Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A(J) NO.31 OF 2024
Sri Ripan Das,
S/o. Late Tarini Kanta Das,
Resident of Birajnagar, Satsangam GP,
W/ No-05, P.S.-Kadamtala,
District-North Tripura.
…… Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary,
To the Department of Home,
New Secretariat, Kunjaban,
P.S. N.C.C., District-West Tripura.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Samar Das, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 14.05.2025.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
This appeal has been filed against the Judgment
and Order of conviction dated 22.09.2023 passed in S.T.(T-1) 08 of
2019 by the Learned Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
By this judgment, the Learned Judge sentenced the appellant to
rigorous imprisonment for three years and imposed a fine of Rs.
5,000/- for the offence punishable under Section 498-A of the IPC.
In default of payment, the appellant is to undergo further
imprisonment
for
six
months.
The
appellant
has
been
also
sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for five years and fined Rs.
5,000/- for the offence punishable under Section 306 of the IPC,
with a default stipulation.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that on 24.07.2017,
one Anil Mahishya Das filed an ejahar stating, inter alia, that on
02.07.2012, the appellant-Ripan Das and his wife Rebati Das (now
deceased) eloped due to a love affair and subsequently got married.
A baby girl was born out of their wedlock. Thereafter, the appellant
began
subjecting
his
wife
to
mental
and
physical
torture,
demanding a plot of land and cash to construct a hut. The victim
informed her father, who expressed his inability to meet these
demands due to financial constraints. Despite this, the appellant
continued to torture his wife. Neighbours attempted to mediate, but
to no avail. On 22.07.2017, the victim, unable to bear the torture,
committed
suicide
in
the
appellant’s
house
at
Birajanagar,
Satsangam Gaon Panchayat under Kadamtala P.S., North Tripura.
The informant lodged an ejahar at Kadamtala P.S., which was
registered as Kadamtala P.S. Case No. 2017 KDL 029 dated
24.07.2017.
3.
Upon
completion
of
the
investigation,
the
investigating officer submitted a charge sheet against the appellant
under Sections 498-A and 304B of the Indian Penal Code. Charges
were later framed under Sections 498-A and 306 IPC. The
prosecution
examined
witnesses
and
exhibited
various
documents in support of its case.
4.
The Learned Trial Court, after hearing the parties,
framed the following points for determination:i. Whether the accused Ripan Das, after his marriage with
the deceased Rebati Das on 02.07.2012, subjected her to
physical and mental cruelty at their residence in
Birajanagar, Satsangam Gaon Panchayat, Ward No. 5,
under Kadamtala P.S., North Tripura District, to meet his
unlawful demand for land and cash?
ii. Whether on 22.07.2017, the accused abetted the
suicide of his wife Rebati Das by subjecting her to such
cruelty?
5.
After considering the arguments and evidence, the
Learned Trial Court delivered the Judgment and Order of conviction
as mentioned herein above.
6.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the Judgment
and Order dated 22.09.2023, the appellant has preferred this
instant appeal.
7.
Heard Mr. Samar Das, learned counsel appearing as
Legal Aid Counsel for the appellant, and Mr. Raju Datta, learned
Public Prosecutor, appearing for the State-respondent.
8.
Mr. Das, learned counsel contended that there is no
evidence on record to suggest any direct act or conduct by the
accused that aided or instigated the victim to commit suicide. The
conviction was based on the testimony of P.Ws:- 3, 5, 16, and 18.
Apart from these four witnesses, no other witness deposed about
any
cruelty.
Even
their
statements
mention
only
occasional
quarrels, which are part and parcel of the matrimonial life. These
witnesses stated that the victim told them about a month before her
death that she was being physically tortured by the accused. Mr.
Das, learned counsel argued that such statements are inadmissible
under Section 32(1) of the Indian Evidence Act as they do not
qualify as dying declarations.
