Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.632 of 2022
Sri Sanjit Debbarma,
S/O Late mansingh Debbarma
of- Ujain Abhoynagar P.O.- Agartala,
District- West Tripura
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Chief Secretary, Department of Home (Jail),
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, P.O.- Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2. Chief Secretary,
Home (Jail) Department, Government of Tripura, Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
3. Secretary,
Home(Jail) Department, Government of Tripura, Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura.
Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura
4. Commissioner of Departmental Enquiries,
Government of Tripura, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura.
5. Inspector General of Prisons
Government of Tripura, Prisons Directorate, Agartala, West Tripura,
P.O.- Dhaleswar.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment & Order
:
01/08/2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. S.
Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the imposition of penalty of withholding of 2(two) increments
without cumulative effect vide order dated 08.12.2021 (Annexture-L to the
writ petition), which was also upheld and affirmed by the appellate authority
under the order dated 12.05.2022 (Annexure-N to the writ petition).
2.1.
During the course of proceeding before the inquiring authority, the
prosecution, i.e., the department concerned had produced one witness, namely
Bhaskar Ghosh, who deposed as PW-2. The inquiring authority had formulated
the following three points for decision:“(1) Whether the Accused Officer, Sri Sanjit Debbarma, Jailor, while
posted at Kamalpur Sub-Jail had sent two convicted prisoners namely
Nripendra Debnath and Sanjit Debnath, to a rice mill at Fuljari Bazar,
in civil dresses, to carry 11 bags of his paddy crop for being milled into
rice, without any escort or prior permission from appropriate authority
thereby jeopardizing and causing breach of the security of the jail and
giving opportunity to the said prisoners to flee away from the jail
custody?
(2)
Whether, the AO, Sri Sanjit Debbarma had violated the
provisions of Rule 242 and 248 of the Bengal jail Code?
(3)
Whether, the AO, Sri Sanjit Debbarma, due to the above, has
failed to maintain absolute integrity and devotion to Govt. duty and
thereby violated the provisions of Rule 3(1) & Rule 3(2)(i) of the TCS
(Conduct) Rules, 1988?”
2.2.
Shortly stated, the petitioner while posted as Jailor at Kamalpur
Sub-Jail, was subjected to disciplinary proceeding on the following article of
charge:“STATEMENT OF ARTICLES OF CHARGE FRAMED AGAINST
SHRI SANJIT DEBBARMA, JAILOR, SABROOM SUB-JAIL, SOUTH
TRIPURA
Article-I
That the said Shri Sanjit Debbarma, Jailor, Sabroom Sub-Jail while
posted at Kamalpur Sub-Jail on 04th march, 2016, failed to maintain
integrity to duty. He sent two convicted prisoners namely Sri Nipendra
Debnath and Sri Sanjit Debnath in civil dresses in a rice mill at Fuljari
Bazar located alongside the Kamalpur-Ambassa road at distance of
about 800 meters from the Kamalpur Sub-Jail to Carry 11(eleven) bags
of his paddy crop to the mill for being milled into rice without any
escort or prior permission from appropriate authority. Thereby, Sri
Sanjit Debbarma, the then Jailor of Kamalpur Sub-Jail violated
provision of Rules 242 and 248 of Bengal Jail Code, Vol-I, Part-1 and
Rule 3(1) and 3(2)(i) of Tripura Civil Servies (Conduct) Rules, 1988.”
2.3.
On conclusion of recording of evidence, the inquiring authority
submitted his report dated 30.07.2019. While deciding the point no.1, the
inquiring authority in his findings stated that “however, the prosecution had
not exhibited any of these listed documents other than Sl. No.2, i.e. the
statement submitted by PW-2, as evidence, due to which the lack of both
documentary evidence and oral evidence through witness had failed to
establish the validity of the charge against the AO of sending the two convicted
prisoner on his personal work in plain/civil clothes outside the jail premises
without escort and prior permission of the authority. Hence, as the Presenting
Officer had failed to submit/produce neither documentary evidences nor oral
evidences in support of the charge of utilizing the services of the convicted
prisoners for personal works that too by jeopardizing the security of the prison
by the AO, Sri Sanjit Debbarma, as such the decision of Point No.1 is given in
the negative and goes in favour of the defence and against the prosecution.”
2.4.
While deciding point no.2, the inquiring authority found that the
charged officer was not aware of Rules 242 of the Bengal Jail Code (for short,
“BJC”). During his examination under Rule 14 (18) of CCS (CC&A) Rules,
1965, the Accused Officer (for short, “AO”) specifically denied the allegations
brought against him and stated that he was not aware of such incident.
