Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
BA No.36 of 2025
Sri Sajul Islam Purakayastha,
Son of Nasir Uddin Purkayastha,
Resident of Jalal Pur, Part 1, P.S. Kalain,
District: Cachar, State: Assam
---Petitioner on behalf
of the accused person in
custody
Sri Samim Uddin Purakayastha,
Son of Nasir Uddin Purkayastha,
Resident of Jalal Pur, Part 1, P.S. Kalain,
District: Cachar, State: Assam
---Accused person in
custody
-VsThe State of Tripura
---Respondent
For Applicant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Subrata Sarkar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Kabrabam Dhirendra Singha, Adv.
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
04/07/2025
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. S. Sarkar assisted by Mr. K. D.
Singha, Learned Counsel is present on behalf of the accusedapplicant. Learned Addl. P.P. Mr. Rajib Saha is present for the
State-respondent.
On the last date we have already heard both the sides in the
matter of granting bail to the accused-applicant. The accused was
granted interim bail by order of this court on 30.05.2025 and
thereafter his period of interim bail was further extended till
today. On 30.05.2025 at the time of hearing Learned Senior
Counsel drawn the attention of the Court that the accused was not
FIR named and no contraband item was seized from his
possession and based on the interrogation report of the coaccused and referring Annexure-J, L and K i.e. the compliance
reports Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of the
Court that in none of the compliance reports the I.O. made any
allegation against the accused-applicant showing his implication
with the alleged crime and from the compliance report only the
name of the master mind Md. Ansar Uddin and other co-accused
persons namely Billal Miah, Saddam Hosain, Saikul and Kader
were revealed and during interrogation the accused admitted that
he modified the fuel tank of vehicle bearing registration No.AS01HC-6438 for monetary benefit although he was unaware regarding
the consignment of drugs (YABA tablets) and Learned Senior
Counsel in support of his contention further submitted that the
„grounds of arrest‟ was not communicated to the accused in arrest
memo(Annexure-P) and in support of his contention in writing he
relied upon the following citations:
In Prabir Purkayastha vs. State (NCT of Delhi
dated May 15, 2024) reported in (2024) 8 SCC 254 wherein in
para Nos.28, 29, 30, 37 and 48 Hon‟ble the Apex Court observed
as under:
“28. The language used in Article 22(1) and Article
22(5) of the Constitution of India regarding the
communication of the grounds is exactly the
identical. Neither of the constitutional provisions
require that the “grounds” of “arrest” or “detention”,
as the case may be, must be communicated in
writing. Thus, interpretation to this important facet of
the fundamental right as made by the Constitution
Bench while examining the scope of Article 22(5) of
the Constitution of India would ipso facto apply to
Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India insofar as
the requirement to communicate the grounds of
arrest is concerned.
29. Hence, we have no hesitation in reiterating that
the requirement to communicate the grounds of
arrest or the grounds of detention in writing to a
person arrested in connection with an offence or a
person placed under preventive detention as provided
under Articles 22(1) and 22(5) of the Constitution of
India is sacrosanct and cannot be breached under
any situation. Non-compliance of this constitutional
requirement and statutory mandate would lead to the
custody or the detention being rendered illegal, as
the case may be.
30. Furthermore, the provisions of Article 22(1) have
already been interpreted by this Court in Pankaj
Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, (2024) 7
SCC 576] laying down beyond the pale of doubt that
the grounds of arrest must be communicated in
writing to the person arrested of an offence at the
earliest. Hence, the fervent plea of the learned ASG
that there was no requirement under law to
communicate the grounds of arrest in writing to the
appellant-accused is noted to be rejected.
37. The interpretation given by the learned Single
Judge that the grounds of arrest were conveyed to
the accused in writing vide the arrest memo is
unacceptable on the face of the record because the
arrest memo does not indicate the grounds of arrest
being incorporated in the said document. Column 9 of
the arrest memo (Annexure P-7) which is being
reproduced hereinbelow simply sets out the “reasons
for arrest” which are formal in nature and can be
generally attributed to any person arrested on
accusation of an offence whereas the “grounds of
arrest” would be personal in nature and specific to
the person arrested.
“9. Reason for arrest
(a)
Prevent
the
accused
person
committing any further offence.
from
(b) For proper investigation of the offence.
(c) To prevent the accused person from
causing the evidence of the offence to
disappear or tampering with such evidence in
any manner.
