Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.55/2023
Sri Sanjit Reang, son of Late Khachandra Reang, resident of Kalma, POMuhuripur, PS-Baikhora, Sub-Division-Belonia, District-South Tripura, PIN799142, aged about 50 years.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary, Rural
Development Department, Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West
Tripura, PIN-799006.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary, Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, POKunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
3. The Chief Engineer, Rural Development Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New
Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
4. Tripura Public Service Commission, represented by its Secretary, having his
office at TPSC Bhawan, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, Sub-DivisionAgartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
5. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, having his office at
TPSC Bhawan, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, Sub-Division-Agartala,
District- West Tripura, PIN-799001.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 15th February, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P.
Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr.
Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate appearing for the State
respondents No.1 to 3 and Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents No.4 & 5/TPSC.
2.
Petitioner is a Degree holder in Engineering. He was initially
appointed as a Junior Engineer (Degree) in Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura vide order dated 30.05.2003 (Annexure-1). He was
then promoted as Assistant Engineer on 04.08.2012 (Annexure-2). In the
present writ petition, petitioner has questioned the amendment to Recruitment
Rules, 2015 framed under Proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India
vide Notification dated 25.06.2015 to the extent as contained in Clause-11(c)
which prescribes passing of an additional paper of Law & Arbitration for
Degree holder Assistant Engineers for being eligible for promotion to the post
of Executive Engineer against the 70% of the post of Executive Engineer
earmarked for the Degree holder Assistant Engineer category coupled with an
experience of 7 years of continuous and regular service in the grade of
Assistant Engineer. The relevant Rule is quoted hereunder:
Recruitment Rules for the post of Executive Engineer under the Rural Development
Department, Government of Tripura.
Name of Post(s):-
Executive Engineer
Number of Post(s):-
Classification:-
14(fourteen) nos. plus additional post(s) as and
when created.
Group-A, Gazetted. (equivalent to TES Grade-III)
Scale of Pay:-
Method of recruitment whether
by direct recruitment or by
promotion or by deputation/
transfer and percentage of the
vacancies to be filled up by
various methods.
Age
limit
for
Direct
Recruitment
Rs.13,575.00-Rs.37,000.00 (PB-4), Grade PayRs.5000.00 plus other allowances per month
subject to revision by the Government from time to
time.
100% by promotion failing which by transfer on
deputation.
Not applicable.
Educational
and
other
qualifications required for
direct recruitment
Whether age and educational
qualifications prescribed for
direct recruits will apply in the
case of promotees.
Period of Probation, if any:-
Not applicable
Whether Selection post or Non
Selection Post
In case of recruitment by
Promotion/deputation/transfer
grades from which promotion/
deputation/transfer is to be
made.
Selection
Not applicable
1(one) year
Promotion:a) 70% of the posts of Executive Engineer shall be
filled by the Degree holder Assistant Engineer
(Civil/Mechanical/Electrical) having 7(seven) years
continuous and regular service experience in the
grade of Assistant Engineer.
b) 30% of the posts of Executive Engineer shall be
filled by the Diploma holder Assistant Engineer
(Civil/Mechanical/Electrical) having 7(seven) years
continuous and regular service experience in the
grade of Assistant Engineer.
c) Degree holder Assistant Engineer should have to
pass departmental examination on i) Accounts
Paper, ii) Simple Rules Paper & iii) Law &
arbitration Paper, subject to revision by the
Government from time to time.
d) Diploma holder Assistant Engineer should have
to pass Departmental examination on i) Accounts
paper & ii) Simple rules paper subject to revision
by the Government from time to time.
e) Engineering officers who have attained the age
of 55 (fifty five) years and above are exempted
from passing departmental examinations.
Seniority of Degree holder Engineers and Diploma
holder Engineers shall be maintained separately and
not to be clubbed together.
Transfer on Deputation:From the officers holding analogous posts in other
Department under State Government.
If a DPC exists, what is its
Composition
Circumstances
in
which
T.P.S.C. is to be consulted in
making recruitment:-
Group "A", DPC
As required under Tripura Public Service
Commission (Exemption from consultation)
Regulation, 1973.
