Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.745 of 2023
Sri Ratan Kumar Das,
son of late Sunil Chandra Das, resident of
village- Hall Chowmuhani, P.O. Belonia,
Belonia, South Tripura, PIN-799155
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
to be represented by Commissioner &
Secretary, Rural Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN
799010
2.
The Project Director,
District
Rural
Development
Kailashahar, Tripura (North)
Agency,
3.
The Project Director (ADM & Collector),
District Rural Development Agency, Gomati
District, Udaipur
4.
The Chief Executive Officer (DM & Collector),
District Rural Development Agency, Gomati
District, Udaipur
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Ms. S. Debbarman, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarman, Addl. GA
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
03.07.2024
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner with the
following reliefs:
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
make the full and final payment of Gratuity with interest
@ 9% per annum to the Petitioner w.e.f. the date on
which gratuity became payable till date of payment after
adjusting lump sum amount of Rs.10,00,000/- already
paid.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders
and/or direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to allow the
benefit of revised pay scale to the Petitioner as per
Tripura State Pay Matrix-2018.
(iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or
order/orders and/or direction/directions of like nature
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
recalculate the initial pay of the Petitioner as per Tripura
State Pay Matrix-2018 and re-determination of gratuity
and leave encashment benefit.
(iv) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders
and/or direction/directions of like nature shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to release the
contributions made by the Petitioner on account of GSLI.
[2]
As stated, the petitioner was appointed as Steno-Typist
under the respondents in District Rural Development Agency (DRDA)
vide Memorandum dated 16.01.1982 and after rendering service of 37
years, he went on superannuation on 31.12.2019 from the post of PSIV. His last basic pay was Rs.83,010/-. His first grievance is that at
the time of retirement, the Chief Executive Officer, DRDA, Gomati i.e.
the D.M. & Collector, Gomati District issued approval and expenditure
sanction of Rs.13,69,665/- in his favour on the count of Death-cumRetirement Gratuity but only Rs.10,00,000/- was credited in his
account stating that the said amount was only admissible as per
notification of the Finance Department, Government of Tripura dated
11.07.2017, though vide notification dated 29.03.2018 the upper
ceiling limit of gratuity was enhanced from Rs.10,00,000/- to
Rs.20,00,000/- by the Central Government. According to him,
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is applicable in his case.
[3]
The second count of grievance of the petitioner is that the
Finance Department concurred with the proposal of DRDA towards
implementation of revised pay scale in terms of Tripura State Civil
Services (Revised Pay) (1st Amendment)
Rules, 2018 (for short-
Revised Pay - 1st Amendment Rules of 2018) in respect of the staff
working under the DRDA subject to the condition that the revision
may be considered w.e.f. 01.10.2018 notionally and actual benefit
may be given from 01.04.2020 and also the arrear may be paid, if
fund is sufficient. As regards the decision on revision of gratuity and
leave salary for these categories of employees, the same was decided
to be taken at a later date on the basis of the flow of fund. According
to the petitioner, such decision of the Finance Department was
evident from a letter dated 05.03.2020 (Annexure-10 of the writ
petition) of Director (Projects), DRDA, addressed to the Chief
Executive Officers (D.M. & Collector) of all Districts, but the benefit of
such pay matrix was denied to the petitioner though he retired on
31.12.2019 and refusal of such benefits was communicated to him
vide letter dated 25.08.2021 (Annexure-12 of the writ petition) of
Director (Projects), SLMC, RD, Government of Tripura on the ground
that as he had retired on 31.12.2019, he was not entitled to any such
financial benefit. According to the petitioner, he was entitled to both
gratuity and leave salary in terms of said Revised Pay - 1st
Amendment Rules of 2018.
[4]
The third count of grievance of the petitioner is that while
in service, he contributed Rs.100/- per month under the GSLI Scheme
but on his superannuation, such benefit of the GSLI Scheme was not
provided to him.
[5]
The respondents in their counter affidavit took the defence
that the petitioner was not eligible for revision of pay as per Revised
Pay - 1st Amendment Rules of 2018 in as much as the direction of the
Finance Department was to calculate the benefit notionally from
01.10.2018 and the actual benefit was to be given from 01.04.2020
subject to availability of fund and before the said date, the petitioner
went on superannuation. According to them, the amount of gratuity
was paid to the petitioner within 30 days from the date of his
retirement as per Tripura Civil Services ROP, 2018. Regarding the
GSLI amount, they stated that a letter in this regard was sent to the
Branch Manager (P & GS), LICI, Silchar Divisional Office, Hailakandi
Road, Silchar on 02.12.2020 (Annexure-D of the counter affidavit).
