Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.868 of 2021
Sri Sajal Deb
---Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
WP(C) No.90 of 2022
Sri Bidhu Bhusan Choudhury
---Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
WP(C) No.134 of 2022
Sri Bhajan Sen and Anr.
---Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
WP(C) No.165 of 2022
Sri Pranab Bhowmik
---Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
WP(C) No.278 of 2022
Sri Sukanta Debnath and Anr.
---Petitioners
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
WP(C) No.279 of 2022
Sri Dipak Chandra Das
---Petitioner
Versus
[2]
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
WP(C) No.280 of 2022
Sri Manoj Kumar Debbarma and 2 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Petitioners
---Respondents
WP(C) No.307 of 2022
Sri Ardhendu Sekhar Paul and 171 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Petitioners
---Respondents
WP(C) No.314 of 2022
Sri Bimal Majumder and 174 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Petitioner(s)
---Respondents
WP(C) No.429 of 2022
Sri Tapas Debbarma and 40 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Petitioners
---Respondents
WP(C) No.434 of 2022
Sri Kamal Ranjan Debnath and 5 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Petitioners
---Respondents
WP(C) No.439 of 2022
Sri Ardhendu Nath and Anr.
---Petitioners
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Respondents
[3]
WP(C) No.531 of 2022
Sri Firuj Kumar Debbarma and 39 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
---Petitioners
---Respondents
PRESENT
In WP(C) No.134 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mrs. Kiran Suri, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate.
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.868 of 2021
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. A. Baran & Mr. K.Debnath, Advocate.
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.165 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. A. Baran & Mr. K.Debnath, Advocate.
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.90 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
[4]
Mr. A. Baran & Mr. K.Debnath, Advocate.
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.278 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.279 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.280 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.434 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.439 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.307 of 2022
[5]
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. K. Nath & Ms. N. Ghosh, Advocates.
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.314 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. K. Nath & Ms. N. Ghosh, Advocates.
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.429 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. T. D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Roy, Mr. T. Halam, Mr. D. Kalai,
Advocates,
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
In WP(C) No.531 of 2022
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. T. D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Roy, Mr. T. Halam, Mr. D. Kalai,
Advocates,
: Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mrs. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
30.01.2023
Date of delivery of Judgment
& Order
:
23.05.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
[6]
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Petitioners are the teachers appointed at Elementary Level
under „Sarba Siksha Abhiyan‟ Scheme, now renamed as „Samagra Siksha
Abhiyan‟ (for short, “SSA”), a project introduced by Central Government.
By means of filing this batch of writ petitions the petitioners have prayed
for regularization of their services with regular pay scale with all other
allied benefits including pension, without being insisted for passing of the
T-TET examination. The petitioners have also challenged the notification
dated 30.09.2021 [Annexure-12 to WP(C) No.868 of 2021] issued by the
Government of Tripura with further prayer to revoke/rescind the same. It
is the plea of the petitioners that since they were not having minimum
qualification as prescribed under NCTE (determination of minimum
qualification for recruitment of teachers in schools) Regulations, 2001(as
amended from time to time) at the time of their recruitment, they are
illegally and arbitrarily insisted upon by the respondents to qualify/pass TTET examination for the purpose of their regularization in service.
2.
On consent of the learned counsel representing the
petitioners of this bunch of writ petitions as well as the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondents, writ petitions bearing nos. WP(C)
No.868 of 2021, titled as Sri Sajal Deb Vs. The State of Tripura and 4
[7]
Ors. and WP(C) No.134 of 2022, titled as Sri Bhajan Sen and Anr. Vs.
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors., have been taken up for hearing and final
disposal as lead cases.
3.
Brief Facts:-
3.1.
All the petitioners of this batch of writ petitions were
appointed on contract basis. Some of the petitioners, for example, the
petitioners in WP(C) No.868 of 2021 graduated with a Degree in Bachelor
of Science (Pure Science) from the Tripura University in the year 2003
and thereafter, they completed the course of Diploma in Elementary
Education (for short, “D.El.Ed”) on December, 2016 from the Indira
Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU).
The petitioner no.1, namely, Bhajan Sen, one of the
petitioners in of WP(C) No.134 of 2022 obtained Master Degree (MA) in
the year 1993. Thereafter, during the course of his service as Contract
Teacher at Upper Primary Level, the petitioner no.1 completed the course
of Diploma in Elementary Education (“D.El.Ed.”, for short) in 2017, from
IGNOU, Agartala. Pursuant to the issuance of the notification dated
10.02.2010 [Annexure-3 to WP(C) No.868 of 2021], the petitioners
became aspirant for appointment to the post of Upper Primary Teacher as
well as Primary Teacher under the Education Department, Government of
[8]
Tripura. On being selected, offers of appointment were issued in favour of
them on different dates of the year 2010.
In WP(C) No.868 of 2021, offer of appointment was issued
vide memorandum dated 04.10.2010 [Annexure-4 to the WP(C) No.868
of 2021] in favour of the petitioner Sajal Deb.
In WP(C) No.134 of 2022, offers of appointment were issued
in favour of the petitioners vide Memos dated 01.02.2010 and 20.02.2004
with honorarium of Rs.7,560/- and Rs. 2,145/- respectively for a period of
one year. However, such engagements of the petitioners were subject to
the following conditions:“1.
The engagement shall be of only 1 (one ) year on a fixed
monthly honorarium as given above.
2.
The person so engaged shall be terminated from the
engagement automatically on expiry of one year from the date of
engagement.
3.
Continuation of engagement for another year shall be
subject to satisfactory Performance of the person in the 1st year of
the engagement.
The expenditure involved on this account shall be debitable
against fund available under SSA during 2010. ”
3.2.
From time to time by way of pay revision, the honorarium of
the petitioners was enhanced. But, the services of the petitioners have
[9]
neither been regularized nor the benefit of regular pay scale has been
granted to them.
3.3.
The petitioners, have inter alia, prayed for regularization of
their services with regular pay scale including the benefit of pension
and other consequential benefits, and thus call for an end of their
services as teachers on contract basis under SSA project.
3.4.
The petitioner, namely Sajal Deb of WP(C) No.868 of 2021
had filed a writ petition, in a representative capacity, which was registered
as WP(C) No.329 of 2015 before this Hon‟ble High Court.
3.5.
After hearing the rival submissions advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the parties, a Division Bench of this Court had
disposed of the said writ petition by a judgment and order dated
23.02.2021, operative portion of which is extracted hereunder, for
convenience, in extenso:“53. We are, therefore, of the view that the petitioners must
receive the remuneration in regular scale of pay assigned to
the primary/upper primary Government teachers. The State
Government also has a policy of initial appointment of a
teacher on fixed pay basis for a period of 5 years. The same
rule can be applied in the present case also. In case of all the
petitioners thus from the date of the petitions or upon
completion of 5 years of service whichever is later, they shall
be placed in regular corresponding scales of pay for the
Government teachers. However, this pay fixation would be
for a notional purpose from the appropriate date till the date
of this judgment, of course with notional release of
[10]
increments as per the rules. Actual difference in salary would
be paid effective from the date of this judgment.
54.
The petitioners would have a right to be regularised
after 10 years of continuous and uninterrupted engagement
from initial appointment. It would be up to the Government
to consider them for regularisation either in existing vacant
posts of Government teachers or to sanction new posts as
SSA teachers by creating such cadre if so advised. It would
be open for the Government to frame a scheme providing
for further terms and conditions on which such
regularisation shall be done. However, any such scheme
shall contain a clause that the service upon completion of 5
years from initial engagement or the date of filing the
petition whichever is later, (when as per this judgment the
petitioners would notionally start receiving pay in regular
scales) till date of regularisation, the services rendered by
the petitioners shall count towards their pensionary benefits.
55.
We are conscious of the legal issues concerning
regular teachers in the Government schools which is a fall
out of the Division Bench judgment of this Court in case of
Tanmoy Nath and others vrs. State of Tripura and others
reported in (2014) 2 TLR 731, where as per further orders
passed by the Supreme Court, all those teachers who were
terminated on account of the judgment of the High Court,
would have a right to compete for fresh selections with age
relaxation granted to them up to 31.03.2023. We have,
therefore, left for the Government to regularize these
petitioners either against the existing posts or on new posts
which may be sanctioned.
56. These directions shall be carried out within a period of
six months from today.”
3.6.
The petitioners submitted repeated representations to the
Director, Elementary Education and State Project Director, Samagra
Siksha, Tripura to comply the judgment and order dated 23.02.2021 and
[11]
to regularize their services and also to facilitate their pension as per
directions ordained in the said judgment.
3.7.
The petitioners in this batch of writ petitions also have taken
a plea that, for appointment to various posts, purely on monthly fixed pay
basis under the Directorate of School Education, Government of Tripura.
