Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 297 of 2025
Sri Ratan Datta, S/O. late Sitanath Datta,
Resident of 79, Akhaaura Road, Ramnagar,
Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
PIN-799002
……Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by the Secretary, Revenue
Department, Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The District Collector, O/o. The District Magistrate & Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District- West
Tripura, PIN-799001
3. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, O/o. The Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, West Tripura, Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799001
4. Smt. Helen Rani Roy, W/O. late Bhupendra Nath Roy, Resident
of Sakuntala Road, Near Rabindra Bhavan, Agartala, P.S.-West
Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN-799001
.......Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Sovan Mahajan, Advocate
Mr. Jyotishmay Das, Advocate
Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Advocate
Ms. Saswati Nag, Advocate
Mr. E.L. Darlong, Advocate
Mr. Sreekant Bal, Advocate
Mr. Rakesh Debnath, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Advocate General
Mr. T.D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. G.A.
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. Dalit Kalai, Advocate
Mr. Keneth L. Debbarma, Advocate
Ms. Budhinika Kaipeng, Advocate
Ms. Shipthang Rani Kaipeng, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & order
:
03.11.2025.
Whether fit for reporting
Yes
:
____________
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
[1]
Heard Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. E.L. Darlon, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned Advocate General and Mr. P. Gautam, learned
Sr. G.A. appearing for the official respondents No.1, 2 & 3. Mr. T.D.
Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K. L. Debbarma, is also
present on behalf of unofficial respondent No.4.
[2]
This present petition is filed under Section 226 of the Constitution
of India seeking following reliefs:
“(i) Issue notice upon the Respondents.
(ii) Call for the records.
(iii) Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why the impugned order dated 27-02-2025(Annexure-19) passed by
the Respondent No.2 i.e, District Collector and Magistrate, Agartala,
West Tripura in connection with the Review case no. 55 of 2025 and
the whole review proceedings shall not be quashed and set aside.
(iv) Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why the impugned suo moto proceeding U/S 95 of TLR & LR Act,
1960 vide Case No. 179 of 2025 initiated by respondent no 2, D.M &
Collector, West Tripura, Agartala, vide order dated 18-02-2025
(ΑΝΝEXURE-17) in connection with the Review case no 55 of 2025
and the whole review proceedings shall not be quashed and set aside.
(v) Issue Rule calling upon all the respondents in general and
respondent no 2 in person to show cause as to under what authority
he deliberately violated the order status quo dated 05-08-2017 in c/w
case no. Civil Misc(Inj) 34 of 2017 arising out of TS (CC) 01 of
2017 passed by Ld. Civil Judge, Sr. Div Court No: 3, Agartala
(Annexure-9) and initiated the impugned suo moto proceeding U/S
95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 vide Case No. 179 of 2025 by passing
the impugned orders dated 18-02-2025 (ANNEXURE- 17) and
impugned order dated 27-02-2025(Annexure-19).
(vi) Issue Rule calling upon all the respondents in general and
respondent no 2 in person to show cause as to under what authority
he deliberately violated the order status quo dated 05-08-2017 in c/w
case no: Civil Misc (Inj.) 34 of 2017 arising out of TS (CC) 01 of
2017 passed by Ld.Civil Judge, Sr. Div. Court No: 3, Agartala
(Annexure-9) thereby causing immense mental pain and agony to the
petitioner and why appropriate proceedings /writ should not be
initiated/issued against him and why respondents in general and
respondent no 2 in person should not be liable to pay
compensation/cost if ordered by this Hon'ble Court.
(vii) And after hearing the parties be pleased to make the rule
absolute. ……….................”
[3]
The case of the petitioner in brief is that in the year 2002, the
he purchased two plots of land, total land measuring 0.0564 Acres, of
Mouja Agartala Sheet No.3, in Hal Plot No.2045/2525 and 2046/2526
classified as Bastu (Nal) by Sale Deed 1-3679. Dated 26/04/2002 from
Smt. Niyati Bhattacharjee, W/O Lt. Jiban Chakraborty. Smt. Eliza
Chakraborty, Smt. Lopamudra Roy and Smt Nayana Chakraborty, all
D/O late Jiban Chakraborty. It is contended that in the said registered sale
deed, there are two schedules of land namely Schedule A (homestead
land measuring 2 Gandas 1 Kara 1 Kranta 19 Dhurs). Schedule B
(Pathway) measuring 8 feet in breadth and 46-6" feet in length, i.e. land
measuring 1 Kara 2 Krantas 3 dhurs, and the total land including the path
way stands as 2 Gandas 3 Karas 1 Kranta 2 Dhurs i.e. 0.0564 Acres. It is
further contended that subsequently, by virtue of three separate deeds,
one from Smt Ranjana Chakraborty alias Smt. Ranjana Chakraborty
(Choudhury), W/O- Sri Manik Lal Coudhury, alias Sri Mani Lal
Choudhury, through her constituted power of attorney namely Sri.