Clause-11(b) of the schedule provides 30% of the posts of
Executive Engineer to be filled by the Diploma holder Assistant Engineer
(Civil/Mechanical/Electrical) with 7 years of continuous and regular service
experience in the grade of Assistant Engineer who are required to pass only
two papers, i.e. i) Accounts Paper & ii) Simple Rules Paper.
3.
Be it also indicated herein that for the next higher post of
Superintending Engineer, the Recruitment Rules, 2015 also provide for
eligibility criteria at Clause-11 of the Schedule in the Notification dated
25.06.2015. The post of Superintending Engineer is to be filled up 100% by
promotion failing which by transfer on deputation. The eligibility criteria at
Clause-11 of the Schedule indicates that for being promoted to the post of
Superintending Engineer, a candidate should have 7(seven) years continuous
and regular service in the grade and should at least have a degree in Civil
Engineering from a recognized University or its equivalent academic
qualification. Clause-11(ii) also prescribes passing of three papers in which one
of them is Law & Arbitration paper. However, in both the schedules, one
relating to promotion to the post of Executive Engineer and the other relating to
promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer, the relevant Clause-11(e)
and 11(iii) provide that Engineering officers who have attained the age of 55
years would be exempted from passing the departmental examinations.
Evidently Diploma holders are not eligible for promotion to the post of
Superintending Engineer and higher posts. The question arises whether a
passing of an additional paper of Law and Arbitration for the Degree holder for
being promoted to Executive Engineer is a valid classification or not having
rational nexus with the objects sought to be achieved?
4.
On behalf of the petitioner, Mr. Somik Deb, learned Sr. Counsel
assisted by Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel, has submitted that laying
down of a higher qualification can be a basis for reasonable classification but
laying down of a condition to pass an additional paper of Law and Arbitration
for the Degree holder Assistant Engineer is unreasonable and has no rational
nexus with the objects sought to be achieved. Diploma holders and Degree
holders Assistant Engineer form part of the common cadre of Assistant
Engineer and eligible for being promoted to Executive Engineer cannot be
segregated by laying down a requirement of passing an additional paper of Law
and Arbitration only for the purposes of promotion for the Degree holders
Assistant Engineers. This would be adding an onerous eligibility criteria to a
cadre of Assistant Engineers who already have a higher qualification. It is
further submitted that after the amendment to the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 2015 an official of the department or an Engineer who is a party to an
Arbitration Proceeding cannot act as an independent arbitrator. Therefore, there
is no valid justification to include such a paper in the promotional exercise to
the post of Executive Engineer.
5.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon
the following judgments:
(a)
Food Corporation of India and others vrs. Om Prakash
Sharma and others reported in (1998) 7 SCC 676 [Para-22];
(b)
T.R. Kothandaraman and others vrs. Tamil Nadu Water
Supply & Drainage BD and others reported in (1994) 6 SCC 282 [Para-2, 5, 6,
8, 16-18, 21-24 and 26];
(c)
State of Punjab and others vrs. Senior Vocational Staff
Masters Association and others reported in (2017) 9 SCC 379; and
(d)
State of Uttarakhand and others vrs. S.K. Singh and
others reported in (2019) 10 SCC 49 [Para-18-31].
6.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the relevant
clause 11(c) laying down an additional requirement of passing of Law and
Arbitration paper should, therefore, be held to be discriminatory as an
impermissible classification amongst incumbents to the common cadre of
Assistant Engineers for the purposes of promotion to the post of Executive
Engineer.
7.
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State, submits that the relevant clause 11(c) of
the amended Recruitment Rules, 2015 prescribes passing of an additional paper
of Law and Arbitration for being considered for promotion to the post of
Executive Engineer which is a reasonable classification between both the
Degree holder and Diploma holder Assistant Engineers depending upon their
educational qualifications and also for the reason that Degree holder Assistant
Engineers are only eligible for being promoted from the post of Executive
Engineer to the higher post of Superintending Engineer and above. In view of
the wide application of the Arbitral Law in Engineering departments, the
Government has thought it proper to prescribe an additional paper for Degree
holder Engineers who are eligible for holding higher post of Superintending
Engineer and have to deal with matters relating to arbitration in their service
career. The rule making authority has the wisdom to prescribe service
conditions as administrative exigencies may need or necessitate. It is open for
the State to prescribe qualifications and other conditions of service including
avenues of promotion criteria to be fulfilled for such promotions. They
pertained to the field of policy and are within the exclusive discretion and
jurisdiction of the State subject to of course the limitations or restrictions
envisaged in the Constitution of India. The wisdom of rule making authority is
not open to question. If the classification is based upon valid objects sought to
be achieved which in the present case is to equip the Degree holder Assistant
Engineers to deal with higher responsibilities of matters relating to Arbitration
proceedings during their service career, the laying down of an additional
criteria of passing Law and Arbitration paper for them as compared to Diploma
holders is neither arbitrary nor discriminatory.
