The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. 02.2020 (Annexure-7) on the ground that he has produced fake mark- sheets of M.Sc. Zoology and B.Ed. from Bundenlkhand University. The decision to cancel his appointment was made during the verification exercise from the Bundelkhand University on the basis of a letter dated 07.01.2020 issued by the said university. Meanwhile, petitioner was also prosecuted for the offences punishable under Sections 468 and 471 of IPC in PRC(WP) No.96 of 2020 where he has finally been acquitted of the charges by the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class (Court No.3), Udaipur, Gomati Tripura vide judgment dated 17.08.2022 as the prosecution had not been able to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt. Thereafter, the petitioner has approached the competent authority/respondent No.3 to issue fresh offer of appointment. However, when his representation remained unheeded, he has approached this Court for appropriate direction upon the respondents to issue fresh appointment letter to the post of Graduate Teacher after quashing of the cancellation of his appointment vide memo dated 15.02.2020 (Annexure-7). [3] Counter-affidavit has been filed by the respondents No.1 to 4 sworn by the Under Secretary, Government of Tripura, under Secondary Education Department. The facts leading to cancellation of the appointment of the petitioner on the basis of the letter of the Bundenlkhand University dat…
07. 01.2020 (Annexure-R/1 supra) and 08.04.2022 (Annexure-12 of writ petition). In the communication dated 07.01.2020, the Examination Controller, Bundelkhand University, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh described the mark sheets of the Master of Science (M.Sc) in Zoology and Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) of the petitioner as „FAKE‟ but in the communication dated 08.04.2022 the same mark sheets were described as genuine which was obtained by the petitioner as a reply under RTI Act, 2005. Now it is the concerned university (respondent No.3) that conferred the degrees of Master of Science (M.Sc) in Zoology and Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) to the petitioner to clarify whether the degrees are genuine or not. In view of the above, the Controller of Examinations, Bundelkhand University, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh has been communicated vide letter dated 24.01.2023. A copy of the letter dated 24.01.2023 is annexed and marked as Annexure-R/3. If the genuineness of the mark sheets of the Master of Science (M.Sc) in Zoology and the Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) of the petitioner is established beyond doubt, the State respondents will have no counterargument to cancel the Memo dated 15.02.2020 (Annexure-7 of writ petition) and issue posting order. Otherwise, the petitioner has no right to claim to consider him for appointment to the post of Graduate Teacher and in that case, the State-respondents deny and dispu…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.1079 of 2022
Sri Sanjoy Das, son of late Suresh Chandra Das, resident of Madhyapara, P.O.
& P.S- R.K. Pur, District- Gomati Tripura.
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura represented by the Secretary, Directorate of Secondary
Education, Education(School) Department, Siksha Bhawan, Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura.
2. The Secretary, Directorate of Secondary Education, Education (School)
Department, Siksha Bhawan, Agartala, District- West Tripura.
3. The Director of Secondary Education, Education (School) Department,
Siksha Bhawan, Agartala, District- West Tripura.
4. Teachers Recruitment Board, Tripura, represented by its Member Secretary,
Government of Tripura Education (School) Department, Siksha Bhawan,
Agartala District- West Tripura.
5. Bundelkhand University, represented by its Registrar Kanpur, Jhansi, Uttar
Pradesh, Pin-284128.
......Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment : 19th May, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
[2]
Petitioner‟s appointment to the post of Graduate Teacher on
04.11.2019 (Annexure-5) after a proper recruitment test was cancelled on
15.02.2020 (Annexure-7) on the ground that he has produced fake mark-
sheets of M.Sc. Zoology and B.Ed. from Bundenlkhand University. The
decision to cancel his appointment was made during the verification exercise
from the Bundelkhand University on the basis of a letter dated 07.01.2020
issued by the said university. Meanwhile, petitioner was also prosecuted for
the offences punishable under Sections 468 and 471 of IPC in PRC(WP)
No.96 of 2020 where he has finally been acquitted of the charges by the
Court of learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class (Court No.3), Udaipur, Gomati
Tripura vide judgment dated 17.08.2022 as the prosecution had not been
able to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt. Thereafter, the petitioner
has approached the competent authority/respondent No.3 to issue fresh offer
of appointment. However, when his representation remained unheeded, he
has approached this Court for appropriate direction upon the respondents to
issue fresh appointment letter to the post of Graduate Teacher after quashing
of the cancellation of his appointment vide memo dated 15.02.2020
(Annexure-7).
