Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:THC:641 )
TRHC010007372025
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 265 of 2025
Sri Sajal Biswas
S/O- Lt Jnanendra Ch Biswas, Resident of Melaghar, P.O and P.SMelaghar, Sepahijala Tripura, Pin – 799115.
---- Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The Union of India & 7 Ors.,
Represented by the Secretary to the Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension,
Department of Personnel and Training, Govt. of India, Central
Secretariat, New Delhi-110001.
2.
The Union Public Service Commission,
Dholpur House, Shajahan Road, New Delhi-110001,
Represented by the Secretary.
3.
The Chairman,
Selection Committee for selection to the Indian Administration
Service Constituted under Regulation 3 of the IAS (appointed by
promotion) Regulations, 1955, represented by its Chairman, Union
Public Service Commission Dholpur House, Shajahan Road, New
Delhi-110069.
4.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary GA (P & T) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Pin-799010, Agartala,
Tripura.
5.
Sri Dilip Kumar Chakma (IAS),
District Magistrate and Collector, Unakoti Tripura,
Government of Tripura.
6.
Sri Nagendra Debbarma,
Director, TRP and PGT, Government of Tripura.
7.
Ratan Biswas,
Director, General Administration (Printing and Stationary),
Government of Tripura.
8.
Rakhi Biswas,
Commissioner of Taxes, Government of Tripura.
---- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Pradyot Maishan, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Bidyut Majumdar, Dy. SGI.
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. GA.
Date of hearing
: 05.05.2026
Date of Delivery of judgment : 18.05.2026
Whether fit for reporting
: No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Mr. Pradyot Maishan, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner and also heard Learned Dy. SGI Mr. Bidyut
Majumdar, appearing on behalf of the respondents No. 1-3 as well
as Learned Addl. GA Mr. Mangal Debbarma, appearing on behalf of
the respondents No.4-8.
2.
The petitioner has filed this present writ petition seeking
the following reliefs:“ I.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to
show cause as to why Writ in the nature of
mandamus and/or Order or direction shall not be
issued whereby quashing and cancelling the Order
No. F.4 (7)-GA (P&T)/2024 dated, 30.05.2024,
issued by the Under Secretary, Government of
Tripura.
Π.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to
show cause as to why Writ in the nature of
mandamus and/or Order or direction shall not be
issued whereby Quashing and cancelling the
Notification, dated, 14/12/2023 & 15/03/2022,
issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of
India.
III.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to
show cause as to why Writ in the nature of
mandamus and/or Order or direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to give
promotion to the Petitioner from the Tripura Civil
Service Cadre (TCS) to Indian Administrative
Service (IAS) by restoring the seniority of the
petitioner with all other ancillary & consequential
service benefit with retrospective effect.
IV.
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to
show cause as to why Writ in the nature of
mandamus and/or Order or direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to create
a supernumery post & give promotion to the
petitioner from Tripura Civil Service Cadre (TCS) to
Indian Administrative Service (IAS).
V.
Make the rules absolute.
VI.
Call for records.
VII.
Pass any further order/orders as this
Hon'ble High Court considered fit and proper.
And
For this act of kindness, the Petitioners as in duty
bound shall ever pray."
3.
At the time of hearing Learned Counsel for the petitioner
first of all drawn the attention of the Court that by a notification
dated 21.10.1997 the petitioner was appointed as TCS, Grade-II
under the Government of Tripura, holding the feeder post against
the promotion quota on probation for a period of two years. The
respondents Nos. 5 & 6 were also appointed by the said
notification and their names were reflected in the said notification
in serial No.27 & 37 whereas the name of the petitioner was
shown to be in serial No.36 (Annexure-1).
4.
Learned Counsel further submitted that vide memorandum
dated 25.01.2011 the GA (P&T) Department, Government of
Tripura also published the seniority list wherein the name of the
petitioner was shown to be in serial No.11 and the name of the
private respondents No.8 & 10 were shown to be in serial No. 26 &
30 (Annexure-2).
5.
