Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C). No.616/2022
Sri Ranjit Debbarma, S/O. Late Bilat Mani Debbarma, Resident of Vill:Ujan Larma, P.O.-Naba Santiganj Bazar, P.S.:-Takarjala, District-West
Tripura, Tripura.
Presently residing at Paschim Jirania, near Bidya Chandra School, P.O.-J.J.
Nagar, P/S-Radhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council, Represented by the
Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
2. The Additional Chief Executive Officer, T.T.A.A.D.C Khumulwng, P.O.J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
3. The Principal Officer (Tribal Welfare), T.T.A.A.D.C Khumulwng, P.O.J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin- 799035.
4. The Zonal Development Officer, West Zone, T.T.A.A.D.C Khumulwng,
P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin- 799035.
5. The Sub-Zonal Development Officer, Mandwi Sub-Zone, T.T.A.A.D.C.,
Mandwi, P.O.-Mandwi, P/S-Mandwi, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
6. Sri Kajal Debbarma, Extension Officer (TW), Notice to be served through
the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
7. Sri Dulal Debbarma, Extension Officer(TW), Notice to be served through
the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
8. Sri Ranjit Debbarma-2, Extension Officer(TW), Notice to be served
through the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/SRadhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
9. Sri Ranjit Chakma, Extension Officer (TW), Notice to be served through
the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/S-Radhapur,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
10. Sri Narendra Reang, Extension Officer(TW), Notice to be served
through the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/SRadhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
11. Sri Sudhaong Mog Choudhury, Extension Officer (TW), Notice to be
served through the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar,
P/S-Radhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
12. Sri Bishnu Debbarma, Extension Officer (TW), Notice to be served
through the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/SRadhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
13. Sri Subodh Debbarma-1, Extension Officer (TW), Notice to be served
through the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/SRadhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
14. Sri Subodh Debbarma-2, Extension Officer(TW), Notice to be served
through the Chief Executive Officer, Khumulwng, P.O.-J.J. Nagar, P/SRadhapur, District-West Tripura, Pin-799035.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. B. Debbarma, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 10th May, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: NO.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Petitioner being aggrieved by promotion of his juniors by the
memorandum dated 22.03.2022 issued by the Additional Chief Executive
Officer, Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council (TTAADC, for
short), Khumulwng approached this Court in the present writ petition as,
according to him, he is the senior-most employee from the Scheduled Tribe
category. Petitioner contends that he was appointed as Project Assistant on
04.11.1991 in the Department of Tribal Welfare, TTAADC Administration
and promoted to the post of Supervisor (TW) on 17.11.2007 and has been
serving in the office of Zonal Development Officer, West Zone,
Khumulwng under the TTAADC Administration. His next promotion was
due to the post of Extension Officer (TW) as per the Departmental Final
Seniority list dated 28.01.2022. However, despite being in the first position
in the ST category as per the seniority list, he was surprised to know that
vide memorandum dated 22.03.2022 his juniors have been promoted
without considering his case. Thereafter, he represented thrice before the
department on 23.03.2022, 07.04.2022 and lastly on 25.04.2022 but of no
avail. Therefore, he has been compelled to approach this Court. Petitioner
also impleaded several respondents who, according to him, are juniors but
have been promoted by the impugned memorandum dated 22.03.2022
(Annexure-7 to the writ petition) from ST category.
2.
In the first counter affidavit filed by the respondents through
Deputy Chief Executive Officer, TTAADC, Khumulwng, it was mentioned
that the name of the petitioner was not considered for promotion as there is a
pending disciplinary proceeding (D.P.)/inquiry against him in relation to
complaint of disproportionate assets. It also referred to an inquiry report on
the complaint in respect of the disproportionate assets case against the
petitioner which found the allegation to be partially true. It is also stated at
paragraph-6 that action would be taken against him very shortly after the
code of conduct applicable during the election to the Legislative Assembly
is over. Respondents also stated that there was no intention to deprive the
writ petitioner of his legal and constitutional rights but due to pending
departmental proceedings where the TTAADC had received an inquiry
report which reveals that the complaint against him is partially true, his case
was not taken up for consideration. Lastly, it was stated that consideration
of the claim for promotion of the writ petitioner may be taken after disposal
of pending disciplinary proceedings for disproportionate assets, if he is not
found guilty.
3.
