The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. 1 Admittedly, the petitioner has been serving as Project Officer for more than 10 (ten) years. Further, it is evident that the post of Project Officer is a sanctioned post having financial concurrence. The petitioner has possessed essential qualification as prescribed under the Recruitment Rules. As such, the TSCST, i.e. the present employer of the petitioner is under obligation to consider the regularization and absorption of the petitioner to the said post of Project Officer. In the instant case, the posting and continuation of the petitioner as Project Officer under the respondent-TSCST is neither irregular nor illegal, rather, the appointment of the petitioner as Project Officer under the TSCST is in accordance with MOU entered into between Tripura University and TSCST under Sub-Clause (v) of Clause 9.0 as stated (supra). The Respondents-TSCST are also liable to pay the pay scale prescribed for the post of Project Officer towards the petitioner as it appears in the Memorandum dated 26.04.2023 [Annexure-Y supra] i.e. in the Pay Band-4, Pay Scale of Rs.15,600-39,100/-, G.P. of Rs.5,400/- as per ROP,2017.
7. 2 For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, I direct the Respondents-TSCST to complete the process of regularization and absorption of the petitioner to the post of Project Officer within a period of 3(three) months from the date of this judgment and till such process is completed, they are directed to release minimum pay in the regular pay scale to the petitioner as prescribed for the post of Project Officer from the month of August, 2023, which is payable in the month of September,2023. With the aforesaid directions and observations, the instant writ petition stands allowed and disposed of. sanjay
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO. 651 OF 2022
Sri Sanjoy Sen, son of Sri Anil Chandra Sen, resident of
North Badharghat, A.D. Nagar, P.O. A.D. Nagar,
P.S. A.D. Nagar, District-West Tripura, PIN-799003, age-53 years.
… Petitioner
Vrs.
1. The State of Tripura, represented by its Secretary to the
Department of Science, Technology and Environment, Government of
Tripura, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West
Tripura, PIN-799006.
2. The Tripura State Council For Science and Technology,
represented by its Member Secretary, Vigyan Bhawan, Gurkhabasti,
P.O. Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura,
PIN-799006.
3. The Joint Member Secretary, Tripura State Council for Science
and Technology, Vigyan Bhawan, Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, PSNew Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
4. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of
Tripura, Vigyan Bhawan, Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, PS- New
Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
… Respondents.
PRESENT
For the petitioner
: Mr. Arijit Bhowmik, Advocate.
For the respondent
Nos. 1 & 4
For the respondent
Nos.2 & 3
: Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
: Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Counsel.
Mr. S. Das, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment and order
:
16.08.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel appearing
for the Respondent-Tripura State Council for Science and Technology (for
short, TSCST).
None appears for the State-respondents.
2.
By means of filing the present petition, the petitioner seeks for
following reliefs:
“Under the Circumstances stated above, it is most humbly and
respectfully prayed that this Hon’ble Court would be graciously pleased to:
i.
Issue Notice upon the Respondents.
ii.
Call for the records.
iii.
Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
Petitioner shall not be extended with the regular pay scale w.e.f. the
date of completion of 5 years of service on fixed pay basis i.e.
18.12.2017 as per the Memorandum dated 16.10.2007 issued by the
Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura along with all service benefits
and arrears of financial benefits.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
Petitioner shall not be regularized in service along with all service
benefits including arrears of service benefits.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
Petitioner shall not be granted all service benefits of regularization
pursuant to the prayers above along with all arrears of financial
benefits.
iv.
And after hearing the parties, be pleased to make the rule absolute.
AND/OR
Pass any other order/orders as deemed fit and proper by this
Hon’ble Court.”
3.
Facts in brief:
3.1
The petitioner in pursuance of an advertisement dated
26.06.2006, issued by the Tripura University, went for a walk-in-interview for
appointment to the post of Junior Project Fellow [for short, JPF]. In terms of
the advertisement, this post was a temporary post in the DBT Collaborative
Project entitled “Hardening of Selected tissue cultured plants and their
demonstrations plantation in Tripura” for a period of one and half years or
till the end of the Project whichever is earlier. The petitioner was selected for
the post of JPF. While the petitioner was discharging his duty as JPF under
Tripura University a Memorandum of Understanding [for short, MOU] was
made in between the Tripura University and the TSCST and in terms of SubClause (v) of Clause 9.0, one Project Fellow was to be transferred to TSCST
at the end of first year and in terms of Sub-Clause (viii) of Clause 10.0,
TSCST would have the liability to pay remuneration of such Project Fellow
during the project tenure. In terms of the MOU, the petitioner under order
dated 15th July, 2006 [Annexure-4, page 9 of the writ petition] was deputed to
TSCST and he was directed to render service in Hardening of Selected tissue
cultured plants and their demonstrations plantation in beneficiary houses as
Junior Project Fellow. On 01.12.2012, the competent authority of TSCST in
consultation with other officials had taken a policy decision under “Note-.4”
[Annexure 5, page 12 of the writ petition], which reads as under:
“Out of 15 project personnel, in the year 2007 we could
regularize 12 in the post of Scientist/Engineer-B (ref. Para 5 of Note-1).
