Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.700 of 2023
Sri Ratneswar Das (Age: 83 years),
S/O. Late Kshetra Mohan Das,
Village: Lamarasnagar,P.O. Fatikroy,
P.S. Fatikroy, District: Unakoti Tripura,
PIN: 799 290
----Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The Director General of CBI,
Represented by the Head of Branch,
Central Bureau of Investigation,
Anti Corruption Branch & Economic Offence-V,
Opposite Balaji Temple, N.H.37, Betkuchi,
Guwahati-781035
2. The Inspector of Police,
Office of the Head of Branch,
Central Bureau of Investigation,
Anti Corruption Branch & Economic Offence-V,
Opposite Balaji Temple, N.H.37, Betkuchi,
Guwahati-781035
3. State Bank of India,
Having its central office at Madam Cama Road,
Back Bay Reclamation, Mumbai,
Represented by Branch Manager,
State Bank of India, Kumarghat Branch (03795),
P.O. & P.S. Kumarghat,
District: Unakoti Tripura, PIN:799 264
4. The Branch Manager,
State Bank of India, Kumarghat Branch (03795),
P.O. & P.S. Kumarghat,
District: Unakoti Tripura, PIN:799 264
---- Respondents (s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of Hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
:
:
Mr. H. Deb, Adv.
Mr. B. Majumder, DSGI.
22.05.2024
:
28.05.2024
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Learned counsel Mr. H. Deb representing the
petitioner and also heard Mr. B. Majumder, Learned DSGI
representing the respondents No.1 and 2. None appeared
on behalf of the respondents No.3 and 4.
02.
By
means
of
filing
this
writ
petition,
the
petitioner has sought for the following reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a
writ of certiorari and/or in the nature thereof,
shall not be issued, calling for the records, lying
with them.
(ii) Issue Rule calling upon the respondents and
each of them, to show cause as to why a writ of
Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, for
mandating/directing the respondents, to remove
the stop of pension payment order, deposited in
Savings Bank Account Number 11855875264 in
the State Bank of India, Kumarghat Branch, in
the name of Petitioner and to allow the petitioner
to withdraw the pension money by petitioner
from his said S.B. A/C. No.11855875264 lying in
the State Bank of India, Kumarghat Branch.
(iii) After hearing the parties be pleased enough
to make the Rules absolute in terms of prayer-ii
above.
(iv) Call records appertaining to this petition.
(v) Costs of and incidental to this petition.
(vi) Any other relief or relief/s, as to this Hon’ble
Court may deem fit and proper.
03.
In course of hearing Learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner being a
retired person presently aged about 83 years who retired
from service from the post of Superintendent of Agriculture
at
Kumarghat
presently
under
under
erstwhile
Unakoti
Tripura
North
Tripura
District.
His
District
pension
payment Order number is PPO No.PEN-2/TIRP/S/SUP/2953.
According to Learned counsel the petitioner went on
superannuation on 31.07.1993. For the purpose of receiving
pension he opened a Savings Bank Account vide Account
No.11855875264 in the State Bank of India, Kumarghat
Branch under Unakoti District. The wife of the petitioner
Smt. Santi Das due to ignorance being influenced by one
Biplab Das an agent of a so called public limited company,
named & styled as Kama Indian Projects and Services
Limited, Bara Service, Ulubari, Guwahati-7 beyond the
knowledge of the petitioner had procured a preference share
certificate on 30.05.2009 from the said so-called public
limited company for an amount or Rs.10,000/- as face value
with redemption value amounting to Rs.19,000/-. The
petitioner did never purchase or procure any preference
share certificate in his own name and the said certificate in
the name of his wife was under Serial No.11111158,
Application No.555769, Term-4 years, Date of Allotment30.05.2009
and
Redemption
date-30.05.2013,
but
unfortunately till date said money could not be redeemed.
04.
On 05.07.2023 when the petitioner went to
withdraw
the
pension
money
from
his
SB.
A/C.
No.11855875264 from the branch of SBI Kumarghat, that
time he could not withdraw the pension as the Bank
Authority stopped payment of pension to his account. So
the petitioner by an application dated 27.07.2023 requested
the respondent No.4 i.e. the Branch Manager, S.B.I.
Kumarghat Branch with a copy to respondent No.2 to allow
him to withdraw the pension money from his said account.