However, the inquiring authority found him guilty of misconduct for ignorance
of Rule 242 of the Bengal Jail Code (herein-after referred to as “Jail Code).
2.5.
While deciding point no.3, the inquiring authority came to a
finding that the charged officer has failed to maintain absolute integrity and
devotion to government duty and thereby violated the provision of Rule 3(1)
and Rule 3(2)(i) of Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988, since point
no.2 has been established against the charged officer that he was ignorant of
Rules 242 of Jail Code.
2.6.
After receipt of the enquiry report, the disciplinary authority
communicated his finding to the petitioner vide memo dated 21.01.2020
(Annexure-D to the writ petition) wherein the disciplinary authority came to a
finding that he had disagreed with the findings of the inquiring authority that
the article of charge had partially been proved and held the charges been fully
proved. This correspondence dated 21.01.2020 issued by the Principal
Secretary, Home (Jail) Department, who is the disciplinary authority had been
challenged by the petitioner by way of filing of a writ petition which was
numbered as WP(C) No.742 of 2020 titled as Sri Sanjit Debbarma Vs. The
State of Tripura & Ors. While disposing of the said writ petition, a coordinate
Bench of this Court (Justice Akil Kureshi, the then C.J) vide order dated
08.01.2021 had disposed of the writ petition with the following observation
and directions:“This assertion of the disciplinary authority defies all logic.
To begin with he had to record his tentative reasons of disagreeing
with the findings of the inquiry officer and then gave a notice to
the petitioner to respond to the same. He instead, after making
above noted strange observations recorded that he has disagreed
with the finding of the inquiry officer. His disagreement is thus
final and not tentative. More importantly, it is based on no
evidence. No disciplinary proceedings can proceed on assumption
of examination of witnesses or of production of documents which
are not produced; and of more efficient functioning of the inquiry
officer to the satisfaction of the disciplinary authority.
The impugned communication dated 21.01.2020 is therefore
set aside. Let the disciplinary authority take a final decision on the
report of the inquiry officer as it stands. In the process, he shall
take into account the contention of the petitioner that there was no
evidence whatsoever which would even enable the inquiry officer
to hold the charge partly proved. This exercise shall be completed
within four months from today.
Petition disposed of accordingly.”
2.7.
Thereafter, the disciplinary authority, i.e., the Principal Secretary
Home (Jail) Department vide communication dated 06.03.2021 requested the
petitioner to submit representation in the manner as under:“Government of Tripura
Home (Jail) Department
No.F.X-501/IGP/2017/323
Dated, the 06th march, 2021
To
Sri Sanjit Debbarma, Jailor,
Kailashahar District Jail,
Unakoti Tripura.
Subject:- Sending of copy of the findings in connection with Case
No.169/InQ/CDI/JAIL/18.
Sir,
A charge Memorandum was drawn up against you vide No.F.X501/IGP/2016/950-51 dated 09/02/2017. Inquiring Authority was
appointed to inquire into the charges.
The Inquiring Authority submitted a report which is enclosed.
The inquiring Authority held the charges as “partly proved”.
The Discplinary Authority had disagreed with the findings of the
Inquiring Authority and held the charges as fully proved vide
communication dated 21st January, 2020.
However, in connection with Case No.W.P(C) No.742 of 2020
order dated 08.01.2021 the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura had issued
order that communication dated 21st January 2020 shall be deemed to
have been set aside and also directed the Disciplinary authority to take
final decision on the report of the Inquiring Officer as it stands.
In view of the above, you are requested to submit your views, if
any, on the findings of the Inquiring Authority, within 15 days from
receipt of this letter as per Rule 15(2) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
Yours Faithfully,
Enclo:As stated.
Sd/- illegible
(BARUN KUMAR SAHU, IAS)
Disciplinary authority
Principal Secretary
Home (Jail) Department”
In response to the said communication dated 06.03.2021, the
petitioner had submitted representation.
2.8.
In the above background facts, I have heard Ms. R. Purkayastha,
learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A.
assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.9.
Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that after consideration of the representation, the disciplinary authority imposed
punishment upon the petitioner by order dated 14.06.2021. Though, in the said
punishment order it was stated that the disciplinary authority had taken the
concurrence of Tripura Public Service Commission (for short, “TPSC”), but no
materials related to the advice of TPSC, which forced the petitioner to file
another writ petition which was numbered as WP(C) No.457 of 2021 titled as
Sri Sanjit Debbarma Vs. The State of Tripura & Ors. A coordinate Bench of
this Court disposed of the writ petition vide order dated 10.09.2021 in the
following manner as under:“Petitioner has challenged an order dated 14.06.2021 by which
the Principal Secretary as a disciplinary authority has imposed a
punishment of withholding of two increments for two years without
cumulative effect. While issuing notice in the petition, it was highlighted
that the main ground of challenge of the petitioner was that the
disciplinary authority had sought and relied upon the advice of the
TPSC which was in any case a statutory requirement, before passing
the impugned order without providing a copy of the advice of the TPSC
and permitting the petitioner to make a representation with respect to
the same.