At that time we could not regularize following 3 as there was shortage of
posts for regularization:
i.
Smt. Arpita Roy, JRF
ii.
Dr. Barnali Dey, Research Associate
iii.
Shri Sanjay Sen, Project Field Assistant
Subsequently, Smt. Arpita Roy has got offer of appointment in
the post of Agriculture officer in the Deptt. of Agriculture, Govt. of
Tripura and Dr. Barnali Dey got offer of appointment in the post of Asst.
Professor in the Directorate of Higher Education, Govt. of Tripura and
they have resigned from TSCST.
At present we have only Shri Sanjay Sen who is rendering
service in our council in consolidated honorarium of Rs.5,000/- per
month + HRA Rs.600/- with EPF coverage.
Now, we may consider to pay his salary against one of the
vacant posts (due to promotion) of Project Officers (carrying Pay Band-4,
Pay Band Scale Rs.13,575/- to 37,000/- with GP-3,700) which is UR.
In that case, the said post may be kept in abeyance and
against the said post Shri Sen be engaged on fixed pay of Rs.8,000/- per
month.”
3.2
It was decided in the said Note that the pay and salary of the
petitioner against one of the vacant posts (due to promotion) of Project Officer
would be considered and he would be engaged against the said post on fixed
pay of Rs.8000/- per month. Accordingly, vide Memorandum dated 15th
December, 2012 [Annexure-6, page 27 of the writ petition] the petitioner was
engaged as Project Officer on fixed pay basis of Rs.8,000/- per month keeping
in abeyance a vacant UR post of Project Officer (carrying Pay Band-4, Pay
Band Scale Rs.13,575/- to 37,000/- with GP-3,700). The petitioner had
complied with all the terms and conditions mentioned in the said
Memorandum dated December 15, 2012(supra). The petitioner had reported
his joining and it was accepted under Memorandum dated 02.01.2013
[Annexure-7, page 29 of the writ petition].The petitioner has brought on
record the Recruitment Rules of Project Officer [Annexure-9, page 33 of the
writ petition]. Under the said Recruitment Rules, the petitioner has possessed
all the essential qualifications to get appointed in the post of Project Officer.
The scale of pay for the post of Project Oficer has been mentioned as Pay
Band-4, Pay Band Scale Rs.13,575-37,000/- with Grade Pay of Rs.3700/-.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner:
4.1
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner has submitted that the petitioner was appointed under the Tripura
University following the normal rules of employment as enshrined under
Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
4.2
There is no quarrel that the appointment of the petitioner was
made under a Project. However, this Project is still continuing. While the
petitioner had been discharging his duties and responsibilities under Tripura
University, a MOU was thereby arrived at between the Tripura University and
TSCST pointing out that after completion of one year of service, the Project
Personnel would be transferred to TSCST on deputation and their
remunerations would be paid by TSCST. Accordingly, the petitioner after
completion of one year of service under Tripura University was deputed to
TSCST on transfer as JPF. In the year 2012, TSCST authorities had decided to
appoint the petitioner as Project Officer since he was working as Project
Officer which was a sanctioned post under the TSCST as would be evident
from the Recruitment Rules that there are two posts of Project Officers.
According to the said policy decision, the TSCST authority had appointed him
as Project Officer and accepted his joining under Memorandum dated
02.01.2013 [Annexure-7(supra)] on fixed pay of Rs.8,000/- per month. Mr.
Bhowmik, learned counsel has strongly emphasized that since the petitioner
has been working as Project Officer for more than a decade, the TSCST
authorities are under obligation to regularize his service with regular pay
scales since he was working against a sanctioned post and further, the
petitioner has possessed all the essential qualifications to hold the same post.
5.
Submissions on behalf of TSCST:
5.1
To confront with the submissions of Mr. Bhowmik, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner, learned senior counsel Mr. Bhattacharya,
appearing for the TSCST has submitted that when the petitioner was entered
into service as Project Officer, there was no sanctioned post of Project Officer
under TSCST. There was no financial concurrence. More so, the post is
temporary.