[3]
Counter-affidavit has been filed by the respondents No.1 to 4
sworn by the Under Secretary, Government of Tripura, under Secondary
Education Department. The facts leading to cancellation of the appointment
of the petitioner on the basis of the letter of the Bundenlkhand University
dated 07.01.2020 during course of verification has been reiterated to defend
their action. However, at paragraph 12, the following statement has also
been made :
“That, in regard to the statements made in paragraph 6 of the writ petition, it
is stated that in the judgment dated 17.08.2022 passed in PRC(WP) 96 of
2020 by the Ld. Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura
opined in paragraph No.18 that “the foregoing analysis and discussion leads
to inevitable conclusion that prosecution has miserably failed to prove its
case beyond reasonable doubts and the accused from the liability of the
case.
And the learned court was pleased to acquitted the petitioner of the offence
punishable under Section 468/471 of IPC and the petitioner was set at
liberty. The acquittal from the criminal charge does not establish the
genuineness of the mark sheets which were described as „FAKE‟ by the
university concerned vide letter dated 07.01.2020 (Annexure-R/1 supra).
It is submitted that the representation of the petitioner was recived by
respondent No.3. The decision regarding the representation cannot be taken
as the Examination Controller, Bundelkhand University, Jhansi, Uttar
Pradesh has given different opinions in two different communications dated
07.01.2020 (Annexure-R/1 supra) and 08.04.2022 (Annexure-12 of writ
petition). In the communication dated 07.01.2020, the Examination
Controller, Bundelkhand University, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh described the
mark sheets of the Master of Science (M.Sc) in Zoology and Bachelor of
Education (B.Ed) of the petitioner as „FAKE‟ but in the communication
dated 08.04.2022 the same mark sheets were described as genuine which
was obtained by the petitioner as a reply under RTI Act, 2005. Now it is the
concerned university (respondent No.3) that conferred the degrees of Master
of Science (M.Sc) in Zoology and Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) to the
petitioner to clarify whether the degrees are genuine or not. In view of the
above, the Controller of Examinations, Bundelkhand University, Jhansi,
Uttar Pradesh has been communicated vide letter dated 24.01.2023. A copy
of the letter dated 24.01.2023 is annexed and marked as Annexure-R/3.
If the genuineness of the mark sheets of the Master of Science (M.Sc) in
Zoology and the Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) of the petitioner is
established beyond doubt, the State respondents will have no counterargument to cancel the Memo dated 15.02.2020 (Annexure-7 of writ
petition) and issue posting order. Otherwise, the petitioner has no right to
claim to consider him for appointment to the post of Graduate Teacher and
in that case, the State-respondents deny and dispute the claim of the
petitioner.”
Respondent No.5, Budenlkhand University has not entered
appearance despite service of notice.
[4]
In these circumstances, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the claim of the petitioner for reinstatement or fresh
appointment after being acquitted for the same charges is not being
considered by the competent authority/respondent No.3. Even the
respondents admit that in the subsequent communication dated 08.04.2022
which was obtained by the petitioner under RTI Act, 2005 the mark-sheets
have been shown as genuine. The text of the letter dated 08.04.2022
(Annexure-12) is extracted hereunder :
“To
SANJOY DAS S/O LT. SURESH CHANDRA DAS
MADHYAPARA, PO + PS- RK PUR
UDAIPUR DIST. GOMATI 799120
Subject :- Verification of Certificate & Mark Sheet.