(d) To prevent such person from making any
inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case so as to
dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the
court or to the police officer.
(e) As unless such person is arrested, his
presence in the court whenever required
cannot be ensured.”
48. It may be reiterated at the cost of repetition that
there is a significant difference in the phrase
“reasons for arrest” and “grounds of arrest”. The
“reasons for arrest” as indicated in the arrest memo
are purely formal parameters viz. to prevent the
accused person from committing any further offence;
for proper investigation of the offence; to prevent the
accused person from causing the evidence of the
offence to disappear or tampering with such evidence
in any manner; to prevent the arrested person for
making inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case so as to
dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the court
or to the investigating officer. These reasons would
commonly apply to any person arrested on charge of
a crime whereas the “grounds of arrest” would be
required to contain all such details in hand of the
investigating officer which necessitated the arrest of
the accused. Simultaneously, the grounds of arrest
informed in writing must convey to the arrested
accused all basic facts on which he was being
arrested so as to provide him an opportunity of
defending himself against custodial remand and to
seek bail. Thus, the “grounds of arrest” would
invariably be personal to the accused and cannot be
equated with the “reasons of arrest” which are
general in nature.”
In Pankaj Bansal vs. Union of India and Ors.
reported in 2024 7 SCC 576 Hon‟ble the Apex Court in para
Nos.38 and 45 observed as under:
“38. In this regard, we may note that Article 22(1) of
the Constitution provides, inter alia, that no person
who is arrested shall be detained in custody without
being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds for
such arrest. This being the fundamental right
guaranteed to the arrested person, the mode of
conveying information of the grounds of arrest must
necessarily be meaningful so as to serve the intended
purpose. It may be noted that Section 45 PMLA
enables the person arrested under Section 19 thereof
to seek release on bail but it postulates that unless
the twin conditions prescribed thereunder are
satisfied, such a person would not be entitled to
grant of bail. The twin conditions set out in the
provision are that, firstly, the court must be satisfied,
after giving an opportunity to the Public Prosecutor
to oppose the application for release, that there are
reasonable grounds to believe that the arrested
person is not guilty of the offence and, secondly, that
he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail.
To meet this requirement, it would be essential for
the arrested person to be aware of the grounds on
which the authorised officer arrested him/her under
Section 19 and the basis for the officer's “reason to
believe” that he/she is guilty of an offence
punishable under the 2002 Act. It is only if the
arrested person has knowledge of these facts that
he/she would be in a position to plead and prove
before the Special Court that there are grounds to
believe that he/she is not guilty of such offence, so
as
to
avail
the
relief
of
bail.
Therefore,
communication of the grounds of arrest, as mandated
by Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 19
PMLA, is meant to serve this higher purpose and must
be given due importance.
45. On the above analysis, to give true meaning and
purpose to the constitutional and the statutory
mandate of Section 19(1) PMLA of informing the
arrested person of the grounds of arrest, we hold that
it would be necessary, henceforth, that a copy of such
written grounds of arrest is furnished to the arrested
person as a matter of course and without exception.
The decisions of the Delhi High Court in Moin Akhtar
Qureshi [Moin Akhtar Qureshi v. Union of India, 2017
SCC OnLine Del 12108] and the Bombay High Court in
Chhagan Chandrakant Bhujbal [Chhagan Chandrakant
Bhujbal v. Union of India, 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9938
: (2017) 1 AIR Bom R (Cri) 929] , which hold to the
contrary, do not lay down the correct law. In the case
on hand, the admitted position is that ED's
investigating officer merely read out or permitted
reading of the grounds of arrest of the appellants and
left it at that, which is also disputed by the
appellants. As this form of communication is not
found to be adequate to fulfil compliance with the
mandate of Article 22(1) of the Constitution and
Section 19(1) PMLA, we have no hesitation in holding
that their arrest was not in keeping with the
provisions of Section 19(1) PMLA. Further, as already
noted supra, the clandestine conduct of ED in
proceeding against the appellants, by recording the
second ECIR immediately after they secured interim
protection in relation to the first ECIR, does not
commend acceptance as it reeks of arbitrary exercise
of power. In effect, the arrest of the appellants and,
in consequence, their remand to the custody of ED
and, thereafter, to judicial custody, cannot be
sustained.”
