The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. 01.2009 is that, the regularization shall take effect on the following day of completion of ten years of service. As such, this court is of the view that the service of the petitioner is liable to be considered for regularization, being covered by the memorandum dated 01.09.2008. Hence, the petitioner’s services shall be deemed to have been regularized w.e.f. 01.07.2008. However, the petitioner shall not get the financial benefit till 22.11.2021, the day when the petitioner has approached this court after a long delay. But from 22.11.2021, the petitioner shall be receiving the salaries and other allowances as entitled, for holding the post of the Group-D employee. Further, the respondents are directed to issue the formal order of regularization within a period of three months from today and to make payment of the arrears as would accrue by virtue of this direction within the said stipulated time. In the result, this petition is allowed. There shall be no order as to costs. The note sheet that has been produced by Mr. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 2 & 3 is taken in the records for future reference. satabdi
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP (C) No. 846 of 2021
Sri Sajal Debnath
……. Petitioner
Vs.
The State of Tripura & 3 Others
……Respondents
For petitioner(s)
:
Mr. A Bhaumik, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N Majumder, Adv.
Ms. S Deb, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
26.04.2022
Heard Mr. A Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner as well as Mr. N Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents No. 2 & 3 and Ms. S Deb, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents No. 1 & 4.
Despite opportunities granted to the respondents, none of the
respondents has filed their reply. However, Mr. N Majumder, learned counsel
has produced a note sheet along with some enclosure to apprise this court of
the status of the petitioner. The relevant information, as sought to be relied
by Mr. Majumder, learned counsel will be reflected in the appropriate part of
the judgment/order.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
stated that the petitioner was initially engaged as part time worker in the year
1983 as would be evident from the information sheet enclosed with the
memorandum dated 11.08.2004 (Anexure-1 to the writ petition). He has also
relied on the list of workers as prepared by the Department of Power
(Annexure-2 to the writ petition), where the petitioner has been shown to
have been engaged on 1983 having approval of the Finance Department. In
that list, the petitioner has been shown as PTW.
But Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel has further relied on the
communication dated 11.03.2011 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition) written by
the Deputy General Manager, Electrical Division No.1, Tripura State Electricity
Corporation Ltd., (TSECL) Agartala. This communication contains the
particulars in a proforma of DRW/contingent/Casual /part-time etc. workers,
who are working in the fixed wages at least for eight hours a day. In the said
proforma, the name of the petitioner has been shown as part time worker
(PTW).
The entire case of the petitioner has been structured on the said
communication as well as on the basis of the order dated 28.10.2013
(Annexure-8 to the writ petition). The said order has been issued by the
General Manager (Finance), Corporate Office, TSECL, where the petitioner
has been shown as PTW (full time) and having the monthly wages to the
extent of Rs.3,963/- which is equivalent to the consolidated monthly wages of
the contingent worker.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel has submitted that since the
petitioner has been acknowledged to have been working for more than eight
hours per day as part time worker and having the wages as equivalent to the
contingent worker, he cannot be categorized as a mere part time worker.
Even though he has been shown as part time worker but for all purposes he
is a full time worker and as such, he is entitled to be treated as contingent
worker for regularization, in terms of the memorandum dated 21.01.2009
(Annexure-4 to the writ petition).
It may be mentioned that the memorandum dated 21.01.2009 is
in sequel to the memorandum dated 01.09.2008 whereby the government
had adopted a policy of regularization for the full time DRW/Casual and
Contingent workers who have completed ten years of service. In accordance
with the earlier memorandum dated 01.09.2008, the persons who were
covered by the said policy of the government had been declared to get the
regularization w.e.f. 01.07.2008. But in the memorandum dated 21.01.2009,
it has been stipulated that the persons of that category who have completed
ten years of service, shall be regularized from the following day of completion
of ten years of service.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel has submitted that the petitioner is
covered by that stipulation even though he was engaged as part time worker.
An alternative submission has been advanced by Mr. Bhaumik, learned
counsel that the petitioner is also covered by the memorandum dated
07.11.2012 whereby the government has adopted a policy to declare the part
time workers, who were engaged prior to 31.03.2003 and have completed
ten years of service, as daily rated worker, Group-D w.e.f. 01.12.2012 subject
to the conditions as laid down in the said memorandum dated 07.11.2012. It
may be mentioned here that the principal condition is that those PTWs had
been paid out of the government funds.
Apart that Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel has placed his reliance
on two decisions of this court. In Smt. Ali Rani Deb Vs. State of Tripura
& 7 Ors. (judgment dated 17.09.2015 delivered in WP(C) No.16/2012) Smt.
Ali Rani Deb was also shown as a part time worker for sweeping even though
she was serving eight hours a day.
So in para 14 of the of the said judgment, this court had
occasion to observe as follows:
“14.
In the ordinary course, this court does not set out
an inquiry as to the correctness of the fact when the fact is
disputed by the respondents in as much as the disputed
facts are ordinarily to be determined on adduction of the
detailed evidence and evaluation of the same. Even to find
out the real state of affairs, an inquiry to the disputed
facts to a limited extent is not entirely forbidden. On such
inquiry it has appeared the base-level and controlling
officers have consistently stated the petitioner to be a
contingent
employee
for
full
time.
Definitely,
the
petitioner like other contingent workers deserves security
of her service after lending long 15 years of service at a
stretch as the petitioner was indisputably engaged on
01.04.1999. The basis that Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel has shown to us is the wage bill but that cannot
be
the
only basis for
determining
the
nature
of
employment.”
Having observed thus the respondents were directed to treat the
petitioner as full time contingent worker w.e.f. 01.04.1999 and regularize her
service as Group D employee in terms of the memorandum dated 21.01.2009.