In view of the aforesaid stand of the respondents, a rejoinder
affidavit was also filed by the petitioner stating that the alleged inquiry
report was 9(nine) months after the promotions were notified and thus, it is
clear that during the tenure of promotion, there was no information or any
inquiry regarding allegation of disproportionate assets against him. Thus,
there was no bar in promoting him to the next level of service. He also
denied the allegations as baseless and concocted which has been
manipulated subsequently after filing of the writ petition to deprive him
from any legitimate promotion. Petitioner also took the plea that he has not
been informed about any such proceeding as alleged either by the
department or through his officials. No explanation has been asked from
him. Neither any show-cause notice has been issued.
4.
In view of the stand of the petitioner, learned counsel for the
respondent-TTAADC stated that instructions have been received and details
of the departmental inquiry and disproportionate assets case instituted
against the petitioner with its present status would be brought on record.
Taking note of this submission vide order dated 25.04.2023, the matter was
adjourned to 01.05.2023. Since the affidavit had been filed by the
respondent's counsel on the same date, the matter has been adjourned for
today. The affidavit dated 01.05.2023 filed by the respondent-TTAADC,
inter alia, states as follows:
"9)
That, the Enquiry Committee of 3(three)
persons headed by Sri Salaparu Mog, Deputy PO(Fishery),
TTAADC submitted Enquiry report on 5/12/2022 by
enclosing a separate sheet naming as Annexure A in items
No.1 to 4.
(A copy of Enquiry Report submitted by the
Enquiry Committee dated- 05/12/2022 is annexed herewith
and marked as Annexure-R/5).
10)
That, the Zonal Development Officer (ZDO),
West Zone, TTAADC forwarded the Enquiry Report which
was submitted by the Enquiry Committee to the Executive
Officer
(Administration),
TTAADC
Khumulwng
No.F.1(7)/ZDO(W)/ADC/Estt/KHW/2020/7037-38,
Vide
dated-
06/12/2022.
(A copy of letter forwarded by the ZDO, West
Zone dated-06/12/2022 is annexed herewith and marked as
Annexure-R/6).
11)
That, the Administrative authority of TTAADC
could not proceed further regarding allegation made by the
complainant against the Writ Petitioner Sri Ranjit Debbarma
for corruption charges as alleged due to General Election for
Tripura Legislative Assembly-2023 which was started from
December 2022 and ended in the month of March 2023 and
there is no ill motive on the part of the TTAADC
Administration not to promote the Writ Petitioner but due to
Tripura Legislative Assembly General Election and election
code of conduct was in force.
Furthermore, I would like to say that TTAADC
authority has no intention to deprive the Writ Petitioner Sri
Ranjit Debbarma from his legal rights and Constitutional
rights as well as the other employees of TTAADC.
12)
That, it is to be mentioned here that the matter
for promotion of the writ petitioner Sri Ranjit Debbarma
would be consider in future if the name of the petitioner for
the allegation made by the complainant is not found guilty and
then his promotion would be taken into consideration with
retrospective effect and seniority."
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent-TTAADC has on the basis
of averments made in the latest affidavit dated 01.05.2023 and on
instructions stated that no memorandum of charges has been issued against
the petitioner for any departmental proceeding nor the department has any
instruction as to any other criminal case instituted against the petitioner on
allegations of disproportionate assets.
6.
The petitioner was aggrieved by the promotional exercise
conducted vide memorandum dated 22.03.2022 whereby his juniors were
promoted without considering his case. The affidavit of the respondents
dated 01.05.2023 and statements made by learned counsel for the
respondent-TTAADC, on instructions, show that there are no pending
departmental proceedings formally initiated against the petitioner till date in
respect of the allegations of disproportionate assets against him. The
departmental proceeding is initiated on issuance of a formal charge-sheet.
There is no averment in the affidavit of the respondents that any criminal
case has been instituted on such allegation or that any formal charge-sheet in
such case has been lodged against the petitioner till date. The promotional
exercise took place more than one year back vide memorandum dated
22.03.2022 when apparently there was no pending departmental proceeding
against him though it is not disputed that his juniors were promoted. In such
circumstances, petitioner appears to have been denied fair consideration on
the claim of promotion though his juniors were promoted vide
memorandum dated 22.03.2022.
7.
Having regard to the aforesaid factual and legal position, this
Court is of the opinion that the respondents should consider the claim of
promotion of the petitioner in accordance with law within a timeframe,
preferably within 12(twelve) weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this
order. Needless to say, dependant on such decision, if the case of the
petitioner is found fit for promotion on all counts, petitioner would be
granted the consequential benefits from the date his promotion was due.
8.
The writ petition is disposed of with the aforesaid observations
and directions.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review