In this respect, in the affidavit-in-reply filed by the respondents it
is stated that:
“Thirdly, it is mentioned here that due to oversight copy
of the concurrence of the TPSC was not provided to the
petitioner.”
Only on this ground of non-supply of copy of the advice of the
TPSC
to
the
delinquent
and
giving
opportunity
of
making
representation with respect to the contents thereof before taking into
consideration for coming to the final conclusion, the impugned order
must go. Learned counsel for the petitioner correctly points out that the
law on the topic is sufficient to hear through the decisions of Supreme
Court in case of Union of India and others vrs. S.K. Kapoor reported
in (2011) 4 SCC 589 and Union of India and others vrs. R.P. Singh
reported in (2014) 7 SCC 340.
Impugned order is set aside. The respondents shall provide a
copy of the advice of the TPSC to the petitioner, enable the petitioner to
make a representation with respect to the same and thereafter may pass
fresh order in accordance with law. Entire exercise may be completed
within four months from today. Since the impugned order is set aside
only on this ground, I have not examined any of the other grounds of
the petitioner. If the disciplinary authority passes a fresh order which is
adverse to the petitioner, it would be open for the petitioner to
challenge the same on all grounds available in law.
Petition disposed of accordingly.”
2.10.
In compliance of the order dated 10.09.2021, the petitioner was
supplied with the copy of the advice of TPSC against which the petitioner also
submitted representation on 02.11.2021(Annexure-K to the writ petition).
Thereafter, the impugned order of punishment dated 08.12.2021 had been
passed imposing the above penalty upon the petitioner. The petitioner preferred
an appeal before the appellate authority, but, it was dismissed upholding the
impugned order of penalty imposed by the disciplinary authority.
3.
Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel for the petitioner has strenuously
argued that, in the instant case, punishment has been imposed based on no
evidence. Learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn my attention to the
article of charge as well as the evidence let in by the department concerned, i.e.,
PW-2, Bhaskar Ghosh. For convenience, the evidence of Bhaskar Ghosh may
be reproduced here-in-below, in extenso:“English Rendering of Statement of Bhaskar Ghosh
Statement
I, Sri Bhaskar Ghosh, aged about 32 years, S/O Sri Bimal
Ghosh, presently posted at Kamalpur Subjail as warder, am voluntarily
deposing my statement today on 5th day of March, 2015 A.D. in the
evening at 4.15 p.m. in presence of the following witnesses before the
Kamalpur Sub-Divisional Magistrate.
Yesterday 4th March 2016 A.D. at 6.50 a.m. in the morning, I
and my colleague warder Sri Shibuprasad Chakraborty jointly had
taken over the charge of work schedule of 9 prisoners from the
concerned jamadar Sri Samiran Bhowmik. Out of these 9 prisoners, I
had taken the charge of 4 prisoner under my personal supervision and
the responsibility of rest 5 prisoners was taken by Sri Shibuprasad
Chakraborty. Sri Nripendra Debnath and Sri Sanjib Debnath were
amongst the five prisoners whose liability was lying with Sri
Shibuprasad Chakraborty. Since, I was feeling unwell, so I handed over
the charge of 5 prisoners under my personal supervision, to warder Sri
Swapan Debbarma, deployed at jail Gate at 10.30 min. Then I returned
to the barrack. I had informed about my illness to the Jailor and the
jamadar Sri Braja Kumar Debbarma.
Witnesses
Illegible
Bhaskar Ghosh
Ilegible
Jail Warder
05/03/2016
Recorded by me and read over to the deponent Sd/- 06/03/2016
SDM Kamalpur.”
4.
On going through the evidence of PW-2, I find that PW-2 nowhere
had stated that he had seen the two prisoners, namely Nripendra Debnath and
Sanjib Debnath to go outside the jail premises. The documents produced by the
presenting officer only proved that the concerned duty officer i.e. Samiran
Bhowmik due to his illness handed over the charge of 4(four) prisoners, who
were under his control, to one Shiburprasad Chakraborty, another Jail Warder
of the same jail.
5.
