Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.435 of 2025
Sri Sanjib Das,
Son of Nirmal Kumar Das,
Resident of Resham Bagan, Khayerpur,
West Tripura, PIN:799 008
----Petitioner (s)
Versus
01. Tripura State Electricity Corporation Ltd (TSECL),
To be represented by the Managing Director,
Banamalipur, Agartala, Tripura
02. The Chairman, Tripura State Electricity
Corporation Ltd. (TSECL),
Banamalipur, Agartala, Tripura
03. The Deputy General Manager,
Transmission Division, 79 Tilla,
Agartala, Tripura (West)
04. The Deputy General Manager (Corporate),
Corporate Office, TSECL, Banamalipur, Agartala
05. The Addl. General Manager,
Transmission Circle, TSECL, Agartala
06. The DGM (Corporate & HR),
TSECL, Bidyuit Bhavan, North Banamalipur,
Agartala, West Tripura
07. The Sr. Manager, 132 KV Sub-Station,
Bodhjungnagar, Tripura
08. The Addl. General Manager, Transmission Circle,
Tripura Power Transmission Limited, Agartala
09. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary,
Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:799 010
10. The Director of Health Services,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN:799 010
11. The Principal/Chairman,
Standing Medical Board,
Agartala Government Medical College & GBP Hospital,
Agartala
---- Respondents (s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Sutapa Deb Barman, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Dhrubajyoti Saha, Adv.
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A
Date of Hearing
: 16.02.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order
: 23.02.2026
Whether fit for
Reporting
:YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman
assisted by Ms. S. Deb Barman, Learned Counsel appearing
for the petitioner and also heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr.
B. N. Majumder assisted by Mr. D. J. Saha, Learned Counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents
No.1-8.
Further
heard
Learned Addl. G.A. Mr. D. Sarma appearing on behalf of the
respondents No.9 and 10 but in spite of service of notice
none appeared for the respondent No.11 i.e. the Chairman
of the Standing Medical Board, AGMC and GBP Hospital,
Agartala.
02.
The petitioner has filed this petition seeking the
following reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby quashing and cancelling the
letter,
dated
02.01.2025,
issued
by
the
Principal/Chairman, Standing Medical Board, AGMC &
GBP Hospital, regretting the issuance of Ex-post facto
Certificate in favour of the Petitioner.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
give the benefit of Medical reimbursement to the
Petitioner in connection with the enpenditure of his
treatment.
(iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issue whereby directing the Respondents to
accord sanction to the Medical reimbursement Bill,
submitted by the Petitioner on 10.04.2023 before the
Chairman-cum-Managing Director, TSECL amounting to
Rs.3,45,505/- in total, for reimbursing the expenditure
incurred by the Petitioner for his treatment outside the
State.
(iv) Make the rules absolute.
(v) Call for records.
(vi)Pass any further Order/Orders as this Hon’ble High
Court considered fit and proper.
03.
Learned Senior Counsel at the time of hearing
drawn the attention of the Court that the petitioner on the
ground of assisting one of his relative for treatment at
Kolkata prayed for leave along with station leave permission
on medical ground and accordingly vide office order dated
10.03.2023 (Annexure-2) his prayer was allowed by the
authority. According to the petitioner he went to Kolkata
along with his relative but on arrival therein suddenly he
had fallen ill and experienced severe chest pain and
immediately he rushed to Rabindranath Tagore International
Institute of Cardiac Sciences, Mukundapur. He was residing
within
the
complex
of
R.N.