Chunilal Ghosh, S/O-Lt. Chandra Kr Ghosh, vide Sale Deed Number 1747 dated 22/01/2011, another from Sri Sushen Ranjan Choudhury vide
sale deed number I-5279. Dated 06/09/2010 and another from Sri Raja
Dasgupta, vide sale deed number 1-2855, Dated-19/06/2009 the
petitioner became the owner and possessor of three other small plots of
adjacent land.
[4]
Thus, in that aforementioned manner, the petitioner by way
of said three registered sale deeds purchased total land measuring 0.0349
Acre of Hal Plot No. 2047, corresponding to Sabek plot MPB 84,
2620/45638, classified as Viti (Nal), of Mouja Agartala Sheet No.3,
covered under Khatian No. 1438/1. The petitioner after purchasing the
said lands, applied for record of rights of the said lands in the name of the
petitioner before the Sub-Division Magistrate, Sadar, West Tripura. It is
also contended that the above-mentioned land was originally allotted in
the year 1978 vide Allotment Case No. 773/76 to the original allottee
namely Anil Chakraborty, S/O Ramanath Chakraborty and Others.
Accordingly, record of right was also prepared in their name vide
Khatian No. 1438/1, 2 & 3. But in the said khatian it was noted that the
land cannot be transferred without the permission of the District
Collector.
[5]
It is further submitted that in the year 1993, there was a
partition suit before learned Civil Judge Senior Division No. 1, Agartala,
West Tripura and in Partition Case Vide No. Title Suit (Partition) No.
103 of 1994 titled as Sri Jiban Chandra Chakraborty Versus Smt.
Prababati Chakraborty & Anr., a partition was decreed vide Judgment
and Decree dated 31-01-1997. Accordingly the said land was partitioned
amongst the partners. It is contended by the petitioner that he had
purchased the land as mentioned earlier, on the basis of said judgment
and decree.
[6]
It is further contended that in Khatian No. 1438/1, 1438/2
&1438/3 it was reflected that, the land cannot be transferred without the
permission of the District Collector. So, the petitioner had filed an
application seeking permission from the competent authority for
transferring the land in favour of his name as well as for the mutation of
the land in his favour. Accordingly the Competent Authority i.e. the
Office of the District Magistrate & Collector. West Tripura, Vide No. F
15(5)-DM/W/REV/MISC/2156/2016, Dated 22-06-2016 prepared a
detailed report before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sadar Sub-Division,
West Tripura. Thereafter, the petitioner got mutation order vide MR No
201640781 dated 02. 11. 2016 in his favor from the competent authority
and finally record of right vide Khatian no: 1438/1 of Mouja Agartala
Sheet 3 was also published in the name of the petitioner in government
revenue records with reference to the land in question and the petitioner
has been possessing the aforementioned plots by constructing pucca
wall/tin fencing with GCI sheet roofing rooms thereon and enjoying the
said plot of land without any disturbance from any corner.
[7]
The unofficial respondent no. 4 herein, in the month of
December, 2016 filed a suit against the petitioner vide no. T.S. 147 of
2016, and the same is pending before the learned Court of Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Court No. 3. Agartala, West Tripura. In the said suit,
the present respondent No. 4 of the instant petition, claimed for a
declaration of right of use of the path purchased by the petitioner along
with some other consequential reliefs. Inter alia, in the said suit, the
respondent no. 4 claimed a plot of land measuring 220 Square feet,
mentioned as "Schedule-B" in the plaint as her purchased land. It is
contended that in connection with the said suit, the petitioner herein filed
one counter claim against respondent No-4 vide case no TS(CC) 01 of
2017 before the Court of learned Civil Judge Senior Division, Court No.
3. West Tripura, Agartala and further in connection with his counter
claim vide case no. TS (CC) 01 of 2017, the petitioner filed one
injunction petition bearing no. Civil Misc(Inj.) 34 of 2017 arising out of
TS (CC) 01 of 2017. It is submitted that considering rival submissions,
the learned Trial Court i.e. Civil Judge Senior Division Court No. 03
passed an order of status quo dated 05-08-2017 in connection with case
no. Civil Misc (Inj.) 34 of 2017 till disposal of both the cases numbered
TS 147 of 2016 and TS (CC) 01 of 2017.