In Vihaan Kumar vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine 269 Hon‟ble the Apex Court in
para No.21 observed as under:
“CONCLUSIONS
21. Therefore, we conclude:
a) The requirement of informing a person arrested of
grounds of arrest is a mandatory requirement of
Article 22(1);
b) The information of the grounds of arrest must be
provided to the arrested person in such a manner
that sufficient knowledge of the basic facts
constituting
the
grounds
is
imparted
and
communicated to the arrested person effectively in
the language which he understands. The mode and
method of communication must be such that the
object of the constitutional safeguard is achieved;
c) When arrested accused alleges non-compliance with
the requirements of Article 22(1), the burden will
always be on the Investigating Officer/Agency to
prove compliance with the requirements of Article
22(1);
d) Non-compliance with Article 22(1) will be a violation
of the fundamental rights of the accused guaranteed
by the said Article. Moreover, it will amount to a
violation of the right to personal liberty guaranteed
by Article 21 of the Constitution. Therefore, noncompliance with the requirements of Article 22(1)
vitiates the arrest of the accused. Hence, further
orders passed by a criminal court of remand are also
vitiated. Needless to add that it will not vitiate the
investigation, charge sheet and trial. But, at the same
time, filing of chargesheet will not validate a breach
of constitutional mandate under Article 22(1);
e) When an arrested person is produced before a Judicial
Magistrate for remand, it is the duty of the Magistrate
to ascertain whether compliance with Article 22(1)
and other mandatory safeguards has been made; and
f) When a violation of Article 22(1) is established, it is
the duty of the court to forthwith order the release of
the accused. That will be a ground to grant bail even
if statutory restrictions on the grant of bail exist. The
statutory restrictions do not affect the power of the
court to grant bail when the violation of Articles 21
and 22 of the Constitution is established.”
Finally after hearing this court granted interim bail with a
direction to the prosecution to produce the case diary. Accordingly
on 27.06.2025 Learned Addl. P.P. produced the case diary. On
27.06.2025 at the time of hearing Learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the accused-applicant relied upon the aforesaid
citations referred by him on the earlier occasion and also
reiterated his submission referring the same citations.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. P.P. in course of his
submission referred few pages of the case diary and submitted
that grounds of arrest was duly communicated to the accused and
as such there was no non-compliance from the side of the
prosecution in compliance with the requirements of law and in
support of his contention he relied upon a citation of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court of India in Kasireddy Upender Reddy vs. State
of Andhra Pradesh and Others in Criminal Appeal No.2808
of 2025 reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1228 wherein in para
No.36 Hon‟ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“36. If a person is arrested on a warrant, the grounds for
reasons for the arrest is the warrant itself; if the warrant is read
over to him, that is sufficient compliance with the requirement
that he should be informed of the grounds for his arrest. If he is
arrested without a warrant, he must be told why he has been
arrested. If he is arrested for committing an offence, he must be
told that he has committed a certain offence for which he would
be placed on trial. In order to inform him that he has committed
a certain offence, he must be told of the acts done by him which
amounts to the offence. He must be informed of the precise acts
done by him for which he would be tried; informing him merely
of the law applicable to such acts would not be enough.
(See: Vimal Kishore Mehrotra (supra)).”
Referring the same Learned Addl. P.P. drawn the attention of
the court that in view of the principle of the law laid down by the
Hon‟ble Apex Court in the aforenoted case since the ground of
arrest was already explained to the accused-applicant at the time
of arrest as such it is not required that the grounds of arrest be
communicated to him in writing and further submitted that there
was no lack on the part of the prosecution to ensure the
compliance of law and as such there is no scope to grant bail to
the accused at this stage and prayed for dismissal of the privilege
of the interim bail granted to the accused.
Considered.
I have already gone through the aforesaid citations referred
by Learned Senior Counsel for the accused-applicant in the
aforenoted cases and also gone through the citation referred by
Learned Addl. P.P. representing the prosecution.
It appears that Hon‟ble the Apex Court at the time of
delivery of the aforesaid judgment in Kasireddy(supra) discussed
about the judgment of Hon‟ble the Supreme Court of India in
Vihaan Kumar (supra) and finally in para Nos.37 and 39 Hon‟ble
the Apex Court further observed as under:
“37. In the overall view of the matter more particularly having
gone through the grounds of arrest we have reached the
conclusion that the requirement in terms of para 21(b) as laid
down in Vihaan Kumar (supra) could be said to have been
fulfilled.