Tagore
Hospital
and
on
11.01.2023 the petitioner was admitted to R.N. Tagore
Hospital under the advice of Dr. Ayan Kar when he was
advised to undergo Coronary Angiography and accordingly
the
petitioner
underwent
Coronary
Angiogram
as
the
petitioner was diagnosed with coronery artery blockage,
hyper tension and metabolic syndrome and he was further
advised not to move without proper treatment otherwise it
will be very risky for his life. From the discharge summary
dated 15.01.2023 it will be clear that the petitioner was
admitted with exertional chest discomfort and he was
diagnosed with double vessel coronary artery disease,
hypertension,
metabolic
syndrome
and
he
underwent
angiography on 11.01.2023 and after coronary angiography
the petitioner undergone PTCA with stenting to LAD on
13.01.2023 at R.N. Tagore, Hospital, Mukundapur and in
this regard he relied upon discharge summary (Annexure-3)
issued by the Hospital Authority. Since the petitioner is
entitled to the medical reimbursement so by a letter dated
10.04.2023 he submitted two MR bills for an amount of
Rs.2,05,857/- and Rs.1,39,648/- to the respondent No.5 in
Form No.49 which was duly certified by the authority.
Thereafter, the Addl. General Manager, Transmission Circle,
TSECL by a letter dated 06.05.2023 forwarded the same to
the Deputy General Manager (Corporation) (Annexure-4).
After that the DGM by a letter dated 22.08.2023 informed
the Addl. General Manager to ask the petitioner to re-submit
the bill along with referral certificate from the Chairman,
Standing
Medical
Board
(Annexure-5).
Thereafter
the
Deputy General Manager, Transmission Division by a letter
dated
01.09.2023
returned
the
nos.
medical
reimbursement bill with a request to re-submit the bill with
referral certificate from the Chairman, Standing Medical
Board to the Sr. Manager (Annexure-6). After that the
petitioner by a representation dated 06.09.2023 (Annexure7) resubmitted the two nos. medical bill to the Deputy
General Manager, Transmission Division, 79 Tilla, Agartala.
In the said representation it has been stated by the
petitioner that on 10.01.2023 he had to leave for Kolkata
along with one of his relative but on arrival therein suddenly
he became ill with serious chest discomfort and ultimately
he had to rush for Rabindranath Tagore International
Institute of Cardiac Sciences, Mukundapur wherein the
Doctor after his diagnosis advised him that he was suffering
from coronery artery blockage and after that he had to
undergo treatment but there was no scope on his part for
obtain referral certificate from the standing medical board.
04.
Station
After that the Senior Manager, 132 KV SubBodhjungnagar
by
a
letter
dated
06.09.2023
forwarded the re-submitted medical re-imbursement bills of
the petitioner with explanation to the DGM, Transmission
Division, 79 Tilla, Agartala (Annexure-8) and after that by
another letter dated 29.09.2023 the Addl. General Manager,
Transmission Circle forwarded the DGM two nos. of medical
re-imbursement
bills
(Annexure-9).
Thereafter
DGM
(Corporate & HR) by a letter dated 01.11.2023 requested
the Director, Health Department regarding admissibility of
medical re-imbursement bills (Annexure-10) and after that
the Director of Health Services by a letter dated 04.12.2023
informed Dy. General Manager (Corporate & HR) that the
referral certificates from the Standing Medical Board was
not found and it was advised that Sanjib Das i.e. the
petitioner should apply his medical re-imbursement claim
through a new medical bill form instead of old medical bill
Form No.49 (Annexure-11) which was returned back to the
Deputy General Manager by DGM (Corporate & HR) by a
letter dated 10.07.2024 (Annexure-12) for informing Sanjib
Das to submit the medical re-imbursement claim in new
medical bill form. After that DGM, Transmission Division, 79
Tilla,
Agartala
informed
Senior
Manager,
KV,
Bodhjungnagar Sub-Station by a letter dated 20.08.2024
(Annexure-13) that
due to
non-availability
of referral
certificate the same was not considered. Thereafter, Senior
Manager, again re-submitted two nos. medical bills of the
petitioner
by
a
communication
dated
05.10.2024
(Annexure-14) to the DGM, Transmission Division, Agartala
which was further forwarded by Deputy General Manager,
Transmission
Division
to
the
Addl.