[6]
Ms. S. Debbarman, learned counsel led by learned senior
counsel, Mr. P. Roy Barman, appearing for the petitioner referred the
above said letter dated 05.03.2020 (Annexure-10 of the writ petition)
of the Director (Projects) and submitted that as per the said letter
itself, the petitioner was entitled to the benefits under said Revised
Pay-1st Amendment Rules of 2018 which was illegally denied to the
petitioner. To substantiate the claims, Ms. Debbarman, learned
counsel
further
referred
another
notification
dated
06.11.2018
(Annexure-13 of the writ petition) of the Finance Department
containing Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) (1 st Amendment)
Rules, 2018 whereby old Rule 15 was substituted with the following
words:
“Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in these
Rules, or in any other Rules for the time being in force,
the benefit of revision of pay for the month of October,
2018 payable in November 2018 and onwards shall be
provided in cash.
The Government employees, who had died/retired/
superannuated on or after the 1st day of October, 2018
and before publication of these Rules in the Official
Gazette, shall be paid arrear pay and allowances for the
period from the 1st day of October, 2018 upto the date of
his death/retirement/superannuation in cash.”
[7]
She also referred another notification dated 07.11.2014 of
the DRDA (Annexure-6 of the writ petition) containing the District
Rural Development Agency Employees Death cum Retirement Gratuity
and Leave Encashment Regulations of Tripura, 2014 wherein provision
for Encashment of Leave and Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity were
provided in the following terms:
Encashment of Leave: Employees of the Agency shall be
entitled to payment of Cash equivalent of leave salary, in
case of retirement, quitting of service, death in service or
invalidation from service in accordance with the relevant
provisions of Tripura State Civil Services (Leave) Rules,
1986 and the relevant orders issued from time to time,
subject to availability of fund under Direction and
Administration of DRDA on 90:10 sharing pattern
between the Government of India and the State
Government.
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity: Employees of the Agency
shall be entitled to payment of Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity in accordance with the relevant provisions of
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 as adopted
in the State, subject to availability of fund under
Direction and Administration of DRDA on 90:10 sharing
pattern between Government of India and the State
Government.
According to learned counsel, gratuity should be paid
taking into consideration the upper ceiling limit as determined by
Central Government in terms of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972
and not by above said provision.
[8]
Ms. Debbarman, learned counsel relied on some decisions
of this Court in the matter of payment of gratuity which will be
discussed in the later part of the judgment.
[9]
Mr. M. Debbarman, learned Addl. GA appearing for the
State-respondents argued that when separate rules were framed by
the State governing the gratuity of employees of DRDA, the petitioner
was not entitled to claim the gratuity in terms of Payment of Gratuity
Act, 1972. Ld. Counsel further argued that the Central Government
ought to have been made party in this case as sharing of fund in this
regard between the Union of India and the State Government is
90:10. Mr. Debbarman, learned Addl. GA also submitted that when
there is a separate provision for Leave Encashment for the employees
of DRDA, the petitioner would be guided by the same and all the dues
were accordingly cleared up by the department in favour of the
petitioner in due time without any delay.
[10]
So far the three counts of claims of the petitioner are
concerned, the same are being discussed one after another.
(i) Claim regarding applicability of Revised Pay 1st
Amendment Rules of 2018 and computation of
leave encashment and gratuity thereupon:
[11]
Tripura State Revised Pay Rules, 2017 was brought into
force w.e.f. 01.04.2017 and the said First Amendment thereof was
made effective from 01.10.2018. It is evident from the letter dated
05.03.2020 [Annexure-10 of the writ petition] of the Director
(Projects), State Level Monitoring Cell of SGSY, Rural Development
Department that the Finance Department concurred with the proposal
of the department towards implementation of revised pay scale in
terms of said Revised Pay - 1st Amendment Rules of 2018 in respect of
staff and workers under DRDA subject to the condition that revision
may be considered w.e.f. 01.10.2018 notionally and actual benefits
may be given from 01.04.2020. The arrears may be paid if fund is
found sufficient. Therefore, there is no doubt that the employees of
the DRDA were entitled to get revised pay scale in terms of said
Revised Pay-1st Amendment Rules of 2018. Only a condition was
imposed that the actual benefit would be paid from 01.04.2020 but
fixation of pay should notionally be done w.e.f. 01.10.2018. The said
decision does not cover the situation where an employee goes on
superannuation before 01.04.2020. Such imposition of condition of
giving actual financial benefits from 01.04.2020 on it‟s plain reading
creates the impression that it was meant for the employee who are in
service on said date 01.04.2020. But said decision of Finance
Department
nowhere
creates
any
bar
in
computing
the
post
retirement benefits of an employee based on said Revised Pay-1st
Amendment Rules of 2018, who went on retirement in between the
period 01.10.2018 to 01.04.2020. At best, fixation of pay of the
concerned employee may be done w.e.f. 01.10.2018 notionally till the
date of his retirement based on which his post retirement benefits
may be computed and paid to him. Therefore, the decision of the
respondents for not giving the benefits of aid 1st Amendment Rules of
2018 to the petitioner on his retirement was arbitrary and illegal. His
pay could be fixed notionally w.e.f. 01.10.2018 and his post
retirement benefits, as admissible, ought to have been provided as
per the said Amendment Rules of 2018 with effect from the date of his
retirement. The letter dated 11.12.2020 [Annexure-A of the counter
affidavit] of Project Director, DRDA, Gomati District, Udaipur shows
that the Gratuity and the Leave Encashment benefits were released in
favour of the petitioner as per Tripura Pay Matrix, 2017, which was,
therefore, not in accordance with the said rules.