39. It is needless to clarify that it shall be open for the person
arrested viz.Kessireddy Raja Shekhar Reddy and in judicial
custody as on date to apply for regular bail before the competent
court. If any regular bail application is pending as on date, the
same shall be taken up for hearing at the earliest and be decided
in accordance with law keeping in mind the well-settled
principles governing the grant of regular bail.”
Further in para No.37 of Kasireddy (supra) Hon‟ble the
Supreme Court stated that the requirement in terms of para 21(b)
as laid down in Vihaan Kumar (supra) could be said to have been
fulfilled. Para 21(b) of Vihaan Kumar (supra) is reproduced
hereunder:
“b) The information of the grounds of arrest must be
provided to the arrested person in such a manner that
sufficient knowledge of the basic facts constituting the
grounds is imparted and communicated to the arrested
person effectively in the language which he understands.
The mode and method of communication must be such
that the object of the constitutional safeguard is
achieved;”
On perusal of Annexure-P i.e. the arrest memo which has
been challenged at the time of hearing by Learned Senior Counsel
for the accused-applicant and also on perusal of the relevant
papers indicated by Learned Addl. P.P. in the case diary at the
time of hearing it appears to this court that at the time of arrest
the grounds of arrest was not communicated to the accusedapplicant by the I.O. of this case and thus the I.O. has failed to
comply with the requirements of law laid down by the Hon‟ble
Apex Court in the aforenoted cases and also the law laid down by
the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the case of Kasireddy Upender Reddy
(supra) as relied upon by the prosecution. In such a situation on
the face of materials on record it appears to this court that for
violation of Article 22(1) the accused should be released on bail
even if statutory restriction on the grant of bail exists. Herein in
the case at hand since there is statutory bar as provided under
Section 37 of the NDPS Act but since the law laid down in the
aforenoted cases is violated, as such there is no scope to disallow
the bail application filed by the accused-applicant for violation of
Article 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India. The submission
made by the Learned Addl. P.P. cannot be accepted and it appears
to this court that there was complete violation of Article 21 and 22
of the Constitution of India and as such inspite of having
restriction of Section 37 of NDPS Act the present accusedapplicant
is
required
to
be
released
on
bail
henceforth.
Furthermore, prosecution also failed to satisfy the Court regarding
application of Section-37 of NDPS Act against the accused at the
time of hearing. Hence, the bail application filed by the accusedapplicant is hereby allowed. The accused-applicant may be
enlarged on regular bail of his execution of bond of Rs.1,00,000/(one lakh) with two sureties of like amount to the satisfaction of
the Learned Special Judge (NDPS), Dhalai Judicial
District,
Ambassa with the following terms and conditions:
(i)
The accused shall appear before the I.O. once in a
week till filing of chargesheet, if any.
(ii)
The accused shall not make any attempt to tamper the
evidence on record of the prosecution.
(iii)
The accused shall not leave the jurisdiction of the Court
without prior permission of the Court.
The accused was in interim bail till today. He is to surrender
before the Learned Court of Special Judge(NDPS) Dhalai Judicial
District, Ambassa invariably on or before 12.07.2025 and shall
execute a fresh bail bond failing which necessary order of remand
be passed and till his surrender before the Learned Special Judge
he shall remain on interim bail as ordered earlier on previous bail
bond. Before departing it is needed to be mentioned here that
time and again this court informed the police authorities to ensure
compliance of law regarding “grounds of arrest” in view of the
principles of law laid down by the Hon‟ble Apex Court. But there
appears no significant improvement in this regard. So a copy of
this order be communicated to the DGP of Police, Tripura for
circulation of the same to all the Police Officers of the State of
Tripura for strict compliance of the order of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court of India. The bail application is accordingly stands disposed
of.
Further for modification of the condition of bail the accused
may
approach
to
the
concerned
court
of
Learned
Special
Judge(NDPS) Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa and the Learned
Special Judge considering the merit of the case and the report of
the I.O. may consider relaxation of bail granted to the accused. In
that case the accused-applicant shall not be required to approach
before this High Court.
Send down the record of the Learned court below along with
a copy of this order.
Returned back the CD to the I.O. through Learned Addl. P.P.
with a copy of this order.
With this observation, this application stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.07.04
06:03:32 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review