8.
Learned counsel for the State has relied upon the following
decisions:
(a)
P.U.
Joshi
and
others
vrs.
Accountant
General,
Ahmedabad and others reported in AIR 2003 SC 2156 [Para-10-13];
(b)
Chandigarh Administration through the Director, Public
Instructions (Colleges), Chandigarh vrs. Usha Kheterpal Waie and others
reported in AIR 2011 SC 2956 [Para-12].
He submits that, therefore, the challenge should fail.
Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel for the TPSC, has also adopted
the arguments made by learned counsel for the State.
9.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties at some length and also examined the relevant Rule brought into force
by the Recruitment Rules, 2015 notified on 25.06.2015. The entire challenge of
the writ petitioner to the relevant clause 11(c) of the Schedule to the
Recruitment Rules, 2015 is based upon the argument of unreasonable
classification and that it does not meet the tenets of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. I have gone through the judgments cited on behalf of the
petitioner. The issue has been examined in several decisions of the Apex Court.
It has been held that though equality is the very bulwark of the provisions of
the Constitution, in service jurisprudence, classifications are a matter of
necessity. Judicial pronouncements have sought to balance the equality
principle with the principle of classification, dependent upon the nexus for
making the classification. Higher educational qualifications have been
repeatedly emphasized as an aspect which can give exclusive promotion,
earlier promotion or for that matter, an accelerated promotion. A higher degree
of qualification intrinsically would bring in certain skills, though undoubtedly,
that should be useful and have a nexus with the job being performed. As to
who should examine this nexus, it has been left to the wisdom of the
administrative authorities, who are best equipped to do so. Where persons
having two different qualifications are given the opportunity of promotion,
there cannot be an absolute equality for the reason that the administration may
consider giving the lesser qualified an opportunity of promotion on different
terms, rather than completely prohibiting them from promotion.
10.
The Apex Court for that matter in the case of State of Jammu &
Kashmir vrs. Triloki Nath Khosa [(1974) 1 SCC 19] has also emphasized that
minute and microscopic classification should not be permitted on microdistinctions. It has also been held that even where direct recruits and promotees
are integrated into a common class, they could for the purpose of promotion to
the higher cadre, be classified on the basis of educational qualification. The
conclusion, thus, was that if the diploma holders can be barred altogether from
promotion, it was difficult to appreciate how and why the rule-making
authority can be precluded from restricting the promotion. The rule-making
authority may be of the opinion, having regard to the efficiency of the
administration and other relevant circumstances that while it is not necessary to
bar the diploma holders from promotion altogether, their chances of promotion
should be restricted. Between direct recruits and promotees, preferential
treatment based on educational qualification was held as valid for considering
promotion. However, among equally qualified candidates, there could be no
further classification. It is for the State to decide whether the qualification has a
reasonable relation to the nature of duties and responsibilities of the
promotional post. Similarly, the question whether the difference in educational
qualification is sufficient to give preferential treatment to one class of
candidates against another, is ordinarily left to the executive authorities to
decide as they have expertise in administrative matters. Ordinarily it would not
be proper for the Court to sit in appeal over their decisions, unless it is
something totally arbitrary or shocking.
11.