General
Manager,
Transmission Circle, TPTL and Addl. General Manager
thereafter forwarded the same again to the Deputy General
Manager
(Corporate)
Corporate
Office
by
another
communication dated 08.10.2024 (Annexure-16). After that
on 04.12.2024 forwarded the medical bills to the Chairman,
Standing Medical Board (Annexure-17) to consider the postfacto referral of the petitioner and accordingly the Standing
Medical Board by a communication dated 02.01.2025
(Annexure-18) informed the petitioner that his case could
not be considered as because the same treatment was
available at Agartala. As the grievance of the petitioner was
not addressed so the petitioner filed this writ petition.
05.
The TSECL has filed the counter-affidavit denying
the claim of the petitioner but they have admitted the fact
of the petitioner and submitted that in view of the
memorandum
dated
22.12.2022
(Annexure-23)
the
petitioner was not entitled to the benefit and also the claim
of the petitioner was not supported by any referral
certificate.
The
State-respondents
also
filed
counter-
affidavit. In para Nos.9 and 10 of the counter-affidavit they
have submitted as under:
“9. That, in regards to the statement made in paragraph3 to 11 of the writ Petition, it is stated that the averments
are matter of records which is required to be
substantiated by the writ petitioner by adducing
necessary documentary evidences in support of his claim.
Anything contrary to records is denied and disputed.
10. That, in regard to the statement made in paragraph
No.12 to 36 of the writ petition it is stated that after
thorough examination and verification of the documents
submitted, the Director of Health Services, Government of
Tripura informed the Dy. General Manager (Corporation &
HR), Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited (A
Government of Tripura Enterprise) Bidyut Bhavan, North
Banamalipur. Agartala West Tripura through Letter
dated-04-12-2023 that the referral certificate from the
Standing Medical Board, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala,
which is a prerequisite as per our department's
guidelines for the reimbursement of medical expenses,
could not be found among the documents received.
To proceed with the verification & potential approval of
the medical reimbursement in question, Referral
Certificate from the Standing Medical Board, AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala is required and also requested to
Resubmit the Complete Set of Documents, including the
aforementioned referral certificate, to this office. Upon
receiving the complete documentation, department will
expedite the verification process & communicate decision
regarding the admissibility of the medical reimbursement
to TSECL at the earliest. Further the medical
reimbursement claim was submitted on the old Medical
Bill Form No-49. As per updated policies and directives,
all new claims must be filed using the revised Medical Bill
Form. So as per assessment, answering respondents
returned the original medical reimbursement bill and
related papers to facilitate the petitioner resubmission in
accordance with the updated guidelines.
It is further submitted that the petitioner explicitly
admitted in para 19 of the writ petition the requirement
to adhere to the aforementioned procedural update. This
admission aligns with department's stance on the matter.
The explicit admission in Para 19 of the Writ Petition
regarding the necessity to comply with the procedural
update (i.e., using the new medical bill form), and in
accordance with department's policy for processing
claims, the Department of Health Services (DHS) is
deemed not liable for any delays or consequences arising
from the initial submission on the obsolete form.”
By
filing
the
counter-affidavit
the
State-
respondents prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
06.
