Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:The Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad
And
The Hon’ble Justice Prasenjit Biswas
F.M.A 2 of 2025
Sri Sachin Lall
Vs.
Union of India and Others
For the Appellant
:Mr. Sardar Amjad Ali, Ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Chira Ranjan Kanjilal, Adv.,
Mr. Puranjan Pal, Adv.,
Mr. Samir Ghosh, Adv.,
Mr. Abdul Wazid, Adv.
For the Appellant U.O.I./
Respondent No. 1
Mr. Udayan Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.,
Mrs. Indrani Chakraborty, Adv.,
Ms, Shreya Sinha, Adv.
For the Mint
Mr. Arup Nath Bhattacharyya, Adv.,
Mr. Hemanta Kr. Das, Adv.,
Mr. Arya Bhattacharyya, Adv.,
Mr. Snehasish Dey, Adv.
Judgment on
: January 14, 2026.
Madhuresh Prasad, J
1. The appellant was the writ petitioner before the learned Single Judge.
The
writ
petition
was
filed
seeking
relief
of
compassionate
appointment upon demise of the writ petitioner’s father namely Jittu
Lall, who died in harness. The writ petition was dismissed on
05.10.2024. This order of the Writ Court is put to challenge in the
present appeal.
2. Briefly stating the facts which are not in dispute are that the
petitioner’s father died while in harness on 13.12.2004, while working
in the Department of I.G. Mint, Alipore. His wife (petitioner’s mother)
applied for petitioner’s compassionate appointment. The claim was
rejected by a communication dated 18.02.2014. The claim was sought
to be revived by the petitioner’s mother by issuing a letter dated
10.10.2017. The authorities again by a
communication dated
31.08.2022, reiterated their stand in the earlier rejection order dated
18.02.2014; and once again regretted the petitioner’s claim for
compassionate appointment.
3. The Writ Court found that the writ petition filed in 2023, nearly a
decade after the first rejection dated 18.02.2014, and nearly two
decades after the petitioner’s father died (13.12.2004), did not merit
any consideration in view of the long unexplained delay. The learned
Single Judge considered the settled legal position that object of
compassionate appointment is to enable the family of a deceased
Government employee to tide over the sudden crisis due to sudden
loss of the bread earner. The compassionate appointment is offered as
an exception to the rule with such social objective; and can be availed
only under such circumstance when the family of a Government
employee is rendered destitute due to the sudden loss. The concept
cannot be stretched so as to make a claim for compassionate
appointment as a matter of right, at any time in future, long after the
crisis is over.
4. The learned Single Judge also found that the writ petitioner’s mother
had
applied
for
payment
of
lump
sum
amount
in
lieu
of
compassionate appointment on 30.03.2021. Therefore, on this ground
also the learned Single Judge was of the view that the petitioner’s
mother had consciously pursued that option and therefore, was
disentitled to raise a belated claim for appointment on compassionate
ground.
5. Mr. Ali, learned Senior Advocate representing the writ petitioner
submits that at the time of his demise, the petitioner’s father was
serving under the Department of I.G. Mint, Alipore. Rejection of the
petitioner’s claim for compassionate appointment by letter dated
18.02.2014, is based on a scheme for grant of compensatory lump
sum allowance in lieu of compassionate appointment introduced by a
different entity, namely Security Printing and Minting Corporation of
India Limited (SPMCIL for short). This entity came into existence later,
in the year 2006, after the Cabinet decision to corporatize the Mint.
Scheme/decision of such an entity cannot govern the petitioner’s
claim. The father of the petitioner never served under the SPMICL and
petitioner’s claim cannot be considered by SPMICL or by any scheme
framed/ implemented after demise of the petitioner’s father by the
SPMICL.
6. It is also submitted that the writ petitioner never applied for lump
sum in lieu of compassionate appointment. It is submitted by the
learned Advocate that the writ petitioner did not write the letter dated
30.03.2021.