The said Directorate issued a notification bearing reference No.F1(1-48)SE/E(NG)/2010 dated 25.08.2010 [Annexure-10 to WP(C) No.134 of
2022], thereby inviting applications wherein the professional qualification
i.e., B.Ed/D.El.Ed was not sought for.
3.8.
Since the services of the appointees under notification dated
25.08.2010, were neither regularized nor being given the benefit of
regular pay scale, they presented a host of writ petitions before this court,
and by a common judgment dated 18.12.2020, those writ petitions were
allowed, which attained finality since it remained unchallenged.
3.9.
In compliance of such judgment and order dated 18.12.2020,
the Directorate of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura issued a
Memorandum dated 06.08.2021 extending the benefit of regular pay scale
to those Assistant Teachers who were appointed in the year 2012, and
completed their continuous 5(five) years‟ service on of fixed pay basis. It
is pleaded that in such a case the respondents did not insist the
requirement of T.TET examination.
[12]
3.10.
It is
contended that the petitioners have been treated
differently for the reason that in purported compliance of the judgment
and order dated 23.02.2021 (Annexure-6), the State Project Director,
Samagra Siksha, Tripura had issued a notification dated 30.09.2021,
whereunder the SSA Teachers have been divided into 3(three) broad
categories, namely, Categories-I, II and III, with further sub-divisions of
Category-III into III(A), III(B) & III(C) for providing the benefit of
regularization and regular scale of pay.
3.11.
The plea of the petitioners is that the professional
qualification vis-ȃ-vis the criteria to qualify in T-TET examination are not
required for their regularization and other ancillary benefits since they
were appointed prior to 23.08.2010, i.e., the cut-off date mentioned
therein for extending the benefit of regularization.
3.12.
After the introduction of the scheme under notification dated
30.09.2021 by the Government of Tripura, the petitioners of WP(C)
No.329 of 2015 and WP(C) No.212 of 2016, initiated contempt
proceedings which were registered as Cont. Cas(C) No.66 of 2021 and
Cont. Cas(C) No.68 of 2021, respectively, for alleged non-compliance of
the judgment dated 23.02.2021 passed by the Division Bench of this
Court as quoted here-in-above.
[13]
The said contempt applications were dismissed with the
following observations:“On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the
contempt petitioners-original writ petitioners contend that the
scheme framed by the State is not in consonance with the
directions issued by the Division Bench of this Court and suffers
from various other legal infirmities.
We are of the considered view that since the State has
framed the scheme dated 30th September, 2021 which has been
appended as annexure-1 to the response filed before the Court,
we condone the delay in making of the scheme and are of the
considered view that the State having framed the scheme nothing
further needs to be done in the present contempt petitions.
However, while dismissing the present contempt petitions
we grant liberty to the contempt petitioners, if they are so advised
to challenge the scheme framed by the State of Tripura dated 30th
September, 2021 on any ground that they may feel appropriate
and the dismissal of the present contempt petitions shall not
amount to an affirmation of the scheme framed by the State in the
said regard. We are compelled to record this finding in order to
enable any person who may be aggrieved by the scheme to
challenge the said scheme and not to prejudge the scheme or give
approval of the scheme in any manner. However, we conclude by
stating that we find no ground for initiating any contempt petition
in the present nature. The judgment referred hereinabove by the
Division Bench was passed in rem.
With the observations as noted hereinabove, both the
contempt petitions stand dismissed. If any individual has any
grievance, they are free to raise such grievances.”
4.
From the aforesaid observations and directions, it comes to
fore that the Division Bench of this Court has allowed the scheme to be
introduced, however, liberty is given to challenge the scheme if they are
[14]
aggrieved of the same and the contempt petitions have been dismissed
without making further remarks on the merit of the scheme.
5.
The State-respondents have pleaded that they have
formulated the scheme vide notification dated 30.09.2021, in terms of the
direction passed by the Division Bench of this Court in WP(C) No.329 of
2015 and WP(C) No.212 of 2016 and in consonance with the NCTE
Regulations, 2001(as amended from time to time) and NCTE
Notifications dated 31.03.2010 published on 05.04.2010 and 25.08.2008
read with the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education
(Amendment Act, 2017) Acts, Rules, and Guidelines as well.
6.
I have heard Mrs. Kiran Suri, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in
WP(C) No.134 of 2022;
Mr. Somik Deb, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. Abir
Baran, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in WP(C) No.868 of
2021, WP(C) No.90 of 2022, WP(C) No.165 of 2022;
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.
S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in WP(C)
No.307 of 2022 and WP(C) No.314 of 2022;
[15]
Mr. T. D. Majumder, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.
Kaushik Roy, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in WP(C) No.
429 of 2022 and WP(C) No.531 of 2022;
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners in
WP(C) No.278 of 2022, WP(C) No.279 of 2022, WP(C) No.280 of 2022,
WP(C) No.434 of 2022 and WP(C) No.439 of 2022; and
Also heard Mr. S. S. Dey, learned Advocate General assisted
by Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. and Mrs. A. Chakraborty, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
7.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioners:-
7.1.
The entire gamut of the submissions of learned counsels
appearing on behalf of the petitioners is that the in-service untrained
teachers who have been recruited, prior to 23.08.2010 with academic
qualification, without professional qualification, at the time of initial entry
into the service are required to obtain professional qualification
(B.Ed/D.El.Ed/B.El.Ed.) only, and they are exempted from qualifying TTET examination as embodied in notification dated 18.06.2012 issued by
the NCTE. According to Mrs. Suri, learned Senior Counsel and Mr.
Somik Deb, learned Senior Counsel, the said notification dated
18.06.2012 had taken into account the proposal of the Government of
Tripura for relaxation of the requirement of minimum qualification for
[16]
appointment as teachers as provided under sub-section (2) of Section-23
of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 (for
short, “RTE Act, 2009”). Learned Senior Counsel, however, contended
that the said relaxation was granted up to 31.03.2015 subject to certain
conditions including the condition that the State Government shall take all
steps to increase the institutional capacity for preparing persons with
essential qualifications prescribed under NCTE Regulations, 2001, to
ensure that only qualified persons are appointed as teachers after
31.03.2015 and this exemption was thereafter extended by a further
Memorandum dated 19.08.2017 wherein it was provided that those
teachers who were already engaged must acquire the qualifications of a
trained teacher as prescribed by NCTE within the stipulated time on
31.03.2019. It was further contended to acquire the prescribed
qualifications. The Government of India also recognized certain online
courses through which the prescribed qualification could be obtained.
7.2.
The learned Senior Counsels appearing on behalf of the
petitioners referring to Section 23(3) of the RTE Act and Rule 11 read
with Rule 20(3) of the RTE Rules tried to persuade this Court that it
would be fallacious to contend that there is distinction between the
petitioners who were appointed under the Centrally Sponsored Scheme,
namely, SSA and the Science Graduate Teachers who were appointed
[17]
against the posts created by the Education Department, Government of
Tripura.
7.3.
According to learned counsels for the petitioners, the
petitioners of this batch of writ petitions also were appointed under
Recruitment Rules promulgated in the year 1971 wherein neither
B.Ed/D.Ed.Ed nor T-TET was there. Learned counsels in the same tune
have argued with vehemence that while framing Regulations, 2001, the
NCTE never prescribed TET to make the persons eligible for appointment
of Teachers.
7.4.
Learned Senior Counsels for the petitioners have seriously
attacked the policy of the State Government dated 30.09.2021 on the
ground that a bare reading of this notification would show that it
contemplates futuristic action, and would not have any application with
respect to any action already performed. According to Mr. Deb, learned
Senior Counsel a subordinate legislation is always prospective and cannot
be retrospective. As such, NCTE notification dated 11.02.2011 should
have prospective effect in the present cases. Since the appointments were
made prior to 11.02.2011, therefore, the State Government by no stretch
of imagination need to adhere to the guidelines in the matter of
recruitment of the SSA teachers framed by the NCTE by notification
dated 11.02.2011.
[18]
7.5.
A plain reading of Section 23(1) of the Act would show that
this is all inclusive (minimum qualifications) which includes academic
qualification, professional qualification, TET qualification. Section 23(2)
is the power to relax conferred on to the Central Government, which only
pertain, professional qualification. The proviso appended that too is only
relatable to Section 23(2) and not the entire context of Section 23. The
NCTE had published notifications extending the time for completion of
in-service teachers‟ training and also provided that the D.El.Ed. course
would be equivalent to the TET course provided it is obtained within
certain time period.
7.6.
Objections raised by the State-respondents as regards the
regularisation of the services of the petitioners for not possessing requisite
educational qualifications is not a valid objection for two reasons; firstly,
the Government itself being the recruiting agency had prescribed
minimum qualifications in the Recruitment Rules. These qualifications
were published in the recruitment notification. The respondents cannot
take the plea that the petitioners did not possess these qualifications.
