would
also be sufficient to hold that the deceased was in
a position to make a statement. It is settled law
that if the prosecution solely depends on the dying
declaration, the normal rule is that the courts must
exercise due care and caution to ensure
genuineness of the dying declaration, keeping in
mind that the accused had no opportunity to test
the veracity of the statement of the deceased by
cross-examination. As rightly observed by the High
Court, the law does not insist upon the
corroboration of dying declaration before it can be
accepted. The insistence of corroboration to a
dying declaration is only a rule of prudence. When
the Court is satisfied that the dying declaration is
voluntary, not tainted by tutoring or animosity, and
is not a product of the imagination of the declarant,
in that event, there is no impediment in convicting
the accused on the basis of such dying declaration.
When there are multiple dying declarations, each
dying declaration has to be separately assessed
and evaluated and assess independently on its own
merit as to its evidentiary value and one cannot be
rejected because of certain variation in the other.‖
[Emphasis supplied]
Referring the same Learned counsel for the
state-respondent submitted that as per law there is no
particular form/procedure prescribed for recording a dying
declaration nor it is required to be recorded by a Magistrate.
In the given case the concerned two Medical Officers PWs 5
and 14 recorded the dying declaration of the deceased and
both the Doctors opined that the deceased was in a fit state
of
mind
and
conscious
to
made
the
statement
and
accordingly the statement of the deceased victim was
recorded in presence of the witnesses and relying upon the
judgment Learned Addl. P.P. further submitted that since
the appellant by way of his defence could not discard the
evidence on record of the prosecution and furthermore the
appellant during his examination under Section 313 of
Cr.P.C. stated that on that relevant day he returned back to
home at about 11.30 a.m. which was a dire falsehood. As
because the victim was admitted in the hospital on that day
in the morning at about 9.00 a.m. and at about 9.20 a.m.
the first dying declaration was recorded by PW-5 in
presence of witnesses and the appellant was present in the
hospital along with PW-1 that time. So the stand taken by
the appellant during his examination under Section 313 of
Cr.P.C. cannot be relied upon and finally Learned counsel for
the state-respondent urged for upholding the conviction
returned by Learned Trial court.
39.
We have also gone through the citations referred
by Learned counsel of both the sides and also discussed the
evidence on record in detail. From the evidence on record it
appears to us that Learned court below based on the dying
declaration recorded by PW-5 and PW-14 rightly convicted
the appellant in the given case. The appellant by way of
cross-examination could not discard the evidence of said
Medical Officers and also the corroborating evidences. In
this regard we would like to rely upon another citation of
the Hon’ble Supreme court in Purshottam Chopra and
Another vs. State (Government of NCT of Delhi)
reported in (2020) 11 SCC 489 wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed as under:
19.1. In Bhagwan: (2019) 8 SCC 95, this Court
accepted the dying declaration made by a person
having suffered 92% burn injury and whose
continued consciousness was certified by the
doctor. This Court referred to the decision in Vijay
Pal v. State (Government of NCT of Delhi): (2015)
4 SCC 749, where the statement made by the
victim having suffered 100% burn injury was also
accepted. This Court said :(B) Can a person who has suffered 92% burn
injuries be in a condition to give a dying
declaration?
24. This question is also no longer res
integra. In Vijay Pal v. State (NCT of Delhi):
2015 (4) SCC 749, we notice the following
discussion: (SCC p. 759, paras 23-24).
23. It is contended by the learned
counsel for the appellant that when
the deceased sustained 100% burn
injuries, she could not have made any
statement to her brother. In this
regard, we may profitably refer to the
decision in Mafabhai Nagarbhai Raval
v. State of Gujarat: (1992) 4 SCC 69
wherein it has been held that a person
suffering 99% burn injuries could be
deemed capable enough for the
purpose
of
making
a
dying
declaration. The Court in the said case
opined that unless there existed some
inherent and apparent defect, the trial
court should not have substituted its
opinion for that of the doctor. In the
light of the facts of the case, the dying
declaration was found to be worthy of
reliance.
24. In State of M.P. v. Dal Singh:
(2013) 14 SCC 159, a two-Judge
Bench placed reliance on the dying
declaration of the deceased who had
suffered 100% burn injuries on the
ground that the dying declaration was
found to be credible.