Thereafter, the petitioner along with others filed one writ
petition before the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench
alleging inter alia that in spite of discharging functions properly
the respondents did not confirm their service after expiry of two
years rather by notification dated 21.07.2008 further extended the
period of probation of the petitioner for uncertain period. By the
aforesaid
writ
petition,
the
petitioner
challenged
the
said
notification dated 21.07.2008 holding that the same was arbitrary
unconstitutional and violative of Tripura Civil Services (Training
and Departmental Examination) Rules, 1967.
6.
It was the further plea of the petitioner that since the
petitioner along with others were given promotion as per the
provisions of Rule 5(1)b of Rules, 1967 observing the procedure
laid down in Rules 14 & 15 of the said Rules, as such they were
exempted from prescribed examination during the probation
period in view of Rule 22 of the said Rules of 1967 and before the
High Court they prayed for their confirmation in view of Rule 23.
7.
Learned Counsel further submitted that the respondents
vide an office order dated 16.03.2025 exempted 17 officers from
appearing in the departmental examination and also by another
office
order
dated
07.07.2008
exempted
officers
from
appearing in the departmental examination in exercise of the
power conferred under Rule 35 of the TCS Rules, 1967. So by the
said writ petition the petitioner sought redress before this Court
for release of their increment which was kept withheld for not
passing the departmental examination. This High Court vide
judgment and order dated 19.07.2012 set aside and quashed the
notification dated 21.07.2008 and directed the respondents to
confirm the petitioner in TCS, Grade-II, under Rule 23 of the TCS
Rules, 1967. But the other prayers were rejected.
8.
Thereafter, the petitioner preferred writ appeal before the
Division Bench which was numbered as Writ Appeal No.60/2012
and during the pendency of the writ appeal the GA (P&T)
Department by a notification dated 03.04.2013 confirmed the
petitioner in TCS, Grade-II on satisfactory completion of the
probationary period w.e.f. 03.11.1999 (Annexure-4).
9.
This High Court partly allowed the appeal to a limited
extent and directed the State to consider promotion for any of the
promotional post which were filled up in between 11.07.1999 to
14.02.2001 but rejected the other prayers of the petitioners.
10.
The operative portion of the judgment dated 02.09.2013
in Writ Appeal No.60/2012 runs as follows:” 9.
The last contention of Mr. Bhowmik,
learned senior counsel is that Rule 35 of the Rules of
1975 empowers the State Government to relax the
Rules. He also submits that in earlier petitions,
especially W.P.(C) No.35/2000 and other matters,
the similarly situated employees of Tripura Civil
Service Grade-II were directed to be confirmed from
the date they completed two years after the
appointment. He also submits that thereafter they
were all promoted. The aforesaid writ petitions
related to appointments much before the year 2001
and in those cases the issue of the effect of the
amendment of the Rules 2001 in the Departmental
Examination Rules was not at all considered.
Therefore, those judgments cannot be held to be an
authority of this point. In any event, relaxation
cannot be claimed as a matter of right. Relaxation
has to be granted by the competent authority,
keeping in view the situation as it exists at a
particular time. Situations may change and it is for
the competent authority to grant or not to grant
relaxation. Therefore, we are of the considered view
that the Court cannot direct that relaxation be
granted, all it can direct is, that the case for
relaxation be considered. But here in view of the
clear cut provisions of the Rules 1975, no such
direction can be issued.
10.
In view of above discussion, the appeal
is only allowed to the limited extent that the
appellant-petitioners
shall
be
considered
for
promotion for any of the promotional posts which
were filled up between 11.07.1999 to 14.02.2001.
All other prayers are rejected.”
11.
Challenging the judgment of the Division Bench the
petitioner thereafter, preferred one SLP before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court bearing No.3287/2014. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court by order dated 08.07.2015 (Annexure-6) directed the
government to consider the case of the petitioner under Rule 35,
1967 Rules and after that the government by another notification
dated 17.04.2017 exempted the petitioner from passing the
departmental examination (Annexure-7).
12.