At the time of hearing Learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioner in support of his contention referred all the
annexed documents and submitted that this High Court in
WP(C)No.1479 of 2017 dated 04.05.2018 and also in
another case this High Court in WP(C)No.1154 of 2019
dated 18.02.2020 similarly allowed such petition in absence
of reference of Medical Board. Learned Senior Counsel also
relied upon another citation of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in
Shiva Kant Jha vs. Union of India reported in (2018)16
SCC 187 wherein in para No.17 Hon‟ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“17. It is a settled legal position that the government
employee during his life time or after his retirement is
entitled to get the benefit of the medical facilities and no
fetters can be placed on his rights. It is acceptable to
common sense, that ultimate decision as to how a patient
should be treated vests only with the doctor, who is well
versed and expert both on academic qualification and
experience gained. Very little scope is left to the patient
or his relative to decide as to the manner in which the
ailment should be treated. Speciality Hospitals are
established for treatment of specified ailments and
services of doctors specialized in a discipline are availed
by patients only to ensure proper, required and safe
treatment. Can it be said that taking treatment in
Speciality Hospital by itself would deprive a person to
claim reimbursement solely on the ground that the said
Hospital is not included in the government order. The
right to medical claim cannot be denied merely because
the name of the hospital is not included in the
government order. The real test must be the factum of
treatment. Before any medical claim is honoured, the
authorities are bound to ensure as to whether the
claimant had actually taken treatment and the factum of
treatment is supported by records duly certified by
Doctors/Hospitals concerned. Once, it is established, the
claim cannot be denied on technical grounds. Clearly, in
the present case, by taking a very inhuman approach, the
officials of the CGHS have denied the grant of medical
reimbursement in full to the petitioner forcing him to
approach this Court.”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel
submitted that since the factum of treatment is proved and
the respondents also did not deny the said fact. So there is
no reason to deny the claim of the petitioner by the
respondents-authority. He further submitted that the claim
of the petitioner is also supported by Hon‟ble Apex Court in
Surjit Singh vs. State of Punjab and Others reported in
(1996) 2 SCC 336. Finally Learned Senior Counsel
submitted that since the claim of the petitioner is genuine
and the petitioner had no other alternative to undergo
treatment at Kolkata which is one of the referral hospital so
the
claim
of
the
petitioner
be
considered
by
the
respondents-authority and prayed for allowing this writ
petition.
07.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel Mr.
B. N. Majumder appearing for TSECL submitted that the fact
of the treatment is not disputed but in absence of any
approval of the Standing Medical Board it was not possible
on the part of the respondent-corporation to consider the
medical re-imbursement bill submitted by the petitioner. He
also drawn the attention of the Court referring Annexure-23
i.e. memo dated 22.12.2022 and also the communication
which the DGM (Corporate & HR) wrote a letter to the
Chairman,
Standing
Medical
Board
dated
04.12.2024.
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel submitted that
in view of the embargo there is no scope to consider the
medical re-imbursement bill submitted by the petitioner.
08.
Learned Addl. G.A. Mr. D. Sarma submitted that
since without any referral from Standing Medical Board the
present petitioner availed the benefit as such he is not
entitled to get any benefit in this case and also relied upon
one citation of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in State
of Punjab and Others vs. Ram Lubhaya Bagga and
Others reported in (1998) 4 SCC 117 wherein in para
Nos. 27 and 28 Hon‟ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“27. Coming back to test the claim of respondents, the
State can neither urge nor say that it has no obligation to
provide medical facility. If that were so it would be ex
facie violative of Article 21. Under the new policy, medical
facility continues to be given and now an employee is
given free choice to get treatment in any private hospital
in India but the amount of payment towards
reimbursement is regulated. Without fixing any specific
rate, the new policy refers to the obligation of paying at
the rate fixed by the Director. The words are:
" .... to the level of expenditure as per the rate
fixed by the Director, Health and Family Welfare,
Punjab for a similar treatment package or actual
expenditure whichever is less."
28. The new policy does not leave this fixation to the
sweet will of the Director but it is to be done by a
Committee of technical experts.
"The rate for a particular treatment would be
included in the advice issued by the District/State
Medical Board. A Committee of technical experts
shall be constituted by the Director, Health and
Family Welfare, Punjab to finalize the rates of
various treatment packages….."
Referring the same Learned Addl. G.A. submitted
that in view of the judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex Court the
present petitioner is not entitled to any benefit in this case.
09.
I have heard the counsels of the parties and
perused the writ petition and the documents annexed with
the petition. Admittedly the petitioner of this case after
availing commuted leave on medical ground proceeded for
Kolkata on 10.01.2023 which was approved by the authority
and on arrival therein all on a sudden he developed some
chest pain which compelled him to undergo treatment at
Rabindranath Tagore Hospital where the petitioner had to
undergo Angiogram as he was suffering from Coronary
Artery Blockage and for that he had incurred medical
expenses and after returning back he submitted medical bill
to the department which was not considered on the ground
that that was not approved by the Standing Medical Board
and although the matter was taken up with the Standing
Medical Board for ex-post facto approval but that was also
turned down on the ground that the similar treatment
is/was available at GBP Hospital, Agartala. It is also the
admitted position that Rabindra Nath Tagore Hospital is one
of the empanelled referral hospital approved by the State of
Tripura.