25. Therefore, the mere fact that the patient
suffered 92% burn injuries as in this case
would not stand in the way of patient giving
a dying declaration which otherwise inspires
the confidence of the Court and is free from
tutoring, and can be found reliable.
20.3. In the case of Thurukanni Pompiah: AIR 1965
SC 939, this Court held that while a truthful and
reliable dying declaration may form the sole basis
of conviction, even without corroboration but the
Court must be satisfied about its truthfulness and
reliability; and if the Court finds that the
declaration is not wholly reliable and a material
portion of the deceased‘s version of the occurrence
is untrue, the Court may, in the circumstances of a
given case, may consider it unsafe to convict the
accused on the basis of the declaration alone
without further corroboration. This Court observed,
inter alia, as under:9. Under clause (1) of Section 32 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, a statement
made by a person who is dead, as to the
cause of his death or as to any of the
circumstances of the transaction which
resulted in his death is a relevant fact in
cases in which the cause of that person‘s
death comes into question, and such a
statement is relevant whether the person
who made it was or was not, at the time
when it was made, under expectation of
death, and whatever may be the nature of
the proceeding in which the cause of his
death comes into question. The dying
declaration of Eranna is, therefore, relevant
and material evidence in the case. A truthful
and reliable dying declaration may form the
sole basis of conviction, even though it is not
corroborated. But the Court must be
satisfied that the declaration is truthful. The
reliability of the declaration should be
subjected to a close scrutiny, considering
that ‗it was made in the absence of the
accused who had no opportunity to test its
veracity by cross-examination. If the Court
finds that the declaration is not wholly
reliable and a material and integral portion
of the deceased‘s version of the entire
occurrence is untrue, the Court may, in all
the circumstances of the case, consider it
unsafe to convict the accused on the basis of
the declaration alone without further
corroboration.
20.4. In Uka Ram: (2001) 5 SCC 254, this Court
again emphasised on the requirement that the
Court should be satisfied about trustworthiness of
the dying declaration, its voluntary nature and
fitness of the mind of the deceased and it was held
that:
6. ….Once the court is satisfied that the
dying declaration was true, voluntary and
not
influenced
by
any
extraneous
consideration, it can base its conviction
without any further corroboration as rule
requiring corroboration is not a rule of law
but only a rule of prudence.
21.1. A dying declaration could be the sole basis of
conviction even without corroboration, if it inspires
confidence of the Court.
21.2. The Court should be satisfied that the
declarant was in a fit state of mind at the time of
making the statement; and that it was a voluntary
statement, which was not the result of tutoring,
prompting or imagination.
21.3. Where a dying declaration is suspicious or is
suffering from any infirmity such as want of fit
state of mind of the declarant or of like nature, it
should not be acted upon without corroborative
evidence.
21.4. When the eye-witnesses affirm that the
deceased was not in a fit and conscious state to
make the statement, the medical opinion cannot
prevail.
21.5. The law does not provide as to who could
record dying declaration nor there is any
prescribed format or procedure for the same but
the person recording dying declaration must be
satisfied that the maker is in a fit state of mind and
is capable of making the statement.
21.6. Although presence of a Magistrate is not
absolutely necessary for recording of a dying
declaration but to ensure authenticity and
credibility, it is expected that a Magistrate be
requested to record such dying declaration and/or
attestation be obtained from other persons present
at the time of recording the dying declaration.
21.7. As regards a burns case, the percentage and
degree of burns would not, by itself, be decisive of
the credibility of dying declaration; and the
decisive factor would be the quality of evidence
about the fit and conscious state of the declarant
to make the statement.
21.8. If after careful scrutiny, the Court finds the
statement placed as dying declaration to be
voluntary and also finds it coherent and consistent,
there is no legal impediment in recording
conviction on its basis even without corroboration.
22. Applying the relevant principles to the facts of
the present case, we have not an iota of doubt that
the appellants have rightly been convicted on the
basis of the statements of the victim Sher Singh, as
recorded by PW-8 Dr. Sushma and PW-16 SI
Rajesh Kumar.