Several years later the Government cannot raise the legality and propriety
as regards the recruitments of the petitioners as Teachers on the ground
that they failed to acquire the educational qualifications prescribed by
NCTE.
[19]
8.
On culmination of the entire submissions advanced by learned
counsels appearing on behalf of the petitioners, the principal issue
revolves round this batch of writ petitions is that whether acquisition of TTET pass certificate is required for regularisation of the service of the
petitioners since the selections of the petitioners were made prior to
23.08.2010. Further, what is culled out from the submissions of learned
counsels for the petitioners is that the main grievance revolves round the
inclusion of the words “at the time of recruitment” embodied in CategoryII of the notification dated 30.09.2021 issued by the Government of
Tripura.
9.
Submissions on behalf of the State-respondents.
9.1.
State Government is under obligation to abide by the
educational notifications issued time to time by the NCTE, the authorized
agency of the Central Government to issue such notifications in exercise
of its power conferred under Section 23(2) of the RTE Act. Learned
Advocate General appearing on behalf of the State of Tripura
emphatically contended that the Government had framed the scheme vide
Notification dated 30.09.2021 for regularization of the SSA Contractual
Teachers in compliance of the directions passed by a Division Bench of
this Court in earlier round of litigation, instituted by Sajal Deb, one of the
petitioners of this batch of writ petitions.
[20]
9.2.
The teachers recruited under the State Recruitment Rules,
1971 cannot be compared with the teachers appointed under SSA scheme.
In compliance with the judgment and order passed by the Division Bench
of this Court, the eligible teachers appointed under SSA scheme have
been granted regular pay scale. The scheme for regularization of SSA
teachers published under notification dated 30.09.2021 by
the
Government of Tripura conforms the educational qualification prescribed
under the NCTE Regulations, 2001(as amended from time to time) vis-ȃvis the notifications issued by the NCTE subsequent thereto. T-TET pass
certificate is a mandate in view of the notifications issued time to time by
NCTE to fulfill the object the Government of India intended to achieve. It
is the fundamental duty of the State to implement the provisions of RTE
Act in its true perspective. The notification dated 30.09.2021 dividing the
SSA teachers into 3(three) broad categories does not in any way offends
Article 14 and 16 of Constitution of India. The present batch of writ
petitions has no merit and deserves to be dismissed.
10.
Analysis.
10.1.
Keeping in mind the aforesaid submissions advanced by
learned counsels appearing for the parties and the main challenge posed in
this bunch of writ petitions as regards policy decision of Government of
[21]
Tripura as regards the regularization of SSA contract teachers, in my
considered view, it would be expedient to first refer the said policy
decision of the Government issued vide notification dated 30.09.2021,
which may be reproduced here-in-below:-
“Government of Tripura
State Project Directorate
Samagra Shiksha
Shiksha Bhavan, Agartala, Tripura
No.F.12(1207)-SE/LA/2015(L-2)/9193-9261
Dt.30th September 2021
Notification
Subject: Scheme to comply with the Judgment & Order of the Hon’ble High
Court of Tripura Dt. 23.02.2021 in WP(C) No.329/2015 and WP(C)
No.212/2016.
Erstwhile Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) was launched in Tripura in the
year 2001-02. Under SSA, primary teachers and upper primary teachers were
engaged on contract basis from 2003-04 onwards. Contractual period for such
teachers was for 1(one) year which was deemed extended from time to time, on
a continuing basis.
Besides, “Rastriya Madhyamik Shiksha Abhiyan” (RMSA) was
launched in 2009-10. From 1st April, 2018 the Integrated Scheme “Samagra
Shiksha Abhiyan” was introduced subsuming both SSA and RMSA.
Seeking regularization of contract teachers engaged under erstwhile
SSA, [now, working under Samagra Shiksha since 1st April,2018] Writ
Petitions WP(C) No.329/2015 and WP(C)No.212/2016 were filed in the
Hon’ble High Court of Tripura.
By the Judgment & Order Dt.23.02.2021 in WP(C) 329 of 2015 and
WP(C) 212 of 2016, the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura issued the following
directions.
Para 53 of the Judgment & Order states that “We are, therefore, of the
view that the petitioners must receive the remuneration in regular scale of pay
assigned to the primary/upper primary Government teachers. The State
Government also has a policy of initial appointment of a teacher on fixed pay
basis for a period of 5 years. The same rule can be applied in the present case
also. In case of all the petitioners thus from the date of petitions or upon
completion of 5 years of service whichever is later, they shall be placed in
regular corresponding scales of pay for the Government teachers. However,
this pay fixation would be for a notional purpose from the appropriate date till
the date of this judgment, of course with notional release of increments as per
the rules. Actual difference in salary would be paid effective from the date of
this judgment.”
[22]
Para 54 of the Judgment & Order states that “The petitioners would
have a right to be regularised after 10 years of continuous and uninterrupted
engagement from initial appointment. It would be up to the Government to
consider them for regularisation either in existing vacant posts of Government
teachers or to sanction new posts as SSA teachers by creating such cadre if so
advised. It would be open for the Government to frame a scheme providing for
further terms and conditions on which such regularisation shall be done.
However, any such scheme shall contain a clause that the service upon
completion of 5 years from initial engagement or the date of filing the petition
whichever is later, (when as per this judgment the petitioners would notionally
start receiving pay in regular scales) till date of regularisation, the services
rendered by the petitioners shall count towards their pensionary benefits.”
Para 55 of the Judgment & Order states that, “We are conscious of the
legal issues concerning regular teachers in the Government schools which is a
fall out of the Division Bench, judgment of this Court in case of Tanmoy Nath
and others vrs. State of Tripura and others reported in (2014) 2 TLR 731,
where as per further orders passed by the Supreme Court, all those teachers
who were terminated on account of the judgment of the High Court, would
have a right to compete for fresh selections with age relaxation granted to
them up to 31.03.2023. We have, therefore, left for the Government to
regularize these petitioners either against the existing posts or on new posts
which may be sanctioned.”
Para 56 of the Judgment & Order states that “These directions shall be
carried out within a period of six months from today.”
The Hon’ble High court of Tripura permitted the State Government to
frame a scheme providing for further terms and conditions on which
regularization of SSA teachers are to be done.
Further, Para 49 of the Judgment & Order states that “Coming to the
last of the Government’s objection regarding qualification of the teachers, to
begin with we are not inclined to go into individual qualifications held by every
teacher which of course would be a subject matter for the Government to
examine. We only propose to clear certain legal issues. If we understand
correctly the objection raised by the Government is that they do not possess
TET pass certificate. The petitioners have pointed out that they have all
cleared D.El.Ed Examinations successfully and for which they have been
granted certificates by the recognised institutions. The petitioners contend that
on account of insufficient number of teachers and insufficient number of
institutions to impart teachers’ training to such unqualified teachers in the
State, the NCTE had published notifications extending the time for completion
of in-service teachers training and also provided that the D.El.Ed Course
would be equivalent to the TET course provided it is obtained within certain
time period..........”
The contention of the petitioners as cited in para-49 with respect to
equivalence of D.El.Ed to TET is not based on facts. In the notification of
NCTE dt. 23.08.2010 passing of TET was made mandatory for the post of
primary teachers and upper primary teachers in addition to the other
prescribed minimum academic and professional (i.e. D.El.Ed/B.Ed.)
qualifications and nowhere has TET been equated to D.El.Ed.
[23]
Under these circumstances, for the purpose of regularization of SSA
contract teachers, a scheme has been framed. Pertinent to be mentioned here
that, in the scheme for regularization of the SSA teachers, on the basis of status
of acquisition of qualifications, contract teachers have been grouped into
following categories:
Category
I
II
III
Description
SSA contract teachers who have been qualified in the
Tripura Teachers’ Eligibility Test(T-TET) and have not
joined as regular teachers till 23.02.2021 (i.e. date of
Judgement & Order).
SSA contract teachers who were appointed on or after
qualifications
in
accordance
with
NCTE
(Determination of Minimum Qualifications for
Recruitment of Teachers in Schools Regulation,
2001(as amended from time to time), at the time of
recruitment.
SSA contract teachers who will not be
covered under the (I) and (II) of the above
III(A)
SSA Contract teachers who as on date
possess the requisite academic &
professional qualifications (D.El.Ed/B.Ed)
but have not cleared T-TET
SSA Contract teachers who as on date have
not acquired the professional qualifications
(D.El.Ed/B.Ed) and neither have cleared TTET.
a)
SSA Contract teachers who have not yet
acquired
the
requisite
academic
qualifications (i.e. XIIth Pass with 50%
marks) for getting admission in professional
qualifications courses (D.El.Ed/B.Ed) and
neither have cleared T-TET.