On this aspect, learned counsel referred to Para-13, 14,
15 and 21 of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported
in (2009) 13 SCC 80 titled as Bhairon Singh Vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh. The same is reproduced here-in-under:“13. The moot question is: whether the
statements attributed to the deceased could be used as evidence for
entering upon a finding that the accused subjected Ranjana Rani @
Raj Kumari to cruelty as contemplated under Section 498A, IPC.
14.
In our considered view, the evidence of
PW-4 and PW-5 about what the deceased Ranjana Rani @ Raj
Kumari had told them against the accused about the torture and
harassment is inadmissible under Section 32(1) of the Evidence Act
and such evidence cannot be looked into for any purpose.
15.
Except Section
32(1) of
the
Indian
Evidence Act, there is no other provision under which the statement
of a dead person can be looked into in evidence. The statement of a
dead person is admissible in law if the statement is as to the cause
of death or as to any of the circumstance of the transactions which
resulted in her death, in a case in which the cause of death comes
into question. What has been deposed by PW-4 and PW-5 has no
connection with any circumstance of transaction which resulted in
her death. The death of Smt. Ranjana Rani @ Raj Kumari was neither
homicidal nor suicidal; it was accidental. Since for an offence under
Section 498A simpliciter, the question of death is not and cannot be
an issue for consideration, we are afraid the evidence of PW-4 and
PW-5 is hardly an evidence in law to establish such offence. In that
situation Section 32(1) of the Evidence Act does not get attracted.”
9.
In response, the Learned P.P. referred to the
testimony of P.W-2, a neighbour, who deposed that the victim was
still alive when brought down after hanging. The accused had time
to save her, but she was not taken to the hospital despite being
advised to do so. She died an hour later. This, according to the
prosecution, indicates the appellant’s negligence and passive role in
her death.
10.
To this, the appellant’s counsel argued that there is
no corroborating medical evidence to support P.W:-2 claim that the
victim was alive at that time.
11.
The Learned P.P. further referred to the testimonies
of P.Ws:- 3, 4, 15, and 16 (neighbours), who all confirmed that the
appellant used to torture the victim. These facts were not effectively
denied. The prosecution also highlighted that the victim was
pregnant at the time of her death and argued that no mother would
commit suicide and kill her unborn child unless pushed to the
extreme.
12.
The appellant’s counsel conceded that the victim
was pregnant and accepted that occasional quarrels may have
taken place. However, he argued that the mere fact of being the
husband does not make one guilty under Section 306 IPC. A general
history of quarrel does not amount to abetment. For an offence
under Section 306 IPC, abetment must be proximate and not
remote.
To support his argument, learned counsel referred
to paras-15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25 and 25.1 of the
recent Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in 2025
LiveLaw (SC) 288 bearing No.Criminal
Appeal No.1388 of
as
dated
March
05,
titled
Patel
Babubhai
Monahardas and ors Vs. State of Gujrat. The same is
reproduced here-in-under:“15. Attempt to commit suicide is an offence in India. Section
309 IPC says that whoever attempts to commit suicide and does
any act towards such act, shall be punished with simple
imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year or with
fine or with both. However, once suicide is carried out, the
offence is complete. Considering the nature of the offence,
obviously such a person would be beyond the reach of the law.
Therefore, question of penalising him would not arise but
whoever abets the commission of such suicide would be
penalised under Section 306 IPC. Punishment prescribed under
Section 306 IPC is imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to 10 years and shall also be liable to fine.
What Section 306 IPC says is that if any person commits suicide,
then whoever abets the commission of such suicide shall be
punished as above.
16. Therefore, the crucial word in Section 306 IPC is „abets‟.
„Abetment‟ is defined in Section 107 of IPC. As per Section 107
IPC, a person would be abetting the doing of a thing if he
instigates any person to do that thing or if he encourages with
one or more person or persons in any conspiracy for doing that
thing or if he intentionally aids by any act or illegal omission
doing of that thing. There are two explanations to Section 107.