25.2. Another emphasis laid on behalf of the
appellants is on the fact that the victim Sher Singh
had suffered 100% burns and he was already in
critical condition and further to that, his condition
was regularly deteriorating. It is, therefore,
contended that in such a critical and deteriorating
condition, he could not have made proper, coherent
and intelligible statement. The submissions do not
make out a case for interference. As laid down in
Vijay Pal‘s case:(2015) 4 SCC 749 and reiterated in
Bhagwan‘s case: (2019) 8 SCC 95 the extent of
burn injuries – going beyond 92% and even to
100% - would not, by itself, lead to a conclusion
that victim of such burn injuries may not be in a
position to make the statement. Irrespective of the
extent and gravity of burn injuries, when the
doctor had certified him to be in fit state of mind to
make the statement; and the person recording the
statement was also satisfied about his fitness for
making such statement; and when there does not
appear any inherent or apparent defect, in our
view, the dying declaration cannot be discarded.
25.3. Contra to what has been argued on behalf of
the appellants, we are of the view that the juristic
theory regarding acceptability of statement made
by a person who is at the point of death has its
fundamentals in the recognition that at the
terminal point of life, every motive to falsehood is
removed or silenced. To a fire victim like that of
present case, the gravity of injuries is an obvious
indicator towards the diminishing hope of life in
the victim; and on the accepted principles,
acceleration of diminishing of hope of life could
only obliterate the likelihood of falsehood or
improper motive. Of course, it may not lead to the
principle that gravity of injury would itself lead to
trustworthiness of the dying declaration. As
noticed, there could still be some inherent defect
for which a statement, even if recorded as dying
declaration, cannot be relied upon without
corroboration. Suffice would be to observe to
present purpose that merely for 100% burn
injuries, it cannot be said that the victim was
incapable to make a statement which could be
acted upon as dying declaration.
28. For what has been discussed hereinabove, we
are clearly of the view that the appellants have
rightly been held guilty of causing death of Sher
Singh by putting him on fire and have also rightly
been convicted for the offence under Section
302/34 IPC. No case for interference is made out.
Accordingly, and in view of the above, these
appeals fail and are, therefore, dismissed.‖
[Emphasis supplied]
40.
In another judgment Bhagwan vs. State of
Maharashtra reported in (2019) 8 SCC 95 Hon’ble the
Apex court in para Nos. 24 and 25 observed as under:
―(B) Can a person who has suffered 92% burn
injuries be in a condition to give a dying
declaration?
24. This question is also no longer res
integra. In Vijay Pal v. State (Government of
NCT of Delhi): (2015) 4 SCC 749, we notice
the following discussion:
23. It is contended by the learned
counsel for the appellant that when
the deceased sustained 100% burn
injuries, she could not have made any
statement to her brother. In this
regard, we may profitably refer to the
decision in Mafabhai Nagarbhai Raval
v. State of Gujarat; (1992) 4 SCC 69:
wherein it has been held that a person
suffering 99% burn injuries could be
deemed capable enough for the
purpose
of
making
a
dying
declaration. The Court in the said case
opined that unless there existed some
inherent and apparent defect, the trial
court should not have substituted its
opinion for that of the doctor. In the
light of the facts of the case, the dying
declaration was found to be worthy of
reliance.
24. In State of M.P. v. Dal Singh;
(2013) 14 SCC 159, a two-Judge
Bench placed reliance on the dying
declaration of the deceased who had
suffered 100% burn injuries on the
ground that the dying declaration was
found to be credible.
25. Therefore, the mere fact that the patient
suffered 92% burn injuries as in this case would
not stand in the way of patient giving a dying
declaration
which
otherwise
inspires
the
confidence of the Court and is free from tutoring,
and can be found reliable.‖
41.
From the aforesaid citations it appears to us that
here in the case at hand there was no contrary evidence on
record that the deceased victim did not make the statement
voluntarily and her statement was not coherent and
consistent and considering the nature of injury sustained by
her she was not in a position to make any such statement.
So after going through the entire evidence on record and
hearing both the sides and also after going through the
principle of citations as referred above, we are of the
considered opinion that the Learned court below rightly and
reasonably found the appellant to be guilty for the offence
charged punishable under Section 302 of the IPC and as
such we do not find any cogent ground to interfere with the
judgment passed by Learned Trial Court.
42.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby dismissed being bereft of merit and accordingly, it
stands dismissed. The judgment and order of conviction and
sentence passed by the Learned court below is hereby
upheld and accordingly it is affirmed. Pending application, if
any, stands disposed of.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
order.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.02.15
03:24:37 -08'00'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review