Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:759
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 41 OF 2023
1. Shri Sailendra Chandra Nath,
S/o Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath.
2. Shri Mantu Nath,
S/o Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath,
Both are residents of Vill. and P.O.- Agnibasa, Ward No. 2,
P.S- Panisagar, District- North Tripura.
3 (a) Smt. Rita Nath,
W/o Lt. Sridam Chandra Nath.
3 (b) Shri Sagar Nath,
S/o Lt. Sridam Chandra Nath.
3 (c) Smt. Sristi Nath@ Rupali Nath,
D/o Lt. Sridam Chandra Nath.
4. Sri Rinku Nath,
S/o Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath.
5. Shri Nantu Nath,
S/o Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath.
All are residents of Vill. & P.O.- Agnibasa, Ward No. 1,
P.S.- Panisagar, District- North Tripura.
.... Appellants
Versus
1. Smt. Suchitra Nath,
W/o Shri Shubhendu Bikash Nath,
Vill., P.O. and P.S. – Panisagar, District- North Tripura
.... Respondent.
2. Smt. Khela Rani Nath,
W/o Shri Promath Nath, D/o Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath,
Vill- Subhash Nagar, P.O. and P.S.- Kanchanpur, District- North Tripura.
3. Smt. Dulu Rani Nath,
W/o Shri Promath Nath, D/O Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath,
Kanchanpur, Trijangsan, Near Gas Agency, P.O. and P.S. – Kanchanpur,
District- North Tripura.
4. Smt. Tulu Rani Nath
W/o Shri Gakul Nath, D/o Lt. Suresh Chandra Debnath,
Vill- Palgaw, Satdrun, P.O.- Tiltahai, P.S.- Panisagar,
District- North Tripura.
.... Proforma-Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For the Appellants
:
Mr. R.K.P.Singh, Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mrs. Pinki Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing and date of delivery of Judgment and Order: 20.06.2026
Whether fit for reporting :
YES NO
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
Heard learned counsel of both sides.
2.
The judgment dated 01.09.2023, passed by learned District
Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar in Tittle Appeal No. 16 of 2022 and
related decree thereof are under challenge in this appeal whereby learned
District Judge set aside the judgment and decree, passed in Title Suit No. 43
of 2020 and decreed the suit of perpetual injunction of the plaintiffrespondent [here-in-after referred to as the plaintiff] by restraining the
appellant [here-in-after referred to as the defendants] and their men and
agents from entering into the suit property and from disturbing the peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the plaintiff over the suit land.
3.
The claim of the plaintiff is that she purchased the suit land from
the original owner Late Suresh Chandra Debnath [predecessor of the
defendants] by two registered deeds of sale bearing No.1-850, dated
03.03.1980 and deed bearing No.1-851, dated 03.03.1980 and since her
purchase, she has been possessing the suit land, though the same was not
mutated in her name. On the death of the original vendor, late Suresh
Chandra
Debnath,
his
legal
representatives
started
disturbing
the
possession of the plaintiff in the suit land, and on 20.09.1980, at about 8:00
am, they cut down some trees from the suit land and also threatened to
dispossess her in future. In that context, the suit was filed seeking perpetual
injunction against the defendants, their men and agents from entering into
the suit land and from disturbing the peaceful possession of the plaintiff
therein.
4.
The defendant nos.1 and 4 contested the suit by filing written
statement. They denied the entire claim of the plaintiff and asserted that their
father late Suresh Chandra Debnath borrowed Rs.10,000/- from the
husband of the plaintiff and in turn he signed on a blank stamp paper as a
token of guarantee that in the event of failure to repay the said amount
within two years, he would execute a sale deed in favour of the plaintiff in
respect of the suit land after obtaining permission from the competent
authority as it was a allotted land. It is also stated by them that said Suresh
Chandra Debnath got the allotment of the suit land with a condition that
within 10 years of the date of allotment he would not transfer it in any
manner. According to them, their father returned the said amount within the
stipulated period but said blank stamp paper was not handed over to said
Suresh Chandra Debnath by the husband of the plaintiff and now taking
advantage of the same, he created sale deed in the said blank signed stamp
paper. According to them, during the lifetime of their father he was
possessing the suit land and after his death, the defendants are possessing
the same having right, title and interest therein.
5.
During pendency of the suit, defendant no.3, Sridam Chandra
Nath died and the plaintiff filed a petition under Order XXII, Rule 4 of CPC
for substitution of legal representatives of the deceased defendant no.3.
Said petition was duly verified and was supported by an affidavit sworn by
the attorney of the plaintiff. The said petition was also allowed by the learned
trial Court.
6.
During trial, the Attorney of the plaintiff examined himself as
PW-1, one Bhupendra Nath as PW-2, Mintu Das as PW-3 and another
Narayan Nath as PW-4 to prove her possession in the suit land.
7.