[8]
However, during pendency of the said civil suits before the
Court of learned Civil Judge Senior Division, Court No. 3, Agartala, as
mentioned hereinabove, the respondent No 4, filed an application under
Section 95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 before the DM & Collector, West
Tripura, Agartala for setting aside the order dated 03-11-2016 passed by
the Dy. Collector & Magistrate, Agartala Revenue Circle, Sadar, West
Tripura and the same was registered as Revenue case vide no. 44 of 2018
under Section 95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960. The Petitioner after receiving
notice of the said proceeding under Section 95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960
from the respondents contested the said proceeding by filing his written
objection on 28-02-2019. It is stated that, inter alia in the said written
objection, the petitioner mentioned the pendency of the aforesaid civil
suits and more specifically after the order of 'status quo' dated 05-082017 in c/w Civil Misc(Inj.) 34 of 2017 arising out of TS (CC) 01 of
2017. It has also been contended that respondent No.4 is estopped to
challenge the mutation proceeding vide MR No. 201640781 and Khatian
No. 1438/1 before the revenue authority as the said respondent had
already raised similar grievance/contention with regard to the subject
matter before the learned Civil Court.
[9]
After considering the rival submissions and material facts,
the District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala, dropped the
said proceeding No. Revenue case No. 44 of 2018 U/S 95 of TLR & LR
Act, 1960 vide Order dated 09-02-2021 considering the fact that the said
Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the matter or to maintain hearing on
the same land during pendency of the Civil Suit.
[10]
Thereafter, again on 19-12-2022, the respondent No 4
hereinabove, filed one Review petition against the Order dated 09-022021 passed in Revenue case No. 44 of 2018 on the ground of
jurisdictional error and the same was registered as Review case vide no.
55 of 2025 under Section 96 of TLR & LR Act, 1960. It is also contended
that in filing the said Review petition there had been a delay of 255 day
and as such, Respondent No 4 filed an application under Section 5 of
Limitation Act, 1963 which was registered as Review case vide no. 01 of
2022 under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 for condonation of
delay of 255 days in the filing the review petition against the Order dated
09-02-2021. Inter alia in the said condonation petition it was contended
that learned Advocate of the Petitioner of the said case, or the person
herself in the said case did not get any notice from the Court for which
the case was dropped on the ground of jurisdictional error, whereas,
according to the petitioner herein, it is clear from the Order dated 09-022021 that the District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala,
dropped the said proceeding under section 95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 on
the ground that the Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the matter or to
continue hearing on the same land during pendency of the Civil Suit.
[11]
According to the petitioner, the said Revenue Court without
considering the submission of the petitioner, allowed the said
condonation petition without considering that Section 5 of Limitation
Act has got no application since TLR & LR Act, 1960 prescribes its own
Law of limitation. Thereafter, the review proceedings was posted on 2201-2025, 18-02-2025 & 27-02-2025 and detail written reply was
submitted on behalf of the petitioner. In connection with Revenue Case
no. 55/2025, the petitioner herein on 18.02.2025 submitted his detailed
written reply wherein inter alia the petitioner mentioned about the order
of revenue authority passed on 09.02.21 in Revenue Case no. 44/2018 on
the ground that civil cases are pending on the similar cause of action and
that the pre conditions of entertaining review petition by checking the
status of civil cases were not done as per the order of sanction for review.
Inter alia, the petitioner also apprised the revenue authority about the
order of status quo dated 05-08-2017 in c/w case no Civil Misc(Inj.) 34
of 2017 arising out of TS (CC) 01 of 2017 passed by learned Court of
Civil Judge, Sr. Div. West Tripura, Agartala, Court No. 3. Thereafter, on
18.02.2025 respondent No.2 initiated a suo moto proceeding U/S 95 of
TLR & LR Act, 1960 vide case No.179 of 2025. Finally, on 27-02-2025,
the respondent no 2 passed Order in connection with Review Case vide
no. 55 of 2025 under Section 96 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 and cancelled
the mutation of the homestead land in the name of the Petitioner. Being
aggrieved by the aforesaid order dated 27.02.2025 passed by the
respondent No.2 herein, the petitioner has preferred the present writ
petition seeking the afore-quoted reliefs.