Particulars of the framed scheme is cited below:
(I)
For SSA teachers who have been qualified in the Tripura Teachers’
Eligibility Test (T-TET) and have not joined as regular teachers till
23.02.2021 (i.e. date of Judgment & Order)
These contract teachers are fully qualified in terms of the RTE Act,2009 and
NCTE Regulations, 2010 and thus they are found eligible for regularisation
with other benefits as directed in the order of the Hon’ble High Court of
Tripura dt.23.02.2021.
They will receive remuneration in regular scale of pay assigned to the
primary/upper primary Government teachers.
[24]
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
They will be placed in corresponding regular pay scale from the date of Writ
Petition or upon completion of 5 years whichever is later.
Pay fixation would be for a notional purpose from the date appropriate for
contract teacher in accordance to the Judgment and Order, till the date of
judgment with notional release of increments.
Actual difference in salary would be paid from the date of judgment.
From the date of petition or upon completion of 5 years whichever is later till
the regularization, the services rendered by the petitioners shall be counted
towards pension benefits.
All benefits accruing from Judgment & Order dt. 23.2.2021 will be granted to
them.
NB: Contract teachers who qualified in the T-TET but not yet completed 10(Ten)
years of continuous and uninterrupted engagement from initial appointment will get
the above benefits soon after completion of 10 (Ten) years of engagement.
(II)
For SSA contract teachers who were appointed on or after
03.09.2001 but prior to 23.08.2010, with the minimum
qualifications in
accordance with NCTE (Determination of Minimum Qualifications for
Recruitment of Teaches in Schools) Regulation, 2001 (as amended from time
to time), at the time of recruitment.
As these teachers were recruited in terms of NCTE Regulations, 2001 thus they
do not fall in the ambit of NCTE Regulations, 2010 and do not require to
qualify in the Teachers Eligibility Test. These contract teachers are fully
qualified in terms of the RTE Act,2009 and NCTE Regulations and thus they
are found eligible for regularization with other benefits as directed in the order
of the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura dt. 23.02.2021.
a) They will receive remuneration in regular scale of pay assigned to the
primary/upper primary Government teachers.
b) They will be placed in corresponding regular pay scale from the date of Writ
Petition or upon completion of 5 years whichever is later.
c) Pay fixation would be for a notional purpose from the date appropriate for
contract teacher in accordance to the Judgment and Order, till the date of
judgment with notional release of increments.
d) Actual difference in salary would be paid from the date of judgment.
e) From the date of petition or upon completion of 5 years whichever is later till
the regularization, the services rendered by the petitioners shall be counted
towards pension benefits.
f) All benefits accruing from Judgment and Order dt. 23.02.2021 will be granted
to them.
g) There will be no insistence from them to qualify in T-TET Examination as they
have been exempted from the same by NCTE notification dt.23.08.2010.
[25]
NB: Contract teachers who possess such qualifications by have not yet completed 10
(Ten) years of continuous and uninterrupted engagement from initial appointment will
get the above benefits soon after completion of 10 (Ten) years of engagement.
(III) SSA contract teaches who will not be covered under the (I) and (II) of
the above
(A)
Contract teachers who as on date possess the requisite academic &
professional qualifications (D.El.Ed/B.Ed) but have not cleared T-TET
a) They will receive remuneration equivalent to regular scale of pay assigned to
the primary/upper primary Government teachers. They will be entitled to basic
pay in regular scale. An annual increase of salary @ 3% per annum on 1st July
of every year will be granted to them.
b) They will be placed in corresponding regular pay scale from the date of Writ
Petition or upon completion of 5 years whichever is later.
c) Pay fixation would be for a notional purpose from the date appropriate for
contract teacher in accordance to the Judgment and Order, till the date of
judgment with notional release of increments.
d) Actual difference in salary would be paid from the date of judgment.
e) State Government will arrange coaching center facilities to these contract
teachers for preparation with respect to T-TET Examination.
f) Regularization with all allied benefits will be accorded towards them with
effect from the date of passing the T-TET examination, in strict accordance
with Judgment and Order dt. 23.02.2021.
g) Age relaxation will be given to them for as many years as may be required by a
particular teacher, so that he/she may be recruited given he/she clears T-TET
in next 5(Five) years i.e. till end of academic year 2025-26.
h) State Government will also legally examine whether for those SSA teachers
who have cleared Central Teachers’ Eligibility Test (C-TET) can be accepted
as equivalent to clearing Tripura Teachers’ Eligibility Test (T-TET), by
consulting NCTE.
(B)
Contract teachers who as on date have not acquired the professional
qualifications (D.El.Ed/B.Ed) and neither have passed T-TET.
a) Those contract teachers who till date have not acquired D.El.Ed/B.Ed will be
accommodated in the Teacher Training Institute of the State for undergoing
such courses, without undergoing any entrance test or selection process, on the
basis of marks on the assumption that they possess 50% in XIIth Class. Also,
the course design will be so prepared that they can study in D.El.Ed and teach
in schools to earn their salary simultaneously.
b) After acquisition of D.El.Ed/B.Ed qualifications, they will be facilitated for
admission in coaching center with respect to T-TET examination and all
benefit under III(A) will accrue to them also on attaining of D.El.Ed/B.Ed.
[26]
(C)
Contract teachers who have not yet acquired the requisite academic
qualifications (i.e. XIIth Pass with 50% marks) for getting admission in
professional qualifications courses (D.El.Ed/B.Ed) and neither have passed TTET.
a) Those contract teachers who have not acquired requisite academic
qualifications i.e. XIIth pass with 50% marks will be facilitated to undergo
relevant courses in NIOS.
b) After acquisition of XIIth pass with 50% marks, they will be facilitated for
professional courses and coaching center for T-TET examination with other
measures as prescribed in III(A) and III(B) of the above, with all constituent
benefits in accordance with III(A) and III(B) of above.
In Para 49 of the Judgment & Order dt. 23.02.2021, reference has been made
to the contention of the petitioners before the Hon’ble High Court that all the
concerned contract teachers have cleared D.El. Ed Examinations successfully.
(D)
(E)
But, as per the information available with the Department as on date, there
some contract teachers who have neither acquired the professional
qualifications (D.El.Ed/B.Ed) nor have cleared T-TET. Come SSa contract
teachers have not yet acuqried the requisite academic qualifications (i.e. XIIth
Pass with 50% marks) for even getting admission to professional qualification
courses (D.El.Ed).
For the contract teachers pertaining to III(B) and III(C) the process of
acquiring D.El.Ed/B.Ed should be completed within 5(Five) years i.e. by the
end of academic session 2025-26. In case of failure to do so, the State
Government will be constrained to take measures as per the directions
conveyed vide letter no. DO No. 17-22017-EE/17 Dt. 03.08.2017 of the
Additional Secretary (EE-II), MHRD, GoI.
Teachers in category III(B) and III(C) would continue as contractual
employees for 5 (five) years or till they acquire educational and training
qualifications whichever is earlier.
(By giving five year’s time, the State Government is going beyond the
provisions of RTE Act, NCTE norms and letter dated 03.08.2017 cited above
which clearly states that 1st April, 2019 shall be last date for teachers to
acquire requisite minimum qualifications as mandated by RTE Act,2009).
In view of these constrains, for the SSA contract teachers presently
under the category III(B) and III(C), regular scale of pay has not been
proposed.
Further, District Education Officers (DEOs) will be provided separate
formats for each category of the contract teachers as specified in the scheme.
DEOs will take necessary action for the collection of filled up formats from the
SSA contract teachers under their respective jurisdiction and will verify their
[27]
year of engagement, academic and professional qualifications and forward the
same to the State Project Directorate for next course of action.
This scheme has been issued with the approval accorded by the
Government of Tripura and the Governing Council of Samagra Shiksha
Abhiyan Rajya Mission, Tripura.
(Chandni Chandran, IAS)
State Project Director
Samagra Shiksha,
Tripura.”
10.2.
For deciding the primary issues involved in this batch of writ
petitions, Category-II of the notification dated 30.09.2021 is important
and relevant. At the cost of repetition, but, for convenience, the said
Category-II is again extracted here-in-below:“For SSA contract teachers who were appointed on or after
03.09.2001 but prior to 23.08.2010, with the minimum
qualification in accordance with NCTE (Determination of
Minimum Qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools)
Regulation, 2001 (as amended from time to time), at the time of
recruitment.”
10.3.
The language of Category-II makes it clear that the teachers,
who were recruited in terms of NCTE Regulations, 2001, do not fall
within the ambit of the NCTE Notifications, 2010 and do not require to
qualify in the Teachers Eligibility Test (“TET”). According to policy
decision of the Government of Tripura, these Contractual Teachers are
eligible for regularisation with other benefits as directed by this Court
vide order dated 23.02.2021.