The petitioner also made so many correspondences with the
respondent No.4 in this regard, but no step was taken. The
respondent No.2, Inspector of Police, CBI, EO-V, Guwahati
by
his
notice
dated
18.07.2023
vide
No.RC2262023
E0002/1140 directed the petitioner to appear before him at
Guwahati on 25.07.2023 at 10.00 hrs. for examining the
petitioner by the respondent No.2 in respect of Case No.RC
2262023 E0002-GWH under Section 420, 406 and 34 of IPC
registered by CBI, EO-V, Guwahati. The notice was send by
the respondent No.2 by Speed Post, but unfortunately the
petitioner received the notice on 08.08.2023. Thereafter,
the petitioner contacted with the number given by the
respondent No.2 in his notice dated 18.07.2023. The
petitioner informed the matter to the respondent No.4 and
as per reply of the respondent No.2 the petitioner could
know that the respondent No.2 was on leave. The petitioner
was verbally informed by the respondent No.4 i.e. the
Branch Manager, S.B.I., Kumarghat Branch that the pension
money credited in his S.B. A/C. No.11855875264 was
stopped as per direction of the respondent No.2. The
petitioner received the notice from the respondent No.2 on
08.08.2023
and
subsequently
by
his
letter
dated
09.08.2023 send on 11.08.2023 by speed post Registration
No.EE410859355IN informed the respondent No.2 that the
petitioner received the notice of the respondent No.2 on
08.08.2023,
the
petitioner
was
an
aged
person
and
suffering from various ailments due to his old days. Due to
stoppage of pension money the petitioner was suffering a
lot and even some times the petitioner is to face starvation.
So he requested the respondent No.2 for releasing the
pension
money
No.11855875264
deposited
of
SBI
in
the
Kumarghat
bank
Branch,
SB.
but
A/C.
the
respondent No.2 did not pay any heed to it.
05.
That on the basis of prayer made by the
petitioner to the respondent No.4, the respondent No.4 by
his information dated 30.08.2023 issued a certificate/letter
stating that the pension of petitioner is being credited to his
SB Account No.11855875264 on a regular basis. Thereafter,
the respondent No.4 by his letter dated 27.09.2023 as per
direction of C.B.I., the payment of pension money was
stopped from SB.A/C. No.11855875264. There was a fraud
in the cheat fund by the name of Kama India Project Mr.
Das i.e. the petitioner had invested in the said cheat fund
and an investigation was going on. The bank did not get any
information from C.B.I. to remove the stop command. So
the bank authority was not in a position to remove that. It
was further submitted that the respondents stopped the
pension money without any basis for which the petitioner is
in severe financial crisis. Hence he filed this petition.
06.
On admission of this writ petition notice was
served upon all the respondents. The respondents No.1 and
2 appeared through Learned DSGI Mr. B. Majumder but the
respondents No.3 and 4 inspite of receipt of notice did not
appear before the court. The respondents No.1 and 2
submitted counter-affidavit and in the counter-affidavit
following reply was given:
“2. That, in pursuant to the Notification dated 11.03.2022
of Govt. of Tripura U/s 6 of DSPE Act followed by
Notification dated 16.01.2023 of Ministry of Personnel,
Public Grievances and Pensions (DoPT) U/s 5 of DSPE
Act, the further investigation of FIR No.164/2014 dated
18.09.2014 of West Agartala PS; FIR No.27/2013 dated
21.03.2013 of Kumarghat PS and FIR No.105/2012 dated
24.08.2012 of Telimura PS have been transferred to CBI
and these FIRs have been amalgamated in one case and
re-registered vide RC2262023E0002 dated 23/02/2023
at CBI, ACB, Guwahati against 17 accused persons,
including accused-petitioner Ratneswar Das.(The copy of
FIR is enclosed herewith and marked as Annexure-R/1).
3.That, after completion investigation of FIR No.27/2013
dated 21.03.2013 of Kumarghat PS, CID of Tripura Police
had filed a charge-sheet vide Final Report No.61/2013
dated 16.11.2016 U/s 420/406/409/120(B)/34 of IPC
and U/s 3 of TPID, Act 2011 against the accusedpetitioner Ratneswar Das and 11 others. The trial of the
said case pending before the Ld. District & Session’s
Court, Kailashahar, Unakoti and same has been stayed
owing to further investigation carried out by CBI.