[12]
Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner submits that
the Revenue Case No 44/2018, was
dropped vide order dated 09-02-2021 passed by District Magistrate &
Collector, West Tripura, Agartala, due to pending civil dispute between
the parties regarding the same land. It is contended that in the review case
under section 96 of the TLR and LR Act the scope is only to review the
said order for which review has been sought for but in the instant case, in
the Order Dated 27-02-2025, the Respondent No 2 acted illegally and
beyond the power and jurisdiction vested U/S 96 of TLR & LR Act, 1960
and passed the said impugned order. The respondent No.2 ignored the
order of a competent Court of law by passing the impugned order and
cancelled the mutation of the petitioner. He contends that the respondent
No.2 violated the order status quo dated 05-08-2017 in c/w case no. Civil
Misc(Inj) 34 of 2017 arising out of TS (CC) 01 of 2017 passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Sr. Div Court No. 3, Agartala and initiated the
impugned suo moto proceeding U/S 95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 vide
Case No. 179 of 2025 by passing the order dated 18-02-2025
and
impugned order dated 27-02-2025. He further submits that the petitioner's
mutation was illegally cancelled by the said respondent during pendency
of civil suit and that should be restored in its original form, i.e. mutation
status should be restored in the stage before filing of the Title Suit No.
147 of 2016 to maintain the order of 'status quo' otherwise the petitioner
would be severely prejudiced. Learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner therefore, urges before this Court to set aside the impugned
order dated 27.02.2025 passed by the respondent No.2 in Review Case
No.55 of 2025.
[13]
To support his contention, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner has placed reliance on the following paragraphs of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court titled as Bhimabai Mahadeo
Kambekar (Dead) through legal representative v. Arthur Import and
Export Company and others reported in (2019) 3 SCC 191, which are
extracted as under:
“……..6. This Court has consistently held that mutation of a land in the
revenue records does not create or extinguish the title over such land nor has
it any presumptive value on the title. It only enables the person in whose
favour mutation is ordered to pay the land revenue in question
7.
The High Court while dismissing the writ petition placed reliance on
the aforementioned law laid down by this Court and we find no good ground
to differ with the reasoning and the conclusion arrived at by the High Court.
It is just and proper calling for no interference.
8. It is not in dispute that the civil suits in relation to the land in question are
pending in the courts between the parties. Therefore, it would not be proper
to embark upon any factual inquiries into the question as to whether the
entries were properly made or not and at whose instance they were made, etc.
in this appeal. It is more so when they neither decide the title nor extinguish
the title of the parties in relation to the land……..”
[14]
On the other hand, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned Advocate
General appearing for the official respondents fairly submits and agrees
that during pendency of the civil suits related to the land in the courts
between the parties, it would not be proper for the official respondents to
go on any factual inquiries into the land records.
[15]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the material
evidence on record.
[16]
It is seen from record that learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.),
Court no.3, West Tripura, Agartala passed an order of status quo vide
order dated 05.08.2017 in case No. Civil Misc(Inj.) 34 of 2017 arising
out of TS (CC) 01 of 2017. For the purpose of reference, the relevant
contents of the said order are extracted as under:
“…..From the contentions made on behalf of the plaintiff petitioner (counter
claimant) and upon perusal of the xerox copy of the khatian No. 1438/01, it
appears that the plaintiff petitioner (counter claimant) has a prima facie case.
But the position that the defendant OP is in possession of some portion of the
schedule property mentioned in the main suit bearing No. TS 147 of 2016
clearly shows that the defendant OP would suffer irreparable injury if they
are dispossessed at this juncture and the balance of the convenience and in
convenience also lies in their favour.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and also after
perusal of all the materials on record, both the parties are directed to
maintain the status quo in respect of the suit land until the disposal of the
main case bearing No. TS 147 of 2016 and the connected counter claim case
bearing No. TS (Counter-Claim) No. 01 of 2017.
Thus the instant case is disposed of on contest…..”
[17]
It is also observed that the petitioner herein, in connection
with Revenue Case no. 55/2025, on 18.02.2025 submitted his detailed
written reply wherein he mentioned about the order of revenue authority
in Revenue Case no: 44/2018 which was dismissed on 09.02.21 on the
ground that civil cases are pending on the similar cause of action. But,
having knowledge of the same, subsequently, on 27-02-2025, the
respondent no 2 passed Order in connection with Review Case vide no.
55 of 2025 and cancelled the mutation of the land in the name of the
petitioner reverting back its previous status. It is also pertinent to note
that in the impugned order the respondent Collector has referred to the
Civil Court proceedings and thus has complete knowledge about the
same. Further the respondent Collector contends before this Court that
the civil court injunction orders are not binding on him.