[28]
11.
In this batch of writ petitions, all the petitioners were
appointed on or after 03.09.2001, but prior to 23.08.2010. According to
policy decision of the Government, dated 30.09.2021, these contract
Teachers must be having minimum qualifications as prescribed under the
NCTE Regulations, 2001 at the time of their recruitment. In view of this,
it is necessary to have a look into the NCTE Regulations, 2001, which is
reproduced here-in-below:“National Council for Teacher Education
F. No. 9-2/2001/NCTE
I.G.I. Stadium, I,P. Estate
New Delhi – 110002
New Delhi, 3rd September, 2001
In exercise of the powers conferred under clause (d)(i) of subsection (2) of Section 32 read with Section 12(d) of the National
Council for Teacher Education Act, 1993 (73 of 1993), the Council
hereby makes the following Regulations:
1. Short title and commencement
These Regulations may be called the NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR
TEACHER EDUCATION (DETERMINATION OF MINIMUM
QUALIFICATIONS FOR RECRUITMENT OF TEACHERS IN
SCHOOLS) REGULATIONS, 2001.
They shall come into force on the date of their publication in the
Official Gazette.
2. Applicability
These Regulations shall be applicable for recruitment of teachers in
all formal schools established, run or aided or recognised by
Central or State Government and other authorities for imparting
education at elementary (primary and upper primary/middle
school), secondary and senior secondary stages.
3. Qualifications for Recruitment
[29]
i) The qualifications for recruitment of teachers in educational
institutions mentioned in Section 2 above shall be as given in
the First and Second Schedules to these Regulations. The
qualifications prescribed in the First Schedule shall apply for
recruitment of teachers for teaching school subjects. The
qualifications prescribed in the Second Schedule shall apply for
recruitment of teachers for Physical Education.
ii) For recruitment of teachers for co-curricular activities such as
work experience, art education, etc., existing qualifications or such
other qualifications as may be prescribed by the concerned
government shall apply.
iii) For promotion of teachers from one level to the next level of
teaching, minimum qualification as given in the Schedules for the
concerned level would be required.
4. Amendment of Recruitment Rules
The existing recruitment rules may be modified within a period of
three years so as to bring them in conformity with the qualifications
prescribed in the Schedules. Meanwhile, teachers appointed as per
the existing recruitment qualifications, subsequent to the issue of
these Regulations, will be required to acquire qualifications as
prescribed in the Schedules.
5. Power to relax
Where the Council is satisfied, on receipt of reference from the
concerned Government, that special circumstances exist warranting
relaxation of some of the provisions of the regulations for sometime
it may grant relaxation of that provision to such extent and subject
to such conditions as it may consider necessary in a just and
equitable manner.
6. Interpretation
If any question arises relating to interpretation of these Regulations
or equivalence of various teachers’ training programmes, decision
of the Council shall be final.
(S.K.RAY)
Member Secretary
First Schedule to the National Council for Teacher Education
(Determination of Qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers)
Regulations 2001
Recruitment qualifications for recruitment of teachers in educational
institutions mentioned in Section 2 of the Regulations
[30]
LEVEL
MINIMUM ACADEMIC AND PROFESSIONAL
QUALIFICATIONS
I Elementary
a. Primary
b. Upper Primary (Middle school
section)
***
11.1.
i. Senior Secondary School certificate or
Intermediate or its equivalent ; and
ii. Diploma or certificate in basic teachers’
training of a duration of not less than two
years.
OR
Bachelor of Elementary Education (B.El.Ed.)
i. Senior Secondary School certificate or
Intermediate or its equivalent ; and
ii. Diploma or certificate in elementary
teachers training of a duration of not less
than two years.
OR
Bachelor of Elementary Education (B.El.Ed.)
OR
Graduate with Bachelor of Education (B.Ed.)
or its equivalent course.
*** *** *** ”
All the petitioners herein were appointed at Elementary
Level i.e. Primary and Upper Primary (Middle School Section) after
03.09.2001 and prior to 23.08.2010. A plain reading of Clause 3 read with
First Schedule of NCTE regulations, 2001 as quoted here-in-above, it
comes to fore, that to get appointed as teachers at primary level one must
have (i) Senior Secondary School Certificate or Intermediate or its
equivalent; and (ii) Diploma or Certificate in basic teachers‟ training of a
duration of not less than two years or Bachelor of Elementary Education
(B.El.Ed.). For appointment to the post of Upper Primary Level one must
possess (i) Senior Secondary School certificate or Intermediate or its
[31]
equivalent; and (ii) Diploma or Certificate in elementary teachers training
of a duration of not less than two years or Bachelor of Elementary
Education (B.El.Ed.) or Graduate with Bachelor of Education (B.Ed.) or
its equivalent.
11.2.
It is further clarified under “Note” of NCTE Regulations,
2001 that for appointment of teachers for primary classes, basic teachers’
training programme of 2(two) years duration is required, and B.Ed is not a
substitute for basic teachers training.
11.3.
On close reading of the policy decision of the State
Government under notification dated 30.09.2021, according to me, it is in
the line of NCTE Regulations, 2001 and NCTE Notifications, 2010
(principal notification) as amended vide notification dated 29.07.2011.
Under the said amendment a new sub-clause has been inserted as 5(b) in
Clause 5 of NCTE regulations, 2010. No change has been carried out in
Clause 5 of principal notification except it is inserted as 5(a) in
regulations, 2011.
11.4.
I have taken note of the submission of Mrs. Suri and Mr.
Deb, learned Senior Counsels for the petitioners as regards their objection
that the words “at the time of recruitment” embodied in category-II of
the States‟ notification dated 30.09.2021 is inconsistent and an arbitrary
[32]
criteria contrary to the spirit of NCTE Regulations, 2010 vis-ȃ-vis
notification dated 18.06.2012.
11.5.
Under clause (g) of Category-II of the said notification
extracted here-in-above there will be no insistence for the teachers to
qualify in T-TET examination as they have been exempted from the same
by NCTE notification dated 23.08.2010.
12.
Referring to para-5 of the notification dated 23.08.2010,
learned Senior Counsels for the petitioners emphatically contended that
the said notification gives an exemption to the State Governments or local
authorities from the requirement of TET if the advertisement to initiate
the process of appointment of teachers was issued prior to the notification
dated 23.08.2010, which is explained and clarified by the communication
dated 05.09.2013. Therefore, according to learned Senior Counsels, for
the candidates who have to be appointed based on advertisements and
selection process initiated prior to 23.08.2010, passing of TET is not
required. It is further contended that Para-5 of the notification dated
23.08.2010 also indicates that process of appointment of teachers initiated
prior to 23.08.2010 has to be in accordance with NCTE Regulations, 2001
which provides academic and professional qualification. However, the
Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India vide
notification dated 18.06.2012 has accorded relaxation to the State
Government of Tripura for a period up to 31.03.2015 for appointment of
teachers under relaxed professional qualification norms. The relaxation is
[33]
subject to the condition that teachers appointed under relaxed
qualification norms shall acquire the minimum qualification within a
period of 2(two) years from appointment (Para-2(vi) of the notification
dated 18.06.2012).
12.1.
To summarize, learned Senior Counsels appearing on behalf
of the petitioners have mainly harped upon the following eventualities in
support of their plea that T-TET examination or passing of T-TET criteria
is not required at all for regularization of the petitioners and for providing
them all allied service benefits including:“I. If a particular post of SSA Teacher has been created, before
23.08.2010;
II. If a particular vacancy of SSA Teacher has arisen before
23.08.2010;
III. If a selection process is initiated, for filling up such vacancy of
SSA Teacher prior to such date (23.08.2010);
IV. If an advertisement is issued for filling up such vacancy of SSA
Teacher prior to such dated (23.08.2010).”
12.2.
In view of the aforesaid submissions, the notification dated
23.08.2010 appears to play a pivotal role and is relevant to examine and
decide the question of consistency between the State‟s notification dated
30.09.2021 and NCTE notifications issued time to time including the
notification dated 23.08.2010. For this purpose, it is worthy to start with
Para-5 of the notification dated 23.08.2010 which may be reproduced
hereunder since it will assist the Court in its quest to find out an
[34]
answer relating to issue of consistency between State‟s notification and
NCTE notifications.:“5.
Teacher appointed after the date of this Notification in
certain cases:- Where an appropriate Government, or local
authority or a school has issued an advertisement to initiate the
process of appointment of teachers prior to the date of this
Notification, such appointments may be made in accordance with
the NCTE (Determination of Minimum Qualifications for
Recruitment of Teachers in Schools) Regulations, 2001 (as amended
from time to time)”
It is pertinent to mention herein that Clause 5(a) of regulations,
2011 is pari materia to Clause 5 stated above.