10.
The petitioner in the writ petition submitted all
the relevant papers regarding his treatment at Rabindranath
Tagore Hospital, Kolkata. From the certificate issued by
Rabindranath Tagore Hospital it appears that the following
observation was made by the hospital authority:
“Course in Hospital
Mr. Sanjib Das, 52 year old hypertensive,
nondiabetic, obese gentleman was admitted with
exertional chest discomfort and positive TMT. ECG
showed NSR. Echocardiography revealed good LV
systolic
function
with
EP
66%.
Coronary
angiography done on 11/1/2023 revealed double
vessel coronary artery disease. PTCA with stenting
to LAD was done on 13/1/2023. PTCA with
stenting to RCA was attempted but wire could not
be passed. Post procedural period was uneventful.
He is now being discharged in a stable condition.”
11.
I have also perused the memo dated 22.12.2022
issued by the Health Department wherein it is mentioned
that the Group-A and Group-B employees of the State
Government and their family members may avail treatment
in any enlisted referral hospital inside/outside the State
approved by the State Government without referral of the
Standing Medical Board subject to condition that ex-post
facto approval shall be given only in case of emergency or
acute illness arising while the Govt. Servant is staying
outside the State with station leave permission. In such a
case certificate from the treating hospital be obtained and if
any treatment is undertaken re-imbursement would be at
per CGHS rate. From the aforesaid clause of memorandum
dated 22.12.2022 it appears that in the said memorandum
it was decided by the Government that ex-post facto
approval should be obtained. Here in the case at hand the
petitioner after returning back prayed for ex-post facto
approval but that was dishonored on the ground that such
treatment was available at Agartala. This High Court in
WP(C)No.1479 of 2017 in para Nos. 7, 16, 17, 19, 20, 21
and 22 observed as under:
“[7] Counsel for the petitioner submits that in
terms of the guidelines laid down by the State
Govt., for admissibility of medical expenses to the
State Govt. officials for treatment outside the State
although has to be referred by the Standing
Medical
Board
to
the
prescribed
medical
institutions as indicated in para-A ordinarily has to
seek permission for taking treatment to be
referred by the Standing Medical Board but is not
always possible in the course of urgency like that
in the case of the petitioner, he had a stroke during
office hours on 15th February, 2017, initially went
to take medical assistance in the Agartala Govt.
Medical College & GBP Hospital but nothing
revealed and as he was still feeling uncomfortable,
proceeded to Fortis Hospital, Kolkata on 20th
February, 2017 and consulted all Neuro Surgeons
and there he found that he had been attacked with
stroke twice but unable to find out any reason of
his disorder in his body.
[16] It is also equally true that no State can have
unlimited resources to spend on any of its project
and that is why the only approves its projects to
the extent it is feasible and same holds good for
providing medical facilities to its citizen including
its employees and expenses of medical assistance
cannot be unlimited. It has to be to the extent
finance permit. This has been extensively
examined by the Apex Court in the case of the
medical reimbursement taking note of the
precedents as to what extent medical expenses are
reimbursable
keeping
in
view
the
circular/guidelines/rules of the State Govt. for
reimbursement of the medical expenses. The Apex
Court in State Of Karnataka and Another v. Sri R.
Vivekananda Swamy, reported (2008) 5 SCC 328
has observed that if an employee obtains
treatment from a hospital of his choice can be
made limited and his entitlement will remain
within the parameters of the medical scheme
introduced by the Govt. for reimbursement of the
medical expenses.