In this situation, the inquiring authority held that the article of
charge in respect of the allegation that the Jailor had committed misconduct
since he allowed two prisoners to go outside the jail premises to carry 11 bags
of paddy crop to the mill for being milled into rice without any escort or prior
permission from appropriate authority.
6.
As I said earlier, the inquiring authority had formulated 3(three)
points to determine the extent of misconduct allegedly committed by the
petitioner which have been quoted in the preceding paragraphs of the judgment.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that since the 1st
point has been decided in favour of the petitioner, then the two other charges
being interlinked or correlated to the first point, automatically, the remaining
two points would be of no consequence. Learned counsel has reiterated that it is
a case based on no evidence and as such, the said order of penalty is liable to be
quashed.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. has strongly
opposed the contention advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner.
Learned G.A. has tried to persuade this court that it is settled proposition of law
that every charge has to be proved independently and there is no straight
formula that if one charge is not proved, the charged officer cannot be held to
be guilty on the basis of other established charges.
According to learned G.A., the disciplinary authority has the right
to impose penalty if he is convinced that other charges have been proved. To
substantiate his submissions, learned G.A. has placed reliance upon the case of
Deputy General Manager (Appellate Authority) & Ors. Vs. Ajai Kumar
Srivastava, reported in (2021) 2 SCC 612 [SCC, p-626, 627; para 22, 23, 24,
25, 26, 27 and 28]. Learned G.A. has tried to persuade this Court that when
there is evidence, then the exercise of power of judicial review of this Court is
very limited under Article 226 of Constitution of India. I have noticed that in
Ajai Kumar Srivastava (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court in para 39 has
clearly held thus:“39. The constitution Bench has clearly laid down that even after the
charges which have been proved, justify imposition of penalty, the court
may not exercise its power of judicial review.”
What the Hon’ble Supreme Court wanted to settle is that amongst
many charges, if one of the charges is proved and justify imposition of penalty,
in that case the Court may not exercise his power of judicial review on the
pretext that other charges have not been proved.
9.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions
advanced by learned counsel appearing for the parties.
10.
The point to be determined in the present case whether the
punishment imposed upon the petitioner is based on no evidence. There is no
quarrel in the proposition of law that the court can exercise its extraordinary
power of judicial review under Article 226 of Constitution of India if it finds
that punishment upon a delinquent/charged officer is based on the basis of no
evidence, which has also been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Ajai Kumar Srivastava (supra).
11.
On bare perusal of the evidence let in by Bhaskar Ghosh (PW-2),
it is crystallized that PW-2 has not stated anything that the Jailor, i.e. the
petitioner herein, has allowed the prisoners to go outside the jail premises to
bring some articles as charged. It is the inquiry officer himself who came to a
finding that the presenting officer or the department concerned had failed to
establish the fact that the two prisoners went outside the jail premises on
04.03.2016.
12.
According to me, the disciplinary authority could not assign any
reason while rejecting the finding of the inquiry authority. There is absolutely
no evidence which prompted the disciplinary authority to come to a finding that
the petitioner, being Jailor had allowed the two prisoners to go outside the jail
to bring some articles. The Warder, Shiburprasad Chakraborty under whose
custody the prisoners were on 04.03.2016, was not examined by the
prosecution. Even the prisoners were not produced before the enquiry officer to
justify the charge levelled against the petitioner. It is the allegation in the
charge that they were sent to bring paddy from market, but no such witness had
been produced by the prosecution to justify the allegation that they went to the
market to bring paddy. If that be so, the mill owner or the mill person could
easily be produced by the prosecution to establish the charge.
13.
Considering the aforesaid circumstances, in my opinion, the entire
allegation levelled against the petitioner is found to be baseless and the
respondents have miserably failed to establish the article of charge framed
against the petitioner. The findings of the inquiry officer, in my opinion, seem
to be correct that the department concerned had failed to establish the article of
charge framed against the petitioner.
14.
The next two points as formulated by the inquiry officer as to
whether the AO had violated the provisions of Rule 242 and 243 of the BJC
and whether the charged officer, i.e. the petitioner has failed to maintain
absolute integrity and devotion to Government duty, in my opinion, these two
points are interlinked and co-related to point no.1. Once it is established that the
prosecution has failed to establish the article of charge that the petitioner had
sent two prisoners outside the jail premises to pound paddy in a mill, then,
automatically there would be no violation of the provisions of Rules 242 and
248 of the BJC. Rules 242 and 248 of the Bengal Jail Code may be re-produced
here-in-below:“242.