12.3.
This notification dated 23.08.2010 had been clarified by the
communication dated 05.09.2013 as claimed by the petitioners which may
be reproduced hereunder:“VRINDA SARUP
ADDITIONAL SECRETARY
Tele: 23383226
Fax: 23070584
D.O. No.1-17/2010-EE(4) (Pt.)I.
5th September, 2013
Dear
Please refer to your letter No.F.13(3-60)-SE/GL-I/2013(L-I)
dated 20th August, 2013 regarding appointment of teachers in
elementary schools for which advertisements were issued by the
Government of Tripura in 2002, 2006, 2009.
2. The National Council of Teacher Education (NCTE) had notified
minimum qualification for appointment of teachers on 23rd August,
2010(copy enclosed). The notification provided for academic
qualification, professional qualification i.e. Diploma in Elementary
Education/B.Ed. for appointment of teachers for class I-V and classes
[35]
VI-VIII respectively. It also made it mandatory for candidates to pass
Teacher Eligibility Test(TET) to be conducted by the appropriate
Government in accordance with the guidelines framed by the NCTE.
Para 5 of the notification gives an exemption to State governments or
local authority from the requirement of TET if the advertisement to
initiate the process of appointment of teachers was issued prior to the
notification of 23rd August, 2010. Therefore, for the candidates who
have to be appointed based on advertisements and selection process
initiated prior to 23rd August, 2010, passing TET is not required.
3. The para 5 of notification of 23rd August, 2010 also indicates that
the process of appointment of teachers initiated prior to 23rd August,
2010 has to be in accordance with NCTE(determination of minimum
qualification for recruitment of teachers in schools) Regulations
2001(as amended from time to time). The NCTE Regulation of 2001
provides for an academic and professional qualification. The Ministry
of HRD vide notification of 18th June, 2012 has granted relaxation to
the State Government of Tripura for a period up to 31st March, 2015
for appointment of teachers under relaxed professional qualification
norms. The relaxation is subject to the condition that teachers
appointed under relaxed qualification norms shall acquire the
minimum qualification within a period of two years from appointment
(para 2(vi) of the notification dated 18th June, 2012).
4. It is for the Government of Tripura to appoint teachers who have
the requisite academic qualification as stipulated in NCTE
Regulations 2001 and get these teachers trained within two years of
their appointment.
5. It would not be possible for the Government of India to consider
any relaxation in academic qualification at all.
6. Any TET relaxation for teacher recruitment process initiated after
NCTE notification of 23rd August, 2010 also will not be possible.
Yours sincerely,
-Sd illegible
(Vrinda Sarup)”
12.4.
From a plain reading of the above communication, it is clear
that exemption has been given to those teachers who were appointed as
[36]
teachers prior to 23.08.2010 provided that they must possess the
qualification as prescribed under NCTE Regulations, 2001.
12.5.
On careful reading of the said communication dated
05.09.2013, it comes to fore that in case the recruitment process for
appointment of teachers for classes I-V and classes VI-VIII, TET was not
required, but, this relaxation was made subject to the condition that
teachers appointed under relaxed qualification norms would have to
acquire the minimum qualification within a period of two years from the
year of appointment as stipulated in Para(vi) of the notification dated
18.06.2012 which may be extracted herein, for convenience, in extenso:“2.
The relaxation granted under this notification shall be
valid for a period upto 31st March, 2015, subject to fulfillment of
following conditions, namely:i. …..
ii. ….
iii. …..
iv. ……
v. ….
vi. The State Government and other school management shall
ensure that teachers who are appointed under relaxed
qualification norms acquire the minimum qualification specified
in the said notification within a period of two year of
appointment.”
12.6.
It is noticed that notification dated 18.06.2012 issued by the
Ministry of HRD, Government of India in pursuance of a proposal made
[37]
by the State of Tripura, in my opinion, sub Paras-(i), (vii) and (viii) are
also relevant herein which is produced here-in-below:“2. (i) the State Government of Tripura shall conduct the Teacher
Eligibility Test as specified in the said Notification as amended from
time to time, of the Council in accordance with the Guidelines for
conducting Teacher Eligibility Test, dated the 11th February, 2011
issued by the Council and those persons who pass the Teacher
Eligibility Test be considered for appointment as a teacher in classes I
to VIII;
(vii) the State Government shall take steps to increase the institutional
capacity for preparing persons with specified qualifications so as to
ensure that only qualified persons are appointed as teachers in classes
I to VIII after the 31st March, 2015 and for this purpose the State
Government shall prepare a strategy for increasing the institutional
capacity for teacher preparation in the State and submit the same to
the Central Government within a period of two months, and
thereafter, submit a Report to the Central Government in every six
months with regard to the steps taken, including increasing capacity
in existing teacher education institutions, establishment of new
teacher education institutions, and other steps, to implement the
strategy for increasing teacher preparation capacity in the State; and
(viii) the relaxation specified in this notification shall be one-time and
no further relaxation under sub-section(2) of section 23 shall be
granted to the State of Tripura.”
12.7.
It is further noticed that clarifying the notification dated
18.06.2012,
the
Ministry
of
HRD,
Government
of
India
by
communication dated 05.09.2013 had categorically stated that TET was
mandatory for teachers and those persons who qualify TET would be
considered for appointment as teacher under clauses (i) to (viii). It is
further mentioned in the said communication dated 05.09.2013 that it was
for the Government of Tripura to appoint Teachers who possess the
[38]
requisite academic qualification as stipulated in NCTE Regulations, 2001
and got those teachers trained within two years of their appointment and it
would not be possible for the Government of India to consider any
relaxation in academic qualification at all.
12.8.
Here, it will be pertinent to mention the minimum
qualifications prescribed by the National Council for Teachers Education
(NCTE) under notification dated 23.08.2010, which was notified in
exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section(1) of Section 23 of the
Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009(for short,
RTE Act, 2009) and in pursuance of notification dated 31.03.2010 issued
by the Department of School Education and Literacy, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India, the National Council for
Teacher Education (NCTE):“NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 23rd August, 2010
F.No.61-03/20/2010/NCTE/(N&S).–In exercise of the powers
conferred by Sub-section (1) of Section 23 of the Right of Children
to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009(35 of 2009), and in
pursuance of Notification No.S.O.750(E) dated 31st March, 2010
issued by the Department of School Education and Literacy,
Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India,
the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) hereby lays
down the following minimum qualifications for a person to be
eligible for appointment as a teacher in class I to VIII in a school
referred to in clause (n) of Section 2 of the Right of Children to Free
[39]
and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, with effect from the date of
this Notification:1. Minimum Qualifications.(i) Classes I-V
(a)
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50%
marks and 2- year Diploma in Elementary Education (by whatever
name known)
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 45% marks and 2year Diploma in Elementary Education (by whatever name known),
in accordance with the NCTE (Recognition Norms and Procedure),
Regulations 2002
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4year Bachelor of Elementary Education (B.El.Ed.)
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 2year Diploma in Education (Special Education)
AND
(b) Pass in the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET), to be conducted by the
appropriate Government in accordance with the Guidelines framed
by the NCTE for the purpose.
(ii) Classes VI-VIII
(a) B.A/B.Sc and 2- year Diploma in Elementary Education (by
whatever name known)
OR
B.A/B.Sc. with at least 50% marks and 1-year Bachelor in Education
(B.Ed)
OR
B.A/B.Sc. with at least 45% marks and 1-year Bachelor in Education
(B.Ed), in accordance with the NCTE (Recognition Norms and
Procedure) Regulations issued from time to time in this regard.
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4year Bachelor in Elementary Education (B.El.Ed)
[40]
OR
Senior Secondary(or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4year BA/B.Sc.Ed.
OR
B.A/B.Sc. with at least 50% marks and 1-year B.Ed.(Special
Education)
AND
(b) Pass in the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET), to be conducted by the
appropriate Government in accordance with the Guidelines framed
by the NCTE for the purpose.
2. Diploma/Degree Course in Teacher Education.- For the
purposes of this Notification, a diploma/degree course in teacher
education recognized by the National Council for Teacher
Education(NCTE) only shall be considered. However, in case of
Diploma in Education(Special Education) and B.Ed(Special
Education), a course recognized by the Rehabilitation Council of
India(RCI) only shall be considered.
3. Training to be undergone.-A person –
(a) with B.A/B.Sc. with at least 50% marks and B.Ed. qualification
shall also be eligible for appointment for class I to V upto 1st
January, 2012, provided he undergoes, after appointment, an NCTE
recognized 6-month special programme in Elementary Education.
(b) with D.Ed(Special Education) or B.Ed(Special Education)
qualification shall undergo, after appointment, an NCTE recognized
6-month special programme in Elementary Education.