[17] Based on the principles laid down by the Apex
Court of which reference has been made one of the
coordinate Bench in WP(C) No. 228 of 2013 [Sri
Ajit Kumar Paul v. The State of Tripura & Others,
dt. 01.07.2016] has observed that if the cardiac
facilities are not available in the Govt. Hospitals
nor in Govt. Medical College in the State, obviously
the patient has to proceed for specialized
treatments to avail medical facilities from the
approved/private hospitals outside the State and
in such exigencies if the patient has to wait and to
first take the recommendation from the Standing
Medical Board is impracticable and to the extent
the
employee
take
treatment
from
a
approved/private hospital outside the State of
Tripura, it is indeed reimbursable.
“15. Admittedly, neither in the Govt.
hospital nor in Govt. medical college,
treatment of cardiac problems is available
though at present there is a private hospital
where the cardiac treatment is available and
for that also, a patient has to wait when a
specialist comes from outside. Reference
Page 9 of 14 by the standing Medical Board
to a referral hospital itself cannot be a
ground
for
not
granting
medical
reimbursement to him, rather the Govt.
should see whether the employee (patient)
took treatment outside the State which is
not available in the State of Tripura. In
WP(C) 228 of 2013 Page 9 of 9 such a
situation, the Govt. should not deny the
medical reimbursement of its employees
merely on the technical ground. This Court is
of the further opinion that the claim of the
petitioner is a genuine one as he is entitled
to medical reimbursement and admittedly
RTIICS, Kolkata is a referral hospital of the
Government of Tripura.
[19] Although, the hospital from where the
petitioner has taken treatment i.e. Aplollo
Speciality Hospital, Chennai is an approved
hospital by the Govt. but that facility is available to
Tripura Health Assurance Scheme for Poor as
revealed from the notification dt. 19th October
2015 (Annexure-4) and such facilities are not
extended to Group-B officers of the State of
Tripura for which he has to seek permission from
the Standing Medical Board and that can be expost-facto permission to regularize the medical
treatment & expenses incurred for reimbursement.
[20] It is true that if a reference would have been
obtained by Standing Medical Board constituted by
the Govt. seeking permission ordinarily was
advisable for the employee to attempt but the
medical treatments which are not available in the
State of Tripura and sometime the procedure laid
down to first take permission from the State
Medical Board and only thereafter to proceed for
taking treatment from approved hospital or the
hospital of his own choice, may not be possible and
appears to be onerous and not workable specially
in the emergency cases and in such exigencies, if
condition of taking first referral from the Standing
Medical Board for taking treatment from the
approved hospital/private hospital under the
notification dt. 25th October 2013 where time is an
essence and not possible for the patient even to
wait for an hour or for a day, still in the procedure
as prescribed by the Govt. under its notification dt.
25th October 2013 has to be mandatorily followed
there is full possibility that the family may lose the
patient and it goes without saying that prompt and
better medical treatment is of utmost priority not
only for a citizen but of the State and his
authorities.
[21] In my considered view, the precondition of
seeking referral from the Standing Medical Board
before to proceed in availing medical treatment
from the approved hospital/private hospital
outside the State if any, under the notification dt.
25th October 2013 is directory in character subject
to fulfillment of the conditions prescribed in
availing reimbursement of medical expenses under
the Govt. notification dt. 25th October 2013, where
a patient has taken treatment from an approved
hospital or the hospital of his choice (Other than
the
approved
hospital)
is
entitled
for
reimbursement of medical expenses incurred to
the extent of such medical expenses if incurred in
taking treatment from the approved hospital or
from a private hospital where he has taken
treatment whichever is lower taking note of the
restrictions imposed by the Govt. under its
notification dt. 25th October 2013 extending
financial assistance to its employees for availing
medical facilities, which is a social obligation of the
State.
[22] In the instant case, looking to the kind of
ailment which the petitioner and his wife were
suffering this Court can take a judicial notice that
such medical facilities are not available in the
State of Tripura and there was no option left
except to take treatment either from the hospital
which is approved by the Govt. under its
notification dt. 25th October 2013 or from a
private medical hospital of own choice, but he
would be entitled for reimbursement of the
medical expenses incurred which is admissible
under the approved medical hospital or from a
private hospital from where he has taken
treatment whichever is lower under notification dt.