7. The third submission advanced by the learned Senior Advocate is
regarding compassionate appointment by SPMICL to 9 other, similarly
situated as the petitioner. In this connection he has placed reliance on
the table (at page 47 of the paper book), containing Draft Seniority List
of Application for Compassionate Appointment, wherein the names of
9 persons have been enlisted. He further submits that whereas these
9 persons were extended the benefit of compassionate appointment,
claim of the writ petitioner was rejected, which fact is apparent from a
reading of the averment made in paragraph 10 of the instruction on
affidavit filed by the respondent in the Writ Court.
8. The learned Advocate for the respondents, on the other hand has
submitted that the Writ Court has rightly rejected the petitioner’s
claim for compassionate appointment raised decades after the date of
death of the employee (petitioner’s father) in harness; and nearly 10
years after rejection of the writ petitioner’s claim by the authority by
their order dated 18.02.2014. It is also submitted that the petitioner
never assailed the rejection order/s.
9. He submits that the Writ Court, therefore, has rightly considered the
petitioner’s claim to be suffering with inordinate and unexplained
delay;
with
reference
to
the
settled
legal
position
regarding
compassionate appointment being available to tide over a crisis due to
sudden loss of the breadearner. The consideration, therefore, requires
no interference by this Court.
10.
We have considered the rival submission, gone through the
records and judgment of the learned Single Judge. At the very outset
we consider it apposite to take note of recent judgment of the Apex
Court in the case of State of West Bengal V. Debabrata Tiwari &
Others reported in (2025) 5 SCC 712, wherein the Apex Court has
considered several earlier judgments and reiterated the law in this
regard which mandates that compassionate appointment being in
exception to the rule can be claimed only under the terms and
conditions under the scheme providing for grant of compassionate
appointment; and in furtherance of its objectives. The primary
objective of compassionate appointment being to enable the family of
the deceased employee to tide over the sudden crisis. The Apex Court
in paragraph 32 and 33 in case of Debabrata Tiwari & Others
(supra) has held amongst others that:
“32. On consideration of the aforesaid decisions of this Court,
the following principles emerge:
32.1. That a provision for compassionate appointment makes a
departure from the general provisions providing for appointment
to a post by following a particular procedure of recruitment.
Since such a provision enables appointment being made without
following the said procedure, it is in the nature of an exception to
the general provisions and must be resorted to only in order to
achieve the stated objectives i.e. to enable the family of the
deceased to get over the sudden financial crisis.
32.2. Appointment on compassionate grounds is not a source of
recruitment. The reason for making such a benevolent scheme by
the State or the public sector undertaking is to see that the
dependants of the deceased are not deprived of the means of
livelihood. It only enables the family of the deceased to get over
the sudden financial crisis.
32.3. Compassionate appointment is not a vested right which
can be exercised at any time in future. Compassionate
employment cannot be claimed or offered after a lapse of time
and after the crisis is over.
32.4. That compassionate appointment should be provided
immediately to redeem the family in distress. It is improper to
keep such a case pending for years.
32.5. In determining as to whether the family is in financial
crisis, all relevant aspects must be borne in mind including the
income of the family, its liabilities, the terminal benefits if any,
received by the family, the age, dependency and marital status
of its members, together with the income from any other source.
33. The object underlying a provision for grant of compassionate
employment is to enable the family of the deceased employee to
tide over the sudden crisis due to the death of the breadearner
which has left the family in penury and without any means of
livelihood. Out of pure humanitarian consideration and having
regard to the fact that unless some source of livelihood is
provided, the family would not be in a position to make both
ends meet, a provision is made for giving gainful appointment to
one of the dependants of the deceased who may be eligible for
such appointment. Having regard to such an object, it would be
of
no
avail to grant compassionate appointment to
the
dependants of the deceased employee, after the crisis which
arose on account of death of a breadwinner, has been overcome.
Thus, there is also a compelling need to act with a sense of
immediacy in matters concerning compassionate appointment
because on failure to do so, the object of the scheme of
compassionate appointment would be frustrated. Where a long
lapse of time has occurred since the date of death of the
deceased employee, the sense of immediacy for seeking
compassionate appointment would cease to exist and thus lose
its significance and this would be a relevant circumstance which
must weigh with the authorities in determining as to whether a
case for the grant of compassionate appointment has been made
out for consideration”
11.