D/Sir,
With reference to your RTI request Id : R6_9_1_2100660 & R6_9_1_21_00661
dated 17-12-2021 on the subject cited above. The verification of documents for
SANJOY DAS, S/O SURESH CHANDRA DAS of M.Sc. bearing enrollment
no.11/MSC/68574 roll no.8035575726 and B.Ed. bearing enrollment
no.14/BED/71457 roll no.103141660101 is found in the record on the
confidential ledger of the university.
The candidate had appeared in the examination from the Bundelkhand University
Campus, Jhansi and had cleared the examination with First division.
Yours faithfully
S/d
Assistant Registrar
Bundelkhand University
Jhansi.”
Therefore, petitioner has a valid claim for reinstatement or fresh
appointment to the post of Graduate Teacher.
[5]
Learned counsel for the respondent-State has relied upon the
contents of the counter-affidavit and defended the action. He has also
referred to the conditions of appointment letter contained at (Annexure-5)
dated 04.11.2019 which specifically stipulated at Clause-5 that if any
declaration given or information furnished by the candidate proves to be
false or if the candidate is found to have willfully suppressed any material
information, he/she will be liable to remove from service and such other
action as the Government may deem necessary. He submits that since the
foundation of the appointment of the petitioner was vitiated on grounds of
fraud, the impugned action of cancellation of his appointment is not illegal
or arbitrary. In such a case, no departmental inquiry was required to be
conducted. Therefore, the writ petition may be dismissed.
[6]
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the material facts and pleadings placed from the
record. Two things emerge out after the chronology of facts and events
narrated hereinabove. (i) That, on the one hand, the same respondent No.5
through letter dated 07.01.2020 had during course of verification exercise
given its remark that the M.Sc. Zoology certificate and B.Ed. certificate of
the petitioner is fake; (ii) the other communication issued in favour of the
petitioner by the same university at (Annexure-12) states that on verification
of the documents of the petitioner bearing enrollment no.11/MSC/68574,
roll no.8035575726 and B.Ed. bearing enrollment no.14/B.Ed./71457, roll
No.103141660101, it has been found from the confidential ledger of the
university that the candidate had appeared in the examination from the
Bundelkhand University Campus, Jhansi and had cleared the examination
with first division. The roll numbers indicated at Annexure-R/1 vide letter
dated 07.01.2020 issued by the Exam Controller of Bundelkhand University,
Jhansi and confidential letter dated 08.04.2022 issued by the Assistant
Registrar, Bundelkhand University, Jhansi (Annexure-12) are one and same
as regards the M.Sc. Zoology course and B.Ed. course. On the other hand,
petitioner has been acquitted of the charges having indulged in seeking
appointment on the basis of forged document under Sections 468 and 471 of
IPC by the learned Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate 1 st Class Udaipur,
Gomati, Tripura vide judgment dated 17.08.2022 (Annexure-8) of course by
giving him the benefit of doubt as the prosecution had failed to prove the
charges beyond reasonable doubt.
[7]
In such circumstances, this Court is of the view that the
respondents should take a fresh decision on the representation of the
petitioner, in accordance with law, if necessary after making an inquiry from
the concerned Bundelkhand University by deputing an officer duly
authorized for that purpose so that the controversy is finally settled.
[8]
As such, the writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the
competent authority/respondent No.3 to take a decision on the claim of the
petitioner for reinstatement/fresh appointment, in accordance with law.
Petitioner shall submit a fresh representation duly supported with all facts
and documents in support of his claim within a period of 2(two) weeks
before the competent authority/respondent No.3. Let such decision be taken
within a period of 16(sixteen) weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this
order along with the representation. Let it be made clear that this Court has
not made any comments on merits of the case so far as the genuineness of
the certificates are concerned.
[9]
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Dipesh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review