25th October 2013 and in the given circumstances,
the decision of the Govt. holding that the medical
expenses incurred by the petitioner is not
admissible for reimbursement because of not being
referred by the Standing Medical Board under its
communication dt. 17th August, 2017 (Annexure3) is not sustainable in law and needs to be set
aside.”
12.
Similarly another Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in WP(C)No.830 of 2019 dated 05.12.2029 in the relevant
portion observed as under:
“The Supreme Court in case of Surjit Singh vs.
State of Punjab and others reported in (1996) 2
SCC 336 had in somewhat similar circumstances
made following observations:
“11. It is otherwise important to bear in
mind that self preservation of one's life is
the necessary concomitant of the right to life
enshrined in Article 21 of the constitution of
India, fundamental in nature, sacred,
precious and inviolable. The importance and
validity of the duty and right to self-
preservation has a species in the right of self
defence in criminal law. Centuries ago
thinkers of this Great Land conceived of such
right and recognised it. Attention can
usefully be drawn to verses 17 18, 20, and
22 in Chapter 16 of the Garuda Purana (A
Dialogue suggested between the Divine and
Garuda, the bird) in the words of the Divine:
17 Vinaa dehena kasyaapi canpurushaartho
na
vidyate
Tasmaaddeham
dhanam
rakshetpunyakar maani saadhayet
Without the body how can one obtain
the objects of human life? Therefore
protecting the body which is the wealth, one
should perform the deeds of merit.
Rakshayetsarvadaatmaanamaatmaa
sarvasya
bhaajanam
Rakshane
yatnamaatishthejje vanbhaadraani pashyati
One should protect his body which is
responsible for everything. He who protects
himself by all efforts, will see many
auspicious occasions in life.
Sharirarakshanopaayaah
Kriyante
sarvadaa
budhaih
Necchanti
cha
punastyaagamapi kushthaadiroginah
The wise always undertake the
protective measures for the body. Even the
persons suffering from leprosy and other
diseases do not wish to get rid of the body.
22 Aatmaiva yadi naatmaanama hitebhyo
nivaarayet
Konsyo
hitakarastasmaadaatmaanam taarayishyati
If one does not prevent what is
unpleasent to himself, who else will do it?
Therefore one should do what is good to
himself.
12. The appellant therefore had the right to
take steps in self preservation. He did not
have to stand in queue before the Medical
Board, the manning and assembling of
which, barefacedly, makes its meetings
difficult to happen. The appellant also did
not have to stand in queue in the
government hospital of AIIMS and could go
elsewhere to an alternative hospital as per
policy. When the State itself has brought
Escorts on the recognised list, it is futile for
it to contend that the appellant could in no
event have gone to Escorts and his claim
cannot on that basis be allowed, on
suppositions. We think to the contrary. In
the facts and circumstances, had the
appellant remained in India, he could have
gone to Escorts like many others did, to save
his life. But instead he has done that in
London incurring considerable expense. The
doctors causing his operation there are
presumed to have done so as one essential
and timely. On that hypothesis, it is fair and
just that the respondents pay to the
appellant, the rates admissible as per
Escorts. The claim of the appellant having
been found valid, the question posed at the
outset is answered in the affirmative. Of
course the sum of Rs.40,000 already paid to
the appellant would have to be adjusted in
computation. Since the appellant did not
have his claim dealt with in the High Court in
the manner it has been projected now in this
Court, we do not grant him any interest for
the intervening period, even though prayed
for. Let the difference be paid to the
appellant within two months positively. The
appeal is accordingly allowed. There need be
no order as to costs.”