4. Teacher appointed before the date of this Notification.-The
following categories of teachers appointed for classes I to VIII prior
to date of this Notification need not acquire the minimum
qualifications specified in Para(1) above.:
(a) A teacher appointed on or after the 3rd September, 2001 i.e. the
date on which the NCTE (Determination of Minimum Qualifications
for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools) Regulations, 2001 (as
amended from time to time) came into force, in accordance with that
Regulation.
Provided that a teacher of class I to V possessing B.Ed qualification,
or a teacher possessing B.Ed(Special Education) or D.Ed(Special
[41]
Education) qualification shall undergo an NCTE recognized 6month special programme on elementary education.
(b) A teacher of class I to V with B.Ed qualification who has
completed a 6-month Special Basic Teacher Course (Special BTC)
approved by the NCTE;
(c) A teacher appointed before the 3rd September, 2001, in
accordance with the prevalent Recruitment Rules.
5. Teacher appointed after the date of this Notification in certain
cases.- Where an appropriate Government, or local authority or a
school has issued an advertisement to initiate the process of
appointment of teachers prior to the date of this Notification, such
appointments may be made in accordance with the
NCTE(Determination of Minimum Qualifications for Recruitment of
Teachers in Schools) Regulations, 2001(as amended from time to
time).
HASIB AHMAD, Member-Secy.
[ADVT III/4/131/10-Exty.]”
12.9.
On plain reading of NCTE notification dated 23.10.2010
together with NCTE Regulations, 2001(as amended from time to time), it
is seen that under notification dated 23.08.2010 the Central Government
and the NCTE for the first time had introduced criteria that one must pass
in Teachers Eligibility Test(TET), to be conducted by the appropriate
Government in accordance with the guidelines framed by the NCTE for
appointment of teachers at elementary level (classes I-V and classes VIVIII).
12.10.
Drawing my attention to Paragraphs-4 and 5 of the
notification dated 23.08.2010, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners
strenuously argued that under the said paragraphs it was clearly stated that
[42]
the teachers appointed for classes I-VIII on or after 03.09.2001, i.e. the
date on which NCTE Regulations, 2001 (as amended from time to time)
came into force and teachers of classes I-V with B.Ed. qualification
having completed six months special basic teacher course (Special BTC)
approved by the NCTE and recruitment process initiated by an
appropriate Government under Regulation, 2001(as amended from time to
time) were not required to pass TET.
12.11
In view of aforesaid submissions, Clause 4 of NCTE
notifications, 2010 requires further analysis. Clause 4 classifies 3(three)
categories of teachers, who “need not acquire minimum qualifications
specified in Para (1) above”. Para(1) means Para(1) of notifications, 2010,
which prescribes “minimum qualification”. Para(1)(b) specifies the
requirements to pass TET.
Without any sort of hesitation, I may hold the expression “in
accordance with that Regulation” embodied in Clause 4(a) of NCTE
notifications, 2010 means and connotes the essential requirements laid
down under NCTE Regulations, 2001
As it is quoted and already discussed in the preceding
paragraphs that NCTE Regulations, 2001 prescribes both academic and
professional qualification (D.Ed./B.El.Ed./B.Ed.) as mentioned in the
“First Schedule” of the said regulation.
[43]
Under Clause 4(a) of NCTE notification, 2010, it is stated
that a teacher who is recruited /appointed on or after 03.09.2001 in
accordance with NCTE Regulations, 2001 does not require minimum
qualification as specified in Para (1)(b) of NCTE notifications, 2010
prescribing to qualify/pass TET.
Again, under Clause 5 of NCTE notifications, 2010 read with
Clause 5(a) of NCTE amended notification dated 29.07.2011, it is
categorically stated that where an appropriate Government or local
authority or a school has issued advertisement to initiate the process of
appointment of teachers prior to the NCTE notification, 2010, such
appointments may be made in accordance with the NCTE Regulations,
2001 as amended from time to time.
12.12.
Now, the cardinal question is whether the petitioners of this
batch of writ petitions possess minimum qualifications as prescribed
under NCTE Regulations, 2001 at the time of their recruitment to claim
the benefit of exemption from qualifying T-TET.
13.
Upon hearing the learned counsels for the petitioners, it is
admitted position that none of the petitioners had acquired the prescribed
minimum qualifications, because, at the time of their initial recruitment,
they did not possess the required qualifications like D.El.Ed. or certificate
in basic teachers‟ training of a duration of not less than two years or
[44]
Bachelor of Elementary Education (B.El.Ed.) or Graduate with Bachelor
of Education (B.Ed.) or its equivalent. It is further noted that appointment
of teachers for primary classes, basic teachers training programmes of two
years‟ duration is required and B.Ed is not a substitute for basic Teachers
training programs.
14.
On conjoint reading of NCTE Regulations, 2001 and sub
paras (a) and (b) of para 4 and 5 of the notification dated 23.08.2010, I
may unhesitantly hold that exemption from qualifying/passing T-TET has
only been given to those teachers who were having minimum
qualifications as prescribed in NCTE regulations, 2001 at the time of their
initial recruitment.
15.
Now, it is to be seen whether the policy decision taken by the
Government of Tripura under notification dated 13.09.2021 suffers from
the vice of unreasonableness or unarbitrariness. In pursuance of the
judgment and order passed by the Division Bench of this Court, the
Government of Tripura has framed the scheme, and the SSA Teachers, i.e.
the petitioners herein who were appointed on contract basis under the
SSA project have been grouped into following categories:“Category
Description
I
SSA contract teachers who have been qualified in the
Tripura Teachers’ Eligibility Test (T-TET) and have not
joined as regular teachers till 23.02.2021(i.e. date of
[45]
Judgment & Order).
II
SSA contract teachers who were appointed on or after
03.09.2001 but prior to 23.08.2010, with the minimum
qualifications in accordance with NCTE(Determination
of Minimum Qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers
in Schools) Regulation, 2001(as amended from time to
time), at the time of recruitment.
III
SSA contract teachers who will not be
covered under the (I) and (II) of the above
III(A)
SSA Contract teachers who as on date
possess
the
requisite
academic
&
professional qualifications (D.El.Ed/B.Ed)
but have not cleared T-TET
III(B)
SSA Contract teachers who as on date have
not acquired the professional qualifications
(D.El.Ed/B.Ed) and neither have cleared TTET.
III(C)
SSA Contract teachers who have not yet
acquired
the
requisite
academic
qualifications(i.e. XIIth Pass with 50%
marks) for getting admission in professional
qualifications courses (D.El.Ed/B.Ed) and
neither have cleared T-TET.”
Category-I is not relevant to decide the present controversy because
none of the petitioners has qualified in the Tripura Teachers Eligibility
Test (T-TET). Category-II is relevant herein which is to be examined
whether it is in consonance with paras-4 and 5 of the notification dated
23.08.2010.
[46]
16.
The primary objection raised by the learned counsel for the
petitioners was the use of words and expression “at the time of
recruitment” embodied in Category-II of the Scheme formulated by the
State vide notification dated 23.02.2021.
There is no dispute in the Bar that all the petitioners of this
batch of writ petitions were appointed under SSA project on contract basis
on or after 03.09.2001, i.e. the cut-off date of introduction of NCTE
Regulations, 2001 and prior to 23.08.2010. The policy makers under
Category-II have decided that such teachers who were recruited in terms
of NCTE Regulations, 2001 were not required to qualify in the Teachers
Eligibility Test (TET) since these contract Teachers were fully qualified
in terms of NCTE Regulations, 2001 and they are eligible for
regularization with ancillary benefits as directed by this Court vide order
dated 23.02.2021.
16.1.
However, the use of the words “at the time of recruitment”
embodied in Category II excludes the petitioners since at the time of their
recruitment/appointment as SSA contract Teachers they were not having
the qualifications, like B.El.Ed/D.El.Ed/B.Ed.
16.2.
Further, the words “in accordance with that regulation” as
embodied in sub-para-(a) of para-4 of the notification dated 23.08.2010
[47]
mean and connote that the teachers appointed for classes I-VIII prior to
03.09.2001 need not acquire minimum qualifications as specified in Para1 of the said notification dated 23.08.2010 where the TET pass criteria has
been introduced. Para-5 of the NCTE notification dated 23.08.2010 also
suggests that in case of any recruitment process for appointment of
teachers was initiated prior to the date of 23.08.2010, such appointments
may be made in accordance with the NCTE Regulations, 2001. This Para5 was sought for relaxation by the Government of Tripura vide
communication dated 20.08.2013 addressed to the Ministry of HRD,
Government of India. The relevant contents seeking for relaxation under
the said communication dated 20.08.2013 may be re-produced here-inbelow, for convenience, in extenso:“3. This may also be pointed out that though in 2001 itself, the NCTE
guidelines provided for certain basic required educational
qualifications for recruitment of Primary Teachers, the State
Government at the material time could not adhere to the said
guidelines of NCTE because the department at that time considered
to follow only the prevailing recruitment rules applicable for
recruitment of primary school teachers.