4. That, further investigation carried out by CBI revealed
that M/s Kama (Indian) Projects & Service Ltd., a NonBanking Financial Company (NBFC), had opened one of its
branch office at Kumarghat and accepted deposits from
the general public with promise to give high returns. The
accused-petitioner had helped the principal accused
Minnatulla Barbhuiya, Director of M/s Kama (Indian)
Projects & Services Ltd. to open the said branch office at
Kumarghat and was instrumental in recruitment of most
of the agents and office staff of Kumarghat Branch of the
said company.
5. That, during further investigation, the accusedpetitioner was interrogated/examined on 13.06.2023 but
he didn’t co-operate and his replies to all the material
questions were evasive. Thereafter, the accusedpetitioner was asked to join investigation for further,
interrogation vide notice no.RC2262023E0002/1140
dated 18.07.2023 but he did not turn up.
6. That, during further investigation, it was found that
accused-petitioner
is
maintaining
SB
A/c
No.31749580829 with SBI, Kumarghat Branch and the
operation of the said account was stopped in exercise of
powers conferred u/s 102 of Cr.P.C. as accused-petitioner
was one of the main person responsible for operation of
branch office of M/s Kama (Indian) Projects & Services
Ltd. at Kumarghat. Further investigation with regard to
said SB account is to be carried out.”
So the respondents No.1 and 2 by the counteraffidavit prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
07.
It is to be noted here that by order dated
21.12.2023 passed in IA No.01 of 2023 arising out of this
petition a direction was given to release the pension amount
from the month of December, 2023 till disposal of the writ
petition. The operative portion of the said order dated
21.12.2023 is mentioned below:
“In view of the above, without observing anything on the
merit of the writ petition, the respondents are hereby
directed to allow the petitioner to draw only his pension
amount payable w.e.f. December, 2023 till disposal of the
writ petition, through said bank account.”
08.
In course of hearing Learned counsel Mr. H. Deb
submitted that the petitioner being old and aged person and
without any basis he has been harassed by the respondents
No.1 and 2 and he is passing days in severe hardships in
absence of his pension amount. Learned counsel further
submitted that from the counter-affidavit it appears that
save and except filing of a criminal case no material could
levelled against the petitioner to withholding his pension.
According to Learned counsel the allegation was a private
company for defrauding the local consumers/public and the
petitioner had got no access with them. But without any
basis he has been implicated in the case. It was further
submitted that there is no allegation that the petitioner
misappropriated or defalcated any money from the public
ex-chequer. So the allegation levelled by the respondents
No.1 and 2 against the petitioner is totally baseless,
concocted and on the basis of that there was no scope to
withhold his pension payment with the bank authority as
per the requisition of the respondent No.2. So Learned
counsel finally urged for allowing this writ petition directing
the respondents to release the pension in favour of the
petitioner.
09.
Per
contra,
Learned
DSGI
representing
the
respondents No.1 and 2 submitted that on 09.03.2011 the
present petitioner deposited Rs.10,000/- to the said Kama
Indian Projects and Services Limited and thereafter on
26.03.2012 further he deposited Rs.25,000/- and again he
deposited Rs.25,000/- to the said Company Limited. That
was the allegation against the petitioner. But regarding
withholding pension Learned DSGI could not give any
proper account. He also could not show any legal reasons
how the authority withhold the payment of pension of the
petitioner being a senior most citizen and a responsible
public servant who went on superannuation in the year
1993 from the post of Superintendent of Agriculture,
Kumarghat, Unakoti District, Govt. of Tripura. Lastly he
submitted that there is no scope legally to withhold the
payment of pension and as per order of the court that has
been regularized.
10.
I have heard detailed argument of Learned
counsels of both the sides and gone through the papers
submitted in this writ petition. Just because filing of a
criminal case it cannot be said that the charge is proved
against any person. Here in the given case the petitioner
was a Superintendent of Agriculture prior to his retirement
and in the year 1993 i.e. on 31.07.1993 he went on
superannuation from the said post and presently aged about
years
old.
It
was
the
allegation
that
he
deposited/invested some money to a Private Company
Limited who might have defrauded some of the investors.
But there is/was no such record that in discharging the
official duties the petitioner misappropriated/defalcated any
public money from the public ex-chequer. There is also no
evidence on record that he defalcated public money and
that amount was invested to the said alleged defalcated
company. Situated thus, in absence of material evidence on
record on the basis of a criminal case it is surprising that
how
the
respondent
No.4
on
the
requisition
of
the
respondent No.2 withhold the payment of the petitioner.