Similar view is expressed by this
Court on number of occasions granting relief
to the Government servants. Reference in
this respect can be made to the following
decisions:
Judgment dated 18.08.2016 in case of
Sri Kallol Roy vrs. The State of Tripura &
others in WP(C) No.277 of 2016, judgment
dated 04.05.2018 in case of Sri Uttam Pal
vrs. The State of Tripura & others in WP(C)
No.1479 of 2017 and judgment dated
27.03.2019 in case of Sri Subal Das vrs. The
State of Tripura & others in WP(C) No.895 of
2018.
In the result, the impugned order
dated
07.12.2018
is
set
aside.
The
respondents are directed to pay the
petitioner’s medical bills in question as
permissible. Such payment shall carry
simple interest @ 7.5% from the date of
completion
of
3(three)
months
of
presentation of bills till actual payment.
Entire payment be made within a period of
2(two) months from today.
Petition is disposed of accordingly.
13.
It is the admitted position that each case has got
its own pattern and every case is to be decided according to
its own merit. Sometimes in some cases it is found that the
subject matters are same and in some cases although
issues are the same but the facts differs from one case to
another case. Here in the case at hand it is the admitted
position that the petitioner went to Kolkata on 10.01.2023
and as he developed chest problem he had to attend R N
Tagore Hospital where coronary angiography was done on
11.01.2023
„PTCA
with
stenting
to
LAD
done
on
13.01.2023‟.
14.
From the judgment of this High Court and also
the fact of the present case it appears to this Court that
coronary artery blockage is such a problem which may need
immediate
hospitalization
and
immediate
treatment
otherwise the life of a person may be at stake at any point
of time and if the problem is immediately on urgent basis is
not addressed that may cause death of a person. In medical
terms “Coronary” artery disease is the most common type
of heart disease. It happens when the arteries that supply
blood to heart muscle (coronary arteries) become hardened
and narrowed. This is due to build up of cholesterol and
other material called plaque, on their inner walls. This build
up is called atherosclerosis. This can lead to chest pain
(angina) or a heart attack. Most heart attacks happen when
a blood clot suddenly cuts off the hearts‟ blood supply,
causing permanent heard damage. Over time, CAD can also
weaken the heart muscle and contribute to heart failure and
arrhythmias. Here in the case at hand the petitioner went
for medical treatment outside the State with another person
and on arrival therein he developed chest problem all on a
sudden for which he had to rush to R N Tagore Hospital
immediately
wherein
angiography
was
done.
If
the
petitioner did not undergo angiography that could lead to
danger of his life and based upon the advice of the
concerned Medical Officers he undergo this angiography and
in that case it was not possible on his part to come back to
Agartala for obtaining reference of the Standing Medical
Board. So he has availed the medical facilities since he was
entitled from one of the State referral hospital. Now the
denial of claim by the respondents authority on the ground
that similar treatment is available at Agartala cannot be a
valid ground for refusal of the genuine claim of the
petitioner. It is not the case of the petitioner that he
admitted GBP hospital at Agartala when Doctor advised him
to undergo angiograph at GBP hospital Agartala but without
adhering to the request of the concerned Medical Officer he
left for Kolkata without any permission in that case the plea
of the respondent could have been accepted that the claim
of the petitioner was not supported by any cogent reasons.
So on the plea of absence of referral certificate there was no
scope on the part of the respondents to dishonor the claim
filed by the petitioner. So considering the facts and
circumstances of the case and also in view of the judgments
passed by this Court in the aforenoted cases I am of the
considered opinion that the petitioner is entitled to the reimbursement of the medical expenses incurred by him for
his treatment at Kolkata.
15.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the
petitioner is allowed. The memo dated 02.01.2025 issued by
the Chairman, Standing Medical Board stands set aside. The
respondents are directed to examine the medical bills
submitted
by
the
petitioner
on
10.04.2023
for
re-
imbursement in view of the guidelines prescribed vide
memo dated 22.12.2022 (Annexure-23) within a period of
two months from the date of passing of this judgment
failing which the petitioner shall be entitled for interest @
9% p.a. till the payment is made.
No order as to costs.
Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2026.02.24
17:22:44 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review