In the present case, the promotion rules, in fact, provide that 70%
of the posts of the Executive Engineer shall be filled up by the Degree holder
Assistant Engineer having 7(seven) years continuous and regular service in the
grade of Assistant Engineer whereas only 30% of the posts of Executive
Engineer has been earmarked for promotion from Diploma holder Assistant
Engineer with similar 7 years experience. The only distinction between the two
categories is that while Degree holder Assistant Engineers have to pass an
additional paper of Law and Arbitration both the Degree holder and Diploma
holder Assistant Engineers have also to pass two common papers, i.e. Accounts
Paper and Simple Rules Paper. The contention of the petitioner is that despite
having a higher qualification of Degree holder, he has been put to more
onerous conditions for being promoted to the post of Executive Engineer
compared to Diploma holder Engineers which does not have a valid basis for
classification. However, it is also evident from a reading of the relevant
schedule for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer and to that of the
Superintending Engineer that it is only the class of Degree holder Assistant
Engineers who become entitled for promotion not only to the post of Executive
Engineer but to the post of Superintending Engineer and above post. The
Diploma holder Assistant Engineers are only eligible for being promoted to the
post of Executive Engineer and no further. The rule making authority has, in
fact, provided for 70% of the post of Executive Engineer to be filled up from
that of the Degree holder Assistant Engineers and restricted the quota of
promotion of Diploma holder Assistant Engineers to only 30% of the post of
Executive Engineer. In that way, Degree holder Assistant Engineers do get a
higher chance of being promoted to the post of Executive Engineer against a
higher quota of the post of Executive Engineers.
12.
The respondent-State has sought to justify the relevant condition
in Clause-11(c) on the ground that it is only the Degree holder Assistant
Engineers who are entitled to be considered for promotion to the Executive
Engineer post and higher post, i.e. Superintending Engineer and above. The
schedule to the Amended Rules relating to promotion to the post of
Superintending Engineer again prescribes passing of three papers by the
Degree holder Executive Engineers having 7 years of experience which
includes Law and Arbitration paper. Prescribing the requirement of a higher
qualification to hold a post in that way cannot be said to be an unreasonable
classification on the part of the rule making authority to be hit by the tenets of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India as being discriminatory in nature.
Whereas in most of the decided cases, laying down of a higher qualification
restricts the chances of promotion to a class of employees who have lesser
qualification, in the present case, the requirement of passing of an additional
paper of Law and Arbitration has been prescribed for a category of Engineers
who have a higher qualification of Degree compared to the Diploma holders.
The object of equipping them to deal with arbitration matters which
Engineering departments are increasingly being made to face on account of the
expansion of arbitration as an Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism and
that too, after coming into force of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996
and its amendment in the year 2015 can be said to be a rational object sought to
be achieved. A classification between the Degree holders and Diploma holders
on the basis of different educational qualification is permissible. The question
is whether the classification prescribing passing of an additional paper of Law
& Arbitration has a rational nexus with the objects sought to be achieved. The
nexus as observed hereinabove is easily discernible as Degree holder Executive
Engineers are only eligible for being promoted to higher post, such as
Superintending Engineer and above. The relevant rules of promotion to the
post of Superintending Engineer also prescribe passing of the additional paper
of Law and Arbitration for being eligible for such higher promotion. As such,
this Court is of the view that the classification between the Degree holder
Assistant Engineers and Diploma holder Assistant Engineers so far as the
passing of additional paper of Law and Arbitration is concerned is not an
unreasonable classification which is discriminatory in nature.
13.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has harped upon the
observations made at paragraph-22 in the case of Om Prakash Sharma and
others (supra) where it has been observed that different tests should not be
prescribed for determining the respective promotional opportunities and that
too solely with reference to the source from which they were drawn. Once a
cadre is formed by recruiting persons drawn from different departments of the
Government, there would normally be no justification for discriminating
between them by subjecting one class to more onerous terms in the matter of
promotional chances. However, it is also apposite to mention here that the
Apex Court at para 31 referred to the case of Rajasthan SEB Accountants
Association Vs. Rajasthan SEB, (1997) 3 SCC 103 and observed that
educational qualification is a proper basis of classification for promotion. Such
a classification with a view to achieve administrative efficiency cannot be said
to be on any fortuitous circumstance and unreasonable as has been held by the
Apex Court in the case of Triloki Nath Khosa (supra). The aforesaid rulings
show that validity of the classification has to be judged on the facts and
circumstances of each case.
14.