Learned DSGI in course of hearing could not give any
satisfactory answers in this regard. As already stated, the
present petitioner being a retired public servant presently
aged about 83 years old or more and was suffering from
severe mental agony and tension and was suffering from
financial hardships. No satisfactory materials laid by the
respondents No.1 and 2 to withhold the payment of pension
of the petitioner from his pension account. The respondents
No.3 and 4 being the banking authority from whom the
petitioner used to draw pension did not dare to appear
before the court inspite of receipt of notice. This practice
was
also
unbecoming
and
unwarranted
which
shows/indicates that their action was also not at all healthy,
fair and transparent to withhold the payment of pension to
the
petitioner.
Learned
DSGI
finally
submitted
that
necessary order may be passed for release of pension as he
failed to counter any valid came to withhold the pension
payment of the petitioner.
11.
In
State
of
Jharkhand
and
Others
vs.
Kitendra Jumar Srivastava and Another reported in
(2013) 12 SCC 210 Hon’ble the Apex Court in para Nos.8,
16, 17 and 18 observed as under:
“8. It is an accepted position that gratuity and pension
are not the bounties. An employee earns these benefits
by dint of his long, continuous, faithful and un-blemished
service. Conceptually it is so lucidly described in D.S.
Nakara and Ors. Vs. Union of India; (1983) 1 SCC 305 by
Justice D.A. Desai, who spoke for the Bench, in his
inimitable style, in the following words:
18.The approach of the respondents raises a vital
and none too easy of answer, question as to why
pension is paid. And why was it required to be
liberalised? Is the employer, which expression will
include even the State, bound to pay pension? Is
there any obligation on the employer to provide for
the erstwhile employee even after the contract of
employment has come to an end and the employee
has ceased to render service?
19. What is a pension? What are the goals of
pension? What public interest or purpose, if any, it
seeks to serve? If it does seek to serve some
public purpose, is it thwarted by such artificial
division of retirement pre and post a certain date?
We need seek answer to these and incidental
questions so as to render just justice between
parties to this petition.
20. The antiquated notion of pension being a
bounty a gratuitous payment depending upon the
sweet will or grace of the employer not claimable
as a right and, therefore, no right to pension can
be enforced through Court has been swept under
the carpet by the decision of the Constitution
Bench in Deoki Nandan Prasad v. State of Bihar
and Ors.[1971] 2 SCC 330 wherein this Court
authoritatively ruled that pension is a right and the
payment of it does not depend upon the discretion
of the Government but is governed by the rules
and a Government servant coming within those
rules is entitled to claim pension. It was further
held that the grant of pension does not depend
upon any one’s discretion. It is only for the
purpose of quantifying the amount having regard
to service and other allied maters that it may be
necessary for the authority to pass an order to that
effect but the right to receive pension flows to the
officer not because of any such order but by virtue
of the rules. This view was reaffirmed in State of
Punjab and Anr. V. Iqbal Singh(1976) 2 SCC 1.
It is thus a hard earned benefit which accrues to
an employee and is in the nature of “property”.
This right to property cannot be taken away without the
due process of law as per the provisions of Article 300-A
of the Constitution of India.
16. The fact remains that there is an imprimatur to the
legal principle that the right to receive pension is
recognized as a right in “property”.
Article 300-A of the Constitution of India reads as
under:
300A Persons not to be deprived of property save
by authority of law. - No person shall be deprived
of his property save by authority of law.
Once we proceed on that premise, the answer to
the question posed by us in the beginning of this
judgment becomes too obvious. A person cannot
be deprived of this pension without the authority
of law, which is the Constitutional mandate
enshrined in Article 300-A of the Constitution. It
follows that attempt of the appellant to take away
a part of pension or gratuity or even leave
encashment without any statutory provision and
under the umbrage of administrative instruction
cannot be countenanced.
17. It hardly needs to be emphasized that the executive
instructions are not having statutory character and,
therefore, cannot be termed as “law” within the meaning
of aforesaid Article 300-A. On the basis of such a circular,
which is not having force of law, the appellant cannot
withhold even a part of pension or gratuity. As we noticed
above, so far as statutory Rules are concerned, there is
no provision for withholding pension or gratuity in the
given situation. Had there been any such provision in
these Rules, the position would have been different.
18. We, accordingly, find that there is no merit in the
instant appeals as the impugned order of the High Court
is without blemish. Accordingly, these appeals are
dismissed with costs quantified at Rs. 10,000/- each.”