4. Lastly, I would submit that we are presuming that Teacher
Eligibility Test (TET) is not applicable for the State Government in
the current process of recruitment of primary school teachers
according to para 5 of Notification of NCTE issued on 23rd August,
2010 because the advertisement to initiate the process of appointment
of Primary Teachers was issued prior to 23.08.2010. We are seeking
[48]
relaxation only in the educational qualifications as prescribed by
NCTE for primary teachers.
5. I am directed to again request you kindly to consider our case on
priority and allow necessary relaxation in the educational
qualifications for recruitment of teachers at the primary level so that
could satisfy the norms and standards as prescribed in the RTE Act,
2009 and solve the prevailing serious problem of acute shortage of
primary teachers in the Government run schools in the State of
Tripura.”
16.3.
In response to the said communication dated 20.08.2013, the
competent authority, i.e. Ministry of HRD communicated to the Principal
Secretary, Government of India, Tripura vide communication dated
05.09.2013 stating, inter alia, that:“3.
The para 5 of notification of 23rd August, 2010 also
indicates that the process of appointment of teachers initiated prior to
23rd August, 2010 has to be in accordance with NCTE(determination
of minimum qualification for recruitment of teachers in schools)
Regulations 2001(as amended from time to time). The NCTE
Regulation of 2001 provides for an academic and professional
qualification. The Ministry of HRD vide notification of 18th June, 2012
has granted relaxation to the State Government of Tripura for a
period up to 31st March, 2015 for appointment of teachers under
relaxed professional qualification norms. The relaxation is subject to
the condition that teachers appointed under relaxed qualification
norms shall acquire the minimum qualification within a period of two
years from appointment (para 2(vi) of the notification dated 18th June,
2012).”
16.4.
So, even if the Government of Tripura is permitted to appoint
teachers in terms of NCTE Regulations, 2001, but was asked to train those
teachers appointed in terms of NCTE Regulations, 2001 and accordingly,
all possible measures were taken by the Government so that they can
[49]
acquire professional qualification as laid down under NCTE Regulations,
2001 to enable them to appear and qualify in TET, one of the essential
mandatory requirements to get appointed as teacher as prescribed under
notification dated 23.08.2010. Added to it, in para 2(i) of the notification
dated 18.06.2012, it is clearly stated that “those persons who pass the
Teacher Eligibility Test be considered for appointment as a Teacher in
Classes I-VIII”. It is reiterated that under this notification, Government of
Tripura was asked to take steps to increase the institutional capacity for
preparing persons with specified qualifications so as to ensure that only
qualified persons are appointed as Teachers in classes I-VIII after
31.03.2015.
17.
In view of the above, in my considered view, it is hard to
digest the submission of learned counsel for the petitioners that the
expression mentioned in Category-II that the teachers who were appointed
on or after 03.09.2001, but prior to 23.08.2010, having minimum
educational qualification as prescribed under NCTE Regulations, 2001, do
not require to qualify TET at the time of recruitment. The group of
teachers having both academic and professional qualifications, like
Diploma or D.El.Ed. or B.El.Ed at the time of recruitment, in my opinion,
reasonably form a separate class, and for this reason, to bring them under
separate category, is in accordance with the spirit of the Right of Children
[50]
to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, the notification dated
23.08.2010, the notification dated 18.06.2012 and in conformity with the
clarification given by the Ministry of HRD vide communication dated
05.09.2013.
18.
Again, the contract Teachers, who as on today, possess the
requisite academic qualifications, i.e. D.El.Ed/B.Ed, but have not cleared
TET, have been classified as a separate group under sub category (A) of
category III because they are differently situated than those of SSA
contract Teachers mentioned under Category-I and Category-II. For this
group of contract teachers, the State Government has decided that they
would be accorded the benefit of regularization along with all allied
service benefits with effect from the date of passing the T-TET
examination, which, in the opinion of this Court, is also in conformity
with the notification dated 31.03.2010 issued by the Department of School
Education and Literacy, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, the National Council for Teacher Education
(NCTE), and formation of a separate class for these SSA contract
Teachers who possess the requisite academic and professional
qualifications, i.e. D.El.Ed/B.El.Ed, etc, but, have not cleared T-TET,
cannot be said an arbitrary exercise of power.
[51]
19.
After going through the judgments and orders passed by this
Court, it comes to fore that the Court had just passed an order upon the
State Government to formulate the scheme for the purpose of
regularization of the teachers with all other allied benefits, but, nowhere
the Court had fixed the terms of the scheme. Needless to say that the
Court in exercise of its discretionary and extraordinary power as vested
upon it under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot dictate the
policy makers as regards the terms and conditions to be mentioned in the
scheme. It is within the domain of legislative power. The Court can only
examine whether such scheme meets the requirement and spirit ingrained
in Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
20.
In the light of above analysis on the RTE Act and various
notifications and communications concerning the teachers who were
appointed between the period commencing from 03.09.2001 and prior to
23.08.2010 and the subsequent notifications issued time to time by NCTE,
in the opinion of this Court, the notification dated 30.09.2021 formulating
the scheme by the Government of Tripura does not in any way offends
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Moreso, the scheme framed by the
State under said notification dated 30.09.2021 provides further
opportunities to the petitioners to clear T-TET by academic year 2025-26
and has also kept the doors open for the SSA teachers who even today
[52]
have not been able to acquire professional qualifications i.e.
D.El.Ed/B.El.Ed/B.Ed as required under 2001 Regulations.
21.
In the light of above discussions, I do not find any merit in
the submissions of learned Senior Counsels for the petitioners that the
policy decision of the Government of Tripura vide notification dated
30.09.2021 formulating the scheme and the way the SSA contract
Teachers categorized suffers from the vice of discrimination and offends
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the submissions of
learned counsels appearing for the petitioners are repelled.
22.
More importantly, all the notifications as mentioned in the
preceding paragraphs of this judgment have been issued to fulfill the
object the legislature intended to achieve, that is, to impart quality
education to the children and to maintain uniformity in teaching. It is
evident that the policy decision of the Government is not to compromise
with the quality of teachers, but to appoint teachers with uniform quality
so that the children across the State are taught by same standard of
teachers.
23.
Lastly, on meticulous reading of the notifications issued time
to time by NCTE read with the communication exchanged between the
State Government and Ministry of HRD, it can easily be said that none of
the notifications suggests that the teachers appointed on or after
[53]
03.09.2001 and prior to 23.08.2010, i.e. the cut-off date without having
professional qualification as prescribed under NCTE Regulations, 2001,
but, obtained professional qualification after the said cut-off date have
been given exemption from qualifying in TET. Only those teachers who
were having both academic and professional qualification as laid down in
NCTE Regulations, 2001 at the time of recruitment, and appointed on or
after 03.09.2001 but prior to 23.08.2010 have been given exemption. In
addition, the teachers appointed between the afore-stated period without
having professional qualification have been given opportunities to acquire
professional qualification and last extension has been given under
RTE(Amendment) Act, 2017 (for short, “Act of 2017”) which provides
that every teacher appointed or in position as on 31 st March, 2015, who
does not possess minimum qualification as laid down under subsection(1) of said Section, shall acquire such minimum qualifications
within a period of further 4(four) years commencing from the date of
notification of the Act of 2017. I am not in agreement with the
submissions of learned counsels appearing on behalf of the petitioners that
the in-service teachers acquiring professional qualification after the cutoff date have automatically brought them within the ambit of exemption
category and to encompass them within the category of qualified teachers
as laid down under NCTE notification, dated 23.08.2010.
24.
In line of aforesaid conclusions, I am of the firm view that to
claim regularization with all service benefits, the SSA contract Teachers
[54]
who have acquired professional qualification as laid down in NCTE
Regulations, 2001 after the cut-off date (i.e. 23.08.2010) must
qualify/pass T-TET(Tripura Teachers‟ Eligibility Test) and mere
acquisition of professional qualifications (D.El.Ed., B.El.Ed., B.Ed.) or
any certificates of academic training would not entail their services to be
regularized by the State.
25.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, I do not
find any merit in the claim of the writ petitioners agitated in this batch of
writ petitions. Since I have already held in the preceding paragraphs that
the notification dated 30.09.2021 classifying the SSA contract Teachers
under different categories does not suffer from vice of arbitrariness and
discrimination, in this circumstance, I do not find any ground to interfere
with the said notification dated 30.09.2021.
26.
Accordingly, the writ petitions filed by the petitioners stand
dismissed and thus, disposed of by this common judgment.
However, there shall be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review