Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.702 of 2023
Sri Samit Kumar Das
......... Petitioner(s);
Versus
Union of India & others
For Petitioner(s)
:
.........Respondent(s)
Ms. Sudipa Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Deputy SGI.
HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
01/02/2024
Petitioner approached this Court with the allegation that persons
junior in the merit list have been appointed though petitioner had cleared the
written examination, the Physical Standard Test (PST) and Physical Efficiency
Test (PET) and scored 58.78897 marks in scheduled caste category. During
medical examination, he was found to be suffering from hypertension and
Tachycardia which was affirmed by the Review Medical Board. Petitioner
contends that he got himself examined at AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala
and the relevant reports at Annexure-7 do not show that he is suffering from
hypertension. Therefore, petitioner has approached this Court with a prayer for
directing the respondents to admit him as Constable (General Duty) in any
force under respondents No.3 to 10. He has also prayed for a constitution of a
medical board to verify the medical fitness of the petitioner as per the
advertisement at Annexure-1.
2.
Counter Affidavit has been filed by the main contesting
respondents No. 1 to 3. Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy SGI has
specifically referred to the statements made at paragraph 2, 6 and 7 of the
Counter Affidavit and also the treatment papers of the petitioner at AnnexureR/8 [Page 179 to 180 to the writ petition] received from the AGMC and GBP
Hospital, Government of Tripura and submitted that in the Detailed Medical
Examination carried out on 17.07.202, he was found to be suffering from
Tachycardia Pulse 160/Min and Systolic Hypertension BP 172/85mm hg,
which was reaffirmed in the Review Medical Examination report. The relevant
part of the statement in the counter affidavit is extracted hereunder:
“Petitioner reported for Detailed Medical Examination (DME) on 17 July 2023
in which after examination by the Medical Officer detailed for DME, his BP was found
172/85mm hg and Pulse Rate-160/min Tachycardia. Subsequently, petitioner has been
served “Memorandum Unfit” vide Form No.01 for Detail Medical Examination of
CT/GD Exam-2022 on 18 July 2023 with reasons of (a) TACHYCARDIA PULSE
160/MIN and (b) SYSTOLIC HYPERTENSION BP 172/85 MM HG”
Further, petitioner applied for Review Medical Examination (RME) and
reported to RME Centre at CH BSF Agartala on 19 July 2023. After careful examination
by the Board of Officers (Consisting of 03 Medical Officers) detailed for RME, his BP &
Pulse rate are again found high for which petitioner was admitted in CH BSF Agartala for
observation. ECG report shows Sinus Tachycardia Low T Wave (V4.V5) Slight ST
Depression (V3). During hospitalization w.e.f. 19 and 20 July 2023 he was found to have
elevated BP & Pulse on few occasions. Therefore, the petitioner was sent for Cardiology
Opinion at AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala on 21 July 2023 and there also his BP was
found at higher side i.e. 170/90 mm hg and was advised to start T. Amlodipine 5 mg and
advised Lab investigation i.e. (TMT, 2D Echo, KFT, B/L USG Renal Art Doppler &
CBC) and to review with reports. Individual was given remote dates for lab investigation,
hence as the recruitment process was time bound matter, he was found unfit with quoting
“a case of HTN and needs further investigation & treatment” and unfit on account of
Hypertension and Tachycardia.
On the basis of DME, RME and Cardiology opinion, Petitioner was served
“Review Medical Examination Report” vide Form No.04 of CT/GD Exam – 2022 on
22 July 2023 with reasons of “HYPERTENSION and TACHYCARDIA” and
petitioner was found unfit for whole process of medical examination for recruitment to
the post of CT (GD).
It is pertinent to mention here that, RME of the petitioner has been conducted as
per revised uniform guidelines contained in MHA F.No-E.32012/ADG (Med)/DME &
RME/DA-1/2020 (Part File)/1166 dtd. 31st May 2021, UO. No.A.VI-1/2014-Rectt (SSB)
dated 20/05/2015 as well as SSC notification. Further, as per direction issued by MHA
vide U.O. No.1-45023/10/2005-Pers-II dated 24/08/2005 that no appeal against the
decision of the Review Medical Board will be entertained. Moreover, the allegation of
petitioner made against DME & RME regarding “BP apparatus machine not functioning
properly, adjusting his machine on several occasion and hitting the BP apparatus
machine” is baseless and had made false allegation.