In Dr. Hira Lal vs. State of Bihar and Others
reported in (2020) 4 SCC 346, Hon’ble the Supreme Court
held as under:
“22. It is well settled that the right to pension cannot be
taken away by a mere executive fiat or administrative
instruction. Pension and gratuity are not mere bounties,
or given out of generosity by the employer. An employee
earns these benefits by virtue of his long, continuous,
faithful and un-blemished service:(2013) 12 SCC 210. The
right to receive pension of a public servant has been held
to be covered under the “right to property” under Article
31(1) of the Constitution by a Constitution Bench of this
Court in Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar:(1971) 2
SCC 330 which ruled that:
30. The question whether the pension granted to a
public
servant
is
property
attracting Article
31(1) came up for consideration before the Punjab
High Court in Bhagwant Singh v. Union of
India [AIR 1962 Punj 503] . It was held that such a
right constitutes “property” and any interference
will
be
a
breach
of Article
31(1) of
the
Constitution. It was further held that the State
cannot by an executive order curtail or abolish
altogether the right of the public servant to receive
pension. This decision was given by a learned
Single Judge. This decision was taken up in letters
patent appeal by the Union of India. Letters Patent
Bench in its decision in Union of India v. Bhagwant
Singh [ILR 1965 2 Punj 1] approved the decision of
the learned Single Judge. The Letters Patent Bench
held that the pension granted to a public servant
on his retirement is “property” within the meaning
of Article 31(1) of the Constitution and he could be
deprived of the same only by an authority of law
and that pension does not cease to be property on
the mere denial or cancellation of it. It was further
held that the character of pension as “property”
cannot possibly undergo such mutation at the
whim of a particular person or authority.
31. The matter again came up before a Full Bench
of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in K.R. Erry
v. State of Punjab [ILR 1967 1 Punj & Har 278].
The High Court had to consider the nature of the
right of an officer to get pension. The majority
quoted with approval the principles laid down in
the two earlier decisions of the same High Court,
referred to above, and held that the pension is not
to be treated as a bounty payable on the sweet will
and pleasure of the Government and that the right
to superannuation pension including its amount is
a valuable right vesting in a government servant.
It was further held by the majority that even
though an opportunity had already been afforded
to the officer on an earlier occasion for showing
cause against the imposition of penalty for lapse or
misconduct on his part and he has been found
guilty, nevertheless, when a cut is sought to be
imposed in the quantum of pension payable to an
officer on the basis of misconduct already proved
against him, a further opportunity to show-cause
in that regard must be given to the officer. This
view regarding the giving of further opportunity
was expressed by the learned Judges on the basis
of the relevant Punjab Civil Service Rules. But the
learned Chief Justice in his dissenting judgment
was not prepared to agree with the majority that
under such circumstances a further opportunity
should be given to an officer when a reduction in
the amount of pension payable is made by the
State. It is not necessary for us in the case on hand
to consider the question whether before taking
action by way of reducing or denying the pension
on the basis of disciplinary action already taken, a
further notice to show-cause should be given to an
officer. That question does not arise for
consideration before us. Nor are we concerned
with the further question regarding the procedure,
if any, to be adopted by the authorities before
reducing or withholding the pension for the first
time after the retirement of an officer. Hence we
express no opinion regarding the views expressed
by the majority and the minority Judges in the
above Punjab High Court decision on this aspect.
But we agree with the view of the majority when it
has approved its earlier decision that pension is
not a bounty payable on the sweet will and
pleasure of the Government and that, on the other
hand, the right to pension is a valuable right
vesting in a government servant.
33. Having due regard to the above decisions, we
are of the opinion that the right of the petitioner to
receive pension is property under Article 31(1) and
by a mere executive order the State had no power
to withhold the same. Similarly, the said claim is
also property under Article 19(1)(f) and it is not
saved by clause (5) of Article 19. Therefore, it
follows that the order, dated June 12, 1968,
denying the petitioner right to receive pension
affects the fundamental right of the petitioner
under Articles
19(1)(f) and 31(1) of
the
Constitution, and as such the writ petition
under Article 32 is maintainable.