(ii) Claim regarding applicability of revised ceiling
limit as prescribed by the Central Government in
terms of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972:
[12]
Ms. S. Debbarman, learned counsel during her submissions
referred two decisions of this Court in case of Sri Jagadish Ch. Deb
vs. State of Tripura & Ors. [first judgment and order dated
19.02.2019 delivered in W.P.(C) No.234 of 2014 and subsequent
order dated 10.05.2022 delivered in W.P.(C) No.288 of 2021] but
both the decisions are on different perspectives and therefore, are not
of any assistance to the petitioner. However, learned counsel also
referred to another decision of this Court in the case of Sri Samir
Kumar Ghosh vs. the State of Tripura & Ors. [Judgment and order
dated 29.05.2020 delivered in W.P.(C) No.1091 of 2017] wherein the
petitioner was an employee of Agartala Municipal Corporation whose
gratuity was fixed by the respondents as per CCS Pension Rules, 1972
and not in terms of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. This Court finally
held that the employees of Municipal Corporation will be guided by
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and directed that Agartala Municipal
Corporation should calculate the gratuity in terms of Section 4(2) of
the Act payable to the petitioner of that case by taking into account
his basic salary and dearness allowance.
[13]
In Sri Bhupati Debnath vs. the State of Tripura
[judgment and order dated 13.02.2020 delivered in W.P.(C) No.1054
of 2019], as relied on by Ms. Debbarman, learned counsel, the
petitioner
was
a
retired
employee
of
Tripura
Handloom
and
Handicrafts Development Corporation Ltd., who was not paid the
Gratuity amount on his retirement taking into consideration the
revised ceiling limit of Rs.20,00,000/- under the said Act of 1972. In
Para-11 of the said decision, this Court has held as under:
11. This revised ceiling thus would apply to all
establishments irrespective of whether they are controlled
or governed by the State or the Central Government as the
appropriate Government. The stand of the respondents,
therefore, that unless and until such revised ceiling of
payment of gratuity is adopted by the State Government,
the employees of the said corporation cannot claim benefit
of such revised limit cannot be accepted. Revised ceiling
limit of ₹20,00,000 (rupees twenty lakhs) would be
applicable to the petitioner.
[14]
Ms. Debbarman, learned counsel also relied on another
decision of this Court in Lal Zakim Rokhum vs. Tripura Road
Transport
Corporation
&
Ors.
[Judgment
and
order
dated
20.02.2020 delivered in W.P.(C) No.1209 of 2019] wherein reference
was also made to the above said observation made in Bhupati
Debnath (supra). In this case the petitioner was a retired employee
of Tripura Road Transport Corporation and he claimed payment of
gratuity in terms of the enhanced ceiling limit of Rs.20,00,000/- as
was issued vide notification dated 29.03.2018 of Government of India.
Finally in said case also enhanced ceiling limit of gratuity of
Rs.20,00,000/- was applied.
[15]
In Agartala Municipal Corporation & Anr. vs. Ratna
Roy and others [Judgment and order dated 19.02.2024 delivered in
W.A. No.161 of 2022 decided analogously with some other appeals]
by the Division Bench of this Court wherein I had the occasion to be a
member of the said Bench also similarly directed the Agartala
Municipal Corporation-respondents to calculate the admissible gratuity
of the appellants therein who retired after 29.03.2018 taking into
consideration the revised ceiling limit of Rs.20,00,000/- in terms of
the provision of the said Act of 1972. Recently this Court in the case
of Smt. Bina Rani Paul & Ors. vs. State of Tripura and Ors.
[Judgment and order dated 09.05.2024 delivered in W.P.(C) No.624
of 2024] held that Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 was also applicable
in case of Anganwadi Workers and Anganwadi Helpers working in
Tripura.
[16]
The
DRDA
is
an
agency
established
for
effective
implementation of anti poverty programmes in rural areas at the
district level and to support and facilitate the development processes
and also to coordinate with all the agencies involved therein for such
purposes. It is a principal organ at district level to oversee the
implementation of different anti poverty programmes of the Central
Government. DRDA works under the control of the State Government.