As per Explanation 1, even if a person by way of wilful
misrepresentation or concealment of a material fact which he is
otherwise bound to disclose voluntarily causes or procures or
attempts to cause or procure a thing to be done, is said to
instigate the doing of that thing. Explanation 2 clarifies that
whoever does anything in order to facilitate the commission of
an act, either prior to or at the time of commission of the act, is
said to aid the doing of that act.
17. Section 114 IPC is an explanation or clarification of Section
107 IPC. What Section 114 IPC says is that whenever any person
is absent but was present when the act or offence for which he
would be punishable in consequence of the abetment is
committed, he shall be deemed to have committed such an act or
offence and would be liable to be punished as an abettor.
18. In Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh1, this Court held
that to „instigate‟ means to goad, urge, provoke, incite or
encourage to do „an act‟. To satisfy the requirement of
„instigation‟, it is not necessary that actual words must be used
to that effect or that the words or act should necessarily and
specifically be suggestive of the consequence. Where the
accused by his act or omission or by his continued course of
conduct creates a situation that the deceased is left with no
other option except to commit suicide, then „instigation‟ may be
inferred. A word uttered in a fit of anger or emotion without
intending the consequences to actually follow cannot be said to
be „instigation‟.
19. Elaborating further, this Court in Chitresh Kumar Chopra
versus State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)2 observed that to constitute
„instigation‟, a person who instigates another has to provoke,
incite, urge or encourage the doing of an act by the other by
„goading‟ or „urging forward‟. This Court summed up the
constituents of „abetment‟ as under:
(i) the accused kept on irritating or annoying the deceased by
words, deeds or wilful omission or conduct which may even be a
wilful silence until the deceased reacted or pushed or forced the
deceased by his deeds, words or wilful omission or conduct to
make the deceased move forward more quickly in a forward
direction; and
(ii) that the accused had the intention to provoke, urge or
encourage the deceased to commit suicide while acting in the
manner noted above. Undoubtedly, presence of mens rea is the
necessary concomitant of instigation.
20. Amalendu Pal alias Jhantu versus State of West Bengal3 is a
case where this Court held that in a case of alleged abetment of
suicide, there must be proof of direct or indirect act(s) of
incitement to the commission of suicide. Merely on the allegation
of harassment without there being any positive action proximate
to the time of occurrence on the part of the accused which led or
compelled the deceased to commit suicide, conviction in terms of
Section 306 IPC would not be sustainable. Similar view has been
expressed by this Court in case of Ude Singh versus State of
Haryana4.
21. After considering the provisions of Sections 306 and 107 of
IPC, this Court in Rajesh versus State of Haryana5 held that
conviction under Section 306 IPC is not sustainable on the
allegation of harassment without there being any positive action
proximate to the time of occurrence on the part of the accused
which led or compelled the person to commit suicide.
22. Abetment to commit suicide involves a mental process of
instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in the doing
of a thing. Without a positive proximate act on the part of the
accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction
cannot be sustained. Besides, in order to convict a person under
Section 306 IPC, there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the
offence.
23. This Court in Amudha versus State6 held that there has to
be an act of incitement on the part of the accused proximate to
the date on which the deceased committed suicide. The act
attributed should not only be proximate to the time of suicide
but should also be of such a nature that the deceased was left
with no alternative but to take the drastic step of committing
suicide.
24. Again, in the case of Kamaruddin Dastagir Sanadi versus
State of Karnataka7, this Court observed that discord and
differences in domestic life are quite common in society.
Commission of suicide largely depends upon the mental state of
the victim. Until and unless some guilty intention on the part of
the accused is established, it is ordinarily not possible to convict
the accused for an offence under Section 306 IPC.
25. Prakash versus State of Maharashtra8 is a case where this
Court after analysing various decisions on the point summed up
the legal position in the following manner:
14. Section 306 read with Section 107 of IPC, has been
interpreted, time and again, and its principles are well
established. To attract the offence of abetment to suicide, it is
important to establish proof of direct or indirect acts of
instigation or incitement of suicide by the accused, which must
be in close proximity to the commission of suicide by the
deceased. Such instigation or incitement should reveal a clear
mens rea to abet the commission of suicide and should put the
victim in such a position that he/she would have no other option
but to commit suicide.