The Jailer shall be the chief executive officer of the
jail and shall control the whole subordinate jail establishment
under the orders of the Superintendent and shall assist the
Superintendent on all occasions, and see that his instructions are
carried into effect. He shall be responsible for the strict carrying
out of all the rules in this Code relating to the management of the
jail and prisoners. He should therefore make himself thoroughly
acquainted with the rules and with the circulars issued by the
Inspector-General.
248.
His chief duties are to secure the safe custody of
prisoners, to enforce discipline among prisoners and his
subordinates, to ensure that prisoners sentenced to rigorous
imprisonment do the work assigned to them, and to maintain a
high standard of health among them so far as this can be secured
by strict compliance with the rules and orders made with this
object. The sedulous attention to all matters which can improve
the health of the prisoners will be considered one of the highest
qualifications for the post of Jailer. He shall visit every part of the
jail daily, including cells and hospital, and see every prisoner at
least once in every 24 hours.”
15.
At the cost of repetition, I reiterate, since there is no proof that the
petitioner being the jailor at that relevant point of time allowed the two
prisoners to go outside the jail premises, there is no question of violation of the
provisions as laid down in Rules 242 and 248 of BJC. I have noticed that the
inquiry officer has given a finding in his report that at the time of examination
of the AO, he stated that he was not aware of Rules 242 and 248 of the Jail
Code, which led the inquiry officer to come to come to a finding that the
accused officer had committed misconduct due to mere ignorance of the above
rules. In my opinion, ignorance of any rule or law will not constitute
misconduct if it does not lead to commit any illegalities in the performance of
one’s duties. Since I have come to a finding that ignorance of law does not
amount to misconduct, then it can easily be said that point no.3 as formulated
by the inquiry officer is not established.
16.
Next, on perusal of the impugned order of punishment dated
08.12.2021, I find that there is no discussion on the satisfaction of the
disciplinary authority to come to a conclusion that the accused officer i.e., the
petitioner herein had committed misconduct. Here, the disciplinary authority
has not assigned any reason to substantiate the misconduct allegedly committed
by the petitioner. Furthermore, the learned G.A could not substantiate that the
letter dated 21.10.2021 issued by the disciplinary authority addressed to the
petitioner is a note of disagreement. In my opinion, letter dated 21.10.2021
reproduced here-in-above is simply a letter asking the petitioner to submit his
representation. There is nothing to satisfy this court that it is a note of
disagreement.
17.
I have taken into consideration the ratio of the decision rendered
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ajai Kumar Srivastava (supra). It is a case
where article of charge framed against the delinquent officer for
misappropriation of fund. Altogether 7(seven) charges were framed and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court came to a finding that there are materials to justify the
imposition of penalty upon the delinquent officer. It is no longer res integra
that to establish a charge in a departmental proceeding, strict rule of evidence is
not required and it can be decided on the evidence of preponderance of
probability, but, to apply the doctrine of preponderance of probability, some
reliable evidence must be on record which may convince the court to justify the
imposition of penalty upon the delinquent officer.
18.
In Ajai Kumar Srivastava (supra) a three Judge Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has categorically held that in case of disagreement,
duty castes upon the disciplinary authority to record the reasons for
disagreement and after affording an opportunity of hearing to the delinquent,
may record his own findings if the evidence available on record is found to be
sufficient for such exercise or else remit the case to the inquiry officer for
further inquiry. It is further held that strict rules of evidence are not applicable
to departmental proceedings. However, the only requirement of law is that the
allegation against the delinquent must be established by such evidence acting
upon which a reasonable person acting reasonably and with objectivity may
arrive at a finding upholding the gravity of charge against the delinquent. The
Hon’ble Supreme court has further held that mere conjecture and surmise
cannot sustain finding of guilt even in the case of departmental proceeding. As
I said and discussed earlier, the present case is a case where penalty has been
imposed upon conjectures and surmises. Added to it, the disciplinary authority
has failed to record his own reasons of disagreement with the findings of the
inquiry officer while deciding the point no.1 in respect of the charge that the
petitioner had allowed the two prisoners to go outside the jail premises to carry
paddy crop to the mill for being milled into rice and virtually, there is no “note
of disagreement”.
18.
In this situation, according to me, the court must exercise its power
of judicial review under Article 226 of Constitution of India.
In view of the above and for the reasons discussed aforesaid, in my
opinion, the findings of the disciplinary authority is wholly perverse.
In the light of above conspectus, the impugned orders of penalty
passed by the disciplinary authority as well as the appellate authority need to be
interfered with and, are, accordingly interfered. The orders of penalty are
accordingly set aside and quashed.
19.
With the above observations, the writ petition stands allowed and
thus disposed of.
JUDGE
SAIKAT
KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.08.08
16:27:39 +05'30'
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review