Learned Trial Court while dismissing the suit observed that after
the petition for substitution of legal representatives of defendant no.3 was
allowed, the plaintiff was asked to file amended plaint on the next date fixed
for that purpose. One amended plaint was also submitted by the plaintiff but,
it did not bear the signature of the plaintiff or her Attorney and it was
antedated and no verification was also signed there and therefore, the
plaintiff was not fair and honest in seeking relief before the Court with clean
hands and exercised fraud which vitiated the trial. Learned Trial Court further
observed that record of right should be presumed to be correct unless
contrary is proved and said record of right was still lying in the name of
father of the defendants and as the amended plaint was shrouded in doubt,
the validity of purchase deeds of the plaintiff were neither proved nor
disproved and hence was not proved and finally the suit was dismissed.
8.
Learned First Appellate Court set aside the judgment and
decree of learned Trial Court and observed that the purchase deeds of the
plaintiff were 30 years old and therefore, presumption of genuineness of the
signature and other parts of the documents were in favour of the plaintiff,
whereas, the defendants did not adduce any evidence to rebut such
genuineness and taking note of the above such purchase deeds and also
the khatian, learned First Appellant Court arrived at the decision that the
plaintiff had acquired title in the suit property but failed to get the land
mutated in her name as it was a allotted land. Accordingly, learned First
Appellate Court decreed the suit by issuing perpetual injunction restraining
the defendants, their men and agents from entering into the suit property
and from disturbing the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the plaintiff
over the suit property.
9.
The appeal was admitted on the following substantial question
of law:
“Whether the impugned judgment and
decree of First Appellate Court are perverse on the
ground that said court passed the said impugned
judgment holding that the plaintiff had her right, title and
interest over the suit land, in a suit for injunction
simpliciter and also when no issue was framed
regarding her right, title and interest in respect of the
suit land.”
10.
Mr. R.K.P. Singh, learned counsel argues of behalf of the
defendants that the original owner of the suit land was the predecessor of
the defendants, and that, without any permission from the DM & Collector,
the alleged deed of transfer was made. Therefore, such transfer is void ab
initio and that the learned First Appellate Court has committed gross error in
decreeing the suit based on such deeds, and moreover, when there was no
relief sought for by the plaintiff seeking declaration of her right, title, and
interest in the suit land, learned First Appellant Court has given categorical
observation that the plaintiff was the owner of the suit land. According to the
learned counsel, such observations is totally illegal, erroneous and same is
liable to be expunged. Learned counsel further argues that the suit itself is
not maintainable inasmuch as, question of title being involved in the suit, no
declaration of right, title and interest of the plaintiff under Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act, was made, and therefore, the suit was not maintainable.
Further, learned counsel contends that no issue regarding right, title and
interest was framed by the learned Trial Court, but, despite the same, the
learned First Appellate Court observed that the plaintiff was the owner of the
suit land.
11.
Finally, in support of his contention, learned counsel relies on a
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bachhaj Nahar vs. Nilima
Mandal & Anr. vs. Civil Appeal Nos.5798-5799 of 2008, wherein it is
observed by the Apex Court that a Court cannot make out a case not
pleaded. The Court should confine its decision to the questions based in the
pleadings. Nor can grant a relief which is not claimed and which does not
flow on the facts and the cause of action alleged in the plaint, and a factual
issue cannot be raised or considered for the first time in the second appeal.
12.
He further relies on another decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Jharkhand State Housing Board vs. Didar Singh & Anr.,
Civil Appeal No.8241 of 2009, wherein it was observed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court that in each and every case where the defendant disputes
the title of the plaintiff, it is not necessary that in all those cases the plaintiff
has to seek the relief of declaration. A suit for mere injunction does not lie
only when the defendant raises a genuine dispute with regard to title and
when he raises a cloud over the title of the plaintiff, then necessarily, in
those circumstances, the plaintiff cannot maintain a suit for mere injunction.
13.
He also relies on another decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of T.V. Ramakrishna vs. M. Mallappa & Anr., Civil
Appeal No.5577 of 2021, wherein at paragraph No.10, it is observed that
where the plaintiff’s title is not in dispute or under a cloud, a suit for
injunction could be decided with reference to the findings on possession,
however, if the matter involves complicated questions of fact and law relating
to title, the Court will relegate the parties to the remedy by way of a
comprehensive suit for declaration of title, instead of deciding the issues in a
suit for mere injunction.
14.
Mr. Saktimoy Chakroborty, learned senior counsel for the
plaintiff, however, submits that no prayer for declaration of right, title and
interest was made by the plaintiff in the case; the reason may be that in the
Khatian there was mention that the transfer was barred under Section 14 of
the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms Act, 1960 [for short, TLR & LR
Act]. However, learned Trial Court erroneously took into consideration only
one part of the said relevant Khatian, wherein the name of the predecessor
of the defendants was mentioned as ‘raiyat’ of the land but ignored the 16th
column of the Khatian, wherein name of the plaintiff was mentioned as the
possessor of the suit land. Therefore, according to the learned senior
counsel, the learned First Appellate Court rightly corrected the view of the
learned Trial Court and decreed the suit. Learned senior counsel further
submits that some harsh observations were made erroneously by learned
Trial Court, stating that the pleading of the plaintiff was doubtful on a
technical ground that when defendant No.3 died, the plaintiff filed a petition
for substitution of his legal representatives, which was allowed by the Court.