In the case of Om Prakash Sharma and others (supra), the
appellant Food Corporation of India had not been able to adduce any
material to show that the graduates deserved preferential treatment vis-à-vis
non-graduates in prescription of shorter length of service for graduates and
longer for non-graduates for being promoted to the post of Assistant Grade I
(AG-I) and Assistant Grade II (AG-II). As observed hereinbefore, the Apex
Court in the same case has also held that educational qualification is a proper
basis of classification for promotion. Even applying the principles laid down in
the case of Om Prakash Sharma and others (supra) to the present facts of the
case do not render laying down an additional criteria of passing Law and
Arbitration paper for incumbents holding the post of Assistant Engineer as
Degree holder as being discriminatory as they are only considered eligible and
entitled for promotion to higher post of Superintending Engineers and above
compared to those who form the class of Diploma holder Assistant Engineers.
15.
In the case of T.R. Kothandaraman and others (supra) also relied
on behalf of the petitioner, the Apex Court has once again held that
classification based on higher educational qualification is permissible
depending on the facts and circumstances of each case but total restriction
cannot be imposed so as to block the chances of promotion. While determining
the validity of classification historical background, efficiency in service, need
for higher education and social justice have to be kept in mind and a proper
balancing of the same had to be made in regard to the object of classification.
The difference in ratio between a promotional quota between Degree holders
and Diploma holders were not interfered with in the relevant Tamil Nadu
Agricultural Engineering Service Rules which were held reasonable and not
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. The above
decisions cited on behalf of the petitioner do only substantiate the underlying
proposition that prescribing an additional qualification or a higher qualification
for promotion and that too, amongst two different classes of incumbents to the
post of Assistant Engineers, i.e. Degree holder and Diploma holder in the
present case is not arbitrary or invalid on that score.
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon the
decision of the Apex Court in the case of Senior Vocational Staff Masters
Association and others (supra) which, however, deals with prescription of pay
scale for incumbents forming the same cadre though having different
qualifications, i.e. Degree holders and Diploma holders brought into the cadre
through common process of selection pursuant to a common advertisement.
This decision, however, does not have any application to the facts of the
present case.
17.
Moreover, the last decision cited by the learned senior counsel for
the petitioner, i.e. in the case of S.K. Singh and others (supra) is apposite to be
referred to hereunder as they only add strength to the opinion expressed by this
Court in the foregoing paragraphs of the judgment. The Apex Court in the said
case had the occasion to examine whether accelerated promotion to the post of
Assistant Engineers to the extent of 7.33% for Degree holder Junior Engineers
with 3(three) years experience as against normal promotion requiring minimum
10 years of service was valid or not. It was held that even where direct recruits
and promotees are integrated into common class for purpose of promotion to
higher cadre, they can be classified on the basis of educational qualifications.
Further having regard to efficiency of administration rule-making authority
may not completely bar diploma holders from promotion but restrict their
chances as it has happened in the instant case where only 30% of the post of
Executive Engineers have been earmarked for promotion from Diploma holder
Assistant Engineers whereas 70% of the posts have been left for the Degree
holder Assistant Engineers to be promoted. The Apex Court after dealing with
the precedents on the subject from paragraphs-17 to 26 held as under:
"27. The spectrum of judicial opinions referred to aforesaid leaves us
with little doubt that though equality is the very bulwark of the provisions of
the Constitution, in service jurisprudence, classifications are a matter of
necessity and judicial pronouncements have sought to balance the equality
principle with the principle of classification, dependent on the nexus for
making the classification. Higher educational qualifications have been
repeatedly emphasised as an aspect which can give exclusive promotion,
earlier promotion or for that matter, as in this case, an accelerated promotion.
A higher degree of qualification intrinsically would bring in certain skills,
though undoubtedly, that should be useful and have a nexus with the job
being performed. As to who should examine this nexus, that has been left to
the wisdom of the administrative authorities, who are best equipped to do so
[M. Rathinaswami v. State of T.N., (2009) 5 SCC 625 : (2009) 2 SCC (L&S)
101] .
28. It has also been opined that even where persons having two
different qualifications are given the opportunity of promotion, there cannot
be an absolute equality for the reason that the administration may consider
giving the lesser qualified an opportunity of promotion on different terms,
rather than completely prohibiting them from promotion.