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura was directed to implement the
said order within a period of three months from today.
The other decision as has been pressed by Mr. Bhaumik, learned
counsel is Sahera Begam Vs. The State of Tripura & 6 Ors. [judgment
dated 14.09.2016 delivered in WP(C) No.647 of 2015]. In that judgment, this
court was considering a plea of regularization in similar context vis-à-vis the
present case. In that case, the petitioner though was appointed as a part
time worker, but have been discharging eight hours’ duty in a day. But she
was not treated as DRW.
Having scrutinized the records as produced before this court and
the submission made by the counsel for the respondents, this court had
observed that the petitioner in Sahera Begam (supra) since has been
discharging duties for eight hours since 19.04.1996 and she has the
educational qualification of Class-VIII passed the contention of the
respondents was not accepted as those were contrary to the records. As
such, it is directed that following the memorandum dated 21.01.2009, the
petitioner shall be considered for regularization as she had been discharging
eight hours’ duty a day for more than the required years.
Mr. Majumder, learned counsel has produced the note sheet with
an information sheet in the present case. The said note was sent to the
Finance Department for purpose of declaration of PTWs as DRWs. The
information sheet attached to that note No.11 dated 26.09.2017 has also
been inspected and perused by Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the
petitioner. In the said information sheet, the petitioner has been shown at
serial No.121 where abruptly he has been shown as PTW working for four
hours. His educational qualification has been shown as Class-VIII passed. His
wages has been shown to have reduced to Rs.2,911/-, whereas in the order
dated 28.10.2013, the General Manager, Finance has certified that the
petitioner was receiving a sum of Rs.3,663/- per month.
Mr. Majumder, learned counsel has submitted that it is fiction
that the petitioner has been working for eight hours a day and the records, as
produced by the petitioner, cannot be relied as there was no proper scrutiny
by the competent authority.
Ms. S Deb, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 1
and 4 has, however, submitted that the matter exclusively relates to the
respondents No.2 & 3 and as such, the respondents cannot have anything to
contend in respect of the reliefs as urged by the petitioner.
The petitioner has no doubt prayed in this writ petition for a
direction on the respondents to regularize his services for his completion of
ten years of service as full time contingent worker in terms of the
memorandum dated 21.01.2009 from the following day on completion of ten
years of service. In the alternative, the petitioner has also urged this court to
engage the petitioner as DRW in terms of the memorandum dated
07.11.2012 including all financial benefits along with arrears of financial
benefits upon such engagement as DRW w.e.f. 01.12.2012.
Having appreciated the submission of the counsel for the parties
and scrutinized the records as placed, the questions that require to be
decided are as under:
[a] Whether the petitioner can be considered as contingent
worker (full time) from the date of his engagement? and
[b] Whether the denial of declaration as DRW in respect of the
petitioner is tenable or not?
This court has scrutinized the records very carefully. It appears
that the responsible officers have prepared the papers such as the
communication dated 11.03.2011 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition) showing
the petitioner as part time worker, working for at least eight hours a day. The
General Manager (Finance), Corporate Office, TSECL by his order dated
28.10.2013 (Annexure-8 to the writ petition) has as well categorically stated
that the petitioner has been working for full time and he is paid the wages
equivalent to the wages of the contingent worker, along with one Shri Satyajit
Roy, whose name has appeared at serial by No.1 of the said order.
All on a sudden and abruptly in the note No.11, the petitioner
has been shown to have been working for four hours. That cannot be
believed by this court. Moreover, the respondents have not filed any reply,
despite the accommodations made for filing their reply.
There is no doubt that the petitioner is entitled to be declared as
DRW in terms of the memorandum dated 07.11.2012 without any further
inquiry. But the petitioner’s alternative relief is coming in conflict with the
main relief. The main relief is for regularization of the petitioner as Group-D
employee under the regular establishment on completion of ten years of the
service in terms of the memorandum dated 21.01.2009.
This court does not find any difficulty to hold that the petitioner
is entitled to be treated as a full time contingent worker for his serving eight
hours a day, even though he was appointed as a part time worker. This court
has, in a series of decisions, held that someone who is working for eight
hours a day, even if he is engaged as part time worker, is to be
acknowledged and treated as full time contingent worker and as such, he
shall be covered by the policy as declared by the memorandum dated
21.01.2009. Therefore, the petitioner is entitled to be regularized in terms of
the memorandum dated 21.01.2009.
The said memorandum is liable to be distinguished in respect of
the effective date of regularization. The memorandum dated 01.09.2008
stipulates that those who have completed the ten years of service and
appointed before 31.03.2003 shall be regularized w.e.f. 01.07.2008. But the
stipulation of effective day of regularisation in the memorandum dated
21.01.2009 is that, the regularization shall take effect on the following day of
completion of ten years of service.
As such, this court is of the view that the service of the petitioner
is liable to be considered for regularization, being covered by the
memorandum dated 01.09.2008. Hence, the petitioner’s services shall be
deemed to have been regularized w.e.f. 01.07.2008. However, the petitioner
shall not get the financial benefit till 22.11.2021, the day when the petitioner
has approached this court after a long delay. But from 22.11.2021, the
petitioner shall be receiving the salaries and other allowances as entitled, for
holding the post of the Group-D employee.
Further, the respondents are directed to issue the formal order of
regularization within a period of three months from today and to make
payment of the arrears as would accrue by virtue of this direction within the
said stipulated time.
In the result, this petition is allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
The note sheet that has been produced by Mr. Majumder,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 2 & 3 is taken in the
records for future reference.
JUDGE
satabdi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review