As per definition of „establishment‟ as provided in Section 2(e) of
Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act,
1991, „establishment‟ means any office under the State, a local or
statutory authority constituted under the constitution of India or any
other law for the time being in force or a Corporation in which not less
than fifty one percent of the paid-up share capital is held by the State
Government and includes Universities and Colleges affiliated to the
Universities,
Primary
and
Secondary
Schools
and
also
other
educational institutions which are owned or aided by the State
Government and also includes an establishment in Public Sector.
By an amendment of 2005, the words “any office of the State
Government” was substituted by the words “any office under the
State” giving wider definition of the same and bringing all the
establishments under the State within the purview of said Act though
all
such
establishments
may
not
be
the
office
of
the
State
Government. As per Section 2(f) of said Act, any industry, trade,
business or occupation owned, controlled or managed by the State is
treated as „establishment in public sector‟. Ld. Addl. G.A., on query by
the Court, also informed that Tripura Schedule Castes and Schedule
Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 is applicable in DRDA and also placed
some documents in the record in this regard.
[17]
In the case of Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya vs. District
Development Officer Dahod and others, 2022 SCC OnLine SC
507 also, a very wider meaning of „establishment‟ was given by
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
to
include
Government
offices
and
establishment within such definition. Therefore, there is no doubt that
DRDA is also an establishment within the meaning of Section 1(3)(b)
of the Act of 1972. Section 5 of the said Act of 1972 authorises the
appropriate government to exempt any establishment to which the
Act applies from operation of provision of the said Act, if in the opinion
of the appropriate government, the employee in such establishment
are in receipt of gratuity or pensionary benefits not less favourable
than the benefits conferred under the Act of 1972.
[18]
The
State
Government
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India has framed a Rule, called District Rural
Development Agency Employees Death cum Retirement Gratuity and
Leave Encashment Regulations of Tripura, 2014 and as indicated
earlier that the provisions were made for Encashment of Leave and
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity of the employees of the DRDA in the
said Rules. It was notified on 07.11.2014 and was made applicable to
the regular employees of DRDA who were in service on or after
31.01.2011. The said rules prescribes that Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity would be paid to the employees of DRDA in accordance with
the relevant provisions of Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972
as adopted in the State subject to availability of fund under direction
and administration of DRDA on 90:10 sharing pattern between the
Government of India and the State Government. The said Rules of
1972 as adopted in the State of Tripura provides the upper ceiling
limit of Gratuity to the extent of Rs.10,00,000/- whereas already vide
notification
bearing
No.
S.O
1420(E)
dated
29.03.2018,
the
Government of India has made the revised ceiling limit of gratuity to
the extent of Rs.20,00,000/-. Therefore, in view of provisions of
Section 5 of the said Act of 1972 as indicated above less favourable
amount of gratuity cannot be paid to an employee where the provision
of Act of 1972 is applicable.
[19]
In view of the above, it is held that the petitioner is entitled
to get the amount of gratuity taking into consideration the revised
ceiling limit of Rs.20,00,000/- as was notified by the Government of
India as indicated above.
(iii) Claim regarding GSLI:
[20]
It
appears
from
the
documents
submitted
under
Annexure-D of the counter affidavit of the respondents that the
petitioner initially contributed Rs.60/- per month and thereafter,
Rs.100/- per month under the GSLI Scheme and in this regard, on
02.12.2020, a letter was written by the Project Director, DRDA,
Gomati District to the Branch Manager LICI, Silchar Division, Silchar
for making necessary payment to the petitioner under said scheme.
The respondents No.3 & 4 will take up the matter with LICI to ensure
that the said benefit is provided to the petitioner immediately, if not
already paid.
[21]
In the result, the writ petition is allowed and disposed of in
the following terms:
The
respondents
shall
re-determine
the
post
retirement benefits of the petitioner i.e the Leave
Encashment and Gratuity after fixation of his basic pay
in terms of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay)
(1st Amendment) Rules, 2018 in the light of the
discussions made in Para-11 above. The Gratuity
payable to the petitioner will be computed after taking
into
consideration
the
revised
ceiling
limit
of
Rs.20,00,000/- as notified by the Government of India
vide notification dated 29.03.2018 and payment of
arrears will be made accordingly. The respondents will
also pay interest @7% per annum on the rest amount
of Leave Encashment and Gratuity, computing from the
date after the expiry of one month of the date of
retirement of the petitioner till payment is made.
The respondents will also ensure payment of
benefits under the GSLI Scheme to the petitioner as
indicated above accordingly at the earliest after taking
up the matter with LICI, if the same is not already paid.
All the above said exercises should be done within
4[four] months from the receipt of the copy of this
Judgment and order.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2024.07.03 18:49:36 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review