*
*
*
6. That, with reference to the statements and averments made in para 5 of the
writ petition filed by the petitioner, it is submitted that the petitioner along with other
total 785 candidates (including petitioner) out of which 699 male candidates and 86
Female candidates qualified in PST (Physical Standard Test)/PET (Physical Efficiency
Test) conducted by Group Centre, CRPF, Agartala for recruitment to the post of CT (GD)
through SSC Exam-2022 in CAPFs, NIA, SSF and Assam Rifles. Further, it is submitted
that DG CRPF (Recruitment Branch) vide L/No.A.VI-1/2022-Rectt (SSB)-CT/GD-2022
dated 12 June 2023 entrusted responsibility to RA (Recruiting Agency) Ftr HQ BSF
Salbagan, Tripura for Document Verification (DV), Detailed Medical Examination
(DME) & Review Medical Examination (RME). The petitioner qualified in document
verification and accordingly he was issued e-admit card for appearing in Detailed
Medical Examination (DME). Accordingly, Detailed Medical Examination (DME) in
respect of petitioner was carried out on 17.07.2023 and found „UNFIT‟ for recruitment to
the post of CT (GD) due to reasons that (a) “TACHYCARDIA PULSE 160/MIN” and
(b) “SYSTOLIC HYPERTENSION BP 172/85MM HG”. Result of Detailed Medical
Examination (DME) was conveyed to the petitioner on 18.07.2023 by serving
„Memorandum Unfit‟ vide Form No.01 with direction that he can apply for Review
Medical Examination (RME). The petitioner opted for Review Medical Examination
(RME) & accordingly, Review Medical Examination of the petitioner was carried out on
19/07/2023 & again his BP & pulse rate found on higher side. Thereafter the petitioner
was admitted in Composite Hospital, BSF, Agartala for observation. ECG conducted on
the petitioner which shows Sinus Tachycardia Low T Wave (V4.V5) slight ST depression
(V3), during hospitalization w.e.f. 19 and 20 July 2023. However, virtuous support give
to the Petitioner in the form of RME (Review Medical Examination) to develop his
restorative capacity.
(Copy of the PST/PET is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure R/1)
(Copy of letter no. A.VI-1/2022-Rectt(SSB)-CT/GD-2022, dated 12.06.2023 is annexed
herewith and marked as Annexure R/2)
(Copy of the documents verification sheet of the petitioner is annexed herewith and
marked as Annexure R/3)
(Copy of e-admit card for appearing in DME is annexed herewith and marked as
Annexure R/40
(Copy of result of DME conveyed to petitioner on 18.07.2023 vide Form no.01 is
annexed herewith and marked as Annexure R/5)
(Copy of admission certificate of the petitioner in Composite Hospital, BSF, Agagartala
is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure R/6)
(Copy of ECG report of the petitioner is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure
R/7)”
3.
It is submitted that the petitioner was kept under observation in the
Composite Hospital, BSF, Agartala. His ECG report shows Sinus Tachycardia
Low T Wave (V4.V5) slight ST depression (V3). During hospitalization on 19th
& 20th July, 2023, he was found to have elevated BP & Pulse on few occasions.
Therefore, he was sent for specialist/cardiologist opinion at AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala on 21.07.2023. There also his BP was found to be at higher
side
i.e.
170/90
mm
hg
and
was
advised
to
start
T. Amlodipine 5 mg and undergo Lab investigation i.e. (TMT, 2D Echo, KFT,
B/L USG Renal Art Doppler & CBC) and to review with reports. The
recruitment process was to be completed in a time bound manner. He was
found as “a case of HTN and needs further investigation & treatment” and
accordingly declared unfit on account of Hypertension and Tachycardia.
4.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy SGI submits that if a
candidate is suffering from such a pronounced medical condition, he is
obviously unfit for discharging duties for the post of Constable (General Duty)
which involves rigorous physical activity. Therefore, the plea of the petitioner
is without merit and the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.
5.
Ms. Sudipa Nath, learned counsel for the petitioner, has sought
time to rejoin the averments made in the Counter Affidavit. However, since the
Counter Affidavit of the respondents No.1 & 3, which are the main contesting
respondents, has been served with sufficient prior notice, the petitioner if
interested could have filed a Rejoinder within time before the matter is taken
up. The statements made in the Counter Affidavit which are based on proper
medical investigation and indoor medical examination of the petitioner in a
BSF Hospital for two dates i.e. 19th & 20th July, 2023 are such which cannot be
brushed aside in a case seeking appointment to a Uniformed Forces on the post
of Constable (General Duty). In fact, upon reference to the Cardiology
Department of AGMC and GBP Hospital on 21.07.2023, petitioner was found
to be suffering from high blood pressure and was advised medicines, undergo
several investigations like TMT, 2D Echo, KFT, B/L USG Renal Art Doppler
& CBC, etc. Since the recruitment process is time bound, the employer could
not have waited for outcome of these investigation reports.
6.
In such circumstances, this Court in exercise of writ jurisdiction
cannot sit as an appellate body to question the opinion of the experts on the
question of medical fitness of the petitioner, a candidate for the post of
Constable (General Duty) in CAPFs.
7.
Therefore, this Court does not find any merit in the instant writ
petition and it is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, shall
stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pijush/
2024.02.07
PULAK BANIK Date:
15:30:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review