25.1. In the aforesaid judgment, this Court referred to its earlier
decision in Sanju @ Sanjay Singh Sengar versus State of M.P.9
and held that in a given case, even a time gap of 48 hours
between using of abusive language by the accused and the
commission of suicide would not amount to a proximate act.”
13.
Regarding the implication of Section 498-A of IPC,
learned counsel appearing for the appellant submits that only the
P.W.1, the mother and P.W.15, the father, these two witnesses only
stated that the deceased victim was torture on demand on
homestead land. P.W.-5 the landlord stated that after few days of
staying as tenant, the accused person purchase land to construct a
house. Except P.W.1 and P.W.15, there is no such statement made
by other witnesses. On the basis of omnibus statement Section 498A of IPC cannot be invoked. Stating thus, the learned counsel
submits that impugned Judgment be set aside and to allow this
appeal.
14.
Learned P.P., submits that on Section 498-A, there
are sufficient witnesses who stated that she was torture by the
husband. P.Ws.-1 and 15 stated that she was torture by the accused
on the demand of homestead land. The fact that she committed
suicide is corroborated with the evidence of torture as evident by the
statement of the witnesses, is enough to convict the victim under
Section 498-A of IPC.
15.
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
16.
Before delving into the conclusion, let us examine
some crucial evidences.
17.
P.W.1, Smt. Ashima Mahishya Das deposed that
about 5 to 6 years ago, her stepdaughter Rebati Das was married to
Ripon Das. After the marriage, Ripan demanded a homestead, but
the family could not provide one. Out of the said wedlock, Rebati
gave birth to a female child and was pregnant again. Approximately
seven months into her pregnancy, the family received information of
her death. The witness stated that they suspected Rebati did not die
a natural death but was murdered. She further stated that Ripan
Das was employed as a Special Police Officer (SPO) in the office of
the Superintendent of Police, North Tripura.
18.
P.W.2, Smt. Archana Karmakar deposed that she is
a neighbour of Ripan Das. On the day of the incident, she returned
home at about 3:00 PM and, upon arrival, heard hue and cry from
the direction of Ripan Das’s house. He immediately rushed to the
spot and found Rebati hanging in the kitchen room. Using a dao
(sharp cutting tool), she cut the rope and brought Rebati down. At
that time, Rebati was still alive, and he advised Ripan and others to
shift her to the hospital for treatment. However, Rebati was not
taken to any hospital and subsequently died.
In the cross-examination, she stated that Rebati died
approximately one hour after being brought down from the hanging
position. At the time of the incident, many people had gathered, and
they had rushed to the spot upon hearing Ripan raise an alarm.
19.
P.W.-3, Bijoya Das, a housewife by occupation
deposed that approximately 3 to 4 years prior, one Rebati, their
neighbour, had passed away. About one month before Rebati’s
death, upon hearing hue and cry from Rebati’s house, the witness
came out of her residence and saw Rebati going somewhere while
stating that she would die. The witness consoled her and escorted
her back to her house. Rebati expressed to the witness that her
husband had committed cruelty upon her, which led her to feel that
she no longer wished to live. The witness then asked Ripan (Rebati’s
husband) about the allegations made by Rebati, to which he replied
that it was a private family matter and that no one else should
interfere.
20.
P.W.-4, Sri Amodini Das also stated that about one
month’s before the death of the victim, he found Rebati going away
from her house crying and also saying that she will not survive any
more and being asked she reported that her husband assaulted her
physically.
21.
P.W.5, Sri Bidyut Das deposed that Ripan Das and
his wife Rebati once lived as tenants in his house, as their marriage
was not accepted by their families. Later, Ripan purchased a plot of
land, constructed a new house, and shifted there with his wife.