However, later on, the learned Trial Court directed the plaintiff to submit a recasted copy of the plaint and took exception to the fact that the re-casted
plaint was not supported by any affidavit and was also not verified by the
plaintiff.
15.
According to learned senior counsel, such observation is
seriously prejudicial to the interest of the plaintiff, as it touches the
genuineness of her claim made through her plaint, though, as per law, there
is no necessity to submit any re-casted plaint in this regard, inasmuch as it
was not an amendment filed under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC, rather it was a
mere petition by the plaintiff for substitution of legal representatives of the
deceased defendant No.3. It was, therefore, the ministerial work of the Court
to incorporate the names of legal representatives in the cause title of the
plaint and plaintiff had no legal obligation to submit any re-casted plaint.
According to Mr. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel, the impugned
judgment of learned First Appellate Court is sound, well-reasoned and
deserves no interference, and therefore, the appeal may be dismissed.
16.
Court has considered the rival submissions of both sides and
also gone through the relevant materials placed in the record.
17.
So far the claim of ownership and possession over the suit land
of the defendants are concerned, they failed to prove the same by adducing
any evidence. On the other hand, from the side of the plaintiff four witnesses
were examined to prove the possession of the plaintiff in the suit land since
her alleged purchases, which remained un-rebutted. The related ROR of the
suit land also reflects the possession of the plaintiff in the suit land in the
relevant 16th column. Therefore, the possession of the plaintiff in the suit
land is established in this case. Thus, learned First Appellate Court
committed no error in decreeing the suit.
18.
The source of claim of such possession by the plaintiff was her
purchase of the suit land by above said two registered purchase deeds. She
did not claim any relief of declaration of her right, title and interest in the suit
land but while discussing such source of her possession, learned First
Appellate Court incidentally observes that she is having title in the suit land.
In fact, no such relief of declaration of her title in the suit land was made by
the plaintiff. Moreover, no issue was also framed therein. Therefore, such
observation of the learned First Appellate Court was not necessary at all
and was beyond the scope of adjudication and thus, such observation of the
learned First Appellate Court is expunged. The question of title of the
plaintiff is kept open. Though learned counsel, Mr. Singh relies on two
decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of T.V. Ramakrishna
Reddy and Jharkhand State House Board (supra) to bolster his
submission that there was a genuine dispute with regard to the title and a
cloud existed over the title of the plaintiff and therefore, the suit for injunction
simpliciter was not maintainable, but to justify their claim, the defendants did
not adduce any evidence in this case. Moreover, according to them their
father was an allottee of the suit land and terms and conditions of such
allotment only restricts transfer of the said land for 10 years after the date of
allotment, but they did not divulge as to when their father had got such
allotment. The sale deeds executed by their predecessor were also
registered under the provision of Indian Registration Act, 1908, therefore,
story of creation of a deed in a stamp paper is also not believable.
Therefore, the present suit is not at all a suit involved in complicated
question of title. Thus, such claim of the defendants is not sustainable.
19.
As indicated earlier, learned Trial Court has also committed
gross error by observing that just because of the reconstructed copy of the
plaint was not signed and verified by the plaintiff, the contents of the original
plaint of the plaintiff was doubtful and she exercised fraud upon the Court.
Learned Trial Court ought to have been conscious of the fact that no petition
for amendment was filed under Order VI, Rule 17 of CPC by the plaintiff
rather, she filed a petition for only substitution of legal representatives of
deceased defendant no.3 under Order XXII, Rule 4 CPC and said petition
was duly verified and supported by affidavit. When learned trial Court
allowed the said petition, it was only ministerial work to be done for
incorporation of names and addresses of legal representatives of said
deceased defendant. Therefore, such observation of learned Trial Court was
uncalled for. As already learned First Appellate Court has set aside the
judgment and decree of learned Trial Court, no further observation is made
in this regard by this Court.
20.
When the possession of the plaintiff in the suit land is
established, same is required to be protected. As per Art. 300A of the
Constitution, no person shall be deprived of his property save the authority
of law. Thus, the plaintiff cannot be dispossessed of her property except due
process of law. Learned First Appellate Court has therefore rightly decreed
the suit.
21.
In view of above such discussion, it is held that the present
appeal is devoid of any merit and accordingly, the same is dismissed.
22.
No order as to costs.
23.
Registry will prepare a decree accordingly and re-consign the
trial Court record and the record of the First Appellate Court with a copy of
this judgment and decree.
24.
Interim application, if any, stand disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.06.24 12:25:34 +05'30'
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review