Thereafter,
vide
notification
dated
03.07.2021
the
petitioner was promoted to the post of TCS Grade-I (Selection
Grade) on ad hoc basis as a onetime measure subject to final
outcome of SLP(C) No.-19765/2015 (Annexure-8). The petitioner
joined his promotional post on ad hoc basis and after that he
made one representation to the department seeking his promotion
to the higher post.
13.
Learned Counsel further submitted that vide notification
dated 14.12.2023 issued by under Secretary, Government of India
Sri Ratan Biswas and Smt. Rakhi Biswas were appointed to Indian
Administrative
Service
and
by
the
said
notification
dated
14.12.2023 the Government of India also appointed Dilip Kumar
Chakma and promoted him to the Indian Administrative Service
from Tripura Civil Service and by another notification dated
15.03.2022 Nagendra Debbarma was promoted from TCS to IAS.
14.
According to the petitioner, said Ratan Biswas and Rakhi
Biswas were junior to the petitioner and both of them joined in the
Tripura State Civil Service on 01.09.1998 and respondent Dilip
Kumar Chakma and Nagendra Debbarma were also promoted
depriving the present petitioner violating Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
15.
The
petitioner
thereafter
approached
to
the Central
Administrative Tribunal Gauhati and the Central Administrative
Tribunal directed the State to consider the representation dated
19.07.2021
of
the
petitioner
(Annexue-12).
The
petitioner
communicated the decision of the Central Administrative Tribunal
to the Secretary GA(P&T) Department and after that the Under
Secretary of Government of Tripura by an office order dated
30.05.2024 informed the petitioner that the petitioner was given
ad hoc promotion as one time measure subject to outcome of the
SLP pending in the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
16.
After that the petitioner further approached the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Gauhati by challenging the order dated
30.05.2024 but the Central Administrative Tribunal by office order
30.07.2024 dismissed the Interlocutory Application on the ground
of jurisdiction (Annexure-15). So, under compelling circumstances
the petitioner has filed the writ petition seeking the reliefs as
stated above.
17.
The state-respondents have contested the writ petition by
filing
counter affidavit.
In
the counter
affidavit
the state-
respondents partly admitted the facts of the case of the petitioner
but in respect his denial for promotion to the post of IAS the staterespondents in para No.10 & 12 have made the following
Assertions:“10.
That, the contents of paragraphs-12 &
13 of the writ petition, I humbly submit that the
contention of the Petitioner is completely denied.
It is fact that by the Notification dated 14-12-2023
of the Department of Personnel & Training, Govt. of
India Shri Ratan Biswas and Smt. Rakhi Biswas
[Respondents No.7 & 8 respectively] have been
appointed to IAS on the basis of Select List of 2018.
It is also fact that by the said Notification dated 1412-2023, Shri Dilip Kumar Chakma [Respondent
No.5] has been appointed to IAS on the basis of
Select List of 2018. For promotion / induction to IAS
for the Select List of 2018, the Selection Committee
Meeting held on the basis of finally published
seniority list of Tripura Civil Service Officers Gr-1
(Selection Grade) as on 01-01-2015. In the said
finally published seniority list, Shri Sajal Biswas
[Petitioner] is not figured. As such, all the aforesaid
Respondents [No.5, 7 & 8] are senior to the
Petitioner. Moreover, by the Notification dated 1503-2022 of the Govt. of India, Department of
Personnel & Training, New Delhi, Shri Nagendra
Debbarma [Respondent No. 6] has been appointed
on the basis of Select List of 2017. For promotion /
induction to IAS for the Select List of 2017, the
Selection Committee Meeting held on the basis of
finally published seniority list of Tripura Civil Service
Officers Senior Selection Grade and Tripura Civil
Service Officers Gr-1 (Selection Grade) as on 01-01-
2015. In the said finally published seniority lists, the
name of Shri Sajal Biswas [Petitioner] is also not
figured. The Petitioner has only been promoted to
TCS Gr-1 (Selection Grade) on 03-07-2021 on adhoc basis because the petitioner did not pass the
Departmental Examination in full as required under
TCS
Rules,
for
granting
higher
grade/promotion to the post of TCS Gr-I(Selection
Grade). But, the above private respondents cleared
their Departmental Examination in full and they got
promotion to the higher post earlier to the
petitioner. Further it is stated that both the
Respondents No.5 & 6 are senior to the Petitioner.