During their stay at his house, the witness once saw Ripan and
Rebati quarrelling over tangra fish, but otherwise found them living
peacefully.
22.
P.W.15, Sri Anil Mahishya Das the father of the
deceased-Rebati Das, deposed that on 02-07-2012, his minor
daughter Rebati was enticed and married by the accused Ripan Das.
Despite initial resistance from both families, the couple lived
together and had a female child. They resided in a rented house
initially, where the child was born. Later, Ripan Das requested land
from the witness's homestead to settle with his wife and child, but
the witness refused, citing limited resources and responsibilities
towards two unmarried daughters. Following this, the witness
alleged that disputes arose between Ripan and Rebati, and Rebati
was subjected to ill-treatment and physical abuse, especially after
repeated pressure to bring money and land from her father. The
witness stated that his daughter was even sent home multiple times
with such demands. On 22-07-2017, when Rebati was six months
pregnant, a fellow SPO informed the witness to visit Ripan’s house.
On arrival, he found Rebati’s body lying inside the dwelling hut, and
was told by Ripan that she had committed suicide. The witness
suspected foul play, attributing the death to murder by Ripan, due to
the ongoing disputes over land and money. He also stated that
Ripan tried to cremate the body secretly, but the witness intervened
and reported the matter to the police.
23.
P.W.-16 who is the neighbour also stated that
Rebati was severely beaten by her husband.
24.
Heard the perused the evidence on record.
25.
On the charge made under Section 306 of IPC, the
Apex Court in the Patel Babubhai Monohardas and ors(supra),
observed that “Merely on the allegation of harassment without there
being any positive action proximate to the time of occurrence on the
part of the accused which led or compelled the deceased to commit
suicide, conviction in terms of Section 306 of IPC would not be
sustainable.”
26.
Here in the instant case, the prosecution failed
to establish a proximate link between the alleged acts of cruelty and
the deceased's decision to commit suicide. No specific evidence was
found that the accused instigated, provoked, or aided the deceased
to take the extreme step. Here the witnesses deposed that one
month back there was a quarrel between the accused and the victim
but nowhere in the record or from the deposition of the witnesses, it
is revealed that proximate to the time of occurrence, the accused
instigated or provoked the victim to commit suicide. P.W.5, i.e., land
lord deposed that there was quarrel between the couple on the
matter of tangra fish otherwise, during the stay in his house, they
were living peacefully.
27.
In view of the above fact, this Court is of the
opinion that mere existence of matrimonial discord, even if proven,
does not automatically attract the rigors of Section 306 of IPC unless
there is clear evidence of incitement or abetment. The prosecution's
evidence, including witness testimony and circumstantial facts, did
not satisfy the threshold of intentional aiding as required under
Section 107 IPC (which defines abetment).In view of the above, the
accused is acquitted of the charge under Section 306 IPC.
28.
evidence
On the charge made under Section 498-A IPC, the
brought
on
record,
including
credible
testimony
of
witnesses, particularly the victim’s family members and their
neighbours, establishes that the accused subjected the deceased to
mental and physical cruelty. The pattern of behaviour shown by the
accused amounts to “willful conduct of such a nature as is likely to
drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or
danger to her life, limb or health," as defined under Section 498-A of
IPC.
29.
The causal connection to suicide could not be
established for Section 306 of IPC, the incidents of sustained cruelty
and harassment are proven from the disposition of P.Ws:-3, 4, 15
and 16 and it squarely falls within the ambit of Section 498-A of IPC.
The defence could not rebut the evidence of harassment with any
credible or consistent alternative explanation. Accordingly, the
accused is held guilty under Section 498-A IPC.
30.
The charges against the accused under Section 306
of IPC stands set aside as not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
31.
The sentence under Section 498-A of IPC stands
upheld. The accused shall undergo punishment.
32.
With the above observation and direction, this
present appeal stands disposed of.
33.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2025.05.21
SINGHA
13:43:44 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review