5.2
Relying upon the averments made in the counter affidavit,
learned senior counsel has submitted that since there is no regular post having
financial concurrence of the Government of Tripura, the claim of
regularization of the petitioner cannot be acceded to.
5.3
To support his submission, learned senior counsel has placed
reliance upon a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Civil
Appeal No.1951 of 2022, titled as The State of Gujarat & Ors. Vrs. R. J
Pathan & Ors.,decided on 24.03.2022.
6.
Discussions and decisions:
6.1
Indubitably, the petitioner was first appointed under Tripura
University through regular recruitment process as JPF. In terms of a MOU, the
petitioner was transferred on deputation to TSCST and in pursuance of a
policy decision taken by the competent authorities of TSCST, the petitioner
was appointed as Project Officer on fixed pay basis of Rs.8000/- per month
with a stipulation that after 5 (five) years he would be provided with regular
pay scale applicable for the post of Project Officer. The petitioner reported his
joining and it was accepted by the authority concerned w.e.f. 18.12.2012.
Admittedly, since then, the petitioner has been discharging his duties and
responsibilities as Project Officer under the TSCST. I have taken note of the
submission of learned senior counsel, Mr. Bhattacharya that this post of
Project Officer is not a sanctioned post. That gives me to peruse the Memo.
dated 4th April,2007 [Annexure-X, page 79 of the counter affidavit] and on
reading of the same, it transpires that the Government of Tripura had approved
the creation of post for the Department and Bodies concurred by the Finance
Department as indicated under Annexure-I and Annexure-II enclosed to the
said Memorandum. Under Annexure-II at Sl. No.25 of the said memorandum,
it comes to fore that the Government of Tripura has sanctioned two posts of
Project Officers/Scientific (TSCST) in the pay scale of Rs.7,800-15,100/-.
From the Memorandum dated 26.04.2023 [Annexure-Y, page 84 of the counter
affidavit] it is revealed that the Government of Tripura has approved towards
continuation of one post of Project Officer with Pay Band-4 in the scale of pay
of Rs.15,600-39,100/-, with G.P. of Rs.5,400/- as per ROP, 2017. It is further
clear that on inspection of roster Recruitment Rules for the post of Project
Officer, provisions have been made for two posts of Project Officer under the
said Recruitment Rules [Annexure-9, page 33 of the writ petition]. So, there
cannot be any quarrel that the post of Project Officer is a sanctioned post
having financial concurrence by the appropriate authority.
6.2
In view of this, I cannot agree with the submissions of Mr.
Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel appearing for the Respondents-TSCST
that the post of Project Officer has no financial concurrence and it was not
sanctioned by the Government of Tripura and accordingly, it is repelled.
6.3
I have taken into consideration the decision rendered in R.J.
Pathan (supra). The facts of the case is that the petitioners were claiming
regularization against the posts they were working under a Project which was
known as “Project Implementation Unit” and the Division Bench of the
concerned High Court had directed the Government to create supernumerary
post for regularization of their services, which the Hon’ble Supreme Court had
interfered with. So, the facts of the present case are wholly different from the
facts of R.J. Pathan (supra).
7.
Conclusion:
7.1
Admittedly, the petitioner has been serving as Project Officer for
more than 10 (ten) years. Further, it is evident that the post of Project Officer
is a sanctioned post having financial concurrence. The petitioner has
possessed essential qualification as prescribed under the Recruitment Rules.
As such, the TSCST, i.e. the present employer of the petitioner is under
obligation to consider the regularization and absorption of the petitioner to the
said post of Project Officer. In the instant case, the posting and continuation of
the petitioner as Project Officer under the respondent-TSCST is neither
irregular nor illegal, rather, the appointment of the petitioner as Project Officer
under the TSCST is in accordance with MOU entered into between Tripura
University and TSCST under Sub-Clause (v) of Clause 9.0 as stated (supra).
The Respondents-TSCST are also liable to pay the pay scale prescribed for the
post of Project Officer towards the petitioner as it appears in the Memorandum
dated 26.04.2023 [Annexure-Y supra] i.e. in the Pay Band-4, Pay Scale of
Rs.15,600-39,100/-, G.P. of Rs.5,400/- as per ROP,2017.
7.2
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, I direct the
Respondents-TSCST to complete the process of regularization and absorption
of the petitioner to the post of Project Officer within a period of 3(three)
months from the date of this judgment and till such process is completed, they
are directed to release minimum pay in the regular pay scale to the petitioner
as prescribed for the post of Project Officer from the month of August, 2023,
which is payable in the month of September,2023.
With the aforesaid directions and observations, the instant writ
petition stands allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
SAIKAT KAR
sanjay
Date: 2024.05.06 13:43:37 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review