It is further stated that the Petitioner was not TCS
Gr-I (Selection Grade) as on 01-01-2015 and he has
only been promoted to TCS Gr-I (Selection Grade)
on 03-07-2021, on ad-hoc basis. As such, contention
of the Petitioner is completed denied.
12.
That, the contents of paragraph-17 of
the writ petition, I humbly submit that the
contention of the petition is strongly denied.
It is pertinent to mention that as per Proviso under
Rule 30 of the TCS Rules, 1967- no person subject to
provision of Rule, 20 of the TCS (Training &
Departmental Examination) Rule, 1975 shall be
considered for appointment to the next higher
scale/ Selection Grade unless he passes the
Departmental Examination in full.
In the instant case, the petitioner did not pass the
Departmental Examination in full as required under
the Rule ibid for promotion to the higher Grade i.e.
TCS Gr-1 (Selection Grade). However, subsequently,
as per direction of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India on 08-07-2015 one time relaxation towards
passing the Departmental Examination was granted
in respect of the Petitioner and others. But, prior to
allowing relaxation from passing the Departmental
Examination in respect of petitioner, the Private
respondents 5 to 8 cleared their Departmental
Examination and got promotion to the next higher
Grade i.e. TCS Gr-I (Selection Grade). But, at that
material period due to pendency of SLP before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in connection with
the Reservation Policy of State Govt. all kinds of
promotion of the State Govt. employees remained
withheld. In this regard a Memo was also issued on
1 April, 2017. Therefore, it is crystal clear that there
is no question of deprivation as well violation of the
any Article of Constitution of India.”
18.
At the time hearing Learned Addl. GA drawn the attention
of the Court that Ratan Biswas and Rakhi Biswas have been
appointed to IAS on the basis of selection list 2018. Sri Dilip
Kumar Chakma was also appointed on the basis of the selection
list 2018. It was further submitted that for promotion/induction to
IAS for the select list of 2018, the selection committee meeting
was held on the basis of finally published seniority list of TCS
officers Grade-I selection grade as on 01.01.2015 and in the said
finally published seniority list the name of the petitioner was not
there and as such, all the private respondents were senior to the
petitioner and Nagendra Debbarma also appointed on the basis of
selection list of 2017.
19.
Learned Addl. GA further submitted that the petitioner was
not in the grade of TCS selection grade on 01.01.2015 as he has
been promoted to the post of TCS Grade-I selection grade on
03.07.2021 on ad hoc basis, so his case could not be considered.
20.
It was further submitted that prior to granting relaxation
from passing the departmental examination as per order of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, the private respondents have cleared
their departmental examination and got promotion to
the next
higher grade i.e. TCS, Grade-I and as such, the case of the
petitioner could not be considered. So, according to Learned Addl.
GA Mr. Debbarma, since the petitioner has not come before the
Court challenging the final seniority list dated 01.01.20215, so
there is no merit in the writ petition filed by the petitioner and
urged for dismissal for the writ petition.
21.
The Union of India also filed counter affidavit and in the
counter affidavit in para numbers 9-14 have asserted the following
facts:-
“9.
That, the process for appointment of
State Civil Service officers to the IAS under IAS
(Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955
begins with determination of year-wise vacancies.
Once the vacancies are determined, the State
Government is required to make available the
relevant service records of eligible State Civil
Service officers who fall within the zone of
consideration
to
the
Union
Public
Service
Commission.
The
Commission
convenes
the
Selection Committee Meeting (SCM). The role of
Union of India in finalizing the selection is restricted
to determination of vacancies based upon a proposal
from the State Government, participating in the
selection process by nominating two officers not
below the rank of Joint Secretary as its
representatives in the Selection Committee Meeting
and finally issuing appointment notification of those
State Civil Service officers who are recommended by
the
Selection
Committee
to
be
Included
unconditionally in the Select List duly approved by
the Union Public Service Commission.