[emphasis supplied]
23. The aforesaid judgment was followed in D.S. Nakara
and Ors. v. Union of India:(1983) 1 SCC 305 by
another Constitution bench of this Court, which held that:
20. The antiquated notion of pension being a
bounty, a gratuitous payment depending upon the
sweet will or grace of the employer not claimable
as a right and, therefore, no right to pension can
be enforced through Court has been swept under
the carpet by the decision of the Constitution
Bench in Deoki Nandan Prasad v. State of Bihar
and Ors wherein this Court authoritatively ruled
that pension is a right and the payment of it does
not depend upon the discretion of the Government
but is governed by the rules and a Government
servant coming within those rules is entitled to
claim pension. It was further held that the grant of
pension does not depend upon any one's
discretion. It is only for the purpose of quantifying
the amount having regard to service and other
allied maters that it may be necessary for the
authority to pass an order to that effect but the
right to receive pension flows to the officer not
because of any such order but by virtue of the
rules. This view was reaffirmed in State of Punjab
and Anr. v. Iqbal Singh:(1976) 2 SCC 1.
29. Summing up it can be said with confidence that
pension is not only compensation for loyal service
rendered in the past, but pension also has a
broader significance, in that it is a measure of
socio-economic justice which inheres economic
security in the fall of life when physical and mental
prowess is ebbing corresponding to aging process
and, therefore, one is required to fall back on
savings. One such saving in kind is when you give
your best in the hey-day of life to your employer,
in days of invalidity, economic security by way of
periodical payment is assured. The term has been
judicially defined as a stated allowance or stipend
made in consideration of past service or a
surrender of rights or emoluments to one retired
from service. Thus the pension payable to a
government employee is earned by rendering long
and efficient service and therefore can be said
to (1983)
SCC
305 (1971)
Supp.
S.C.R.
634 (1976) II LLJ 377 SC be a deferred portion of
the compensation or for service rendered. In one
sentence one can say that the most practical raison
d'etre for pension is the inability to provide for
oneself due to old age. One may live and avoid
unemployment but not senility and penury if there
is nothing to fall back upon.
31. From the discussion three things emerge: (i)
that pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of
grace depending upon the sweet will of the
employer and that it creates a vested right subject
to 1972 Rules which are statutory in character
because they are enacted in exercise of powers
conferred by the proviso to Article 309 and clause
(5) of Article 148 of the Constitution; (ii) that the
pension is not an ex gratia payment but it is a
payment for the past service rendered; and (iii) it
is a social welfare measure rendering socioeconomic justice to those who in the hey-day of
their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer on an
assurance that in their old age they would not be
left in lurch..”
[emphasis supplied]
24. The right to receive pension has been held to be a
right to property protected under Article 300-A of the
Constitution even after the repeal of Article 31(1) by
the Constitution
(Forty-Fourth
Amendment)
Act,
1978 w.e.f. 20.06.1979, as held in State of West Bengal v.
Haresh C. Banerjee and Ors.:(2006) 7 SCC 651.
25. The Division Bench of the Patna High Court in the
impugned judgment has relied solely on the earlier
decision of a co-ordinate bench of the Patna High Court
in Vijay Kumar Mishra v. State of Bihar: (2017) (1) PLJR
to
deny
the
reliefs
sought
by
the
Appellant. Pertinently, the judgment in Vijay Kumar
Mishra was overruled by a Full Bench of the Patna High
Court in Arvind Kumar Singh
Ors. :2018 SCC OnLine Pat 749.
v.
State
of
Bihar
&
26. In view of the above, we hold that the RespondentState was unjustified in withholding 10% pension of the
Appellant
under
administrative
Circulars
dated
22.08.1974 and 31.10.1974, and Government Resolution
No. 3104 dated 31.07.1980 after the Appellant had
superannuated on 31.03.2008. We direct that 10% of the
pension amount which had been withheld after
superannuation on 31.03.2008 till 19.07.2012 is liable to
be paid to the appellant within a period of 12 weeks from
the date of this judgment.”
12.
In view of the above, this court after hearing
both the sides direct the respondents that the respondents
shall continue to pay the pension to the petitioner including
arrear pensions, if any to his respective bank account
without any delay and shall continue to pay the same until
otherwise is directed. The order dated 21.12.2023 passed in
the connected IA No.1 of 2023 is thus made absolute. Since
the petitioner being old and aged person had to suffer
financial loss during his old days without any justified
grounds so the respondent No.4 shall pay litigation cost of
Rs.20,000/-(twenty thousand) to the petitioner within a
period of 3(three) months from today. Failing which, the
petitioner shall be at liberty to take appropriate steps by
due process of law.
With this observation and direction, this writ
petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.05.29
18:13:31 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review