29. We are conscious of the fact that in further posts, higher than AE,
there is no distinction between persons having different qualifications. There
are no direct appointments. The posts are filled in only through promotions.
The question is: what is really being done? In our view, all that has been done
is that, at a particular promotion stage, in the wisdom of the administration,
recognising higher skills developed through higher qualifications, and as an
incentive to others to acquire these higher qualifications, an accelerated
promotion on a small percentage of posts had been granted.
30. We did put to the learned counsel for the private respondents if
they could have been shut out from promotion, or if the time periods could
have been different for promotion, then the result would have been the same
as their grievance today i.e. some of the degree-holders would rank higher
than the diploma-holders. Thus, this is not something out of the ordinary
which has happened, or would result in a situation which can be categorised
extraordinary by reason of accelerated promotion to the degree-holder.
31. We have noticed another important aspect i.e. that the direct
recruitment to the post of AE required a candidate to be a degree-holder. 50%
of the posts were reserved for degree-holding direct recruits. In the 50%
promotion quota, a 10% promotion quota was carved out, leaving only 40%
for promotion through the normal route. Possibly with the intention of
obviating any grievance which the promotees may have, the normal
promotion route was sought to be maintained at 50%, without any accelerated
promotion in that portion, by bringing in 10% from the direct recruitment
quota to the promotion quota, and that being utilised for accelerated
promotion, for promotees with a degree. Had this quota not been there at all,
whether earlier or later, but the direct recruitment in promotion quota had
been maintained in equal ratio, the diploma-holders could, in any case, have
had no grievance. The bringing forth from the direct recruitment quota (for
which the qualification is the degree) to the promotion quota and giving that
through accelerated promotion for such persons who have a degree can, thus,
hardly be said to have any intrinsic defects which could violate Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution.
32. The historical perspective also cited before us hardly supports the
private respondents as even the State of Uttar Pradesh, as it existed earlier,
and the Rules as they existed then, provided for such 7.33% quota, which was
never assailed by any party.
33. We may also add before ending, that there exist inconsistencies,
which we have pointed earlier in para 16, in the principles laid down in the
impugned judgment [S.K. Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, 2011 SCC OnLine
Utt 1417] in para 30.
34. We are, thus, unequivocally of the view that the impugned
judgment [S.K. Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, 2011 SCC OnLine Utt 1417]
cannot be sustained and the challenge to the Rule is misplaced. The
consequence would be the dismissal of the writ petition by the diplomaholders and the appeal of the Government being allowed. Parties are left to
bear their own costs."
18.
As held therein even where persons having two different
qualifications are given the opportunity of promotion, there cannot be an
absolute equality for the reason that the administration may consider giving the
lesser qualified an opportunity of promotion on different terms, rather than
completely prohibiting them from promotion. In the present case, the Assistant
Engineers from both Degree and Diploma holder category have been given
opportunity for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer but the quota of
Diploma holders have been restricted to 30% whereas those of Executive
Engineers have been enlarged to 70% which is a valid classification. The
petitioner belonging to the Degree holder class, therefore, cannot be allowed to
complain on the requirement of passing an additional paper of Law and
Arbitration for being promoted to the post of Executive Engineer when it is
also obvious that only Degree holder Engineers are eligible for promotion to
higher post of Superintending Engineer and above which require expertise in
dealing with arbitration matters. Though the concerned Engineer may not act as
an arbitrator, as may be impermissible in an arbitration proceeding relating to
the department in view of the amendment to the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 2015, but having such additional qualification of Law and Arbitration
paper would be justified for dealing with arbitration matters, at higher stages in
their career. This in the opinion of the Court is a valid reason for the rulemaking authority to lay down such an additional requirement for Degree holder
Assistant Engineers for being considered for promotion to higher post. It is also
true that non-passing of the departmental examinations completely does not
oust the chances of promotion to the higher post of Executive Engineer or
Superintending Engineer as the Schedule 11(e) and 11(iii) of the relevant Rules
provide that Engineers who have attained the age of 55 years and above are
exempted from passing departmental examinations.
19.
Therefore, in view of reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court
does not find any merit in the challenge. The writ petition is accordingly
dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
2024.02.22
PULAK BANIK Date:
17:11:09 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review