10.
That, the Central Government, upon
receiving the approval of the UPSC on the
recommendations of the Selection Committee,
issues two notifications viz. Part A and Part B. The
Part A notification is issued to notify the Select List
of the State Civil Service officers, prepared by
Selection Committee under Regulation 5(5) and
approved by UPSC under Regulation 7(2) of
Promotion Regulations towards filling up promotion
quota vacancies. This notification contains all names
of the officers including dead, retired and
provisional, recommended by Selection Committee.
Officers included in this Select List are considered to
be appointed to the IAS. The Part B notification is
issued appointing those State Civil Service officers,
who were included in the Select List (Part A
notification) unconditionally and are in service and
have furnished necessary declarations.
11.
That, with respect to the appointment
by promotion of SCS officers to the IAS of Tripura
cadre from the Select List of 2017 to 2020, it is
stated that this respondent vide letter dated
30.01.2018 had determined 06 vacancies for
promotion of SCS officers to IAS of Tripura cadre
from Select List of 2017 (i.e. for vacancies arisen
between 01.01.2017 to 31.12.2017) and vide letter
dated 01.06.2022 had determined 07, 04 and 05
vacancies for promotion of SCS officers to IAS of
Tripura cadre from Select List of 2018, 2019 and
2020 respectively.
12.
That, the State Government who, once
the vacancies are determined by the Central
Government, is required to make available the
relevant service records of eligible officers who fall
within the zone of consideration to the Union Public
Service Commission (UPSC). The UPSC convenes
meeting of the Selection Committee (SCM), which
makes its recommendations for promotion of State
Service Officers to IAS.
13.
That, it is also submitted that the
respondent
Department,
upon
receiving
the
approval of the UPSC, vide letter dated 14.03.2022
on the recommendations of the Selection Committee
Meeting held on 08.02.2022 for preparing Select List
of 2017, issued two notifications viz. Part A and Part
B on 15.03.2022. Through Part A notification, the
Select List 2017 comprising name of all the officers
included in the Select List was notified. The Part B
notification was issued appointing those SCS
officers, who were included in the Select List (Part A
notification) unconditionally and were in service and
have furnished necessary declarations.
14.
That, it is further submitted that the
respondent
Department,
upon
receiving
the
approval of the UPSC, vide letter dated 12.12.2023
on the recommendations of the Selection Committee
Meeting held on 16.10.2023 for preparing Select List
of 2018 to 2020, issued two notifications viz. Part A
and Part B on 14.12.2023. Through Part A
notification, the Select Lists 2018 to 2020
comprising name of all the officers included in the
Select Lists was notified. The Part B notification was
issued appointing those SCS officers, who were
included in the Select List (Part A notification)
unconditionally and were in service and have
furnished necessary declarations.”
22.
However, at the time of hearing Learned Dy. SGI drawn
the attention of the Court that the name of the petitioner was not
forwarded by the state government to UPSC for consideration of
the selection committee and as such, the selection committee did
not recommend his name for inclusion in any of the select list of
2017 to 2020 and in absence of such recommendation the
petitioner could not have appointed to the Indian Administrative
Service.
23.
However, at the time of hearing Learned Counsel for the
petitioner could not satisfy the Court as to why the petitioner has
not challenged the final seniority list of TCS Grade-I selection
grade dated 01.01.2015.
24.
Although,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
petitioner
fairly
submitted that due to pendency of the SLP the petitioner could not
challenge the said finally published senioriy list dated 01.01.2015.
So, after hearing both the sides it appears to the Court that until
and
unless
the
said
finally
published
seniority
list
dated
01.01.2015 is challenged by the petitioner, there is no scope on
the part of this Court to issue any Rule against the respondents or
to grant any relief in favour of the present petitioner.
In view of the above, the writ petition filed by the
petitioner appears to be devoid of merit and accordingly, the same
stands dismissed. No costs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
SATABDI DUTTA
Satabdi
Date: 2026.05.19 12:10:17 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review