[18]
In this regard, the relevant contents from the said impugned
order dated 27.02.2025 passed by the Court of District Collector, West
Tripura, are quoted as under:
“……Since the suit land was "Allottee" mentioning with the land cannot be
transferred without permission of the Collector. Thus, before transferring
land, execution of deed from the said khatian, it is exigent to obtain
permission to sale land from the Collector concern as per the law. But the
present recorded owner of the khatian bearing No. 1438/1, i.e. Ratan Datta
could not produce the copy of sale permission in respect of khatian bearing
No. 1438/1 before the Court after several times given.
Moreover, how the nomenclature of the original land status has been
changed to "Rayati" from "Allottee" could not give explain by the respondent
as well as in the report of others.
Hence, the Court is of the opinion that the changing of land status to
"Rayati" from "Allottee" is an offence in the eyes of law and such recordings
were malafidely done while mutation proceeding/recording in khatian
bearing No. 1438/1, 2 & 3. Therefore, the Court cannot turn a blind eye to
the above mutation recordings and to promote such illegality. The court felt
that it would be highly appreciated part to the concerned who was performed
to make such illegal record it the court does not take any major part in this
regard for cancellation of mutation proceeding as stated above.
However, the Court has decided to correct record reverting back its previous
status considering the fact and circumstances of case records and to order as.(i) The order dated 03.11.2016 in respect of MR No. 201640781 is hereby
quashed.
(ii) The name of the respondent i.e, Ratan Datta S/o Sitanath Datta shall be
deleted from column No. 6 of khatian bearing No. 1438/1 and the name of
previous recorded owners to be entered as per present status of manual
khatian bearing no. 1438/1 of Mouja Agartala Sheet No. 3.
(iii)The share in column No. 7 shall be recorded as per the manual khatian
bearing No. 1438/1-2 & 3.
(iv) The status "Allottee" shall also be recorded in column No. 6 Instead of
"Rayati" in khatian bearing No. 1438/1-2 & 3 of mouja Agartala Sheet No. 3
under Ramnagar T.K. and other content of the records will remain
unchanged.
Therefore, the instant case is hereby disposed off……..”
[19]
It is further noticed that affidavit in-opposition
dated
20.09.2025 has been filed on behalf of the official respondents No.1 to 3
wherein, it has been stated that the said respondents were not made
parties to the petition in which the status quo order in favour of the
petitioner was passed and the said order is not binding on the respondents
as they are not parties in the suit. It has further been submitted in the said
affidavit-in opposition that unless there is any prayer in the injunction
petition regarding the mutation in involving the respondent, a stus quo
order passed on the basis of any prayer of the petitioner on a different
subject cannot restrict/limit the jurisdiction of the respondent in creating
the record of right/changing the mutation as alleged.
[20]
In view of the above discussions, this Court is of the opinion
that knowing very well the fact that the matter is sub judice by the
concerned Court and order of status quo was also passed, the respondent
No.2 herein, passed the impugned order dated 27.02.2025 in connection
with Review Case vide no. 55 of 2025 and cancelled the mutation in the
name of the petitioner. The property which is the subject-matter before
the trial Court where injunction has been granted against the parties, for
the same property in question, the respondent No.2 has initiated steps
upon the request made by the unofficial respondent No.4 for entering
certain names in the revenue records. Though the official respondent
No.2 was not made party in the proceeding in which order of status quo
was passed, this Court opines that the action of the official respondent
No.2 in interfering the order passed by the concerned Court is illegal as
the matter was duly informed to him by the petitioner by submitting
written replies.
[21]
This Court draws an adverse inference against the action of
respondent No.2 since he has interfered with the judicial process of the
Court and due to which, the unofficial respondent No.4 would be taking
advantage of the said impugned order dated 27.02.2025 in connection
with Review Case vide no. 55 of 2025 passed by the District Collector,
West Tripura District, respondent No.2 herein and would come in the
way of implementing the injunction order dated 05.08.2017 in case No.
Civil Misc(Inj.) 34 of 2017 arising out of TS (CC) 01 of 2017 passed by
the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Court no.3, West Tripura, Agartala.
[22]
Thus, with the above discussions, keeping view the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court as referred by the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner cited supra, this Court is of the view that the
impugned order passed by the respondent No.2 dated 27.02.2025 in
Review Case No.55 of 2025 is illegal in the eye of law and liable to be set
aside and accordingly the same is set aside. Both parties are at liberty to
avail remedies under law and also to cooperate with the judicial
proceedings if any, pending before the Civil Court(s).
[23]
With the above observations, the instant petition is allowed
to the extent as indicated above and thereby, the same is disposed of. As a
sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also stand
closed.
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2025.11.07 17:03:49 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review