We find that the petitioner’s father died in harness on
13.12.2004,
and
his
mother
applied
for
his
compassionate
appointment on 11.01.2005. The claim was rejected on 18.02.2014,
under intimation to the petitioner and his mother. The fact of rejection
dated 18.02.2014, is acknowledged by the petitioner in paragraph 9 of
the writ petition. However, he has tried to explain the delay in filing
the writ petition by stating in paragraph 10 of the writ petition that
authority repeatedly assured the petitioner and his mother that
compassionate appointment would be granted. Therefore, petitioner
did not file the writ petition earlier. It is only when the authorities
again rejected the petitioner’s claim for compassionate appointment
by the communication dated 31.08.2022, then the petitioner filed the
present writ petition.
12.
We find no substance in such submission. The petitioner’s
claim was rejected and admittedly communicated
to
him on
18.02.2014, merely because he has subsequently reiterated such
claim thereafter, cannot be made a ground to meet the delay.
13.
Making
of
application(s)/representation(s)
subsequent
to
rejection of petitioner’s claim on 18.02.2014, or passing of any
subsequent order would not give rise to a fresh/new cause of action.
The issue of limitation or delay and laches is required to be considered
with reference to the earlier rejection, in this case being rejection order
dated 18.02.2014. Our conclusion is fortified by decision of the Apex
Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. M. K. Sarkar,
reported in (2010) 2 SCC 59, wherein it was held:
“15. When a belated representation in regard to a “stale” or
“dead” issue/dispute is considered and decided, in compliance
with a direction by the court/tribunal to do so, the date of such
decision cannot be considered as furnishing a fresh cause of
action for reviving the “dead” issue or time-barred dispute. The
issue of limitation or delay and laches should be considered with
reference to the original cause of action and not with reference to
the date on which an order is passed in compliance with a
court's direction. Neither a court's direction to consider a
representation issued without examining the merits, nor a
decision given in compliance with such direction, will extend the
limitation, or erase the delay and laches.”
14.
We further find that the petitioner never assailed the rejection
order(s) dated 18.02.2014 and the second rejection order dated
31.08.2022. Even in the present writ proceeding he choose not to
challenge the two rejection orders.
15.
As such in light of the decision in the case of Debabrata Tiwari
& Ors. (supra) and M. K. Sarkar (supra), the petitioner cannot be
permitted to agitate a claim for compassionate appointment in respect
of his father who died in harness on 13.12.2004, by filing a writ
petition in the year 2023. We, therefore, have no hesitation in holding
that the writ petition is barred by delay and laches.
16.
Insofar as the submission regarding the petitioner’s claim being
rejected under a scheme which came into operation after demise of
the petitioner’s father, we are of the view that the petitioner cannot
raise any such claim today, since he chose never assail the rejection
order dated 18.02.2014 or the subsequent rejection order dated
31.08.2022, both relying upon the scheme issued by the SPMCIL. If
the petitioner was aggrieved by such rejection he
was required to
diligently put the same to challenge which he has chosen not to do.
There is no prayer in the writ petition challenging the two rejection
orders dated 18.02.2014 and 31.08.2022. It is a different matter that
today, a challenge to the two rejection orders would not be sustainable
as being barred by delay and laches in view of the above two decisions
of the Apex Court in the case Debabrata Tiwari & Ors. (supra) and
M. K. Sarkar (supra).
17.
Insofar as the third ground being substantially an allegation
that petitioner was subjected to discriminatory treatment, we find that
there is no factual foundation for making such allegation. The table
relied upon contains a draft seniority list only of applications. The
same does not manifest grant of compassionate appointment to
anyone. There is nothing on record to show that at any point of time
compassionate appointment was granted to any one of those 9
candidates. For lack of factual foundation in this regard the plea of
discrimination is also untenable.
18.
In view of the above consideration we find no infirmity in the
decision of the learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petitioner’s
writ petition, seeking relief of compassionate appointment.
19.
The appeal is dismissed.
20.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties, expeditiously after complying with all
necessary legal formalities.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
I agree.
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review